π Lecture 34 β Kinds of Writ
π Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive explanation of the various kinds of writs available under constitutional law, with specific reference to the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. It details the meaning, purpose, and legal principles governing each writ, which are essential remedies for enforcing fundamental rights and ensuring lawful exercise of public office and judicial authority.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main kinds of writs: Writ of Quo Warranto (challenging the authority to hold a public office), Writ of Habeas Corpus (securing personal liberty against illegal detention), Writ of Certiorari (review of inferior court/tribunal proceedings), Writ of Prohibition (preventing a court from exceeding its jurisdiction), and Writ of Mandamus (compelling performance of a public duty). It also discusses the powers of the High Court under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
π Lecture Summary
Kinds of Writ
Meaning of the writ of Quo Warranto as per Blackβs Law Dictionary Edition 9th:
Writ of Quo Warranto is Law Latin for "by what authority". It is a common law writ used to inquire into the authority by which a public office is held. It is an action by which the state seeks to revoke a corporationβs charter.
The writ is a remedy whereby the Court enquires into the legality of the claim which a party assumes to an office, and to oust him from that office if the claim is not well founded, or to have it declared forfeited and to recover it.
The High Court, in exercising its constitutional jurisdiction, is competent to enquire from a person holding the public office as to under what authority of law he claims to hold the office.
The writ of Quo Warranto was in its nature an information, lying against a person who claimed and usurped an office, franchise or liberty and was intended to enquire by what authority he supported his claim in order that the right to the office or franchise or liberty may be determined. It is necessary for the issue of writ that the office should be one created by the state, by charter or by statute and that the duty attaching to the office should be of a public nature. It is also necessary that the respondent should be in possession and user of the particular office in question. The office must be substantive in character, that is, an office independent in title and not being terminable at pleasure.
Under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, the High Court in exercise of its constitutional jurisdiction is competent to inquire any person holding public office as to show under what authority he is holding the office. Under such situation it is the duty of the petitioner to provide information before the court that such officer has no legal authority to retain the office. For a petitioner who acts as an informer is not required to establish his locus standi to invoke the jurisdiction of the Court. The writ can be moved by a person who even is not an aggrieved party. Meaning thereby any person can move the High Court to challenge the unauthorized occupation of a public office.
Relief in Writ of Quo Warranto is confined to:- (i) issuing an injunction to a person holding the office not to act therein. (ii) where necessary to declare the office to be vacant.
π Definition β Writ of Quo Warranto: A remedy whereby the Court inquires into the legality of a claim to an office and ousts the holder if the claim is not well founded.
π Definition β Locus Standi: The right or capacity to bring an action or to appear in a court. For Quo Warranto, the petitioner does not need to establish this.
π Example: Any person can move the High Court to challenge the unauthorized occupation of a public office, even if that person is not personally aggrieved.
Writ of Habeas Corpus
Meaning of the Writ of Habeas Corpus as per Blackβs Law dictionary Edition 9th: Law Latin "that you have the body". It is a writ employed to bring a person before a court, most frequently to ensure that the personβs imprisonment or detention is not illegal.
Generally the writ of Habeas Corpus is issued in case of illegal and improper detention in public or private custody. Writ is applicable as a remedy in all cases of wrongful deprivation of personal liberty.
In other sense it may be said that the writ is issued to test the validity of any detention whether by the executive or by a private individual or by any other authority exercising judicial or quasi judicial powers.
The writ of Habeas Corpus may be used to obtain judicial review of the: (i) regularity of the extradition process; (ii) right to bail etc. (iii) jurisdiction of a court that has imposed a criminal sentence
Halsbury in his Laws of England 4th Edition states: The writ of Habeas Corpus is a prerogative process for securing the liberty of the subject by affording an effective means of immediate release from the unlawful or unjustifiable detention whether in prison or in private custody. It is a prerogative writ by which the Queen has a right to inquire into the laws for which any of her subjects are deprived of their liberty.
The writ of Habeas Corpus is also known as "the Great Writ of Liberty".
Kinds of Habeas Corpus Writ: Following are the kinds of Writ of Habeas Corpus:
(1) Habeas Corpus ad subjiciendum: It means that you have the body for submitting to and receiving. (2) Habeas Corpus ad testificundum: The object of this writ is to bring a legally detained person before the court for purpose of giving evidence. (3) Habeas Corpus ad deliberandum and recipiendum: The object of this writ is to remove a prisoner from one's custody to another for the purpose of his trial in the proper jurisdiction. (4) Habeas Corpus ad respondendum: The object of this writ is to bring a prisoner detained under civil or criminal processes, before a magistrate or court for trial or examination on any charge other than for which he has been imprisoned.
