π Lecture 23 β Fundamental RightβInviolability of Dignity of Man and Privacy of Home
π Overview: This lecture examines Article 14 of the Pakistan Constitution of 1973, which guarantees the inviolability of human dignity and the privacy of home. It explains the limits of this protection, the prohibition of torture for confessions, and the legal remedies available when these fundamental rights are violated.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the meaning and scope of Article 14, including the key terms "dignity," "subject to law," and "inviolable." It discusses the regulation of privacy rights, the prohibition and history of torture, specific legal provisions against torture in Pakistan, and concludes with the remedy of a writ of prohibition for enforcement of these rights.
π Lecture Summary
Fundamental Right---Inviolability of Dignity of Man and Privacy of Home
Article 14 of the Pakistan Constitution of 1973 provides that "the dignity of man and, subject to law, privacy of home, shall be inviolable." This establishes two core protections: the inherent worth of every person and the security of their residence. The protection of the privacy of home is made subject to law, meaning it can be regulated by law but not abolished. For example, a police officer may be permitted by law to enter a house to make an arrest or a search. However, actions like tapping or stealthily photographing something inside a house are considered invasions of privacy.
π‘ Why this matters: The phrase "subject to law" creates a balance between individual rights and the state's need to enforce laws, such as for lawful arrests or searches, preventing the right from being an absolute barrier to justice.
π Definition β Dignity: self-respect. π Definition β Subject to law: having regard to the law. π Definition β Inviolable: sacred; unchallengeable; unbreakable.
The lecture clarifies that the protection is not absolute. The guarantee cannot be taken away by law, but it can be regulated. Torture, defined as the infliction of pain on human beings, is prohibited by both Article 14 and the general law. Despite this, police sometimes inflict various forms of torture on suspects, such as keeping them awake all night, laying them on an ice slab, or hanging them from the ceiling with head downwards, to extract evidence.
In England, torture was once a recognized part of criminal procedure. In 1689, the "Claim of Right" was enacted to curb it, declaring the use of torture in petty cases without evidence illegal. Instruments like iron bars and thumbscrews were used. Torture was finally abolished in England during the reign of Queen Anne by an Act of Parliament.
In Pakistan, torture is prohibited by various laws. Under Section 163(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898, "no police officer or any person in authority shall offer or make any inducement, threat or promise for obtaining a confession." Under Section 348 of the Pakistan Penal Code 1860, it is an offence to wrongfully confine a person for the purpose of extracting a confession from him. Furthermore, Article 38 of the Qanun-e-Shahdat 1984 states that a confession made to a Police Officer is inadmissible as evidence against the maker.
π Definition β Code: a complete system of positive laws, carefully arranged and officially promulgated. π Definition β Confine: detain in prison. π Definition β Extracting: taking. π Definition β Confession: declaration of guilt. π Definition β Abolished: eradicated. π Definition β Inadmissible: not allowed; disallowed.
Remedy for the enforcement of the fundamental rights
A remedy is the means of enforcing a right or preventing a wrong. Where executive action questions the dignity of man and privacy of home, the remedy is filing a writ of prohibition.
π Definition β Remedy: the means of enforcing a right or preventing a wrong.
A writ of prohibition is an extraordinary writ issued by an appellate court to prevent a lower court from exceeding its jurisdiction or to prevent a non-judicial officer or entity from exercising a power. No person can be arrested by the Police except in accordance with law for the purpose of investigation. Where it is found that Police or other agency is acting against the law and contrary to the fundamental rights of a citizen, then a writ of prohibition may be filed with the court.
π Definition β Writ of prohibition: an extraordinary writ issued by an appellate court to prevent a lower court from exceeding its jurisdiction or to prevent a non-judicial officer or entity from exercising a power. π Definition β Contrary: opposite. π Example: If police enter a private home without legal authorization to conduct a search, a citizen can file a writ of prohibition to stop the action. Similarly, if police torture a suspect to extract a confession, a writ of prohibition can be sought to forbid this unlawful action.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that Article 14 of the Constitution guarantees the inviolability of human dignity and the privacy of home, but the latter is subject to reasonable regulation by law. Torture is strictly prohibited in Pakistan by multiple laws, including the Constitution, the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Pakistan Penal Code, and the Qanun-e-Shahdat, and any confession obtained through such means is inadmissible as evidence. Understand the precise definitions of key terms like "dignity," "inviolable," and "subject to law" as they apply to Article 14. Finally, know that the primary remedy for violation of these fundamental rights is a writ of prohibition, which is used to prevent a lower court or authority from acting outside its jurisdiction or in violation of law.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does Article 14 of the Pakistan Constitution of 1973 state regarding dignity and privacy?
