๐ Lecture 16 โ New Trends of Journalism in Pakistan
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the evolution and emerging trends in Pakistani journalism, focusing on technological advancements in printing, the rise of pictorial journalism, and the role of newspapers in public discourse. It highlights how global practices like investigative journalism remain underrepresented in Pakistan while local innovations like forum discussions and feature writing have grown in importance.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the historical shift from Litho to Offset printing in Pakistan (1953), the significance of pictorial journalism in news and advertising, the role of forum discussions and newspaper-organized events in enhancing freedom of expression, the absence of investigative reporting in Pakistan compared to the US (Watergate scandal example), the 2005 Press Ordinance, and the distinction between news and features as a substitute for investigative reporting.
๐ Lecture Summary
New Trends of Journalism in Pakistan
There are several important factors in the formation of a newspaper, including make up, designing, printing, and stall value (the display appeal at newsstands).
Printing Evolution
In Pakistan after independence till 1953, Litho printing was used, which lacked clarity and gave a very ordinary impression on paper. In 1953, Kohistan started Offset printing, which made photo journalism possible. In offset printing, photographic plates are used and then converted onto Aluminum plate.
Pictorial Journalism
In newspapers, a good picture should supplement the news. A Chinese saying states that "a good picture is better than one thousand words." During the Vietnam war, 58,000 American soldiers lost their lives. People saw the ugly face of death on television, which created a very different impact, causing Americans to criticize the government's policy. ๐ก Why this matters: This demonstrates how visual journalism can shape public opinion and influence policy.
Another important aspect of pictorial journalism is show biz. Fashion photography has become part of newspapers today. Similarly, advertising is also an essential part of pictorial journalism. Many advertisements are in multi-colour, which was absent 10 years ago.
Forum Discussions and Newspaper Events
A new trend that has emerged in our newspapers is forum discussion. Papers invite different experts, giving the advantage of having different opinions at one platform, which are then published in newspapers. Some newspapers organize musical activities to get marketing and publicity. Many seminars on serious issues are also organized by different newspapers, enhancing freedom of expression. A recent example is the Hudood Ordinance, where many newspapers organized discussion panels for that.
Investigative Reporting
In Pakistani newspapers, there is no investigative reporting. In many countries like the USA, investigative reporting is very common. President Nixon had to leave his office after the investigative reporting of Washington Post that the Watergate building was bugged. President Nixon ordered that all the speeches and sessions of Democrats would be recorded. When Washington Post published this news, the President had to resign.
In Pakistan, freedom of press is not encouraging. However, an ordinance of 2005 was implemented that made things very easy, but still it is not the ideal one.
Features vs. News
Features have covered the gap of investigative reporting. There is a wide difference between news and a feature. Features are not time bound while news are time bound. Features can be objective and subjective while news is always objective. Features writers take their material from the happenings around them.
๐ Definition โ Litho printing: A printing method used in Pakistan until 1953 that lacked clarity and gave an ordinary impression on paper. ๐ Definition โ Offset printing: A printing method introduced by Kohistan in 1953 using photographic plates converted onto Aluminum plate, enabling photo journalism. ๐ Definition โ Investigative reporting: In-depth reporting that uncovers hidden information, as demonstrated by the Washington Post's Watergate coverage that led to President Nixon's resignation. ๐ Key Difference: Features โ not time bound, can be objective and subjective. News โ time bound, always objective. ๐ Example (Watergate): President Nixon ordered recording of Democrat sessions in Watergate building; Washington Post published the story, leading to Nixon's resignation. This example shows the power of investigative journalism in holding leaders accountable.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that offset printing revolutionized Pakistani journalism in 1953 by enabling photojournalism, while the shift to multi-colour advertising and fashion photography represents modern pictorial trends. Forum discussions and newspaper-organized seminars have enhanced freedom of expression in Pakistan, though investigative journalism remains absent unlike in the USA where it forced President Nixon to resign. The 2005 Press Ordinance improved press freedom but is not ideal, and features have filled the gap of investigative reporting since features are timeless and can blend objectivity with subjectivity unlike time-bound, strictly objective news.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What printing method was used in Pakistan from independence until 1953, and what was its main limitation?
