π Lecture 17 β The Assessment of Intelligence
π Overview: This lecture explores the central role of intelligence assessment in clinical psychology, from its historical origins to contemporary debates. It examines the complex challenge of defining and measuring intelligence, reviews key psychometric concepts of reliability and validity, and surveys major theoretical approaches. The lecture also traces the history of intelligence testing and addresses critical issues of test fairness and cultural bias.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing the importance of intelligence assessment in clinical psychology's history and practice. It then introduces foundational psychometric concepts of reliability and validity essential for understanding test construction. The concept of intelligence is examined through multiple definitions and theoretical frameworks, including factor-analytic approaches by Spearman, Thurstone, Cattell, and Guilford, as well as more recent cognitive and multiple-intelligence theories by Gardner and Sternberg. The historical development of intelligence testing is traced from Binet and Simon through Wechsler's scales, concluding with contemporary controversies about test bias and minority assessment.
π Lecture Summary
The Concept of Intelligence
The concept of intelligence presents clinical psychology with one of its greatest dilemmas. Psychologists have been pressured for almost 100 years to quantify individual differences in intellectual functioning, yet intelligence has remained one of the most difficult and controversial psychological constructs to define and measure. The impetus to define and quantify intelligence comes from both practical forces (predicting academic and work potential) and scientific forces (comprehending an important aspect of human behavior). Two unresolved issues persist: exactly what is meant by the term intelligence, and how to develop valid instruments for measuring it.
Reliability and Validity
RELIABILITY
With regard to psychological tests, reliability refers to the consistency with which individuals respond to test stimuli. Several ways of evaluating reliability exist.
First, test-retest reliability is the extent to which an individual makes similar responses to the same test stimuli on repeated occasions. Problems can arise when clients remember responses from the first occasion, develop "test-wiseness," or show practice effects. To address these issues, equivalent-forms reliability uses parallel forms of a test to avoid memory and practice effects.
When developing equivalent forms is too expensive or impractical, split-half reliability is assessed by dividing a test into halves (usually odd versus even items) and comparing participants' scores on the two halves. This serves as an index of a test's internal consistency β whether items appear to be measuring the same thing. The preferred method of assessing internal consistency involves computing the average of all possible split-half correlations for a given test.
π Definition β Inter-rater reliability: The index of the degree of agreement between two or more raters or judges as to the level of a trait that is present or the presence/absence of a feature or diagnosis.
VALIDITY
In general, validity refers to the extent to which an assessment technique measures what it is supposed to measure.
π Definition β Content validity: The degree to which a group of test items actually covers the various aspects of the variable under study.
π Definition β Predictive validity: Demonstrated when test scores accurately predict some behavior or event in the future.
π Definition β Concurrent validity: Involves relating today's test scores to a concurrent criterion.
π Definition β Construct validity: Shown when test scores relate to other measures or behaviors in a logical, theoretically expected fashion.
Definition of Intelligence
Intelligence is a hypothetical construct β a concept that exists only in the way that psychologists and the public choose to define it. You cannot touch intelligence nor directly observe it; you can only observe the consequences of intelligence as reflected in behavior and performance.
There is no universally accepted definition of intelligence, but most definitions have fallen into one of three classes: (1) definitions emphasizing adjustment or adaptation to the environment β adaptability to new situations and capacity to deal with a range of situations; (2) definitions focusing on the ability to learn β educability in the broad sense; (3) definitions emphasizing abstract thinking β the ability to use a wide range of symbols and concepts, including both verbal and numerical symbols.
Notable definitions include:
- Wechsler (1939): "Intelligence is the aggregate or global capacity of the individual to act purposefully, to think rationally, and to deal effectively with his environment."
- Robinson & Robinson (1965): Intelligence refers to "the whole class of cognitive behaviors which reflects an individual's capacity to solve problems with insight, to adapt himself to new situations, to think abstractly, and to profit from his experience."