π Definition β Writ of Habeas Corpus: A prerogative writ employed to bring a person before a court to ensure that their imprisonment or detention is not illegal, also known as "the Great Writ of Liberty".
π Example: A person illegally detained by a private individual or by the executive can seek this writ to test the validity of their detention.
Writ of Certiorari
Law Latin word which means "to be more fully informed". It is an extraordinary writ issued by an appellate Court, at its discretion, directing a lower court to deliver the record in the case for review.
Halsbury states: "The order of Certiorari issues out of High Court, and is directed to the judge or officer of an inferior tribunal to bring proceeding in a cause or matter pending before the tribunal into the High Court to be dealt with in order to ensure that the applicant for the order may have the more sure and speedy justice. It may be had in either civil or criminal proceedings."
As observed by Mr. Justice Secrutoon: "the writ of Certiorari is a very old and high prerogative writ drawn up for the purpose of enabling the court of King's Bench to control the action of inferior courts and to make it certain that they shall not exceed their jurisdiction."
The Court issuing a Writ of Certiorari acts in exercise of a supervisory jurisdiction, not appellate jurisdiction. As regards the character and scope, certiorari will be issued for correcting error of jurisdiction: (1) When an inferior court or tribunal acts without jurisdiction or in excess of it or fails to exercise it. (2) When the court or tribunal acts illegally in the exercise of its undoubted jurisdiction as when it decides without giving an opportunity to the parties to be heard, or violates the principle of natural justice. (3) If there is an error apparent on the face of the record.
A writ of Certiorari is undoubtedly available to correct errors in the exercise of quasi judicial appellate powers. High Court can issue a Writ of Certiorari to inspect the proceedings of a subordinate Court to determine whether there has been any irregularity.
A person invoking discretionary power of court is bound to show that some injustice has been done to parties.
π Definition β Writ of Certiorari: An extraordinary writ issued by an appellate court, at its discretion, directing a lower court to deliver the record in the case for review, to correct errors of jurisdiction.
π Principle: The writ is issued in exercise of supervisory jurisdiction (not appellate) to correct errors of jurisdiction, violations of natural justice, or errors apparent on the face of the record.
π Example: If an inferior tribunal decides a case without giving the parties an opportunity to be heard, the High Court may issue a Writ of Certiorari to quash that decision.
Writ of Prohibition
Meaning of "Writ of Prohibition" as per Black's Law Dictionary Edition 9th: "An extraordinary writ issued by an appellate court to prevent a lower court from exceeding its jurisdiction or to prevent a non judicial officer or entity from exercising a power."
Prohibition is an original remedial writ, as old as Common Law itself. The writ is so ancient that forms have been given in Glanvile, the first book of English Law, written in 1189.
Prohibition is the converse of a "Writ of Mandamus" in the mandatory form, as the Writ of Prohibition is issued to prevent a court from doing something which it has no power to do. A "Writ of Prohibition" is an order directing an inferior tribunal to refrain from continuing with a proceeding therein on the ground that the proceeding is without or in excess of jurisdiction or contrary to the laws of the lands, and the proceeding may be without jurisdiction if it contravenes some enactment or some principles of Common Law.
Grounds on which "Writ of Prohibition" may be issued:
Want of Jurisdiction: The "Writ of Prohibition" lies only when it is intended to restrain a court or tribunal from assuming a jurisdiction which it does not possess. The writ lies not only for excess of jurisdiction but also for the contravention of some statute or principles of Common Law. A statutory functionary acting malafide or in a partial and unjust or apprehensive manner is amenable to the writ jurisdiction of the High Court. A "Writ of Prohibition" is justified only where there is an unlawful assumption of jurisdiction as distinguished from an erroneous and improper exercise of it.
Violation of Principle of Natural Justice: A "Writ of Prohibition" may be issued when it is found that the action was in violation of principles of natural justice. The procedure adopted without issuing a show cause notice was held to be against all principles and canons of justice, fair play and equity.
According to the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, a "Writ of Prohibition" may be issued against any person performing within the territorial jurisdiction of the court, functions in connection with the affairs of the Federation or Province or a local authority.
π Definition β Writ of Prohibition: An extraordinary writ issued by an appellate court to prevent a lower court from exceeding its jurisdiction or to prevent a non-judicial officer or entity from exercising a power.
π Example: If a lower court assumes jurisdiction over a matter it has no legal authority to hear, the High Court may issue a Writ of Prohibition to stop the proceedings.