- How did offset printing change journalism in Pakistan when introduced by Kohistan in 1953?
- What was the impact of television coverage of the Vietnam war on American public opinion?
- What major event did Washington Post investigative reporting expose, and what was the outcome for President Nixon?
- What are the two key differences between news and features in terms of time and objectivity?
๐ Lecture 17 โ Magazine Journalism
๐ Overview: This lecture defines magazine journalism and traces its historical evolution from early periodicals to modern publications. It explores the diverse categories of magazines that emerged in Pakistan after independence, examines the reasons for their rise and decline, and outlines the essential qualities required for successful magazine journalism.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with foundational definitions of magazine, periodical, and journal, followed by a historical perspective dating back to 1731. It then provides a comprehensive classification of magazines in Pakistan after independence, including literary, religious, film, sports, political, women's, childrenโs, fashion, digest, in-house, and research journals. The lecture concludes by discussing the necessities and qualities of effective magazine journalism, emphasizing the editor's role and the importance of photo journalism.
๐ Lecture Summary
Magazine
A magazine is a periodical publication containing a wide variety of articles on various subjects.
๐ Definition โ Periodical: A regular issue from a press; it could be a magazine or a review.
๐ Definition โ Journal: A professional periodical.
Historical perspective
The term Magazine was first used in 1731 in the title of โGentlemanโs Magazineโ founded in London, though magazines in early form were available to the general public since 1646. In 1691, The Compleat Library appeared, considered the first magazine to break away from book information. The first essay-type periodical was Tattler, and the first magazine published from the USA was Andrew Branfordโs American Magazine.
Magazine Journalism after Independence
Major contribution of periodicals in Pakistan's history had been in the area of literature. A huge number of literary journals and magazines of high quality were published in early years after independence, creating a mindset among readers that a periodical is a literary journal, which is altogether wrong. Since independence, different magazines and periodicals have been published and can be classified into different categories.
Literary Magazine
A literary magazine is a periodical devoted to literature, covering poetry, short stories, essays, critical reviews, interviews of poets and authors, letters, and related content. Famous literary magazines that have vanished include Sawera, Naqsh, Naya Daur, Naya adab, and Urdu adab. After the 1960s, they disappeared and digest magazines took their place. Critics blame radio, television, and newspapers for this decline. Television and radio provide entertainment and information through dramas, songs (poetry), and discussions, reducing the demand for literary magazines. Another reason is the lack of availability of good writings and the cheap entertainment available in the form of digests.
Religious Magazine
A religious magazine is devoted to a specific religion, aimed at preaching through religious poetry, scholars' articles, interviews, answering queries, historical incidents, and comparative analysis with other religions. In the 19th century, when journalism was taking shape in the sub-continent, the most popular periodicals were religious magazines. Hindus, Muslims, and Christian missionaries were publishing their magazines and propagating their religions. Different organizations, sects, and people publish religious magazines in Pakistan, but they are no longer popular because electronic media, particularly private Islamic and other channels, are doing the job in a more popular way, reducing the demand for religious magazines.
Film Magazine
Film magazines provide both information and entertainment, offering updates on upcoming local and international movies, interviews and pictures of stars, spicy news about actors and actresses, and other public interest content. In Pakistan, film magazines have become less popular due to the overall downfall of Pakistan's Film Industry. Till 1970, approximately 110 films were released per year; now it is 20-25. Similarly, the number of cinema houses was 850 till 1970; now it is about 350. This decline has disturbed film magazine circulation. Another reason is the extensive coverage of films and entertainment by newspapers, which reduces the need for separate film magazines.
Sports Magazine
Sports magazines cover sports and sports persons, providing sports fans with information about international and national sports events and sports persons, and giving pictorial coverage to mega sports events to meet public demands.
Political Magazine
Political magazines provide insight and updates on different political events nationally and internationally, political updates, news, interviews of famous politicians, political party activities, scandals, and public opinion regarding party popularity. In the 7th and 8th decades of the 20th century, popular political magazines existed, but their circulation has decreased. The major reason for decline is newspapers, which now deeply and thoroughly cover political news through editorials, features, and columns, making people less interested in spending extra money on political magazines. Famous political magazines that once existed include Lail-o-nahar and Al-fateh.
