π Lecture 15 β Conditioning
π Overview: This lecture examines learning theories in consumer behavior, specifically focusing on conditioning and its strategic marketing applications. It explains how consumers form associations between stimuli and responses, and how marketers can leverage these principles to build brand loyalty, encourage repeat purchases, and shape customer preferences through reinforcement strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers stimulus generalization and its implications, including me-too brands and private label brands. It then discusses family branding, umbrella branding, and line/form/category extensions. The concepts of stimulus generalization versus stimulus discrimination are explained, followed by instrumental learning theory and its strategic applications in marketing, including reinforcement schedules like fixed and variable ratio. Finally, massed versus distributed learning is introduced.
π Lecture Summary
Theories of learning (Continued)
Consumer behavior is considered a "black box" that marketers need to understand. Learning theories help marketers identify the correct targets for their strategies. The frequency and ratio of advertising create different impacts: first advertisement creates awareness, second creates relevance, and third creates benefits.
Stimuli generalization and its implications
Neo-Classical learning, also called Cognitive Associated Learning (CAL) , involves creating expectations. For example, a consumer has an unconditional response to a brand like Sony TV. When Sony launches another brand under the same umbrella name, the customer creates an expectation for the new brand based on Sony's good image, even without prior experience.
Two strategic implications are:
- Me too brands: brands that copy features like packaging, color, or design of the market leader. Consumers pick these products because of the same features.
- Private Label Brands: For example, WAL-MART develops private label brands like Wal-Mart Cola, with a design similar to brand leaders. This involves two concepts: Family Branding and Umbrella Branding.
Family Branding and Umbrella Branding
Procter & Gamble has different brands (HEAD & SHOULDER, PERT, WASH & GO) under the P&G umbrella. Unilever has brands like Dove, Lifebuoy, and Clear under one umbrella. Conversely, Sony uses the same brand name for all products (Sony TV, Sony Walkman, Sony Camera). Companies decide branding strategies based on stimulus.
π Definition β Line Extension: many brands sold under one brand name within the same category (e.g., bar soap, gel, liquid soap, shampoo). π Definition β Form Extension: changing the form of the same brand (e.g., small bottle, large size bottle). π Concept β Category Extension: moving from one product to other product categories using the same brand name. π Example: Sony TV β Sony Walkman β Sony Camera. Research suggests brands with more categories are more successful because people compare good features and generalize them to other brands.
π‘ Why this matters: This explains how Cognitive Associated Learning (CAL) depends on the status and level of stimulus, and why strong brand expectations are created through generalization.
Stimulus generalization
A stimulus is an action or procedure used to gain a response.
π Definition β Stimulus Generalization: when a stimulus is generalized to a similar stimulus and still gains the same response. π Example: In Pavlovian Theory, when a bell rings at a certain tone, a dog salivates. If the bell rings at a higher or lower tone, the dog may still salivate. The bell tone is a generalized stimulus.
Stimulus discrimination
π Definition β Stimulus Discrimination: when someone can discriminate between stimuli, which gradually weakens the effect of the stimulus on the required response. π Example: A dog is given increasingly different sounding bells from the original sound. The stimulus has a decreased effect, and eventually the dog will not give any response at all.
In marketing, the environment contains too much information, making segmentation more difficult. It is strategically important to bring a stimulus that is strategically discriminating.
Instrumental learning theory
In instrumental learning theory, stimulus and response come through trial and errors. The behavior is instrumental in creating a change in the environment, and that environmental change affects the likelihood of the behavior that produced it. These things come through reinforcement. Reinforcement can be positive or negative.
π Example of negative reinforcement: Life insurance ads showing the death of a person and the problems his family faces, followed by the message of life insurance.
Strategic Application of Instrumental Conditioning
Implications of instrumental learning are done through different processes.
- Example 1: In state-of-the-art beauty salons, extra services like coffee or tea are offered. These have no relationship with quality but help build strong relationships and increase customer retention and satisfaction.
- Example 2: Hotels offer amenities, welcome drinks, or fruit baskets to create relationships with customers through instrumental learning.
The response comes from trial and errors. Positive reinforcement occurs when a customer visits several shops and finds a jean that fits perfectly. This reinforces the customer to return to that shop, and the association becomes stronger by repetition. This repetition can reach EXTINCTION, where the relationship ends.
