๐ Lecture 11 โ The Research Process
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the systematic process of conducting research in clinical psychology, from generating hypotheses to disseminating findings. It emphasizes that research is a story beginning with a question, and that ethical considerations are imperative throughout. Understanding this process is foundational for evaluating and contributing to the scientific knowledge base that underpins clinical practice.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the six broad steps of the research process: generating hypotheses, selecting measures, selecting a research design, selecting a sample, testing hypotheses, and interpreting and disseminating results. It details research methods including survey methods and observational methods, cross-sectional versus longitudinal approaches, and concludes with a comprehensive section on research ethics including informed consent, confidentiality, deception, debriefing, and fraudulent data.
๐ Lecture Summary
GENERATING HYPOTHESES
Any piece of research begins with a question that needs to be answered. In order to serve as the focus of scientific research, a question needs to be refined into a hypothesis, which reflects the researcher's best educated idea about the expected answer. A hypothesis can be tested to determine if the null hypothesis (i.e., that there is no difference or no relationship between the variables) can be rejected with some degree of certainty. Some descriptive research may not be framed in terms of hypotheses but instead attempts to provide information defining the extent or parameters of a behavior or disorder. Research hypotheses can emerge from at least three sources: careful observations of a clinical case or cases, a theory concerned with human behavior or psychopathology, and the results of previous research. Computerized literature search programs such as PsychLit, PsychInfo, and MedLine are helpful in expediting the process of reviewing current research.
๐ Definition โ Hypothesis: A researcher's best educated idea about the expected answer to a question that can be tested.
๐ Definition โ Null hypothesis: The assumption that there is no difference or no relationship between the variables being studied.
๐ Example: A clinical psychologist observing that aggressive children often come from high-conflict families may hypothesize that marital conflict contributes to childhood aggression. Equally plausible is the hypothesis that aggressive child behavior contributes to parental tension.
MEASURING KEY VARIABLES
Once a set of hypotheses has been developed, the next challenge is to determine how to measure the key variables. This involves assessment of characteristics of people's thoughts, emotions, behavior, and physiology. The researcher must decide what aspects are most central, select specific methods, and determine whether to use existing or new measures. Specific methods include direct observations, self-reports, measures of physiological reactivity (e.g., heart rate variability, skin conductance), and performance on structured experimental tasks. Each method has inherent strengths and weaknesses. Self-reports are necessary for private experience but are subject to biases in self-presentation and inaccurate reporting. Observational methods are objective but cannot measure private thoughts. A solution is to use different types of measures to determine if findings converge. Researchers should use measures with established levels of reliability and validity.
๐ Definition โ Reliability: The degree to which a measure produces consistent results. ๐ Definition โ Validity: The degree to which a measure accurately assesses the construct it is intended to measure.
๐ Example: In anxiety research, anxiety can be measured at different levels including self-report ("I feel tense"), observations of overt manifestations (shaking hands), and physiological arousal (elevated heart rate). These three approaches often yield different results, presenting a challenge in interpretation.
SELECTING A RESEARCH DESIGN
Armed with a clear set of hypotheses and appropriate measures, a clinical psychologist is prepared to design a study. There are four basic types of designs: descriptive designs, correlational designs, experimental designs, and single-case designs. The two main methods of data collection are the survey method and observational method. All designs can be cross-sectional (one point in time) or longitudinal (over time). The choice depends on the nature of the question and ethical/practical limitations.
RESEARCH METHODS
SURVEY RESEARCH METHODS
Survey methods are used to obtain people's responses and opinions regarding an issue or problem. Types include computerized online surveys, telephonic surveys, voting polls, personal interviews, and questionnaires. The aim is to measure certain attitudes and/or behaviors of a population or sample. Survey research is primarily quantitative but may use qualitative methods. Since populations are often too large, researchers must sample a part of the population. Gaining a representative sample is crucial.
SOME COMMON SAMPLING STRATEGIES
Simple random sampling involves drawing members of the population at random with each having an equal chance of being selected. Stratified random sampling identifies sub-groups (strata) and selects respondents at random from within relevant strata. Proportionate sampling imposes the constraint that the sample must reflect the same proportions of sub-groups as found in the population. Non-probability sampling does not give a representative sample and includes convenience sampling, self-selected sampling, and snowball sampling.
๐ Definition โ Simple random sampling: Each member of the population has an equal chance of being in the sample. ๐ Definition โ Stratified random sampling: Respondents are selected at random from within relevant sub-groups. ๐ Definition โ Non-probability sampling: A procedure in which the sampling strategy does not give a representative sample.