Womenโs Magazine
Before partition, the sub-continent had popular womenโs magazines like Ismat, published from Delhi. After independence, in the 1960s, besides independent women's magazines, all national dailies started publishing womenโs periodicals. A womenโs magazine covers everything of womenโs interest: beauty tips, articles on women issues, their poetry and writings, and interviews of successful women.
Childrenโs Magazine
Phool was one of the most popular childrenโs magazines of the sub-continent before independence. Khilona from Delhi continued publishing even after partition. In Pakistan, daily newspapers publish childrenโs special periodicals covering childrenโs drawings, pictures, poems, short stories, cartoons, and other interest-related content.
Fashion Magazine
Fashion magazines, also called society magazines, inform people about new trends of society in different ways. A special feature is their high-quality Photo Journalism. They are usually liked by people but their circulation is not high due to their expensive nature.
Digest Magazine
Readerโs Digest is the first digest in history. A digest magazine provides digestible material to its readers. In Pakistan, 80-85 digest magazines are available for light reading, covering translations of short stories and novels from other languages (mostly English), mythological stories, local stories, and fiction. Digest magazines have become the most popular and affordable type of magazine in Pakistan.
In-house Journal
In-house journals are published by different organizations to provide information to clients and employees regarding their services, policies, and related information. In Pakistan, government, semi-government, and private organizations publish in-house journals, which can be divided into sub-categories. Newsletter is one of the most popular types.
Research Journal
Research journals are usually published on a quarterly basis. They cover and publish latest research, usually in the form of research papers, sometimes on different topics and sometimes in a specific area. Almost all universities and higher education institutions publish these research journals regularly because they are considered a symbol of progress and knowledge. Students also give them more importance over their academic books. Other professional journals like medical journals, architectural journals, and IT journals are also being published in Pakistan.
Necessities/requirements/qualities of Magazine Journalism
The editor of a periodical or magazine should be a reputable person in his field in terms of his contacts. For example, an editor of a literary journal must be aware of all important persons in the field and have friendly relations with them because they are the biggest source of information for the magazine.
Photo Journalism
Another important requirement is high-quality photo journalism. Whatever category a magazine falls in, its pictorial coverage of events, incidents, and personalities has always been a major reason for popularity among readers. A magazine with low-quality photo journalism cannot establish its identity and position, neither in the market nor in the eyes of its readers. Life Magazine, a magazine of international repute, was purely based on photo journalism and is considered a fine example for others. It not only established its own identity through its pictures but also helped in establishing a standard guideline for other magazines.
โญ Key Takeaways
A magazine is a periodical publication containing varied articles, distinct from a periodical (any regular press issue) and a journal (a professional periodical). The term "magazine" was first used in 1731 for "Gentleman's Magazine." In Pakistan, magazines are classified into literary, religious, film, sports, political, womenโs, childrenโs, fashion, digest, in-house, and research journals. Most categories, except digest magazines, have declined due to competition from electronic media and newspapers that now cover these topics extensively. High-quality photo journalism and a well-connected editor are essential requirements for successful magazine journalism, as exemplified by Life Magazine.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a magazine, a periodical, and a journal as defined in the lecture?
- Name at least three literary magazines that vanished from Pakistan after the 1960s and what replaced them.
- Why have film and political magazines declined in popularity in Pakistan according to the lecture?
- What percentage of films were released per year till 1970 compared to now, and how many cinema houses were there in each period?
- What is the significance of Life Magazine in the context of magazine journalism, and what quality does it exemplify?
๐ Lecture 18 โ News Agency
๐ Overview: This lecture covers the definition, history, and global significance of news agencies, including major international wire services. It also provides a detailed historical account of the development of news agencies in Pakistan, distinguishing between state-owned and private entities, and explains the fundamental operational difference between a newspaper and a news agency.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining a news agency and its role as a news source for other media. It traces the historical development of the world's first news agencies in the 19th century, from New York to Europe, and lists the four major international news agencies operating today. The lecture then shifts to a detailed history of news agencies in the subcontinent and Pakistan, covering the formation of APP, PPI, and UPP, as well as their evolution under various governments. Finally, it contrasts the operational policy constraints of a news agency with the editorial freedom of a newspaper.
