π Lecture 28 β Fundamental Rightsβ(1) Freedom to Profess Religion & to Manage Religious Institutions (2) Safeguard as to educational institutions in respect of religion etc. (3) Right to acquire and dispose of property
π Overview: This lecture examines three fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973: the freedom to profess, practice, and propagate religion (Article 20); safeguards for educational institutions regarding religious instruction (Article 22); and the right to acquire, hold, and dispose of property (Article 23). It also introduces the writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 199 as a remedy for rights violations, making these protections judicially enforceable.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the detailed interpretation of Article 20, including definitions of key terms like "profess," "practice," and "propagate," and the meaning of religion. It explains the limitations of "subject to law, public order, and morality" and how fundamental rights cannot be taken away by law, citing Jibendra Kishore vs. East Pakistan. It then examines Article 22's safeguards for students in educational institutions and discrimination protections. Finally, it details Article 23's right to property, its constitutional limits (e.g., compulsory acquisition), and introduces the writ jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 199 for enforcement.
π Lecture Summary
Article 20 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973
Article 20 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provides that, subject to law, public order and morality: (a) Every citizen shall have the right to profess, practice and propagate his religion; and (b) Every religious denomination and every sect thereof shall have the right to establish, maintain and manage its religious institutions.
The lecture explains "subject to law, public order and morality" as meaning "having regard to" those elements. Key terms are defined: "Profess" means admit or acknowledge; "Practice" means follow or observe; "Propagate" means promulgate; "Denomination" means value; "Every sect thereof" means every division or faction of the religion; "Establish" means set up or found; "Maintain" means uphold or preserve; "Manage" means deal with or control. A synonym-based restatement is provided: "Every citizen shall have right to acknowledge, follow and promulgate his religion; and every religious value and every faction of the religion shall have the right to set up, uphold and control its religious institution."
π Definition β Religion: Religion includes all forms of belief in the existence of a superior being exercising power over human beings by volition, and imposing rules of conduct, with future rewards and punishments. Religion is also defined as a matter of belief and doctrine, concerning the human spirit expressed overtly in the form of ritual and worship. "Belief" means faith or conviction; "Doctrine" means a set of guidelines; "Overtly" means explicitly; "Ritual" means practice; "Worship" means respect or adoration.
The right of a man to entertain religious views as they appeal to his individual conscience, without dictation or interference by any person or power, civil or ecclesiastical, is as fundamental in a free government as is the right to life and liberty. "Conscience" means sense of right and wrong; "Dictation" means notation; "Interference" means intervention; "Civil" means public; "Ecclesiastical" means priestly or church.
Subject to public order and morality: If a religion is immoral (e.g., allowing indecent exposure of human body) or its practice leads to public disorders, the legislature may step in to regulate the religion, practice, and propagation. So long as religious beliefs are held, professed, and practiced in private, no question of public disorder can arise. But when they are practiced and propagated in publicβby speeches, processions, and placards, and are accompanied by denunciation of other religionsβthey are bound to clash with the rights of others and lead to breaches of the peace. "Denunciation" means condemnation, criticism, or censure. It is for this consideration that the practice and propagation of religion is made subject to law.
The fundamental right in the Pakistan Constitution has been subjected to law, but this does not mean it can be taken away by law. The case Jibendra Kishore vs. East Pakistan held that the very conception of a fundamental right is that, being a right guaranteed by the Constitution, it cannot be taken away by law. Therefore, in accordance with the principle that a constitution should receive liberal interpretation in favor of the citizenβespecially with respect to provisions designed to safeguard freedom of conscience and worshipβthe words "subject to law" cannot mean that the right to profess, practice, and propagate religion may be completely taken away by law. They should be interpreted as merely permitting the making of laws by which the manner in which religion is to be professed, practiced, and propagated, and the establishment, management, and maintenance of religious institutions (e.g., Waqf Alal-Aulad), may be regulated.
π‘ Why this matters: This distinction ensures that fundamental rights are genuine constitutional guarantees, not mere privileges revocable by ordinary legislation.
Fundamental Right β Safeguard as to educational institutions in respect of religion etc.
Article 22 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 provides that no person attending any educational institution shall be required to receive religious instruction, or take part in any religious ceremony, or attend religious worship, if such instruction, ceremony, or worship relates to a religion other than his own. "Instruction" means teaching; "Ceremony" means ritual.
