π Lecture 09 β Ethical Standards for Clinical Psychologists
π Overview: This lecture introduces the ethical framework that governs the practice of clinical psychologists. It explains why ethical guidelines are essential, detailing the structure and content of the APA Ethics Code, including its aspirational General Principles and enforceable Ethical Standards. Understanding these standards is critical for protecting both the public and the integrity of the profession.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a rationale for ethical guidelines, explaining that psychology holds members to a higher standard than the law. It then covers the Introduction and Applicability of the APA Ethics Code, followed by the Preamble. The five aspirational General Principles (A-E) are presented, followed by a detailed breakdown of the enforceable Ethical Standards across seven key areas: Resolving Ethical Issues, Competence, Human Relations, Privacy and Confidentiality, Record Keeping and Fees, Assessment, and Therapy. The lecture concludes with a summary reinforcing the importance of these standards.
π Lecture Summary
Ethical Standards for Clinical Psychologists
Clinical psychologists, whether researchers, teachers, or therapists, are expected to maintain the highest professional ethics. Psychology is one of the few fields with guidelines holding members to a higher standard than the law. Clinical psychologists have a high degree of responsibility that impacts others' lives, making professional ethics crucial. For instance, psychotherapy therapists are entrusted with clients' vulnerabilities, teachers must provide unbiased information, and researchers must protect subjects and report accurately. Following ethical principles ensures appropriate, responsible, and professional behavior.
Rationale
While some behaviors, like sexual contact with current patients, falsifying data, breaking confidentiality, or over-billing, are clearly unethical, many other situations are ambiguous. The APA Ethics Code provides specific guidance and has been updated nine times since 1953. The current version was adopted on August 21, 2002, and became effective on June 1, 2003.
Introduction and Applicability
The APA's Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct (Ethics Code) consists of an Introduction, a Preamble, five General Principles (A-E), and specific Ethical Standards. The Introduction discusses the intent, organization, and scope of application. The Preamble and General Principles are aspirational goals that guide psychologists toward the highest ideals but are not themselves enforceable rules. The Ethical Standards are enforceable rules for conduct.
The Ethics Code applies to psychologists' scientific, educational, or professional roles, including clinical, counseling, school practice, research, teaching, supervision, and administration. It applies across various contexts, including in-person, postal, telephone, internet, and electronic transmissions. Membership in the APA commits members to comply with the Ethics Code, and lack of awareness is not a defense against unethical conduct. If a conflict arises between the Ethics Code and the law, psychologists must meet the higher ethical standard. If the conflict is irresolvable, they may adhere to the law, in keeping with basic principles of human rights.
π Definition β Ethics Code: The APA's Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct, consisting of an Introduction, Preamble, General Principles, and specific Ethical Standards.
Preamble
Psychologists are committed to increasing knowledge of behavior and using that knowledge to improve the condition of individuals, organizations, and society. They respect and protect civil and human rights and freedom of inquiry. They strive to help the public make informed judgments. This Ethics Code provides a common set of principles and standards for professional and scientific work, with the goals of welfare and protection of individuals and groups. The development of ethical standards requires a personal commitment and lifelong effort to act ethically and to encourage ethical behavior in others.
General Principles
The General Principles are aspirational in nature, meant to guide and inspire psychologists toward the highest ethical ideals. They do not represent obligations and should not form the basis for imposing sanctions.
Principle A: Beneficence and Nonmaleficence
Psychologists strive to benefit those with whom they work and take care to do no harm. They safeguard the welfare and rights of those they interact with professionally. When conflicts occur, they attempt to resolve them in a way that minimizes harm. They are alert to and guard against factors like personal, financial, social, or political factors that might lead to misuse of their influence. They are also aware of the possible effect of their own physical and mental health on their ability to help others.