If a customer goes to another branded shop and cannot find the product of their choice, negative reinforcement starts, and the customer will not choose that product again. FORGETTING occurs when a customer liked a product but forgets the specific shop over time, which is forgotten reinforcement.
To cope with forgetting, marketers use techniques like free coupons and loyalty cards to retain customers.
π Research finding: American Customer Satisfaction Index research suggests it is wrong to assume that lower prices and more diverse product lines alone make customers satisfied. While prices should be equal or lower and choices should exist, there must also be a strong personal connection. This leads to Customer Relationship Marketing (CRM) .
π Definition β Fixed Ratio Reinforcement: reinforcement given at a set interval, e.g., every fourth purchase you receive a discount. π Example: Customers will try to enhance their purchase to four units to avail the discount opportunity.
π Definition β Variable Ratio Reinforcement: the customer is not told about the benefits they will get. π Example: Customers continue shopping, and all of a sudden, they receive gifts. This surprise reinforces the customer.
In some cases, reinforcement performed before behavior takes place: marketers put drastic discounts on a particular product while people are purchasing other products (e.g., Mother's Day sale, Father's Day sale).
Massed Vs. Distributed Learning
π Definition β Mass Learning: short-term, immediate learning, often done through competitive or penetration strategies. π Definition β Distributed Learning: a long-term learning process, done through extension or market development.
β Key Takeaways
A student must understand that consumer learning is driven by associations formed through conditioning, primarily through stimulus generalization and discrimination. Marketers use family and umbrella branding strategies to leverage positive brand expectations across product categories. Instrumental learning emphasizes that customer behavior is shaped by trial and error and reinforcementβpositive reinforcement builds loyalty while negative reinforcement leads to avoidance. Reinforcement schedules (fixed vs. variable ratio) are powerful CRM tools for retention. Finally, massed learning focuses on short-term impact, while distributed learning builds long-term customer relationships.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between stimulus generalization and stimulus discrimination, and give a marketing example of each?
- Explain line extension, form extension, and category extension with examples.
- How does negative reinforcement work in advertising, and what is one example from the lecture?
- What is the difference between fixed ratio and variable ratio reinforcement in customer relationship marketing?
- How does cognitive associated learning (CAL) explain consumer expectations for new products under an established brand name?
π Lecture 16 β Instrumental Learning
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of learning theories in consumer behavior, focusing on instrumental learning and its practical applications in marketing. It explores how consumers learn through observation, cognitive processing, and information retention, and covers strategic marketing models like the Ansoff Growth Matrix and various decision-making frameworks that marketers use to influence consumer behavior.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers CRM and brand loyalty dynamics, the Ansoff Growth Matrix with its four strategic quadrants, modeling or observational learning, cognitive learning theory and its step-by-step process, three specific decision-making models (promotional, decision-making, and innovation adoption), the basic information processing system including sensory memory and retention, and concludes with an introduction to involvement theory.
π Lecture Summary
Theories of learning (continues)
Researchers emphasize the importance of developing a relationship between product and consumer, making CRM (Customer Relationship Management) very significant. When a person is overly loyal to a product, they will be more dissatisfied if their expectation is not met at any time and will never return. This highlights the delicate balance needed in building consumer relationships.
ANSOFF GROWTH MATRIX
This model suggests how to create marketing strategies for specific purposes. On one axis is product and on the other is market. When there is an existing product in an existing market, this is called MARKET PENETRATION β here people use mass learning concepts and produce products in bulk. Marketing existing products into a new market is called MARKET DEVELOPMENT, which requires distributed advertising based on distributive learning. PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT means offering new products into the existing market, and DIVERSIFICATION means offering new products to a new market.
π Definition β Market Penetration: selling existing products in existing markets using mass learning and bulk production strategies. π Definition β Market Development: selling existing products to new markets using distributed advertising strategies. π Formula: Ansoff Matrix β Four strategic options based on product (existing/new) and market (existing/new) combinations.
Modeling or Observational Learning
Instead of trial and error, people watch others using a particular product and observe the responses they receive, then develop their own behavior based on that. This tendency is normally seen in children who watch their elders and prefer the products their elders use. The same concept applies to opinion leaders β individuals who belong to particular product categories whom others normally try to follow. For example, when buying a computer, people tend to go to someone more experienced about computers. In marketing, using models is an effective way of communicating messages and capturing customer behavior β for instance, a lady with shining hair using a specific shampoo will incline viewers to use that same shampoo, creating reinforcement.
