π Lecture 6 β How Clinical Psychologists Became Involved in Treatment
π Overview: This lecture traces the historical evolution of clinical psychologists from their early exclusion from psychotherapy to becoming primary providers of mental health treatment. It covers key breakthroughs in psychoanalysis, the critical impact of World War II, the development of alternative therapeutic approaches, and the professional organization of clinical psychology as a distinct discipline.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the late 1800s shift from psychoses to treating neurotic patients, focusing on Charcot's work with hysteria and the Breuer-Freud collaboration leading to psychoanalysis. It then examines the early involvement of psychologists through the child guidance movement and play therapy, followed by the transformative role of World War II in opening treatment roles for psychologists through the Veterans' Administration. The lecture covers alternative approaches including Rogers' humanistic therapy, behavioral approaches based on conditioning, and cognitive-behavioral integration. It concludes with the development of prevention programs, professional regulation through APA and its splits, and the formation of APS.
π Lecture Summary
The Shift from Classification to Treatment
During 1850-1890, psychologists like Kraepelin focused on classifying psychoses. By the late 1800s, attention shifted to treating neurotic patients using suggestion and hypnosis. Jean Charcot, though a neurologist, used a psychosocial approach to explain hysteria. This period saw the collaboration of Josef Breuer and Sigmund Freud, beginning with Breuer's treatment of "Anna O" in the early 1880s.
π Definition β Hysteria: A psychological disorder characterized by physical symptoms (paralysis, blindness, seizures) without organic cause, believed to be rooted in unconscious psychological conflicts.
Anna O's treatment led to theoretical breakthroughs. Breuer and Freud published Studies on Hysteria in 1895, which served as the launching pad for Psychoanalysisβthe single most influential theoretical and treatment development in the history of psychiatry and clinical psychology.
π Example: Anna O, a young woman diagnosed with hysteria, exhibited symptoms including paralysis and speech difficulties. Through talking about her symptoms (the "talking cure"), she found relief. This case demonstrated that psychological symptoms could be alleviated through verbal expression and exploration of unconscious material.
In 1900, Freud published The Interpretation of Dreams, leading to mainstream acceptance of the psychoanalytic perspective. The 1906 Clark University conference, where Freud lectured American professionals, stimulated acceptance of his theories in the United States.
π‘ Why this matters: The psychoanalytic movement initially placed treatment of psychopathology firmly within psychiatry (medicine), creating barriers that clinical psychologists had to overcome to gain therapeutic roles.
Early Involvement through Child Guidance
The first avenue for psychologists to enter treatment was the child guidance movement. In 1909, William Healy established a child guidance clinic in Chicago staffed by psychiatrists, social workers, and psychologists. They treated children and adolescents for what are now labeled Conduct Disorder and Oppositional Defiant Disorder.
Play therapy emerged as a second trend, based on Freud's psychoanalytic theory. Psychologists encouraged children to engage in play and offered psychoanalytic interpretations of their play activities.
Group therapy gained attention in the early 1930s through the work of J. L. Moreno and S. R. Slavson. Frederick Allen (1934) described "passive therapy" as another precursor to modern approaches.
World War II: Clinical Psychology and the Treatment of Psychopathology
World War II was critical in expanding psychologists' roles. The war renewed the need for psychologists to evaluate thousands of enlistees through psychological testing. More importantly, psychologists identified a new syndrome: "shell shock" or "battle fatigue", now known as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD).
π Definition β PTSD: A disorder characterized by high levels of anxious arousal, recurrent and persistent intrusive thoughts and emotions pertaining to a trauma, and persistent efforts to avoid all reminders and thoughts about the traumatic event.
Observations showed that soldiers treated immediately in the context of battle recovered better than those whose treatment was delayed in hospitals removed from the battlefield. The armed services faced a critical shortage of trained mental health personnelβmedical personnel (including psychiatrists) were needed for physical casualties. Psychologists were called upon because they had the most representative set of skills needed for the task.
The National Council of Women Psychologists
During WWII, most clinical psychologists were men. Women psychologists were excluded from APA's war mobilization effort. In response, women founded the National Council of Women Psychologists to work on community problems, reducing war stress on civilians and advising women working outside their homes for the first time. This organization exemplified the struggles of women to achieve equal status with men in clinical psychology.
The Veterans' Administration
The end of World War II brought dramatic changes. The VA faced caring for over 40,000 psychologically wounded veterans with too few psychiatrists available. The VA chose to draw on psychology as a new source of professionally trained mental health personnel.
