π Lecture 10 β Rule of Natural Justice
π Overview: This lecture explains the fundamental principles of natural justice, which are essential for fair decision-making in judicial, quasi-judicial, and administrative proceedings. It covers the two traditional rules, a newly evolved third principle, and the exceptions to these rules, emphasizing their role in preventing miscarriage of justice.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the Rule of Natural Justice and its two core principles: "No one should be made a judge in his own cause" and "No one can be condemned unheard." It then discusses the relationship between natural justice and statutory provisions, including key case law. The lecture introduces a third principleβthe requirement for speaking orders or reasoned decisionsβand delves into the concept of bias, including its kinds (pecuniary, personal, official). Finally, it outlines the exceptions to the rule of natural justice.
π Lecture Summary
What is Rule of Natural Justice?
The Rule of Natural Justice is founded on two principles: (1) Nemo in propria causa index ess debet (No one should be made a judge in his own cause) and (2) Audi alteram Partem (no one can be condemned unheard). It is described as a sound product of human civilization, a high law of nature, and intelligent common sense. In American Jurisprudence, it is called due process of Law. De Smith states that the rule expresses the close relationship between common law and moral principles distinguishing right from wrong. Megory J. describes natural justice as simple and elementary, distinct from complex, sophisticated, and technical justice. The aim of natural justice is to prevent miscarriage of justice. These two basic principles form the superstructure of judicial control of administration and are usually not made part of statutory laws. In the case Al Hya Noor-ul-Zaman v. AJ & K Zakat Council (NLR 1987 Civil 341), it was held that the principles of natural justice shall be presumed to be incorporated in every statute unless their application is excluded by express words.
Natural Justice & Statutory Provisions
Generally, no provision is found in any statute for the observance of the principles of Natural Justice by adjudicatory authorities. The question arises: whether the adjudicating authority is bound to follow these principles? The law became well-settled after the powerful pronouncement of Byles J. in Cooper v. Wandsworth Board of Works (1863) 14CB (NS) 180, wherein his Lordship observed: "A long course of decisions... establish that although there are no positive words in the statute requiring that the party shall be heard, yet the justice of the common law will supply the omission of the legislature." De Smith also states that where a statute authorizing interference with property or civil rights is silent on notice and hearing, courts will apply the rule as it is of universal application. It is against the rule of natural justice if the complainant, the judge, and the prosecution are one and the same person (PLD 1965 SC 64).
π Definition β Natural Justice: The principle that no one should be a judge in their own cause and no one can be condemned unheard; aimed at preventing miscarriage of justice. π‘ Why this matters: Even if a statute is silent, courts will supply the requirement of a fair hearing to prevent injustice.
Professor H.W.R Wadeβs view on rule of Natural Justice: Breach of natural justice will produce void decisions.
Against whom rule of Natural Justice can be enforced
The principle of natural justice is binding on all courts, judicial bodies, and quasi-judicial bodies. However, the important question is whether it applies to administrative authorities. The answer is: where the duty is merely administrative and not judicial or quasi-judicial, it is erroneous to say that the principle of natural justice will apply. The compulsion of hearing before passing an order, implied in the maxim Audi Alteram Partem, applies only to judicial or quasi-judicial proceedings. In Pakistan, courts have opined that unless the authority concerned is required by the law under which it functions to act judicially, there is no room for the application of the rule of natural justice.
π Definition β Quasi-judicial body: An authority that is required to act judicially, even if not a formal court, and must follow principles of natural justice.
Third principle of Natural Justice
Traditional English Law recognizes two principles: (1) Nemo in propria causa index ess debet and (2) Audi alteram Partem. However, due to the rapid growth of 'Administrative Law' and 'Constitutional Law', a third principle has evolved: (3) Speaking order or reasoned decision. A speaking order means an order speaking for itself; every order must contain reasons in its support. According to this principle, the party affected must know why and on what grounds the order was passed against him. There are three reasons why reasons for a decision are required to be disclosed: (1) The aggrieved party has a right to appeal to an appellate court on the ground that the decision is based on erroneous reasons. (2) The obligation to record reasons is a deterrent against arbitrary action taken by executive authority invested with judicial power.
