π Lecture 19 β Definition of Arrest: Fundamental Right: Safeguards as to Arrest & Detention
π Overview: This lecture defines the concept of arrest and outlines the constitutional protections afforded to arrested persons under Pakistani law. It explains the distinction between arrest with and without a warrant, details the rights of the accused under Article 10 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, and covers the provisions related to preventive detention. Understanding these safeguards is crucial for ensuring that the fundamental right to liberty is not arbitrarily violated.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with a formal definition of arrest and its explanation, tracing its historical roots back to the Magna Carta and Petition of Rights. It then distinguishes between arrest with a warrant and arrest without a warrant, specifying what constitutes an arrestable offence. The core of the lecture details Article 10 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, covering the rights of arrested persons, the law of preventive detention, the definition and role of the appropriate Review Board, communication of grounds, furnishing of documents, maximum detention periods, and the constitutional right to file a writ of habeas corpus against illegal detention.
π Lecture Summary
Definition of arrest
"Arrest is the restraint of a man's person or liberty, obliging him to be obedient to law." Explanation: Arrest involves the physical seizure of a person's liberty by using force. Normally, Police or FIA has powers to arrest a person on account of some criminal offence done by a person. The provisions of Magna Carta 1215 and Petition of Rights 1627 provide that no man may be arrested or imprisoned except under due process of law.
π Definition β Magna Carta 1215: (Latin for 'Great Charter') The English Charter that King John Granted to the Barons in 1215, generally regarded as one of the great Common Law documents and as the foundation of constitutional liberties.
π Definition β Petition of Rights 1627: One of the great charters of English Liberty establishing that no man be compelled to make any gift, loan, benevolence, tax, or such like charge, without common consent by act of Parliament.
π Definition β Due Process of Law: The conduct of legal proceedings according to established rules and principles for the protection and enforcement of private rights.
Usual course for the Police making arrest
Usually before making arrest, Police formally applies to a concerned Magistrate for issuance of a warrant for a person's arrest; the warrants are granted by the Magistrate on solid grounds and not otherwise. A 'general warrant' which does not contain the name of a person to be arrested is illegal.
π Definition β Warrant: to authorize.
Arrest without warrant
The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 provides a distinction between arrestable offences for which no warrant of arrest is necessary and non-arrestable offences for which a warrant of arrest is necessary. An arrestable offence is: (i) Any offence for which the sentence is fixed by law; that is, murder and treason; (ii) Offences carrying a penalty of five years or more imprisonment; (iii) Various listed statutory offences.
Article 10 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973
(1) No person shall be detained in custody without being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds of such arrest, nor shall be denied the right to consult, and be defended by a legal practitioner of his choice. (2) Every person who is arrested and detained in custody shall be produced before a Magistrate within twenty four hours of such arrest, excluding the time necessary for the journey from the place of arrest to the court of the nearest magistrate. (3) The conditions contained in clauses (1) and (2) of Article 10 do not apply to any person who is arrested or detained under any law providing for preventive detention.
Persons to be dealt under the law of preventive detention
Clause 4 of Article 10 provides that no law providing for preventive detention can be made except "to deal with persons acting in a manner prejudicial to the integrity, security or defense of Pakistan or external affairs of Pakistan or public order or the maintenance of supplies or services." The article further provides that no such law shall authorize the detention of a person for a period exceeding three months unless the appropriate Review Board has afforded him an opportunity of being heard in person, reviewed his case and reported, before the expiration of the said period, that there is, in its opinion, sufficient cause for such detention. If the detention is continued after the period of three months, the Review Board must review his case and report before the expiration of each period of three months that there is sufficient cause for such detention.
π Definition β Prejudicial: detrimental; harmful. π Definition β Integrity: honor.
Definition of appropriate Review Board
A Board, in the case of a person detained under Federal Law, appointed by the Chief Justice of Pakistan and consisting of a Chairman and two other persons, each of whom is or has been a Judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court. In the case of a person detained under Provincial Law, a Board appointed by the Chief Justice of the High Court concerned and consisting of a Chairman and two other persons each of whom is or has been a Judge of a High Court. The opinion of the Review Board is "expressed in terms of the views of the majority of its members".
Communication of grounds of preventive detention
Under clause (5) of Article 10, when any person is detained under a law providing for preventive detention, the authority making the order shall, within fifteen days from such detention, communicate to such person the grounds on which the order has been made, and shall afford him the earliest opportunity of making a representation against the order. However, the authority may refuse to disclose facts which it considers to be against the public interest to disclose.