Principle B: Fidelity and Responsibility
Psychologists establish relationships of trust with those they work with. They uphold professional standards, clarify their roles and obligations, accept responsibility for their behavior, and manage conflicts of interest that could lead to exploitation or harm. They consult with, refer to, or cooperate with other professionals to serve the best interests of others. They strive to contribute a portion of their professional time for little or no compensation.
Principle C: Integrity
Psychologists promote accuracy, honesty, and truthfulness in the science, teaching, and practice of psychology. They do not steal, cheat, or engage in fraud, subterfuge, or intentional misrepresentation. They strive to keep their promises. If deception is ethically justifiable, psychologists have an obligation to consider the need for it, its consequences, and their responsibility to correct any resulting mistrust.
Principle D: Justice
Psychologists recognize that fairness and justice entitle all persons to access to and benefit from psychology and to equal quality in processes, procedures, and services. They take precautions to ensure that their potential biases, the boundaries of their competence, and the limitations of their expertise do not lead to unjust practices.
Principle E: Respect for People's Rights and Dignity
Psychologists respect the dignity and worth of all people, and their rights to privacy, confidentiality, and self-determination. They are aware that special safeguards may be necessary for vulnerable persons or communities whose vulnerabilities impair autonomous decision making. They respect cultural, individual, and role differences, including those based on age, gender, race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, disability, and socioeconomic status. They try to eliminate the effect of biases based on these factors. π‘ Why this matters: The General Principles set the aspirational tone for the entire profession, guiding psychologists beyond mere compliance with rules.
Ethical Standards
1. Resolving Ethical Issues
1.01 Misuse of Psychologists' Work: Psychologists take reasonable steps to correct or minimize misuse or misrepresentation of their work. 1.02 Conflicts Between Ethics and Law: Psychologists make known their commitment to the Ethics Code and take steps to resolve the conflict. If unresolvable, they may adhere to the law. 1.03 Conflicts Between Ethics and Organizational Demands: Psychologists clarify the conflict, make known their commitment to the Ethics Code, and resolve the conflict to permit adherence to it. 1.04 Informal Resolution of Ethical Violations: When psychologists believe an ethical violation may have occurred, they attempt to resolve it informally by bringing it to the attention of the individual, if appropriate and without violating confidentiality. 1.05 Reporting Ethical Violations: If an ethical violation has substantially harmed someone, psychologists take further action, such as referring to state or national ethics committees or licensing boards. 1.06 Cooperating With Ethics Committees: Psychologists cooperate in ethics investigations. Failure to cooperate is itself an ethics violation. 1.07 Improper Complaints: Psychologists do not file ethics complaints made with reckless disregard for or willful ignorance of facts. 1.08 Unfair Discrimination Against Complainants and Respondents: Psychologists do not deny persons employment, advancement, or admission solely based on their having made or been the subject of an ethics complaint.
2. Competence
2.01 Boundaries of Competence: Psychologists provide services only within the boundaries of their competence, based on education, training, supervised experience, consultation, or study. This includes understanding factors like age, gender, culture, and disability. When asked to provide services in an emergency where other services are unavailable, they may do so while making a reasonable effort to obtain the needed competence. 2.02 Providing Services in Emergencies: In emergencies, psychologists may provide services to ensure they are not denied, but they are discontinued as soon as the emergency ends or appropriate services become available. 2.03 Maintaining Competence: Psychologists undertake ongoing efforts to develop and maintain their competence. 2.04 Bases for Scientific and Professional Judgments: Psychologists' work is based upon established scientific and professional knowledge. 2.05 Delegation of Work to Others: Psychologists take steps to avoid delegating work to persons with multiple relationships that could lead to exploitation, authorize only responsibilities others can perform competently, and see that these persons perform competently. 2.06 Personal Problems and Conflicts: Psychologists refrain from activities if personal problems could prevent them from performing competently. If they become aware of such problems, they take appropriate measures, such as obtaining professional consultation or limiting their duties.