POSSIBLE SOURCES OF BIAS IN SURVEY RESEARCH
Demand characteristics occur when respondents tend to say what they think the researcher wants to hear. Acquiescence refers to the tendency to say "yes" more easily than "no." Reactivity occurs when thinking about questions tends to change respondents' opinions. Response bias refers to some people tending to answer more positively or in more extreme terms.
OBSERVATIONAL METHODS
The most basic research method is observation. Types include unsystematic observation, naturalistic observation, controlled observation, and case studies. Unsystematic observation is casual observation that helps develop hypotheses. Naturalistic observation is more systematic and rigorous, carried out in real-life settings, but lacks control by the observer. Controlled observation involves the investigator exerting some degree of control over events. The case study method involves the intensive study of a client in treatment, including material from interviews, test responses, and treatment accounts.
๐ Definition โ Controlled observation: Observation where the investigator exerts some degree of control over events, either in the field or in relatively natural settings. ๐ Definition โ Case study: The intensive study and description of one person, including biographical and autobiographical data.
๐ก Why this matters: Case studies are valuable for providing descriptions of rare phenomena, disconfirming universally known information, and generating testable hypotheses. However, they cannot lead to cause-effect conclusions because clinicians cannot control important variables.
CROSS-SECTIONAL VERSUS LONGITUDINAL APPROACHES
A cross-sectional design evaluates or compares individuals at the same point in time. A longitudinal design follows the same subjects over time. Cross-sectional approaches are correlational because the investigator cannot manipulate age or assign participants to different age groups. Differences could be due to the eras in which participants were raised rather than age itself. Longitudinal studies allow insight into how behavior changes with age and help eliminate the third variable problem, but are costly and require great patience.
๐ Definition โ Cross-sectional design: A design that evaluates or compares individuals at the same point in time. ๐ Definition โ Longitudinal design: A design that follows the same subjects over time.
SELECTING A SAMPLE
Selection and recruitment of a sample is important to the ultimate generalizability (external validity) of research findings. If the sample is not representative, results may be biased by sample characteristics such as sex, age, education level, income, and ethnic background. In research with clinical samples, it is important to determine the extent to which the sample represents the clinical population.
๐ Definition โ Generalizability (External validity): The extent to which research findings can be applied to the larger population.
TESTING HYPOTHESES
Psychologists rely on inferential statistics to evaluate the degree to which the null hypothesis has been rejected. If an obtained value could be expected to occur by chance alone less than 5 times out of 100, it is deemed statistically significant (p < .05). The larger the statistical value, the more likely it is to be significant. With large numbers of participants, even small statistical values can be significant. Therefore, it is important to distinguish between statistical significance and practical significance. A correlation of .19 may be significant, but the magnitude of the relationship is modest.
๐ Definition โ Statistical significance: The probability that an obtained result is not due to chance, traditionally set at p < .05. ๐ Definition โ Practical significance: The real-world importance or meaningfulness of a statistical finding, regardless of its statistical significance.
๐ Example: In a study of 5000 graduate students, a correlation of .15 between GRE scores and faculty ratings of academic competence may be statistically significant but practically small, as most variance is due to other factors.
INTERPRETING AND DISSEMINATING FINDINGS
The final step is to place the meaning of a study in a broader context. A first step is to submit findings to peer-reviewed professional journals. The review process ensures published work meets accepted criteria for scientific quality. Researchers have an obligation to translate findings into usable information for practicing psychologists, the public, and mental health policy makers.
RESEARCH ETHICS
Research participants have rights, and investigators have responsibilities. The American Psychological Association (APA, 1992) published ethical standards requiring investigators to plan research according to recognized standards, implement safeguards for participant welfare, retain responsibility for ethical practices, comply with laws, gain approval, establish clear agreements, obtain informed consent, take care with inducements, use deception only when necessary, protect participants from harm, inform participants of data use, minimize invasiveness, provide debriefing, and treat animal subjects humanely.
Informed consent requires that participants give formal informed consent (usually in writing) prior to participation, being informed of risks, discomforts, limitations on confidentiality, and compensation. Confidentiality requires that individual data be guarded from public scrutiny, with code numbers used to protect anonymity. Deception should be used only when research is important and there is no alternative, with careful debriefing afterward. Debriefing at the end of research is mandatory to explain why the research was carried out and its importance.
๐ Definition โ Informed consent: Formal agreement by participants to participate in research after being informed of risks, discomforts, and limitations on confidentiality. ๐ Definition โ Debriefing: Providing participants with information at the close of research to erase any misconceptions.
