๐ Lecture 14 โ The Process of Diagnosis
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental process of diagnosis in clinical psychology, including its importance, advantages, and historical evolution. It provides a detailed examination of the DSM-IV classification system, its structure, and the critical issues surrounding psychiatric classification such as reliability, validity, and bias, which are essential for understanding how mental disorders are identified and treated.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining why diagnosis is important and its four major advantages: communication, enabling research, investigating etiology, and guiding treatment. It then traces early classification systems leading to the DSM-IV, detailing its multi-axial structure and providing a case example. The second half examines eight general issues in classification: categories versus dimensions, bases of categorization, pragmatics, description, reliability, validity, bias, coverage, and additional concerns about the social impact of labeling.
๐ Lecture Summary
THE IMPORTANCE OF DIAGNOSIS
Diagnosis is a type of expert-level categorization essential for survival, allowing us to make important distinctions (e.g., mild cold versus viral pneumonia). The diagnosis of mental disorders enables mental health professionals to make critical distinctions, such as between schizophrenia and bipolar disorder with psychotic features.
๐ Definition โ Diagnosis: An expert level of categorization used by mental health professionals that enables us to make important distinctions between mental disorders.
ADVANTAGES OF DIAGNOSIS
There are at least four major advantages. First, a primary function is communication. A wealth of information can be conveyed in a single diagnostic term, acting as "verbal shorthand." Using standardized diagnostic criteria (like those in the DSM-IV) ensures comparability. Diagnostic systems are especially useful because they are largely descriptiveโbehaviors and symptoms are presented without reference to theories of causes, allowing use by diagnosticians of any theoretical persuasion.
Second, diagnoses enable and promote empirical research in psychopathology. Clinical psychologists define experimental groups in terms of diagnostic features, allowing comparisons. Diagnostic constructs stimulate research on individual criteria, alternative criteria sets, and comorbidity (co-occurrence) between disorders.
๐ Definition โ Comorbidity: The co-occurrence of two or more disorders in the same individual.
Third, research into the etiology (causes) of abnormal behavior would be almost impossible without a standardized system. To investigate potential etiological factors, subjects must first be assigned to groups sharing diagnostic features. For example, the hypothesis that childhood sexual abuse predisposes individuals to borderline personality disorder (BPD) could only be tested with a reliable method of assigning subjects to the BPD category.
Finally, diagnoses may suggest which mode of treatment is most likely effective. For instance, a diagnosis of schizophrenia suggests antipsychotic medication is more likely effective than psychoanalytic psychotherapy. However, often several treatments appear equally effective for an individual disorder.
๐ก Why this matters: Diagnosis serves multiple critical functionsโfrom simple communication and research to understanding causes and guiding treatment decisionsโmaking it a cornerstone of clinical practice.
EARLY CLASSIFICATION SYSTEMS
Classification systems for mental disorders have existed for many years. The earliest reference to a depressive syndrome appeared as far back as 2600 B.C. The Congress of Mental Science adopted a single classification system in 1889 in Paris. More recent attempts trace to the World Health Organization's 1948 International Statistical Classification of Diseases, Injuries, and Causes of Death.
In 1952, the American Psychiatric Association published its own classification system in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM-I) , containing a glossary describing each diagnostic category. This was followed by revisions: DSM-II (1968), DSM-III (1980), and DSM-III-R (1987). Presently, the most widely used system is the DSM-IV (1994). All these manuals embody Emil Kraepelin's late nineteenth-century efforts.
The most revolutionary changes were introduced in DSM-III (1980), including: explicit diagnostic criteria, a multiaxial system of diagnosis, a descriptive approach neutral regarding theories of etiology, and greater emphasis on clinical utility.
DSM-IV
The DSM-IV was published in 1994. Revisions were guided by a three-stage empirical process. First, 150 comprehensive literature reviews on important diagnostic issues were conducted, leading to recommendations and documenting rationale. Second, 40 major re-analyses of existing data sets were completed where literature reviews could not resolve issues. Third, 12 field trials assessed clinical utility and predictive power of alternative criteria sets. Changes were based on empirical data to a much greater extent than in previous editions.
