π Lecture 32 β Administrative Tribunal and Rules of Evidence & Procedure
π Overview: This lecture examines the procedural flexibility of administrative tribunals, which are not bound by strict rules of evidence and procedure but must adhere to the rule of natural justice. It explores the scope of judicial review of tribunal decisions and distinguishes administrative tribunals from traditional courts. This matters because understanding these procedural rules and constitutional safeguards is crucial for grasping how administrative justice operates outside the formal court system.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the inherent power of administrative tribunals to regulate their own procedure, the two principles of natural justice (no one should be a judge in his own cause and no one can be condemned unheard), the non-application of technical evidence rules, the scope of High Court interference, the judicial review of tribunal decisions, suggestions of the Franks' Committee, and the distinction between administrative tribunals and courts.
π Lecture Summary
Administrative Tribunal and Rules of Evidence & Procedure
An administrative tribunal has inherent power (=power arising from a status, office or a position) to regulate its own procedure subject to (=having regard to) statutory requirement (=requirement arising from a statute). Administrative tribunals are vested with the power of summoning witnesses and enforcement of attendance, discovery and inspection, production of documents etc. under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The proceedings of an administrative tribunal are deemed judicial proceedings for the purpose of Sections 193, 195 and 228 of the Penal Code 1860 and Sections 480, 481 and 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898. However, as a matter of fact, the tribunals are not bound to follow strict rule of evidence and procedure. Administrative tribunals are bound to follow the rule of natural justice and fair play.
What is Rule of Natural Justice?
There are two principles known as the rule of natural justice: (1) Nemo in propria causa index ess debet β No one should be made a judge in his own cause; (2) Audi alteram Partem β No one can be condemned unheard. The rule of natural justice is a sound product of human civilization, a high law of nature, and an intelligent common sense of human beings. In American Jurisprudence, it is called "due process of Law". De Smith states that "the rule of Natural Justice express the close relationship between Common law and moral principles describing what is right what is wrong." Megory J. states Natural Justice is simple and elementary, as distinct from justice that is complex sophisticated and technical. The aim of Natural Justice is to prevent miscarriage of justice.
These two basic principles on which the whole superstructure of judicial control of administration are usually not made part of statutory laws. In a case Al Hya Noor-ul-Zaman v. AJ & K Zakat Council (NLR 1987 Civil 341), it was held that the principle of Natural Justice shall be presumed to be incorporated in every statute unless its application is excluded by express words in it.
π Definition β Rule of Natural Justice: A legal principle that no one should be a judge in their own cause and no one can be condemned unheard; it is a high law of nature and intelligent common sense, also known as "due process of law" in American jurisprudence.
Technical Rules of Evidence and Fair Opportunity
Technical rules of evidence do not apply to the proceedings of Administrative Tribunals; they can rely on hearsay evidence or decide the question on the basis of onus of proof or admissibility of evidence and documents by exercising discretionary power. In a case it was held that tribunals exercising quasi-judicial functions are not Courts; and they are not bound to follow the procedure prescribed for trial of actions in courts nor are they bound by strict rules of evidence. They can, unlike Courts, obtain all information material for the points under enquiry from all sources and through all channels without being fettered by rules and procedure which govern proceedings in Court. The only obligation which the law casts on them is that they should not act on any information which they may receive unless they put it to the party against whom it is to be used and give him a fair opportunity to explain it.
What is fair opportunity? What is fair opportunity depends on the facts and circumstances of each case but where such an opportunity had been given, the proceedings are not open to attack on the ground that the enquiry was not conducted in accordance with the procedure followed in the Courts.
π Definition β Fair Opportunity: A contextual concept where the party against whom information is used must be given a chance to explain it; its adequacy depends on the facts and circumstances of each case.
Scope of Interference of High Court
A tribunal vested with judicial or quasi-judicial power may pronounce an erroneous decision; in this regard the High Court may issue writ on the instance of aggrieved party. But where the decision does not disclose any error on the face of the proceedings, there is absolutely no ground which would justify a superior court in issuing a writ or direction for the removal of the decision of the tribunal.