- Sternberg & Salter (1982): Intelligence is expressed in terms of "adaptive, goal-directed behavior" where what is labeled "intelligent" is determined largely by cultural or societal norms.
- Spearman: Intelligence has very few traits in common β resemblance is an external fact, not an internal essence. There can be no process-based definition of intelligence because it is not a unitary quality.
Theories of Intelligence
Theoretical approaches to understanding intelligence include psychometric theories, developmental theories, neuropsychological theories, and information-processing theories.
FACTOR ANALYTICAL APPROACHES
Spearman (1927), the father of factor analysis, posited the existence of a g factor (general intelligence) and S factors (specific intelligence). Elements that tests have in common are represented by g, while elements unique to a given test are S factors. Spearman's message was that intelligence is a broad, generalized entity.
Thurstone (1938) challenged Spearman by presenting evidence for a series of "group" factors rather than the g factor. Based on factor analysis of 57 tests administered to 240 participants, he described seven group factors: number, word fluency, verbal meaning, perceptual speed, space, reasoning, and memory.
CATTELL'S THEORY
R. B. Cattell (1987) emphasized the centrality of g while offering a tentative list of 17 primary ability concepts. He described two important second-order factors representing a partitioning of Spearman's g into two components: fluid ability (the person's genetically based intellectual capacity) and crystallized ability (capacities attributed to culture-based learning, tapped by usual standardized intelligence tests). Cattell's approach is essentially a hierarchical model of intelligence.
GUILFORD'S THEORY
Guilford (1967) proposed a Structure of the Intellect (SOI) model, using the model as a guide in generating data rather than inferring a model from data. He reasoned that intelligence components could be organized into three dimensions: operations, contents, and products.
The operations dimension includes cognition, memory, divergent production (constructing logical alternatives), convergent production (constructing logic-tight arguments), and evaluation. The content dimension involves areas of information: figural, symbolic, semantic, and behavioral. When a mental operation is applied to a specific content type, there are six possible products: units, classes, systems, relations, transformations, and implications. This yields 120 separate intellectual abilities. The most widely held reservation is that this is a taxonomy or classification rather than a theory.
π‘ Why this matters: Guilford's model represents the most ambitious attempt to map the full landscape of human intellectual abilities, though its practical utility in clinical assessment has been limited.
RECENT DEVELOPMENTS
Traditional intelligence tests assessed what we know or can do, but recent approaches have taken on a cognitive or information-processing orientation. Researchers describe moment-by-moment attempts to solve problems β from stimulus registration to verbal or motor response β creating a more dynamic view of intelligence. Some focus on speed of information processing, others on strategies of processing. Levels studied include speed of processing, speed in making choices, and speed of extracting language from long-term memory. Remaining questions include whether there is a central processing mechanism, how processing elements change with development, and whether skills are general or specific to certain ability areas.
Gardner (1983) described a theory of multiple intelligences, suggesting that human intellectual competence involves a set of problem-solving skills enabling resolution of problems or difficulties. He proposed a family of six intelligences: linguistic, musical, logical-mathematical, spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, and personal (the personal refers both to access to one's own feeling life and ability to notice distinctions among other individuals). A major criticism is that some "intelligences" may be better conceptualized as "talents."
Sternberg (1985, 1991) proposed a triarchic theory of intelligence maintaining that people function on the basis of three aspects: componential (analytical thinking β characterizes a good test-taker), experiential (creative thinking β ability to combine separate elements of experience insightfully), and contextual ("street smart" β knowing how to manipulate the environment). This approach deemphasizes speed and accuracy, emphasizing instead planning and monitoring responses.
Despite these newer theories, clinicians' day-to-day use of tests suggests they have not outgrown Spearman's g factor or Thurstone's group factors. Most current intelligence tests yield a single IQ score (implying g) but are composed of subtests (implying acceptance of group factors). Practicing clinicians appear to think more in line with Spearman or Thurstone, remaining as yet little affected by recent information-processing developments.