At that time, total APA membership across all specializations was barely 4,000. The VA estimated 4,700 clinical psychologists were needed and invested enormous amounts to fund doctoral-level training. Consequently, while no formal clinical psychology university programs existed in 1946, by 1950 half of all PhDs in psychology were awarded in clinical psychology.
Alternative Approaches to Psychotherapy
Carl Rogers, a founder of humanistic psychology, was influential in moving psychotherapy out of medicine and psychoanalysis. While director of the Rochester Child Guidance Center, Rogers argued that trained clinical psychologists could perform as well as medically trained analysts.
π Key Publication: Rogers' 1942 book Counseling and Psychotherapy identified psychotherapy as legitimate for clinical psychologists and offered the first model not based on psychoanalytic theory.
The Behavioral Approach
Advances in learning and conditioning theory led to behaviorally oriented treatments. Psychiatrists and psychologists applied classical conditioning and operant conditioning models to explain and treat maladaptive behavior.
π Definition β Reciprocal Inhibition: Joseph Wolpe's (1958) concept that "neurotic" behaviors (anxiety disorders) are learned through conditioning and can be unlearned through a similar processβby pairing anxiety-provoking stimuli with incompatible responses (e.g., relaxation).
π Example: Early work by Watson, Raynor, and Jones demonstrated conditioning's role in developing fears. Wolpe applied these principles to treat phobias, obsessive-compulsive disorder, anxiety, and disruptive behavior in children.
In 1967, the Association for Advancement of Behavioral Therapy (AABT) was founded and remains a major professional organization for clinical psychologists.
The Cognitive-Behavioral Approach
The 1970s treatment focus shifted to changing thoughts, feelings, and expectations alongside overt behavior. Key figures included Albert Ellis (Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy), Aron Beck (cognitive treatments for depression), and Bandura (self-efficacy work). These led to integrating cognitive approaches with behavioral approaches.
Present Approaches
During the late 1970s and early 1980s, professionals sought to integrate the best methods of various approaches, emphasizing common factors in an Eclectic Approach.
The Bio-psycho-social approach emerged in the late 1900s, suggesting biological, psychological, and social aspects of health intimately influence each other. Psychologists must understand these multidimensional influences to treat and understand others.
Key psychotherapy research landmarks include:
- Rogers' (1942) early research on client-centered therapy
- Eysenck's (1952) critical evaluation of psychotherapy effectiveness
- Wolpe's (1958) behavioral methods for anxiety
- Rush, Beck, Kovacs & Hollon (1977): first evidence of cognitive therapy efficacy for depression
- Smith & Glass (1977): first use of meta-analysis to evaluate psychotherapy studies
- Lobitz & LoPiccolo (1972): first evidence behavioral methods could treat sexual dysfunction
- Comparisons of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy for depression and anxiety disorders
Clinical Psychologists' Involvement in Prevention
Treatment reduces the prevalence (existing cases) of disorders but cannot reduce the incidence (new cases). This recognition provided impetus for prevention efforts.
π Definition β Prevalence: The number of existing cases of a disorder in a population at a given time. π Definition β Incidence: The number of new cases of a disorder developing in a population over a specific period.
Key events moving prevention into mental health policy:
- Late 1950s: U.S. Joint Commission on Mental Illness and Health report
- 1963: President Kennedy's initiative for programs combating mental retardation and psychological disorders
- 1960s: Development of comprehensive community mental health centers
These initiatives highlighted the need to reduce new cases and addressed unequal access to mental health treatmentβindividuals of lower socioeconomic status have less access to mental health professionals. Prevention programs focus primarily on children, aiming to prevent aggressive behavior, conduct disorder, depression, and substance abuse.
The Development of Clinical Psychology as a Profession
As clinical psychologists acquired new skills, the profession needed to organize to monitor and regulate activities. The APA played a leading role in:
- Establishing ethical principles for psychology practice
- Accrediting training programs in clinical psychology
- Working with legislatures to support regulation of psychology practice
Clinical Psychology's Interactions with APA
In 1917, fifteen of 375 APA members broke off to form the American Association of Clinical Psychology (AACP). To prevent losing more members, APA established a special Clinical Section in 1919.
In the early 1930s, the New York State Psychological Association became the Association of Counseling Psychologists (ACP). In 1937, the clinical section disbanded from APA and joined ACP, renamed the American Association for Applied Psychology (AAAP).
