π Lecture 20 β Attitude Formation
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of attitude models in consumer behavior, focusing on the Multi-Attribute Attitude Model, the Trying to Consume Model, and the Attitude towards the Ad Model. It then explains how attitudes are formed through cognitive frameworks, experience, and stimulus generalization, concluding with strategies for developing and communicating positioning and changing negative attitudes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Multi-Attribute Attitude Model and its connection to the Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA), including demographic, purchase preference, benefit perception, and consumer lifestyle influences on online shopping behavior. It then examines the Trying to Consume Model, the Attitude towards the Ad Model, and the three key methods of attitude formation: cognitive framework, experience, and stimulus generalization. Finally, it discusses developing positioning strategy (including niche marketing, realism in media), and four key motivational functions for changing attitudes: knowledge, value expressive, utilitarian, and ego defensive functions.
π Lecture Summary
Attitude Formation
As we have been discussing the underlying dimensions of an attitude:
- Tri-Component Attitude Model
- Multi-Attribute Attitude Model
- Trying to Consume Model
- Attitude towards the Advertisement Model
And we have already discussed about the Tri-Component Attitude Model. Now we need to discuss other three frameworks.
2. Multi-Attribute Attitude Model
As we already discussed, the most important theory for this model is the Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA), proposed by Ajzen and Fishbein (1975 & 1980). This theory has three general components: behavioral intention (BI), attitude (A), and subjective norm (SN). The theory suggests that a person's behavioral intention depends on the person's attitude about the behavior and subjective norms (BI = A + SN). If a person intends to do a behavior, then it is likely that the person will do it.
A model is presented showing the impact of four factorsβdemographic, purchase preference, consumer lifestyles, and benefit perceptionβon online shopping behavior, where attitude plays the role of a mediating variable.
π Definition β Mediating Variable: a variable through which action takes place; an intermediate factor that explains the relationship between an independent variable and a dependent variable.
Demographic β Consumers from different demographics choose products according to their own needs, so different demographic backgrounds might lead to different attitudes towards brands.
Purchase Preferences β Preferences of every individual are different, depending on lifestyles, demographic factors, geographic factors, age, profession, and other factors that impact changing preferences. These different preferences lead to changing behaviors.
Benefit perception β If a person feels that the product will benefit him by shopping online, then he/she will obviously prefer to choose that.
Consumer Life style β The lifestyle of consumers is different, and every individual tries to choose the product matching his/her lifestyle.
Attitude towards Behavior β Once the attitude towards the product has been developed, the chances of purchasing that specific product become high. Once attitude is developed, behavior is developed, and once behavior is developed, the chances of buying become high.
The TRA model has two sections:
- Subjective aspect β the impact of people observing your behavior; your assumptions and feelings about how they will feel about your actions (belief about what another will think and motivation to comply with specific referent).
- Objective aspect β attitude toward the object model, which includes two factors: the outcome you are expecting (belief about outcome) and the feelings/evaluation of the outcome (evaluations of outcomes).
π Definition β Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA): a theory proposing that a person's behavioral intention depends on their attitude about the behavior and subjective norms, expressed as BI = A + SN.
π Example: "If I buy a certain product, how will it be beneficial to me? [objective aspect β outcome] and second point is how others will say about it [subjective aspect]."
π Formula: BI = A + SN β Behavioral Intention equals Attitude toward the behavior plus Subjective Norms.
3. Theory of Trying to Consume
This model tries to study the factors where you are not able to buy or consume the product towards which you have a positive attitude. This is more organizationally orientedβwhere you are often not in a position to buy, possibly due to unavailability of the product (e.g., a service center suggests you buy next week).
π Definition β Trying to Consume Model: a framework that examines situations where consumers have a positive attitude toward a product but are unable to purchase or consume it due to barriers like product unavailability.
4. Attitude towards the Ad Model
This model emphasizes that marketers always try to communicate to the customer using a medium (TV, radio, internet). It is different from the traditional concept of directly contacting the customerβhere we use a medium to communicate. The attitude created by the ad has a direct impact on consumers and their buying behavior. Many factors impact consumer senses to buy, including advertisements, message communicated, aesthetics, communication ways, and emotional appeals.