๐ Lecture Summary
News Agency
A news agency is an organization that acts as a source of news for different newspapers, radio, television and other organizations and individuals who are interested in getting them. News agencies do not publish these news themselves; they collect the news and provide them after subscription to their clients. They are also called as wire services or news services or press agencies.
Historical perspective
Worldโs first news agency was formed around 1820s in New York City under the name of Association of Morning Newspapers. It was formed to gather upcoming reports from Europe. The first international news agencies formed in Europe were: Agence Havas of Paris (1835); the Reuter Telegram Company of London (1851), known simply as Reuters; and the Continental Telegraphen Compagnie of Berlin (1849), known as the Wolff Agency. They started their work as a financial data service to bankers and businessmen but then extended their service to world news. Reuters is also considered as the oldest news agency of the world. Initially news agencies used to send news through telegraphy services now it has been replaced by internet.
International News Agency
Four major international news agencies are: Reuters, Associated Press (AP), United Press International (UPI), and Agence France-Presse (AFP). They are providing extensive service to their subscribers all over the world. They provide 3.5 crore words per day to their subscribers in more than 150 countries. These international news agencies work 24 hours and now also provide trade related hot news, international market trends and rates, currency rates and other commerce related information to their clients.
News Agencies in Pakistan
United Indiaโs first news agencies were Press Trust of India and Associated Press of India. Later before independence when two-nation theory got a recognition and acceptance, another news agency called Orient was formed in Lahore by Muslim journalists and newspapers of sub-continent. After independence, Orient survived for a very short time; however the part of Associated Press of India that remained in Pakistan was declared as the first news agency of Pakistan with a name called Associated Press of Pakistan (APP). Now APP is considered among the worldโs major International news agencies. APP was formed and initially controlled and run by the journalists and newspapersโ editors of Pakistan. In 1956 some journalists parted from it and formed a private news agency called Pakistan Press Association. After sometime when it broadened its canvas and started working internationally, it changed its name to Pakistan Press International (PPI).
In 1960 General Ayub Khanโs government took APP under governmentโs control and made it a state owned news agency under the Federal Information Department. From that day till date APP is working as a state owned news agency.
Another news agency United Press of Pakistan (UPP) came into existence in December 1949. Mr. Qutubuddin Aziz, as a private limited company founded it. However for a long time, the agency has merely existed on paper and just about manages to get the small subsidies marked for it by the central and provisional governments. In general Ziaโs regime some smaller news agencies also appeared but they could not establish their identity and name as APP and PPI did.
๐ก Why this matters: This history shows that Pakistan's news landscape has been shaped by both a dominant state-owned agency (APP) and private sector initiatives (PPI, UPP), reflecting ongoing tension between government control and independent journalism.
Difference between the working of a newspaper and news agency
A newspaper has its own policy under its own specific management; however, a news agency cannot form a specific policy or point of view. A news agency has its clients and subscribers in different parts of the world with their own specific policies and stance on different issues. Therefore, a news agency is bound to adopt an unbiased, objective and indifferent approach in its reporting and services to keep its subscribers satisfied.
โญ Key Takeaways
- A news agency is a wholesale news provider that collects and distributes news to multiple media clients via subscription, without publishing it themselves, requiring strict objectivity.
- The worldโs oldest and four major international news agencies (Reuters, AP, UPI, AFP) originated in the 19th century and now send 35 million words daily to over 150 countries.
- In Pakistan, APP (Associated Press of Pakistan) was the first news agency, initially private but taken over by the state in 1960, while PPI emerged as its main private competitor.
- Unlike newspapers which can adopt their own editorial policy, news agencies must remain unbiased and objective to serve clients with diverse viewpoints globally.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference in policy approach between a newspaper and a news agency?
- Which news agency is considered the oldest in the world, and in which year was it founded?
- Under which Pakistani government was APP taken into state control, and in which year?
- Name the two major news agencies that emerged in Pakistan after independence, and state which one is state-owned.
- How many words per day do the four major international news agencies collectively provide to their subscribers, and in how many countries?