This represented a significant split between scientific and applied psychology. In 1939, Carl Rogers discussed awarding a doctor of psychology (PsyD) degree rather than a PhD. The AAAP published a model certification act, a major factor leading to state licensing boards.
The split was addressed in the 1940s when APA changed membership standards, eliminating the requirement of two research publications beyond the dissertation for membership. APA bylaws were expanded to advance psychology as both a science and a profession. The Practice Directorate supports legislation, public education, and practicing psychologists.
Formation of the American Psychological Society (APS)
Tension between research and applied interests arose again in the 1980s when academic psychologists felt APA ignored psychological research. This led to the formation of the American Psychological Society (APS) in 1988. APS is committed to promoting scientific research in basic and applied psychology, providing an alternative for psychologists who worry APA has become a guild protecting practice without sufficient scientific basis.
The two groups function independently with separate governing bodies, conventions, and journals, though many scientifically oriented clinical psychologists belong to both.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that clinical psychologists' involvement in treatment was historically resisted by psychiatry but forced open by practical needsβfirst through child guidance clinics, then massively through World War II's psychological casualties and the VA's response. The evolution from psychoanalysis through behavioral, cognitive-behavioral, and bio-psycho-social approaches shows increasing professional sophistication. The tension between scientific and applied psychology shaped the profession's organization, leading to the split formation of APS alongside APA. The fundamental shift from treating existing disorders to preventing new cases marked an important expansion of clinical psychology's mission.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the "talking cure" and how did the case of Anna O contribute to the development of psychoanalysis?
- How did World War II specifically create opportunities for clinical psychologists to become treatment providers?
- Why did Carl Rogers's 1942 book Counseling and Psychotherapy represent a breakthrough for clinical psychologists?
- What is the difference between prevalence and incidence of psychological disorders, and why does this distinction matter for prevention?
- What led to the formation of the American Psychological Society (APS) in 1988, and how did it differ from APA?
π Lecture 7 β Models of Training in Clinical Psychology
π Overview: This lecture explores the major training models that have shaped clinical psychology as a profession. It traces the historical development from the Boulder Conference's scientist-practitioner model through alternative approaches like the Psy.D and clinical scientist models, explaining why these different training philosophies emerged and how they continue to influence the field today.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main training models in clinical psychology: the scientist-practitioner (PhD/Boulder) model with its rationale and criticisms, the practitioner-oriented (Psy.D/Vail) model including its rationale and evaluation, professional/freestanding schools and their challenges, the clinical scientist model emerging from McFall's "Manifesto," and combined professional-scientific training programs. The conclusion ties these models to market forces and future trends in the profession.
π Lecture Summary
Background to the PhD Training Model: The Boulder Conference
As doctoral training expanded after World War II, the American Psychological Association (APA) established accreditation criteria for course curricula, research training, qualifying examinations, and clinical training. Carl Rogers appointed David Shakow to formulate a training model. Shakow recommended that training should produce professionals equipped to conduct research, assessment, and psychotherapy over four years at the PhD (doctoral) level, including course work, research, and supervised clinical practicum experiences. He proposed the third year should consist of a full-time internship in a clinical setting followed by a final year devoted to doctoral dissertation research. Shakow also recommended discontinuing master's-level training in clinical psychology.
The landmark Boulder Conference in Boulder, Colorado in 1949 formulated the "scientist-practitioner" model, also called the Boulder model. The recommendation was that students should be trained as psychologists first and practitioners second β skilled in both the science and application of psychological knowledge. This two-pronged approach has set standards for training for over 50 years.
1. The Scientist-Practitioner (PhD) Training Model
The scientist-practitioner model is represented in PhD clinical psychology programs. Students develop skills as both psychological researchers and practicing psychologists. While the balance is rarely exactly 50-50, all Boulder Model programs share a commitment to relative balance between science and application. These programs are housed mostly in university-based psychology departments. Students complete course work in basic areas of psychology and specialized clinical seminars. They must carry out at least two pieces of original research: a master's thesis (or equivalent) and a doctoral dissertation. Students must also complete a specific number of hours of clinical practice training (typically assessment and psychotherapy) followed by a full-year, 40-hours-per-week internship under licensed supervisors. A typical Boulder Model program requires four years at university followed by an internship in the fifth year.
The Rationale for the Scientist-Practitioner Model β The rationale is that regardless of career path, clinical psychologists need both skill sets. For researchers, experience with clinically significant problems keeps them grounded in real issues rather than selecting research questions based on convenience or fashion. For practitioners, training in research methods enables them to be educated consumers of research advances throughout their careers. π‘ Why this matters: This integration ensures clinical practice remains informed by scientific evidence.