π Definition β Speaking order: An order that contains the reasons for the decision, allowing the affected party to understand the basis of the order.
Bias or interest
The first requirement of the rule of natural justice is that a judge must be impartial, neutral, and free from bias. Bias is an intention to decide for or against one party without proper regard to the true merits of the case. Kinds of bias include: (1) Pecuniary bias (2) Personal bias (3) Official bias
Pecuniary bias: The least pecuniary interest in the subject matter of litigation disqualifies a person from acting as a judge. Griffeth and Street state that a pecuniary interest, however slight, will disqualify the judge. π Example: Dr. Bonham, a doctor of Cambridge University, was fined by the College of Physicians for practicing in London without a license. The statute provided that fines should go half to the King and half to the college. Coke C.J. disallowed the claim because the college had a pecuniary interest in its own judgment and was a judge in its own cause.
Personal bias: Personal bias arises due to some relationship between the authority deciding the issue and the party, inducing him to favor the case. The Supreme Court held in a case that a manager cannot conduct an inquiry against a worker arising from an allegation that the worker had beaten the manager.
Official bias: A mere general interest in the general object pursued will not disqualify a judge from deciding the matter. It is necessary that the judge must have a direct connection in the litigation. According to Griffeth and Street, only rarely will this bias invalidate proceedings.
π Definition β Bias: An intention to decide for or against a party without proper regard to the true merits of the case.
What are the exceptions to the rule of natural justice?
The rule of natural justice shall not be applied in the following situations: (1) Statutory exclusion (2) Exclusion in case of emergency (3) Exclusion in case of confidential inquiries (4) Exclusion in case of preventive action (5) Exclusion in case of necessity (6) Exclusion where no right of any person is infringed
Conclusion
It may be said that the rule of natural justice is beyond doubt a humanly principle intended to require law with the flare of fairness and to secure justice. Over the years, it has grown widely into a pervasive rule affecting a vast area of administrative action.
β Key Takeaways
The core of natural justice rests on two principles: no one can be a judge in their own cause (absence of bias) and no one can be condemned unheard (right to a fair hearing). These principles are presumed to be part of every statute unless expressly excluded. Courts have added a third requirement: that decisions be reasoned or speaking orders. Bias can be pecuniary (any financial interest disqualifies), personal (relationships bias), or official (only if there is a direct connection). Exceptions to natural justice include statutory exclusion, emergencies, and where no rights are infringed.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two traditional principles of natural justice?
- In which landmark case was it established that courts will supply the omission of the legislature regarding a hearing?
- What is a "speaking order" and why are reasons for a decision required?
- What is the difference between pecuniary bias and personal bias? Provide an example of each.
- List three exceptions where the rule of natural justice will not be applied.
π Lecture 11 β Administrative Adjudication
π Overview: This lecture examines the growing phenomenon of administrative adjudication, where executive bodies rather than traditional courts resolve disputes between the state and individuals or between private parties. It explains why this shift is necessary in modern governance and balances the benefits against the significant harms and procedural shortcomings of such systems.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first defines administrative adjudication and explores multiple reasons for its growth, including the overload of traditional courts, the need for specialized expertise, lower costs, and flexibility to apply policy considerations. It then systematically presents eleven distinct harms or problems associated with administrative adjudication, such as lack of uniform procedures, absence of natural justice, official bias, political influence, anonymity of decisions, and unpredictability.
π Lecture Summary
Administrative Adjudication
As per the constitution, it is the duty of the traditional courts to dispense justice, but the courts cannot do this in every walk of life. Hence, tribunals are given this task of dispensation of justice. Therefore, we see that the majority of the decisions affecting citizens are given by administrative agencies.
Reasons for the growth of administrative adjudication
Adjudication on a question of law or question of fact between individuals or between the state and an individual is the core business of traditional courts. But due to the increase in the role of modern government, the executive organ of a state also exercises adjudicating power. Therefore, it is a wrong notion that traditional courts have monopolistic adjudicating power in a state.