Every functionary of state derives its power from the Constitution or law and is required to act within the defined parameters of law. Constitutional schemes leave no room for arbitrariness (=unpredictability), capriciousness (=untrustworthiness), nepotism (=favoritism) and jobbery (=impersonation). Article 199 does not forbid issue of writs against Government but only limit them to particular cases. Even a writ may be issued against administrative order if there is defiance (=disobedience) from mandatory provision of law.
Judicial Review of Tribunals' Decisions
No appeal, revision, or reference against the decision of Tribunal is maintainable where the said right is not made available by a statute. Provisions may also be provided for ousting jurisdiction of civil court; and in such situations the decision given by a Tribunal will be final and conclusive. But this statutory finality will not affect the jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 & 227 and of the Supreme Court. The judicial review power of High Court and Supreme Court is recognized by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 and the same can be taken away by any statute.
Where a tribunal had acted without jurisdiction (=allocated field of work) or has failed to exercise jurisdiction vested in it or if the order passed by the Tribunal is arbitrary (=illogical), perverse (=bad) or malafide (=with bad intention) or it has not observed the principle of natural justice or there is an apparent error on the face of the order or record or the order is ultra vires (=beyond the prescribed limit) the Act, or there is no evidence in support of the order or the order is based on irrelevant considerations or where the finding recordings are conflicting and inconsistent or grave (=serious) injustice is perpetuated (=carried on) by the order passed by the Tribunal or the order is such that no reasonable man would have made it, the same can be set aside by the High Court or by the Supreme Court.
Review is not re-hearing of the matter on merits. A review of a judgment is a serious step and it is done where there is glaring omission or patent mistake or a grave error has erupt by judicial fallibility. A mere repetition through different Counsels and overruled arguments, a second round on ineffectually covered ground or minor mistakes of inconsequential import are insufficient.
π Example: If a tribunal decides a case without hearing one party, the High Court can set aside that order for violating the rule of natural justice (audi alteram partem).
Suggestions of Franks' Committee on the Improvement of Administrative Tribunal System
In 1955, a committee under the chairmanship of Sir Oliver Frank was constituted to give recommendations on the constitution and working of Administrative Tribunals. The following were the recommendations:
- Chairman of Tribunal should be appointed and removed by the Lord Chancellor.
- Member should be appointed by the council and removed by the Lord Chancellor.
- Chairman should have legal qualifications and always in the case of Appellate Tribunal.
- Remuneration for service on Tribunal should be reviewed by the Council of Tribunals.
- Procedure for each Tribunal based on Common principles but suited to its needs should be formulated by the Council.
- The Citizen should be helped to know in good time the case he will have to meet.
- Hearing should be in public except only in cases involving (i) public security (ii) intimate personal or financial circumstances (iii) professional reputation, where there is a preliminary investigation.
- Legal representation should always be allowed save only in most exceptional circumstances.
- Tribunals should have power to take evidence on oath, to subpoena witnesses and to award costs. Parties should be free to question witness directly.
- Decisions should be reasoned, as full as possible, and made available to the parties in writing.
- Final Appellate Tribunal should publish and circulate selected decisions.
- There should be right of appeal on a point of law and merits to an Appellate Tribunal, except where the lower Tribunal is exceptionally strong.
Administrative Tribunal Distinguished from Court
Administrative tribunal and court have certain similarities: both are constituted by state; both are vested with judicial powers; their duty is to dispense justice to masses; they are of permanent stature and existence; they are permanent adjudicating bodies. It was held in a case that the basic and fundamental feature common in both is that they discharge judicial functions and exercise judicial powers vested in a sovereign state. But, besides the above, it is a core fact that an "Administrative Tribunal" is not a full-fledged court but possesses some of the trappings of a court.
Following are the points of distinction between the two:
- A court is part of the traditional system of court; it derives judicial power from a sovereign state, whereas an Administrative Tribunal is an agency created by statute vested with judicial powers. Administrative tribunal is part and parcel of executive branch of a state. Lord Green said Administrative Tribunal performs hybrid form of functions.
- Judges of the traditional court are independent from the executive organ of a state in respect of their terms and condition of services etc., whereas the matter is otherwise in relation to the judges of Administrative Tribunal.
- A court of law is presided over by a judge well learned in law, whereas, the matter may be otherwise in case of Administrative Tribunal.
