๐ Lecture 15 โ Distinction between Administrative Functions
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the three fundamental organs of stateโLegislature, Executive, and Judiciaryโand their respective functions. It explores the practical difficulties in clearly distinguishing between legislative, executive, and judicial functions, and analyzes the legal consequences that flow from such classifications, particularly concerning administrative, quasi-judicial, and quasi-legislative acts.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by introducing the three organs of state and their relationship, using the example of taxation to illustrate their distinct functions. It then examines the difficulty of precisely distinguishing between administrative, quasi-judicial, and quasi-legislative functions, providing definitions from scholars like Willis and Justice Holmes. The lecture further distinguishes legislative from judicial functions, legislative from administrative functions using tests by Griffith and Street, and quasi-judicial from judicial functions. Finally, it distinguishes administrative from quasi-judicial functions, providing examples of each.
๐ Lecture Summary
Three organs of state:
There are three basic organs of a state: (1) Legislature, (2) Executive, and (3) Judiciary. These three organs perform three kinds of functions; the ordinary function of the legislature is law-making or enactment of laws; the executive is to administer the law; and the judiciary is to interpret the law and to dispense justice to the masses.
๐ Definition โ Legislature: The organ of state responsible for making or enacting laws. ๐ Definition โ Executive: The organ of state responsible for administering the law. ๐ Definition โ Judiciary: The organ of state responsible for interpreting the law and dispensing justice.
Relationship between legislature, executive and judiciary:
The relationship between the three organs of state may be understood through the comments of Wade & Phillips. They narrate the relationship by quoting the example of taxation:
- "The enactment of a law authorizing a new tax is a legislative function."
- "The provision of machinery assessing and collecting the tax payable by each taxpayer is an administrative or executive function."
- "The determination of dispute between the taxpayer and the tax collector as to tax due in a particular case is a judicial function, involving the interpretation of law and its application to the facts of the case."
Similarly, in criminal law: the creation of a new offence is legislation, the enforcement of law is an executive function, and the trial of an alleged offender is a judicial function.
It was held in a case that it cannot be assumed that legislative functions are exclusively performed by the legislature, executive functions by the executive, and judicial functions by the judiciary. In Halsbury's Law of England, it is stated that there is no implication that the functions of the executive are confined exclusively to those of an executive. Today, the executive performs different functions, for example: it investigates, prosecutes, prepares and adopts schemes, issues and cancels licenses, adjudicates on disputes, and imposes fines.
Whether the functions performed by the executive are purely administrative, quasi judicial or quasi legislative?
It is very difficult to give a precise and clear-cut answer to this question. There is no scientific principle to distinguish these three functions from one another, yet the classification is necessary as many consequences flow from it. For example, if the executive authority performs quasi-judicial functions, then it has to follow the principle of natural justice.
Distinction between legislative, Executive and Judicial functions
Willis, in his treatise on Constitutional Law, states definitions by Mr. Green:
- Legislative power: The power to create rights, powers, privileges or immunities and their correlatives, as well as status, not dependent upon any previous rights, duties, etc.
- Judicial power: The power to create some rights or duties dependent upon a previous right or dutyโthe power to create remedial legal capacities and liabilities.
- Executive power: Power including all governmental power which is not part of the process of legislation or adjudication; the power concerned mostly with the management and execution of public affairs.
Distinction between legislative and judicial function:
In a case, Justice Holmes made the distinction between legislative and judicial functions as follows:
- "A judicial inquiry investigates, declares and enforces liabilities as they stand on present or past facts and under laws supposed already to exist. That is its purpose and end."
- "Legislation on the other hand looks to the future and changes existing conditions by making a new rule to be applied thereafter to all or some part of those subject to its power."
According to Justice Holmes, a legislative function prescribes a future pattern of conduct and creates new rights and liabilities, whereas a judicial function determines rights and liabilities on the basis of present or past facts.
Professor Dickinson says: "What distinguishes legislation from adjudication is that the former affects the rights of individuals in the abstract and must be applied in a further proceeding before the legal position of any particular individual will be definitely touched by it; while adjudication operates concretely upon individuals in their individual capacity."