These days, by the side of traditional courts, there are many administrative bodies that are exercising adjudicating power in a state. Administrative adjudication is now an inevitable part of modern government. The trend is functionally useful, hence being practiced in Britain, USA, and in all democratic states including Pakistan.
Modern government has increased its governance role manifold, trying to control labor, taxation, excise, financial, health, corporate, and all other like issues. When modern government handles these areas, it comes into conflict with individuals or corporate entities β for example, taxation issues. To resolve these issues, the executive itself gives an executive adjudication mechanism, and traditional courts are not involved. Thus, circumstances necessitate the growth of administrative adjudication.
The administrative adjudication system is a relatively low-cost, easily accessible mechanism of speedy administrative justice. Another cogent reason for its growth is that traditional courts are already stuffed with a huge stock of pending cases, and the adjudication process is already very slow. Had the other administrative adjudication matters been sent to the system of traditional court adjudication, the traditional courts would have collapsed.
It is indeed the expansion of technical, scientific, economic, and other similar growth of civilized society that government's functions have increased manifold. Hence, without administrative adjudication, a state cannot now run its affairs nor do good governance.
Another reason in favor of administrative adjudication is that in traditional courts, the ordeal of litigation is very high, while in administrative adjudication it is relatively low. Political philosophers also give a reason for growth: sometimes a situation arises which is resolved not by applying law but by applying consideration of policy. Such questions arise in relation to taxation, labor, excise, foreign exchange, and preventive detention. As a matter of fact, such policies cannot be applied in traditional courts but only under administrative adjudication, as administrative tribunals are somewhat under the influence of government.
Judges of traditional courts do not entertain the idea of policy conflicting with law; they always follow law. Administrative adjudication is also favored on the ground that a judge of a traditional court is a generalist, while in a modern state, due to administrative process, expert knowledge is required to handle issues involving special knowledge like taxation and accounting. Hence, administrative adjudication is inevitable. An expert is in a better position to handle such kinds of issues.
Other reasons for the growth of administrative adjudication are that they are less expensive, more expeditious, and free from procedural technicalities. Finally, it may be said that administrative adjudicatory bodies have grown not from political philosophy but from practical necessity. Therefore, to cater to the need of civilized modern society where the role of government has increased manifold, the role of administrative adjudication is practically beneficial.
Harms of administrative adjudication
Following are the harms or problems of administrative adjudication:
(1) Ordinary citizens fear that all tribunals dispensing administrative adjudication are anti-legal in mindset.
(2) A variety of procedures are adopted by a variety of tribunals; there is no uniform procedure adopted in all administrative tribunals. Sometimes procedure is laid in the Act, or sometimes it is left to be determined by the administrative agency.
(3) Sometimes an administrative agency is given the power of a civil court to compel attendance and production of documents.
(4) In some cases, an administrative agency does not follow the rule of natural justice, which is a wrong deviation from a universal principle based on or derived from human nature.
(5) In administrative tribunals, no uniform system of appeal is applicable. Every tribunal has its own procedure β sometimes appeal is preferred to a higher authority, or sometimes appeal is made to the traditional High Court.
(6) Not all administrative tribunals publish their decisions; therefore, they avoid public criticism.
(7) It is a rule of natural justice that in litigation there must be a clear aspect of predictability of judicial decision. Administrative adjudication lacks this predictability.
(8) There is also a glaring factor of anonymity of decision involved in administrative adjudication. No one knows where the decision will come from. Sometimes it is seen that one fine morning a litigant receives a communication or notice that the President or the Governor is pleased to give this decision.
(9) Under administrative adjudication, the law of evidence is not strictly applied. Usually, no statement and cross-examination is done on witnesses.
(10) Under administrative adjudication, official bias also works at its peak. It is seen that if there is a case between an individual and an administrative agency, the result is normally seen in favor of the agency.
(11) In administrative adjudication, there is always political influence on judges of the tribunal.