๐ Example: In a study predicting viewing gun magazines will increase hostility scores, participants are told the experiment focuses on short-term memory to avoid influencing their responses.
โญ Key Takeaways
The research process in clinical psychology follows six systematic steps: generating hypotheses, selecting measures, selecting a research design, selecting a sample, testing hypotheses, and interpreting/disseminating findings. Hypotheses emerge from clinical observation, theory, and previous research, and must be testable against the null hypothesis. Researchers must choose between survey and observational methods, and between cross-sectional and longitudinal designs, each with distinct strengths and limitations. Statistical significance (p < .05) must be distinguished from practical significance, as even small correlations can be statistically significant with large samples. Ethical standards require informed consent, confidentiality, minimal deception, thorough debriefing, and absolute honesty in reporting data.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six broad steps of the research process in clinical psychology?
- What are the three main sources from which research hypotheses can emerge?
- What is the difference between a cross-sectional design and a longitudinal design?
- What is the difference between statistical significance and practical significance?
- What are the key ethical requirements regarding informed consent, deception, and debriefing in psychological research?
๐ Lecture 12 โ The Concept of Abnormal Behavior & Mental Illness
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental challenge of defining abnormal behavior and mental illness in clinical psychology. It examines three major definitional approachesโconformity to norms, subjective distress, and disability/dysfunctionโdetailing their advantages and limitations through case examples, and concludes with the DSM-IV definition of mental disorder.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing why abnormal behavior is difficult to define, then systematically examines three proposed definitions: conformity to norms (statistical infrequency or violation of social norms), subjective distress, and disability or dysfunction. Each definition is illustrated with case examples, followed by advantages and problems. The lecture concludes with the DSM-IV definition of mental illness and its relationship to abnormal behavior.
๐ Lecture Summary
WHAT IS ABNORMAL BEHAVIOR?
Abnormal behavior is difficult to define because (1) no single descriptive feature is shared by all forms of abnormal behavior, and no one criterion is sufficient; and (2) no discrete boundary exists between normal and abnormal behavior. Many myths persist, such as equating abnormal behavior with bizarre, dangerous, or shameful behavior. Three proposed definitions are examined: conformity to norms, subjective distress, and disability or dysfunction. Each highlights an important aspect but is incomplete by itself.
A. CONFORMITY TO NORMS: STATISTICAL INFREQUENCY OR VIOLATION OF SOCIAL NORMS
When behavior conforms to social norms or is frequently observed in others, individuals are not likely to come to the attention of mental health professionals. However, when behavior becomes deviant, outrageous, or nonconforming, it is more likely to be categorized as "abnormal."
๐ Definition โ Statistical Infrequency: A definition of abnormality based on how rarely a behavior occurs in the population, often determined by cutoff points on standardized measures.
๐ Definition โ Violation of Social Norms: A definition of abnormality based on behavior that deviates from prevailing social standards or expectations.
๐ Conformity to Norms Approach: Abnormal = behavior that is statistically rare OR violates social norms โ used to identify individuals who stand out from the population.
๐ Example โ The Case of Billy A: Billy, a second-grade student, was referred to a school psychologist after scoring poorly on a routine achievement test. Testing revealed an IQ of 64 on the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale and an estimated IQ of 61 on the Draw-a-Person Test. A social maturity index derived from parental reports was quite low. The psychologist concluded Billy suffered from mental retardation. His behavior violated norms because his IQ and school performance departed considerably from the mean, making his deviance quantifiable.
๐ Example โ The Case of Martha L: Martha, a high school student, began exhibiting changes: severe plain hairstyle, ill-fitting clothing, no makeup or jewelry, hours reading the Bible, slipping notes criticizing other girls' "immorality," attending religious services constantly, fasting frequently, and decorating her walls with religious images. When she announced plans to join an obscure religious sect, her parents took her to a psychiatrist. She was hospitalized with diagnoses including schizophrenia, paranoid type and schizoid personality. Her behavior came to attention because her clothes, appearance, and interests did not conform to norms typical of females in her culture.
ADVANTAGES OF THIS DEFINITION
-
Cutoff Points: The statistical infrequency approach establishes quantitative cutoff points. If the cutoff on a scale is 80 and an individual scores 75, the decision to label the behavior as abnormal is relatively straightforward. This principle is used in interpreting psychological test scores, where test authors designate cutoff points based on statistical deviance from the mean of a "normal" sample.