A complete DSM-IV diagnostic evaluation is a multi-axial assessment, evaluating clients along five axes:
- Axis I: Clinical disorders (except personality disorders and mental retardation)
- Axis II: Personality disorders and mental retardation
- Axis III: Current medical conditions relevant to conceptualization/treatment
- Axis IV: Psychosocial and environmental problems
- Axis V: Quantitative estimate (1-100) of overall level of functioning (GAF - Global Assessment of Functioning)
THE CASE OF MICHELLE M
Michelle M. was a 23-year-old woman admitted after her sixth suicide attempt in two years. She had a five-year history of multiple depressive symptoms. She also had great difficulty controlling her emotions, impulsive behaviors (polysubstance abuse, binge eating), unpredictable intense anger, unstable relationships, intense fear of abandonment, and repeated failed attempts to leave home.
Her DSM-IV diagnostic evaluation:
- Axis I: Dysthymic Disorder early onset, Alcohol Abuse, Cannabis Abuse, Cocaine Abuse, Hallucinogen Abuse
- Axis II: Borderline Personality Disorder (PRINCIPAL DIAGNOSIS)
- Axis III: none
- Axis IV: Problems with primary support group, Educational problems
- Axis V: GAF = 20 (Current)
Noteworthy features: Michelle received multiple Axis I diagnoses to describe problems comprehensively; her BPD on Axis II was the principal diagnosis (chiefly responsible for admission); her GAF score of 20 indicates serious impairment (danger of hurting herself).
GENERAL ISSUES IN CLASSIFICATION
CATEGORIES VERSUS DIMENSIONS
Mental disorder categories represent a typology, but this approach has limitations. First, there is a tendency to confuse categorization with explanation (circular reasoning like "This patient has obsessions because she has OCD"). Second, abnormal behavior exists on a continuous dimensionโdifferences are of degree rather than kind. The categorical "all-or-nothing" model may misrepresent how symptoms are distributed. For example, a categorical model of BPD may be inappropriate because individuals differ only in how many BPD symptoms they exhibit (a quantitative difference).
BASES OF CATEGORIZATION
Patients are classified using a wide assortment of methods. Some are classified solely on current behavior/presenting symptoms, others on history. Some diagnoses require a diagnostic interview, others are based on laboratory results (e.g., dexamethasone suppression test for depression) or self-report measures. The diagnostic enterprise is complicated, requiring knowledge of and access to a wide variety of diagnostic techniques. A major implication is that membership in any diagnostic category is likely heterogeneous due to multiple bases for diagnosis.
PRAGMATICS OF CLASSIFICATION
Psychiatric classification appeals to medical authority but also has a democratic aspect. For example, homosexuality was regarded as a disease for many years but was dropped from the DSM system by a vote of psychiatric membership (now considered an alternate lifestyle). This example shows that classification systems are crafted by committees representing varying constituencies, making the final product potentially a political document reflecting compromises.
DESCRIPTION
The DSM-IV provides thorough descriptions of diagnostic categories, including additional information for each diagnosis: age of onset, course, prevalence, complications, family patterns, cultural considerations, associated descriptive features, and associated laboratory findings. This descriptive detail should enhance the system's reliability and validity.
RELIABILITY
Reliability refers to the consistency of diagnostic judgments across raters. The inclusion of specific, objective criteria in DSM-III was an attempt to increase reliability. An early study by Beck et al. (1962) showed that two different psychiatrists interviewing the same 153 patients achieved only 54% overall agreement. Some disagreement stemmed from inconsistent patient information, but much lay with diagnosticians or the diagnostic system itself.
Certain pragmatic factors reduce reliability, such as institutions refusing to admit patients with certain diagnoses (leading to "fudging" diagnoses) or insurance companies reimbursing differently based on diagnosis. However, Meehl (1977) argues that psychiatric diagnosis is not as unreliable as believedโif confined to major categories with adequate clinical exposure and well-trained clinicians, acceptable agreement levels can be reached.
The field has developed structured diagnostic interviews that "force" diagnosticians to assess specific DSM criteria. Diagnostic reliability has increased greatly following their introduction. However, reliability is not equally good across all categories (e.g., generalized anxiety disorder is difficult to judge), and reliability coefficients are never as high in routine work settings as in research studies.
๐ Definition โ Reliability: In diagnosis, the consistency of diagnostic judgments across different raters or clinicians.
VALIDITY
Reliability directly affects validity. Without reliability, it is impossible to demonstrate meaningful correlates (prognosis, treatment outcome, etiology). The predominant method for establishing diagnostic validity was outlined by Robins and Guze (1970) , proposing a five-stage process:
- Clinical description (including demographic features beyond symptoms)
- Laboratory studies (including psychological tests)
- Delimitation from other disorders (ensuring homogeneity)
- Follow-up studies (assessing test-retest reliability)
- Family studies (demonstrating hereditary component)
This method remains influential, and most contemporary psychopathology research represents one or more of these validation stages.