History of Intelligence Testing
Two important developments in the latter half of the nineteenth century influenced the introduction of intelligence measures. First, compulsory education in the United States and other countries resulted in diverse student bodies and dramatically increased failure rates, creating pressure to identify those most likely to succeed in school. Second, psychological scientists demonstrated that mental abilities could be measured. Early attempts focused on measures of sensory acuity and reaction time (Francis Galton, James McKeen Cattell).
Alfred Binet and his collaborator Theodore Simon became leaders in the intelligence testing movement when they devised the Binet-Simon test to identify individual differences in mental functioning. Binet's original purpose was to develop an objective method of identifying those truly lacking in academic ability. Like others of the day, they regarded intelligence as a "faculty" that was inherited, though also affected by training and opportunity. Institutions such as schools, industries, military forces, and governments were interested in individual differences that might affect performance, so intelligence testing prospered.
By the end of the 1960s, many attacked the validity of these tests, arguing that they discriminate through inclusion of unfair items. A lengthy civil rights suit (Larry P. v. Wilson Riles, begun in 1971) resulted in the California State Board of Education imposing a moratorium on the use of intelligence tests to assess disabilities in African Americans (1975). The court held that IQ testing is prejudicial to African American children and tends to place them in stigmatizing programs for cognitively impaired individuals. Others disputed this judgment, with some African Americans contemplating challenge of the ruling, claiming it assumed they would do poorly on tests. Still others argued IQ testing is the principal means by which wrongs imposed upon minorities by a devastating environment can be righted.
The most widely used intelligence tests in the United States are those developed by psychologist David Wechsler during the 1940s and 1950s. Building on existing tests (Stanford-Binet, Army Alpha and Beta tests, Bellevue intelligence scale), Wechsler first developed an individual test for adults, followed by a similarly structured test for school-age children (to age 16), and finally a test for preschool-age children. These tests reflect Wechsler's belief in a total or global level of intellectual capacity that can be measured, yielding an overall intelligence score. Wechsler's tests more than any others have shaped psychologists' perception of intellectual functioning as comprised of separate but related verbal and performance (non-verbal) abilities.
Wechsler (1939) emphasized that an IQ test measures functional intelligence, not intelligence itself. Functional intelligence is influenced by nonintellectual factors including motivation, configuration of specific abilities, and emotional adjustment. A score on an IQ test reflects what one has learned, which is a function of opportunities to which one has been exposed and one's ability to take advantage of those opportunities. All three versions of Wechsler's scales have undergone substantial revisions, taking two forms: changes in test items to make them more current and appropriate, and testing of new normative samples for up-to-date comparisons.
Conclusion
There is little question that intelligence tests have been misused at times in ways that have penalized minorities, and that some tests have contained items adversely affecting minority performance. The lecture concludes that efforts should focus on developing better tests and administering and interpreting them in a sensitive fashion, rather than banning tests entirely β as banning may ultimately harm the very people who need help.
β Key Takeaways
The single most critical understanding from this lecture is that intelligence is a hypothetical construct with no universally accepted definition, yet it remains a cornerstone of clinical assessment. Students must master the psychometric concepts of reliability (test-retest, equivalent-forms, split-half, internal consistency, inter-rater) and validity (content, predictive, concurrent, construct) as they form the basis for evaluating any intelligence test. The major theoretical approaches β Spearman's g and S factors, Thurstone's seven group factors, Cattell's fluid and crystallized intelligence, Guilford's SOI model, Gardner's multiple intelligences, and Sternberg's triarchic theory β represent different ways of conceptualizing intellectual functioning, though clinicians continue to rely primarily on Spearman and Thurstone. The history of intelligence testing from Binet through Wechsler shows how societal needs drove test development, while the Larry P. v. Wilson Riles case highlights ongoing controversies about cultural bias and the appropriate use of intelligence tests with minority populations.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main types of reliability discussed in this lecture, and what specific aspect of consistency does each measure?