Distinction between legislative and administrative functions.
To draw a distinction between the two, Griffith and Street have given two tests:
- Institutional test: That which the legislature enacts is legislation, but the word 'enacts' includes all kinds of action taken by parliament; thus, this test is not appropriate.
- Second test (Extent of applicability): A power to make rules of general application is a legislative power, and the rule is a legislative rule. A power to give an order in specific cases is an executive power, and the order is an executive action.
De Smith also says that a legislative act is the creation and promulgation of a general rule of conduct without reference to particular cases, while an administrative act is the application of a general rule to a particular case. However, this test is also not complete; the difficulty is in distinguishing what is 'general' from what is 'specific,' as the difference is only a matter of degree.
In a case, Union of India versus Cynamide India Ltd., the Supreme Court observed: "With proliferation of delegated legislation, there is a tendency for the line between legislation and administration to vanish into an illusion."
Legal consequences flow from the distinction:
De Smith states that the following legal consequences flow from the distinction:
- If an order is legislative in character, it must be published in a certain manner, but this is not necessary if it is of an administrative nature.
- If an order is legislative in character, the court will not issue a writ of certiorari to quash it. If an order is an administrative order and the authority was required to act judicially, the court can quash it by issuing a writ of certiorari.
- The duty to give reasons applies to administrative orders but not to legislative orders.
- Only in most exceptional circumstances can legislative powers be sub-delegated, but administrative powers can be sub-delegated.
Distinction between quasi judicial function from judicial function.
Judicial function: According to the Committee on Ministers' Power, a pure judicial function presupposes an existing dispute between two or more parties and involves four requisites:
- The presentation of the case by the parties to the dispute.
- If the dispute is a question of fact, the ascertainment of fact by means of evidence adduced by the parties to the dispute, often with the assistance of argument by or on behalf of the parties on evidence.
- If the dispute is a question of law, the submission of legal argument by the parties.
- A decision which disposes of the whole matter by finding upon the facts in dispute and an application of the law of the land to the facts so found, including where required a ruling upon any disputed question of law.
Thus, in a pure judicial function, all four requisites must be present. If these requisites are present, the decision is a judicial decision even though it might have been made by an authority other than a court (e.g., a minister, board, executive authority, or administrative tribunal).
๐ Definition โ Quasi-judicial function: The word "quasi" means 'not exactly.' A quasi-judicial function presupposes a dispute between the parties and involves only two requisites:
- The presentation of the case by the parties to the dispute.
- If the dispute is a question of fact, the ascertainment of fact by means of evidence adduced by the parties.
It does not necessarily involve the third requisite and never involves the fourth requisite.
A quasi-judicial function differs from a purely judicial function in the following respects:
- A quasi-judicial authority has some of the trappings of a court but not all of them; nevertheless, there is an obligation to act judicially.
- A lis inter partes (a controversy between two parties) is an essential characteristic of a judicial function, but this may not be true of a quasi-judicial function.
- A court is bound by the rules of evidence and procedure, while a quasi-judicial authority is not.
- A court cannot be a judge in its own cause, while an administrative authority vested with quasi-judicial power may be a party to the controversy but can still decide it.
Distinction between Administrative and quasi judicial function
Acts of an administrative authority may be purely administrative, legislative, or judicial. Decisions which are purely administrative stand on a wholly different footing from judicial as well as quasi-judicial decisions and must be distinguished. To make a distinction between administrative and quasi-judicial function, understanding of the two expressions 'Lis' and 'Quasi lis' is necessary:
- Lis: A piece of litigation; a controversy or dispute.
- Quasi lis: A piece of litigation which is the subject matter of administration.
- Lis inter partes: A controversy between two parties.
A function can be called quasi-judicial as distinguished from pure administrative when there is a lis inter partes and the administrative authority is to decide it between the parties and to adjudicate upon the lis. In such a situation, the authority will be acting as quasi-judicial.