Meaning of the term: "Writ of Mandamus" as per Black's Law Dictionary edition 9th:
Latin "We Command". The writ is issued by a Court to compel performance of a particular act by a lower court or a government officer or a body to correct a prior action or failure to do some act.
"Writ of Mandamus" is a command issued by the High Court directing any person to do any particular act therein specified which appertains to his office and is in the nature of a public duty.
A "Writ of Mandamus" cannot be issued without a right; absence of a clear right in writ petitioner would denude him to invoke the writ jurisdiction.
Writ of Mandamus is not issued against Government in discretionary matters. Writs of prohibition and writ of certiorari can be issued.
It is a well settled principle of law that a proceeding in the writ jurisdiction is more in the nature of a "Summary Proceedings" in which examination of disputed questions of fact is taken.
High Court on application of any aggrieved party has power to make an order directing a person performing within territorial jurisdiction of High Court functions in connection with affairs of Federation, Province or a Local authority to refrain from doing anything he was not permitted by law to do or to do anything he is required by law to do or make an order giving such directions to any person or authority exercising any power or performing any function in relation to any territory within the jurisdiction of that High Court as could be appropriate for enforcement of any fundamental rights conferred by the Constitution of Pakistan.
Mr. Justice Cornelius' Observation on the "Writ of Mandamus": The writ of mandamus is a direction issued to any natural person, corporation or inferior court within the jurisdiction requiring them to do some specific thing therein and which appertains to their office or duty.
π Definition β Writ of Mandamus: Latin for "We Command". A writ issued by a court to compel performance of a particular act by a lower court or a government officer or a body, which appertains to their office and is a public duty.
π Example: If a government officer is legally required to issue a license but refuses to do so without lawful justification, the High Court may issue a Writ of Mandamus compelling the officer to perform that duty.
Power of High Court under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973
Authorities performing judicial, quasi judicial and administrative functions fall under the jurisdiction of High Court. Article 199 makes no distinction between administrative, judicial or quasi judicial bodies.
Article 199 is wide in scope and has been introduced to correct the actions of Government functionaries which suffer either from lack of jurisdiction or excess of jurisdiction.
Right to file petition under Article 199 has been given to an "aggrieved person".
A writ petition under this Article is not maintainable if the petitioner has come for some indirect purpose.
A petitioner acting malafide is not entitled to relief by the High Court.
While exercising jurisdiction under Article 199, the court is not to treat the matter as if it were a court of further appeal.
π Definition β Aggrieved Person: A person who has suffered a legal grievance, against whom a decision has been pronounced which has wrongfully deprived them of something or wrongfully refused them something.
π‘ Why this matters: Article 199 provides a broad constitutional remedy to correct illegal actions by government functionaries, but it requires the petitioner to be genuinely aggrieved and not acting with improper motives.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture covers five distinct kinds of writs, each serving a specific legal purpose. The Writ of Quo Warranto challenges the authority to hold a public office and can be moved by any person without requiring locus standi. The Writ of Habeas Corpus is the "Great Writ of Liberty" used to secure release from illegal detention. The Writ of Certiorari is a supervisory writ to correct errors of jurisdiction or violations of natural justice by inferior tribunals. The Writ of Prohibition stops a court from exceeding its jurisdiction. The Writ of Mandamus compels performance of a public duty. Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 empowers the High Court to issue these writs to enforce fundamental rights, but only an aggrieved person acting in good faith can invoke this jurisdiction, and the court will not act as a court of further appeal.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the meaning of "Quo Warranto" and who can file a petition for this writ?
- Why is the Writ of Habeas Corpus called "the Great Writ of Liberty" and what are its four kinds?
- On what three grounds can a Writ of Certiorari be issued?
- What is the key difference between a Writ of Prohibition and a Writ of Mandamus?
- Under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973, who is entitled to file a writ petition and what is the limitation on the High Court's power while exercising this jurisdiction?
π Lecture 35 β Judicial Review
π Overview: This lecture examines the concept of judicial review of administrative action as a mechanism to check excesses of governmental power and protect private rights. It explores the historical development, purpose, grounds, and scope of judicial review across different legal systems including Britain, USA, and Pakistan, emphasizing its constitutional significance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and rationale for judicial review of administrative action, the historical practice and concept of judicial review in Britain, USA and Pakistan, the duty of courts in exercising judicial review, the purpose and object of judicial review, the grounds of judicial review including proportionality, unreasonableness, procedural impropriety, illegality and irrationality, and the powers and jurisdiction of courts under the Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
π Lecture Summary
Judicial Review of Administrative Action
Judicial Review acts as a check against excess of power in derogation of private right. The functionaries of state derive their powers from the constitution or laws and are required to act clearly within the defined parameters of law. Exercising governmental power is a sacred trust, and functionaries must perform their duties as trustees. They are required to act reasonably (logically; sensibly), impartially (neutrally), without arbitrariness (randomness), and within the defined sphere (area; field) of their power.