๐ Lecture 19 โ Press and Government
๐ Overview: This lecture traces the historical evolution of press-government relations in the Indian subcontinent from 1782 to post-independence Pakistan. It examines how colonial rulers gradually tightened press controls as vernacular newspapers emerged, and how Muslim journalism played a pivotal role in political movements like the Khilafat Movement. The lecture also critically analyzes the early tensions between Pakistan's founding leadership and the press regarding freedom of expression.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the early period of English-language newspapers under East India Company rule (1780-1822), the introduction of the first press licensing act in 1823 following the emergence of Urdu newspapers, the severe crackdown on Muslim journalists after the 1857 War of Independence, Sir Syed Ahmed Khan's reformist journalism through Tehzib-ul Ikhlaq, the role of Muslim newspapers in the Khilafat Movement (1914-1924), the repressive Rowlett Act of 1919, the shift toward Muslim versus Hindu journalism after 1929, and the beginning of press-government tensions in Pakistan after 1947.
๐ Lecture Summary
1780-1822
All newspapers were published in English language, which was not a matter of concern for East India Company because the major population of the sub-continent was unable to read and understand English. They were at ease that these newspapers could not raise the people against them in any way, and therefore they did not regulate them or other publications through any law. However, they showed a little concern when initially William Bolt in 1776 showed interest in publishing the first newspaper in the sub-continent and was ultimately deported back to England by East India Company.
Jame Jahan Numa, the first Urdu newspaper, appeared on the scene from Calcutta in 1822, but as Urdu was not a popular language at that time, Munshi Sada Sukh later converted it into Persian and then made it a bilingual newspaper. An important Press Act was introduced by the foreign rulers in 1823, immediately after native people's idea of publishing newspapers in their own languages (Persian, Urdu, Bengali). According to this act, taking a prior permission (license) for publishing a newspaper or any other publication was made compulsory. The government also had the authority to cancel the license whenever it desired.
๐ก Why this matters: The 1823 Press Act marked the first formal censorship mechanism in the subcontinent and set a precedent for all future colonial and post-colonial press regulations.
Pre and post 1857 period
When the War of Independence began, the British government wanted to curtail the freedom of press completely, so they victimized different local papers, claiming that this war was the result of that freedom which was given by them to local media. As the British came out victorious and it was a Muslim ruler whose throne was toppled by them, Muslims had to face more bitter consequences than Hindus. Newspapers published and edited by them, particularly the newspapers and journalists of Delhi, were blamed to be responsible for the so-called mutiny and rebellion against British and East India Company. Sadaq-al-akhbar edited by Syed Jamiluddin and Delhi Urdu Akhbar edited by Maulvi Muhammad Baqir were closed down by the Raj as punishment for standing against them.
At this bleak and difficult time, Sir Syed Ahmed Khan realized his responsibility as a learned and educated man and played a major role in reducing distances between the British government and Muslims of the sub-continent. His Tehzib-ul Ikhlaq, an Urdu journal published in 1870, propagated his reformative doctrines regarding society and religion. He is undoubtedly the greatest figure in the transitional period of the sub-continent's history.
Khilafat Movement 1914-1924
The Khilafat movement was a religio-political movement launched by the Muslims of British India for the retention of the Ottoman Khilafat and for not handing over the control of Muslim holy places to non-Muslims. When the Khilafat movement started in 1914, Muslim journalists played a vital role in steering the direction of the struggle. Zamindar of Molana Zafar Ali Khan, Comrade and Hamdard of Maulana Muhammad Ali Jauhar, and Al-Hilal and Al-Balagh of Molana Abul Kalam Azad, Urdu e Mualla of Molana Hasrat Mohani were the prominent newspapers and magazines which performed their duties to express their resentment.
These Muslim journalists and their papers were sentenced and sanctioned several times. In 1910, another Press Act was enforced by the Raj; under this press act, only Zamindar had to give security 11 times. Newspapers and journalists of Bombay, Delhi, UP, and Madras were particularly under strict observation in this period.
๐ Definition โ Zamindar: A prominent Urdu newspaper edited by Molana Zafar Ali Khan that was repeatedly penalized under the 1910 Press Act, being forced to pay security deposits 11 times for its pro-Khilafat stance.