3. Human Relations
3.01 Unfair Discrimination: Psychologists do not engage in unfair discrimination based on age, gender, race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, disability, or other bases proscribed by law. 3.02 Harassment: Psychologists do not knowingly engage in harassing or demeaning behavior. 3.03 Avoiding Harm: Psychologists take reasonable steps to avoid harming clients/patients, students, and others, and to minimize harm where it is foreseeable and unavoidable. 3.04 Multiple Relationships: A multiple relationship occurs when a psychologist is in a professional role with a person and simultaneously in another role, or has a relationship with a person closely associated with them. Psychologists refrain from entering into a multiple relationship if it could impair objectivity, competence, or effectiveness, or risks exploitation or harm. Multiple relationships that would not cause impairment or risk are not unethical. 3.05 Conflict of Interest: Psychologists refrain from taking on a professional role when interests or relationships could impair objectivity or expose the person to harm. 3.06 Third-Party Requests for Services: Psychologists clarify the nature of the relationship with all involved, including the role of the psychologist, who the client is, and limits of confidentiality. 3.07 Exploitative Relationships: Psychologists do not exploit persons over whom they have supervisory, evaluative, or other authority. 3.08 Cooperation with Other Professionals: Psychologists cooperate with other professionals to serve their clients effectively. 3.09 Informed Consent: Psychologists obtain informed consent using understandable language. For persons legally incapable of giving consent, they seek the individual's assent and obtain permission from a legally authorized person. When services are court-ordered, they inform the individual of the nature and limits of confidentiality. 3.10 Psychological Services Delivered To or Through Organizations: Psychologists provide information beforehand about the nature and objectives of the services, the intended recipients, and limits of confidentiality. 3.11 Interruption of Psychological Services: Psychologists make reasonable efforts to plan for facilitating services in the event of interruption by factors like illness, death, relocation, or retirement.
4. Privacy and Confidentiality
4.01 Maintaining Confidentiality: Psychologists have a primary obligation to protect confidential information obtained through or stored in any medium. 4.02 Discussing the Limits of Confidentiality: Psychologists discuss the relevant limits of confidentiality and the foreseeable uses of the information at the outset of the relationship. Those offering services via electronic transmission inform clients of the risks to privacy. 4.03 Recording: Psychologists obtain permission before recording voices or images. 4.04 Minimizing Intrusions on Privacy: Psychologists include only information relevant to the purpose in reports and consultations. 4.05 Disclosures: Psychologists may disclose confidential information with consent. They may disclose without consent only as mandated by law or for a valid purpose, such as to provide needed services, protect the client or others from harm, or obtain payment, with disclosure limited to the minimum necessary. 4.06 Consultations: When consulting, psychologists do not disclose confidential information that could lead to identification unless consent is obtained or disclosure cannot be avoided, and they disclose only to the extent necessary. 4.07 Use of Confidential Information for Educational or Other Purposes: Psychologists do not disclose personally identifiable information unless they take reasonable steps to disguise the person, the person has consented in writing, or there is legal authorization.
5. Record Keeping and Fees
5.01 Documentation of Professional and Scientific Work and Maintenance of Records: Psychologists create and maintain records to facilitate services, allow for replication of research, meet institutional requirements, ensure accuracy of billing, and ensure compliance with law. 5.02 Maintenance, Dissemination, and Disposal of Confidential Records: Psychologists maintain confidentiality in creating, storing, accessing, transferring, and disposing of records. 5.03 Withholding Records for Nonpayment: Psychologists may not withhold records needed for emergency treatment solely because payment has not been received. 5.04 Fees and Financial Arrangements: Psychologists reach an agreement specifying compensation and billing arrangements as early as feasible. They do not misrepresent their fees. 5.05 Barter with Clients/Patients: Barter is the acceptance of goods or services in return for psychological services. Psychologists may barter only if it is not clinically contraindicated and the arrangement is not exploitative. 5.06 Accuracy in Reports to Payors and Funding Sources: Psychologists ensure accurate reporting of the nature of the service, fees, and diagnosis. 5.07 Referrals and Fees: Payment to each professional involved is based on the services provided, not on the referral itself.