The development of administrative process poses many serious problems as it affects the relationship between public power and personal rights. It magnifies the problem of reconciling freedom and justice for the private citizen with the necessities of modern government demands regarding the promotion of far-reaching social or economic policies. The extended powers and functions of the modern state hold potential threats to justice and freedom. Properly exercised, the new powers of the executive lead to the welfare state, but abused they lead to the totalitarian state.
It has been established through experience that if administrative authorities are allowed to function unfettered of judicial control, then exercise of authority is likely to become colorable through arbitrariness, capriciousness, political influence, policy consideration and such other expediencies. This is the historical rationale for the introduction of judicial review of the administrative actions of authorities.
In strict sense, judicial review means that the Superior Courts can strike down a law on the touchstone of the Constitution. Moreover, it is inherent in the nature of Judicial Review that the Constitution is regarded as the supreme law, and any law or Act contrary to it or infringing its provisions is to be struck down by the court.
π Definition β Judicial Review: The power of Superior Courts to strike down a law on the touchstone of the Constitution; a mechanism to check that administrative authorities act within their defined legal parameters.
Practice and Concept of Judicial Review of Administrative Action in Britain, USA & Pakistan
In Britain, Administrative Law was not being studied as a separate branch of law due to the influence of A.V. Dicey. The idea of administrative adjudicatory authority entrusted with the power to determine private rights was anathema (abhorrence) to English Lawyers. Administrative Law was thought to be inconsistent with the maintenance of the rule of law. However, today the study of Administrative Law in Britain has recovered fully from Dicey's denial of its existence. The post-war period in Britain saw a steady rise in the number of Tribunals to deal with the problems following the war. Attempts have been made to regulate the working of such tribunals by the creation of the office of Parliamentary Commissioner under the Parliamentary Commissioner Act 1967.
In the USA, the creation of administrative bodies was also faced with initial resistance from the legal profession and influential writers. But the growth of administrative agencies has been accepted as inevitable. It was recognized that in a government of limited powers, these agencies of regulations must themselves be regulated. Judicial review has been found as an effective manner of regulating administrative agencies. The controversies about the powers of the administrative agencies and the scope of judicial review have clarified the issues and paved the way for a reasonable amount of judicial control over the agency actions.
In Pakistan, the development of judicial review of administrative action has followed the pattern of Britain and USA. There has been marked no opposition to the administrative process, but it has been accepted as an inevitable consequence of national planning and growth of the welfare state. Judicial review of the administrative action is commonly exercised through writ jurisdiction of the superior courts.
Duty of Court & Judicial Review
The duty of court in exercising the power of judicial review is to confine itself to the following questions:
(1) Whether a decision-making authority exceeded its powers? (2) Whether the authority has committed an error of law? (3) Whether the authority has committed a breach of the principle of natural justice? (4) Whether the authority has reached a decision which no reasonable person would have reached? (5) Whether the authority has abused its power?
It is to be noted that the power of judicial review is not directed against the decision but is confined to the decision-making process. Therefore, courts generally do not appreciate evidence or enter into determination of questions which demand elaborate examination of evidence or interference in the punishment imposed unless the administrative action is malafide.
π‘ Why this matters: This distinction β reviewing the process, not the decision itself β is fundamental to understanding the limited yet powerful scope of judicial review. Courts do not substitute their own judgment but ensure fairness in how decisions are reached.
Purpose & Object of Judicial Review
The purpose and object of judicial review is to keep various functionaries of State within the ambit of their authority. Firstly, Superior Courts check the functioning of the legislature β whether laws made by it are in conformity with the constitution. Secondly, it checks the quasi-legislative and quasi-judicial functions of the administration.
Delegated legislation i.e., rules, regulations, bye laws etc. made by the administration can be judicially reviewed by Superior courts to determine whether powers conferred on administration by the legislature have been properly exercised. Similarly, propriety of quasi-judicial action can also be subject to judicial review. Where any law made by the legislature is found in conflict with any provision of the constitution, or where any rule, regulation or bye law made or action taken by the administrative authorities are found to be violative of any provision of the constitution or any other law, the same is declared as ultra vires and invalid.