๐ Definition โ Validity: The extent to which a diagnostic classification system has meaningful correlates, including prognosis, treatment outcome, and etiology.
BIAS
Ideally, a classification system will not be biased regarding gender, race, or SES. The two areas receiving most attention are sex bias and racial bias. Widiger and Spitzer (1991) argued that differential sex prevalence does not itself demonstrate bias (biological or cultural factors may explain it). For example, antisocial personality disorder is diagnosed more in men, possibly due to biological differences. However, they presented evidence suggesting clinicians may be biased in applying diagnoses to men versus women even with identical symptoms, indicating the need for better diagnostician training rather than overhaul of diagnostic criteria.
COVERAGE
With close to 400 possible diagnoses, DSM-IV cannot be faulted for being too limited. However, some feel its scope is too broadโfor example, childhood developmental disorders (dyslexia, stuttering, arithmetic difficulties) are included as mental disorders, and many question the appropriateness of labeling these conditions as such.
ADDITIONAL CONCERNS
Several subtle problems arise from diagnostic classification systems. Classifications create the impression that mental disorders exist per se, with language (disorder, symptom, condition) suggesting the patient is a victim of a disease process. There is a risk that classifying people becomes more satisfying than relieving their problemsโpigeonholing provides immediate reward but no long-term positive social significance.
The system caters to the public's desire to regard problems in living as medical problems easily solved by a pill or injection, when in reality solving psychological problems is hard work. Finally, diagnosis can be harmful or stigmatizingโclosing doors rather than opening them, obscuring the real person behind labels, damaging relationships, preventing employment, and even encouraging people to assume the role of a "sick" person.
โญ Key Takeaways
Diagnosis is a form of expert categorization with four key advantages: communication, enabling research, investigating etiology, and guiding treatment. The DSM-IV uses a multi-axial system (five axes) and was developed through a rigorous three-stage empirical process. The most critical issues in classification include the debate between categorical versus dimensional models, the need for both reliability and validity (established through Robins and Guze's five-stage method), and awareness of potential biases (sex bias, racial bias). Finally, students must remember that while diagnosis is essential for clinical practice, it carries risks of stigmatization and can obscure the real person behind the label.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four major advantages of using mental disorder diagnoses?
- Describe the five axes of the DSM-IV multi-axial assessment system.
- What is the difference between reliability and validity in diagnostic classification, and how did Robins and Guze propose establishing diagnostic validity?
- What are the potential limitations of using a categorical model for mental disorders instead of a dimensional one?
- What evidence suggests that clinicians may be biased in applying diagnoses, and what does this imply for clinical training?
๐ Lecture 15 โ The Concept of Psychological Assessment in Clinical Psychology
๐ Overview: This lecture defines psychological assessment as a systematic process of gathering information to make decisions in a person's best interests. It outlines the critical steps in the assessment process, from formulating initial questions to communicating findings, and emphasizes the role of theory and research in making assessment systematic and objective.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and steps of psychological assessment, including deciding what to assess (referral questions and person-environment levels), determining goals (diagnosis, severity, screening, prediction, intervention evaluation), selecting standards (normative vs. self-referent), collecting data (methods, reliability, validity), making decisions (clinical vs. statistical prediction), communicating information (psychological report), and addressing ethical issues.
๐ Lecture Summary
DEFINITION OF PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
Psychological assessment can be defined as "the process of systematically gathering information about a person in relation to his or her environment so that decisions can be made, based on this information that is in the best interests of the individual." For a clinical psychologist, important questions include: what are the patient's current problems and resources, what past information might contribute to the problem, who in the patient's life can help, and what is the likely future behavior.
STEPS IN THE ASSESSMENT PROCESS
First, a psychologist formulates an initial question or set of questions, typically in response to a referral. Second, the psychologist generates goals for collecting information. The third step involves identifying standards for interpreting the collected information. Fourth, the psychologist must collect relevant data about the person and environment. The fifth step involves making decisions and judgments based on the data. Finally, the psychologist communicates these judgments to others, usually in the form of a psychological report. Psychological theory and research are the primary factors that shape the assessment process.