There may be cases in which an administrative authority is to decide a lis not between two parties but between itself and another party. For example, where an authority makes an order granting legal aid, dismissing an employee, refusing to grant, revoking, suspending, or cancelling a license, cancelling examination results of a student for using unfair means, or rusticating a studentโsuch decisions are judicial in nature. In all these cases, there are no two parties before the administrative authority (the other party to the dispute, if any, is the authority itself), yet there is a situation resembling a lis. In such situations, the administrative authority must decide the case objectively after taking into account the objections of the party before it. If such authority has exceeded or abused its power, a writ of certiorari can be issued against it.
๐ Example โ Administrative functions:
- Order setting up a commission of inquiry
- Order for acquisition of property
- Order of preventive detention
- Order of assessment under the Sales Tax Act
- Power to issue a license or permit
๐ Example โ Quasi-judicial functions:
- Dismissal of an employee on the ground of misconduct
- Disciplinary proceeding against a student
- Confiscation of goods under the Customs law
- Forfeiture of pension or gratuity
- Determination of citizenship
๐ก Why this matters: The distinction between administrative and quasi-judicial functions determines which procedures must be followed (e.g., natural justice) and what remedies are available (e.g., writ of certiorari). Misclassifying a function can invalidate a decision or leave an affected person without recourse.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that the three organs of stateโlegislature, executive, and judiciaryโperform functions that are not always exclusive; the executive today performs quasi-legislative and quasi-judicial functions. The key tests for distinguishing functions include the future-oriented nature of legislation versus the past/present fact-based nature of adjudication, and the general applicability of legislative rules versus the specific applicability of administrative orders. A pure judicial function requires four requisites (presentation of case, ascertainment of facts, legal argument, and a final decision), whereas a quasi-judicial function requires only the first two. The legal consequences of classifying an action as legislative, administrative, or judicial are significant, affecting publication requirements, availability of writs, duty to give reasons, and the ability to sub-delegate power.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to Wade & Phillips, what are the three different functions performed by the state in the context of taxation, and which organ of state typically performs each?
- What is the difference between a legislative function and a judicial function as described by Justice Holmes?
- According to Griffith and Street, what is the test to distinguish a legislative function from an administrative function?
- What are the four requisites of a pure judicial function as per the Committee on Ministers' Power?
- In what four ways does a quasi-judicial function differ from a purely judicial function?
๐ Lecture 16 โ Public Interest Litigation
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of Public Interest Litigation (PIL), a legal mechanism that allows individuals or groups to seek judicial redress for the benefit of the public, especially for marginalized and disadvantaged sections of society. It explores the evolution, nature, and global application of PIL, focusing on its critical role in Pakistan for ensuring access to justice and upholding fundamental rights, while also addressing its inherent pitfalls.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an introduction to Public Interest Litigation, defining it through various sources like the Ford Foundation and Black's Law Dictionary, and justifying its need in Pakistan due to widespread poverty and illiteracy. It then explains the nature of PIL as a participative and cooperative process for social welfare. The lecture provides a comparative overview of PIL in the USA, UK, China, and Pakistan, detailing its specific applications and importance in the Pakistani context. Finally, it discusses the evolved doctrine of locus standi in PIL cases and highlights the critical pitfalls and shortcomings courts must guard against when dealing with such petitions.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction to Public Interest Litigation
The Supreme Court and High Courts of Pakistan now entertain petitions filed pro bono publico (for the public good), marking a new chapter in the judicial system. The Ford Foundation USA defined 'Public Interest Law' as efforts to provide legal representation to previously unrepresented groups, such as the poor, environmentalists, consumers, and racial minorities, because the ordinary legal market fails them. In America, it gives a voice to those who cannot afford lawyers. In Pakistan, it is justified by the population's poverty and illiteracy, which denies millions access to justice.
๐ Definition โ Public Interest Litigation (PIL): A legal action initiated in a court of law for the enforcement of public interest or general interest, where the public or a class of the community has a pecuniary interest or some interest by which their legal rights or liabilities are affected. It provides all citizens with inviolable access to justice for the protection of fundamental human rights.