Though some discretion is necessary to keep the giant wheels of administration moving in this age of an intensive form of government, if the power is misused, the arms of the court are long enough to reach to pull the administration and compel it to obey the mandates of the constitution.
Grounds of Judicial Review
Following are the grounds of judicial review:
(1) Proportionality (2) Unreasonableness (3) Procedural impropriety (4) Illegality (5) Irrationality
Proportionality
Proportionality means that action should not be more drastic than it ought to be for obtaining the desired results. It covers some common ground with reasonableness. Proportionality is a course of action which could have been reasonably followed and should not be excessive or severe. The legal principle of proportionality acts in favor of reliability and predictability. This means that administrative action should be proportionate to the end pursued by the law.
π Definition β Proportionality: The principle that administrative action should not be more drastic than necessary to achieve the desired results; action should be proportionate to the end pursued by law.
Unreasonableness
Unreasonableness means that either the facts do not warrant the conclusion reached by the authority or the decision is partial and unequal in its operation. Unreasonableness of an action as a ground cannot be passed in the sense that it is not reasonable but in the sense that it is discriminative or partial or operates unequally between different classes or is manifestly unjust or malafide or oppressive or gross interference with the rights of the people that no justification can be found in the mind of a reasonable man.
π Definition β Unreasonableness: A ground of judicial review meaning the decision is partial, unequal, discriminatory, manifestly unjust, malafide, oppressive, or such that no reasonable person could justify it.
Procedural Impropriety
Procedural impropriety means that the procedure for taking administrative decision and action must be fair, reasonable and just. When a legislative, quasi-legislative, judicial or quasi-judicial action is called in question before any superior Court for judicial review, the court is quite competent to examine whether such actions suffer from any procedural infirmity of such a grave nature that it goes to the very root of validity of such action. Such actions are always liable to judicial review.
π Definition β Procedural Impropriety: A ground of judicial review where the procedure followed in taking administrative decisions or actions is not fair, reasonable, or just, and such procedural infirmity goes to the very root of validity of the action.
Illegality
Illegality as a ground for judicial review means that the decision maker must understand correctly the law that regulates his decision-making power and must give effect to it.
π Definition β Illegality: A ground of judicial review where the decision-maker fails to understand correctly or give effect to the law that regulates his decision-making power.
Irrationality
Irrationality means the decision which is so outrageous in its defiance of logic or of accepted moral standards that no sensible person who had applied his mind to the question to be decided could have arrived at that decision.
π Definition β Irrationality: A ground of judicial review where the decision is so outrageous in defiance of logic or accepted moral standards that no sensible person could have reached it.
Powers and Jurisdiction of Courts
Judicial Review is an essential feature and signature tune of our constitution. Administrative actions are subject to judicial control. Legislative power to make law is confined within the limit prescribed by the constitution. No law can be made which is in conflict with any constitutional provision or which may violate or take away or even abridge the Fundamental Rights that have been guaranteed in Part II of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. If the legislative or executive authorities trespass in the sphere of Fundamental Rights or transgress beyond the limits prescribed by the Constitution, any law made or action taken can be struck down as usurpation and unconstitutional exercise of powers.
The High Court under Article 199 and the Supreme Court of Pakistan under Article 184 of the Pakistan Constitution have vast powers to entertain and adjudicate constitutional petitions. Such jurisdiction of the Superior court is known as Constitutional Jurisdiction. In the ancient English Judicial system, this system was known as writ jurisdiction which empowered the court of King's Bench to issue writs in the name of the sovereign.
Pakistan has a hierarchical judicial system in which the Supreme Court of Pakistan is the Apex Court. It is the final interpreter of law and the ultimate court of appeal in all civil, criminal and constitutional matters. It is also the protector of people's Fundamental Rights.
Judicial review is not only an integral part of the Constitution of Pakistan but is also a basic structure of the Constitution which cannot be abolished. In any democratic society, judicial review is the soul of the system because without it democracy and the rule of law cannot be maintained.
π‘ Why this matters: The recognition of judicial review as part of the "basic structure" of the Constitution means it cannot be removed even by constitutional amendment, making it an unassailable feature of Pakistan's legal system.
β Key Takeaways
Judicial review serves to keep all state functionaries within the ambit of their constitutional and legal authority, reviewing the decision-making process rather than the decision itself. The duty of the court is confined to five key questions: whether the authority exceeded powers, committed an error of law, breached natural justice, reached an unreasonable decision, or abused its power. The five grounds of judicial review β proportionality, unreasonableness, procedural impropriety, illegality, and irrationality β provide a comprehensive framework for challenging administrative actions. In Pakistan, judicial review is exercised through the writ jurisdiction of the High Court (Article 199) and the Supreme Court (Article 184), and it forms part of the basic structure of the Constitution that cannot be abolished. Understanding these grounds and their application is essential for analyzing any administrative action's legality.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the difference between reviewing a decision itself and reviewing the decision-making process, and why does this distinction matter in judicial review?
