π Lecture 11 β PERCEPTION (CONTβD)
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of perception, a critical topic for marketers because it explains how consumers process stimuli in their environment. It covers the psychological dynamics of how consumers select, organize, and interpret information, and why understanding these processes is essential for effective marketing strategy. The lecture also explains key concepts like JND, subliminal information, selective perception, and interpretation biases that influence consumer decision-making.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture defines the core terms of perception including stimulus, JND (Just Noticeable Difference), and subliminal information. It then explains the dynamics of perception, the "black box" of consumer information processing, and the selection processes of selective attention, selective perception, selective interpretation/distortion, and blocking. The lecture covers organization of messages through figure/background, contrast, and grouping, and concludes with a detailed discussion of interpretation/distortion factors including physical appearance, stereotyping, first impressions, halo effect, and jumping to conclusions.
π Lecture Summary
Perception (Cont'd)
Perception is a very important topic because it tells marketers what consumers see around them. Before moving to further detail, marketers must be aware of the important terms used in the concept of perception.
Stimulus is something external that influences an activity. It is something received by the sensory receptors like ears, eyes, nose, mouth and skin which can create response. For example, if you put your hand on a hot plate, you will immediately withdraw it because you will sense the difference. Your reflex will help you do this. These concepts are normally linked with the methods of communications that marketers use for the promotion of products.
π Definition β Stimulus: something external that influences an activity, received by sensory receptors (ears, eyes, nose, mouth, skin) that can create a response. π Example: Putting your hand on a hot plate causes an immediate withdrawal reflex because you sense the temperature difference.
JND (Just Noticeable Difference) is the smallest detectable difference between a starting and secondary level of a particular sensory stimulus. When there are a lot of stimuli, people get used to them, so they do not notice the difference.
π Definition β JND (Just Noticeable Difference): the smallest detectable difference between a starting and secondary level of a particular sensory stimulus. π‘ Why this matters: Marketers must understand JND to know when a change in a product (e.g., price reduction, package redesign) is noticeable enough to influence consumer behavior, or when a change is small enough to go unnoticed (e.g., reducing product size while keeping price the same).
Subliminal Information refers to the tendency of people to notice things without being consciously aware that they are noticing. In our everyday activities, we notice different things but we are not aware about them. According to a study conducted at the National Institute of Mental Health in 1990, "Subliminal visual stimuli are words or pictures that are presented so as to be unidentifiable to the viewer's conscious perception." For example, images may be sparked in front of the eye too quickly for the conscious mind to catch or notice. Such stimuli can, however, exert an effect on judgment and behavior.
π Definition β Subliminal Information: words or pictures presented so as to be unidentifiable to the viewer's conscious perception, yet capable of influencing judgment and behavior. π Example: Images flashed in front of the eye too quickly for the conscious mind to notice can still affect a person's choices or reactions.
Dynamics of Perception β how does black box operate?
People receive information in blocks and then interpret the information in their own ways. For example, different people watching the same advertisement interpret the information in different ways. Advertisers float a lot of information about a product in advertisements, but consumers pick up that information which is relevant to them or of their interest and then perceive the product accordingly. Their sorting of this information normally surrounds nearby their needs. The information is sorted normally on the basis of their needs. If they feel that the product can satisfy their needs, then they will buy that product; otherwise, they will start looking for some other. People select those things more which they need more.
If we link this concept to previous lectures, marketers must understand needs on the very first stage and then make the segmentation accordingly. This will be the only way to impact the senses of consumers.
a. Selection of:
- Selective Attention
- Selective Perception
- Selective Interpretation / Distortion
- Blocking
- Selective Perception comes from the point that we need to isolate only that information which we like to have. This kind of work is done by our own sub-consciousness β we are trying to perceive a particular idea or message.
π Definition β Selective Perception: the process by which consumers isolate only the information they like or need, guided by their sub-consciousness.