π Definition β Observational Learning: learning by watching others' behavior and the responses they receive, then developing one's own behavior accordingly.
Cognitive Learning
Cognitive learning involves a person going through a process of thinking, following a number of steps. It focuses on thinking and problem-solving processes belonging to an individual. It is distinctive from cognitive associative learning. In cognitive learning, the following important concepts are involved: Problem Recognition, Information Gathering, Evaluation, Decision and Post Decision Evaluation. Two factors affect how information is gathered and processed: the Ability of Individual and the Complexity of the Information. For convenience products, there is no need for extensive information gathering, but for specialty products, information collection is necessary.
π Definition β Cognitive Learning: a learning process where individuals go through a thinking and problem-solving process involving multiple steps from problem recognition to post-decision evaluation.
1. Promotional Model
This model is explained by AIDA (Attention-Interest-Desire-Action), which is mostly used in advertising. A customer who has full knowledge about a product will lose interest if given low information. Therefore, marketers should provide full knowledge of the product.
π Definition β AIDA Model: a promotional framework where consumers move through Attention, Interest, Desire, and Action stages in response to advertising.
2. Decision Making Model
This model relates to Awareness which gradually moves to create Knowledge. The customer then starts making Evaluation and reaches the final stage called Purchase Decision.
3. Innovation Adoption Model
When linking the Product Development stage of Ansoff Model with the Innovation Adoption Model, marketers need to create Awareness which eventually creates Interest in customers. Thereafter, customers start Evaluating the product to decide if it fulfills their requirements. If satisfied, they purchase it as a Trial and then evaluate for future action called Post Trial Evaluation. If the trial is not reinforced, instrumental learning will not occur and the customer will lose interest.
π Definition β Innovation Adoption Model: a process where consumers move from awareness to interest, evaluation, trial, and post-trial evaluation when adopting new products.
Basic Processing System
Senses send information in small packets to the brain, where information is assembled to create a picture or scenario within a second. Information with no basis of interest is immediately passed on, but information of interest moves into the short term store where processing occurs. Without focus, information is gradually lost, but through Rehearsal (repetition), retention chances increase. Repeated information moves to long term memory and can stay for days, weeks, months, or years. Marketers create different cues related to their brand so these small cues form associations that become pictures or schemas. For example, the letter 'M' recalls McDonald's, recalling food and burgers. For retention, the degree of prior knowledge is important. Information can be retained Episodically (related to time series β e.g., recalling a specific Sunday brunch) or Semantically (stored conceptually β e.g., the experience of that brunch). Retrieval is another important concept β cues bring information from long term memory to short term memory. For marketing purposes, people are normally concerned with benefits not attributes β for example, saying a computer has "very high speed" is easier for customers to remember than "3 GHz."
π Definition β Rehearsal: the process of repeating information to increase retention and transfer it from short-term to long-term memory. π Definition β Schema: a mental framework or picture formed by associations and cues related to a brand or concept.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that learning theories in marketing include observational learning (watching others), cognitive learning (problem-solving steps), and instrumental learning (reinforcement). The Ansoff Growth Matrix provides four strategic options based on product and market combinations. The basic processing system involves sensory input moving to short-term memory, then through rehearsal to long-term memory, where information is stored either episodically or semantically. Marketers must use cues and focus on benefits (not attributes) to facilitate consumer retention and retrieval. The AIDA, Decision Making, and Innovation Adoption models provide specific frameworks for understanding and influencing consumer decision processes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four quadrants of the Ansoff Growth Matrix and what does each strategy involve?
- How does observational learning differ from cognitive learning in consumer behavior?
- What is the role of rehearsal in moving information from short-term to long-term memory?
- Explain the difference between episodic and semantic retention of information.
- What are the stages of the Innovation Adoption Model and what happens if trial is not reinforced?