Nature of โPublic Interest Litigationโ
Public interest litigation focuses on social welfare and humanitarianism, evolving a new form of jurisprudence. It is part of participative justice and a legal aid movement to bring justice to the poor masses. PIL is not for enforcing one individual's right against another, but to promote public interest and address the violated rights of large, ignorant, and socio-economically poor groups.
๐ก Why this matters: PIL is a cooperative effort between the petitioner, the state, and the Court, ensuring the rule of law protects not just the fortunate few but also the deprived. It offers the government a chance to assure social and economic justice, the "signature tune" of the constitution. Courts entertain PIL to ensure the observance of social and economic rescue programs, not in a confrontational manner.
Public Interest Litigation in Different Countries of the World
Public Interest Litigation in United States of America: After the 1960s social turmoil, the term 'Public Interest Law' became widely used. Louis Brandies, a future Supreme Court Judge, advocated for the public's interest, criticizing that "able lawyers... have neglected their obligation to use their powers for the protection of the people." During the 1960s and 70s, law graduates defined themselves as โPublic Interest Lawyersโ to distinguish themselves from โCorporate Adjunctsโ.
Public Interest Litigation in United Kingdom: In the UK, "Public Interest" is used as a defense against certain lawsuits (e.g., libel) and as an exemption from laws (e.g., freedom of information). Under Common law, judges can make judgments on grounds of public policy.
Public Interest Litigation in China: While China does not follow the Common Law system, a small community of lawyers has gained acceptance for PIL as a legitimate means to resolve social issues. Chinese reformers believe that implementing an associational standing ruleโallowing organizations to instigate lawsuits to protect members' interestsโcould speed up the development of public interest law.
Public Interest Litigation in Pakistan: PIL in Pakistan is interpreted by judges for the intent of the public at large, as it is not defined in any statute. Areas for PIL include: ยท Violation of basic human rights of the poor or vulnerable groups ยท Content or conduct of government policy ยท Compelling public authorities to perform a public duty ยท Violation of basic fundamental rights PIL is a selfless and noble undertaking to deliver civic justice through speedy redress of violated rights. It strengthens the rule of law, furthers justice, secures civil liberties, and accelerates constitutional objectives, as seen in the Supreme Court's suo moto actions. However, courts must be careful not to overstep into the executive or legislative domains.
Locus Standi & Public Interest Litigation
The traditional rule of locus standi requires a petitioner to be an "aggrieved person" who suffered a wrong. This rule has been evolved in countries with poverty, illiteracy, and ignorance that impede access to justice. Blindly following the Anglo-Saxon rule would close the doors of justice to the poor and deprived.
๐ Definition โ Evolved Locus Standi: Any public-spirited citizen, even with no greater interest than a regard for the due observation of the law, may move the courts if public authorities transgress any law or constitutional directive. The court can grant an appropriate legal remedy in its discretion. ๐ Example: In Muhammad Bin Ismail v. Tan Sri Hajji Othman Satt (1982-2 MLJ133), Justice Wan Yahya of Malaysia laid down this dictum, allowing any public-spirited citizen to challenge a public authority's transgression.
Pitfalls in Public Interest Litigation
Despite its cogent justification, PIL has grave pitfalls that courts must consider: (1) The court must verify the petitioner is a bona fide person or group, not acting for personal gain, and must not allow politicians to abuse the process for delaying lawful action or gaining political advantage. (2) Courts must distinguish between locus standi and justifiability, as not every default by a public authority is justifiable. (3) Courts must not overstep their judicial function and trespass into areas reserved for the executive and legislature. (4) Courts must consider the impact of their relief on the rights of persons not before the court. (5) While a court can treat a letter as a writ petition, it is not every letter that qualifies. It must be from an aggrieved person or a public-spirited individual where the communication carries a sense of responsibility. The danger is inherent when a letter is from a person with unknown antecedents and uncertain status.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical point is understanding Public Interest Litigation (PIL) as a legal tool designed to provide access to justice for the poor and marginalized, moving beyond the traditional rule of locus standi which required a direct personal injury. Students must remember the evolved definition of locus standi from the Muhammad Bin Ismail case, which allows any public-spirited citizen to challenge a public authority's violation of law. The lecture also emphasizes the global recognition of PIL, particularly its growth in Pakistan via suo moto actions by the Supreme Court. Finally, it is crucial to remember the inherent pitfalls of PIL, especially the court's duty to ensure the petitioner is bona fide and to avoid encroaching on the executive and legislative domains.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to the Ford Foundation, what is the primary goal of 'Public Interest Law'?
