π Lecture 21 β Press and Government III
π Overview: This lecture examines the historical tension between the press and government in Pakistan, focusing on repressive measures taken against journalists and newspapers. It traces key events from the post-independence Security Act through the 1971 crisis, and documents the mechanisms governments use to control media, while also outlining professional journalistic standards and Pakistan's major press organizations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture discusses the Security Act rejected by Quaid-e-Azam but later enforced, government actions during the 1971 East Pakistan crisis and its aftermath, specific punitive measures used against newspapers including ad and newsprint quota reductions, the Declaration of Principles on the Conduct of Journalists from the International Federation of Journalists, and three major Pakistani press organizations: All Pakistan Newspapers Society (APNS), Council of Pakistan Newspaper's Editors (CPNE), and Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ).
π Lecture Summary
Press and Government III
In all societies of the world, democratic or un-democratic, rulers always resent any attempt to provide new philosophies, new opinions and new ideas to the people. Press history of Pakistan shows that most actions taken against the press and journalists by the government were taken in the first 5-7 years of its independence. Immediately after independence a Security Act was brought in front of Quaid-e-Azam which was a black law to restrict the freedom of people and press. Under this act, law enforcing agencies had the authority to arrest any person for three to six months without giving any reason in the name of keeping peace, law and order or to avoid any law and order situation. Quaid-e Azam being a man of law very rigorously rejected this act. After Quaid's death the same Act was first enforced as an ordinance and later on passed by the parliament and enforced as a law. This Security Act was brutally used against politicians and the journalists by the later governments.
π Definition β Security Act: A repressive law that allowed law enforcement agencies to arrest any person for 3-6 months without reason or charge, rejected by Quaid-e-Azam but later enacted as law after his death.
1971-1977
In 1971 crisis, journalists and newspapers were under strict observation and no journalist or newspaper was permitted to write about situation or incidents happening in East Pakistan, to keep the people blind of the situation. Freedom of press which was bestowed on newspapers and journalists was for obscene and immoral things, not for objective or unbiased reporting. People's right to know was an unacceptable thing to the government. Later, nation's anger over country's humiliating defeat by India boiled into street demonstrations throughout country. To forestall further unrest, General Yahya hastily surrendered his powers to Zulfikar Ali Bhutto of Pakistan People's Party. After Dhaka fall media played a great role in re-boasting nation's morale that were very disappointed over country's division into two parts and brought them back to the real life. Even then Draconian law, PPO (Press and Publications Ordinance) was revived again and used against the press by the new government. Weekly Outlook and Punjab Punch were closed down using this ordinance despite the fact that they were among those papers that supported PPP in election.
Different governments used different actions against newspapers and journalists in different times. However most actions usually taken by the governments against newspapers to show their anger and to punish them are: Quota of Official ads is reduced or abandoned; Newsprint quota is reduced; Ending up subscription of newspapers in public institutions; Not inviting journalists to official functions and not to let them cover official meetings, seminars or functions.
π Definition β PPO (Press and Publications Ordinance): A Draconian law revived after the 1971 crisis and used to suppress press freedom, resulting in closure of newspapers like Weekly Outlook and Punjab Punch.
Declaration of Principles on the Conduct of Journalists
Adopted by the Second World Congress of the International Federation of Journalists at Bordeaux on 25-28 April 1954 and amended by the 18th IFJ World Congress in HelsingΓΆr on 2-6 June 1986. This international Declaration is proclaimed as a standard of professional conduct for journalists engaged in gathering, transmitting, disseminating and commenting on news and information and in describing events.
- Respect for truth and for the right of the public to truth is the first duty of the journalist.
- In pursuance of this duty, the journalist shall at all times defend the principles of freedom in the honest collection and publication of news, and of the right of fair comment and criticism.
- The journalist shall report only in accordance with facts of which he/ she knows the origin. The journalist shall not suppress essential information or falsify documents.
- The journalist shall use only fair methods to obtain news, photographs and documents.
- The journalist shall do the utmost to rectify any published information which is found to be harmfully inaccurate.
- The journalist shall observe professional secrecy regarding the source of information obtained in confidence.
- The journalist shall be aware of the danger of discrimination being furthered by the media, and shall do the utmost to avoid facilitating such discrimination based on, among other things, race, sex, sexual orientation, language, religion, political or other opinions, and national or social origins.