- How did Spearman's concept of a general g factor differ from Thurstone's theory of seven group factors, and what evidence did Thurstone present?
- What is the distinction between fluid ability and crystallized ability in Cattell's theory, and which is more influenced by genetics versus culture-based learning?
- According to Wechsler, what is functional intelligence, and what nonintellectual factors influence an IQ score?
- What was the outcome of the Larry P. v. Wilson Riles case, and what arguments were made both for and against the court's ruling?
π Lecture 18 β Intelligence Tests
π Overview: This lecture defines intelligence tests and explores their purpose, advantages, and disadvantages. It critically examines the use and misuse of these tests, details common administration procedures, and provides a thorough introduction to the most widely used clinical instruments: the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales and the Wechsler Scales (WAIS-III and WISC-III). The lecture concludes by discussing the clinical applications of intelligence testing, including estimating intellectual level, predicting academic success, and appraising a client's problem-solving style.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by defining intelligence tests and their purpose, then outlines important precautions and criticisms of their use. It describes the common procedures involved in test administration, followed by a balanced discussion of their advantages and disadvantages. The core of the lecture introduces the three most commonly used intelligence tests: the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales and the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS-III) and Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-III). Key foundational concepts of IQ and Deviation IQ are explained before delving into the structure, purpose, and subtests of each instrument. The lecture concludes with a section on the clinical use of intelligence tests, focusing on estimating general intellectual level, predicting academic success, and appraising the test-taker's cognitive and behavioral style.
π Lecture Summary
DEFINITION
Intelligence tests are psychological tests designed to measure a variety of mental functions, such as reasoning, comprehension, and judgment.
PURPOSE The goal of intelligence tests is to obtain an idea of the person's intellectual potential. The tests center around a set of stimuli designed to yield a score based on the test maker's model of what makes up intelligence. Intelligence tests are often given as a part of a battery of tests.
PRECAUTIONS WITH INTELLIGENCE TESTS
There are many different types of intelligence tests and they all do not measure the same abilities. Although the tests often have aspects that are related with each other, one should not expect that scores from one intelligence test, that measures a single factor, will be similar to scores on another intelligence test that measures a variety of factors. Also, when determining whether or not to use an intelligence test, a person should make sure that the test has been adequately developed and has solid research to show its reliability and validity. Additionally, psychometric testing requires a clinically trained examiner. Therefore, the test should only be administered and interpreted by a trained professional. This is especially true in case of different tests that measure different abilities in individuals. A person who is well trained in the administration of one test may or may not be as well trained in the administration of another test.
CRITICISM OF INTELLIGENCE TESTS
A central criticism of intelligence tests is that psychologists and educators use these tests to distribute the limited resources of our society. These test results are used to provide rewards such as special classes for gifted students, admission to college, and employment. Those who do not qualify for these resources based on intelligence test scores may feel angry as if the tests are denying them opportunities for success. Unfortunately, intelligence test scores have not only become associated with a person's ability to perform certain tasks, but with self-worth. Many people are under the false assumption that intelligence tests measure a person's inborn or biological intelligence. Intelligence tests are based on an individual's interaction with the environment and never exclusively measure inborn intelligence. Intelligence tests have been associated with categorizing and stereotyping people. Additionally, knowledge of one's performance on an intelligence test may affect a person's aspirations and motivation to obtain goals. Intelligence tests can be culturally biased against certain groups.
COMMON PROCEDURES
When taking an intelligence test, a person can expect to do a variety of tasks. These tasks may include having to answer questions that are asked verbally, doing mathematical problems, and doing a variety of tasks that require eye-hand coordination. Some tasks may be timed and require the person to work as quickly as possible. Typically, most questions and tasks start out easy and progressively get more difficult. It is unusual for anyone to know the answer to all of the questions or be able to complete all of the tasks. If a person is unsure of an answer, guessing is usually allowed.