Furnishing of documents to Review Board
Under clause (6) of Article 10, it is incumbent on the authority making the order to furnish to the appropriate Review Board all documents relevant to the case unless a certificate, signed by a Secretary to the Government concerned, to the effect that it is not in the public interest to furnish any documents, is produced.
Maximum limit for period of detention
Clause (7) of Article 10 provides that within a period of twenty four months commencing on the day of his first detention in pursuance of an order made under a law providing for preventive detention, no person shall be detained for more than a total period of eight months in the case of a person acting in a manner prejudicial to public order and twelve months in any other case. However, this condition does not apply to any person who is employed by, or works for, or acts on instructions received from the enemy or who is acting or attempting to act in a manner prejudicial to the integrity, security or defence of Pakistan or who commits or attempts to commit any act which amounts to an anti-national activity as defined in Federal Law or is a member of any association which indulges in any such anti-national activity.
Rights of arrested persons
There are four constitutional rights of an accused person: (1) He shall not be detained in custody without being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds of his arrest. (2) He shall have the right to consult and to be represented by a lawyer of his own choice. (3) He has a right to be produced before the nearest Magistrate within 24 hours of his arrest, excluding the time spent on journey. (4) He is not to be detained in custody beyond the said period of 24 hours without the authority of the court.
Writ of habeas corpus against the persons found illegally detained by public authority
The High Court can issue directions in the nature of habeas corpus if a person is found to be illegally detained by Police. An order in the nature of habeas corpus is intended to preserve the liberty of the subject and is a safeguard against unlawful or improper manner of detention. This applies where no criminal case is registered against the detainee, he is handcuffed and fettered without any entry in the Roznamcha relating to his arrest, or he is not the accused in an FIR or is found confined in the precinct of the Police Station without entering his arrest in the daily diary. Proceedings in a habeas corpus petition are summary in character.
Who can file writ of habeas corpus?
Article 199 of the Constitution makes clear that a writ of habeas corpus need not necessarily be sought by an aggrieved person. A petitioner being an Advocate and a Director of a Human Rights Organization was even competent and had locus standi to file a writ of habeas corpus.
β Key Takeaways
The fundamental right of an arrested person includes being informed of the grounds of arrest, consulting and being defended by a lawyer of his choice, and being produced before a Magistrate within 24 hours. Article 10 provides a comprehensive framework for both ordinary arrests and preventive detention, with mandatory review by a Board of senior judges for detentions exceeding three months. The maximum period of preventive detention is strictly limited, with an eight-month cap for public order cases and a twelve-month cap for others, though exceptions exist for anti-national activities. The writ of habeas corpus is a powerful remedy against illegal detention and can be filed by any concerned person, including advocates and human rights activists, not just the aggrieved party.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Define an arrest under law and identify the two key historical documents that established the principle of "due process of law" for arrests.
- What is the primary distinction between an arrest with a warrant and an arrest without a warrant according to the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984?
- According to Article 10(2) of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, within what time frame must an arrested person be produced before a Magistrate, and what time is excluded from this calculation?
- Describe the composition of the appropriate Review Board for a person detained under a Federal law providing for preventive detention.
- Under Article 10(7), what are the maximum total periods of preventive detention for a person acting prejudicial to public order and for other cases?
π Lecture 20 β Fundamental Rights β (1) Protection Against Double Punishment
π Overview: This lecture explains the constitutional principle that no person can be prosecuted or punished more than once for the same offence, as enshrined in Article 13(a) of the Pakistan Constitution 1973. It also explores the related legal doctrines, statutory provisions, and judicial interpretations that define the scope and limits of this protection, establishing it as a fundamental right.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the protection against double punishment under Article 13(a) of the Pakistan Constitution, explaining the principle of autrefois convict and autrefois acquit from the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898. It also examines the related provision in Section 26 of the General Clauses Act 1897, the rule against double jeopardy (based on the Common Law maxim), and clarifies that subsequent trial for a "distinct" or "different" offence is not barred. Judicial interpretation through the case of Alamdar Hussain v. Abdul Baseer Qureshi (PLD 1978 SC 121) and commentary by Muhammad Munir are also included.
π Lecture Summary
Article 13 (a) β Protection Against Double Punishment
Article 13 (a) of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provides that βno person shall be prosecuted or punished for the same offence more than onceβ. The word Prosecuted means to put on trial. The lecture explains that Article 13 (a) raises to constitutional status the principle of βautrefois convictβ and βautrefois acquitβ embodied in Section 403 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898.