STEP 1: DECIDING WHAT IS BEING ASSESSED
The assessment process begins with a series of questions, including about the nature of the problem, its possible causes, and likely treatment. These come partly from the client as referral questions. The assessment process begins with a referral from a patient, teacher, psychiatrist, or judge. It is crucial to understand exactly what the referral source is seeking. Often, a client's presenting concerns are tied to a recent event, which may represent the final step in a long-standing problem. Clients may purposefully or unknowingly withhold information. A psychologist must use theory and research to formulate a complete set of initial questions.
Most current theories recognize multiple levels of functioning relevant to understanding behavior. Emotions have underlying biological processes, exist in conscious awareness, and are linked to observable events. The primary targets for assessment are:
- Biological and Psychophysiological processes: heart rate reactivity, blood pressure, galvanic skin response, muscle tension, sexual arousal, startle response, and eye tracking movement.
- Cognitive processes: intellectual functioning, perceptions of the self and others, beliefs about the causes of events, and perception of control.
- Emotional processes: mood states, trait levels of emotions, and emotional reactivity.
- Overt behavior: performance on standardized tasks, observations in simulated situations, and behavior in the client's natural environment.
The environment is also multifaceted, with levels including:
- Proximal (immediate) features: family environment, school or work setting.
- Intermediate levels: geographic region.
- Distal (broader) environment: the general geographic and socio-cultural environment.
A psychologist's theoretical orientation plays a critical role in guiding what information to obtain and what to disregard.
STEP 2: DETERMINING THE GOALS OF ASSESSMENT
The second step is formulating the psychologist's goal, which may include diagnostic classification, determination of severity, risk screening, evaluation of treatment effects, and prediction of future behavior.
Diagnosis Diagnosis is a subset of the broader assessment process. It implies that certain procedures are administered to classify the person's problem and, if possible, to identify causes and prescribe treatment. Psychologists typically make diagnoses based on DSM-IV criteria. Diagnosis provides information about specific symptoms a person shares with others. There is a close link between assessment procedures and the diagnostic system; assessment identifies distinguishing features, while the diagnostic system groups cases by those features.
Severity It is not sufficient to know a person meets criteria for a disorder, as there can be heterogeneity (substantial differences among individuals with similar problems). Discriminating severity requires methods sensitive to variation in the frequency, intensity, and duration of specific symptoms. An important factor is the degree of impairment in the person's daily life. The psychologist must consider the individualโs overall life functioning and competence.
Screening Clinical psychologists are often called to screen large groups to identify problems or predict who is at risk. For example, depression screening encourages individuals to complete a brief questionnaire. Those scoring above a cutoff are contacted for a diagnostic interview. Children of parents with Major Depression are more likely to develop problems, so psychologists may screen for early evidence of problems. Depression in adolescence is often unrecognized and associated with somatic problems like recurrent headaches. Screening tools can also be used in medical emergency rooms.
Predictions Psychologists are often called to make predictions about future behavior, ranging from short-term to long-term. A major challenge is predicting violent behavior, especially youth violence. Psychologists have been largely unsuccessful due to a lack of understanding of the complex factors leading to violence. Psychologists are more effective at predicting problems with a high base rate of occurrence. For low base rate behaviors, psychologists must consider the consequences of false positive (wrongly predicting an outcome) and false negative (missing an outcome) predictions.
Evaluation of Intervention Effective assessment continues after treatment begins. Assessment methods should be re-administered at regular intervals to monitor and evaluate the effects of treatment. This involves obtaining baseline (pretreatment) information and then conducting follow-up assessment with the same instrument to evaluate change (the ABA method). This requires that the same instruments be used, that they are reliable (consistent), and that cut-off points are developed to distinguish clinically meaningful change from trivial shifts.
๐ก Why this matters: Assessment is not a one-time event but an ongoing process for monitoring treatment progress and making evidence-based adjustments.
STEP 3: SELECTING STANDARDS FOR MAKING DECISIONS
A psychologist must know what to do with the information once collected. Standards are points of reference for comparison, used to determine if a problem exists, its severity, and whether improvement has occurred. Comparisons can be made to normative standards (involving other people) or self-referent standards (comparing the person to themselves at other times).
Psychological assessment reflects the meeting point of the nomothetic tradition (interest in the nature of people in general) and the idiographic tradition (concern about a specific person). When working with an individual, a psychologist uses the idiographic tradition to discover what is unique. To make judgments, however, the psychologist draws on the nomothetic tradition of general laws. No single individual is perfectly represented by data on large samples, so predictions based on normative data may not hold for a particular individual.