- The journalist shall regard as grave professional offences the following: Plagiarism; Malicious misrepresentation; Calumny, slander, libel, unfounded accusations; Acceptance of a bribe in any form in consideration of either publication or suppression.
- Journalists worthy of that name shall deem in their duty to observe faithfully the principles stated above. Within the general law of each country the journalist shall recognize in professional matters the jurisdiction of colleagues only, to the exclusion of every kind of interference by governments or others.
π Definition β Declaration of Principles on the Conduct of Journalists: An international standard of professional conduct for journalists adopted by the IFJ in 1954, emphasizing truth, freedom, fair methods, accuracy, and prohibiting plagiarism, misrepresentation, and bribery.
APNS (All Pakistan Newspapers Society)
APNS is the organization of the Pakistani newspapers' owners. Its election is held every year; three major groups of newspapers are the major players of APNS that are: Jang Group, Dawn Group and Nawa-i-Waqt Group. These groups are accused for bribing the smaller newspapers and getting benefit at large from the successive governments. This is the major body which refuses to give the Wage Board Award to the working journalists. According to the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists, the labor laws are violated in the Pakistani newspaper industry but no government dares to take action against these powerful elite of the country.
It was founded in 1953 by the major, pioneering editors and publishers of the day to facilitate the exchange of views between the editors of the major publications of Pakistan and to protect the rights of newspapers by giving them a voice to appeal unfair decisions against them. Today, the APNS is a clearing house of sorts for its member publications, safeguarding the commercial interests of newspapers under its membership (including tax payment). For example, if a company advertises in a publication but refuses to pay, the publication complains to the APNS. The APNS gives the agency an ultimatum: pay or get blacklisted.
Its founders were: Hamid Nizami, Altaf Hussain β all the important, pioneering editors of the day. Before APNS in 1950, the Pakistan Newspapers Society (PNS) was founded (to emerge the existing publishers), when the editors of the time realized that the print media needed organization and needed a clearing house. However, the PNS didn't last for very long as it didn't receive much support from publishers, advertisers or authorities. Three years later in 1953 the All Pakistan Newspapers Society (APNS) came into being. It was badly needed to 'facilitate the exchange of views amongst newspaper owners on matters of common interest.' APNS successfully gave newspaper owners the means to watch over, protect, preserve and promote the rights and interest of the newspaper industry on matters directly or indirectly affecting its rights and interests. The Daily DAWN was the founding member.
π‘ Why this matters: APNS represents newspaper owners' commercial interests but has been criticized for opposing fair wages for working journalists, highlighting the tension between ownership and labor rights in Pakistani media.
π Definition β APNS (All Pakistan Newspapers Society): An organization founded in 1953 representing Pakistani newspaper owners, primarily the Jang, Dawn, and Nawa-i-Waqt groups, that protects commercial interests of member publications including advertising payment and tax matters.
CPNE (Council of Pakistan Newspaper's Editors)
A couple of years later after APNS came into existence, in 1955, the Council of Pakistan Newspaper's Editors (CPNE) was established as a representative body of the editors of the publications of Pakistan. Both the CPNE and the APNS struggled against black press laws that trampled over the freedom of the press.
π Definition β CPNE (Council of Pakistan Newspaper's Editors): A representative body established in 1955 for editors of Pakistani publications, which alongside APNS fought against repressive press laws.
PFUJ (Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists)
Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ) is located in Islamabad, Pakistan. PFUJ is arguably South Asia's first association representing the journalists of an entire country. To its credit, in the 50-odd years since its inception it has always stood out as a symbol of freedom of speech. The battles it waged for press freedom and for a democratic dispensation in the country will always remain etched in the collective memory of Pakistanis. To this day, PFUJ remains committed to the ideals for which it was established in 1950. Set up primarily to work towards a better working environment for Pakistani journalists, it didn't remain isolated from the struggles and campaigns launched by the civil society. In fact, it was in the vanguard whenever sacrifices needed to be made and freedoms were to be won.
