📘 Lecture 9 — Role of Mass Media in the Era of 1977 to 1988
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the role of mass media in Pakistan during the politically turbulent period from 1977 to 1988, covering the later years of Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto’s rule, the imposition of martial law by General Zia-ul-Haq, and the media’s response to censorship, political movements, and international events like the Afghan War. Understanding this era is crucial for grasping how Pakistani media navigated state control, opposition movements, and geopolitical pressures.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the PPP’s constitutional contributions and media’s role in promoting the 1973 constitution; the Shimla Agreement and media’s clarification of its terms; the 1977 elections and the PNA movement; the imposition of the third martial law by General Zia-ul-Haq; censorship and cancellation of newspaper declarations; the PFUJ movement for press freedom; the launch of MRD for democracy restoration; local bodies elections in 1985; the Iranian Revolution and the Afghan War; and Pakistan’s role in the US-backed jihad against communism, with media support.
📝 Lecture Summary
Role of Mass Media in the Era of 1977 to 1988
The major contribution of PPP rule of 1972 was to develop a unified constitution accepted by all parties in the National Assembly. Pakistan is a federation, which always faces a problem of representation. This problem was solved by introducing a bicameral political system: Parliament was divided into the National Assembly (representation based on population) and the Senate (equal representation for all federating units). This gave confidence to smaller federating units that they would not be exploited by larger population units. In this era, mass media created awareness about the approved constitution and gave people the realization that the new constitution was the best one considering Pakistan’s circumstances — a positive contribution by newspapers.
Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto also signed the Shimla Agreement with the Indian government, leading to the release of 93,000 Pakistani army prisoners. Indian media started propaganda, giving the impression that the Shimla Agreement recognized the Kashmir Issue as a bilateral issue between Pakistan and India, which could not be raised on any international forum. Pakistani media clarified the vision of the people that no such clause was included in the Shimla Accord, stressing it was the best possible agreement signed.
Elections were held in 1977, and opposition parties formed an alliance called PNA (Pakistan National Alliance) — comprising 8 Pakistani political parties and 1 from Azad Jammu Kashmir. This alliance blamed the government for rigging in elections, and soon this movement became very violent. Mass media in this movement clearly presented the stance of opposition parties — something never seen before in Pakistan’s history. Only Radio, Television, and NPT newspapers presented the government’s point of view, but the rest of the papers felt their role and presented a real picture of the political arena.
On 5th July, Gen Zia ul Haq enforced the 3rd martial law in Pakistan’s history. He promised to play the role of an umpire, hold free and fair elections, and transfer power to the winning party. However, he postponed elections not just after 90 days but several times until 1985, when elections were held on a non-party basis.
During the martial law era, declarations of many newspapers were cancelled. Musawat was the first newspaper targeted by Gen Zia’s aggression, as it was the party newspaper of PPP. In the meanwhile, PFUJ (Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists) started a movement against the censorship policies of Gen Zia and against the cancellation of newspaper declarations.
On 14th March 1983, MRD (Movement for the Restoration of Democracy) was launched. 59 signatories signed a memorandum for the restoration of democracy. Among these signatories, 9 were NPT employees and 1 was a Punjab University professor. All 9 NPT employees were terminated from their services by the martial government and were restored in 1985 under the civil government of Muhammad Khan Junijo.
Local Bodies elections were held in 1985 by Gen Zia’s government, and newspapers projected the importance of these elections in a very forceful way.
In 1978, the communist faction in Afghanistan overthrew the government that was backed by the USSR. The very next year, the Iranian Revolution took place, a religious faction led by Ayatullah Khomeini came to power, and Raza Shah Pehlvi was forced to flee. The new Iranian government openly declared the USA as the open enemy of Iran. This posed a threat to the USA because America feared that through the influence of Afghanistan and an anti-American government, communism could reach the Gulf States and capture their oil resources.
Communist philosophy negates God and provokes a godless society. So Americans declared Muslims as their natural ally and planned to support the Jihadis for a holy war against communism. Pakistan had an important geographical position as its boundaries joined with Iran and Afghanistan, so Pakistan was given a leading role to stop communist influence. Pakistani media favored this holy war against communism. Pakistan was used as a base, and America launched a militant movement in collaboration with Gen Zia ul Haq that ended in 1989.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The 1977-1988 period in Pakistan was defined by martial law, political suppression, and significant media challenges. Mass media both promoted the 1973 constitution and clarified the Shimla Agreement, but under Zia’s rule, newspapers like Musawat faced declaration cancellations, and journalists’ unions like PFUJ resisted censorship. The MRD movement for democracy included NPT employees who were terminated. Internationally, the Iranian Revolution and the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan led to a US-backed jihad against communism, which Pakistani media supported, with Pakistan serving as a base for this movement. For exams, remember the dates and details of the 1977 elections, the 3rd martial law (5th July), the 1983 MRD launch, the 1985 local bodies elections, and the media’s role in the Afghan War.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Which was the first newspaper targeted by Gen Zia ul Haq’s government, and why?