Attitude Formation
How are attitudes formed? There are three important methods:
a. Cognitive framework β This means having information about the product. The more information one has, the more chances of attitude development. In the concept of high and low involvement products, the attitude formed from intensive reading becomes stronger than one from low involvement.
b. Experience β Attitude β Experience with a product shapes attitude. A good experience leads to a positive attitude and repeat purchase.
π Example: "I needed medicine for a headache. I visited a pharmacy and demanded medicine 'A,' but the representative said it was not available but offered me 'B' which has the same function. I purchased 'B' and it fulfilled my requirementβso I had a good experience. Next time I feel pain in my head, I may demand the same medicine 'B' because of that good experience."
c. Generalization of stimulus β For example, offering a new product under an old and established brand name. The key question is whether the positive attitude toward the old brand can be generalized to the new product.
π Definition β Generalization of Stimulus: the process by which a response learned to one stimulus is transferred to a similar stimulus, such as extending a positive attitude from an existing brand to a new product under the same brand name.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding how attitudes are formed helps marketers design strategies to build positive attitudes from scratch or leverage existing brand equity.
Developing and Communicating a Positioning Strategy
Which positioning to Promote?
- If there is a similarity between the brandβs existing products and the new extension, then the attitude will be stronger in terms of positive or negative.
- The match between the image of existing brands products and the extension directly impacts attitude development.
Positioning: How many ideas to promote? Sometimes you face different problems in the positioning process:
- Under positioning β not enough differentiation
- Over positioning β too narrow or exaggerated claims
- Confused positioning β unclear or conflicting messages
Niche Marketing
Providing a product to a market that is much more specified or specialized.
π Example: Hush Puppies shoes are developed for specific people who are more concerned about comfort and style, creating a positive attitude towards these shoes.
Realism in Media
Media plays an important role in developing attitude, specifically electronic media. Marketers try to pass information on TV, Radio, Internet, and other forms of media to consumers to build their attitude. The more you interact with the brand on media, the more strongly it will be able to influence attitudes. The attitude of a low involved person may not be so strong, but a person with strong involvement has a strong position in developing attitudes.
If a negative attitude is created, what do marketers need to do to convert it into a positive attitude? Four key factors:
Changing the Key Motivational Functions
1. Knowledge Function β People like to know about things and about people before they come to a particular conclusion. This is a cognitive need or brand positioning. So the knowledge function tends to show that your brand is different from competitors.
π Definition β Knowledge Function: a motivational function where attitudes are formed to satisfy a cognitive need for information and understanding, helping consumers differentiate a brand from competitors.
2. Value Expressive Function β Attitudes express individuals' lifestyles and general value systems. Knowing attitudes can help marketers anticipate values and outlooks, and reflect these lifestyles and characteristics in their products.
π Definition β Value Expressive Function: a motivational function where attitudes serve to express an individual's core values, lifestyle, and self-concept.
3. Utilitarian Function β This is normally related to the attitude created when we have used a product and found it usefulβthat it had utility for usβcreating a positive attitude. Utility is tangible in nature, which is different from value.
π Example: "Tissue for drying handsβutility could be sanitized."
π Definition β Utilitarian Function: a motivational function where attitudes are based on the tangible, practical benefits or usefulness a product provides.
4. Ego Defensive Function β This will be discussed in the next lecture in more detail.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture presents four attitude models, with the Multi-Attribute Model grounded in the Theory of Reasoned Action (BI = A + SN). Attitudes are formed through cognitive frameworks (information), personal experience, and stimulus generalization from existing brands. Marketers must choose positioning strategies carefullyβavoiding under, over, or confused positioningβand can leverage niche marketing and media realism to shape attitudes. To change negative attitudes, marketers target four motivational functions: knowledge (cognitive need), value expressive (lifestyles), utilitarian (tangible benefits), and ego defensive (to be continued).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of the Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA), and what is the formula for behavioral intention?
- Explain the difference between the subjective and objective aspects of the TRA model as presented in the lecture.
- What are the four factors that influence online shopping behavior through the mediating variable of attitude?
- Describe the three methods of attitude formation: cognitive framework, experience, and generalization of stimulus.