-
What were the five specific questions that a court must consider when exercising the power of judicial review?
-
Explain how the principle of proportionality differs from unreasonableness as grounds for judicial review.
-
Under which articles of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 do the High Court and Supreme Court exercise their constitutional jurisdiction for judicial review?
-
Why is judicial review considered part of the "basic structure" of the Constitution of Pakistan, and what does this status mean for its abolishment?
π Lecture 36 β Ombudsman
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of the Ombudsman (or Mohtasib), tracing its roots from Islamic tradition through the Quranic concept of Ihtesab to modern global administrative practice. It examines the salient features of an effective Ombudsman system, provides an international historical overview, and details the establishment and functioning of the Ombudsman system in Pakistan, including its powers to combat mal-administration.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by defining the Ombudsman from multiple sources including Black's Law Dictionary, Encyclopedia Islam, and Sir Edmund Compton, establishing its role as a citizen's representative against government. It then outlines the ten salient features of an ideal Ombudsman system, from independence to publicizing reports. The historical development is traced from Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) as the first Ombudsman, through the Swedish model influenced by the Dewan-e-Mazalim, to its adoption in Denmark, Finland, New Zealand, and the UK. The lecture concludes with a detailed section on the Ombudsman system in Pakistan, the concept of mal-administration, and the specific powers of the Mohtasib.
π Lecture Summary
Meaning of the word: "Ombudsman" as per Black's Law Dictionary
"An official or semi official office or person to which people may come with grievances connected with government. The Ombudsman stands between and represents the citizen before the government."
Meanings of the word: "Ombudsman" as per Thomas Patric
"Muhtasib is the public censor of religion and morals who is appointed by a Muslim ruler to punish Muslim for neglecting the rules of their religion."
Meanings according to Encyclopedia Islam
The word βIhtesabβ has two meanings. On one hand, it means "it is the duty of every Muslim to promote good and forbid evil." On the other hand, it means "the function of the person who is effectively entrusted in a town with the application of this rule in the supervision of moral behavior and more particularly of the markets"; the person entrusted with the ihtesab is called "Muhtasib".
Meaning of the word: "Muhtasib" according to Advanced Learners Dictionary
"A government official who examines and reports on complaints made by ordinary people about the government or public authorities."
Role of Ombudsman defined by Sir Edmund Compton
The Ombudsman function is to investigate the action taken by a department and decide whether there has been mal-administration by the department or not. Primarily, the Ombudsman is an investigator.
Meaning of the word: Ombudsman as per Encyclopedia Americana
"Ombudsman, an independent public officer, appointed to receive complaints from citizens about abuses, unreasonable acts, or delays by government agencies. He investigates and reports his findings and recommends solutions."
In Islam the theoretical foundation of Muhtasib lie in the following Quranic verses:
Let there arise out of you a band of people inviting to all that is good, enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong. They are the ones to attain felicity. (Al-Quran (3:104)
Salient features of Ombudsman system
For a perfect Ombudsman system, the following are the glaring features:
- The Ombudsman exercises surprising amount of independence even from the legislature. Meaning thereby independence is fundamental to the ombudsman system.
- The ombudsman receives complaint about government action or inaction from the public or he sets on at his own initiatives.
- The ombudsman system involves speedy, inexpensive, and formal procedure.
- Ombudsman generally conducts an impartial investigation; he calls upon all persons for information, requires the production of documents and gets access to government record subject to specific limitations.
- He has no right to quash or reverse a decision or order of any official and can only make a report, recommendation or suggestion even in Sweden and Finland. His most potent weapon is an expression of his opinion.
- Ombudsman is easily accessible.
- He gives reasons for the dismissal of a complaint.
- An advocate is not required once a complaint is filed, the Ombudsman himself becomes the moving party.
- Ombudsman may suggest changes or improvements in administrative procedure or change in legislation.
- The Ombudsman publicizes his opinions and issue reports.
First Ombudsman of the world & the office of Ombudsman in different countries
Prophet Muhammad (Peace be upon him) was the first Ombudsman of the world who introduced the institution of Muhtasib and provided justice to the down trodden people of Arabia. The institution of Muhtasib is one of the most distinctive features of the socio-administrative history of Islam. It ceased to exist by the end of the 19th century as an office of public conscience and morality, but left behind a trail of golden traditions.