-
Intuitive Appeal: People tend to believe that behaviors they consider abnormal would be evaluated similarly by others. As a Supreme Court justice said about pornography, we believe we "know it when we see it."
PROBLEMS WITH THIS DEFINITION
-
Choice of Cutoff Points: It is difficult to establish agreed-upon cutoff points. In Billy's case, is an IQ of 64 significantly different from 70? Traditional practice sets the cutoff for mental retardation at 70, but rationally justifying such arbitrary points is difficult. In Martha's case, are five crucifixes too many? Is three church services per week acceptable?
-
The Number of Deviations: It is unclear how many deviant behaviors one must evidence to earn the "deviant" label. In Martha's case, was it just the crucifixes, or the total behavioral configuration? Had she manifested only three categories of unusual behavior, would she still be classified as deviant?
-
Cultural Relativity: Martha's behavior was not deviant in an absolute sense. Had she been a member of an exceptionally religious family subscribing to radical beliefs, she might never have been classified as maladjusted. What is deviant for one group is not necessarily so for another. Judgments vary depending on whether family, school authorities, or peers make them, contributing to diagnostic unreliability. Carrying cultural relativity to the extreme can place nearly every reference group beyond reproach. Additionally, elevating conformity to a position of preeminence is alarmingโnonconformists have made beneficial social contributions, and it becomes easy to remove those whose unusual behavior bothers society (e.g., political dissidents placed in mental hospitals in Russia, or elderly relatives hospitalized to obtain power of attorney). Excessive conformity itself has sometimes been the basis for judging persons abnormal.
B. SUBJECTIVE DISTRESS
This definition shifts focus from the observer's perceptions to the affected individual's perceptions. The basic data are not observable deviations of behavior, but the subjective feelings and sense of well-being of the individual. If the person is anxiety-ridden, they are maladjusted regardless of whether overt behaviors are deviant.
๐ Definition โ Subjective Distress: A definition of abnormality based on the individual's internal experience of emotional pain, anxiety, or suffering, regardless of how their behavior appears to others.
๐ Example โ The Case of Cynthia S: Cynthia, married 23 years with two children, above average intelligence, characterized as a "coper" who functions effectively despite stress. She appears confident, assertive, competent, and outgoing. However, in an existential account written for a night course, she revealed: "In the morning, I often feel as if I cannot make it through the day... I am terribly frightened when I have to meet new people... At times I feel a tremendous sense of sadness." None of these feelings were apparent from her overt behavior.
๐ Example โ The Case of Robert G: Robert, being considered for a promotion, was interviewed and appeared very self-confident, content, with no expressed anxieties. However, his enemies were visibleโhe used people, was inconsiderate, cruel, insensitive, reveled in prejudices, and kept his family in turmoil with insensitive demands. He saw nothing wrong with himself and would react negatively to any suggestion of therapy.
These contrasting cases show that Cynthia's behavior is conforming and her coping admired, yet she is unhappy and conflicted. Her friends would be shocked to learn she sought help. In contrast, Robert's family would be gratified if he sought help, but he is not at odds with himself.
ADVANTAGES OF THIS DEFINITION
Defining abnormal behavior in terms of subjective distress seems reasonableโindividuals can assess whether they are experiencing problems and share this information. Many clinical assessment methods (self-report inventories, clinical interviews) assume the respondent is aware of their internal state and will respond honestly. This relieves the clinician of making an absolute judgment about the degree of maladjustment.
PROBLEMS WITH THIS DEFINITION
The judgment of whether Cynthia, Robert, or both are maladjusted depends on one's criteria. From a strict subjective report standpoint, Cynthia qualifies but Robert does not. Labeling someone maladjusted is not meaningful unless the basis for judgment and behavioral manifestations are stated. Not everyone considered "disordered" reports subjective distressโsome individuals with little contact with reality profess inner tranquility yet are institutionalized, reminding us that subjective reports must yield to other criteria. Additionally, determining the amount of subjective distress necessary to be considered abnormal is problematic. All people experience anxieties; the total absence of such feelings cannot be the sole criterion. How much anxiety is allowed, and for how long, before one acquires a label?
C. DISABILITY OR DYSFUNCTION
A third definition invokes the concept of disability or dysfunction. For behavior to be considered abnormal, it must create some degree of social (interpersonal) or occupational problems for the individual. Dysfunction in these spheres is often apparent to both the individual and the clinician.
๐ Definition โ Disability/Dysfunction: A definition of abnormality based on impairment in social relationships or occupational functioning caused by behavioral or emotional problems.