- What are the four key motivational functions that can be changed to convert a negative attitude into a positive attitude?
π Lecture 21 β Consumer Learning Processes
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of attitude, focusing on how marketers can change consumer attitudes from negative to positive. It explores various strategies for attitude change, including the Elaboration Likelihood Model, and introduces the Cognitive Dissonance Theory, which explains how behavior can precede attitude formation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers multiple ways to change consumer attitudes, including associating with a group or personality, resolving conflicting attitudes, changing motivational factors (knowledge, value expressive, utilitarian, ego defensive functions), altering components of the multi-attribute model, changing beliefs about competitive brands, and adding attributes. It also introduces the Cognitive Dissonance Theory and consumer strategies to resolve post-purchase dissonance.
π Lecture Summary
Ways to change Attitude
Marketers are interested in changing negative attitudes to positive ones. Several strategies can be employed to achieve this attitude change.
a) Associate with a group or personality The assumption is that linking a product with a respected group or personality will create a positive attitude. For example, cause-related marketing ensures customers that a portion of their purchase price will be given to charity. This association directly impacts consumer attitude, making them prefer those products.
b) Resolving conflicting attitudes Conflicting attitudes often occur when a consumer faces a choice between two options with different pros and cons. For example, choosing between a conventional camera (low cost) and a digital camera (advanced graphics, easy to operate). Marketers need to recognize and help resolve these conflicts. A consumer might resolve it by buying the conventional camera now and planning to buy the digital camera later when it becomes cheaper.
c) Change motivational factors Motivation is a force that helps consumers achieve their objectives. It can be intrinsic (internal) or extrinsic (external). To change attitudes, marketers need to change factors directly related to motivation by altering key motivational functions.
Changing the Key Motivational Functions
5. Knowledge Function People like to know about things and people before forming a conclusion. This is a cognitive need or brand positioning. The knowledge function helps show that your brand is different from competitors.
π Definition β Knowledge Function: A motivational function where attitudes are formed based on a cognitive need to understand and categorize information, helping show brand differentiation.
6. Value Expressive Function Attitudes express individuals' lifestyles and general value systems. If marketers understand these value systems, change becomes easier. Knowing attitudes helps marketers anticipate values and outlooks, and reflect these lifestyles and characteristics in their products.
π Definition β Value Expressive Function: A motivational function where attitudes express an individual's core values, lifestyle, and self-concept.
7. Utilitarian Function This relates to attitudes created when a product is used and found to be useful (having utility). Utility is tangible and different from value. For example, a paper towel is useful for drying. If a competitor positions a paper towel with germ-killing ability, it can change consumer attitude from the original brand to the new one.
π Definition β Utilitarian Function: A motivational function where attitudes are formed based on a product's perceived usefulness and tangible benefits.
8. Ego Defensive Function Most people want to protect their self-image from inner doubts. They care whether products really suit them. Marketers bring functions and attributes into products to convince customers they will benefit from using them.
π Definition β Ego Defensive Function: A motivational function where attitudes protect the individual's self-image from inner doubts or external threats.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these four motivational functions allows marketers to tailor their communication strategies to target the specific psychological needs driving consumer attitudes.
d) Altering components of multi attribute model β related to the object Customers sometimes choose products based on different attributes. Marketers try to change an attribute that has been ignored by consumers but is considered important. They highlight this attribute to improve brand positioning, changing the relative evaluation of that attribute and creating brand salience.
π Definition β Brand Salience: The degree to which a brand is noticed or stands out in a purchase situation.
e) Change belief about competitive brand Marketers need to change customer beliefs from competitors' brands to their own, especially when competing brands become dominant in customers' minds. For example, an advertisement comparing Surf Excel with Ariel aims to change belief in favor of Surf Excel.
f) Adding an Attribute Adding an attribute that has been ignored or adding a technological improvement can change behavior. For example, highlighting that yogurt has more potassium than bananas adds a new attribute to yogurt, potentially changing purchase behavior.
Behavior Proceed or Follow Attitude
While attitude typically leads to behavior, sometimes behavior comes first. The Cognitive Dissonance Theory explains this phenomenon.