The office of the Swedish Ombudsman is the long established and the most powerful of all contemporary ombudsman offices. Public Administration books reveal that the office was the outcome of a historical event in the era of King Charles XII when there was a rebellion against him. The King sought refuge in Turkey where he observed the working of Dewan-e-Mazalim. The King learnt the concept and established the institution of Ombudsman in Sweden in 1713.
Denmark has had an office of Ombudsman since 1966 when a new constitution was being planned after the First World War. The committee on the constitution proposed that Parliament should elect one or two persons from outside the Parliament whose function would be to supervise the administrative system and the armed forces. The committee gave its opinion that such increased guarantees could be through the office of Ombudsman similar to the Swedish prototype.
Following the Swedish example, the institution of parliamentary ombudsman was included in the Constitution Act of 1919 in Finland. Credit goes to Finland for having adopted the institution of Ombudsman long before the idea became popular in the rest of the democratic world.
New Zealand established the institution of Ombudsman by enacting the "Parliament Commissioner (Ombudsman) Act 1962". The Commissioner was appointed by the Governor General.
In the late fifties and the beginning of the sixties in the U.K., the view gained ground that there was a need for a citizen's grievance against administration. The emerging belief that the minister's own accountability to Parliament was no longer sufficient to protect the victim of departmental error and mal-administration led to the establishment of the office of Parliamentary Commissioner in 1967.
Ombudsman system in Pakistan
In Pakistan, the establishment of an Ombudsman institution had been advocated for some time before Article 276 of the interim Constitution of 1972 provided for the appointment of a Federal Ombudsman and Provincial Ombudsman. In Urdu, this institution is called "Wafaqi Mohtasib" or "Sobaei Mohtasib". The Constitution of Pakistan 1973 also provided for a Federal Ombudsman, and the institution was eventually created through the Establishment of the Office of Wafaqi Mohtasib Order 1983, which is now part of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 by virtue of Article 270-A.
The Ombudsman has its Head Quarter in Islamabad and Regional offices in Lahore, Sukkur, Quetta, Faisalabad, Multan, Dera Ismail Khan, Peshawar, and Karachi. Other Ombudsman agencies in Pakistan include Provincial Ombudsman offices in Punjab, Balochistan, and Sindh. There are also a Banking Ombudsman, Federal Insurance Ombudsman, and a Federal Tax Ombudsman. The disputed region of Azad Jammu Kashmir also has an Ombudsman Office. Under the Protection of Woman at Work Place Act 2010, Musarat Hilali was appointed in the same year to be the first Ombudsman for the protection of women against harassment at the workplace.
The various Ombudsman agencies participate in a forum of Pakistan Ombudsman, and the Federal bodies are affiliated to the Asian Ombudsman Association and the International Ombudsman Institute.
Mal-administration, a persistent evil of the executive organ of a state
The dictionary meaning of the term mal-administration is 'faulty administration'. Sir K.C. Wherare asserts that mal-administration is a very large subject; it occurs wherever social organization exists, and it is not confined to the operation of the government or the state alone. It is not eccentric (strange) to conclude that if there is more administration, there will be more mal-administration. Nobody can define mal-administration in plain terms, said Sir Edmund Compton.
Maladministration can be divided into three parts: firstly, mal-administration connected with the executive actions of government; secondly, mal-administration connected with the discretionary decisions of government; and thirdly, mal-administration arising out of faulty laws. Maladministration in different departments of government takes place in the following form:
- Abuse of powers
- Biased attitude
- Misconduct
- Undue delays in proceedings
- Inability of the staff in comprehending the relevant laws
- Negligent behavior
- Adoption of defective procedure
- Wrong adjudication by the department
- Arbitrary decisions
Powers of Mohtasib
If the Mohtasib finds an element of mal-administration in a matter, he can, after investigating the matter, ask the agency concerned to consider the matter further, to modify or cancel its decision, to take disciplinary action against any public servant, to dispose of the case within a specified time, or to improve the working of the agency, or to take any other specified steps.
Failure on the part of an agency to comply with the Ombudsmanβs recommendation is treated as "Defiance of Recommendations", which may lead to reference of the matter to the President of Pakistan, who in his discretion may direct the Agency to implement the recommendations.
The Mohtasib is empowered to award compensation to an aggrieved person for any loss or damage suffered by that person on account of maladministration. But if the complaint is found to be false, or frivolous, he can also award compensation to the agency or the functionary against whom the complaint was made.