- Explain the "evolved" doctrine of locus standi as it applies to Public Interest Litigation.
- What are the key pitfalls a court must consider before entertaining a Public Interest Litigation petition?
- Name one country besides Pakistan discussed in the lecture, and briefly describe how Public Interest Litigation is practiced there.
- Why does the lecture state that the traditional Anglo-Saxon rule of standing is insufficient for countries like Pakistan?
๐ Lecture 17 โ Introduction to Constitution
๐ Overview: This lecture defines the concept of a constitution as the supreme law of the land, distinguishing between written and unwritten constitutions and their legal consequences. It explains why written constitutions were historically demanded, their objectives, and the specific features of Pakistanโs constitutional framework, including the role of the Objective Resolution of 1949.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition of constitution by Bolingbroke, the narrower and wider meanings of constitution, kinds of constitution (written vs. unwritten), reasons for enacting written constitutions, legal consequences of written versus unwritten constitutions, the distinction between flexible and rigid constitutions, the scope of constitutional law in Pakistan, the three components of the Objective Resolution of 1949, the subjects of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, and the distinction between constitutional law and administrative law.
๐ Lecture Summary
What is constitution?
Constitution is defined by Bolingbroke as โthat assemblage of laws, institutions and customs, derived from certain fixed principles of reason... that compose the general system, according to which the community has agreed to be governed.โ It is the Supreme law of the land, from which all public authorities derive their powers, all laws their validity, and all subjects their rights.
Kinds of constitution
The word โConstitutionโ has two meanings: a narrower meaning (concrete sense) given to a written constitution, and a wider meaning (abstract sense) covering an unwritten constitution. The narrower meaning refers to a document with special legal sanctity (legal force) that sets out the framework and principal functions of the organs of government and declares the principles governing their operation. All private rights are determined according to constitutional law, and if there is a conflict between the Constitution and ordinary law, the latter must yield to the former. Administrative acts conflicting with the constitution and fundamental rights may be declared without lawful authority. In Pakistan, the Supreme Court is empowered with judicial review of administrative and legislative acts. The unwritten constitutions of the United Kingdom, New Zealand, and Israel are not covered by the narrower definition because they cannot be derived from a single document.
Why written constitutions are enacted?
Demand for written constitution arose after the American and French Revolutions. The objective of the written constitution was to meet two objectives:
- The entrenchment (firmly established) of the principles of constitutionalism and limited government to control the three organs of the state.
- The guaranteeing of basic human rights to the citizens.
๐ Definition โ Entrenchment: The process of firmly establishing constitutional principles so they cannot be easily changed or violated by ordinary legislative processes.
Tom Pain described: โA constitution is a thing antecedent to a government and a government is only the creature of a constitution... a constitution is not the act of a government but of a people constituting a government; and government without a constitution is a power without a right.โ ๐ Definition โ Antecedent: Precursor or forerunner.
Legal consequences of the unwritten constitution
In Pakistan, the spirit of the constitution introduced a federal form of government whereby executive and legislative fields are divided into Federal and Provincial categories, with constitutional limits binding both. By virtue of a written constitution, certain rights of citizens described as basic or fundamental rights are placed beyond the reach of the three organs of state. Fundamental rights may be entrenched by requiring a special legislative procedure for amendment, or even by rendering them unalterable, as in the Federal Republic of Germany. Many written constitutions avoid concentration of power by adopting the principle of separation of powers, vesting legislative power in the legislature, executive power in the executive, and judicial power in the courts. The unwritten constitution cannot secure these objectives. For the establishment of a Federal system, a written constitution is necessary. The function of protecting the rights of individuals and minorities against legislative infringement cannot be accomplished in an extremely flexible unwritten constitution.