๐ Example โ The Case of Richard Z: Richard, convinced by his wife to consult a psychologist, has not worked in several years despite having a bachelor's degree in library science. He claims inability to find employment due to health problems, reporting dizziness, breathlessness, weakness, and abdominal sensations. He takes multiple pills prescribed by numerous physicians, none of whom have found physical problems. His mother doted on him as a child; his father disappeared when Richard was 18 months old. His wife supports him. He is completely dependent on his wife (social dysfunction) and unemployed (occupational dysfunction).
๐ Example โ The Case of Phyllis H: Phyllis is in her sixth year of undergraduate study without a degree, having changed majors four times and withdrawn from school on four occasions. Her withdrawals are associated with her drug habit. She has been placed in mental hospitals twice and served jail sentences for shoplifting. She engages in minor crimes to support her drug habit. Diagnoses include antisocial personality disorder and drug dependence (cocaine). Her drug habit has interfered with her occupational (school) functioning.
ADVANTAGES OF THIS DEFINITION
The greatest advantage is that relatively little inference is required. Problems in the social and occupational sphere often prompt individuals to seek treatment. Individuals often realize the extent of their emotional problems when these problems affect their family or social relationships and significantly affect their performance at work or school.
PROBLEMS WITH THIS DEFINITION
Who should establish standards for dysfunctionโthe patient, therapist, friends, or employer? Judgments regarding social and occupational functioning are relative, not absolute, and involve value-oriented standards. While most agree that having relationships and contributing to society are valuable, it is harder to agree on what specifically constitutes an adequate level of functioning. Psychopathologists have developed self-report inventories and special interviews to assess functioning systematically.
Where Does This Leave Us?
All definitions have strengths and weaknesses. They can incorporate certain examples but exceptions are easy to provide. Abnormal behavior does not necessarily indicate mental illness. Rather, mental illness refers to a large class of frequently observed syndromes comprised of certain abnormal behaviors or features that tend to co-vary or occur together. For example, major depression is a mental illness whose features (depressed mood, sleep disturbance, appetite disturbance, suicidal ideation) tend to co-occur. An individual manifesting only one or two features would not receive the diagnosis. One can manifest a wide variety of abnormal behaviors yet not receive a mental disorder diagnosis.
MENTAL ILLNESS
The fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) (American Psychiatric Association, 1994) defines a mental disorder as:
"a clinically significant behavioral or psychological syndrome or pattern that occurs in an individual and that is associated with present distress (e.g., a painful symptom) or disability (i.e., impairment in one or more important areas of functioning) or with a significantly increased risk of suffering, death, pain, disability, or an important loss of freedom."
In addition, this syndrome must not be merely an expectable and culturally sanctioned response to a particular event (e.g., death of a loved one). Whatever its original causes, it must currently be considered a manifestation of a behavioral, psychological, or biological dysfunction in the individual. Neither deviant behavior (e.g., religious, political, or sexual) nor conflicts primarily between the individual and society are mental disorders unless the deviance or conflict is a symptom of dysfunction.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that no single definition of abnormal behavior is sufficientโconformity to norms, subjective distress, and disability/dysfunction each capture important aspects but have limitations including arbitrary cutoff points, cultural relativity, and value judgments. Students must understand that abnormal behavior does not automatically equal mental illness; mental illness requires a syndrome of co-occurring features associated with distress, disability, or increased risk of problems. The DSM-IV definition integrates all three approaches but is more restrictive by focusing on syndromes representing dysfunction within the individual. The key insight is that defining abnormality ultimately depends on value judgments, and clinicians must specify their criteria and the behavioral manifestations supporting their conclusions.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main definitions of abnormal behavior discussed in this lecture, and what is the primary focus of each?
- How does the case of Martha L illustrate the problem of cultural relativity in defining abnormality?
- Why might an individual like Robert G not be considered abnormal under the subjective distress definition, yet seem "sick" to those around him?
- What are the three components of the DSM-IV definition of a mental disorder, and how does it differ from simply having abnormal behavior?
- According to Phares as quoted in the lecture, why is a definition of abnormality only possible with reference to value judgments?