1. Cognitive Dissonance Theory
Cognitive Dissonance Theory (CDT) was given by Leon Festinger in 1956. It holds that conflicting thoughts or beliefs about an object create discomfort. For example, after purchasing a product, a consumer realizes other products could also fulfill the requirement, creating discomfort from conflicting beliefs.
π Definition β Cognitive Dissonance: The psychological discomfort experienced when a person holds two or more conflicting cognitions (thoughts, beliefs, or attitudes).
π Example: A consumer buys a product at a superstore but later realizes other products could have fulfilled their requirement. This creates discomfort because of conflicting beliefs about their purchase decision.
Strategies of Consumers to ignore the dissonance
- Rationalizes: Consumers try to rationalize their decision internally to reach a stable point.
- Seeks information: They try to find more information about the purchased product and competitor products.
- Tells Friends: If satisfied, they may start word-of-mouth promotion of the product.
- Seek out others: They try to find people who purchased similar products to learn more. This normally happens in durable product categories but can also occur with small goods.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are the multiple strategies for changing consumer attitudes, including associating with groups, resolving conflicts, and altering motivational functions (knowledge, value expressive, utilitarian, and ego defensive). Marketers can also change attitudes by altering multi-attribute model components, changing beliefs about competitive brands, or adding new attributes. Understanding the Cognitive Dissonance Theory is essential, as it explains how behavior can precede attitude, with consumers using rationalization, information seeking, word-of-mouth, and social comparison to resolve post-purchase discomfort.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four key motivational functions that can be changed to alter consumer attitudes?
- How does the Cognitive Dissonance Theory explain the relationship between behavior and attitude?
- What is the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in the context of attitude change?
- Name three strategies consumers use to resolve cognitive dissonance after a purchase.
- How can adding a new attribute to a product change consumer attitudes and behavior?
π Lecture 22 β Attribution
π Overview: This lecture explores attribution theory, which examines how individuals perceive the causes of success and failure, and how these perceptions influence subsequent behaviors and attitudes. It introduces key concepts like self-perception theory and persuasion techniques such as foot-in-the-door and door-in-the-face, and concludes with an introduction to communication models. Understanding attribution is vital for marketers aiming to shape positive consumer attitudes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers Attribution Theory and its three main factors: Self-Perception Theory, the Foot in the Door technique, and the Door in the Face technique. It then explains how to test attribution through steps like testing, consistency, consistency over time, and telling friends. Finally, it introduces the Communication Model, including its components: sender, receiver, message, medium, and feedback, distinguishing between verbal and non-verbal communication.
π Lecture Summary
Attribution Theory
Attribution theory is the βsubjective perception of causality, not necessarily reality, which influences outcome behaviorβ and focuses on an individualβs perceived causes of success and their direct and indirect effects on consequent behaviors (Cort et. al., 2007). For example, when deciding to donate money (like Zakat or Sadqa), we choose a charity like Edhi Welfare Trust. We attribute our action to Edhi because of certain factorsβwe rationalize that Edhi is doing a good job and will invest our money for the needy. This logic involves attributing our behavior to external factors (the charityβs reputation) rather than internal ones. There can be many factors in attribution theory.
π Definition β Attribution Theory: The subjective perception of causality, not necessarily reality, which influences outcome behavior.
a. Self Perception theory
Self Perception Theory was given by Baryl Bern and describes that people develop their attitudes by observing their behaviors. This theory contrasts with the view that attitudes come prior to behaviors; instead, it says that attitude is the resulting object of behaviors. For example, you purchase software to design Photoshop and share it with friends. You might come up with reasons to buy it like βI know the crux to draw a picture as I am an expert in this fieldββthis is an intrinsic/internal attribution. Or you might say βThe software is so good which resulted with good photosββthis is an external attribution. If a person realizes that things happen due to personal capabilities but also accepts that the software helped a lot, this behavior leads to the development of a positive attitude towards that object. π‘ Why this matters: For marketers, they should try to develop campaigns where customers start relating product attributes to themselves, leading to positive attitude development.