Criticism of Scientist-Practitioner Model β Critics argue this model is unrealistic because most practicing clinicians do not engage in research due to lack of time or interest, making research training seem meaningless. Drabman (1985) described students arriving at internships without adequate knowledge of administering, scoring, and interpreting psychological tests, showing surprising lack of experience with clinical populations. Despite criticisms, a majority of clinical programs still subscribe to this model in varying degrees.
π Definition β Scientist-Practitioner Model: A training model requiring students to develop skills as both psychological researchers and practicing psychologists, with a balanced emphasis on science and application.
Background to Psy.D Training Model: The Vail Conference
The wisdom of training clinical psychologists as both competent scientists and practitioners was questioned vigorously after Boulder. In 1968, Donald Peterson presented a model for the first professionally oriented clinical psychology training program at the University of Illinois. This culminated in the Vail Conference in Vail, Colorado in 1973. At this meeting, the Boulder model was reaffirmed, but a second professional model of training also emerged with significant support. The professional model validated the importance of knowledge of psychological research but deemphasized training in research skills. Programs could now receive APA accreditation by following either model. The number of Psy.D (Doctor of Psychology) degree programs grew rapidly, mostly in freestanding professional schools independent of universities. This contributed to widening the gap between practicing clinicians and researchers. The Psy.D program is also called the "Practitioner-oriented Model of Training."
2. Psy.D Training Model
Psy.D programs differ from PhD programs in the balance of training devoted to research versus clinical practice. Most exist in freestanding professional schools. Relatively little emphasis is given to clinical research and more training is devoted to assessment and intervention skills. While students may conduct original clinical research for their dissertation, Psy.D programs allow alternatives such as a literature review or detailed case study. The first program was developed at the University of Illinois in 1968. Psy.D programs are not substantially different from PhD programs during the first two years. The real divergence begins in the third year with increasing experience in therapeutic practice and assessment. The fourth year continues clinical emphasis with internship assignments. More recently, Psy.D programs have moved toward compressing formal course work into the first year and expanding clinical experience through five-year practices.
The Rationale Behind Practitioner-Oriented (Psy.D) Model β First, there is a large body of knowledge and skills needed to become a competent clinician, requiring more time than can be devoted in a program emphasizing both research and practice. Second, because most clinical psychologists do not conduct research, they need relatively less research training. Proponents contend it is no longer possible to acquire the necessary foundation of both clinical and research skills in four to five years of doctoral training.
Evaluation of Psy.D Model β Researchers such as Peterson, Eaton, Levine and Snepp (1982) hold that Psy.D practitioners are more satisfied with their graduate training and careers than traditionally trained clinicians. They encounter few problems becoming licensed and report the Psy.D degree is an advantage in competing for clinical positions. However, finding academic jobs is difficult, and PhD graduates engage in scholarly activities more often than Psy.D graduates.
π Definition β Psy.D (Doctor of Psychology): A doctoral degree in clinical psychology emphasizing clinical practice over research training, allowing alternatives to original research for dissertation requirements.
3. Professional Schools
Professional schools represent an even more radical innovation. Many have no affiliation with universities β they are autonomous with their own financial and organizational framework, called "freestanding" schools. Most offer the Psy.D degree and emphasize clinical functions with little or no research orientation. Faculty are chiefly clinical in orientation, providing better role models for students. The first such freestanding school was the California School of Professional Psychology, founded by the California State Psychological Association. By 1993, almost half (49.9%) of doctorates in clinical psychology were awarded by professional schools, which tend to admit far more students than traditional university-based programs.
Evaluation of Freestanding Schools β Their greatest problem is stability of funding. Many depend on tuition as their chief source of funds, which does not generate enough money for financial security. They often depend heavily on part-time faculty whose major employment is elsewhere, making it difficult for students to have sustained contact with professors. Although some professional schools are fully APA-accredited, this is the exception rather than the rule. Recent training conferences recommend that all doctorate programs be at or affiliated with regionally accredited universities.
4. Clinical Scientist Model
Over the past decade, empirically oriented clinical psychologists became concerned that clinical psychology is not well grounded in science. Many treatment methods have not been demonstrated effective in controlled clinical studies. Some empirical studies do not support continued use of these techniques, and assessment techniques not shown to be reliable, valid, and leading to positive treatment outcomes have been called into question.