Rowlett Act, 1919
Rowlett Act was a black law introduced in India. According to the law, the government got authority to persecute any Indian, and the arrested had no facility of legal assistance and right to appeal โ just as the 'Lettres de Cachet' in France before the French Revolution. Quaid e Azam resigned from the central legislature as protest.
In 1929, after the failure of All Parties Conference in which Hindus rejected demands presented by Muslim leaders and refused to adjust them in any way, Indian politics divided into Muslim politics and Hindu politics, and similarly Muslim journalism and Hindu journalism. In 1942, Congress started Quit India Movement which became quite violent; press laws were amended again by the government to control them, and strict actions were taken against newspapers that supported this movement, which were mostly Hindu newspapers.
๐ Example: The Rowlett Act operated like the French "Lettres de Cachet" โ a system where the government could imprison any individual without trial, legal assistance, or right to appeal. This authoritarian law was so extreme that Muhammad Ali Jinnah (Quaid-e-Azam) resigned from the Central Legislative Council in protest.
After independence
The establishment and bureaucracy of the new-born state were mostly comprised of British trained officials. So in a way, the same approach regarding freedom given to press traveled down to Pakistan from the Raj. Quaid-e-Azam addressed the opening session of Pakistan's Constituent Assembly on 11th September 1947, which was presided by Jugindhar Nath Mandal. In this session, Quaid-e-Azam took an oath as President of the Assembly and delivered a speech announcing his policy and the shape of the constitution, along with defining the structure and form of the political scene of Pakistan. A part of the speech was:
"...you are free to go to your mosques, you are free to go to your temples or to any other place of worship. It has nothing to do with the business of state and politics. By pursuing this policy you will realize after sometime that Hindus will cease to be Hindus and Muslims will cease to be Muslims not in religious sense because religion is a matter of personal faith for everyone. But as citizens of Pakistan for political purposes, all citizens will have equal rights in Pakistan..."
A press advice was issued to radio and newspapers in which they were asked not to publish the complete text of Quaid's speech. Dawn's editor Altaf Hussain did not like the idea as he was very close to Quaid; he called PID (Press Information Department) to find out who was behind it and what part of the speech they didn't want to be published, but the true source could not be located. This is how the press-govt relationship began in Pakistan.
๐ก Why this matters: The censorship of Quaid-e-Azam's historic secularism speech by his own government officials reveals that press suppression in Pakistan did not begin with military regimes but was present from the very first days of the state, setting a troubling pattern for decades to come.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that press-government tension in South Asia has deep colonial roots. The British initially ignored English newspapers but imposed strict licensing laws (1823) once vernacular newspapers emerged in Urdu, Persian, and Bengali. Muslim journalists and newspapers bore the heaviest persecution after the 1857 War of Independence, with papers like Delhi Urdu Akhbar and Sadaq-al-akhbar being shut down. Muslim journalism played a critical role in the Khilafat Movement (1914-1924), with papers like Zamindar, Comrade, Hamdard, and Al-Hilal being repeatedly penalized under the 1910 Press Act. The Rowlett Act of 1919 represented the most extreme colonial press suppression, allowing imprisonment without trial. Perhaps most significantly, the post-independence period reveals that censorship in Pakistan began immediately after independence when a press advice prohibited newspapers from publishing Quaid-e-Azam's full speech about equal citizenship rights, demonstrating that press freedom challenges were inherited from the colonial administrative mindset.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What was the significance of the 1823 Press Act, and why was it introduced immediately after the emergence of Jame Jahan Numa?
- How did the British use the 1857 War of Independence as justification to crack down on Muslim journalists, and which specific newspapers were closed?
- What was the role of Muslim journalism in the Khilafat Movement (1914-1924), and how many times was Zamindar forced to pay security under the 1910 Press Act?
- What were the key features of the Rowlett Act 1919, and why did Quaid-e-Azam resign from the central legislature in protest?
- What specific incident immediately after independence in 1947 demonstrated the continuation of colonial-era press control in Pakistan, and which newspaper editor protested against it?