- Selective Interpretation / Distortion refers to how consumers normally interpret information in their own way. They try to distort the information for their own benefits. For example, something that does not suit you, you want to block it off, but if the information is coming in again, then you will most probably interpret the information similarly according to your own value system. Sometimes you receive the message from external stimuli and you change/interpret the message according to your own value system. For example, marketers sent a written message; since people can't interact with the marketers, they will change the implications of the message to meet their own needs.
π Definition β Selective Interpretation / Distortion: when consumers change or interpret a message according to their own value system, often to meet their own needs. π Example: A marketer sends a written advertisement; since consumers cannot interact with the marketer, they reinterpret the message's implications to fit their personal needs.
b. Organization of message It is very important that the information which you receive be organized in such a way that it makes sense of what is around you. Organization of information means to collect the important information of your concern and put it into a box to use for the satisfaction of your needs. From the marketer's point of view, there are three important things that need to be considered:
-
Background / Figure: Figure is the peak point of attention that we want to draw. And background is the one through which we would like to stand against.
-
Contrast: Contrast is to make that picture stand out. For example, using different colors in an advertisement will attract customers more.
-
Grouping: It means how we are grouped together in a scene or a scenario.
π Definition β Figure: the peak point of attention that marketers want to draw in a message. π Definition β Background: the setting or context against which the figure stands. π Definition β Contrast: using differences (e.g., different colors) to make a picture or message stand out. π Definition β Grouping: how elements are arranged together in a scene or scenario to create meaning.
Interpretation / Distortion
Interpretation of the information is related to our own personal experiences. There are certain important factors in interpretation:
a. Physical Appearance Let us suppose a person went to Switzerland; he comes in and is traveling to the north. He will try to associate the same picture that he has seen to the one that he experienced in the past. This is because people tend to compare the characteristics of things with others. Since appearances are critical, we try to associate the features of products with others and then rate the products accordingly.
b. Stereotyping Stereotype is a belief about a specific social group or types of individuals. For example, you might have listened to someone passing a comment on another that he is looking like a manager. Why is the person associating the other with a manager? The reason is that manager becomes a stereotype, and anybody who fits into that framework, you will assume him as a manager. The same happens with advertisements. Let us take an example of ads of banks which show a man wearing a three-piece suit, carrying a bag, and going to the office. So actually they try to relate it to a manager, which is stereotyping.
π Definition β Stereotype: a belief about a specific social group or types of individuals, used to categorize people or things. π Example: Bank advertisements showing a man in a three-piece suit carrying a bag to the office β they stereotype him as a "manager."
c. First Impression (First impression is the last impression) This concept has strong implications in marketing. If you are able to impress the customers in the first stage, it will create a positive impression for all the time on the senses of consumers. So for marketers, it is very important to be very careful while designing marketing strategies.
d. Halo Effect Halo effect is a cognitive bias in which the perception of one trait is influenced by the perception of another trait of that person. We see one characteristic in an individual and on the basis of that we conclude the whole. It is difficult for a person to observe all the characteristics at a single point, so normally he picks up the important characteristic and generalizes it as a whole.
π Definition β Halo Effect: a cognitive bias where the perception of one trait influences the perception of another trait of that person, leading to a generalization based on a single characteristic. π Example: Seeing that a product is expensive (one trait) and concluding it must be high quality (another trait) without actual experience.
e. Jumping to conclusions Some people conclude things immediately without knowing the full information. For example, if a product has a high price, normally people consider it as a high-quality product even without experiencing it.
Since marketers' job is to satisfy the needs of customers, they have to go through all the steps necessary to reach this specific goal. Hence, they must be aware of all these concepts and then devise marketing strategies accordingly.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are the definitions and marketing implications of JND (Just Noticeable Difference), the smallest detectable difference between stimuli that determines whether consumers notice changes in products or prices. You must understand how selective perception, selective interpretation, and blocking filter consumer attention β people only process information relevant to their needs. The organization of messages through figure/background, contrast, and grouping is essential for effective advertising design. Finally, the five interpretation biases β physical appearance, stereotyping, first impressions, halo effect, and jumping to conclusions β directly influence how consumers form product perceptions and must be carefully considered in all marketing strategies.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is JND (Just Noticeable Difference) and why is it important for marketers when making changes to product packaging or pricing?