In making normative comparisons, the psychologist must determine how similar the individual is to the normative sample on demographic characteristics like age, sex, ethnicity, and economic status. ๐ Definition โ Variability of a Normative Sample: The distribution of scores in a sample, commonly represented by the mean (measure of central tendency) and standard deviation (measure of variability). The mean is the sum of all scores divided by the number of individuals. These are often converted to standard scores for easy comparison across different measures.
Self-Referent Standards Some judgments involve comparing the person to themselves over time. Self-referent standards are useful for determining a clientโs initial goals and satisfaction with treatment gains. For example, a client who could not sleep for even minutes may be satisfied with four to five hours of uninterrupted sleep. However, self-referent standards do not replace normative standards, as it may still be important for health reasons to strive for expected sleep duration (e.g., seven to eight hours).
STEP 4: COLLECTING ASSESSMENT DATA
A psychologist must decide which methods to use to assess the selected targets. These include structured or unstructured clinical interviews, reviews of history, measurements of physiological functioning, psychological tests, self-reports, reports from significant others, and direct observation of behavior.
- Interviews can be open-ended or highly structured.
- Physiological measures can monitor heart rate, blood pressure, skin temperature, or muscle tension.
- Psychological tests include measures of intelligence, neuropsychological functioning, objective personality tests, and projective methods.
- Self-report measures assess symptoms of specific problems like depression or stressful life events.
- Direct observation methods assess specific behaviors in natural or simulated conditions.
Typically, a psychologist will draw on several methods. The choice is influenced by the client's age (e.g., child assessment often involves informants), the referral question, and the psychologist's theoretical orientation.
Reliability and Validity The most fundamental concern is the accuracy of the data collected, reflected in reliability (consistency) and validity (whether it measures the intended construct).
Reliability Reliability refers to the consistency of observations or measurements.
- Test-retest reliability: The extent to which an individual makes similar responses to the same test stimuli on repeated occasions.
- Equivalent-forms reliability: Uses equivalent or parallel forms of a test to avoid practice effects.
- Split-half reliability: A test is divided into halves (e.g., odd vs. even items), and scores on the two halves are compared. This serves as an index of a test's internal consistency (whether items are highly correlated). The preferred method involves computing the average of all possible split-half correlations.
- Inter-rater reliability: The degree of agreement between two or more raters or judges regarding the level of a trait or the presence/absence of a feature or diagnosis.
Validity Validity reflects the degree to which an assessment technique measures what it is designed or intended to measure. It is determined by using maximally different methods to measure the same construct.
- Content validity: The degree to which test items cover the various aspects of the variable under study.
- Predictive validity: When test scores accurately predict some future behavior or event.
- Concurrent validity: Relating todayโs test scores to a concurrent criterion.
- Construct validity: Shown when test scores relate to other measures or behaviors in a logical, theoretically expected fashion.
STEP 5: MAKING DECISIONS
The information obtained is valuable only to the extent it can be used in making important decisions. The goals of assessmentโdiagnosis, screening, prediction, and evaluation of interventionโdetermine the type of decision. These decisions can have profound effects on people's lives.
Clinical versus Statistical Prediction When using assessment data, the question is whether to combine data using statistical methods (actuarial judgments based on probabilities from large samples) or more subjectively by the clinician based on experience. Over 100 studies show the superiority of statistical methods in making judgments, including diagnostic decisions, predictions of violence, and treatment response. Statistical methods are superior partly because they are perfectly reliableโthey combine information in exactly the same way every time. However, the role of the clinician is crucial for tasks like generating hypotheses and using theory.
๐ก Why this matters: While clinicians bring essential human judgment, statistical methods provide greater reliability and accuracy for combining assessment data, leading to better client outcomes.
STEP 6: COMMUNICATING THE INFORMATION
The final task is communicating information and interpretations, typically in the form of a written psychological report. This report is shared with the client, other professionals, a court, or family members. Challenges include being accurate, explaining the basis for judgments, and communicating without technical jargon. A good psychological report shares features with a good research article: it should include an introduction (referral questions), methods (assessment procedures), results (data summary), and a discussion (interpretation and recommendations).
ETHICAL ISSUES IN ASSESSMENT
Psychologists are guided by a code of conduct that includes rules for ethical conduct in assessment. Foremost are concerns for protecting clients from abuse, ensuring confidentiality, protecting privacy rights, using procedures with well-established reliability and validity, and using results in the client's best interests. Information obtained is shared in the strictest confidence. Clients have the right to understand all information obtained and to regulate access to it. The need to protect confidentiality centers on the disposition of test results and reports. Information is always considered confidential. Lack of reliability may produce untrustworthy information, and lack of validity indicates the results are not an accurate representation of the individual's psychological functioning.