- What was the composition of the PNA (Pakistan National Alliance) formed in 1977?
- On what date was the MRD (Movement for the Restoration of Democracy) launched, and how many NPT employees were among the signatories?
- How did Pakistani media clarify the terms of the Shimla Agreement regarding the Kashmir issue?
- What was the key reason the USA declared Muslims as their natural ally during the Afghan War period, and what role did Pakistani media play?
📘 Lecture 10 — Role of Mass Media in the Era of 1977 to 1988
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the complex role of mass media in Pakistan during the Zia-ul-Haq era (1977–1988), a period shaped by the Afghan Crisis and Iranian Revolution. It explores how media became aligned with state policy, particularly in supporting the Afghan Jihad, while failing to address rising sectarianism and extremism. The lecture critically analyzes how newspapers abandoned their social responsibility role during this authoritarian phase.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the international political events (Afghan Crisis, Iranian Revolution) that impacted Pakistan, General Zia-ul-Haq's Islamization agenda, the three demands Pakistan made to the USA for playing a role in the Afghan crisis, media's full support for Mujahideen and Jihadi groups, the consequences of this coverage including sectarian violence and religious extremism, newspapers' avoidance of sensitive religious topics, and the failure of Pakistani media to fulfill social responsibility theory.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Changes in International Political Arena (1979)
Two major international events—the Afghan Crisis and the Iranian Revolution—directly affected Pakistan. The country's geographical location made it a center of attention for super powers. Internally, General Zia-ul-Haq was trying to islamicize the country. Mass media working in Pakistan faced difficulties because ideal media functioning is only possible in democracy where everyone enjoys freedom of expression.
Religious-based political parties gained a major role as the Afghan issue promoted slogans of Jihad (Holy war), creating a suitable environment for such parties. General Zia-ul-Haq was also in favor of this approach. All newspapers of that time covered Afghan stories and fully supported Mujahideen and Jihadi groups.
Pakistan's Three Demands for Afghan Crisis Role
General Zia-ul-Haq presented three demands to perform a basic role in the Afghan crisis:
(a) Arms supply given to Mujahideen should be of Russian origin and no American ammunition would be used.
(b) No other country including USA would be allowed to contact Mujahideen directly. Aid for Afghan refugees would be dealt through Pakistan so that Pakistan could avoid any chaotic condition.
(c) At a given time, two aero planes loaded with ammunition would land in Pakistan. Further arms supply would be made after confirmation by this country.
Americans agreed to all three demands, and Pakistan started to play a significant role in Afghan Jihad, fully supported by mass media.
Negative Consequences of Media Coverage
Mass media in that era did not mention the negative aspects of Afghan policy, leaving many areas of concern for Pakistan:
- Pakistani militant groups gained expertise in ammunition during the Afghan war
- Sectarian groups armed themselves with modern weapons and ammunition
- Religious groups received encouragement that they were fighting a bigger enemy in the name of Jihad
- This aspect encouraged religious extremism and sectarian violence in the country
Newspapers' Failure in Social Responsibility
There was no tolerance preached by newspapers to acknowledge the creed and sects of others. Newspapers published news of sectarian violence quite regularly, but there was no planned effort to discourage sectarian violence.
Pakistani papers started to treat religion as a sensitive issue, avoiding such topics in editorials and articles. They used simplified terms to name and blame culprits.
Newspapers never developed social pressure on extremist groups by educating people. Papers never tried to organize that problem. In terms of Social Responsibility Theory, people ignored their role of social responsibility. The newspapers were never representative of the following definition of democracy in the country:
"When we agree to disagree with each other, it is democracy."
🔑 Definition — Social Responsibility Theory: A media theory that holds media should serve the public interest by presenting accurate, balanced information and by encouraging social harmony rather than merely pursuing profit or state interests.