b. Foot in the Door technique
Let us explain this technique with an example. In America, there was a very rude chief executive who would not allow salesmen to talk with him for more than five minutes. He had a big project of USD 200 million, but it was difficult for any salesman to secure it. A company approached a retired salesman, Mr. Murphy, who agreed to meet the chief executive but asked for two things: (1) He would charge 5% value of the total contract as commission (2) Contractors would not ask anything he is doing. Mr. Murphy then flew to South Africa and purchased a butterfly for USD 20,000. He called the chief executive and asked to meet his son. The chief executive agreed and fixed a time. When Mr. Murphy reached the office, he saw the son was in a wheelchair. Mr. Murphy opened his briefcase, took out the butterfly, and asked the son, βIs it the same one on which you have written an article?β The son was surprised and accepted it. Mr. Murphy said he went to South Africa and brought this butterfly, then took it back and left. The chief executive was very surprised. His son insisted on buying the butterfly. The chief executive called Mr. Murphy back, who then put forward the contract (USD 200 million project) and asked him to sign. The chief executive signed without further discussion. He signed for two reasons: (1) How much the salesman was involved in his personal matters (2) If he could take the pain of going to South Africa for what his son was interested in, he would complete the project in the same and better manner. The technique Mr. Murphy used was Foot in the Door technique.
π Definition β Foot in the Door technique: A persuasion technique where a small initial request is made, and once agreed to, a larger request is made, leveraging the desire for consistency in behavior.
c. Door in the Face technique
Let us explain this by an example: A salesman went to a customer to offer a mobile. The customer asked the price, and the salesman said it is for Rs. 10,000. The customer replied, βOh! Itβs too costly.β Immediately, the salesman changed his offer and said he would give a memory card, a SIM, and Bluetooth for free. The customer will think the salesman is caring for him, so his attitude will become positive towards that mobile. Here, the salesman used the Door in the Face concept to attract the customer towards his product. These concepts tell us what attributes we can add to a product so that a positive attitude can be built. These are important concepts through which attribution takes place.
π Definition β Door in the Face technique: A persuasion technique where a large initial request is made (which is likely to be refused), followed by a smaller, more reasonable request, making the second request appear more appealing.
How to test attribution
Attribution can be tested through a number of steps: a. Test b. Consistency c. Consistency over time d. Telling to the friends
For example, you purchase a Grinner Machine used to round the edges of a table. When you start using the machine, you try to get the perceived attributesβmaking edges round. Using it one time may not create attribution that this machine is good enough. So, you will test the machine on 2 or 3 other tables, and if consistently same results come, you can say it has good attributes. The same machine would be useful for benches and other things. So you get the same result over a period of time. Finally, you talk to your friends that this specific machine is beneficial for rounding edges. All these steps come from the logic of attribution which creates our attitude towards that product.
Communication
Communication is a message from one person (sender) to another person (receiver), and the main thing which travels is the message which will be encoded. There are two main types of communication: verbal communication (oral, written) and non-verbal communication (gestures, postures, body language, facial expression). There are different components of communication, including the communication model:
- Sender β also called encoder
- Receiver β also called decoder
- Message
- Medium β how will the message flow? (face to face or through media)
- Feedback β also very important component
Communication Model: Sender β Message β Channel β Receiver β Feedback
π Definition β Communication: The process of transmitting a message from a sender to a receiver through a medium, with feedback as a critical component.
β Key Takeaways
Attribution theory is the subjective perception of causality that influences behavior, and it is tested through consistency and repeated use of a product. Self-perception theory states that attitudes develop from observing one's own behavior, not the other way aroundβa key insight for marketers to design campaigns that link product attributes to customer experience. The Foot in the Door and Door in the Face techniques are powerful persuasion strategies that leverage sequential requests to shape positive attitudes towards products. Finally, effective communication involves a sender encoding a message, transmitting it through a medium, and receiving feedback, with both verbal and non-verbal channels playing crucial roles in consumer interaction.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is attribution theory, and how does it differ from objective causality?
- Explain self-perception theory with an example from consumer behavior.
- Describe the Foot in the Door technique and the Door in the Face technique, giving one example for each.
- What steps are involved in testing attribution for a product like a Grinner Machine?
- List the five components of the communication model and explain their roles.