โญ Key Takeaways
Psychological assessment is a systematic, theory-driven process that goes beyond diagnosis to include evaluating severity, screening populations, predicting future behavior, and monitoring treatment outcomes. A critical distinction is between the idiographic (individual case) and nomothetic (population norms) approaches, which must be balanced using appropriate normative or self-referent standards. The accuracy of any assessment is fundamentally dependent on the reliability (consistency) and validity (meaningfulness) of the methods used. Research strongly supports the use of statistical (actuarial) methods over purely clinical judgment for making decisions and predictions from assessment data. Finally, ethical practice requires protecting client confidentiality, ensuring measures are valid and reliable, and using all information in the best interests of the client.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six steps in the psychological assessment process?
- What is the difference between the idiographic tradition and the nomothetic tradition in assessment, and how are both used?
- What are the four primary aspects of a person that are possible targets for assessment?
- How does "statistical prediction" differ from "clinical prediction," and which has been shown to be superior?
- Why are reliability and validity considered essential for the ethical treatment of clients in psychological assessment?
๐ Lecture 16 โ The Clinical Interview
๐ Overview: This lecture defines and explores the clinical interview as the most basic and widely used assessment technique in clinical psychology. It covers the definition, advantages, various types of interviews, and critical factors affecting their reliability, validity, and overall effectiveness in clinical settings.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the clinical interview and introducing its importance as a fundamental clinical tool. It outlines the advantages of interviews and then details six specific types: intake/admission, case history, mental status examination, crisis, diagnostic, and structured interviews. The discussion moves to the crucial concepts of reliability and validity in interviews, including suggestions for improvement. Finally, it examines factors that influence interviews, such as the physical setting, note-taking, rapport, and specific interviewing techniques, concluding with potential threats like bias.
๐ Lecture Summary
DEFINITION OF INTERVIEW
A clinical interview is defined as a situation of primarily vocal communication, voluntarily integrated on a progressively unfolding expert-client basis. Its purpose is elucidating characteristic patterns of living that the patient experiences as particularly troublesome or valuable, from which they expect to derive benefit. According to Bingham and Moore, the clinical interview is "a conversation with a purpose," though the purpose and area of the interview can differ.
INTRODUCTION OF INTERVIEW
Almost all professions use interviewing as a chief technique for gathering data and making decisions. People often take interviews for granted, believing they involve no special skills, and may overestimate their understanding of the process. The assessment interview is at once the most basic and the most serviceable technique used by clinical psychologists. In the hands of a skilled clinician, its wide range of applications and adaptability make it a major instrument for clinical decision making, understanding, and predictions. However, it is not greater than the skill and sensitivity of the clinicians who use it.
IMPORTANT THINGS TO KNOW ABOUT CLINICAL INTERVIEWS
- It is not a cross-examination but a process where the interviewer must be aware of the client's voice intonation, rate of speech, and non-verbal messages like facial expression, posture, and gestures.
- It is sometimes used as a sole assessment method but is more often used along with other methods.
- It serves as the basic context for almost all other psychological assessments.
- It is the most widely used clinical assessment method.
ADVANTAGES OF THE CLINICAL INTERVIEW
- Inexpensive
- Taps both verbal and non-verbal behavior
- Portable
- Flexible
- Facilitates the building of a therapeutic relationship
TYPES OF INTERVIEW
There are many forms of interviews. Some are highly structured with specific questions, while others are unstructured and spontaneous. The common forms discussed are: the intake/admission interview, the case history interview, the mental status examination interview, the crisis interview, the diagnostic interview, and the structured interview.
THE INTAKE/ADMISSION INTERVIEW
According to Watson, this interview is concerned with clarifying the patient's presenting complaints, the steps they took to resolve difficulties, and their expectations of treatment. The purpose is to develop a better understanding of the patient's symptoms or concerns to recommend the most appropriate treatment or intervention plan. The basic question is "Why is the patient here?"
๐ Definition โ Intake/Admission Interview: An initial interview focused on clarifying the patient's complaints and history to recommend the most appropriate treatment or intervention plan.
A careful intake interview guards against mistakes and conserves the time of other professional staff. Real therapy, in the sense of the patient's attitude and motivation, begins at the time of admittance. A bungled intake interview can prolong treatment, while an effective one can shorten it.