6. Assessment
6.01 Bases for Assessments: Psychologists base their opinions on information and techniques sufficient to substantiate their findings. They provide opinions about individuals only after conducting an adequate examination. 6.02 Use of Assessments: Psychologists use assessment instruments whose validity and reliability have been established for the population tested. They use methods appropriate to an individual's language preference. 6.03 Informed Consent in Assessments: Psychologists obtain informed consent for assessments, except when testing is mandated by law or is a routine organizational activity. 6.04 Interpreting Assessment Results: Psychologists consider the purpose of the assessment, test factors, and personal, linguistic, and cultural differences that might affect their interpretations. 6.05 Assessment by Unqualified Persons: Psychologists do not promote the use of assessment techniques by unqualified persons. 6.06 Obsolete Tests and Outdated Test Results: Psychologists do not base decisions on data or tests that are outdated or obsolete. 6.07 Explaining Assessment Results: Psychologists ensure that explanations of results are given to the individual, unless the nature of the relationship precludes this.
7. Therapy
7.01 Informed Consent to Therapy: Psychologists inform clients about the nature and course of therapy, fees, and limits of confidentiality. For developing treatments, they inform clients of the potential risks and alternative treatments. If the therapist is a trainee, the client is informed and given the supervisor's name. 7.02 Therapy Involving Couples or Families: Psychologists clarify at the outset which individuals are clients and the relationship they will have with each person. 7.03 Group Therapy: Psychologists describe the roles and responsibilities of all parties and the limits of confidentiality at the outset. 7.04 Providing Therapy to Those Served by Others: Psychologists carefully consider treatment issues and the client's welfare before offering services to those already receiving therapy elsewhere. 7.05 Sexual Intimacies with Current Therapy Clients/Patients: Psychologists do not engage in sexual intimacies with current therapy clients/patients. 7.06 Sexual Intimacies With Relatives or Significant Others of Current Therapy Clients/Patients: Psychologists do not engage in sexual intimacies with close relatives or significant others of current clients/patients. 7.07 Interruption of Therapy: Psychologists make reasonable efforts to provide for orderly resolution of responsibility for client care if employment or contractual relationships end. 7.08 Terminating Therapy: Psychologists terminate therapy when the client no longer needs the service, is not likely to benefit, or is being harmed. Prior to termination, they provide pre-termination counseling and suggest alternative service providers.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is that the APA Ethics Code has two components: the General Principles, which are aspirational goals for the highest ethical ideals (e.g., Beneficence, Integrity, Justice), and the Ethical Standards, which are enforceable rules for professional conduct. A key distinction is between "must" (enforceable standards) and "should" (aspirational principles) for exam purposes. You must remember the specific standards on Competence (practicing within boundaries), Multiple Relationships (avoiding those that impair objectivity), Informed Consent (obtaining it for therapy, assessment, and research), and Confidentiality (maintaining it and discussing its limits at the outset). Finally, the prohibition of sexual intimacies with current therapy clients/patients (Standard 7.05) is an absolute and non-negotiable rule.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between the General Principles and the Ethical Standards in the APA Ethics Code?
- Under what specific circumstances can a psychologist disclose confidential information without a client's consent?
- A psychologist's friend asks them to provide therapy. According to Standard 3.04, why might this be problematic, and what must the psychologist consider?
- What five purposes must psychologists consider when creating and maintaining their professional records?
- What are the specific obligations of a psychologist regarding informed consent when the client is a legally incapable minor?