π Lecture 17 β Theories (Contβd)
π Overview: This lecture explores the Involvement Theory of consumer behavior, explaining how the level of consumer involvement (time, energy, and interest) influences purchasing decisions. It examines the brain's hemispheric processing, routes to persuasion, and ethical considerations in advertising, particularly regarding children. Understanding these concepts helps marketers segment audiences and design effective communication strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Involvement Theory, including the roles of the left and right brain hemispheres in processing information, impulse buying, high and low involvement product strategies (central and peripheral routes to persuasion), methods for measuring involvement and consumer learning (recall, recognition, comprehension), behavioral measures of brand loyalty, and ethical issues in advertising, especially Conspicuous Consumption and advertising to children (CARU guidelines).
π Lecture Summary
Involvement Theory
Consumer involvement theory helps marketers understand the psychology and behavior of target consumers. Involvement refers to the time, energy, interest, and resources a customer spends searching, purchasing, and using a product. By understanding involvement, market segments can be developed. A key concept is impulse buying, which is the unplanned decision to buy a product, typically made at the point of purchase (e.g., seeing toffees in a store and buying them).
π Definition β Involvement: The time, energy, interest, and resources a customer spends in searching, purchasing, and using a product. π‘ Why this matters: Understanding involvement levels allows marketers to tailor message content and media selection for different segments.
The theory originates from clinical studies suggesting the brain has two hemispheres. The left hemisphere relates to information, analyzes things, and works in an informative framework. The right hemisphere is more intuitive, dealing with non-verbal, timeless, pictorial, and holistic information. The right hemisphere's processing is intuitive, emotional, and impulsive. For example, a television ad with little information will engage the right hemisphere and its heuristic behavioral systems. If a person consistently uses the left side of the brain, their activity is more related to information processing. Marketers must understand which hemisphere their target audience uses to choose appropriate media, messages, and content.
π Definition β Left Hemisphere: The part of the brain that analyzes information and works in an informative framework. π Definition β Right Hemisphere: The part of the brain that processes non-verbal, pictorial, and holistic information in an intuitive and emotional way.
Right Hemisphere
Research suggests the right hemisphere is more tuned to classical conditioning, which relates to the visual components of advertising, such as the model, background, and picture, not the product's detailed attributes. For a TV advertisement to trigger long-term memory, the marketer must decide which cue can be sent as a stimulus to draw the desired response. The cue must be familiar and easily recalled, leading to repurchase behavior.
Left Hemisphere
To involve the left side of the brain, logic dictates that complete information must be provided so people can analyze it and reach a conclusion. If a marketer wants to compete in a market with established products and repeat purchase behavior, they must force the target to get involved by showing distinctive, competitive advertising that challenges the brain. For example, if a product is relevant to an individual, a marketer can increase the perceived risk in the purchase behavior. For instance, if a marketer suggests that using the wrong shampoo could cause hair loss, this creates high risk and forces the person into a high involvement area, where they may start reading ingredients. If the marketer offers their product as an alternative, the probability of market breakthrough is high.
Finally, impulse buying is normally done by household consumers and is not found in business-to-business (B2B) marketing. In B2B systems, there is extensive or limited problem solving, and thus a naturally high level of involvement, requiring complete and comparative information.
π Definition β Perceived Risk: The consumer's belief that a wrong purchase decision could lead to negative consequences. π Example: A marketer suggests a wrong shampoo can cause hair loss, increasing perceived risk and forcing the consumer into high-involvement decision-making.
Routes to Persuasion
- High Involvement Products (Central route of persuasion): Marketers use a lot of data, such as rational arguments, attribute descriptions, and comparative technical information, to persuade the consumer.
- Low Involvement Products (Peripheral route of persuasion): This is promoted by giving pictorial advertisements without much information, focusing on the imagery side.
π Definition β Central Route to Persuasion: A persuasion strategy using rational arguments and detailed information, effective for high-involvement products. π Definition β Peripheral Route to Persuasion: A persuasion strategy using imagery and non-informational cues, effective for low-involvement products.
Measure of Involvement
Involvement can be measured through several frames:
- Behavioral frame
- Cognitive frame
- Product category
Involvement varies depending on the product category. For example, a person may be highly involved in buying a laptop but not a TV. When targeting high involvement products, marketers must check if consumers comprehend the information given. If the target customer cannot understand the information, it is a waste of time, effort, and money.
Some examples of testing questionnaires use a Likert scale (1 to 5). For example, "To me the product is: 1. Important ... 5. Unimportant".