๐ก Why this matters: The intake interview sets the stage for the entire therapeutic process. The relationship and information gathered here can significantly influence the speed and success of later treatment.
CASE HISTORY INTERVIEW
In many hospitals and clinics, the intake interview is followed immediately by the personal and social history interview. The purpose is to gather information helpful in diagnosing and treating the patient's disorder. Sources of information other than the patient, such as friends, relatives, and records, are used. The typical information includes material on the patient's early life, family relationships, educational and vocational history, habits, and recreations. Patients may lie due to an inability to remember, painful memories, or cultural reasons. The fact that an occasional patient will lie is not a reflection on the interviewer's skill but rather on the patient's condition.
๐ Definition โ Case History Interview: An interview that gathers personal and social history information from the patient and other sources to aid in diagnosing and treating the disorder.
MENTAL STATUS EXAMINATION INTERVIEW
This interview is conducted to screen the patient's level of psychological functioning and the presence or absence of abnormal mental phenomena such as delusions, delirium, or dementia. It includes a brief evaluation of the patient's appearance, manner, speech, mood, thought processes, insight, judgment, attention, concentration, memory, and orientation. Results provide preliminary information about a likely psychiatric diagnosis and direction for further assessment. Most are unstructured, but some are structured and result in scores compared to national norms.
๐ Definition โ Mental Status Examination (MSE) Interview: A screening interview that evaluates a patient's current psychological functioning to detect abnormal mental phenomena like delusions, dementia, or disorientation.
๐ Example: An MSE might ask questions to determine orientation to time ("What day is it?"), place ("Where are you now?"), and person ("Who is the president?"). It may also test short-term memory by asking the patient to remember three objects (e.g., "dog, pencil, vase").
THE CRISIS INTERVIEW
A crisis interview occurs when the patient is in the middle of a significant and often traumatic or life-threatening crisis. The nature of the emergency dictates a rapid, "get to the point" style and quick decision making in a calming context. The interviewer may need to be more directive (e.g., encouraging the person to phone the police), break confidentiality if the person is in serious and immediate danger, or enlist help from others.
๐ Definition โ Crisis Interview: A rapid, directive interview conducted when a patient is in the midst of a traumatic or life-threatening emergency.
THE DIAGNOSTIC INTERVIEW
The purpose of the diagnostic interview is to assist the clinician in understanding the patient. If the level of diagnostic understanding required is merely screening (e.g., separating the fit from the unfit in military settings), the interview task is one of screening. In other cases, the task is highly specific, requiring a detailed diagnostic label like "paranoid schizophrenia." In such cases, primary dependence is not placed on the interview alone, as psychological tests play an important role. The interviewer observes the interviewee's behavior and content of answers to form hypotheses.
๐ Definition โ Diagnostic Interview: An interview conducted to understand the patient, often to assign a specific diagnosis or to screen for psychological fitness.
STRUCTURED INTERVIEW
In an effort to increase the reliability and validity of clinical interviews, structured interviews have been developed. They include very specific questions asked in a detailed flow chart or decision tree format. The goal is to obtain necessary information to make an appropriate diagnosis, determine if a patient is appropriate for a specific treatment or research program, and secure critical data for patient care.
๐ Definition โ Structured Interview: A highly standardized interview using a specific set of questions in a decision tree format to increase reliability and validity.
RELIABILTY AND VALIDITY OF INTERVIEWS
RELIABILITY The reliability of an interview is typically evaluated in terms of inter-rater reliability (the level of agreement between at least two raters). Standardized (structured) interviews are more reliable because they reduce both information variance (variation in questions asked and observations made) and criterion variance (variation in scoring thresholds). Test-retest reliability refers to the consistency of scores or diagnoses across time.
๐ Definition โ Information Variance: The variation in the questions clinicians ask, the observations made, and the method of integrating the information obtained during an interview. ๐ Definition โ Criterion Variance: The variation in scoring thresholds or decision-making standards among different clinicians.
VALIDITY The validity of an interview concerns how well it measures what it is intended to measure.
- Content validity: The measure's comprehensiveness in assessing the variable of interest.
- Criterion-related validity: The ability of a measure to predict scores on other relevant measures, either concurrently or predictively.
- Discriminant validity: The interview's ability to not correlate with measures that are not theoretically related.
- Construct validity: An overarching term that refers to all aspects of validity.
For structured diagnostic interviews, content validity is usually assumed because they are based on DSM criteria, leaving the need to establish criterion-related, discriminant, and construct validity.