The "Call to Action" for Clinical Scientists β This appeared in 1991 in the "Manifesto for a Science of Clinical Psychology" by McFall (1991) . The manifesto argued three key points: (1) Scientific clinical psychology is the only legitimate and acceptable form of clinical psychology. (2) Psychological services should not be administered to the public (except under strict experimental control) until: (a) the exact nature of the service is described clearly, (b) claimed benefits are stated explicitly, (c) claimed benefits are validated scientifically, and (d) possible negative side effects outweighing benefits are ruled out empirically. (3) The primary objective of doctoral training must be to produce the most competent clinical scientist possible. Like-minded psychologists were urged to integrate scientific principles into clinical work, differentiate scientifically valid techniques from pseudoscientific ones, and focus graduate training on producing "clinical scientists" β individuals who think and function as scientists in every professional setting.
Outcome of the "Manifesto" β One outgrowth is the Academy of Psychological Clinical Science, consisting of graduate programs committed to training in empirical research methods integrated with clinical training. The academy is affiliated with the American Psychological Society (APS) and by 1999 included 43 member programs. Its primary goals include: fostering training for careers in clinical science research, advancing clinical science research and theory, developing resources for training and careers, applying clinical science to human problems, and disseminating clinical science to policy-making groups, practitioners, and consumers.
Evaluation of the Clinical Scientist Model β A network of graduate programs adhering to this model has developed, sharing ideas, resources, and training innovations. They collaborate on increasing grant funding, addressing state licensing requirements, and increasing visibility in undergraduate education. The ultimate success of this model remains to be seen.
π Definition β Clinical Scientist Model: A training model emphasizing that clinical psychology must be grounded in scientific evidence, producing professionals who function as scientists in all aspects of their work.
5. Combined Professional-Scientific Training Programs
This final alternative training model involves a combined specialty in counseling, clinical, and school psychology. As outlined by Beutler and Fisher (1994) , this model assumes: (1) These specialties share core areas of knowledge, and (2) The actual practices of graduates from each specialty are quite similar. The curriculum focuses on core areas within psychology and exposes students to each subspecialty.
Evaluation of Combined Professional-Scientific Programs β The model emphasizes breadth rather than depth of psychological knowledge, which can also be seen as a potential weakness. Graduates may not develop a specific subspecialty or area of expertise by the end of doctoral training. This model appears better suited for future practitioners than for future academicians or clinical scientists. By the end of 1998, there were nine APA-accredited programs in combined professional-scientific psychology, one offering a Psy.D degree.
Conclusion
The changes in graduate training over the past 30 years have mirrored the marketplace for clinical psychologists. Starting in the mid-1960s, a shift occurred from university-based academic jobs to private practice jobs. Complaints about limitations of the scientist-practitioner model surfaced, focusing on perceived inadequacy of training for future practitioners. Out of the Vail Training Conference in 1973 came explicit endorsement of alternative training models. Several recent trends affect viability: (1) There may be an oversupply of practice-oriented psychologists, which could affect internship placement β programs training practitioners (professional schools, Psy.D programs) will likely feel this effect most. (2) The managed health care revolution will affect demand and curriculum, with more emphasis on empirically supported brief interventions and focal assessment. (3) There may be an undersupply of academic and research-oriented clinical psychologists, potentially benefiting scientist-practitioner and clinical scientist programs.
β Key Takeaways
The Boulder Conference established the scientist-practitioner (PhD) model as the foundational training approach, requiring balanced training in research and clinical practice. However, criticism that this model inadequately prepares practitioners led to the Vail Conference's endorsement of the practitioner-oriented Psy.D model, which emphasizes clinical skills over research. Professional/freestanding schools have proliferated but face funding instability and accreditation challenges. The clinical scientist model emerged as a response to concerns about insufficient scientific grounding in practice, while combined programs integrate counseling, clinical, and school psychology. The future of training models will be shaped by market forces including managed care, internship availability, and the demand for empirically supported treatments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were the key recommendations of David Shakow's report regarding the structure of doctoral training in clinical psychology?
- What is the central difference between the Boulder model and the Vail model of training?
- Why do proponents of the Psy.D model argue that training in research skills should be de-emphasized?
- According to McFall's 1991 "Manifesto," what four criteria must psychological services satisfy before being administered to the public?
- What are the three recent trends that may affect the viability and success of different training models in clinical psychology?