How to measure overall consumer learning
Measuring consumer learning requires targeting three areas to understand if information has been learned:
- a. Recall: This is unaided memory. The consumer is asked to recall an ad or scenario to see if they can remember target items.
- b. Recognition: This is aided memory. The consumer is shown a cue and asked to recognize its origin.
- c. Understanding and Comprehension: This checks if the person understood what the seller was trying to say.
π Definition β Recall: Unaided memory of a stimulus (e.g., an ad). π Definition β Recognition: Aided memory, where a cue is presented to help identify a stimulus.
Behavioral Measures towards Brand
Attitudinal measures measure the feelings of customers towards a brand. Loyalty cannot be measured solely by watching customers buy the brand. It is measured using:
- Commitment: How committed a consumer is towards a specific brand.
- Propensity to buy: Asking which brand the consumer will buy for their next purchase.
- Repeat Purchase: How many times the consumer has bought a specific brand in the last few days.
If a customer is continuously purchasing a brand, it indicates brand loyalty.
π Definition β Brand Loyalty: A consumer's consistent preference for and repeat purchase of a specific brand over others.
Ethical Issues in Consumer Learning Process
It is critical to check the possible end results of advertising, especially in Children Advertising where children copy elders. An example is an ad where a person puts a biscuit into a toaster and beautiful things come out, suggesting happiness. As a result, a child put a biscuit in a toaster and, when nothing happened, used a spoon to retrieve it and was badly injured. This led to the establishment of the Children Advertising Review Unit (CARU) in the USA to observe what children perceive from advertisements.
Another example is a Cotton Candy Machine ad that showed a child operating the machine without guidance, implying children could do it alone. CARU told advertisers to change the ad and emphasized two points:
- Discourage ads that push children to force parents to buy.
- Do not give the impression that ownership of a product will give status among friends and peers.
An ethical issue among mature consumers is Conspicuous Consumption, which means buying things just to show others that you own them.
π Definition β Conspicuous Consumption: The act of buying and using products to display wealth or status to others. π Example: Buying an expensive luxury car primarily for the prestige and to impress others.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points for the exam are: (1) Involvement is the time, energy, and interest a consumer puts into a purchase, and it determines whether a central (high involvement, rational) or peripheral (low involvement, imagery-based) route to persuasion is used. (2) The left brain processes detailed information while the right brain is intuitive and visual; marketers must match their ad content and media to the target's brain hemisphere preference. (3) Impulse buying is an unplanned, low-involvement behavior common in household consumers but not B2B. (4) Consumer learning is measured through recall, recognition, and comprehension, while brand loyalty is measured via commitment, propensity to buy, and repeat purchase. (5) Ethical issues in advertising, like conspicuous consumption and the impact on children (overseen by CARU), must be carefully managed to avoid negative outcomes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the central route to persuasion, and for what type of product is it most effective?
- How does the right hemisphere of the brain process advertising information?
- What is the difference between "recall" and "recognition" in measuring consumer learning?
- How can a marketer increase the perceived risk of a previously low-involvement product to force higher involvement?
- What are the two key guidelines that CARU (Children Advertising Review Unit) emphasizes for advertising to children?
π Lecture 18 β Attitude
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between learning, perception, attitude, and behavior in consumer decision-making. It explains how attitudes are formed, how they influence purchasing behavior, and the key models that help marketers understand and predict consumer attitudes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and nature of attitudes, how they relate to perception and learning, the difference between perception and attitude, the elements that constitute an attitude, the conditions under which attitudes can change, and the four structural models of attitude including the Tri-Component, Multi-Attribute, Trying to Consume, and Attitude towards the Advertisement models.
π Lecture Summary
Learning Perception
Learning which takes place in the human being leads to the development of perceptions about a specific object. This is because consumers perceive reality. For example, a wrist watchβevery person looks at it from a different perspective. Some see it from the point of view of time, others perceive it as a jewelry item. Therefore, perception is totally an internalized frame. Actually, every individual is receiving stimuli and they try to organize this information to get a clear picture of the world. This perception depends on the information which marketers float and customers receive. If information is very high, it is possible that they may not get anything out of it, hence they may reject this information. On the other side, if information is very low, then they may not decide anything about the product due to limited information available.
π‘ Why this matters: Marketers must balance the amount of information they provideβtoo much overwhelms consumers, too little leaves them unable to decide.