๐ Lecture 13 โ Causes of Mental Illness: Overview of Etiology
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive overview of the causes (etiology) of mental disorders, emphasizing that precise causes are unknown but broad biological, psychological, and social forces interact to shape mental health and illness. It introduces the biopsychosocial model as a framework for understanding disease and explores how correlation, causation, and consequences must be distinguished in research. The lecture then details specific biological influences (genetics and infections) and psychosocial influences (psychodynamic theories, behaviorism, and social learning theory) on mental health.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the biopsychosocial model of disease proposed by George Engel, the distinction between correlation, causation, and consequences in etiological research, biological influences on mental health including genetics (heritability, twin studies, Mendelian vs. complex transmission) and infectious influences (neurosyphilis, HIV-associated dementia, PANDAS), and psychosocial influences including psychodynamic theories (Freud's structural model), behaviorism (classical and operant conditioning), and social learning theory (observational learning).
๐ Lecture Summary
BIOPSYCHOSOCIAL MODEL OF DISEASE
The modern view that many factors interact to produce disease is attributed to the seminal work of George L. Engel, who in 1977 put forward the Biopsychosocial Model of Disease. Engel's model is a framework for understanding health and disease, asserting that simply looking at biological factors alone is not sufficient to explain health and illness. According to this model, biopsychosocial factors (biological, psychological, and sociocultural) are involved in the causes, manifestation, course, and outcome of health and disease, including mental disorders.
One single factor in isolation may weigh heavily or hardly at all, depending on the behavioral trait or mental disorder. For example, a personality trait like extroversion is linked strongly to genetic factors, and schizophrenia is also linked strongly to genetic factors according to twin studies. However, this does not mean that genetic factors completely preordain the disorderโsocial factors modify expression and outcome. Some mental disorders, such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) , are clearly caused by exposure to an extremely stressful event (e.g., rape, combat, natural disaster), yet not everyone develops PTSD after such exposure; on average, about 9 percent do, but for women who are victims of crime, the prevalence can be 26 percent. The likelihood of developing PTSD is related to pre-trauma vulnerability (genetic, biological, and personality factors), magnitude of the stressful event, preparedness, and quality of care after the event.
UNDERSTANDING CORRELATION, CAUSATION, AND CONSEQUENCES
Any discussion of etiology must distinguish three key terms: correlation, causation, and consequences. A correlation is an association or linkage of two (or more) eventsโit simply means the events are linked in some way. Finding a correlation between stressful life events and depression prompts more research on causation: Does stress cause depression? Does depression cause stress? Or are both caused by an unidentified factor?
If a correlational study shows that a stressful event is associated with an increased probability for depression and that the stress usually precedes depression's onset, then stress is called a "risk factor" for depression. Risk factors are biological, psychological, or sociocultural variables that increase the probability for developing a disorder and antedate its onset. For each mental disorder, there are likely to be multiple risk factors woven together in a complex chain of causation.
Establishing causation is extremely difficult. Studies in the form of randomized, controlled experiments provide the strongest evidence of causation, but experimental research in humans may be logistically, ethically, or financially impossible. Correlational research in humans has provided much of what is known about the etiology of mental disorders. Multiple correlational studies can support causality, especially when combined with evidence of biological plausibilityโmeaning that correlational findings should fit with biological, chemical, and physical findings about mechanisms of action relating to cause and effect. Biological plausibility is often established in animal models of disease.
Consequences are defined as the later outcomes of a disorder. For example, the most serious consequence of depression in older people is increased mortality from either suicide or medical illness. The biopsychosocial model holds that biological, psychological, or social factors may be causes, correlates, and/or consequences in relation to mental health and mental illness. A stressful life event, such as receiving a diagnosis of cancer, offers a graphic example: the brain's sensory cortex registers the information (a correlate), sets in motion biological changes (heart pounds faster), and the patient may experience fear of death that escalates to anxiety or depression (consequences), which may prompt further social consequences like social withdrawal.
๐ก Why this matters: Distinguishing correlation from causation prevents premature conclusions about what "causes" a disorder based only on observed associations, which is critical for developing effective treatments and prevention strategies.
BIOLOGICAL INFLUENCES ON MENTAL HEALTH AND MENTAL ILLNESS
There are far-reaching biological and physical influences on mental health and mental illness. The major categories are genes, infections, physical trauma, nutrition, hormones, and toxins (e.g., lead).
THE GENETICS OF BEHAVIOR AND MENTAL ILLNESS
That genes influence behavior, normal and abnormal, has long been established. Research suggests that many mental disorders arise in part from defects not in single genes, but in multiple genes. None of the genes has yet been pinpointed for common mental disorders. The human genome contains approximately 80,000 genes that occupy approximately 5 percent of the DNA sequences of the human genome.