📌 Example: During the Zia era, newspapers reported sectarian violence regularly but made no organized effort through editorials, articles, or public education to discourage such violence. This demonstrates a failure of social responsibility, as media did not use its influence to create social pressure against extremism.
💡 Why this matters: This example shows how media can become complicit in societal problems by reporting problems without attempting solutions, especially when the state promotes a particular narrative.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical lesson from this lecture is that mass media during the Zia-ul-Haq era (1977–1988) became a tool for state policy, fully supporting the Afghan Jihad narrative while ignoring negative consequences. Newspapers failed in their social responsibility by not discouraging sectarian violence, treating religion as too sensitive to critique, and never developing social pressure against extremist groups. The era demonstrated how media functioning is compromised under authoritarian regimes where freedom of expression is limited. Students must understand that media's silence on critical issues—even when reporting problems—represents a failure of democracy, which requires "agreeing to disagree" with others. The three demands of Pakistan to the USA show how the state controlled the Afghan crisis narrative that media then amplified.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What were the two major international events of 1979 that affected Pakistan during this era?
- What were the three demands General Zia-ul-Haq presented to the USA for Pakistan's role in the Afghan crisis?
- How did mass media coverage of the Afghan Jihad contribute to religious extremism and sectarian violence in Pakistan?
- Why does the lecture state that newspapers failed in their "social responsibility" during this period?
- What is the democratic principle quoted in the lecture that newspapers failed to represent?
📘 Lecture 11 — Role of Mass Media in the Era of 1988 to 1999
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the evolution of mass media in Pakistan during the politically turbulent period from 1988 to 1999. It covers key transitions including the end of military rule, changes in press ordinances, the rise of evening newspapers, conflicts between government and media, and media's role during national events like Pakistan's nuclear tests.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the non-party elections of 1985 and M. Khan Junicho's premiership, the international scenario under Gorbachev and USSR's withdrawal from Afghanistan, General Zia-ul-Haq's death and the subsequent caretaker government's replacement of PPO with RPPO, the emergence of evening newspapers and yellow journalism trends, governments from 1988 to 1996 and assembly dissolutions, the 1998 conflict between Nawaz Sharif and the Jang group over journalist dismissals, the journalist movement for press freedom, debates about government privileges affecting journalistic neutrality, and media's response to India and Pakistan's nuclear tests in 1998.
📝 Lecture Summary
Non-Party Elections and Political Background
In 1985, non-party elections were held to lift martial law, and M. Khan Junicho was appointed Prime Minister of Pakistan. On the international front, Michael Gorbachev came to power and determined that communism was no longer sustainable as a national movement. Because communism had an international character requiring USSR to support smaller communist countries, this was a burden on the USSR. According to the Geneva agreement, Gorbachev decided to withdraw Russian forces from Afghanistan, and by 1989, all Russian forces had been withdrawn.
Meanwhile, M. Khan Junicho was dismissed by General Zia-ul-Haq, who argued that the party system is not fruitful for Pakistan as there is no party system in Islam.
Caretaker Government and Press Ordinances
In 1988, General M. Zia-ul-Haq's Plane C130 crashed in Bhawalpur, and a caretaker government was formed. This caretaker government replaced the PPO (Press Publication Ordinance) with RPPO (Registration of Press & Publication Ordinance). However, when new assemblies were formed, this ordinance was not presented for approval and ultimately quashed. During the caretaker government period, with the decline of PPO, a lot of newspapers started to publish, which suddenly gave a boost to journalism in Pakistan.
💡 Why this matters: The replacement and eventual abandonment of the PPO represented a significant liberalization of press controls, allowing greater freedom for newspaper publication.
Emergence of Evening Newspapers
Gradually, a new trend of evening newspapers was introduced. Evening newspapers were quite common in Karachi but now they started to print from Lahore and Islamabad. This was considered a positive start. However, many critics said that they started a fiction trend and yellow journalism began to be practiced. Newspapers refuted this blame.
🔑 Definition — Yellow Journalism: [as implied in the lecture] A style of journalism that emphasizes sensationalism, exaggeration, and unverified or fictional content to attract readers, often at the expense of factual accuracy and ethical standards.
Political Instability (1988-1996)
From 1988 to 1996, different governments were formed, but each time the president dissolved assemblies at different times. In the 1996 election, Pakistan Muslim League achieved a landslide victory, and its governments were formed in all the provinces and also in the National Assembly.