π Lecture 8 β Current Issues in Clinical Psychology: Professional Regulation
π Overview: This lecture examines the professional regulation of clinical psychology, including certification and licensing standards designed to protect the public. It also explores major contemporary issues such as managed health care, prescription privileges, medical staff privileges, and the changing landscape of private practice that shape the profession today.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers professional regulation through certification and licensing, including typical requirements for licensure such as education, experience, examinations, and administrative requirements. It examines the American Board of Professional Psychology (ABPP) and the National Register of Health Service Providers. Major current issues include managed health care systems (HMOs and PPOs), their impact on clinical practice, prescription privileges for psychologists with supporting and opposing arguments, medical staff privileges in hospitals, and trends in private practice.
π Lecture Summary
PROFESSIONAL REGULATION
As clinical psychology grew and the number of practitioners multiplied, issues of professional competence began to arise. Professional regulation attempts to protect the public interest by developing explicit standards of competence for clinical psychologists. Many people have neither the time nor sophistication to distinguish the professional from the charlatan.
CERTIFICATION
Certification is a relatively weak form of regulation. It guarantees that people cannot call themselves "psychologists" while offering services to the public for a fee unless a state board of examiners has certified them. Certification often involves an examination but sometimes consists only of a review of training and professional experience.
π Definition β Certification: An attempt to protect the public by restricting the use of the title "psychologist." Its weakness is that it does not prevent anyone (from the poorly trained to outright impostors) from offering psychological services to the public. Certification laws were often the result of effective psychiatric lobbying of state legislatures, as many psychiatrists resisted any law recognizing psychotherapy by non-medical specialties.
LICENSING
Licensing is a stronger form of legislation than certification. It specifies the title "psychologist," the training required for licensure, and defines what specific professional activities may be offered to the public for a fee. Many state laws prevent evasions by defining psychotherapy and making it the province of psychiatry, clinical psychology, or other designated professions.
To strengthen oversight, the American Psychological Association developed a model act for licensure in 1987, with a revision by the American Association of State Psychology Boards (AASPB) in 1992. States use these guidelines to develop specific requirements.
π Summary of Typical Requirements for Licensure:
- Education: Doctoral degree from an APA-accredited program in professional psychology
- Experience: One to two years of supervised postdoctoral clinical experience
- Examinations: Must pass the Examination for Professional Practice in Psychology (EPPP); some states require oral or essay examinations
- Administrative Requirements: Citizenship or residency, age, evidence of good moral character
- Specialties: Licensure is generic, but psychologists must practice within their demonstrated competence
π‘ Why this matters: Most states examine educational background, require several years of supervised experience beyond the doctorate, and have continuing education requirements. Licensing boards are becoming increasingly restrictive, sometimes requiring specific courses and degrees from APA-approved programs.
ISSUES REGARDING LICENSING
Licensing and certification remain topics of intense professional interest. Some insist licensing standards should not be enforced until research demonstrates their utility and positive client outcomes. Others note certification and licensing are not valid measures of professional competence (Koocher, 1979). Some suggest licensing should ensure the public is not harmed rather than regulate competence levels (Danish & Smyer, 1981). Academic clinical psychologists are concerned that licensing requirements violate academic freedom because they dictate coursework offered by clinical psychology programs.
Despite these questions, the regulation of professional practice seems here to stay as the only method to protect the public from the poorly trained.
AMERICAN BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL PSYCHOLOGY (ABPP)
The American Board of Examiners in Professional Psychology was established in 1947, with its name shortened to American Board of Professional Psychology (ABPP) in 1968. ABPP offers certification of professional competence in behavioral psychology, clinical psychology, counseling psychology, family psychology, forensic psychology, health psychology, industrial and organizational psychology, school psychology, and clinical neuro-psychology.
Candidates must have five years' postdoctoral experience. An oral examination is administered, the candidate's handling of a case is observed, and records of previous cases are submitted. Requirements are more rigorous than state certification or licensing. The public can be assured such a clinician has submitted to scrutiny by a panel of peers.
NATIONAL REGISTER
In 1975, the first National Register of Health Service Providers in Psychology was published. The Register is a kind of self-certification, listing only practitioners who are licensed or certified in their own states and who submit their names for inclusion and pay to be listed. Along with increasing numbers of clinicians in private practice and recognition by insurance companies, the Register indicates the growing professionalism of clinical psychology.
ISSUES OF MANAGED HEALTH CARE
The character of health care changed dramatically during the 1980s and 1990s, with managed health care playing an increasingly greater role. Under managed systems, decisions about health care are regulated by companies that provide services or insurance companies that underwrite costs.