π Definition β Prosecuted: to put on trial π Definition β Convicted: found guilty π Definition β Acquitted: not found guilty π Definition β Bar: stop
Section 403 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898
This section of the Cr.P.C. 1898 provides the statutory basis for the protection. It states that a person who has once been tried by a Competent Court for an offence and convicted or acquitted of such offence, shall while such conviction or acquittal remains in force, not be liable to be tried again for the same offence nor on the same facts for any other offence (for which a different charge might have been made under Section 236, or for which he might have been convicted under Section 237 of the Cr.P.C. 1898).
Section 26 of the General Clauses Act, 1897
The principle also appears in a modified form in Section 26 of the General Clauses Act, 1897. This section provides that where an act or omission constitutes an offence under two or more enactments, then the offender shall be liable to be prosecuted and punished under either or any one of those enactments but shall not be liable to be punished twice for the same offence.
π Definition β Act: do something π Definition β Omission: lapse; slip π Definition β Enactments: Laws made by Parliament
Exception β Subsequent Trial for a Distinct Offence
These provisions, however, do not bar subsequent trial for a βdistinctβ or βdifferentβ or βotherβ offence as described in subsections (2) & (3) of Section 403 of the Criminal Procedure Code 1898. This means that the protection only applies when the second trial is for the same offence; a different offence can still be tried.
Rule Against Double Jeopardy
This principle is described by Americans as the rule against double jeopardy, which is based on the Common Law maxim: βnemo debet bis vexari pro una et eadem causaβ. This means "no one should be troubled twice for the same cause." When a criminal charge has been once adjudicated upon by a Court of competent jurisdiction, that adjudication is final, whether it takes the form of an acquittal or a conviction.
π Definition β Jeopardy: trouble π Definition β Adjudicated: decision given
Judicial Interpretation (Alamdar Hussain v. Abdul Baseer Qureshi)
Dr. Nasim Hassan Shah, J. of the Supreme Court of Pakistan in Alamdar Hussain v. Abdul Baseer Qureshi PLD 1978 S.C. 121 held that the word βprosecutionβ in Article 13 (a) of the Pakistan Constitution includes βpunishmentβ. The result is that fresh prosecution for the same offence would be barred only where the prosecution was finally concluded and ended either in acquittal or conviction. π‘ Why this matters: This interpretation confirms that both being tried again and being punished again for the same offence are prohibited, but the prohibition only applies after the first prosecution has been completed with a final verdict.
Commentary by Muhammad Munir
According to Muhammad Munir (Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan Ed. 1975 p.128), Article 13 (a) βraises to a constitutional status the principle of autrefois convict and autrefois acquit embodied in section 403 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898 and a part of Section 132 of the Evidence Act 1872.β He further states, βthe present Article prohibits both double prosecution and double punishment for the same offence.β
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that Article 13(a) of the Pakistan Constitution establishes a fundamental right against being prosecuted or punished twice for the same offence. This right is based on the autrefois convict/acquit principle from the Cr.P.C. and the common law rule against double jeopardy. However, a key exception is that this bar does not apply if the subsequent trial is for a distinct or different offence. Finally, the Supreme Court in Alamdar Hussain clarified that the word "prosecution" in Article 13(a) includes "punishment," and the bar only applies once the first prosecution has concluded in a final verdict (acquittal or conviction).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does Article 13(a) of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provide regarding double punishment?
- Explain the legal terms autrefois convict and autrefois acquit.
- What is the exception to the rule against double punishment, as mentioned in the lecture?
- What does the Common Law maxim 'nemo debet bis vexari pro una et eadem causa' mean?
- According to the case of Alamdar Hussain v. Abdul Baseer Qureshi, when is a fresh prosecution for the same offence barred?
π Lecture 21 β Fundamental Rights ---- Protection Against Self Incrimination
π Overview: This lecture examines the constitutional protection against self-incrimination under Article 13(b) of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. It explains who qualifies as an accused person entitled to this protection, and discusses how fundamental rights are enforced through the superior courts under Articles 184 and 199.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the principle of protection against self-incrimination as embodied in Article 13(b), its comparison with the American Fifth Amendment, the conflict between Article 13 and Article 44 of Qanun-e-Shahdat 1984, the definition of who is an "accused person" entitled to this protection, the enforcement of fundamental rights through High Court jurisdiction under Article 199, and the conditions under which courts must grant relief for violations of fundamental rights.