Conflict Between Government and Jang Group (1998)
In 1998, a conflict was established between Muhammad Nawaz Sharif and the Jang group. Nawaz Sharif demanded that 23 journalists should be dismissed from the Jang group who were opposing Mian Nawaz Sharif's policy, but the Jang group refused to do so.
Against this step, journalists launched a movement and called it an attack on freedom of press.
Debate on Journalistic Neutrality
Following this conflict, a group of journalists started to argue that journalists should stop taking privileges from the government because it affects the neutrality of journalists. They argued that when journalists accept government privileges, their objective writing becomes subjective.
🔑 Definition — Objective Writing: Journalistic writing that is impartial, unbiased, and based on facts without personal opinions or influences from external sources such as government favors. 🔑 Definition — Subjective Writing: Journalistic writing influenced by personal opinions, biases, or external pressures, losing its neutral stance.
Nuclear Tests and Media Response (1998)
In 1998, India tested its nuclear devices and adopted a very aggressive policy against Pakistan. Pakistan responded to that aggressive policy by testing nuclear devices on 28th May, 1998.
On this event, all the newspapers started to favor the government stance and told the people that Pakistan is now in the race of super powers and there will be a new opening for Pakistan after that.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The period from 1988 to 1999 marked a significant transformation in Pakistani media, beginning with the replacement of the restrictive PPO with RPPO (which was later quashed), leading to a boom in newspaper publication. The introduction of evening newspapers from Lahore and Islamabad brought both positive growth and criticism of yellow journalism. The 1998 conflict between Nawaz Sharif and the Jang group sparked a major journalist movement defending press freedom, while simultaneously raising important debates about how government privileges compromise journalistic neutrality. Finally, during the 1998 nuclear tests, media universally supported the government stance, portraying Pakistan's achievement as entry into the superpower race.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What was the PPO, and how did the caretaker government change it in 1988?
- Why did critics accuse evening newspapers of practicing yellow journalism?
- What was the core demand that Nawaz Sharif made against the Jang group in 1998?
- According to some journalists, how do government privileges affect journalistic writing?
- How did Pakistani newspapers respond to Pakistan's nuclear tests on 28th May, 1998?
📘 Lecture 12 — Pakistan Towards Press Freedom
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the gradual evolution of press freedom in Pakistan, beginning with the caretaker government of 1988 following the Bahawalpur tragedy. It explores how global technological changes, particularly satellite communication, and international political events like 9/11 influenced Pakistan's media landscape and the government's approach to freedom of expression.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the historical suppression of press freedom under Ayub Khan's regime, the shift towards openness after 1988, the impact of satellite technology and dish antennas on information flow, the delayed publication of the Hamood Ur Rehman Commission Report on Dhaka's fall, and how the 9/11 tragedy and subsequent US-Afghanistan military operation affected Pakistani media's ability to present diverse viewpoints including anti-government sentiments.
📝 Lecture Summary
Freedom of Expression in Pakistan
Freedom of expression in Pakistan began with the arrival of the caretaker government after the tragedy of Bahawalpur in 1988. Meanwhile, the world was moving towards a global village through satellite communication, which made it impossible for governments to hide facts from the public. Pakistan was affected by this new technology as dish antennas became quite common across the country. The government felt this change and gradually started to think about press freedom.
Historical Suppression of Press Freedom
In Pakistan, there was never a favorable time regarding press freedom — facts were always kept hidden from the public. Ayub Khan was the first ruler who curtailed not only political growth but also the growth of press freedom. This trend of suppression prevailed in Pakistan for a very long time, and no government tried to break these chains of communication until 1988.
The Hamood Ur Rehman Commission Report
The inquiry report of Dhaka's fall, known as the Hamood Ur Rehman Commission Report, was published after 34 years in 2005. The reason for publication was that an Indian website revealed and published it on the internet. When it became an open secret, the government of Pakistan also decided to publicize the report. This is a clear example of how international scenarios affect national policies.
🔑 Definition — Hamood Ur Rehman Commission Report: The official inquiry report into the causes of East Pakistan's separation (Dhaka fall) in 1971, which was suppressed by successive Pakistani governments for 34 years until an Indian website leaked it online in 2005.
💡 Why this matters: This event demonstrates how global connectivity and foreign media can force national governments to release information they would otherwise keep secret, a key factor in the development of press freedom.
Impact of 9/11 on International Politics
The framework of international politics changed drastically after the 9/11 tragedy in the US. Strain in relations was seen on the international horizon — Western Europe and American relations became strained, and similarly, Middle East and American relations also went under great strain.