๐ Lecture 20 โ Press and Government II
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the complex relationship between the press and government in Pakistan from 1947 to 1971. It covers how successive regimesโcivilian and militaryโused legal ordinances, takeovers, and censorship to control media, while journalists and publications resisted these pressures. Understanding this period is crucial for grasping the historical roots of media-state tensions in Pakistan.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture spans three distinct periods: 1947-1958, covering Pakistan's alignment with the American bloc and the targeting of Progressive Papers Limited (PPL); 1958-1969, detailing Ayub Khan's martial law, the Press and Publications Ordinance (PPO), and the National Press Trust (NPT); and 1969-1971, examining Yahya Khan's brief liberalization followed by renewed crackdowns on journalists. Key themes include state control through legal instruments, suppression of leftist voices, and the ethical decline of journalism during periods of apparent freedom.
๐ Lecture Summary
1947-1958
When Pakistan emerged on the world map, the Cold War (an ideological war between the Soviet Union and America) was ongoing, with media as the primary channel. The world was divided into two blocs: the Communist bloc and the American bloc. Pakistan's leaders chose to join the American bloc, after which numerous actions were taken against newspapers, magazines, and journalists who leaned toward the communist school of thought.
Progressive Papers Limited (PPL) was an important organization formed by Mian Iftikharuddin, a former member of the Communist Party of India. Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah had asked Muslim journalists to publish newspapers from different places to spread the Muslim League's message and support the Pakistan Movement. The intellectuals in PPL were mostly those who participated in the Progressive Writers Movement (1936). It is the only organization in Pakistan's history that gathered such a huge number of laureates and intellectuals under its roof.
After joining the American bloc, the first newspapers and publications targeted by the government were PPL's publications. In 1953, the Communist Party was banned. From 1947 to 1953, almost 58 magazines and books were banned by the establishment and removed from the market.
๐ก Why this matters: This period established the pattern of using Cold War alignment as justification for suppressing dissenting media voices.
๐ Definition โ Progressive Papers Limited (PPL): A newspaper organization formed by Mian Iftikharuddin that published progressive, left-leaning newspapers and gathered leading intellectuals under its roof. ๐ Formula: American bloc alignment โ suppression of communist-leaning press โ PPL targeted first ๐ Example: From 1947-1953, 58 magazines and books were banned by the establishment and removed from the market because of their perceived communist sympathies.
1958-1969
On October 7, 1958, President Sikander Mirza abrogated the Constitution and declared Martial Law in the country. The Constitution of 1956 was abrogated, ministers were dismissed, Central and Provincial Assemblies were dissolved, and all political activities were banned. General Muhammad Ayub Khan, the then Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces, became the Chief Martial Law Administrator. The parliamentary system in Pakistan came to an end. Within three weeks, on October 27, 1958, Sikander Mirza was ousted by General Ayub Khan, who then declared himself President.
Ayub Khan, within the first week of his coup, detained Syed Sibt-e-Hassan (editor of weekly Lail-o-Nihar), Ahmed Nadim Qasmi (editor of Imrooz), and Faiz Ahmed Faiz (editor of Pakistan Times)โall of whom worked for PPL. On April 18, 1959, the government took over PPL's papers, aimed at preventing the organization from roaming in the โDISTANT ORBITS AND ALIEN HORIZONSโ (referring to PPL's Progressive Ideology). The Board of Directors of PPL was dissolved, and an administrator was appointed.
Press and Publications Ordinance (PPO)
In 1961, the Press and Publications Ordinance (PPO) was formed and enforced to keep newspapers under government control. It was described as a "black law" completely boycotted by media organizations and journalists. One clause stated that all newspapers were ordered to publish DPR's (Directorate of Public Relations) or PID's (Press Information Department) handouts exactly as received, which is simply against freedom of press.
In 1963, the West Pakistan Press and Publications Ordinance and East Pakistan Press and Publications Ordinance were introduced by the provincial governments. The pressure from these provincial laws resulted in an amendment to the PPO, but even after that, its harshness remained the same.