Attitude Behavior
Attitude is a learned predisposition to behave in a consistently favorable or unfavorable way with respect to a given object. Attitude represents an individual's likeness or dislikes of something. Sometimes negative attitudes are developed and sometimes positive attitudes are formed in the mind of consumers. These are developed based on perceptions, and perceptions are developed from the learning process, which further leads to the development of behaviors. So the actual thing is behavior, behind which the process of attitudes is operated. For example, a person is going to purchase Colgate because he has a positive attitude towards this specific brand. This positive attitude created his behavior towards this specific brand due to which he purchases Colgate. Attitude was developed due to his perception towards the brand, and perception is developed from learning. Learning takes place from advertisement, word of mouth, opinion leaders, or from elder advice.
π Definition β Attitude: A learned predisposition to behave in a consistently favorable or unfavorable way with respect to a given object.
Another example is NIKE and REBOOK shoe companies who conduct research to gauge reactions to various styles, colors, sizes, etc., before moving to development so that they can know about the attitude of consumers towards their shoes.
Companies conduct market research to know about the attitudes of consumers before devising marketing strategies. For example, Coca-Cola changed its product. Coca-Cola was promoting that their product is the top favorite for its sweetness and excitement. PEPSI conducted some blind tests where they put drinks in different glasses and asked consumers to taste and tell which is the best product. It was observed that even the loyal customers of Coca-Cola selected the glass of PEPSI. Using these results, PEPSI attacked Coca-Cola, and as a result, Coca-Cola lost market share. To cover this loss, Coca-Cola created a new formula and developed its new drink. When consumers tasted this new formula, they liked it, so Coca-Cola started production based on the new formula. But the researchers found no specific impact on the market ratio because they observed negative reactions from loyal consumers who started boycotting the product. Coca-Cola concluded to re-launch the product with the same formula.
What happened was: on one side, there were perceptionsβpeople who thought PEPSI's taste was good still reacted and forced Coca-Cola to bring back the same product. This happened due to their attitude toward Coca-Cola, which was very consistent with buying behavior. So logic says that attitude is more relevant to buying behavior and perception can be different. For example, our perception is that Japanese products are of high quality, but we still use Pakistani products due to our behavior toward our own country. Perception can be developed through different factors like word of mouth or advertisement. A perception is built that Chinese goods are cheaper, but the attitude may be differentβthey may prefer to buy Japanese products. Similarly, people perceive that German cars are better in quality than Japanese cars. This is perception, but when actual time comes, they may not purchase a German car due to a sudden rise in prices or decrease in buying conditions, so their positive attitude may not transfer to buying behavior.
Change of Attitude
A person has a big car that carries a lot of stuff and is interested to take the car on a long trip. His attitude was very positive towards this usage, but if his interest changes towards a cross-country trip, his attitude may change towards a jeep on which he can easily drive to maximum points of tour. So his buying behavior changes toward a rugged Jeep from a car. Here we observe that attitude can change as it is time, situational, and context specific.
π‘ Why this matters: Attitudes are not permanent; they evolve with changing needs, situations, and contexts, which marketers must monitor continuously.
Elements of an Attitude
- Object: Attitude is always related to a specific objectβa specific thing.
- Attitude have consistency: It has to be consistent so that a conclusion can be drawnβwhether the attitude is positive or negative.
- Learned Predisposition: Attitude is learned predisposition because it already exists in the system and then it is learned from different sources.
- Attitudes Occur within Situations: Behaviors can be changed at any point of time, so attitude can also be situational. For example, a person is a loyal customer of Nokia and went to purchase a mobile, but at the point of purchase, he buys a China mobile because he has a low budget at that specific time. It does not mean his attitude toward Nokia is negative, but due to cost factor, his buying behavior shifted toward China mobile despite his positive attitude toward Nokia.
Structural Model of Attitude
We will look into four underlying dimensions of an attitude:
- Tri-Component Attitude Model
- Multi-Attribute Attitude Model
- Trying to Consume Model
- Attitude towards the Advertisement Model
1. Tri-Component Attitude Model
The Tri-Component model is made up of three potential parts: a. Affect b. Behavior c. Cognitive
a. Affect
It relates to feelings and emotions. It says that attitude can be framed through either the thinking component or the feeling component.
b. Behavior / Connation
Connation is actual behavior, which is also called the active elements of attitudes.
c. Cognitive
Cognition is thinking, or the thought component of an attitude. It is a person's mental representation of an object or stimulus.