From studying how disorders run in families, we have learned that heredity (genes) plays a role in the transmission of vulnerability for disorders such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, early onset depression, autism, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, anorexia nervosa, and panic disorder. However, the transmission of risk is not simple. Certain human diseases such as Huntington's disease and cystic fibrosis result from the transmission of a mutation (a deleteriously altered gene sequence) at one location in the human genome. The transmission of a trait due to a single gene is called Mendelian transmission, after Gregor Mendel.
In contrast to Mendelian disorders, all mental illnesses and all normal variants of behavior are genetically complexโno single gene or combination of genes dictates whether someone will have an illness or a particular behavioral trait. Rather, mental illness appears to result from the interaction of multiple genes that confer risk, and this risk is converted into illness by the interaction of genes with environmental factors. The implications are that no gene is equivalent to fate for mental illness, and modifiable environmental risk factors can eventually be identified and become targets for prevention efforts.
Heritability refers to how much genetics contributes to the variation of a disease or trait in a population at a given point in time. One powerful method for estimating heritability is through twin studies, which compare the frequency with which identical versus fraternal twins display a disorder. Identical twins share the exact genetic inheritance; fraternal twins share only 50 percent. If a disorder is heritable, identical twins should have a higher rate of concordance (the expression of the trait by both members of a twin pair) than fraternal twins. For example, the heritability of bipolar disorder is about 59 percent, and the heritability of schizophrenia is estimated at a somewhat higher level. However, even with a high level of heritability, environmental factors can play a significant role in the severity and course of a disorder. The median concordance rate among identical twins for schizophrenia is 46 percent, meaning that in over half of the cases, the second twin does not manifest schizophrenia even though he or she has the same genesโimplying that environmental factors exert a significant role in the onset of schizophrenia.
๐ Formula: Heritability = genetic contribution to variation of a disease/trait in a population โ A statistical estimate. ๐ Example: For bipolar disorder, heritability is about 59% from twin studies. For schizophrenia, the median concordance rate among identical twins is 46%โmeaning that environmental factors are significant since over half of identical co-twins do not develop the disorder.
INFECTIOUS INFLUENCES
Since the early 20th century, it has been known that infectious agents can penetrate into the brain and cause mental disorders. A highly common mental disorder of unknown etiology at the turn of the century, termed "general paresis," turned out to be a late manifestation of syphilis. The sexually transmitted infectious agentโTreponema pallidumโfirst caused symptoms in reproductive organs and then, sometimes years later, migrated to the brain where it led to neurosyphilis, manifest by neurological deterioration (including psychosis), paralysis, and later death. With the wide availability of penicillin after World War II, neurosyphilis was virtually eliminated.
HIV-associated dementia continues to encumber HIV-infected individuals worldwide. HIV infection penetrates into the brain, producing a range of progressive cognitive and behavioral impairments. Early symptoms include impaired memory and concentration, psychomotor slowing, and apathy. Later symptoms include global impairments marked by mutism, incontinence, and paraplegia. The prevalence of HIV-associated dementia ranges from 15 percent to 44 percent of patients with HIV infection. Notably, it appears to be caused not by direct infection of neurons, but by infection of immune cells known as macrophages that enter the brain from the blood. The macrophages indirectly cause dysfunction and death in nearby neurons by releasing soluble toxins.
Other mental disorders caused by infectious agents include herpes simplex encephalitis, measles encephalomyelitis, rabies encephalitis, and chronic meningitis.
PANDAS
In the late 1980s, it was discovered that some children with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) experienced a sudden onset of symptoms soon after a streptococcal pharyngitis. This led to the identification of a new classification of OCD called PANDASโan acronym for pediatric autoimmune neuropsychiatric disorders associated with streptococcal infection. PANDAS are distinct from classic cases of OCD because of their episodic clinical course marked by sudden symptom exacerbation linked to streptococcal infection.
The exacerbation of symptoms is correlated with a rise in levels of antibodies that the child produces to fight the strep infection. Researchers proposed that PANDAS are caused by antibodies against the strep infection that also manage to attack the basal ganglia region of the child's brain. In other words, the strep infection triggers the child's immune system to develop antibodies, which, in turn, may attack the child's brain, leading to obsessive and compulsive behaviors. The strep infection does not directly induce the condition; rather, it may do so indirectly by triggering antibody formation.
PSYCHOSOCIAL INFLUENCES ON MENTAL HEALTH AND MENTAL ILLNESS
Stressful life events, affect (mood and level of arousal), personality, and gender are prominent psychological influences. Social influences include parents, socioeconomic status, racial, cultural, and religious background, and interpersonal relationships.