- Explain the difference between selective perception and selective interpretation/distortion. Give an example of each from a consumer's perspective.
- What are the three key elements of message organization from a marketer's point of view? Briefly describe each.
- Define the halo effect and provide a marketing example of how it influences consumer perception.
- Why is "first impression" considered critically important in marketing? What is the implication for marketers designing marketing strategies?
π Lecture 12 β Product Positioning
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of product positioning, which is how marketers attempt to place their products favorably in consumers' minds relative to competitors. It covers methods of positioning based on features and benefits, various positioning strategies, the importance of perceptual mapping, and the distinct challenges of positioning services versus physical products.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and significance of product positioning, methods of positioning through features or benefits, multi positioning and umbrella positioning strategies, re-positioning strategies, positioning of services, perceptual mapping, product quality dimensions including conformance and performance, service quality measurement, and factors influencing the perception of quality.
π Lecture Summary
Product Positioning
Positioning is a method by which a marketer tries to place his product in a favorable position among all the other products that are located and which provide same need specifying features. For example, soap is placed in a big retail shop; nearby there will be many other brands of soap but how your brand is being positioned, how has it been packaged is and how it looks like. There are two important points: one is that positioning is done by the marketers and second is perception that is related to what happened in the minds of the consumers. So unless there is a match between the positioning that marketer is suggesting and the way it is being perceived by the consumer β there will be gap. And this gap will create distractions which may lead to the failure of the product.
π‘ Why this matters: Positioning is not just about where the product sits on a shelf; it is about its place in the consumer's mind. A mismatch between intended and perceived positioning can cause the product to fail.
How a product is positioned?
Two areas are important to be considered: a. Offering a feature: For example, if we are selling an air conditioner, we can position it as βthis air conditioner can cool the room up to 16 ΒΊCβ. So this is the feature of our product which we are offering. b. Offering a benefit: The benefit in our above quoted example is that this air conditioner will provide you comfort. Important point to be noted here is that two products (of different manufacturers) can provide the same feature then how to differentiate it? So you can differentiate your product by providing unique benefit. Benefit can be one about which your target customer is aware or unaware. So you can create awareness to give him more satisfaction.
For example, Sting Energy Drink β they have positioned themselves as energy booster; Mountain dew positioned them as thrill. Another example in which the brand actually challenged competitors is of 7Up. While offering a feature they offered:
- itβs uncola
- never had it
- never will So its uncola stated that others are cola drinks and this one is the only providing uncola. Their never statement indicate that neither the uncola was before nor will it be in future. So 7up is directly hitting the competitors.
Another example is of Hertz which is a car rental company whose statement is no β itβs not that. So here they wanted to show that they are different from others and if any one wants to provide similar service, they can not provide. Hertz is considered as number one rental company. On the other side, its competitors are AVIS whose statement is βwe try harderβ. These examples show that the brands have focused on the features option and positioned themselves accordingly.
On the other side, is positioning on the basis of BENEFIT. Let us take an example of Maxwell House Coffee whose positioning statement is βgood to the last dropβ. They are trying to provide benefit to the consumers in terms of taste that remains till the last drop.
Multi Positioning Strategy
This strategy would suggest that in a number of segments, same product is positioned but in all of them with different positioning strategies. This strategy sometimes confuses the customers because it is difficult for them to differentiate. So marketers can use number of approaches. They can be direct one to one through websites, they can sell through retailers, and they can also sell through whole sellers. So being marketers, we must be careful in devising strategies as the strategy which is used for one segment may be different from that of the other.
Umbrella Positioning Strategy
This suggests that there is one overall brand and under that you can sell number of other brands. For example, Engro Group and under the umbrella of Engro Group, there are number of brand like Oplers, Omore and Engro fertilizer etc.