Pakistani journalists are although following some code of ethics on their own as different media organizations and newspapers have their own code of ethics but there is no unanimous written code of ethics for the country's press which is mainly because PFUJ has always stood on the demand that the government should first abolish the black laws against press and after that talk about the code of ethics. In established democracies, press and media have their own independent bodies, court of honours and code of ethics to keep the media, press and journalists accountable.
Among the laws that are used against press, newspapers and journalists, other than press/media laws, are laws of defamation and liable. Another law of contempt of court is also used against press and journalists particularly in case of court reporting.
π‘ Why this matters: PFUJ positions itself as a defender of press freedom rather than a regulator, refusing to adopt a code of ethics until repressive laws are abolished, contrasting with established democracies where media self-regulation exists.
π Definition β PFUJ (Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists): South Asia's first national journalists' association, established in 1950 in Islamabad, committed to better working conditions for journalists and fighting for press freedom, refusing to adopt a code of ethics until black laws against press are abolished.
β Key Takeaways
The Security Act rejected by Quaid-e-Azam was later enforced and used against journalists, demonstrating how early post-independence governments suppressed press freedom through black laws. During the 1971 crisis, strict censorship prevented reporting on East Pakistan, and after the Dhaka fall, the PPO was revived to close newspapers even those supporting the government. Governments typically punish newspapers by reducing official ads, cutting newsprint quotas, ending subscriptions, and excluding journalists from official events. Three major press organizations exist in Pakistan: APNS (owners' body founded 1953), CPNE (editors' body founded 1955), and PFUJ (journalists' union founded 1950), with PFUJ refusing to adopt a code of ethics until black laws are abolished. The IFJ Declaration of Principles establishes international standards for journalists including truth, fair methods, confidentiality, and prohibiting plagiarism and bribery.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the Security Act rejected by Quaid-e-Azam, and how was it later used against journalists?
- List four specific actions governments take to punish newspapers according to the lecture.
- What are the three major groups that dominate APNS, and what criticism is leveled against them regarding the Wage Board Award?
- Why does PFUJ refuse to adopt a unanimous written code of ethics for Pakistani journalists?
- According to the IFJ Declaration of Principles, what are the four grave professional offences journalists must regard?
π Lecture 22 β Press and Government IV
π Overview: This lecture covers the relationship between the Pakistani press and government from 1977 onward, beginning with the Zia-ul-Haq era and its harsh press restrictions. It also explores the fundamental concept of the people's right to know, examining international declarations, Pakistan's constitutional provisions, and the flawed Freedom of Information Ordinance of 2002.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with General Zia-ul-Haq's military coup in 1977 and the severe press restrictions including closures, arrests, and pre-censorship that lasted until 1988. It then covers the transition to the RPPPO ordinance and the relatively better environment for press under subsequent governments, including Musharraf's era. The second half examines the philosophical foundation of press freedom through the people's right to know, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966), and critically analyzes Article 19 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 and the Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002.
π Lecture Summary
1977- till date
General Zia-ul-Haq came to power by overthrowing Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto after widespread civil disorder in a military coup on July 5, 1977, and imposed Martial Law. He assumed the post of President of Pakistan in 1978 and was assassinated in a planned aircraft crash on August 17, 1988 under mysterious circumstances.
18 magazines and newspapers were closed down and almost 150 journalists were arrested and given different punishments by the Martial Law courts during this period. For a long time, pre-censorship was imposed on newspapersβno newspaper could publish anything without prior approval from the Information Department. In protest, newspapers initially published leaving empty spaces for censored news, but they were then ordered by the Information Department to publish some other news in place of censored news. These restrictions continued until 1988.
After Zia's death, the new caretaker government repealed PPO and introduced a new, better ordinance: the Registration of Printing Press and Publications Ordinance (RPPPO). RPPPO was a sign of relief for journalists and newspapers, and since then the press has comparatively enjoyed and worked in a better environment without major clashes with the government. The only exception was during 1997-99 when Nawaz Sharif's government had some problems with the Jang Group of Newspapers.
On 12th October, 1999, General Musharraf took over, but no new law or additional restrictions were imposed on the press. Rather, Musharraf's government appreciated the private sector and gave them a chance to invest more in electronic media, which resulted in many new radio and TV channels.
π‘ Why this matters: This chronology shows how press freedom in Pakistan has been directly tied to the type of government in power, with military regimes imposing the harshest restrictions and democratic/caretaker governments offering more freedom.