๐ Definition โ Separation of Powers: The principle of vesting legislative power exclusively in the legislature, executive power in the executive, and judicial power in the courts to avoid concentration of power in any one organ of state.
A flexible constitution is one under which every law of every description can legally be changed with the same ease and in the same manner by one and the same body. A rigid constitution is one under which certain laws (constitutional or fundamental laws) cannot be changed in the same manner as ordinary law. Under the Pakistan Constitution (Article 239), a bill to amend the constitution may originate in either house and when passed by the votes of not less than two-thirds of the total membership of the house, is transmitted to the other house where it is passed with or without amendment by the same majority. Where the constitution is written, it is easy to distinguish constitutional law from the rest of the legal system; but where the constitution is unwritten, there is no scientific distinction.
The constitutional law deals with the distribution and exercise of the functions of the government and the relations of government authorities to each other and to the individual citizen.
Subjects of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973
The scope of Constitutional law in Pakistan can only be determined with reference to the Objective Resolution of 1949. The Objective Resolution appeared as a preamble in all constitutions of Pakistan (1956, 1962, Interim 1972, and the present 1973 Constitution). The preambles are verbatim et literatim reproduction of the Objective Resolution with minor alterations.
The Objective Resolution has three distinct components:
- Structural feature: The sovereignty of Almighty Allah descending on the people of Pakistan constituting the State of Pakistan is to be exercised through their chosen representatives. Individuals, authorities, institutions, and courts do not figure in this structure.
- Qualitative feature (good): The sovereignty delegated by the Almighty to the chosen representatives is further delegated by them to the individuals, institutions, authorities, courts, and other instrumentalities of the State.
- Normative feature (describing or setting standards): The norms, goals, and ideals of the state have to be spelt out with particularity for their achievement in the constitution.
The Constitution of Pakistan 1973 reflects the commands intended by the Objective Resolution and recounts to the following topics:
- Fundamental Rights, violation of which is redressable by the High Courts under Article 199 and by the Supreme Court under Article 184(3), and the limitations on Fundamental Rights.
- Principles of Policy for the general guidance of the Legislature, which are not cognizable by any court of law. ๐ Definition โ Cognizable: Capable of being judicially tried.
- The method of election of the President, terms and conditions of office, impeachment, and executive, legislative, and other powers. ๐ Definition โ Impeachment: The act of calling an official to remove him from office.
- The constitution of both Houses of Parliament, their relations, qualifications for membership, and privileges of members.
- The authority, powers, and working of the Federal Government, the Prime Minister, his Cabinet, and the status of Ministers, and similar matters relating to provincial government.
- The position of the Civil Servants, Armed Forces, the general system of Courts, their judicial power and jurisdiction, and the tenure and immunities of judges.
- The mode of amendment of the Constitution.
Note: Under unwritten constitutions, it is difficult to make a distinction between Constitutional law and Administrative law. In continental countries, a distinction is commonly drawn. The subject matter of Administrative law is public administration. Administrative law determines the organization, powers, and duties of administrative agencies. An important aspect is the control exercised by courts or tribunals over those powers, especially in relation to citizensโ rights. These tribunals or administrative courts may be established in respect of: (i) matters relating to terms and conditions of persons in service of Pakistan (including disciplinary matters), (ii) matters relating to claims arising from tortuous acts of government or any person in service of Pakistan, and (iii) matters relating to acquisition, administration, and disposal of enemy property.
โญ Key Takeaways
A constitution is the supreme law of the land, and the key distinction is between written (narrower meaning, single document) and unwritten (wider meaning, derived from multiple sources) constitutions. Written constitutions were historically demanded to entrench constitutionalism, limit government power, and guarantee fundamental rights, which unwritten constitutions cannot fully secure. Pakistan has a written, rigid, and federal constitution whose scope is defined by the Objective Resolution of 1949, which has three features: structural (sovereignty from Allah to people through representatives), qualitative (delegation to state organs), and normative (setting state ideals). The 1973 Constitution covers fundamental rights, principles of policy, government structure, courts, civil service, armed forces, and amendment procedures, with a clear distinction between constitutional law and administrative law being possible only under written constitutions.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two meanings of the word โConstitutionโ and how do they differ?