Re-Positioning Strategy
Sometimes marketers need to go for re-positioning strategy due to number of reasons:
- Taste/Sweetness
- Original position is a mistake: The first position which marketers took may not be successful. It means that they tried to position in the mind of consumers but due to any reason that failed. For example, you took a positioning strategy for general public but that was actually for Niche market. You tried to position your product for general public but it was actually suitable for niche market.
- For premium price: There is direct link in the minds of consumers regarding price and quality. and the price which they expect from the product. Two points are important here, among them one is if there is a reference point which is internal or external. So he will normally compare the referent point price with the actual price and will make the assumption accordingly.
Positioning Services
The positioning strategy for services are different then product strategies because services are totally intangible. So it is suggested that some tangibility should be created. When customers are consuming services, they do not look to the delivery point but they look for a point called Surrogate Cues. Cues mean what kind of indicators are telling about the service quality. For example, Doctor is providing services which are intangible. But marketers bring tangibility can be brought in this by placing the framed copies of Doctorβs degree and pictures of Doctor attending conference etc. So whenever a company is positioning its products, they bring their competitors into picture. Therefore, they are hitting the competitors. However, there is a method by which one locates a point which has not been positioned by competitors in that particular area.
Perceptual Map
Perceptual map helps to understand how your product or brand appears in relation to competitorsβ product brand. How a customer see various products located in his perceptual framework. Customers create number of variables about a product and then compare them with the other variables for the same product of the competitors. The lecture depicts two variables: Taste and Price. Customers will start comparing these variables to the competitors and then make the decision.
A survey was carried out on cars and a perceptual map was drawn. Variables were: is it old fashion, is it practical and affordable etc. We can locate a gap and empty space between the brands by using this perceptual map. For example, we can locate the gap between the car FORD and the car TOYOTA. If we want to fill this gap, this will be our new POSITION. While locating a position strategy, we must emphasis on the quality of our product.
Quality of Product
We, being marketers, must also understand the quality and its important concepts.
- Conformance: It means to show the detail of the usage of product. For example, Honda motorcycle can take you 70 km in one liter petrol ...one liter petrol / 70 km.
- Performance: The perception of the person who is into position. A person might believe a car is faster going from 0 second to 60 second than the other car.
Services Marketing
As discussed earlier, services marketing are intangible in nature. Marketers have to understand what is expected by the consumer and how gaps are created. So first interpretation about what is expected by the consumer and what does marketer thinks that he expects can create a first gap. If marketer could exactly identify what customers want, then the second point could be the marketer could identify the method to deliver that. Hence, the second gap is what marketer understands and what he delivers. Third gap is when marketer responded to, how it is perceived by the consumer. All these gaps when they pull together can create the gap between expected and delivery. So here, we found that services marketing are different from the products.
Quality of Service
There are five factors to measure quality of services;
- Reliability
- Assurance
- Responsiveness
- Empathy
- Tangibility
These are repeatedly used to determine service quality and help us to understand what quality in terms of services is. Many factors have direct impact on service quality which includes retail outlet, country of origin and manufacturerβs image have direct impact on perception of quality. That is what we, being marketers, need to understand and keep in mind while devising position strategies.
π Definition β Positioning: a method by which a marketer tries to place his product in a favorable position among all the other products that are located and which provide same need specifying features. π Definition β Surrogate Cues: indicators that tell about service quality, used because services are intangible. π Definition β Perceptual Map: a tool to understand how your product or brand appears in relation to competitorsβ product brand. π Definition β Conformance: showing the detail of the usage of a product. π Definition β Performance: the perception of the person who is into position.
π Formula: No explicit formulas provided in this lecture.
π Example: A survey was carried out on cars and a perceptual map was drawn with variables like "it own old fashion", "practical and affordable". A gap was located between the car FORD and the car TOYOTA. Filling this gap creates a new POSITION.