π Lecture Summary
Protection against Self Incrimination
Article 13 (b) of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 provides that βno person shall, when accused of an offence, be compelled to be a witness against himselfβ. This provision embodies the principle of protection against compulsion, which is one of the fundamental canons of the British system of criminal jurisprudence. The same principle has been adopted by the American system and incorporated in the Federal Constitution; the Fifth Amendment of the American Constitution provides that βno person shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himselfβ.
Article 44 of Qanun-e-Shahdat, 1984 lays down that βall accused, including an accomplice, shall be liable to cross-examinationβ. Both these provisions, in so far as they make an accused person compellable witness and liable to compulsory cross examination, are ultra vires (going beyond the limit) Article 13 of the Constitution. For if any law compels an accused person to give evidence and such evidence will tend directly or indirectly to be self incriminatory, that law to that extent will be unconstitutional by reason of this Article.
π Definition β Ultra vires: going beyond the limit or scope of legal authority π Definition β Prosecution: trial; hearing before a court π Definition β Accused: person on whom blame is laid upon
Who is given protection under Article 13?
The protection conferred by Article 13 is confined only to an accused person, that is a person against whom a formal accusation relating to the commission of an offence has been leveled, which in the normal course may result in the prosecution. The mere lodging of information or conducting investigation against a person does not make him an accused person.
It is not necessary, in order to avail the protection, that actual trial should have commenced before the Court. A person against whom an F.I.R. (First Information Report) has been lodged and investigation ordered can claim the benefit of the protection because he is an accused person.
π‘ Why this matters: This distinction is critical β a person under investigation alone (without formal accusation) cannot claim the protection against self-incrimination, but once an FIR is lodged, that person becomes an "accused" and the protection applies.
Enforcement of Fundamental Rights
Provision of Article 199 (2) and 184 of the Constitution have set the superior courts with the responsibility to enforce the fundamental rights in case of complaint about their violation. Aggrieved (distressed; upset; annoyed) citizens, on the basis of the rule ex debito justitiae as a matter of right, can claim the redress of his grievance and for the enforcement of his fundamental rights, and there is little room for the discretion left in such cases.
The aim of having declaration of fundamental rights in the Constitution is that such rights should be regarded as inviolable under all conditions. According to Clause (1) (C) of this Article, the fundamental rights guaranteed in the Constitution are not mere a pious (virtuous) enunciation (articulation) of the principle on which the constitution is based but are made specifically justifiable in the clause under reference. They are not liable to be abridged (shortened) by any legislative or executive orders except by virtue of the provisions of the Constitution.
π Definition β Ex debito justitiae: as a matter of right; without discretion
Law denying fundamental right
Where an order is passed by the Government which amounts to denial of fundamental rights, the court must grant proper relief to the party. It cannot refuse relief on the ground that the Government could amend the law to bring it in conformity with fundamental rights.
The power of the High Court to issue directions, orders and writs is not limited to the writs but extends to making of order restraining or directing any authority or Government discharging executive function. The High Court, while enforcing fundamental rights, is competent to direct that monetary compensation be paid to the victim of violation of Fundamental Rights.
Constitutional jurisdiction of High Court under Article 199 could not be invoked by anyone who was guilty of bad faith and of unconscionable conduct. The right was in the nature of ex debito justitiae, but would only be granted if the petitioner could show that their conduct was not such as to disentitle him of such relief.
β Key Takeaways
Article 13(b) protects only an accused person from being compelled to be a witness against himself β mere investigation without formal accusation does not qualify. Article 44 of Qanun-e-Shahdat 1984 is ultra vires Article 13 because it compels accused persons to give evidence and submit to cross-examination. Superior courts under Articles 199 and 184 have the duty to enforce fundamental rights, and aggrieved citizens can claim redress as a matter of right (ex debito justitiae). Courts must grant relief for denial of fundamental rights and cannot refuse on the ground that the government could amend the law. Monetary compensation can be awarded to victims of fundamental rights violations, but the petitioner must not be guilty of bad faith or unconscionable conduct.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does Article 13(b) of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 specifically prohibit?
- Why is Article 44 of Qanun-e-Shahdat 1984 considered ultra vires Article 13?
- At what point does a person become an "accused person" entitled to the protection against self-incrimination?
- What remedy can the High Court grant under Article 199 for violation of fundamental rights besides issuing writs?
- Under what condition can a court refuse to grant relief under Article 199 despite a violation of fundamental rights?