- What were the two main objectives behind the demand for written constitutions after the American and French Revolutions?
- What are the three distinct components of the Objective Resolution of 1949?
- Under which articles of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 are fundamental rights violations redressable?
- What is the difference between a flexible constitution and a rigid constitution, and how does Pakistanโs amendment procedure (Article 239) illustrate a rigid constitution?
๐ Lecture 18 โ Right to Life & Liberty
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of fundamental rights, focusing on the right to life and liberty as enshrined in the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. It explores the definition of nationality, the scope of human rights in international law, and the specific constitutional protections and case law that define and expand these fundamental rights.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining a fundamental right and explaining nationality under Pakistani law, listing the ten kinds of citizenship under the Pakistan Citizenship Act 1951. It then discusses human rights in international law, emphasizing the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The lecture covers the constitutional inviolability of human dignity under Sharia and Articles 14 and 3 of the Constitution, before providing a detailed analysis of Article 9 on the right to life and liberty, including its scope and relevant case law.
๐ Lecture Summary
What is fundamental right?
A right derived from Constitutional law is known as a fundamental right.
What is nationality or citizenship?
According to Blackโs Law Dictionary (8th edition), nationality is "the relationship between a citizen of a nation and the nation itself, customarily involving allegiance by the citizen and protection by the state; membership in a state." Nationality is important as it relates to diplomatic protection abroad, immigration, deportation, and the negotiation of treaties. Nationality law is based on the doctrine of allegiance, which Blackstone defines as "the tie, or ligament which binds the subject to a state, in return for that protection which the state affords to the subject."
Under the Pakistan Citizenship Act 1951, there are ten kinds of Pakistan citizenship: (1) By birth in Pakistan before 14 August 1947. (2) By birth in India having domicile in Pakistan. (3) By naturalization as a British subject in Pakistan. (4) By migration to Pakistan from India before 13 April 1951, proved by a certificate issued under the Rules. (5) By birth in Pakistan after 13 April 1951. (6) By descent if born after 13 April 1951, if the father was a citizen of Pakistan at the time of his birth. (7) By migration from India between 13 April 1951 and 1 January 1952, acquired by registration granted by the Federal Government. (8) By migration to India from Pakistan after 1 March 1947 and returning to Pakistan under a permit for resettlement. (9) By registration of a person whose father or fatherโs father was born in India and was resident outside Pakistan before 13 April 1951 and has obtained a certificate of domicile. (10) By naturalization under the Naturalization Act, 1926 and registration as a citizen of Pakistan.
Human Rights in International Law
Human rights were introduced by the United States Declaration of Independence, 1776 and the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen, 1789 of the French Revolution. The United Nations lists 19 major conventions of Human Rights and over 20 Declarations. The most important of all is the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the General Assembly in 1948.
Dignity of man is inviolable
According to Sharia, it is the stateโs duty to enhance human dignity and alleviate conditions. Article 14 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 lays down that the dignity of man is "inviolable". Article 3 lays down: "the State shall ensure the elimination of all forms of exploitation and the gradual fulfillment of fundamental principle, from each according to his ability and to each according to his work." Article 39 sets down that the state shall secure the well-being of the people, irrespective of sex, caste, creed, or race, by raising their standard of living, preventing the concentration of wealth and means of production and distribution in the hands of a few to the detriment of general interest, and by ensuring equitable adjustment of rights between employers and employees, and landlords and tenants.