A person's raw scores on an intelligence test are typically converted to standard scores. The standard scores allow the examiner to compare the individual's score to other people who have taken the test. Additionally, by converting raw scores to standard scores the examiner has uniform scores and can more easily compare an individual's performance on one test with the individual's performance on another test. Depending on the intelligence test that is used, a variety of scores can be obtained. Most intelligence tests generate an overall intelligence quotient or IQ. As previously noted, it is valuable to know how a person performs on the various tasks that make up the test. This can influence the interpretation of the test and what the IQ means. The average of score for most intelligence tests is 100.
ADVANTAGES
In general, intelligence tests measure a wide variety of human behaviors better than any other measure that has been developed. They allow professionals to have a uniform way of comparing a person's performance with that of other people who are similar in age. These tests also provide information on cultural and biological differences among people. Intelligence tests are excellent predictors of academic achievement and provide an outline of a person's mental strengths and weaknesses. Many times the scores have revealed talents in many people, which have led to an improvement in their educational opportunities. Teachers, parents, and psychologists are able to devise individual curricula that match a person's level of development and expectations.
DISADVANTAGES
Some researchers argue that intelligence tests have serious shortcomings. For example, many intelligence tests produce a single intelligence score. This single score is often inadequate in explaining the multidimensional aspects of intelligence. Another problem with a single score is the fact that individuals with similar intelligence test scores can vary greatly in their expression of these talents. It is important to know the person's performance on the various subtests that make up the overall intelligence test score. Knowing the performance on these various scales can influence the understanding of a person's abilities and how these abilities are expressed. Furthermore, intelligence tests only measure a sample of behaviors or situations in which intelligent behavior is revealed. For instance, some intelligence tests do not measure a person's everyday functioning, social knowledge, mechanical skills, and/or creativity. Along with this, the formats of many intelligence tests do not capture the complexity and immediacy of real-life situations. Therefore, intelligence tests have been criticized for their limited ability to predict non-test or nonacademic intellectual abilities. π Example: Two people have identical scores on intelligence tests. Although both people have the same test score, one person may have obtained the score because of strong verbal skills while the other may have obtained the score because of strong skills in perceiving and organizing various tasks.
COMMONLY USED INTELLIGENCE TESTS
The three most commonly used intelligence tests are:
- Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales
- Wechsler-Adult Intelligence Scale
- Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children
CONCEPTS OF IQ & DEVIATION IQ
Before we go into the details of the three tests, let us first understand the two basic concepts that are employed in the tests. These are the concepts of IQ and Deviation IQ.
THE INTELLIGENCE QUOTIENT (IQ or RATIO IQ)
Binet regarded the mental age (MA) as an index of mental performance. Each item successfully passed on a Binet test signified a certain number of months' credit. At the conclusion of the test, the items passed were added up and the MA emerged. Thus, there was nothing magical about an MA: all it meant was the X numbers of items has been passed. Subsequently, Stern (1938) developed the concept of intelligence quotient (IQ) to circumvent several problems that had arisen in using the difference between the chronological age (CA) and the MA to express deviance. π Definition β Ratio IQ: An IQ score computed by dividing a person's mental age (MA) by their chronological age (CA) and multiplying by 100. π Formula: IQ = MA / CA x 100 π Example: A 15-year-old child with a Mental Age of 14 has an IQ of 14/15 x 100 = 93. A 5-year-old child with a Mental Age of 4 has an IQ of 4/5 x 100 = 80. This shows that the younger child is more deviant despite the same one-year discrepancy between MA and CA, because intellectual growth is more rapid at younger age levels. It should be noted that in measuring intelligence, we cannot be sure that we are dealing with equal-interval measurement. We cannot be sure that an IQ of 50 is really twice as much as an IQ of 25 or that our scale has an absolute zero point. We cannot add and subtract IQs. All we can do is state that a person with an IQ of 50 is brighter than a person with an IQ of 25.