In respect of any religious institution, there shall be no discrimination against any community in the granting of exemption or concession in relation to taxation. "Discrimination" means inequality or favoritism.
Subject to law, no religious community or denomination shall be prevented from providing religious instructions for pupils of that community or denomination in any educational institution maintained wholly by the community or denomination.
Subject to law, no citizen shall be denied admission to any educational institution receiving aid from public revenue on the ground only of race, religion, caste, or place of birth.
Nothing in this article shall prevent any public authority from making provisions for the advancement of any socially or educationally backward class of citizens.
Fundamental right β Right to acquire and dispose of property
Article 23 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provides that "every citizen shall have the right to acquire, hold and dispose of property in any part of Pakistan, subject to the Constitution and any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the public interest."
"Right" means an interest protected by law; "Acquire" means buy or purchase; "Hold" means grasp; "Dispose of" means sell; "Subject to" means having regard to; "Reasonable" means logical or sensible; "Restrictions" means limitations.
Thus, Article 23 provides that "every citizen shall have an interest protected by law to buy, grasp and sell the property in any part of Pakistan, having regard to the constitution and any logical limitations imposed by law in public interest."
Subject to the Constitution: The right to acquire, hold, and dispose of property guaranteed to the citizen of Pakistan is subject to the following other provisions of the Constitution:
- Compulsory acquisition of land with compensation.
- The compulsory acquisition of land without compensation for preventing danger to life, property, or public health; or enemy property or evacuee property; and the taking over of property acquired by unfair means and the management of property for a limited period in public interest.
- Compulsory acquisition of property without compensation for the purposes of:
- (a) Providing education and medical aid to all or any specified class of citizens; or
- (b) Providing housing and public facilities and services such as roads, water supply, sewerage, gas and electric power to all or any specified class of citizens; or
- (c) Providing maintenance to those who, on account of unemployment, sickness, infirmity, or old age, are unable to maintain themselves.
Writ Jurisdiction of High Court
Provisions of Article 199 are not confined to cases where the person against whom the order is proposed to be passed has been performing judicial or quasi-judicial functions. Administrative or executive authorities also fall within the orbit of the jurisdiction conferred by this Article on the superior courts. Article 199 is very wide in scope and has been introduced to correct the actions of government functionaries which suffer either from lack of jurisdiction or excess of jurisdiction. This article is an omnibus article under which relief can be granted to the citizens of the country against infringement of any provision of law or of the Constitution.
If the citizens of this country are deprived of the guarantee given to them under the Constitution illegally, or not in accordance with law, then Article 199 can always be invoked for redress. The High Court, on application of an aggrieved party, has power to make an order directing a person performing, within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court, functions in connection with affairs of the Federation, Province, or a local authority to refrain from doing anything against the fundamental rights conferred by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that Article 20 guarantees religious freedom but is expressly limited by law, public order, and morality. However, the landmark case of Jibendra Kishore vs. East Pakistan establishes that "subject to law" cannot completely take away the rightβit only permits regulation of the manner of exercise. Article 22 protects students from forced religious instruction of a different religion and prohibits discrimination based on race, religion, caste, or place of birth in state-aided institutions. Article 23 guarantees the right to acquire, hold, and dispose of property, but this right is subject to constitutional limitations including compulsory acquisition, sometimes even without compensation, for public welfare purposes. Finally, Article 199 provides a powerful remedy: the High Court can issue orders to any government functionary to stop violations of fundamental rights, making these constitutional guarantees judicially enforceable.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Explain the scope of "subject to law, public order and morality" in Article 20 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973, citing the case that clarified their meaning.
- What are the protections granted to students regarding religious instruction under Article 22 of the Constitution? Are there any exceptions?
- List three circumstances under which property can be compulsorily acquired without compensation according to the Constitution.
- What is the significance of Article 199 (Writ Jurisdiction of the High Court) in enforcing fundamental rights?
- Define "religion" as given in the lecture, and explain why its practice and propagation are made subject to law.