β Key Takeaways
Product positioning is about creating a favorable place for a product in the consumer's mind, and a mismatch between marketer intent and consumer perception creates a gap that can lead to failure. Key methods of positioning include offering a feature (e.g., a specific cooling temperature) or a benefit (e.g., comfort). Marketers can use multi positioning (same product, different strategies in different segments), umbrella positioning (one parent brand covering multiple sub-brands), or re-positioning when the original strategy fails or when price-quality links need adjustment. For services, positioning is more challenging due to intangibility, so marketers use surrogate cues to create tangibility and must manage three service gaps (expectations-understanding, understanding-delivery, delivery-perception). Perceptual maps are essential tools for visualizing where a brand stands relative to competitors and for identifying empty gaps for new positioning, while service quality is measured by five dimensions: reliability, assurance, responsiveness, empathy, and tangibility.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of product positioning, and why is a mismatch between marketer and consumer perception problematic?
- Explain the difference between positioning based on a feature and positioning based on a benefit, using examples from the lecture.
- Describe the three types of positioning strategies discussed: multi positioning, umbrella positioning, and re-positioning.
- What is a perceptual map, and how can a marketer use it to find a new position for a product?
- List the five factors used to measure service quality, and explain why services require a different positioning approach than physical products.
π Lecture 13 β Behavioral theories
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between perception, positioning, and risk in consumer behavior, leading into the concept of repositioning when consumer preferences shift. It then introduces behavioral learning theories, particularly classical conditioning, explaining how marketers can use these principles to influence consumer behavior and build brand associations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a recap of perception, positioning, and risk, then explains why repositioning is necessary when consumer preferences change or competitors move closer. It covers perceptual maps for tangible products (magazines) and services (universities), discusses the concept of risk and how consumers reduce it, introduces learning processes, and delves into behavioral learning theories with a focus on classical conditioning theory and its marketing applications.
π Lecture Summary
Repositioning
Repositioning occurs when a marketer needs to change the position of a product or service in the consumer's mind. This happens specifically when new preferences have taken place or a competitor has positioned themselves near your position. Perception is relative to other products, so when the perceptual landscape changes, repositioning becomes necessary.
Example: Magazine Repositioning: A magazine has two attributes: amount of written material versus pictures, and two types of focus: club oriented versus fashion. If two competitors are providing magazines with the same positioning (club oriented with more pictures), the original company must shift towards written, fashion area, and pictorial contents. This creates a different position from competitors, and the only way to succeed is through repositioning.
Example: University Repositioning: A perceptual map for a university uses two features: quality and price. University A has low price and low quality, University B has high price and high quality, and University C has low price but slightly higher quality than A. There is a gap between B and C. If positioning a new University D, the optimal position is to keep price lower than B and quality higher than C, providing the best option for both quality-conscious and price-conscious customers.
How quality of a University is perceived
Since services are intangible, marketers must create tangible cues to help target market build perceptions. These cues include:
- Brochure β good brochures impact students' senses
- Faculty β qualified and experienced faculty impact perceptions of students and parents
- Infrastructure β buildings, facilities, classrooms, and transportation help build perception
These tangible aspects help build positive perceptions for intangibles like a university.
Risk
Risk is an important factor in motivation and perception. Consumers face several types of risk when building perceptions about a specific product:
- Functional risk
- Physical risk
- Financial risk
- Social risk
- Psychological risk
- Time risk
How customers reduce these risks
Marketers should understand how consumers manage risk:
- Get more information β learn about functional aspects of products and major competitors
- Brand Image β a brand with a good image increases consumer confidence
- Brand loyalty β brand loyal customers can easily choose products
- Reputable retail store β consumers perceive fewer problems from reputable stores
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding risk helps marketers build trust and reduce barriers to purchase.
Learning processes
Learning is a process by which consumers tend to learn how to purchase, how to consume, and how to dispose of the product. It is a process by which individuals acquire the basic purchase and consumption knowledge and experience that they apply to future related behavior.