SUGGESTIONS TO IMPROVE RELIABILTY AND VALIDITY
- Whenever possible, use a structured interview.
- If one does not exist, consider developing one.
- Whether using a structured or unstructured interview, essential interviewing skills are needed.
- Be aware of the patientโs motives and expectancies.
- Be aware of your own expectations, biases, and cultural values.
FACTORS THAT INFLUENCE INTERVIEWS
Many factors influence the productivity of an interview, including the physical setting, the nature of the patient, and the interviewerโs skills. Training and supervised experience are crucial.
1. THE PHYSICAL SETTING The best conditions are characterized by privacy, freedom from interruption, and control of sounds. The room should suggest comfort and have a professional flavor.
2. NOTE-TAKING AND RECORDING While all contacts need to be documented, there is debate over note-taking during the interview. Taking occasional notes is generally desirable, but any attempt at taking verbatim notes should be avoided as it can prevent the clinician from attending fully to the patient and observing non-verbal cues. Audio or videotaping should never be done without the patient's fully informed consent.
3. RAPPORT Rapport characterizes the relationship between patient and clinician, involving a comfortable atmosphere and mutual understanding of the interview's purpose. Good rapport is the primary instrument for achieving the interview's purpose.
4. SETTING THE RIGHT TONE The atmosphere most conducive to successful information elicitation is one of mutual respect.
5. GETTING THE INTERVIEW OFF TO A GOOD START The clinician must make sure the client understands the purpose of the interview.
COMPONENTS OF GOOD LISTENING -Elimination of distraction -Alertness -Concentration -Patience -Open-mindedness
6. ADJUSTMENT Adjust the sequence of topics to the anxiety level of the informant.
7. MOVING RAPIDLY THROUGH THE INTERVIEW A rapid-fire technique may result in greater reliability for personal and case history interviews.
8. ASKING QUESTIONS STRAIGHTFORWARDLY Having laid a foundation of rapport, it is best to ask questions in a direct manner.
9. CONSIDERABLE TACT AND SKILL MUST BE USED IN HANDLING PAUSES The clinician should not be too eager to answer for the client but should give them time to think. Pauses should not be allowed to become so long as to become painful or awkward.
10. ATTEMPT TO GET BENEATH SUPERFICIAL ANSWERS Rephrase or ask additional questions when answers are obviously superficial.
11. NOTE DISCREPANCIES IN THE ACCOUNT AND CHECK THEM Inconsistencies should be checked as unobtrusively as possible without challenging the client's veracity.
12. HANDLING EMOTIONAL SCENES TACTFULLY A moderate amount of crying or anger is expected, but the clinician must maintain control and not allow the client to become too depressed.
13. PREPAREDNESS Be prepared for questions directed to you by the informant.
POTENTIAL THREATS OF EFFECTIVE INTERVIEWING
BIASNESS Interviewers may be biased by their personality, theoretical orientation, interests, values, previous experiences, and cultural background. These factors can influence how they conduct an interview, what they attend to, and what they conclude.
๐ Example: A psychologist who is an expert on child sexual abuse might automatically assume that a patient's depression and anxiety are due to repressed memories of abuse, even when the patient denies any history of it. This illustrates how bias can lead to distorted or destructive approaches.
RELIABILITY AND VALIDITY Reliability and validity may be threatened if different interviewers end up with different diagnoses or if patients report different information in separate interviews. Factors like interviewer gender, race, age, and skill level can affect patient response. Reliability and validity can be enhanced by using structured interviews, asking similar questions in different ways, using multiple interviewers, and supplementing interview information from other sources.
โญ Key Takeaways
The clinical interview is the most basic, flexible, and widely used assessment method in clinical psychology, but its effectiveness depends entirely on the clinician's skill. There are several distinct types of interviewsโintake, case history, mental status exam, crisis, diagnostic, and structuredโeach with a specific purpose. Reliability and validity are crucial concerns; structured interviews improve both by reducing information and criterion variance. The success of an interview relies heavily on establishing rapport, maintaining a respectful and private setting, and using specific techniques like direct questioning and handling pauses tactfully. Finally, the clinician must be acutely aware of their own potential biases and the various factors that can threaten the reliability and validity of the information gathered.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to Bingham and Moore, what is the clinical interview best described as?
- List the five advantages of using the clinical interview for assessment.
- What is the primary purpose of a Mental Status Examination (MSE) interview?
- What are "information variance" and "criterion variance," and how do structured interviews affect them?
- Name three potential threats to effective interviewing discussed in the lecture.