People's right to know
Freedom of press is linked with the people's right to know or free access to information that ensures accountability and a true democratic society. In all democratic societies, government accepts people's right to know and therefore cannot stop anyone from getting any information. It is an accepted basic human right in democratic societies to keep governments accountable to the public.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)
On December 10, 1948, the General Assembly of the United Nations adopted and proclaimed the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The Assembly called upon all member countries to publicize the text of the Declaration and "to cause it to be disseminated, displayed, read and expounded principally in schools and other educational institutions, without distinction based on the political status of countries or territories."
Article 19: "Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers."
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)
Article 19
- Everyone shall have the right to hold opinions without interference.
- Everyone shall have the right to freedom of expression; this right shall include freedom to seek, receive and impart information and ideas of all kinds, regardless of frontiers, either orally, in writing or in print, in the form of art, or through any other media of his choice.
- The exercise of these rights carries with it special duties and responsibilities. It may therefore be subject to certain restrictions, but these shall only be such as are provided by law and are necessary:
- For respect of the rights or reputations of others.
- For the protection of national security or of public order (order public), or of public health or morals.
Till 2002, this basic right was not approved or accepted in Pakistan. Freedom of expression and freedom of press is mentioned in the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 but with conditions that are very vague and can be used by the government to exploit any journalist, newspaper, or media organization.
Constitution of Pakistan 1973
Article 19: "Every citizen shall have the right of freedom of speech and expression, and there shall be freedom of the press, subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of the glory of Islam or the integrity, security, or defense of Pakistan or any part thereof, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality or in relation to the contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an office."
During the caretaker government of Malik Mairaj Khalid (Nov. 1996 β Feb. 1997), Information Minister Javed Jabbar introduced an ordinance "Right to know." But the government that came later did not forward it in the assembly, and therefore the ordinance died its own death.
In October 2002, when international donors insisted on legislation on the people's right to know, an ordinance called the Freedom of Information Ordinance was hurriedly promulgated by General Musharraf's government. The fact that the parliament that had come into being at that time was deliberately bypassed in making the law throws some light on the negative attitude of the government of the day on the issue.
Some serious flaws in the Freedom of Information Law stand out:
- First, the ordinance is in addition to, and not in derogation of, anything contained in any other law for the time being in force. This means that if there is any law that militates against the right to know, that law will take precedence over the ordinance and nullify its effect.
- Secondly, the ordinance prohibits making public several important documents which throw light on the decision-making process in government departments. These include noting on files, minutes of meetings, any interim orders, records of banking companies relating to the accounts of their customers, and the record of private documents furnished to public offices among others. Denying access to these important documents means shielding the government against charges of mis-governance and corruption in hatching schemes and making purchases that might be utterly useless or downright harmful.
π‘ Why this matters: The Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002, despite its name, contained structural flaws that effectively allowed the government to continue withholding crucial information, defeating the very purpose of a right-to-know law.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture is critical for understanding how press freedom in Pakistan has evolved through different regimes and the legal frameworks governing it. The Zia-ul-Haq era (1977-1988) was the most repressive period, with 18 publications closed, 150 journalists arrested, and strict pre-censorship imposed. The transition to RPPPO after Zia's death marked a significant improvement. Internationally, press freedom is protected under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966), both guaranteeing freedom of opinion and expression. However, Pakistan's Constitution of 1973, Article 19, grants freedom of speech and press only "subject to reasonable restrictions" based on vague grounds like Islam's glory, national security, and public order, making it easy for governments to suppress dissent. The Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002 was deeply flawed because it was subordinate to other laws and specifically exempted key decision-making documents like file notings and meeting minutes from public access.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What happened to newspapers that left empty spaces for censored news during Zia-ul-Haq's regime, and what was the government's response?
- What was the Registration of Printing Press and Publications Ordinance (RPPPO), when was it introduced, and why was it significant?
- According to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), Article 19, what specific rights does everyone have regarding freedom of opinion and expression?
- What are the two major flaws in the Freedom of Information Ordinance 2002 that make it ineffective in ensuring the people's right to know?
- How does Article 19 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 differ from the international standards set by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the ICCPR regarding freedom of expression?