PSYCHODYNAMIC THEORIES
Psychodynamic theories of personality assert that behavior is the product of underlying conflicts over which people often have scant awareness. Sigmund Freud (1856โ1939) was the towering proponent of psychoanalytic theory. Freud's theory holds two major assumptions: (1) that much of mental life is unconscious (i.e., outside awareness), and (2) that past experiences, especially in early childhood, shape how a person feels and behaves throughout life.
Freud's structural model of personality divides the personality into three partsโthe id, the ego, and the superego. The id is the unconscious part that is the cauldron of raw drives, such as for sex or aggression. The ego, which has conscious and unconscious elements, is the rational and reasonable part of personality; its role is to maintain contact with the outside world and mediate between the conflicting tendencies of the id and the superego. The superego is a person's conscience that develops early in life and is learned from parents, teachers, and others.
When all three parts of the personality are in dynamic equilibrium, the individual is thought to be mentally healthy. However, if the ego is unable to mediate between the id and the superego, an imbalance would occur in the form of psychological distress and symptoms of mental disorders. Psychoanalytic theory views symptoms as important only in terms of expression of underlying conflicts between the parts of personality.
BEHAVIORISM AND SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY
Behaviorism (also called learning theory) posits that personality is the sum of an individual's observable responses to the outside world. As charted by J. B. Watson and B. F. Skinner in the early 20th century, behaviorism stands in opposition to psychodynamic theories. It rejects the existence of underlying conflicts and an unconscious, focusing instead on observable, overt behaviors that are learned from the environment. Its application to treatment of mental problems is known as behavior modification.
Learning is accomplished largely through either classical conditioning or operant conditioning. Classical conditioning, grounded in the research of Ivan Pavlov, explains why some people react to formerly neutral stimuli in their environment. Pavlov's dogs, for example, learned to salivate merely at the sound of the bell by repeatedly pairing the sight of food with the sound of the bell. Operant conditioning, described by B. F. Skinner, is a form of learning in which a voluntary response is strengthened or attenuated depending on its association with positive or negative consequences. The strengthening of responses occurs by positive reinforcement (e.g., food, pleasurable activities, attention from others). The attenuation or discontinuation of responses occurs by negative reinforcement in the form of removal of a pleasurable stimulus. Under behaviorism, mental disorders are maladaptive behaviors that were learned and could be unlearned through behavior modification.
SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY
The movement beyond behaviorism was spearheaded by Albert Bandura (1969, 1977), the originator of social learning theory (also known as social cognitive theory). While acknowledging classical and operant conditioning, social learning theory places far greater emphasis on observational learningโlearning that occurs through selectively observing the behavior of another person, a model. When the behavior of the model is rewarded, children are more likely to imitate the behavior.
Social learning theory asserts that people's cognitionsโtheir views, perceptions, and expectations toward their environmentโaffect what they learn. Rather than being passively conditioned by the environment, humans take a more active role in deciding what to learn as a result of cognitive processing. Social learning theory gave rise to cognitive-behavioral therapy.
โญ Key Takeaways
The biopsychosocial model emphasizes that biological, psychological, and social factors interact in the causes, manifestation, course, and outcome of all mental disordersโno single factor operates in isolation. It is crucial to distinguish correlation from causation and consequences in etiological research, as simple associations do not prove cause-and-effect relationships. Genetically, most mental disorders are complex, involving multiple genes interacting with environmental factors, not single-gene Mendelian transmission; heritability estimates from twin studies show the degree of genetic contribution but also highlight the significant role of environment. Infectious agents can directly or indirectly cause mental disorders, as illustrated by neurosyphilis, HIV-associated dementia, and PANDAS (pediatric autoimmune neuropsychiatric disorders associated with streptococcal infection). Finally, psychosocial theoriesโpsychodynamic (Freud's id/ego/superego), behaviorism (classical/operant conditioning), and social learning theory (observational learning and cognitive processing)โprovide complementary frameworks for understanding how psychological and social factors contribute to mental health and illness.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three broad categories of factors in the biopsychosocial model of disease, and what does each contribute to the understanding of mental disorders?
- What is the difference between correlation, causation, and risk factors in the study of etiology, and why is evidence of biological plausibility important?
- How do Mendelian transmission and genetically complex transmission differ, and what does the 46% concordance rate for schizophrenia in identical twins tell us about the role of environment?
- What is PANDAS, and what is the proposed mechanism by which a streptococcal infection leads to obsessive-compulsive symptoms in children?
- According to Freud's structural model, what are the id, ego, and superego, and what happens when the ego cannot mediate between the id and superego?