π Definition β Learning: A process by which individuals acquire the basic purchase and consumption knowledge and experience that they apply to future related behavior.
There are two main learning theories:
- Behavioral β more concerned about the outcome of behavior in terms of how perception works
- Cognitive β focuses on how one thinks towards the behavior and what happens in the mind before behavior takes place
Basic elements that affect learning
The knowledge frame is provided by these elements: a. Motivation β sets goals achieved from the consumption process. Motivation plays a moderating role in learning. For example, if a group wants to go for an adventure on a bicycle, their motivation to learn will help them know about the area they are interested in. Level of motivation increases or decreases the level of desire to learn. b. Cues β stimuli or clues given to direct motivation. Using the adventure example, the person needs to know where to find a robust mountain bike, visit websites, read magazines, and talk to friends. He needs to get different cues from different channels/forums about the product he is searching. c. Response / Reinforcement β Theory suggests that the number of times you reinforce something, the person will be habituated to it. For example, a salesperson required to visit a client five times a week who receives a bonus for every fifth visit will try to repeat that behavior. This is called reinforcement. If a behavior is repeated again and again, more learning will take place. If expectation exceeds perception, reinforcement will be enhanced.
Learning theories β Behavioral Theory
Classical Conditioning Theory Discovered by Russian Physiologist Ivan Pavlov, classical conditioning is a learning process that occurs through associations between an environmental stimulus and a naturally occurring stimulus. It involves placing a neutral signal before a naturally occurring reflex.
π Definition β Classical Conditioning: A learning process that occurs through associations between an environmental stimulus and a naturally occurring stimulus.
π Process: Unconditioned Stimulus β Unconditioned Response, then Neutral Stimulus + Unconditioned Stimulus β Unconditioned Response, finally Conditioned Stimulus β Conditioned Response.
π Example: Pavlov's experiment on dogs:
- Bell was the neutral/conditional stimulus
- Meat was the unconditioned stimulus
- Salivating was the conditioned response He would ring a bell, then place meat on the dog's tongue, and the dog salivated. After repeating this, when he rang the bell without giving meat, the dog still salivated.
π Marketing Example β Dinner Time:
- Unconditioned Stimulus β Cooking smell
- Unconditional Response β Hunger
- Conditional Stimulus β 9'O Clock News
- Conditional Response β Hunger
If marketers understand that 9'O Clock News is conditioned with hunger, they can place advertisements for Pizza, Burger, etc. at that specific time. Marketers can apply classical conditioning in many ways to promote their products.
β Key Takeaways
Repositioning is necessary when consumer preferences change or competitors move closer to your position, and perceptual maps help visualize ideal positioning for both tangible products and intangible services. Risk (functional, physical, financial, social, psychological, time) is a critical factor in consumer decision-making, and marketers can reduce it through information, brand image, brand loyalty, and reputable retail stores. Learning is a continuous process involving motivation, cues, response, and reinforcement, divided into behavioral (outcome-focused) and cognitive (process-focused) theories. Classical conditioning, demonstrated by Pavlov's dogs, shows how a neutral stimulus can trigger a conditioned response through association, and marketers can apply this by pairing products with naturally occurring triggers. Reinforcement through repeated positive experiences strengthens learning and encourages repeat behavior.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main reasons that motivate a marketer to reposition a product?
- How can a university use tangible cues to build positive perceptions of its intangible service?
- List the six types of risk consumers face when building perceptions about a product.
- What are the four basic elements that affect the learning process, and how does each contribute to consumer learning?
- Explain how Pavlov's classical conditioning experiment applies to a marketing situation involving television news and food advertisements.
π Lecture 14 β Theories of learning
π Overview: This lecture explores various theories of learning that explain how consumers acquire, process, and retain information. Understanding these theories is crucial for marketers because it helps them design effective advertising strategies, create lasting brand associations, and influence consumer behavior through repetition, reinforcement, and stimulus management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Pavlovian theory of reflexive response and the Neo-Pavlovian theory of cognitive association, marketing implications of learning including repetition, association, and optimal exposure frequency. It then examines stimulus generalization with applications in product line extensions, form extensions, category extensions, family branding, branded families, and licensing. The lecture concludes with stimulus discrimination, instrumental learning through trial and error, reinforcement types (positive and negative), and the concepts of extinction and forgetting.