π Lecture 29 β Fundamental Rights ----(1) Protection of Property Rights (2) Non-Discrimination in Respect of Access to Public Places (3) Safeguard Against Discrimination in Services (4) Preservation of Language, Script & Culture
π Overview: This lecture examines four fundamental rights enshrined in the Pakistan Constitution 1973: protection of property rights, non-discrimination in access to public places, safeguards against discrimination in services, and preservation of language, script and culture. These constitutional guarantees establish the legal framework for individual economic security, equal treatment, and cultural identity preservation, making them essential for understanding the rights and protections available to Pakistani citizens.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Article 24 regarding compulsory acquisition of property with compensation requirements and multiple exceptions for public safety, unfair means, enemy property, state management, education, medical aid, housing, and social welfare. Article 26 addresses religious freedom in educational institutions, non-discrimination against religious communities in taxation, and admission rights to publicly-funded institutions. Article 27 prohibits discrimination in government service appointments based on race, religion, caste, sex, residence or place of birth, with provisions for reserved posts and provincial residence requirements. Article 28 guarantees the right to preserve and promote distinct languages, scripts and cultures, while Article 199 establishes the writ jurisdiction of High Courts.
π Lecture Summary
Protection of Property Rights β Article 24
Article 24 of the Pakistan Constitution provides that no person shall be compulsorily deprived of his property save in accordance with law. This means no person shall be by force dispossessed of their property except according to legal procedure.
π Definition β Compulsorily: by force; under duress π Definition β Deprived: dispossessed; run down; set aside π Definition β Save: except
No property shall be compulsorily acquired or taken possession of save for a public purpose, and save by the authority of law which provides for compensation thereof. The law must either fix the amount of compensation or specify the principles and manner in which compensation is to be determined and given.
π Definition β Acquire: purchase π Definition β Possession: control; custody π Definition β Compensation: recompense; payment π Definition β Thereof: of the property
Thus no property shall be by force purchased or taken control of except for a public purpose and except by the authority of law which provides for payment of the property and either fixes the amount of compensation or specifies the principles and the manner in which compensation is to be determined and given.
π‘ Why this matters: This establishes the constitutional requirement that any government taking of private property must be for a public purpose and must include compensation, protecting citizens from arbitrary state seizure.
Exceptions to Article 24 protection: Nothing in this Article shall affect the validity of any law permitting:
- Compulsory acquisition for preventing danger to life, property or public health
- Taking over of property acquired by unfair means or contrary to law
- Acquisition, administration or disposal of enemy property or evacuee property
- Taking over management of property by the State for a limited period in public interest or for proper management
- Acquisition of property for providing education and medical aid to citizens
- Acquisition of property for providing housing and public facilities such as roads, water supply, sewerage, gas and electric power
- Acquisition of property for providing maintenance to those unable to maintain themselves due to unemployment, sickness, infirmity or old-age
π Definition β Unfair: unmerited; unjust; unreasonable π Definition β Means: earnings; resources π Definition β Contrary: against
Non-Discrimination in Respect of Access to Public Places β Article 26
Article 26 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provides that no person attending any educational institution shall be required to receive religious instruction, or take part in any religious ceremony, or attend religious worship, if such instruction, ceremony or worship relates to a religion other than his own.
π Definition β Religious instructions: holy teachings or holy lessons π Definition β Religious Ceremony: holy ritual; holy service; holy observance π Definition β Religious Worship: holy devotion
Thus no person attending any educational institution shall be required to receive holy lessons, or take part in any holy ritual, or attend holy devotion, if such instruction, ceremony or worship relates to a religion other than his own.
In respect of any religious institution, there shall be no discrimination against any community in the granting of exemption or concession in relation to taxation.
π Definition β Discrimination: bias π Definition β Community: group of people π Definition β Granting: conferring; giving way π Definition β Exemption: immunity; exception π Definition β Concession: allowance
Thus in respect of any religious institution, there shall be no bias against any group of people in conferring of immunity or allowance in relation to taxation.
Subject to law, no religious community or denomination shall be prevented from providing religious instruction for pupils of that community or denomination.
π Definition β Subject to law: having regard to law π Definition β Religious community: holy group of people π Definition β Religious instruction: holy lessons π Definition β Pupil: taught
Thus having regard to law, no religious group of people or denomination shall be prevented from providing religious lessons for taught of that group of people or denomination.
Subject to law, no citizen shall be denied admission to any educational institution receiving aid from public revenues on the ground only of race, religion, caste or place of birth.
Nothing in Article 26 shall prevent any public Authority from making provision for the advancement of any socially or educationally backward class of citizens.
Safeguard against Discrimination in Services β Article 27
Article 27 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provides that no citizen otherwise qualified for appointment in the service of Pakistan shall be discriminated against in respect of any such appointment on the ground only of race, religion, caste, sex, residence or place of birth.