Right to Life & Liberty
Lord Atkin said that "right to life and liberty" is "one of the pillars of liberty". Article 9 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 provides that "No person shall be deprived of life or liberty save in accordance with law." This is the first fundamental right, found in Chapter 1 of Part II of the Constitution, in which 20 fundamental rights are enumerated. The provision of Article 9 is a declaration that no person is to take the life or liberty of another person except under a law authorizing him to do so. The person whose life and liberty is threatened is therefore entitled to require the person seeking to deprive him of the right to live or move freely to show the legal authority under which he is purporting to act.
The Lahore High Court, in Sakhi Daler Khan vs. Superintendent, set the petitioner at liberty as the respondent was arrested and detained in flagrant violation of the law. The High Court held that no authority can deprive a person, whether a citizen or not, of his liberty in violation of law, and the deprivation of liberty of the petitioner had to be declared without lawful authority and of no legal effect because it was not in accordance with the law.
๐ Definition โ Fundamental Right: A right derived from Constitutional law.
๐ Formula: Article 9 (Right to Life & Liberty): "No person shall be deprived of life or liberty save in accordance with law." โ This means the state can only take a person's life or restrict their freedom if a law specifically allows it.
๐ Example: Sakhi Daler Khan vs. Superintendent: The respondent was arrested and detained in flagrant violation of the law. The Lahore High Court set the petitioner at liberty, holding that no authority can deprive a person of liberty in violation of law.
Scope of right to life
The right to life does not mean "restricted to mere vegetative life or animal existence." It means something more than just physical survival. The right to life includes the right to live with human dignity and all that goes along with it, namely, the bare necessities of life such as adequate nutrition, clothing, and shelter, and other facilities necessary for life. The right to life includes the right to live with human dignity and all that goes along with it, namely, the facilities for reading, writing, and expressing in diverse forms, freely moving about and mingling and comingling with fellow human beings. It was held in a case that the right to life includes access to road in hilly areas.
Relevant Case Law
The Supreme Court of Pakistan in Shela Zia vs. Wapda (P.L.D. 1994 S.C. 693) held that environmental pollution caused by electromagnetic radiation of high voltage transmission lines of electricity posed a serious health hazard to the quality of life and was therefore violative of the right to life guaranteed by Article 9 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. The right to life includes the right to rehabilitation of bonded laborers who had been earlier released in pursuance of an order of the concerned court. In Article 9, deprivation of liberty means deprivation of the right to eat and sleep when one lies or to work or not work as and when one pleases, etc., and includes any assault on the body of a person for example, whipping, torture, blind folding, fettering, house arrest, solitary confinement, preventing a person from reading a book, religious or non-religious. In the absence of law or rule having the force of law authorizing it, such an act of invasion would be violative of Article 9.
๐ก Why this matters: This expansive interpretation of the right to life and liberty means that a wide range of state actions, from pollution to poor prison conditions to lack of basic necessities, can be challenged as constitutional violations, making Article 9 a powerful tool for protecting citizens' rights.
๐ Definition โ Doctrine of Allegiance: The tie or ligament which binds the subject to a state, in return for that protection which the state affords to the subject.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway is that a fundamental right is derived from Constitutional law, and the primary focus is Article 9, which guarantees that no person shall be deprived of life or liberty except in accordance with law. This right is not limited to mere survival but includes the right to live with human dignity, encompassing necessities like nutrition, shelter, and freedom of movement. Students must remember the ten kinds of Pakistani citizenship under the Pakistan Citizenship Act 1951 and the sources of human rights in international law. The landmark case of Shela Zia vs. Wapda is crucial for understanding how the right to life extends to environmental protection, while Sakhi Daler Khan vs. Superintendent reinforces that any deprivation of liberty must be strictly in accordance with the law. Finally, deprivation of liberty includes physical assaults like torture, whipping, and solitary confinement, all of which violate Article 9 if not authorized by law.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of a fundamental right as taught in the lecture?
- According to Article 9 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, under what condition can a person be deprived of life or liberty?
- List three of the ten kinds of Pakistani citizenship under the Pakistan Citizenship Act 1951.
- In the case of Shela Zia vs. Wapda, what specific activity was held to be a violation of Article 9?
- Does the right to life, as defined in the lecture, only mean protection from being killed? Explain its scope.