π Lecture Summary
LEARNING
This section introduces the importance of understanding consumer learning processes. Marketers need to understand how consumers learn because this knowledge allows them to tailor their responses to consumer behavior in favorable ways. The learning process is a critical component for marketers who want to effectively communicate with their target audience.
Response
This section focuses on how consumers respond to stimuli. Consumer behavior and learning are understood under two conditions, beginning with instinctive response or reflexive response.
- Reflexive Response is based on Pavlov's experiment with dogs, where a conditional stimulus is associated with an unconditional response. There are four main points in the Pavlovian Theory: a. Sequence β the conditional stimulus must come first, and the unconditional stimulus must come second b. Pairing β the two stimuli happen at the same time c. Biological response β the response is physiological and automatic d. Repetition β the pairing must be repeated to establish the connection
π Definition β Neo Pavlovian Theory: Cognitive Association: This theory proposes that the learning system is not purely reflexive; instead, it depends on the cognitive association between stimuli. When unconditional and conditional responses are brought together, consumers engage in a thinking process to link these responses and may also link a third response to the existing ones. This does not happen instinctively but because consumers use cognitive, logical, and rational thinking to create associations, resulting in a better understanding of the situation before a response occurs.
π‘ Why this matters: The Neo Pavlovian theory is important because it shifts the understanding of learning from a purely automatic process to one that involves active consumer thinking, which has significant implications for how marketers design messages.
Marketing implications
- Repetition β ads are repeated: In advertising, learning or what is called recall condition will not occur unless the message is repeated. Repetition is the mechanism that brings these concepts together.
- Association β adding a product under a brand: When repetition occurs, associations will take place. It is critical that these associations are relevant to the individual's own desires.
- How many repetitions are enough?: Marketers need to know how many times an ad should be repeated because excessive repetition can create a problem of boredom. Two things are important to know:
- How many repetitions are sufficient to establish the relationship
- That over repetition has a negative impact
Research suggests that three repetitions are enough to create learning, a concept known as the three shot theory:
- First visibility creates awareness
- Second visibility creates association
- Third visibility creates learning
Another research suggests that to achieve these three shots, consumers need 10β11 exposures, but an individual customer will register only three of these. With too many exposures, consumers lose their memory, and watching the same ad becomes boring. Marketers can address this by changing the ad in two ways:
- Cosmetic Change: The original words remain the same, but the background, color, design, and style are changed
- Major Changes: Different ads display different single attributes, dividing the product's features across multiple ads rather than presenting all attributes in one
Stimulus generalization
Pavlov realized that when a bell was rung, the dog salivated. If any similar stimulus arose, like the sound of keys which is similar to a bell, the dog would also salivate. Therefore, if any stimulus similar to the original one arises, the response will be the same. The marketing implications are significant: there are many "me too products" in the market where other marketers try to copy original products and sell them to the same market. Consumers may confuse which product is the original and buy the copied product. On the other hand, companies also bring differentiated products, which is beneficial for both marketers and consumers.
Applications of stimulus generalization Marketers can apply generalized stimulus through several methods:
- Product Line Extensions: Launching a related product within the same line. For example, a washing powder for hand wash (original) can be extended to machine wash powder
- Product Form Extension: Changing the shape or form of the product. For example, teeth cleaning toothpaste (original) can be extended to toothpowder or mouthwash
- Product Category Extension: A totally different use of a product. For example, deodorant (original) can be followed by launching shaving cream, which is a totally different product category
Brand Management Strategies In brand management, there are two types of branding strategies:
- Family Branding: One single brand is used for all product categories. For example, Gillette for razors and toiletries, or P&G for shampoos like Pantene and Head & Shoulders. This is called a house of brands meaning under one shelter there are many brands
- Branded Family: This strategy involves launching brands within the same family. For example, Gillette launches razors and toiletries under the same family name
For successful generalization, four points are necessary: a. Complementary products b. Some kind of substitute between the attributes c. Some transferability d. A key image component
This is especially relevant for umbrella branding where one brand holds many brands. Marketers must look for these concepts to make the generalization successful.