Pakistan's Role in the Afghan Military Operation
The blame for 9/11 was placed on Osama bin Laden and the Taliban in Afghanistan, so a military option was decided. To complete the military operation in Afghanistan, either Iran could be helpful or Pakistan. Since Iran had no bilateral relations with the US, Pakistan was the last suitable option for the USA. President Musharraf was contacted and his answer was in affirmation regarding helping US forces carry out the military operation.
🔑 Definition — 9/11 tragedy: The terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, in the United States, which fundamentally altered international relations and led to the US invasion of Afghanistan, subsequently affecting Pakistan's domestic and foreign policy.
Pakistani Media's Response to Musharraf's Stand
Pakistani newspapers clearly wrote that the people of Pakistan did not like President Musharraf's stand on the Afghan issue. Some newspapers even wrote that the US is not a reliable friend of Pakistan. Despite these criticisms, President Musharraf's statements that terrorism cannot be eradicated unless the root causes are removed were also reported. Thus, a balanced sort of view was seen in newspapers — they not only reflected government feelings but also expressed some anti-government sentiments.
First Independent Coverage by Pakistani Media
Generally, for all information, Pakistan relied on Western media that provides their own point of view. During the Iraq war, for the first time, private TV channels and newspapers sent their representatives to Jordan and Syria near the Iraq border to get the real picture. This was the first attempt of Pakistani mass media to present their own point of view independently.
📌 Example: During the Iraq War, Pakistani private TV channels and newspapers sent correspondents to Jordan and Syria — neighboring countries to Iraq — to independently report events rather than relying solely on Western media sources. This marked Pakistan's first effort at independent war coverage.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that press freedom in Pakistan began emerging only after 1988, following decades of suppression dating back to Ayub Khan's era. The Hamood Ur Rehman Commission Report's 34-year delay demonstrates how governments control sensitive information until forced by external factors like foreign media. The 9/11 tragedy transformed international politics and placed Pakistan in a strategic position between the US and Afghanistan, creating space for Pakistani media to express both pro-government and anti-government views. The Iraq War marked a watershed moment when Pakistani media first attempted independent war coverage by sending their own reporters rather than relying on Western sources. Ultimately, global technological changes like satellite communication and international events forced gradual liberalization of Pakistan's press environment.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What event in 1988 marked the beginning of freedom of expression in Pakistan?
- Which Pakistani ruler was the first to curtail both political growth and press freedom?
- Why was the Hamood Ur Rehman Commission Report finally published in 2005, 34 years after the Dhaka fall?
- How did President Musharraf's response to US requests for help in Afghanistan create space for Pakistani media to express diverse viewpoints?
- What was significant about Pakistani media's coverage of the Iraq War compared to previous international conflicts?
📘 Lecture 13 — Role of Print Media After 2000
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the evolving role of print media in Pakistan after the year 2000, focusing on the complex relationship between the government and media. It critically analyzes the divergent policies and coverage of English versus Urdu newspapers on key national issues such as terrorism, nuclear policy, child labour, women's rights, and religious extremism, highlighting the profound impact of these differences on public opinion and government initiatives.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the watch-dog role of mass media versus government interests; the impact of the Musharraf government's post-9/11 US support; the phenomenon of dummy newspapers and untrained staff; the significant policy divide between English and Urdu newspapers; and specific case studies including nuclear tests (1998), child labour, women's rights, religious extremism, and President Musharraf's anti-extremism policy.
📝 Lecture Summary
Role of Print Media After 2000
Mass media and governments are often in opposition because governments want to highlight achievements, while mass media acts as a watch dog, interested in flaws and mistakes. The mistakes of the government become a hot issue when printed in newspapers, keeping reader interest intact. Newspapers seek stories that portray something exciting for the people. The decision of Musharraf Government to support the US after 9/11 cost a lot for Pakistan, as a fresh wave of terrorism was seen across the country.
💡 Why this matters: This tension between government spin and media scrutiny defines the environment in which Pakistani journalism operates.
Dummy Newspapers and Untrained Staff
Every newspaper tries to keep itself in the mainstream. However, some dummy newspapers remain in the main line by submitting copies of the newspapers to the press branch. The declaration of newspapers is bound to their circulation. Many dummy newspapers just to keep their declaration intact give the impression that the newspaper is printing, so they keep submitting a few copies to the press branch. In Pakistan, many newspaper staff are untrained. The emergence of RPPO (Removal of Press and Publications Ordinances) started a mushroom growth of newspapers, and these newly emerged newspapers could not find technically competent staff. Therefore, many journalists are unaware of the working conditions and ethics of journalism.