π Lecture 10 β The Role of Research in Clinical Psychology
π Overview: This lecture explains why research is fundamental to clinical psychologyβit provides the evidence base for assessment, diagnosis, and treatment. It covers the four main research designs used in clinical psychology, with particular emphasis on experimental methods, including their underlying logic, key concepts, and common threats to validity. Understanding these research methods is essential for evaluating clinical evidence and making informed practice decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing the reciprocal relationship between research and clinical practice, then introduces four basic research designs: descriptive, correlational, experimental, and single-case designs. It explains descriptive research for epidemiology, correlational research for measuring associations, and experimental research for establishing causality. The bulk of the lecture details experimental methodsβincluding the model, essential characteristics, types of variables, reliability and validity, hypotheses, and ten alternative hypotheses that can threaten internal validity. It concludes with types of experimental designs (true experimental and single-subject designs) and a note about the complementarity of different research approaches.
π Lecture Summary
THE ROLE OF RESEARCH IN CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY
Research lays a foundation of knowledge for understanding psychopathology, mental health, and the relationship between psychological factors and physical disease. Research also provides a body of evidence to guide clinical practice, including empirically validated methods to assess people and their problems and empirically supported methods of prevention and treatment. Psychological tests and other assessment methods should be based on research that has established their reliability and validity.
Just as research informs clinical practice, clinical experiences provide a source of ideas and hypotheses for research. Research also provides ideas for new directions and applications for the field.
Because of the wide range of questions that confront researchers in clinical psychology, a variety of methods are used. Research designs range from single-case designs that study one individual to large-scale, multisided studies involving hundreds or thousands of participants. Clinical psychologists conduct research in experimentally controlled laboratories as well as naturalistic settings such as hospitals, clinics, schools, and the community. The methods chosen shape the types of questions asked, reflect the hypotheses being tested, and influence the interpretation of findings.
RESEARCH DESIGNS
There are four basic types of research designs: descriptive designs, correlational designs, experimental designs, and single-case designs.
DESCRIPTIVE RESEARCH DESIGNS
Descriptive research designs are used to report on the prevalence or incidence of a human characteristic or problem in the population. The goal is to describe a particular phenomenon without trying to predict or explain when or why it occurs. Descriptive studies are often an important first step because they allow researchers to define the scope of a problem.
Researchers involved in descriptive research are primarily concerned with accurate measurement and with the representativeness of the sample. If participation is biased toward a particular segment of the population, results could misrepresent the prevalence of a problem. This type of research does not attempt to predict or understand causes.
A descriptive approach is used most frequently in epidemiological studies, which try to identify the prevalence (number of disorders in a population at a particular point in time) and the incidence (onset of new cases during a specified period). Epidemiology has a long history in public health and has been used more recently to estimate the extent of psychiatric disorders within populations.
π Definition β Prevalence: The number of existing cases of a disorder in a population at a particular point in time. π Definition β Incidence: The number of new cases of a disorder that develop during a specified period of time.
CORRELATIONAL RESEARCH DESIGNS
Correlational research designs are used to determine the degree to which there is an association between two or more variables. The researcher wants to determine whether, and to what extent, different variables are related to each other by measuring each variable and using statistics to determine how changes in one variable relate to changes in another.
THE MODEL UNDERLYING CORRELATIONAL RESEARCH METHODS
Correlational research designs are founded on the assumption that reality is best described as a network of interacting and mutually-causal relationships. The dynamics of a systemβhow each part affects each other partβis more important than causality. As a rule, correlational designs do not indicate causality.
A simple (or bivariate) correlation represents the relationship observed between two variables. The same two variables are assessed for each person, and a correlation coefficient is calculated to provide a numerical representation of the magnitude and direction of this association.
The degree of relationship is expressed as a number between -1 and +1. This coefficient can range from positive 1.00 (one variable increases at exactly the same rate as the other), to zero (no association), to negative 1.00 (one variable decreases at exactly the same rate as the other increases). As the coefficient moves toward either -1 or +1, the relationship gets stronger.
The direction of the relationship is indicated by the "-" and "+" signs. A negative correlation means that as scores on one variable rise, scores on the other decrease. A positive correlation indicates that the scores move together, both increasing or both decreasing.