In 1964, the National Press Trust (NPT) was established, and all PPL papers were handed over to this "monster." The NPT had the right to take over any newspaper or magazine that was apparently financially unable to run the newspaper or was deemed dangerous to the country's security. Apparently, it was an independent body, but actually, it was state-controlled. After PPL's publications, Daily Mashriq was also handed over to NPT; the Sindhi paper Hilal-e-Pakistan was taken over; Morning News (published since 1936, first from Calcutta and after partition from Karachi and Dhaka) was also taken over. Some Bengali newspapers were also taken over by the NPT. Dawn, Jang, and Nawa-e-Waqt were the only papers not taken into government custody, but they still had a tough time under Ayub, as they were not liked by the government.
Another harsh action taken against the press by Ayub's government was the condition imposed on international news agencies: they could not directly send news to their subscribers in Pakistan. They were asked to send their news via APP (Associated Press of Pakistan) or PPI (Pakistan Press International). This action was taken to control and restrict the news and information coming from international media from reaching Pakistani people.
๐ก Why this matters: The PPO and NPT became templates for state control of media that would be replicated and adapted by later regimes.
๐ Definition โ Press and Publications Ordinance (PPO) 1961: A black law that forced newspapers to publish government handouts verbatim and gave the state broad powers over the press. ๐ Formula: Martial Law โ PPO (1961) โ NPT (1964) โ State takeover of PPL papers โ Control of international news agencies ๐ Example: On April 18, 1959, the government took over all PPL papersโPakistan Times, Imrooz, Lail-o-Nihar, and Sports Timesโdissolved the Board of Directors, and appointed an administrator.
1969-1971
In March 1969, the second Martial Law was enforced in Pakistan by General Yahya Khan. After taking over, he accepted all the political demands that had been asked by political parties for quite some time. The press was given complete freedom, and a moratorium was put on the PPO so that it could not be used against the press any further.
Although freedom of press was enjoyed by media and newspapers, General Yahya's period is not considered a flourishing period of journalism, because in this period no ethics were observed by the newspapers, with an exception to a few reputable papers. Many dummy papers were revived; free insulting and even abusive language was used. Other than state-owned papers and some private newspapers, the journalistic scenario was quite dark during this time, out of the freedom given to the press.
In this period, some actions were taken against journalists. The first target was again PPL: 24 journalists were fired from Imrooz, Pakistan Times, and Lail-o-Nihar. These fired journalists formed Journalist United and revived a dummy paper called Azad. A rebellion case was filed against the editorial board of Azad in the Martial Law court, as they were favoring the Majority Party that won the election (the 1970 elections which the Awami League won). This action made it clear that even in General Yahya's government, freedom was restricted to immorality, not to the truth.
๐ก Why this matters: This period demonstrates that press freedom without ethical responsibility can be as damaging as state censorship.
๐ Example: 24 journalists were fired from PPL papers (Imrooz, Pakistan Times, and Lail-o-Nihar). They formed Journalist United and revived Azad. A rebellion case was filed against Azad's editorial board in Martial Law court for favoring the majority party that won the 1970 elections.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical point to remember is that Pakistan's early governments systematically suppressed left-leaning media, starting with Progressive Papers Limited (PPL) and its intellectuals like Faiz Ahmed Faiz. The Press and Publications Ordinance (PPO) of 1961 and the National Press Trust (NPT) of 1964 were the primary legal instruments used by Ayub Khan's regime to control newspapers, force publication of government handouts, and take over financially troubled publications. International news was also filtered through state agencies (APP/PPI). Although Yahya Khan's period (1969-1971) lifted the PPO, the resulting press freedom was marred by ethical decline, abusive language, and dummy papersโand journalists who supported the winning party in the 1970 elections were still targeted with rebellion cases. The pattern across all three periods shows that press freedom in Pakistan was consistently subordinated to political and ideological interests of the ruling regime.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What was Progressive Papers Limited (PPL), who founded it, and why was it specifically targeted by the government after Pakistan joined the American bloc?
- List three specific actions taken by Ayub Khan's government to control the press between 1958 and 1969.
- What clause in the Press and Publications Ordinance (PPO) of 1961 was considered most damaging to press freedom, and what did it require newspapers to do?
- How did the National Press Trust (NPT) of 1964 function, and which major newspapers were taken over by it?
- Why is General Yahya Khan's period (1969-1971) not considered a flourishing period of journalism, despite the lifting of the PPO?