DEVIATION IQ
Although initially appealing, the ratio IQ is significantly limited in its application to older age groups. The reason is that a consistent (even if very high) mental age (MA) score accompanied by an increasing chronological age (CA) score will result in a lower IQ. Thus, it may appear that IQ has decreased over time when, in fact, one's intellectual ability has been maintained. To deal with this problem, Wechsler introduced the concept of deviation IQ. The assumption is made that intelligence is normally distributed throughout the population. A deviation IQ then involves a comparison of an individual's performance on an IQ test with that of his or her age peers. Thus, the same IQ score has a similar meaning, even if two individuals are markedly different in age (for example, a 22-year-old versus an 80-year-old). In both cases, an IQ of 100 indicates an average level of intellectual ability for that age group. π‘ Why this matters: The Deviation IQ solves the fundamental problem of the Ratio IQ by using statistical comparison to a peer group, making IQ scores comparable across different age groups. This is the standard method used in modern intelligence tests like the Wechsler scales.
THE CLINICAL ASSESSMENT OF INTELLIGENCE
THE STANDFORD-BINET SCALE
The Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale: Fourth Edition (SB: FE) is a standardized test that measures intelligence and cognitive abilities in children and adults, from age two through mature adulthood. It is a descendant of the Binet-Simon scale which was developed in 1905 and became the first intelligence test. The Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale was developed in 1916 and was revised in 1937, 1960, and 1986. The present edition was published in 1986, and is called the Stanford-Binet Fourth Edition, or SB-4.
PURPOSE The Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale was originally developed to help place children in appropriate educational settings. It can help determine the level of intellectual and cognitive functioning in preschoolers, children, adolescents and adults, and assist in the diagnosis of a learning disability, developmental delay, mental retardation, or giftedness. It is used to provide educational planning and placement, neuropsychological assessment, and research. The Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale is generally administered in a school or clinical setting.
DESCRIPTION The Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale is comprised of four cognitive area scores which together determine the composite score and factor scores. The test consists of 15 subtests, which are grouped into the four area scores. These area scores include: Verbal Reasoning, Abstract/Visual Reasoning, Quantitative Reasoning, and Short-Term Memory. The composite score is considered to be what the authors call the best estimate of "g" or "general reasoning ability" and is the sum of all of subtest scores. This "g" is considered to represent a person's ability to solve novel problems. The composite score is a global estimate of a person's intellectual functioning.
- The Verbal Reasoning area score measures verbal knowledge and understanding obtained from the school and home learning environment and reflects the ability to apply verbal skills to new situations.
- The Abstract/Visual Reasoning area score examines the ability to interpret and perform mathematic operations, the ability to visualize patterns, visual/motor skills, and problem-solving skills through the use of reasoning.
- The Quantitative Reasoning area score measures: numerical reasoning, concentration, and knowledge and application of numerical concepts.
- The Short-Term Memory score measures concentration skills, short-term memory, and sequencing skills. Subtests comprising this area score measure visual short-term memory and auditory short term memory involving both sentences and number sequences.
SB-4 uses an adaptive testing procedure called multistage testing. The examiner first gives the Vocabulary Test to determine the entry point (that is, which item to start with) for each remaining subtest. This initial estimate of ability provides a more appropriate entry or starting point on subsequent subtests, and is likely to result in more efficient testing, than relying exclusively on chronological age as a guide for a starting point.
THE WECHSLER SCALES
David Wechsler used a deviation IQ concept. This approach assumes that intelligence is normally distributed and compares individuals with their age peers. This method statistically establishes an IQ of 100 as the mean for each age group.
BACKGROUND OF WAIS
Earlier versions of the Stanford-Binet had a number of disadvantages that led David Wechsler in 1939 to develop the Wechsler-Bellevue Intelligence Scale. This was a test designed for adults β one that would offer items whose content was more appropriate for and more motivating to adults than the school-oriented Binet. In contrast to the Stanford-Binet, whose items were arranged in age levels, the Wechsler-Bellevue Intelligence Scale grouped its items into subtests. In addition, there was a Performance Scale and a Verbal Scale (consisting of five and six subtests, respectively). A separate IQ for each scale could be calculated, along with a Full Scale IQ. The systematic inclusion of performance items helped remedy the overemphasis on verbal skills that limited the utility of the earlier Stanford-Binet with special populations.