First proviso: For a period not exceeding twenty years from the commencing day, posts may be reserved for persons belonging to any class or area to secure their adequate representation in the service of Pakistan.
π Definition β Provided: proviso that brings addition or condition or exception to whatever is said earlier
Second proviso: In the interest of the said service, specified posts of service may be reserved for members of either sex if such posts or services entail the performance of duties and functions which cannot be adequately performed by members of the other sex.
π Definition β Entail: demand; require
Nothing in clause (1) shall prevent any Provincial Government or authority from prescribing, in relation to any post or class of service, conditions as to residence in the Province for a period not exceeding three years prior to appointment.
Preservation of Language, Script & Culture β Article 28
Article 28 of the Pakistan Constitution provides that "subject to Article 251, any section of citizens having a distinct language, script or culture shall have the right to preserve and promote the same and, subject to law, establish institution for that purpose."
π Definition β Subject to: having regard to π Definition β Section of citizens: segment of citizen π Definition β Distinct: different; dissimilar π Definition β Subject to law: having regard to law
Thus having regard to Article 25, any segment of citizens having a different language, script or culture shall have the right to preserve and promote the same and having regard to law, establish institution for that purpose.
The National Language of Pakistan is "Urdu" but the English Language may for the time being be used for official purpose.
This Article does not entitle a person or community speaking a regional language to claim that the University operating in its area should make such language one of the media of examination. Any section of citizens, however, have the right to promote their distinct language, script or culture and for the purpose to establish the necessary institutions.
Writ Jurisdiction of High Court β Article 199
Provisions of Article 199 are not confined to cases where the person against whom the order is proposed to be passed has been performing judicial or quasi judicial functions. Administrative or executive authorities also fall within the orbit of the jurisdiction conferred by this Article on the superior courts.
Article 199 is very wide in scope, and has been introduced to correct the actions of Government functionaries which suffer either from lack of jurisdiction or excess of jurisdiction. This article is an omnibus article under which relief can be granted to the citizens of the country against infringement of any provision of law or of the constitution.
If the citizens of this country are deprived of the guarantee given to them under the Constitution illegally, or not in accordance with law, then Article 199 can always be revoked for redress.
The High Court on application of an aggrieved party has power to make an order directing a person performing, within territorial jurisdiction of High Court, functions in connection with affairs of federation, province or a local authority to refrain from doing anything against the fundamental rights conferred by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
β Key Takeaways
The protection of property rights under Article 24 requires that no person be deprived of property except by law and for a public purpose with compensation, though seven specific exceptions exist for public safety, unlawful acquisition, enemy property, state management, education, medical aid, housing, and social welfare. Article 26 prohibits requiring students to participate in religious activities of other faiths, bans discrimination against religious communities in taxation, and ensures admission to publicly-funded institutions cannot be denied based on race, religion, caste or place of birth. Article 27 prohibits discrimination in government service appointments based on race, religion, caste, sex, residence or place of birth while allowing twenty-year reservations for underrepresented groups and sex-based reservations for posts requiring specific gender performance. Article 28 grants linguistic and cultural minorities the right to preserve and promote their distinct language, script and culture through institutions, though Urdu remains the national language. Article 199 establishes the High Court's writ jurisdiction as a broad remedy against any infringement of fundamental rights by government functionaries, whether judicial, quasi-judicial or administrative.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under Article 24, what are the two essential requirements that must be met before property can be compulsorily acquired by the State?
- Name at least four exceptions listed in Article 24 that permit compulsory acquisition of property without violating the fundamental right.
- According to Article 26, on what grounds is it prohibited to deny admission to an educational institution receiving aid from public revenues?
- What are the prohibited grounds of discrimination in government service appointments under Article 27, and what two exceptions are provided?
- Under Article 28, what specific rights do citizens with a distinct language, script or culture possess, and what limitation exists regarding universities and regional languages?
π Lecture 30 β Fundamental Rights---Equality of Citizens
π Overview: This lecture examines Article 25 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973, which guarantees equality of citizens before the law and equal protection of the law. It explains the distinction between these two concepts, the principle of reasonable classification, and the legal remedies available through the superior courts for enforcement of fundamental rights, particularly under Articles 199 and 184.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the text and explanation of Article 25, including non-discrimination on the basis of sex and special provisions for women and children. It then distinguishes between "Equality before law" and "Equal Protection of the Laws", citing Dicey and Jennings. The concept of classification and its reasonableness is explained with two required conditions. The lecture covers the remedy for enforcement of fundamental rights through Articles 199(2) and 184, including who cannot invoke these articles, the duty of the High Court, and the meaning of "writ" and locus standi.