Traditionally, physicians treated patients as they saw fit, and medical insurance paid for whatever procedures doctors ordered. Lacking medical degrees, clinical psychologists could not be reimbursed by medical insurance. In the 1970s, psychologists lobbied for "freedom-of-choice" laws allowing licensed mental health professionals to be eligible for insurance reimbursement. By 1983, 40 of 50 states had passed such legislation.
Psychology enjoyed these advantages for 10 to 20 years. Typically, insurance reimbursed 50% to 80% of fees. However, health care costs rose dramatically, increasing about 2.7 times the rate of inflation. By 1995, health care costs exceeded one thousand billion dollars per year, accounting for about 15% of the gross national product (GNP). About 30% of all health care costs were for unnecessary, ineffective, inappropriate, or fraudulent procedures.
DIAGNOSIS-RELATED GROUPS (DRGs)
In 1983, Congress initiated a new method of paying hospitals with a fixed, predetermined fee for treating Medicare patients. Payment was determined by the patient diagnosis rather than actual treatment cost. Patients were categorized into Diagnosis-Related Groups (DRGs), and costs were calculated based on average cost per patient for a given diagnosis.
A hospital would receive a fixed fee for treating a patient with a particular diagnosis. If additional time or money was needed, monies were not available; if the patient could be treated for less, hospitals kept the difference. Following DRGs, Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs) and Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs) exploded onto the scene during the late 1980s and 1990s.
HEALTH MAINTENANCE ORGANIZATIONS (HMOS)
An HMO provides comprehensive health and mental health services within one organization. An employer pays a monthly fee; members obtain all care from the HMO for no additional cost or a small co-payment (e.g., $5 per visit). Patients have little choice regarding providers, who are paid a yearly salary rather than a fee per patient.
To be profitable, the HMO must control costs and minimize unnecessary services. Cummings (1995) reported that only 38 large HMOs "the size and efficiency of Kaiser-Permanente can treat 250 million Americans with only 290,000 physicians, half the present number, and with only 5% of the gross national product."
PREFERRED PROVIDER ORGANIZATIONS (PPOs)
A Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) is a compromise between traditional fee-for-service and HMO style. A PPO is a network of providers who agree to treat patients for discounted rates. Professionals choose to apply to be on the PPO network. Patients may contact any network provider, but some services still need authorization by the PPO before payment is guaranteed.
With HMOs and PPOs, spiraling health care costs have been better contained. Insurance companies now have an important vote in the types of services rendered.
EVALUATION OF HMOs & PPOs: IMPACTS OF MANAGED HEALTH CARE ON CLINICAL PRACTICE
Some argue managed health care changes do not save money, but rather shift monies from hospitals and providers to the managed-care insurance industry. Providers and patients are less satisfied with managed care than traditional fee-for-service. A survey of over 17,000 HMO patients revealed general dissatisfaction, while fee-for-service patients expressed the most satisfaction (Rubin et al., 1993).
A survey of over 14,000 APA members revealed 78% felt managed care had a negative impact on their work, with only 10.4% reporting a positive impact. Over 90% of ABPP diplomates felt managed care was negative and problematic. Another survey found 49% of 718 psychologists reported patients were negatively impacted by delayed or denied services, while 90% reported managed care reviewers interfered with appropriate treatment.
The mental health professional's discontent stems from several concerns:
First, all professional decisions must be authorized through utilization review by a representative of the insurance company, who is often not a licensed mental health professional.
Second, concerns about patient confidentiality have arisen, as details must be disclosed to obtain authorization for services.
Third, many psychologists feel overwhelmed by paperwork required for managed-care providers.
Fourth, many resent accepting significant fee reductions (e.g., from $100 to $65 per hour), with additional paperwork and telephone time not reimbursed.
Fifth, psychologists feel too few sessions are authorized (e.g., only 3 or 5 sessions).
Sixth, many resent having someone tell them how to treat patients, including urging group rather than individual therapy to save costs. In a capitation program, the insurance company pays a set fee (e.g., $250) for treatment no matter how many sessions are required, transferring risks from insurance to practitioner.
Some psychologists note managed care offers hidden benefits: it encourages clear thinking about cost-effective treatment, promotes interdisciplinary collaboration, and demands accountability, encouraging empirically validated and brief problem-focused treatments.
PRESCRIPTION PRIVILEGES FOR CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGISTS
A highly controversial issue is obtaining the legal ability to prescribe psychotropic medications. Historically, psychiatrists have been the only mental health professionals legally allowed to prescribe medication, yet any physician from any specialty may prescribe them. The majority (approximately 80%) of psychotropic medications are prescribed by general family practice or internal medicine physicians.