π Example: A student's grade and the amount of studying done are generally positively correlatedβthe more study done, the higher the grade. Stress and health, on the other hand, are generally negatively correlatedβthe more stress experienced, the lower the health status.
LIMITATION: The researcher cannot make conclusions about cause and effect; even a strong correlation does not mean that changes in one variable cause changes in another (correlation can be due to a third variable).
EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH DESIGNS
Experimental research designs involve the control or manipulation of one or more variables (the independent variables) to determine their effect on a second variable or set of variables (the dependent variables). Because the independent variable is under the control of the researcher, it is possible to determine if changes in this factor cause changes in the dependent variable.
Experimental designs are used in two primary ways in clinical psychology research. First, researchers conduct controlled experiments to study possible causal relationships between variables. Ethical concerns prohibit research that actually causes a psychological disorder, so experimental studies are conducted on analogues (representations) of psychopathology, or with patients already suffering from a disorder. Experimental research with animals can also have important implications.
The second major area is in studies designed to evaluate the effectiveness of an intervention, where participants are randomly assigned to a group that receives the intervention or to an alternative condition (a control group).
THE MODEL UNDERLYING EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH METHODS
Experimental designs are founded on the assumption that the world works according to causal laws that are essentially linear. The goal is to establish these cause-and-effect laws by isolating causal variables.
A softer view is that sometimes and in some ways, the world works according to causal laws. Both views agree that some important psychological questions are questions about what causes what, and experimental designs are the tools for these questions.
ESSENTIAL CHARACTERISTICS OF AN EXPERIMENT
To be "experimental," a study must meet two conditions: having an experimental independent variable with experimental control, and having random assignment.
(a) EXPERIMENTAL/INDEPENDENT VARIABLE: The researcher systematically alters/manipulates one variable (IV) to see if the manipulation causes a change in some aspect of behavior (DV). There must be at least one manipulated variable for a study to be an experiment.
π Example: The effect of training program type (IV) on cashiers' job performance (DV); the effect of servers' appearance (IV) on size of tip (DV).
(b) EXPERIMENTAL CONTROL: All factors other than the IV that could affect the DV must be held constant. This means avoiding confounding variables, such as when the experimenter affects subjects' behavior unintentionally.
2. Random assignment: Subjects must be randomly assigned to experimental conditions, meaning that all subjects have an equal chance of being exposed to each condition.
π Example: Newly hired cashiers are randomly assigned to one of 3 training programs; servers are randomly assigned to dress in new uniforms or dirty uniforms.
Random assignment makes it more likely that groups are equivalent on all important variables. If groups are identical except for exposure to treatment, any differences after treatment are inferred to have been caused directly by the treatment.
The GOAL OF EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH is to establish cause-and-effect relationships between variables. We hypothesize that the IV caused changes in the DV, but these changes may have been caused by many other factors or alternative hypotheses. The purpose of experimental designs is to eliminate alternative hypotheses. Good experimental designs are those which eliminate more alternative hypotheses.
π Example: Testing whether a new form of psychotherapy is successful at improving mental health. The research hypothesis is that psychotherapy is the cause. An experimental design is used to eliminate all (or as many as possible) alternative hypotheses.
TYPES OF VARIABLES
-
INDEPENDENT VARIABLE (IV): IV has levels, conditions, or treatments. The experimenter may manipulate conditions or assign subjects to conditions; supposed to be the cause.
-
DEPENDENT VARIABLE (DV): Measured by the experimenter; the effect or result.
-
CONTROL VARIABLES: Held constant by the experimenter to eliminate them as potential causes.
-
RANDOM VARIABLES: Allowed to vary freely to eliminate them as potential causes.
-
CONFOUNDING VARIABLES: Vary systematically with the independent variable; may also be a cause. Good experimental designs eliminate them.
π Example: If those in the psychotherapy group know they are getting a new treatment and expect to get better, while those in the control group know they are not getting treatment and expect to get worse, the expectations will be a confounding variable. If the experimental group improves, we will not know whether it was because of the psychotherapy or because of the participants' expectations.