β Key Takeaways
Administrative adjudication has grown out of practical necessity because traditional courts are overburdened, expensive, and lack the specialized expertise needed for modern technical disputes like taxation and labor issues. However, this system comes with serious drawbacks: there is no uniform procedure or appeal system, rules of natural justice are often ignored, decisions are unpredictable and anonymous, and official bias and political influence frequently tilt outcomes in favor of the state. Students must remember that while administrative adjudication is inevitable for efficient governance, it fundamentally compromises traditional legal safeguards such as predictability, public scrutiny, cross-examination, and judicial independence.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the main reasons why traditional courts cannot handle all disputes in a modern state, necessitating the growth of administrative adjudication?
- Explain why "consideration of policy" can be applied in administrative tribunals but not in traditional courts.
- List at least four specific harms of administrative adjudication mentioned in the lecture.
- What does the lecture mean by "anonymity of decision" in the context of administrative adjudication?
- What is the difference between a "generalist" judge in a traditional court and the expertise found in administrative tribunals?
π Lecture 12 β Delegated legislation
π Overview: This lecture explains delegated legislation β laws made by bodies other than Parliament under powers granted by an enabling Act. It covers why such legislation is necessary in modern governance, its various forms, advantages and disadvantages, and the controls that exist to prevent misuse of delegated powers.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and purpose of delegated legislation, its six types including Orders in Council, regulations, rules, schemes, directions, and byelaws, followed by the advantages and disadvantages of using delegated legislation, the factors responsible for its growth in modern states, and finally the parliamentary and judicial controls over delegated legislation with particular emphasis on the doctrine of ultra vires.
π Lecture Summary
Delegated legislation:
Delegated legislation is legislation that is passed otherwise than in an Act of Parliament. An enabling Act or the parent Act confers a power to make delegated legislation on a Government Minister or another person or body. Several thousand pieces of delegated legislation are made each year, compared with only a few dozen Acts of Parliament.
Delegated legislation can be used for a wide variety of purposes, ranging from relatively narrow, technical matters such as fixing the date on which an Act of Parliament will come into force, or setting the level of fees payable for a public service, e.g. the issue of a passport, to filling in the detail of how an Act setting out broad principles will be implemented in practice.
π Definition β Delegated Legislation: legislation passed otherwise than in an Act of Parliament, made by a person or body under powers conferred by an enabling Act. π Formula: Enabling/Parent Act β Confers Power β Minister/Body β Makes Delegated Legislation π Example: Fixing the date an Act comes into force or setting passport fees are matters dealt with by delegated legislation rather than a full Act of Parliament.
Types of delegated legislation
(1) Orders in Council are made by the Queen on the advice of the Privy Council. These are generally used where it would be inappropriate for the order to be made by a Minister, for example where the matter is of constitutional significance such as transferring powers and functions from one Minister to another, or bringing into force emergency powers to be exercised by Ministers.
Orders of Council are made by the Lords of the Privy Council in their own right and most commonly relate to the regulation of professional bodies and the higher education sector, over which the Privy Council exercises a supervisory function.
Orders are usually made by Ministers and are an exercise of executive powers, for example to create or dissolve a public body. Commencement Orders are used to set the date on which an Act, or part of an Act, comes into force.
π Definition β Orders in Council: delegated legislation made by the Queen on advice of the Privy Council, used for matters of constitutional significance or emergencies.
(2) Regulations are also usually made by Ministers. Regulations are the means by which substantive and detailed law is made, for example setting out in detail how an Act is to be implemented. Regulations made under the European Communities Act 1972 are the means by which the Government most often implements European law within the United Kingdom.
π Definition β Regulations: the means by which substantive and detailed law is made, showing how an Act is to be implemented.
(3) Rules set out procedures, for example rules governing court procedures, or the way in which the Patent Office deals with applications. Rules may be made by Ministers or, if specified in the parent Act, a senior judge.
(4) Schemes: for example, schemes made by the Charity Commission to amend how a charity is governed.
(5) Directions are a means by which Ministers give legally binding instructions to a public body about the way it exercises its functions.