- In a court of law a judge may be an impartial arbiter and he cannot decide the matter in which he is interested but in the case of judge of Administrative Tribunal, the matter is otherwise.
- A court of law is bound by all the rules of evidence and procedure but Administrative Tribunal is not bound by all these unless made obligatory by the statute.
Whether Administrative Tribunal follows Principle of Natural Justice?
Administrative Tribunal does not perform purely administrative function; it performs judicial and quasi-judicial functions. The tribunal decides disputes independently, judicially and objectively without any bias or prejudice. The Frank Committee, in its report, declared following three fundamental objectives of Administrative Tribunal: (1) Openness (2) Fairness (3) Impartiality. The Law Commission in its fourteenth Report observed that Administrative Tribunal performs quasi-judicial functions and they must act judicially in accordance with the rule of natural justice.
What is Rule of Natural Justice? (Revisited)
There are two principles known as rule of natural justice: (1) Nemo in propria causa index ess debet (No one should be made a judge in his own cause); (2) Audi alteram Partem (no one can be condemned unheard). Rule of Natural Justice is a sound product of human civilization, a high law of nature, and an intelligent common sense of human beings. In American Jurisprudence it is called "due process of Law". However due to rapid growth of 'Administrative Law' & 'Constitutional Law' a third principle of Natural Justice has been evolved which is: (3) Speaking order or reasoned decision.
Speaking order means an order speaking for itself. In other words every order must contain reason in its support. According to this principle the party affected must know why and on what grounds the order was passed against him.
As to why reasons for a decision are required to be disclosed, there are three reasons:
- Aggrieved party has right to appeal to appellate court on the ground that the decision of the authority is based on erroneous reasons.
- Obligation to record reason is a deterrent against arbitrary action taken by executive authority invested with judicial power.
π Definition β Speaking Order: An order that contains reasons in its support so that the affected party knows why and on what grounds the order was passed against them; it is the third principle of natural justice evolved due to the growth of Administrative Law and Constitutional Law.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points to remember from this lecture are: (1) Administrative tribunals are not bound by strict rules of evidence and procedure but must follow the rule of natural justice, which includes the principles that no one should be a judge in their own cause and no one can be condemned unheard. (2) The High Court and Supreme Court retain judicial review power over tribunal decisions if the tribunal acted without jurisdiction, violated natural justice, made an arbitrary or perverse order, or if the order is ultra vires. (3) A third principle of natural justice, the speaking order or reasoned decision, has evolved requiring tribunals to provide reasons for their decisions. (4) The Franks' Committee recommended openness, fairness, and impartiality as fundamental objectives of administrative tribunals, with specific procedural safeguards including public hearings and legal representation. (5) Courts differ from administrative tribunals in that courts are part of the traditional judicial system with independent judges bound by all rules of evidence, while tribunals are executive agencies with procedural flexibility and may not have legally qualified presiding officers.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two core principles of the rule of natural justice, and what does each Latin maxim mean?
- Under what conditions can the High Court set aside a decision of an administrative tribunal?
- What is a "speaking order" and why is the obligation to record reasons important?
- List at least five distinctions between an administrative tribunal and a traditional court.
- What were the three fundamental objectives of administrative tribunals declared by the Franks' Committee?
π Lecture 33 β Judicial & Alternative Remedies against Administrative Action
π Overview: This lecture examines the judicial and alternative remedies available against administrative action, emphasizing the constitutional framework for controlling executive power. It explains the importance of prerogative writs, the jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, and key principles such as locus standi, delay and laches, and alternative remedies. Understanding these remedies is crucial for protecting individual rights and maintaining the rule of law in a democratic state.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the fundamental concept of remedies against administrative action, the historical background and purpose of prerogative writs, the jurisdiction of High Court regarding judicial review under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, the meaning and importance of locus standi, against whom writs may be issued including the definition of "State" under Article 12, the doctrine of delay and laches, and the principle of alternative remedy. It also discusses the discretionary nature of writ jurisdiction and the circumstances under which courts may refuse relief.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction: Need for Control over Administrative Action
Administrative Law recognizes that there must be some outside control strong enough over administrative action to prevent injustice to the individual while giving the administration adequate freedom to carry on the business of government effectively. Today, government functions have increased manifold in every walk of life. In this regard, Lord Denning says that "proper exercising the new executive powers lead to a welfare state but where they are abused lead to a totalitarian state."