CONCEPTS IN EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH
1. RELIABILITY: Are the results of the experiment repeatable? Reliability refers to the consistency of resultsβif we get the same results again and again by repeating an experiment, the results are reliable.
2. INTERNAL VALIDITY: Internal validity refers to the accuracy or truth-value of an experimentβhow accurately the experiment measures what it was designed to measure. Internal validity indicates the extent to which the experimenter is sure that the IV caused the effects in the DV. In experimental research, this usually means eliminating alternative hypotheses.
π Example: In evaluating a new psychotherapy, internal validity is whether the psychotherapy really was the causal factor in improving participants' mental health.
3. EXTERNAL VALIDITY: External validity refers to generalizabilityβto what extent can the results be applied in another setting or to another population?
HYPOTHESES
Experimental research methods revolve around hypotheses, educated guesses. The research hypothesis states that there is an effect and it is due to the independent variable. The null hypothesis states that there is no effect or that differences are due to chance only. The first step is ruling out chanceβwe set up a design to allow us to reject the null hypothesis.
If there is an effect beyond chance, it may be due to the IV or to extraneous variables or confounding variables (alternative hypotheses). We use experimental designs to eliminate alternative hypotheses.
π Definition β Research hypothesis: States that results are due to the IV. π Definition β Null hypothesis: States that differences are due to chance or that there are no differences between treatments. π Definition β Alternative hypotheses: Suggest that results are due to factors other than the IV.
ALTERNATIVE HYPOTHESES
1. Subject effect or selection effect: Results are due to systematic differences in research participants assigned to different conditions or treatments. π Example: If those who receive the new therapy are different from those in a control group (healthier, more motivated, more experienced). π‘ Common solution: Matching or random assignment to groups.
2. History effect: Results are due to events outside the experiment. π Example: A traumatic event like a natural disaster occurs at the same time as the treatment. π‘ Common solution: A control group exposed to the same history but not the new therapy.
3. Maturation effect: Results are due to changes within subjects over time (growth, fatigue, learning). π Example: A single group's mental health may improve over time without therapy. π‘ Common solution: A control group measured over the same period but without treatment.
4. Experimenter expectancy effect or Experimenter bias: Results are due to the experimenter's actions or expectations. π Example: The researcher who assesses mental health may distort assessments in the direction of the research hypothesis. π‘ Common solution: Use independent judges or more objective measurements.
5. Demand characteristics or Hawthorne effect: Results are due to subjects' expectations of desired behavior in the research setting. π Example: Research participants report less depression because they think that is what is expected. π‘ Common solution: Blind and double-blind designs; use a control group measured the same way.
6. Testing effect or reactivity: Results are due to the data gathering procedures. π Example: Measuring participants' mental health could get them thinking about their lives, thus improving them. π‘ Common solution: A control group that is also measured but without therapy.
7. Regression artifact or regression-to-the-mean: Results are due to extreme scores moving toward the mean over time. π Example: Those with the worst mental health scores are likely to improve over time without therapy. π‘ Common solution: A control group with similar characteristics but no treatment.
8. Instrumentation: Results are due to an aberration in measuring tools. π Example: The dependent variable is measured by a poor test. π‘ Common solution: Select or develop a better measure.
9. Halo effect: The researcher's expectations about certain subjects based on some subject characteristics. π Example: An outgoing, sociable subject is rated as more intelligent. π‘ Common solutions: Random assignment, blind judges, more objective measures.
10. Attrition or mortality effect: When subjects drop out of an experiment, it can bias the results. π Example: If more participants drop out of the new therapy group, only those who benefited most remain. π‘ Common solution: Find out why participants dropped out to get important clues.
11. Other non-specific factors: In psychotherapy research, the therapeutic relationship may lead to benefits rather than the specific intervention.