(6) Byelaws are laws of limited application, usually restricted to certain places, made by local authorities or certain other bodies (for example, train operating companies or the National Trust for Places of Historic Interest or Natural Beauty) to control the activities of the people in public spaces, such as in public parks or on board public transport.
π Definition β Byelaws: laws of limited application, usually restricted to certain places, made by local authorities or certain bodies to control activities in public spaces.
Advantages and disadvantages of delegated legislation
Advantages:
Firstly, it allows laws to be enacted without using up scarce Parliamentary time on technical matters, for example the fine detail of a public sector pension scheme or the precise design of traffic signs, thereby freeing Parliament to discuss matters of broad principle and policy.
Secondly, it allows laws relating to technical matters to be prepared by those with the relevant expert knowledge.
Thirdly, delegated legislation is flexible enough to deal speedily with changing circumstances, for example increasing costs of services, developments in scientific knowledge or minor changes in policy. This also makes it invaluable in emergencies when very swift action is required β delegated legislation made under emergency powers can be drafted, enacted and brought into force in a matter of hours rather than the days, weeks or months that would be required to pass an Act of Parliament.
Disadvantages:
Delegated legislation can be criticized on the grounds that it is subject to less parliamentary scrutiny than primary legislation and thereby may potentially be used by the Government in ways which Parliament had not intended or appreciated when it conferred the power.
Another disadvantage is in the sheer volume of laws that are passed as delegated legislation. Because of this bulk, there is normally little publicity or knowledge about the changes that are being made.
π‘ Why this matters: While delegated legislation saves Parliamentary time and allows expert, flexible law-making, it risks being used beyond what Parliament originally intended and often escapes public attention due to its sheer volume.
Why delegated legislation is need of a modern state?
The need of delegated legislation is based on the fact that the scope of modern government has been widened extensively. Urgencies, complexities and details of governance are so complicated and manifold that delegated legislation seems pragmatic and practicable. It is said that law making is not a turn key project, ready made in all details and to grasp the dynamics of legislation, delegated legislation is the real solution.
Factors responsible for the growth of delegated legislation:
(1) Even if members of Parliament work day and night they cannot meet the legislative need of the society, hence delegated legislation is a compulsive necessity of a modern state.
(2) Modern day government goes through perplexed and technical issues; they are close to ground realities which the legislature is not; therefore legislature keeps itself to just policy making and delegates the power of legislation to government or executive.
(3) Parent legislation is not easily amendable whereas delegated legislation is easily amendable or tailorable according to the practical needs of the society.
(4) Delegated legislation is an easy source of legislation in crisis situations.
Controls over delegated legislation
There are both parliamentary and judicial controls over delegated legislation. The parliamentary controls, by which delegated legislation made by Statutory Instrument may either need to be approved by a vote of each House of Parliament before it is made, or be subject to a veto by either House within a certain period of time after it is made.
Judicial control is exercised through the means of judicial review. Because delegated legislation is made by a person exercising a power conferred by an Act of Parliament for a specified purpose, rather than by Parliament exercising its sovereign law-making powers, it can be struck down by the courts if they conclude that it is ultra vires. This would be the case if the Government attempts to use delegated legislation for a purpose not envisioned by the parent Act, or if the legislation is an unreasonable use of the power conferred by the Act, or if pre-conditions imposed by the Act (for example, consultation with certain organizations) have not been satisfied.
π Definition β Ultra Vires: beyond the power; a legal doctrine allowing courts to strike down delegated legislation made for a purpose not envisioned by the parent Act. π Definition β Judicial Review: a courtβs power to review the actions of the other branches of government.
π Example: If a Minister uses delegated legislation to impose taxes when the parent Act only allowed regulation of public health, the courts would strike it down as ultra vires.
Note: There is a constitutional convention that the House of Lords does not vote against delegated legislation.