🔑 Definition — Dummy Newspapers: Newspapers that exist only on paper for the purpose of maintaining their legal declaration and circulation registration, without genuine readership or journalistic output.
Policy Divergence Between English and Urdu Newspapers
In Pakistan, mainstream newspapers are either English or Urdu. Local language newspapers have little influence. Unfortunately, even these two types of newspapers have a major difference in their policies. The readership of English newspapers is very different in culture, values, status, economic interest, and political understanding. Therefore, we see a widening horizon between these two papers. Some groups in Pakistan print both Urdu and English newspapers, but their policy is found different for Urdu newspapers and different for English newspapers.
Case Study: Nuclear Tests of 1998
The best example of the difference of opinion between English and Urdu newspapers can be seen in 1998. When India tested nuclear devices and the Pakistani government was thinking about a response for three weeks, Urdu newspapers clearly supported the stance that Pakistan should also have nuclear weapons. Urdu newspapers never talked about the harmful impacts of nuclear weapons. On the other hand, English newspapers opted for a very moderate stance and clearly informed the public about the negative impacts of nuclear weapons.
Case Study: Child Labour and Women's Rights
Child Labour is another issue dealt with very seriously by English newspapers, which clearly condemn the issue, while there is very rare chance of any such news or article in Urdu newspapers. Similarly, English newspapers very frequently talk about Woman rights and show the clear picture of their exploitation in society as a suppressed class, while Urdu newspapers remained silent on this issue for quite a long time.
Case Study: Religious Extremism
Religious extremism is condemned by English newspapers, while Urdu newspapers have no such policy. In fact, many times in Urdu newspapers articles were written or news was molded in a way that people developed sympathy with religious extremists. Politicians also did not condemn religious extremism. Since Urdu newspapers give 70% of their news in the form of political statements, a common man had nothing else to read, and politicians were silent on the issue.
Failure of Government Policy on Extremism
President Musharaf's policy to uproot extremism could not be successful because Urdu newspapers never supported the policy, and the common man got very little to read about the negative impacts of extremism. It is a fact that only those movements got success that were supported by mass media, as happened in 1977 and during the Afghan Jihad. English newspapers played their part, but the majority of Urdu newspapers did not do that. In a nutshell, the basic reason for government failure in catering religious extremism was the role of Urdu newspapers, as they never supported the government on this issue.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The single most critical insight from this lecture is the deep and consequential policy divide between English and Urdu newspapers in Pakistan. English newspapers consistently adopt a moderate, progressive stance on issues like nuclear weapons, child labour, women's rights, and religious extremism, informing the public about negative consequences. In contrast, Urdu newspapers either remain silent or actively shape public opinion in support of nationalist or extremist viewpoints, directly influencing the failure of government policies like President Musharraf's anti-extremism drive. This divergence stems from the different readership bases — English papers catering to a more educated, elite, and internationally aware audience, while Urdu papers rely heavily on political statements and reflect more conservative public sentiment. Additionally, the phenomenon of dummy newspapers and untrained staff undermines overall journalistic quality in Pakistan.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Why did President Musharraf's policy to uproot extremism fail, according to the lecture?
- What was the difference in coverage between English and Urdu newspapers regarding India's 1998 nuclear tests?
- What is a "dummy newspaper" and why do such publications exist in Pakistan?
- Which social issues are covered by English newspapers but largely ignored by Urdu newspapers?
- What percentage of Urdu newspaper content typically comes in the form of political statements?
📘 Lecture 14 — The Present Situation of Print Media in Pakistan
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the current state of print media in Pakistan, focusing on differences between Urdu and English newspapers regarding religious extremism. It critically analyzes the freedom of mass media in Muslim countries compared to the West, and highlights the challenges of propaganda, outdated terminology, and lack of self-analysis platforms in Pakistani media.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the sensitivity of Pakistani media on Islamic character, the lack of press freedom in most Muslim countries, the monopoly of Western media in shaping global opinions, psychological warfare as part of Western media strategy, the four influential groups in a state, the misuse of superficial terms like “unanimous opinion” and “dynamic leadership” in Pakistani media, and the need for neutrality and modernization in Pakistani mass media.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Present Situation of Print Media in Pakistan
In Pakistan, Urdu and English newspapers differ significantly in their content regarding religious extremism. Pakistani mass media has been very sensitive on International Islamic Character even before Pakistan’s creation, as seen in the Khilafat Movement. Most Muslim countries have not paid attention to the identity of their own country or other Islamic countries; the concept of Ummah negates nationalism for them, which ignores the present age of nation states. In Muslim countries, mass media is not as free as it is in Pakistan and Turkey, so Pakistani media is free to criticize the government to a great extent.