π Lecture 22 β Fundamental Right β Inviolability of Dignity of Man
π Overview: This lecture examines Article 14 of the Pakistan Constitution of 1973, which declares the dignity of man and privacy of home as inviolable. It explains the constitutional protection against torture for extracting evidence, and explores how cruel, inhuman, and degrading punishments violate human dignity under both domestic and international law.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the three parts of Article 14, including the absolute guarantee of dignity of man, the qualified protection of privacy of home subject to law, and the prohibition of torture for evidence extraction. It discusses what constitutes violation of dignity through punishments like whipping, solitary confinement, and public hanging, referencing Supreme Court judgments and international declarations including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Islam.
π Lecture Summary
Fundamental Right β Inviolability of Dignity of Man
Article 14 of the Pakistan Constitution of 1973 provides that βthe dignity of man and, subject to law, privacy of home, shall be inviolable.β Dignity means self-respect. Subject to law means having regard to the law. Inviolable means sacred, unchallengeable, or unbreakable. The Article further provides that βno person shall be subjected to torture for the purpose of extracting evidence.β Torture means pain or suffering. Extract means take out or pull out. Evidence means something that tends to prove or disprove the existence of an alleged fact.
The Article is divided into three parts. The first part declares the dignity of man to be unbreakable. The second part makes the privacy of home inviolable, but this part is subject to law whereas the first part is not. The third part prohibits torture for the purpose of extracting evidence. Prohibit means ban.
π Definition β Inviolable: sacred, unchallengeable, unbreakable; meaning the right cannot be violated or challenged. π Example: The dignity of man under Article 14(1) is absolute and not subject to any legal limitation, unlike privacy of home which is subject to law.
Dignity of Man
Any law that violates the dignity of man will be unconstitutional. What law amounts to violation of the dignity of a man? Every law which provides inhuman and cruel punishments is violative of dignity of man, as for instance, whipping, solitary confinement, barbarous invasion on human personality. Even hanging may be considered a violation of human dignity. Note: In some countries, capital punishment has been abolished on the ground that it is inhuman.
The Supreme Court held that the dignity and self-respect of every human being has become inviolable and this guarantee is absolute. Chief Justice Supreme Court Dr. Nasim Hassan Shah in the matter of public hanging held in a case that βexecuting in public even the worst criminal violates the dignity of man, and therefore a law authorizing public hanging is unconstitutional.β
π‘ Why this matters: This establishes that even the most serious criminal punishments must respect basic human dignity, and public execution is unconstitutional regardless of the crime.
π Definition β Dignity of man: self-respect and inherent worth of every human being, protected as an absolute and unbreakable constitutional right.
Continuation on Dignity of Man
In every system of law, all unusual, cruel, and inhuman punishments are constitutionally declared as violative of human dignity. Unusual means strange or odd. Cruel means unkind or malicious. Violative means against. Thus in every system of law, all strange, unkind, and inhuman punishments are constitutionally declared as against human dignity.
On the view that the contemporary society takes of such punishments, the chopping off the hands and feet of convicts is considered cruel and inhuman because it involves torture, acute pain, and lingering death. Contemporary means present day. Convict means judicially pronounced guilty. Lingering means lasting.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 10 December 1948, to which Pakistan is a party, provides in its Article 5 that βno one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.β
Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Islam Relating Dignity of Man
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Islam of 12 April 1980 states in its Article 7 that βit is not permitted to torture the criminal, still less the suspect: God will inflict punishment on those who have inflicted torture in the world.β
β Key Takeaways
Article 14 of the Pakistan Constitution contains three distinct protections: the absolute and unqualified right to dignity of man, the qualified right to privacy of home (subject to law), and the prohibition of torture for extracting evidence. Any law providing cruel, inhuman, or degrading punishments like whipping, solitary confinement, or public hanging violates constitutional dignity and is therefore unconstitutional. The Supreme Court has held that even executing the worst criminal in public violates dignity of man, making such laws invalid. International human rights instruments, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Islam, reinforce this prohibition against torture and degrading treatment. The guarantee of dignity is absolute and not subject to any legal limitation, while the privacy of home may be restricted by law.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three parts of Article 14 of the Pakistan Constitution of 1973?
- Why is the privacy of home protection qualified by "subject to law" while the dignity of man protection is not?
- According to the Supreme Court judgment by Chief Justice Dr. Nasim Hassan Shah, why is public hanging unconstitutional?
- What does Article 5 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights state regarding torture and punishment?
- Why is chopping off hands and feet of convicts considered violative of human dignity under contemporary standards?