π Definition β Licensing: Well-established brands give a license to other companies to use their brand name. For example, Marriott Hotels and Pearl Continental Hotels give licenses to others to use their brand name. Companies must be very careful that the licensee maintains the same standard as the original brand.
Stimulus discrimination
The concept of stimulus discrimination is used in the concept of positioning, which is a basic concept in the marketing framework. The positioning concept desires that every company wants to differentiate their products in such a manner that consumers will be attracted to that particular product. This can only happen if no other competing brand can position itself like the original brand. Here, the re-positioning concept can be used for better explanation. Discrimination occurs when marketers try to discriminate against other brands and push their own brand more and more in the market.
Instrumental Learning
Instrumental learning is essentially operant learning, which means individuals learn through experiences. In this type of learning, the behavior is instrumental in producing a change in the environment, and that environmental change in turn affects the probability of the behavior that produced it. It is used to explain complex behaviors and occurs through trial and error response. For example, a consumer searches for a specific product at retail stores, visits many stores, and finally reaches a store that provides good exposure. The consumer then starts preferring that same store again and again, learning through trial and error.
A famous scholar, B.F. Skinner, conducted experiments using animals to learn certain behaviors. He trained pigeons to play ping pong by rewarding them when the ball went in the right direction and punishing them when it went the wrong direction. Slowly, the animals learned to go in the direction Skinner wanted. The conclusion is that the learning system is a continuous process acquired through trial and error.
Reinforcement
While discussing reinforcement, there are two important types:
- Negative Reinforcement: This should not be confused with punishment. Punishment is used to discourage a behavior, whereas negative reinforcement is used to encourage a behavior. For example, insurance policy ads that show death are not meant to discourage but to encourage people to buy health policies. On the other hand, cigarette ads that show negative consequences are normally used to discourage the behavior
- Positive Reinforcement: This creates highly satisfactory results and encourages the continuation of the behavior
Extinction and forgetting
People tend to forget over time, so learning can slowly get reduced. Forgetting can take place, and memory decay can start happening. Once decay starts, a person will normally tend to lose the things they had remembered over a period of time. Marketers can counteract this by creating repetitive advertisements and generating customer satisfaction over a period of time. For example, universities with placement services can do two things: 1) place new graduates in jobs, but students may forget over time; 2) stay in touch with students over a period of time, which helps students recall the universities' services when finding a job.
β Key Takeaways
The four critical points from this lecture are: first, learning theories explain how consumers form associations between stimuli and responses, with the Neo Pavlovian theory emphasizing that this is a cognitive rather than purely reflexive process. Second, repetition is essential for learning, with the three-shot theory suggesting three effective exposures are needed, and marketers must balance enough repetition against the risk of boredom through cosmetic or major ad changes. Third, stimulus generalization explains how similar stimuli can trigger the same response, leading to me-too products and brand extension strategies, while stimulus discrimination is the foundation of product positioning to differentiate a brand from competitors. Fourth, instrumental learning through trial and error, reinforced by positive or negative reinforcement, explains complex consumer behaviors, and marketers must actively counteract forgetting and memory decay through continued engagement and repetition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main points of the Pavlovian Theory of reflexive response, and how do they explain the learning process?
- According to the three-shot theory, what does each of the three visibilities achieve in consumer learning?
- What is the difference between a cosmetic change and a major change in advertising, and why would a marketer use each?
- Explain the difference between positive reinforcement and negative reinforcement, and give one marketing example for each.
- What are the four points necessary for successful generalization in umbrella branding, and why is each important?