The Mohtasib has the same powers as a civil court under the Civil Procedure Code for production of documents and receiving evidence on affidavits. He also has powers identical to that of the Supreme Court of Pakistan to punish any person for contempt.
From the complaints against Federal agencies, 50 percent were admitted for thorough investigation, and the remaining were not entertained due to the reason that either they were subjudice service matters or no mal-administration was found apparently. During the year 1993, the highest number of complaints β i.e., 20,934 out of 44,578 complaints after scrutiny β were admitted for investigation, and 79 percent of them were disposed of resulting in relief to the aggrieved. Since its establishment, the most significant impact of this institution is that it has revived the concept of administrative accountability in Pakistan, which is both an Islamic tenet (principle) and a democratic obligation.
β Key Takeaways
The Ombudsman is an independent public officer who receives and investigates citizen complaints against government mal-administration, but whose primary power is recommendation rather than direct reversal of decisions. The concept has deep Islamic roots in the Quranic principle of "enjoining good and forbidding evil" and was historically institutionalized as the Muhtasib, while also being influenced by the Dewan-e-Mazalim observed by the Swedish King. In Pakistan, the Federal Ombudsman (Wafaqi Mohtasib) was established by the 1983 Order and possesses civil court powers for investigation and can award compensation, but relies on the President for enforcement against defiant agencies. Mal-administration is defined broadly to include abuse of power, bias, negligence, delays, and arbitrary decisions, and it is the central evil the Ombudsman system is designed to address.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental characteristic of an Ombudsman system, and what is the Ombudsman's "most potent weapon" since he cannot quash official decisions?
- According to the lecture, who is considered the first Ombudsman of the world, and which historical Islamic institution influenced the creation of the Swedish Ombudsman?
- What is the definition of "mal-administration," and list at least four of its specific forms as mentioned in the lecture.
- Under the Establishment of the Office of Wafaqi Mohtasib Order 1983, what actions can the Mohtasib take if he finds an element of mal-administration?
- What happens when a government agency fails to comply with the Ombudsman's recommendation, and what power does the Mohtasib have regarding compensation?
π Lecture 37 β Definitions of Administrative Law
π Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental definitions of Administrative Law as provided by two prominent legal scholars, Sir Ivor Jennings and K.C. Davis. It breaks down the core components of these definitions, including the concepts of "administration" and "administrative agencies," as well as the critical process of "judicial review," explaining why this branch of law is essential for regulating government power.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by acknowledging the difficulty in precisely defining Administrative Law, then presents and explains the definition by Sir Ivor Jennings, focusing on the meaning of "administration." It then presents the definition by K.C. Davis, explaining the terms "administrative agencies" and "judicial review." The lecture concludes by synthesizing Davis's definition into a comprehensive statement.
π Lecture Summary
Definitions of Administrative Law
It is impossible to give a precise definition of Administrative Law; nevertheless the following definitions of Administrative Law are discussed:
Definition of Administrative Law by Sir Ivor Jennings
βAdministrative Law is the law relating to the administrationβ.
π Definition β Administration: It is the management of the executive duties of government institutions. Thus it may be said that βAdministrative Lawβ is the law relating to the management of the executive duties of a government institutions.
Definition of Administrative Law by K.C Davis
Administrative Law is the law concerning the powers and procedures of administrative agencies, including especially the law governing judicial review of administrative action.
π Definition β Administrative Agencies: It means a governmental body with the authority to implement and administer particular legislation for example Police, F.I.A. & FBR etc.
π Definition β Judicial Review: It is a courtβs power to review the actions of other branches of government i.e. legislature and executive.
Thus it may be said that βAdministrative Lawβ is the βlawβ concerning the powers and procedures of governmental bodies with the authority to implement and administer particular legislation for example F.I.A and Police etc. including especially the law governing courtβs power to review the action of other branches of government i.e. legislature and executive.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture presents two key definitions of Administrative Law. Sir Ivor Jennings' definition is broad, framing it as the law relating to the management of executive duties of government institutions. K.C. Davis' definition is more specific, focusing on the powers and procedures of administrative agencies (like the Police or FBR) and the crucial role of judicial review, which is the court's power to oversee actions of the legislature and executive. For an exam, a student must be able to state both definitions and explain the core components: administration, administrative agencies, and judicial review.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is Sir Ivor Jennings' definition of Administrative Law?
- According to the lecture, what is meant by "administration"?
- In the context of K.C. Davis's definition, what is an "administrative agency"?
- What does the term "judicial review" mean?
- How does K.C. Davis define Administrative Law?