π Definition β Tri-Component Attitude Model: A model of attitude consisting of three components: affect (feelings/emotions), behavior/connation (actual behavior), and cognition (thinking/mental representation).
β Key Takeaways
Attitude is a learned predisposition to behave consistently favorably or unfavorably toward an object, and it is built upon perceptions that come from learning. Perception and attitude can differβa consumer may perceive a product as superior but still not purchase it due to situational factors, budget constraints, or loyalty to local brands. Attitudes have four key elements: they relate to a specific object, have consistency, are learned predispositions, and occur within situations. The Tri-Component Attitude Model explains attitude through three parts: affect (feelings), behavior (action), and cognition (thinking). Understanding attitudes is critical for marketers because attitudes directly influence buying behavior, and they can change over time based on context and new experiences.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of attitude as taught in this lecture, and what are its four key elements?
- How does the PEPSI vs. Coca-Cola blind taste test example illustrate the difference between perception and attitude?
- What are the three components of the Tri-Component Attitude Model, and what does each represent?
- Why can a consumer's positive attitude toward a brand not always result in a purchase? Provide an example from the lecture.
- How can a person's attitude toward a product change over time, and what factors drive this change?
π Lecture 19 β COGNITION
π Overview: This lecture explores the structural models of attitude, focusing on how attitudes are formed and changed through cognitive, affective, and conative components. It covers the Tri-Component Attitude Model, Multi-Attribute Attitude Model, and strategies for influencing cognitive-based attitudes, all of which are crucial for understanding consumer behavior and designing effective marketing strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture examines four underlying dimensions of attitude: the Tri-Component Attitude Model (consisting of cognitive, affective, and conative components), methods for measuring attitude through these components, strategies for influencing cognitive-based attitudes (including change belief, shift importance, add belief, and change ideal situation), and an introduction to the Multi-Attribute Attitude Model (including attitude towards object model, attitude towards behavior model, and theory of reasoned action model).
π Lecture Summary
Structural Model of Attitude
The lecture introduces four underlying dimensions of an attitude that help us understand how consumers form and change their attitudes toward products and brands. These include the Tri-Component Attitude Model, Multi-Attribute Attitude Model, Trying to Consume Model, and Attitude towards the Advertisement Model.
i. Tri-Component Attitude Model
The Tri-Component Attitude Model is made up of three potential parts: Affect, Behavior, and Cognitive. These three components work together to form a complete attitude toward an object or stimulus.
d. Cognitive
Cognition is the thinking process or the method in which information is analyzed or interpreted, serving as the thought component of an attitude. It is a person's mental representation of an object or stimulus. The first factor that comes into play is attitudes formed because people tend to engage in thinking processes and evaluate information related to attributes. People with high involvement tend to have more demand for information. Marketers always try to generate favorable attitudes. This part guides thoughts which have an impact on attitude.
π Definition β Cognition: The thinking process or method in which information is analyzed or interpreted; the thought component of an attitude representing a person's mental representation of an object or stimulus.
e. Affective Component
The Affective Component is another way of measuring attitude by accessing what kind of feelings a brand can play in the mind of consumers. If feelings are positive, it creates a better attitude toward the brand. This component relates to feelings and emotions. It says that attitude can be framed through either the thinking component or the feeling component. If feelings can be measured, attitude can be easily measured.
π Definition β Affective Component: The component of attitude that relates to feelings and emotions, where attitude is formed based on the emotional response to an object or stimulus.
f. Connation Framework
Conative framework refers to action or behavior that suggests what one's attitude is. It talks about predictions about the futureβwhether a consumer will buy in the future or not, and whether they will recommend the brand to friends and family members. Connation is actual behavior, also called the active element of attitudes.
π Definition β Connation: The actual behavior component of attitude, also called the active element of attitudes, which predicts future actions such as purchase intention and recommendations.