π Lecture Summary
Fundamental Rights---Equality of Citizens
Article 25 of the Pakistan Constitution, 1973 provides that all citizens are equal before law and are entitled to equal protection of law. "Equal before law" means identical before law, and "entitled" means warranted. "Equal protection of law" means identical shelter of law. The Constitution also states there shall be no discrimination on the basis of sex alone, and nothing in this Article shall prevent the state from making any special provision for the protection of women and children.
β Equality before lawβ & βEqual Protection of the Lawsβ
The expression "equality before law" is a declaration of equality of all persons, meaning the absence of any privilege in favor of any individual. Every person, whatever his rank or position, is subject to the ordinary jurisdiction of the ordinary courts. Dicey in his βLaw of the Constitutionβ explains legal equality as: "with us every official from the Prime Minister down to a constable or a collector of taxes, is under the same responsibility for every act done without any legal justification as any other citizen".
The second expression "equal protection of laws" directs that equal protection shall be secured in the enjoyment of rights and privileges without favoritism or discrimination. It is a pledge of protection or guarantee of equal laws. Although there is much in common between the two expressions, they do not mean the same thing. The word "Law" in "Equality before law" is used in a generic sense β a philosophical sense β whereas the word "laws" in "Equal protection of laws" denotes specific laws. Jennings in his law of the Constitution said that equality before law means that amongst equals the law should be equal and should be equally administered and that like should be treated alike. It forbids discrimination between persons who are substantially in similar circumstances or conditions. The rule is: like should be treated alike and unlike should be treated differently.
Classification
The rule that like should be treated alike and unlike should be treated differently leads to classification between persons made by laws. Persons may be classified in groups, and such groups may differently be treated if there is a reasonable basis for such difference.
Reasonableness of classification
A classification to be valid must be reasonable. It must always rest upon some real and substantial distinction bearing a reasonable and just relation to the needs in respect of which the classification is made. To pass the test of permissible classification, two conditions must be fulfilled:
- The classification must be founded on an intelligible differentia which distinguishes persons or things that are grouped together from others left out of the group.
- The differentia must have a rational relation to the object sought to be achieved by the statute in question.
Remedy for the enforcement of fundamental right
Provisions of Articles 199(2) and 184 of the Constitution of 1973 of Pakistan have authorized the superior courts with the power to enforce the fundamental rights in case of complaint about violation. An aggrieved citizen, on the basis of the rule "ex debito justitiae" β as a matter of right β can claim redress of his grievance for the enforcement of his fundamental rights. The aim of having a declaration of fundamental rights in the constitution is that such rights should be regarded as inviolable under the constitution. They are not mere pious enunciations of principle but are made specifically justiciable under the constitution. When a citizen complains of violation of fundamental rights, the High Court should exercise its power under Article 199 to investigate the matter and pass such order as may be found just, legal and equitable.
Who cannot invoke Article 199 and 184 of the Constitution?
Constitutional jurisdiction of the High Court & Supreme Court cannot be invoked by any one who is guilty of bad faith and of unconscionable conduct.
Duty of High Court in relation to Article 199
Exercise of jurisdiction under Article 199 is discretionary, but the High Court must exercise the powers in good faith, justly and fairly having regard to all relevant circumstances.
Abuse of power by executive authority
Where there is clear abuse of power by executive authority and there is denial of fundamental right to citizens, the High Court is under constitutional duty to ensure that people must be dealt in accordance with law.
What is meant by the word: βWritβ?
Writ means a written order. According to Blackβs Law dictionary Edition 8th, a writ is: "A courtβs written order, in the name of a state or other competent legal authority, commanding the addressee to do or refrain from doing some specified act." In other words, a writ is a remedial right for the enforcement of a substantive right. Through writs, the superior courts control executive actions. Whenever the executive acts in violation of the law, the High Court may grant an order which will relieve the aggrieved from the ultra vires act of the executive. Through a writ petition, the High Court exercises its power to provide expeditious and efficacious relief to the writ petitioner. A petition filed under Article 199 is neither a suit nor an application under the Civil Procedure Code; it is a petition under the supreme law of the land, i.e., the constitution.