β Key Takeaways
Delegated legislation is law made by government ministers or other bodies under powers granted by a parent Act, not by Parliament directly. The six types are Orders in Council, regulations, rules, schemes, directions, and byelaws β each serving different purposes from constitutional orders to local byelaws. Its main advantages are saving Parliamentary time, using expert knowledge, and handling emergencies swiftly; its main disadvantages are reduced scrutiny and risk of misuse. Delegated legislation has grown because Parliament cannot handle all legislative needs, government has technical expertise, and delegated law is easily amendable. Controls exist through parliamentary approval/veto and judicial review under the ultra vires doctrine, where courts strike down delegated legislation used beyond the parent Act's purpose.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between an Order in Council and an Order of Council?
- Name three advantages and two disadvantages of delegated legislation.
- What does "ultra vires" mean in the context of delegated legislation?
- List four factors responsible for the growth of delegated legislation in modern states.
- What are the two main types of controls over delegated legislation and how do they work?
π Lecture 13 β Controls & Safeguards as Regard Delegated Legislation
π Overview: This lecture examines how delegated legislative powers are controlled to prevent abuse by the executive. It explores judicial, legislative, and other controls, emphasizing that while delegated legislation is a practical necessity, safeguards are essential to protect civil liberties and ensure the lawful exercise of power.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with definitions of delegation doctrine, delegate, delegator, and delegated legislation, then discusses the modern acceptance of delegated legislation alongside the risk of executive abuse. It covers the finding of a middle course between two conflicting principles, and then details three main categories of control: judicial control (substantive and procedural ultra vires), legislative control (laying on the table and scrutiny committees), and other controls (precise limits and trustworthy authorities).
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
The delegation doctrine is the principle that legislature has the ability to transfer its legislative power to another government branch, especially the executive. A delegate is an organ of a state who acts for another organ of a state. A delegator is one who delegates a responsibility to another. Delegated legislation is a rule or order, having legal force, usually issued by an administrative agency or executive organ of a state.
In modern world, it has been accepted that legislative power can validly and legitimately be delegated to the executive within permissible limits. However, there is a clear danger that the executive may abuse these powers for illegal or unreasonable purposes and may usurp civil rights and civil liberties of individuals. The Committee on Minister's powers stated: "though the practice of delegated legislation is not bad, risk of abuse are incidental to it and therefore safeguards are required if the country is to continue the advantages of the practice without suffering from its inherent dangers."
It is important to note that there is no inherent power of delegation in the legislature. The constitution simply confers power and imposes a duty on the legislature to enact laws. If the legislature delegates and crosses the implied limits, failing to perform essential legislative functions by determining legislative policy, it risks the enabling Act being declared ultra vires the constitution.
Finding Middle Course between two Conflicting Principles
Two basic principles conflict: one permitting wide delegation power for practical reasons to the executive, while the other argues that no new legislative bodies should be set up by transferring essential legislative functions to administrative authorities. Finding a middle course between these two is the need of the day.
Controls on Delegated Legislation
Control on delegated legislation is divided into three categories: (1) Judicial control, (2) Legislative control, and (3) Other control.
Judicial Control
Delegated legislation falls under the purview of judicial review. Courts are competent to decide the validity of delegated legislation. Two sets are applied: (i) Substantive ultra vires (ii) Procedural ultra vires
Substantive ultra vires: When a subordinate legislation goes beyond what the delegate is authorized to make law, it is known as substantive ultra vires. Powers delegated by statute are limited by its terms and subordinate to its objects. The delegate must act in good faith, reasonably, intra vires the powers granted, and on relevant consideration of material facts.
π Definition β Ultra vires: [Latin for "beyond the powers"] An action that exceeds the legal authority or power granted to a person or body.
Grounds of Substantive ultra vires: Delegated legislation may be challenged on these grounds: (1) Where parent Act is unconstitutional (2) Where delegated legislation is unconstitutional (3) Where delegated legislation is inconsistent with the parent Act (4) Unreasonableness (5) Malafide (bad faith) (6) Exclusion of judicial review (7) Retrospective operation
π Example: In a case, certain employees were promoted to high post in accordance with the rule. Thereafter, a correction slip was added with retrospective effect, wiping out not only the promotion of the employee but even length of service for about nine years. The rule was held to be arbitrary (illogical; capricious; founded on prejudice rather than on reason) since it was not made to meet exigencies (a state of emergency) of service and there was no real objective or purpose behind it.