The American Psychological Association has supported efforts to develop a curriculum to train psychologists in psychopharmacology and lobby for prescription laws. During the past decades, there has been an explosion of research on medication effects for psychiatric problems.
OPPOSITION FROM OTHER PROFESSIONS
The American Medical Association and American Psychiatric Association are adamantly opposed. A survey of approximately 400 family practice physicians revealed strong opposition (Bell, Digman, & McKenna, 1995). They claim a medical degree is necessary to competently administer medications dealing with mind-body interactions.
OPPOSITION FROM WITHIN PSYCHOLOGY
Some psychologists argue prescription privileges would distract from traditional focus on non-biological interventions. Some argue psychology would lose its unique identity and become "junior psychiatrists" (DeNelsky, 1996). Concerns include sizable increases in malpractice insurance costs and increased influence of pharmaceutical companies.
PROS AND CONS OF PRESCRIPTION PRIVILEGES
PROS:
- Enable clinical psychologists to provide a wider variety of treatments and treat a wider range of clients
- Potential increase in efficiency and cost-effectiveness for patients needing both psychological treatment and medication
- Give clinical psychologists a competitive advantage in the health care marketplace
- View obtaining prescription privileges as a natural progression to becoming a "full-fledged" health care profession
CONS:
- May lead to de-emphasis of "psychological" forms of treatment because medications are often faster-acting
- May damage clinical psychology's relationship with psychiatry and general medicine, resulting in financially expensive lawsuits
- Would likely lead to increases in malpractice liability costs
MEDICAL STAFF PRIVILEGES
Historically, only physicians could treat patients independently in hospitals and serve on medical staff. Medical staff privileges allowed admitting and discharging patients and managing treatment plans. If a psychologist's patient required hospitalization, care was turned over to a physician. The psychologist could see the patient only as a visitor.
After about 10 years of legislative advocacy, approximately 16% of clinical psychologists have obtained full medical staff privileges. In 1978, legislation passed allowing psychologists to obtain medical staff privileges independently in California.
ISSUES IN PRIVATE PRACTICE
About 35% to 40% of clinical psychologists primarily work in solo or group private practice. Over two-thirds maintain at least some part-time private practice. This represents a 47% increase since 1973. However, experts predict this trend will reverse due to rapid changes in health care delivery and insurance reimbursement.
A survey of over 15,000 APA members revealed over 40% of practitioners licensed before 1980 worked in solo independent practice, compared with only about 30% of those licensed after 1990. Managed health care has made it increasingly difficult to develop and maintain independent practice. Managed-care companies look to master's-degree counselors as lower-cost alternatives.
CONCLUSION: CURRENT ISSUES IN CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY
Clinical psychology is changing and growing rapidly. On the positive side, psychology has contributed to better understanding of human behavior and ways to improve quality of life. Psychology has attained increasing independence through licensing laws, medical staff privileges, prescription privileges, and freedom of choice legislation.
However, the trend toward managed health care and constraints in funding for research and practice potentially threaten growth. Despite challenges, clinical psychology remains a fascinating endeavor with tremendous potential to help individuals and society.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture emphasizes that professional regulation through certification and licensing serves to protect the public, though certification is weaker as it only restricts the title "psychologist" while licensing also defines specific professional activities and requires doctoral degrees, supervised experience, and the EPPP examination. Managed health care through HMOs and PPOs has fundamentally transformed clinical practice by giving insurance companies control over treatment decisions, authorization, and session limits, creating significant dissatisfaction among practitioners who report negative impacts on patient care, confidentiality, and professional autonomy. The debate over prescription privileges remains highly contentious, with arguments focusing on expanding treatment options and serving underserved populations opposed by concerns about professional identity, medical liability, and the de-emphasis of psychological interventions. Medical staff privileges and private practice have both been significantly affected by managed care, with fewer psychologists able to maintain independent solo practices and increasing reliance on master's-level providers for cost containment. The field continues to evolve toward greater integration of biological and psychological perspectives while facing ongoing challenges from economic pressures, interprofessional conflicts, and the need to adapt to changing health care systems.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between certification and licensing in professional regulation?
- What are the five typical requirements for licensure as a clinical psychologist?
- How did Diagnosis-Related Groups (DRGs) change the payment system for health care services?
- List three concerns psychologists have about managed health care's impact on clinical practice.
- What are two arguments for and two arguments against prescription privileges for clinical psychologists?