🔑 Definition — Ummah: The collective community of Muslim believers, which some argue negates the concept of nationalism in Muslim countries.
💡 Why this matters: The tension between Ummah and nationalism shapes how Pakistani media covers both domestic and international Islamic issues, influencing editorial policies and content.
Mass Media as a Platform for Self-Analysis
Mass media presents an analysis of a nation’s drawbacks. If media is under constant observation and not free, it becomes impossible to analyze a nation. Unfortunately, the Muslim world has no platform for self-analysis because press is not free in most Muslim countries. This gap is filled by Western mass media, so people are bound to see Western media to satisfy their curiosity about the drawbacks of their governments.
🔑 Definition — Self-analysis platform: A free press environment that allows a nation to critically examine its own weaknesses and failures.
Western Media Monopoly and Psychological Warfare
Western mass media creates a monopoly and tries to manipulate the ideas of other nations. They have been so successful that today, if Economist, Time Magazine, and New York Times write something, it is considered true. Western media has mastered psychology of warfare — psychological warfare is a part of mass media. The Muslim world is far behind in safeguarding its interests in this regard.
📐 Formula: Western Media Monopoly → Global Manipulation of Ideas → Acceptance as Truth
📌 Example: When Time Magazine or The New York Times publishes a story about a Muslim country, it is widely accepted as true globally, even if it does not reflect local realities, because Muslim countries lack their own credible media platforms.
The Role of Media in Influencing Policy
In any state, there are four influential groups: Policy Makers, Military Elites, Politicians, and Civilians. To influence policy makers, it is important to influence the common man because statesmen take decisions in favor of the people. Direct communication has an important part to play — television, radio, and newspapers play an important role in it.
🔑 Definition — Four influential groups: Policy Makers, Military Elites, Politicians, and Civilians — the key stakeholders that media must target to influence national policy.
Problematic Terminology in Pakistani Media
Democratic societies do not use superficial sorts of words in mass media. The word “unanimous opinion” is most commonly used in Pakistani media, while there is no unanimity in democracy because democracy means to acknowledge different thoughts. Another word exploited by Pakistani mass media is “dynamic leadership.” All these words show how biased Pakistani media is and how bad its outlook is compared to other mass media of the world. Pakistani mass media is still working on the same footing as it did during the Pakistan movement — using obsolete and outdated terms. Mass media should realize that times have changed and we are no longer in conflict. Such words used for leaders of the Pakistan movement should be avoided. Present-age media should look like a true established democratic media, and neutrality should be its chief characteristic.
📌 Example: The term “dynamic leadership” was used excessively for political leaders during the Pakistan movement era. Using the same term for modern politicians creates a biased and outdated portrayal that does not reflect democratic neutrality.
💡 Why this matters: Outdated terminology maintains a conflict-oriented mindset in media, preventing Pakistan from developing a mature, neutral, and democratic press culture.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that Urdu and English newspapers in Pakistan differ in their coverage of religious extremism, reflecting linguistic and audience-based editorial biases. The Muslim world lacks free media platforms for self-analysis, forcing people to rely on Western media that monopolizes global narratives and uses psychological warfare. Pakistani media still uses obsolete terms like “unanimous opinion” and “dynamic leadership” which contradict democratic principles of acknowledging diverse opinions. Neutrality should be the chief characteristic of modern democratic media, and media must move beyond the conflict-oriented language of the Pakistan movement era. To influence policy makers, media must first influence the common man, as statesmen make decisions in favor of the people.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- How do Urdu and English newspapers in Pakistan differ in content regarding religious extremism?
- Why is the Muslim world unable to perform self-analysis through its own media, and how does Western media fill this gap?
- What are the four influential groups in any state according to this lecture?
- Why is the term “unanimous opinion” problematic in a democratic media context?
- What is “psychological warfare” in the context of Western mass media, and why is the Muslim world behind in countering it?