THE WAIS-III
DESCRIPTION The most recent version, the Wechsler Adult Intelligent Scale-Third Edition (WAIS-III), was introduced in 1997. It is an individually administered measure of intelligence, intended for adults aged 16β89.
PURPOSE The WAIS-III is intended to measure human intelligence reflected in both verbal and performance abilities. Besides being utilized as an intelligence assessment, the WAIS-III is used in neuropsychological evaluation, specifically with regard to brain dysfunction. Large differences in verbal and nonverbal intelligence may indicate specific types of brain damage. The WAIS-III is also administered for diagnostic purposes. IQ scores reported by the WAIS-III can be used as part of the diagnostic criteria for mental retardation, specific learning disabilities, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
The WAIS elicits three intelligence quotient scores, based on an average of 100, as well as subtest and index scores. The WAIS elicits an overall intelligence quotient, called the full-scale IQ, as well as a verbal IQ and a performance IQ. The three IQ scores are standardized in such a way that the scores have a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15. The WAIS also elicits four indices: verbal comprehension, perceptual organization, working memory, and processing speed.
THE VERBAL IQ is derived from scores on seven of the subtests: information, digit span, vocabulary, arithmetic, comprehension, similarities, and letter-number sequencing.
- The information subtest is a test of general knowledge.
- The digit span subtest requires test takers to repeat strings of digits.
- The comprehension subtest requires test takers to solve practical problems and explain the meaning of proverbs.
- The similarities subtest requires test takers to indicate the similarities between pairs of things.
- The letter-number sequencing subtest involves ordering numbers and letters presented in an unordered sequence.
THE PERFORMANCE IQ is derived from scores on the remaining seven subtests: picture completion, picture arrangement, block design, object assembly, digit symbol, matrix reasoning, and symbol search.
- In the picture completion subtest, the test taker completes pictures with missing elements.
- The picture arrangement subtest entails arranging pictures in order to tell a story.
- The block design subtest requires test takers to use blocks to make specific designs.
- The object assembly subtest requires people to assemble pieces to build a whole object.
- In the digit symbol subtest, test takers must pair digits and symbols.
- The matrix reasoning subtest requires test takers to identify geometric shapes.
- The symbol search subtest requires examinees to match symbols appearing in different groups.
PRECAUTIONS The WAIS III is not considered an adequate measure of extremely high and low intelligence (IQ scores below 40 and above 160). Wechsler himself stressed that his scales were not appropriate for people with an IQ below 70 or above 130. Also, when administering the WAIS to people at extreme ends of the age range (below 20 years of age or above 70), caution should be used when interpreting scores. The age range for the WAIS III overlaps with that of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC) for people between 16 and 17 years of age, and it is suggested that the WISC provides a better measure for this age range.
THE WISC-III
The latest version, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III), was published in 1991. It is an individually administered measure of intelligence intended for children aged six years to 16 years and 11 months.
PURPOSES The WISC is designed to measure human intelligence as reflected in both verbal and nonverbal (performance) abilities. The WISC is used in schools as part of placement evaluations for programs for gifted children and for children who are developmentally disabled. In addition to its uses in intelligence assessment, the WISC is used in neuropsychological evaluation, specifically with regard to brain dysfunction. The WISC is also used for other diagnostic purposes. IQ scores reported by the WISC can be used as part of the diagnostic criteria for mental retardation and specific learning disabilities. The test may also serve to better evaluate children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and other behavior disorders.
WISC III scores yield an overall intelligence quotient, called the full scale IQ, as well as a verbal IQ and a performance IQ. The three IQ scores are standardized in such a way that a score of 100 is considered average. Verbal and performance IQ scores are based on scores on the 13 subtests. The full scale IQ is derived from the child's scores on all of the subtests.