π Definition β Remedial right: The secondary right to have a remedy that arises when a primary right is broken. π Definition β Substantive right: A right that can be protected or enforced by law.
What is locus standi?
Locus standi is the right to bring an action or to be heard in a given forum. To file a writ petition, it is necessary that the person aggrieved must have a locus standi.
Power of High Court under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973
Authorities performing judicial, quasi-judicial, and administrative functions fall under the jurisdiction of the High Court. Article 199 makes no distinction between administrative, judicial or quasi-judicial bodies. Article 199 is wide in scope and has been introduced to correct the actions of Government functionaries which suffer either from lack of jurisdiction or excess of jurisdiction. The right to file a petition under Article 199 has been given to an βaggrieved person.β A writ petition under this Article is not maintainable if the petitioner has come for some indirect purpose. A petitioner acting malafide is not entitled to relief by the High Court. While exercising jurisdiction under Article 199, the court is not to treat the matter as if it were a court of further appeal.
β Key Takeaways
1. Article 25 establishes equality before law (generic, philosophical, absence of privilege) and equal protection of laws (specific laws, guarantee without discrimination). 2. The principle of classification is valid only if it is reasonable, founded on an intelligible differentia, and has a rational relation to the statute's objective β like must be treated alike, unlike differently. 3. Enforcement of fundamental rights is through Articles 199 (High Court) and 184 (Supreme Court); an aggrieved person with locus standi can seek a writ as a matter of right (ex debito justitiae). 4. A writ is a remedial right β a courtβs written order commanding action or restraint; it is not a suit or civil application but a constitutional petition. 5. The High Courtβs jurisdiction is discretionary but must be exercised in good faith; it cannot be invoked by persons guilty of bad faith or unconscionable conduct, and the court does not act as a further appeal court.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two expressions contained in Article 25 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973, and how do they differ in meaning?
- Explain the rule of classification derived from equality before law. What are the two conditions for a classification to be valid?
- Through which Articles can a citizen seek enforcement of fundamental rights, and what is the legal principle (ex debito justitiae) governing such a claim?
- According to Blackβs Law Dictionary, what is a βwritβ , and why is it considered a remedial right?
- Who is not allowed to invoke the constitutional jurisdiction under Articles 199 and 184, and what is the duty of the High Court when exercising its discretionary power under Article 199?
π Lecture 31 β Administrative Tribunal
π Overview: This lecture examines the concept of Administrative Tribunals in modern governance, explaining how the executive organ of a state now performs quasi-judicial functions alongside traditional courts. It covers the constitutional basis for creating these tribunals, their types, characteristics, and the reasons for their growth, particularly as the old police state model has transformed into a welfare state.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining that the traditional theory of all judicial functions being performed by ordinary courts has become obsolete. It then discusses the constitutional provision under Article 212 for creating Administrative Tribunals, lists the kinds of tribunals (Service, Election, Inland Revenue, and Labor Tribunals), defines what constitutes a special law versus general law, and explores the reasons for the growth of Administrative Tribunals including the insufficiency and rigidity of traditional courts. Finally, it outlines the key characteristics of Administrative Tribunals.
π Lecture Summary
Administrative Tribunal
Today the executive organ of a state performs many quasi-legislative and quasi-judicial functions. The traditional theory that all judicial functions are performed by the traditional judiciary has become obsolete (= outdated). In reality, many judicial functions are now performed by the executive organ of a state, such as search and seizure, imposition of fine, levy of penalty, and confiscation of fine. Due to the increase in the role of modern government, the old police state has converted into a welfare state.
These days, due to change in theory and practice, the executive organ regulates industrial relations and exercises control over production. Under the overwhelming role of the executive in the administration of the state, it is not possible for ordinary courts to decide disputes expeditiously (= fastly). Therefore, to decide issues created under special laws, Administrative Tribunals are created to decide various quasi-judicial issues in place of ordinary courts. The tribunals are created under the Constitution of Pakistan.
π‘ Why this matters: This shift reflects a fundamental change in how justice is administered in modern states β the traditional judiciary cannot handle the volume and specialization of disputes arising from the expanded role of government.
Relevant Article of Constitution as regard creation of Administrative Tribunal
Under clause (1) of Article 212, the appropriate legislature is empowered to enact laws for the creation of Administrative Tribunal. The tribunals exercise exclusive jurisdiction in the relevant subject matter.