π‘ Why this matters: Without effective control on the executive, the individual will be without remedy, which is against the fundamental concept: ubi jus ibi remedium (where there is a right, there is a remedy). It is said that right and remedy are two sides of a coin and cannot be disassociated from each other.
π Definition β Remedy: the means of enforcing a right or redressing a wrong.
The important judicial remedy available to an aggrieved person against administrative action is the prerogative remedy. Prerogative writs are writs which originally were issued only at the suit of the King but which were made available to the subject. They were called "prerogative" because they were conceived as being intimately connected with the rights of the Crown.
Historical Background and Purpose of Prerogative Writs
In England, the prerogative writs played a vital role in maintaining and upholding the rights and liberties of common men and in providing effective safeguards against the arbitrary actions of public authorities.
As per the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, judicial review is an integral part of our constitutional system, and without it there will be no government according to the rule of law. Judicial review is basic and fundamental for the maintenance of a democratic state and is the unquestionable part of our judicial and constitutional system.
Jurisdiction of High Court as Regard "Judicial Review"
Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 confers powers on the High Court to make orders on the writ petition of an aggrieved party. The Article intends to enable the High Court to control the executive so as to bring it in conformity with the law. Whenever the executive acts in violation of the law, an appropriate order may be granted by the court to make the citizen relieved from the illegal act of the executive.
π Definition β Writ (as per Black's Law Dictionary): A court's written order in the name of a state or other competent legal authority commanding the addressee to do or refrain from doing some specified act.
The powers and jurisdiction of the High Court conferred by Article 199 cannot be restricted through any law which is not a part and parcel of the constitution.
The High Court and the Supreme Court can issue writs in the nature of habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto, and certiorari.
The jurisdiction of the High Court under this Article is meant to provide expeditious and efficacious remedy in a case where illegality, impropriety, and flagrant violation of law regarding the impugned action is apparent and can be established without any comprehensive inquiry into complicated, ticklish, controversial, and disputed facts.
Article 199 casts an obligation on the High Court to act in aid of law, protect the rights of the citizens within the framework of the constitution against the infringement of law and the Constitution by the executive authorities, and strike a rational compromise and a fair balance between the rights of citizens and the actions of the state functionaries claimed to be in the larger interest of society.
Who has Locus Standi to File Writ before High Court?
The issue as to who may file a petition is a fundamental question and has given rise to much debate and controversy, yet its importance cannot be ignored or underestimated because the court may not entertain such a petition if not presented by an aggrieved or interested person.
It is an established rule that if the petitioner has no locus standi to file the petition, he cannot be heard on the merits.
π Definition β Locus Standi (as per Black's Law Dictionary): The right to bring an action or to be heard in a given situation.
π Example 1: In a case, a petitioner was a candidate who submitted an application following the advertisement published by the department for a vacancy of a driver. It was held by the court of law that no law conferred a right to the petitioner to be appointed by the authorities, but the petitioner had the right to demand that the authorities should determine his application in accordance with law. It was held that the petition was maintainable.
π Example 2: In another case, it was held by the High Court that every citizen and member of the public, whether he is personally aggrieved or not, has the duty to highlight and raise voice against illegal and unconditional acts of the Provincial Government.
Against Whom Writ May Be Issued?
While deciding whether a writ would lie in given circumstances, the first inquiry to be made is against whom a writ can be issued.
Ordinarily, a writ lies against the State and the statutory bodies and persons charged with public duties. Though private persons are not immune from the writ jurisdiction of the Supreme Court and High Court, issuance of the writ to them requires exceptional circumstances.
As a general rule, a writ lies against the State, and as per Article 12 of the Constitution 1973, the State includes: "In this part unless the context otherwise requires, the State includes the Government and Parliament of the country and the Government and the Legislature of each of the Provinces and all local or other authorities within the territory of the country or under the control of the Government."
Meaning thereby, a writ may be issued against the following:
- The Government and Parliament of the country.
- The Government and the Legislature of each of the provinces.
- All local or other authorities within the territory.