VERBAL IQ The child's verbal IQ score is derived from scores on six of the subtests: information, digit span, vocabulary, arithmetic, comprehension, and similarities.
- The information subtest is a test of general knowledge.
- The digit span subtest requires the child to repeat strings of digits.
- The comprehension subtest asks the child to solve practical problems and explain the meaning of simple proverbs.
- The similarities subtest asks the child to describe the similarities between pairs of items.
PERFORMANCE IQ The child's performance IQ is derived from scores on the remaining seven subtests: picture completion, picture arrangement, block design, object assembly, coding, mazes, and symbol search.
- In the picture completion subtest, the child is asked to complete pictures with missing elements.
- The picture arrangement subtest entails arranging pictures in order to tell a story.
- The object assembly subtest asks the child to put together pieces to construct an entire object.
- In the coding subtest, the child makes pairs from a series of shapes or numbers.
- The mazes subtest asks the child to solve maze puzzles of increasing difficulty.
- The symbol search subtest requires the child to match symbols that appear in different groups.
CONCLUSION
THE CLINICAL USE OF INTELLIGENCE TESTS
THE ESTIMATION OF GENERAL INTELLECTUAL LEVEL
The most obvious use of an intelligence test is as a means for arriving at an estimate of the patient's general intellectual level. Often the goal is the determination of how much general intelligence βgβ a given person possesses. Often, the question is stated a bit differently, for example, what is the patient's intellectual potential? Posing the question in this way suggests that perhaps the person is not functioning as well as his or her potential would indicate. The potential can form a baseline against which to measure current achievements, thus providing information about the patient's current level of functioning.
PREDICTION OF ACADEMIC SUCCESS
There are data that demonstrate a relationship between intelligence test scores and school success. To the extent that intelligence should logically reflect the capacity to do well in school, we are justified in expecting intelligence tests to predict school success. One must remember, however, that intelligence and academic success are not conceptually identical.
THE APPRAISAL OF STYLE
The clinical psychologistsβ interest is not only in the clientβs success or failure on particular test items but also how that success or failure occurs. One of the major values of individual intelligence tests is that they permit us to observe the client or patient at work. Such observations can help us greatly in interpreting an IQ. π‘ Why this matters: This section emphasizes that a clinical psychologist uses an intelligence test not just for a score, but as a structured behavioral observation, gaining insights into the client's motivation, anxiety, problem-solving approach, and other qualitative aspects that give meaning to the numerical results.
β Key Takeaways
Intelligence tests measure a sample of mental functions to estimate intellectual potential, but they must be used with caution due to cultural bias and the risk of reducing a person's worth to a single score. The fundamental concepts for understanding scores are the Ratio IQ (MA/CA x 100) and the more modern Deviation IQ (which compares an individual to their age peers, using a mean of 100). The two main families of tests are the Stanford-Binet (which provides a composite score, area scores for Verbal, Abstract/Visual, and Quantitative Reasoning, and Short-Term Memory, and uses multistage testing) and the Wechsler Scales (WAIS for adults 16-89, WISC for children 6-16), which provide Verbal, Performance, and Full Scale IQs along with index scores. Clinically, these tests are used not only to estimate general intellectual level ("g") and predict academic success, but also for neuropsychological evaluation and, crucially, to appraise a client's qualitative cognitive and behavioral style during test-taking.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary difference between a "Ratio IQ" and a "Deviation IQ," and why is the Deviation IQ considered superior?
- Name the four cognitive area scores measured by the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale (SB-4) and explain how they combine to form a composite score.
- List three of the seven verbal subtests and three of the seven performance subtests that comprise the WAIS-III, and describe what one of each type measures.
- What is the key caution when interpreting a Full Scale IQ from a Wechsler test if there is a large discrepancy between a person's Verbal IQ and Performance IQ?
- Beyond providing an IQ score, what is the clinical value of "appraising style" during the administration of an individual intelligence test?