Kinds of Tribunals
Following are the kinds of Tribunals:
- Service Tribunal
- Election Tribunal
- Inland Revenue Tribunal
- Labor Tribunal
Tribunals are those bodies of men appointed to decide controversies arising under certain special law.
What is Special Law?
As per Black's Law Dictionary (8th Edition), a special law is a law that pertains to a person, place, or thing, as opposed to the general public.
What is General Law?
General law is law that is neither local nor confined in application to a particular person.
Administrative Tribunal includes a court, and often these two terms are used interchangeably. The functions of the special tribunal are wholly judicial and not administrative. Some writers say it is not possible to define the word "Tribunal"; however, it means a seat or a bench upon which a judge or judges sit in a court to dispense justice as regards some special law.
Tribunals are clad (= clothed) in many of the trappings of a court, and though they exercise quasi-judicial functions, they are not full-fledged courts.
π Definition β Administrative Tribunal: An adjudicatory body which decides controversies and exercises judicial power as distinguished from pure administrative power, and possesses some of the trappings of a court but not all.
Reasons for the Growth of Administrative Tribunals
As per Dicey's theory of 'Rule of Law', the ordinary law of the state must be administered by the ordinary courts; hence, he believes there is no scope for Administrative Tribunal in a state. The classical theory of separation of power also states Dicey's view by saying that in a state it is the duty of the ordinary court to dispense justice and there is no scope for Administrative Tribunal.
However, the conversion of the police state concept into welfare state ideology has necessitated the emergence of special laws. Hence, in a modern state, Administrative Tribunals are inevitable.
Following are the cogent (= logical; convincing) reasons for the growth of Administrative Tribunals:
- The traditional courts are insufficient in number and capacity to keep pace with the role of governance in a welfare state.
- The traditional courts are slow in process, costly, and more formal in processing cases.
- Due to the manifold increase in socio-economic responsibility of governance, many special branches of society have emerged, and disputes thereunder need special courts; ordinary courts lack expertise in such specialized fields.
- Administrative tribunals can avoid technicalities as they take a functional view rather than a theoretical and legalistic one.
- The traditional judiciary is conservative, rigid, and technical. They follow strict rules of evidence and procedure, whereas tribunals are not bound to follow strict rules of evidence and procedure and can take a practical view of the matter to decide the issue in contention.
- In ordinary courts, decisions are given after hearing parties and on the basis of record and evidence. This procedure is not fully followed in administrative tribunals; instead, wide discretionary power is conferred on them, and they mostly follow the formula: less of law, more of discretion.
Characteristics of Administrative Tribunal
- Administrative Tribunal is not an executive body or administrative department of the Government.
- Administrative Tribunal cannot delegate its quasi-judicial function to any other authority.
- It follows rule of natural justice while discharging its judicial functions.
- Administrative tribunals are bound to perform their duties judicially.
- Administrative Tribunals record findings of facts and apply legal rules on the hearings.
- Administrative tribunal is the creation of a statute and has statutory origin.
- As regards procedural matters, Administrative Tribunal possesses powers of a court, e.g., to summon witnesses, to administer oath, and to compel production of documents.
- Administrative Tribunal is not bound to follow strict rules of evidence and procedure.
- Administrative Tribunals are independent and are not subject to administrative interference in the discharge of judicial and quasi-judicial functions.
- Against the decisions of Administrative Tribunal, writ of certiorari and writ of prohibition are available to an aggrieved person.
β Key Takeaways
Administrative Tribunals are statutory bodies created under Article 212 of the Constitution of Pakistan to adjudicate disputes arising under special laws, as the traditional judiciary is insufficient, slow, costly, and lacks expertise in specialized fields. The main types include Service, Election, Inland Revenue, and Labor Tribunals. While they possess many trappings of a court (e.g., power to summon witnesses), they are not bound by strict rules of evidence and procedure β instead, they follow a "less of law, more of discretion" approach. Key characteristics include independence from administrative interference, adherence to natural justice, and being creations of statute. Importantly, their decisions remain subject to judicial review through writs of certiorari and prohibition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under which Article of the Constitution of Pakistan can the legislature create Administrative Tribunals?
- What are the four kinds of Administrative Tribunals mentioned in the lecture?
- What is the difference between a "special law" and a "general law" as per Black's Law Dictionary?
- List three reasons why traditional courts are insufficient for modern governance, leading to the growth of Administrative Tribunals.
- What two writs are available to an aggrieved person against the decisions of an Administrative Tribunal?