📘 Lecture 15 — Newspaper Contents and Changes in It Over the Period of Time
📖 Overview: This lecture traces the historical evolution of newspaper content from simple narrative stories to the modern structured format. It identifies the three core segments of a newspaper—advertising, editorial, and news—and explains how advertising has become the financial backbone, influencing editorial policy and newspaper operations.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the historical evolution of newspapers from unformatted story forms (like the popular Paisa newspaper in the sub-continent) to the modern segmented format. It then explores the three fundamental segments: advertising as the lifeblood of newspapers (including the misconception of Jewish control), the editorial page with its columns and letters to the editor, and the reporting segment with its beats, shifts, and news collection sources.
📝 Lecture Summary
Historical Evolution of Newspaper Format
In the beginning, newspapers were not in the form they are seen today. In the earlier phase, newspapers were just in a story form, and there was no concept of formatting of news. In the sub-continent, the Paisa newspaper was very popular; its layout was just like a Magazine, and there was no concept of a heading.
🔑 Definition — Paisa newspaper: A popular early newspaper in the sub-continent that lacked modern news formatting and had a magazine-like layout without headings. 💡 Why this matters: This shows how the visual structure of news is a relatively modern invention.
The Three Basic Segments of a Modern Newspaper
There are three basic segments in a newspaper nowadays: (a) Advertising, (b) Editorial, and (c) News.
Advertising is a very important feature of a newspaper. The most persuasive advertising leaves a lasting impact and has great appeal for the newspaper readers. There is a general misconception that news sources are directly under the control of Jews. In fact, Jews own Multinational companies and they are the biggest advertisers. Therefore, advertising is the life blood of a newspaper, which is why newspapers subdue to the policy of these multinationals.
🔑 Definition — Life blood of a newspaper: Advertising, which gives newspapers financial viability and substantial influence over editorial policy. 📐 Concept: Advertising revenue → Multinational company influence → Newspaper policy alignment 📌 Example: Jewish-owned multinationals are among the biggest advertisers; thus, newspapers adjust their policies to avoid losing this crucial revenue.
A newspaper has a circulation department, and good newspapers do a lot of research to find out the interest of the readers. This marketing is a device to address the interest of the readers so that the circulation of the newspapers can be enhanced.
Editorials are another important segment. The subjective opinion of every kind is given on this page. The ethics of journalism say that news should be objective; therefore, a separate page is associated for that, called the editorial page. Usually, the editorial page reflects the policy of the newspaper. Columns are printed on the editorial page. In the beginning, columns were just humorous. In the sub-continent, Abdul Majeed Salik, Chragh Hassan Hasrat, and Atta-ul-Haq Qasmi are prominent names in this horizon. Usually, columns are called the interpretation of the news. Walter Lipan, a famous journalist, says that "events are not important unless they are reported." Letters to the editor also carry a personal opinion, so they are printed on the Editorial Page.
🔑 Definition — Editorial page: The page in a newspaper dedicated to subjective opinion that reflects the newspaper's policy, as opposed to objective news pages. 🔑 Definition — Column: A piece on the editorial page, originally humorous, now considered the interpretation of news.
Reporting is the third important segment. Every kind of news is classified into its respective beat. Every reporter in a newspaper has a special beat. News are constantly monitored by sub editors in a news room. Every source is used by the newspapers to collect the news: Radio, television, news agencies (National and International news agencies). For reporting, there are normally three shifts, and the last shift is very important till 2am because it has to collect all the material until the dead line.
🔑 Definition — Beat: A specific area or topic assigned to a reporter for regular news coverage. 🔑 Definition — Dead line: The final time (noted as 2am for the last shift) by which all material must be collected for the newspaper.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that newspapers evolved from unstructured story formats to three distinct segments: advertising, editorial, and news. Advertising is the critical financial driver, often leading to policy accommodation of major advertisers (multinationals). The editorial page serves as the space for subjective opinion and the newspaper's policy reflection, while the news/reporting segment relies on beats, sub-editors, multiple shifts, and diverse news sources (radio, TV, agencies). For the exam, remember the three segments, the role of advertising as "life blood," the names of sub-continent columnists, and the function of the editorial page versus objective news reporting.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What were the characteristics of the Paisa newspaper in the sub-continent?
- What are the three basic segments of a modern newspaper?
- According to the lecture, why do newspapers subdue to the policy of multinational companies?
- Who are the three prominent columnists mentioned from the sub-continent, and what was the original nature of columns?
- Why is the last shift (until 2am) considered very important in newspaper reporting?