Measuring attitude through tri-component
Attitude can be measured through the tri-components by using specific questions on a Likert scale. For example, with Old Spice aftershave lotion, a cognitive component question might be: "Is it refreshing?" measured from "Refreshing" to "Not Refreshing" on a 5-point scale. This allows marketers to easily judge consumer feelings about a specific brand.
a. Affective Component
Emotions and feelings act as moderators to positive or negative attitudes and may be recalled later. For example, measuring feelings toward Old Spice using a 5-point Likert scale with items like: Relaxed, Tight, Smooth, Clean, Refreshed, Younger, Revived, Renewedβwhere agreement indicates positive attitude.
b. Connation
Connation can be measured by asking about future behaviorβwhether a consumer will prescribe the product to friends, which suggests positive attitude. It is measured through likelihood or tendency. For example: "Which statement describes the chance that you will buy Old Spice aftershave lotion next time?" with options: 1. I definitely will buy, 2. I probably will buy, 3. I am uncertain, 4. I probably will not buy, 5. I definitely will not buy.
π‘ Why this matters: This buying scale reflects how consumers will behave in the future, allowing marketers to predict and influence purchase decisions.
Attitude can be changed by choosing any one of the three factors. To bring change through cognition, information must significantly change the knowledge frame of consumers. The particular piece of knowledge that doesn't exist in the mind of consumers would be sufficient to bring change in behavior.
Influencing Cognitive Based Attitudes
To influence cognitive-based attitudes, marketers need to look into four specific aspects of cognition: Change Belief, Shift Importance of particular attribute, Add Belief, and Change ideal situation.
a. Change Belief
Belief can be changed by providing new information. For example, people used to believe that pure ghee and pure butter are good for health. However, research found that other oils are better. This represents a belief change.
b. Add Belief
For example, a paper or kitchen towel used for cleaning surfaces or drying hands. A person may add a belief that a paper towel is also sanitized, meaning it will also kill bacteria. Adding this kind of belief, when projected effectively, creates positive attitude toward buying that brand.
f. Change ideal situation
For example, an ad for UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply) used an acid battery that normally brings fuels. Although it's a good battery, suggesting a sealed battery for the same purpose would be a better choice. Here, a new idea is suggested that can also protect the environment and fulfill other purposes along with the existing need.
These strategies are necessary to understand how attitudes can be changed.
B. Multi Attribute Model
The Multi-Attribute Model includes many models that look at consumer perceptions as they help form or influence attitude formation. There are more than one model, including: 1. Attitude towards object model, 2. Attitude towards behavior model, 3. Theory of Reasoned Action model.
1. Attitude towards object model
This model is more related to the cognitive model. It uses specific attributes with semantic differentials. For example, measuring the cognitive component of Diet Coke with questions like: Strong taste β Mild taste, Low Priced β High Priced, Caffeine free β High Caffeine, Distinctive taste β Similar taste. Measuring instruments include: "The last soft drink I consumed was...", "I usually drink... soft drink", "What is the likelihood that you will buy Diet Coke?"
2. Theory of Reasoned Action model
The Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) was proposed by Ajzen and Fishbein (1975 & 1980) and has three general components: behavioral intention (BI), attitude (A), and subjective norm (SN). This theory suggests that a person's behavioral intention depends on the person's attitude about the behavior and subjective norms (BI = A + SN). If a person intends to exhibit a behavior, it is likely that the person will do it. This theory is very important in consumer behavior.
π Formula: BI = A + SN β Behavioral Intention equals Attitude plus Subjective Norm
π Definition β Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA): A theory proposed by Ajzen and Fishbein suggesting that a person's behavioral intention depends on their attitude about the behavior and subjective norms.
β Key Takeaways
The Tri-Component Attitude Model consists of cognitive (thinking), affective (feeling), and conative (behavior) components, all of which can be measured using Likert scales and semantic differentials. Attitude can be changed through cognition by changing beliefs, adding beliefs, shifting importance of attributes, or changing ideal situations. The Multi-Attribute Model includes the attitude towards object model and the theory of reasoned action, where behavioral intention equals attitude plus subjective norm. Understanding these models is essential for predicting consumer behavior and designing effective marketing strategies.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of the Tri-Component Attitude Model, and how do they differ?
- How can attitude be measured through the affective component using a Likert scale?
- What are the four strategies for influencing cognitive-based attitudes?
- What is the formula for the Theory of Reasoned Action, and what do each of its components represent?
- How does the "change ideal situation" strategy work to change consumer attitudes?