π‘ A COMMENT: There is no such thing as perfection in an experimental design. However, perfection is not the best standard. We look for studies that are good enough to base strong conclusions on.
TYPES OF EXPERIMENTAL DESIGNS
TRUE EXPERIMENTAL DESIGNS
These designs attempt to eliminate most alternative hypotheses, especially those related to time and group composition.
A. RANDOMIZED GROUPS DESIGN OR BETWEEN-GROUPS DESIGN: Each participant is randomly assigned to one group and gets only one level of the IV. There may be pre-tests and post-tests or only post-tests. This design can eliminate selection, history, and maturation effects.
B. REPEATED MEASURE DESIGN or WITHIN-SUBJECT DESIGN: Each participant gets all levels of the IV. Treatment orders must be counterbalanced to eliminate order effects.
C. MIXED MODEL DESIGNS OR COMPLEX DESIGNS: Combine randomized groups and repeated measures designs (e.g., two IVs, one between groups and one within groups).
SINGLE-SUBJECT DESIGNS
Single-subject designs (N=1 designs) are used most often in behavior modification. This is experimental research in a controlled setting; it is not case study research. They can provide strong internal validity but typically suffer from low external validity.
In each design, a series of regular observations is taken over time, divided into baseline (no treatment) and treatment conditions.
I. ABA OR REVERSAL DESIGN: Observations with no treatment (A or baseline) are followed by observations with treatment (B). If treatment is successful, there should be improvement. Another no-treatment (A) session is given. If improvements reverse, the research hypothesis is supported.
π Example: Observe a client daily for a week (A). Introduce new therapy for two weeks (B). If improvement occurs, take away therapy (A) and see if improvement goes away. If it does, the therapy works.
II. ABAB DESIGN: Like ABA, but another series of B (treatment) sessions is added. This leaves subjects with the advantage of a successful treatment and provides a replication of the AB comparison.
π Example (1997 study): Researchers used a single-case design to evaluate family-based behavioral treatment for a 14-year-old girl with severe disabilities and self-injurious, aggressive, and destructive behaviors. They implemented several interventions through parents' behavior across different settings. The frequency of problem behaviors decreased in each setting following the program.
CONCLUSION TO EXPERIMENTAL DESIGNS
Which design is best? Some researchers believe experimental designs are superior because only they can determine causal relationships. This is a misrepresentation of the research processβeach type of design is useful for addressing some questions and not others.
Clinical psychologists are often interested in observing things as they occur in the natural environment; descriptive and correlational designs are best suited for this. In other instances, they are interested in determining cause-and-effect relationsβgoals addressed only with experimental designs.
Furthermore, ethical constraints often limit the types of designs that can be used. Researchers cannot ethically cause significant distress or psychopathology. The first priority is the welfare of participants. Much research on the causes of psychopathology must rely on descriptive and correlational designs combined with analogue or animal research.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is that research provides the foundation for all clinical practiceβassessment tools must be reliable and valid, and treatments must be empirically supported. The four types of research designs serve different purposes: descriptive designs establish prevalence and incidence (especially in epidemiology); correlational designs measure the strength and direction of associations but cannot establish causality; experimental designs with random assignment and control can establish cause-and-effect relationships; and single-subject designs offer strong internal validity for individual cases. Students must master the ten alternative hypotheses (selection, history, maturation, experimenter bias, demand characteristics, testing, regression, instrumentation, halo, and attrition effects) as these are the primary threats to internal validity that good experimental designs seek to eliminate. Finally, no single design is universally superiorβthe choice depends on the research question, ethical constraints, and practical considerations.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between prevalence and incidence in epidemiological research?
- Why can correlational research designs not establish causality, and what is a "third variable" in this context?
- What are the two essential characteristics that make a study "experimental"?
- Describe three alternative hypotheses that threaten internal validity and explain how a control group helps eliminate each.
- What is the difference between an ABA reversal design and an ABAB design in single-subject research, and which is preferred for ethical reasons?