- All local or other authorities under the control of the Government.
Delay and Laches
Under Article 226, the power of the High Court to issue a writ is discretionary. The relief cannot be claimed as of right; however, where the relief claimed is one relating to enforcement of a fundamental right, the court must grant it.
One of the grounds for refusing relief is that the petitioner is guilty of delay and laches. If the petitioner intends to take relief, it is imperative that he comes to the court at the earliest reasonable opportunity.
Inordinate delays in filing the writ will be a sufficient ground for refusing to exercise the discretion. It is essential that the person aggrieved of an action of the government or any executive action should come to the High Court with utmost expedition.
In an appropriate case, the High Court may not exercise its discretion and may refuse to grant relief if there is such negligence or omission on the part of the applicant to assert his right as taken in conjunction with the lapse of time and other circumstances.
As a general rule, the Superior Courts are averse to granting relief in the exercise of their extraordinary power of judicial review to parties who are guilty of laches or delays in invoking the jurisdiction. The reason is that by their omission to act promptly, such parties may be deemed to have accepted the orders of the administrative authorities, and it would be unfair to disturb, at their instance, rights and obligations which had been settled and finalized long ago under the relevant law.
Difficulty arises as to measures of delay since the Limitation Act 1908 does not apply to writ petitions, and no period of limitation is prescribed by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 to move the Supreme Court and High Court; the matter is more or less left to judicial discretion.
π Example: In a case, it was held that no hard and fast rule can be laid down as to when the High Court should refuse to exercise its jurisdiction in favor of a party who moves it after considerable delay and is otherwise guilty of laches. That is a matter which must be left to the discretion of the High Court, and like all matters left to the discretion of the Court, in this matter too, discretion must be exercised judiciously and reasonably.
Alternative Remedy
Article 32 confers powers on the Supreme Court to issue certain writs, directions, and orders for the enforcement of fundamental rights conferred by the Constitution.
The Constitution of Pakistan 1973 empowers the High Court to issue such writs, directions, or orders for enforcement of fundamental rights or "for any other purpose." It is well established that the remedy provided for in the Constitution is a discretionary remedy and the High Court has always the discretion to refuse to grant such relief in certain circumstances even though a legal right might have been infringed. Availability of an alternative remedy is one of such considerations which the court may take into account to refuse to exercise its jurisdiction.
The writ of mandamus, certiorari, and prohibition, and for that matter, all high prerogative writs, are not issued where there exists an alternative remedy equally efficient and adequate.
Whether the alternative remedy is equally efficacious or adequate is a question of fact to be decided in each case.
When there is violation of fundamental rights of the petitioner, the Supreme Court as well as the High Court have to exercise their extraordinary jurisdiction to issue appropriate writs.
When the question raised in the petition is constitutional or of public importance and the general public is interested, it is desirable for the High Court to entertain the petition.
When once a High Court entertains a petition under the Constitution, it would not be proper to dismiss it only on the ground that an alternative remedy is available to the applicant.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points for exam preparation are: (1) Prerogative writsβhabeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto, and certiorariβare the primary judicial remedies against administrative action, with Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 empowering High Courts to issue them; (2) Locus standi is essentialβonly an aggrieved or interested person can file a writ petition, though citizens may raise voice against illegal government actions; (3) Writs are ordinarily issued against the State (including government, parliament, provincial governments, and local authorities) and not private persons except in exceptional circumstances; (4) The writ jurisdiction is discretionary, and courts may refuse relief on grounds of delay and laches or if an equally efficacious alternative remedy exists, though this does not apply when fundamental rights are violated; (5) The fundamental principle is ubi jus ibi remediumβwhere there is a right, there is a remedyβand the purpose of judicial review is to control executive action and bring it in conformity with law.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the meaning of the Latin maxim "ubi jus ibi remedium" and why is it fundamental to administrative law?
- List the five types of prerogative writs that the High Court and Supreme Court can issue under the Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
- Under which Article of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 does the High Court obtain its writ jurisdiction, and what is the purpose of this Article?
- What is "locus standi" and why is it important for filing a writ petition before the High Court?
- Explain the doctrines of "delay and laches" and "alternative remedy" as grounds for refusing the exercise of writ jurisdiction by the High Court.