Effect of ultra vires act: An ultra vires action is null and void once the court declares that some administrative act is legally zero.
Procedural ultra vires: When a subordinate legislation does not comply with certain procedural requirements prescribed by the parent or enabling Act, it is known as procedural ultra vires. Where the enabling act requires the delegate to observe a prescribed procedure (such as holding consultation with particular bodies, publication of draft rules, or laying them before Parliament), it is obligatory on the delegate to comply. Failure may invalidate the rule.
Procedural requirements: Two basic procedural requirements exist: (1) Publication (2) Consultation
Publication: It is a fundamental principle of law that ignorance of law is no excuse (ignorantia juris non excusat), but there is an equally established principle that the public must have access to the law. Domatt's observation: "All laws ought to be known or at least laid open to the knowledge of the world in such a manner that no one may claim that he was ignorant of the law." For Acts made by Parliament, sufficient publicity occurs through bill introduction, printing, select committee reference, and mass media coverage. Jain & Jain stated: "it is essential that people are not caught on the wrong foot in ignorance of the rules applicable to them in a given situation."
π‘ Why this matters: Without proper publication, citizens cannot know their legal obligations, making the principle "ignorance of law is no excuse" fundamentally unfair.
Legislative Control on Delegated Legislation
Where Parliament delegates legislative powers to the executive, it must also see that those powers are properly exercised. Jain & Jain stated that since it is the legislature which delegates power, it is primarily for it to supervise and control the actual exercise of those powers and ensure against the danger of objectionable, abusive, and unwarranted use.
The underlying object of parliamentary control is to keep watch over rule-making authorities and provide an opportunity to criticize them if there is abuse of power.
Legislative control can be effectively exercised by: (1) Laying on the table (2) Scrutiny committee
Laying on the table: In almost all Commonwealth countries, this procedure is followed. It serves two purposes: firstly, it informs the legislature as to what rules have been made; secondly, it provides an opportunity for legislators to question or challenge the rules already made or proposed.
Scrutiny committees: Since laying on the table has not always been mandatory, scrutiny committees are established to strengthen parliamentary control. The committee's function is to scrutinize and report to the respective houses whether the delegated legislation was done according to the law or constitutional parameters.
Conclusion: Parliamentary control is not entirely effective. Wade says: "one of the features of the 20th century has been a shift of the constitutional centre of gravity away from Parliament and towards the executive."
Other Controls on Delegated Legislation
Besides judicial and parliamentary control, other controls include:
- Precisely limiting the power of the delegate: The precise limits of law-making power should be expressly defined in clear and express language by the statute conferring it. When discretion is conferred, its limits should be defined with equal clearness.
- Court interpretation: Courts should interpret the law so that no blanket powers can be exercised by the executive while making rules, regulations, or bye laws.
- Trustworthy authorities: Only trustworthy authorities (e.g., Federal Government, Provincial Government) should be delegated power, as these authorities will exercise the power in a reasonable manner.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that while delegated legislation is a practical necessity in modern governance, it carries inherent risks of executive abuse. Three main categories of control exist: judicial control through substantive and procedural ultra vires review, legislative control through laying procedures and scrutiny committees, and other controls including precisely defining limits of power and delegating only to trustworthy authorities. The effect of any ultra vires action is nullity. Ultimately, despite these safeguards, parliamentary control is not entirely effective, as constitutional power has increasingly shifted from Parliament to the executive over the 20th century.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the distinction between substantive ultra vires and procedural ultra vires in delegated legislation?
- What are the seven grounds on which delegated legislation may be challenged for substantive ultra vires?
- What are the two basic procedural requirements that must be complied with to avoid procedural ultra vires?
- What are the two main methods of exercising legislative control over delegated legislation?
- What is the legal effect of an ultra vires act once declared by a court?