- Explain the significance of the phrase "subject to law" in the context of the privacy of home.
- Name three specific laws in Pakistan that prohibit or penalize torture or the extraction of confessions by force.
- What is the definition of a writ of prohibition, and when is it the appropriate remedy for a violation of Article 14?
- Define the terms "inviolable," "dignity," and "inadmissible" as used in this lecture.
π Lecture 24 β Fundamental Rights ----(1) Freedom of Movement etc. (2) Freedom of Assembly
π Overview: This lecture examines two fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973: the freedom of movement (Article 15) and the freedom of assembly (Article 16). It explains the scope, limitations, and judicial interpretation of these rights, including concepts like externment, internment, and the determination of reasonable restrictions in both normal times and national emergencies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Article 15 on freedom of movementβincluding the right to remain, enter, move freely, reside, and settle in any part of Pakistan subject to reasonable restrictions in public interest. It also covers Article 16 on freedom of assemblyβincluding the right to assemble peacefully without arms, the distinction between rights and liberties under English law, judicial tests for reasonableness, and the impact of national emergencies on these freedoms.
π Lecture Summary
Article 15 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 provides that βevery citizen shall have the right to remain in, and subject to any reasonable restriction imposed by law in the public interest, enter and move freely throughout Pakistan and to reside and settle in any part thereof.
This article guarantees every citizen the right to stay in Pakistan, with the ability to enter, move freely, reside, and settle in any part of the country. The right to remain in the country is described as absolute and unqualified. Key terms include: Remain (= stay; continue), Subject to (= having regard to), Reasonable (= logical; practical; sensible), Restriction (= limitations; control), Public interest (= community concern), and Any part thereof (= any part of Pakistan).
Under Article 15, a citizen cannot be banished from the country. His right to step in, step out from the country, move freely throughout Pakistan, reside, and settle in any part of Pakistan is subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by law. In Abul Ala's Maudoodi vs. the State Bank of Pakistan (PLD 1969 Lah. 908), Muhammad Akram, J. held that the purpose behind this safeguard "is to remove all territorial barriers within the country for the citizens of Pakistan. It is designed to be a check against provincialism, regional discrimination, and all parochial considerations." To a citizen of Pakistan, the whole of his country is his cherished home, freely and equally accessible to him subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the public interest.
π Definition β Externment order: An order meaning "to leave a certain area." π Definition β Internment order: An order meaning "not to leave a certain area." Both orders curtain (restrict) the freedom of movement. A law authorizing externment or internment must fall within the limits of permissible legislation, and the restrictions on the exercise of the right of freedom of movement must be reasonable and in public interest.
Freedom of Assembly
Freedom of Assembly includes taking part in public meetings, processions, and demonstrations. Under English Law, all the freedoms including the freedom of assembly are in fact liberties and not rights. Freedom of assembly means that there is no law forbidding people to assemble. If a number of people choose to go to the same place at the same time, this is not unlawful, provided that they keep within the limits of the law, individually and collectively. An assembly convened for the purpose of affecting a breach of peace is unlawful at Common Law, and there are various statutory offenses, notably under Public Orders Acts, Highways Acts, the Police Act 1964, and local bye-laws. Britain is a party to the European Convention which provides that everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly.
Article 16 of the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 provides that "every citizen shall have the right to assemble peacefully without arms, subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of public order." The US Supreme Court held that "the very idea of a government, republican in form, implies a right on the part of citizens to meet peaceably for consultation in respect of public affairs."
The fundamental right guaranteed to citizens of Pakistan is to gather unarmed and for peaceful purposes, which can only be restricted by laws that have as their object the maintenance of public order. The restrictions imposed must be reasonable, and in each case it is the court to decide whether the restriction is reasonable or not. In deciding whether the restrictions are reasonable or not, the court will take into consideration the conditions prevailing at the time, the extent and the duration of the restrictions, and all the other surrounding circumstances.
In Abdul Hameed Qadri vs. D.M. Lahore (P.L.D. 1957 Lah. 213), it was held that "the danger to human life and safety and the disturbance of the public tranquility fall within the purview of the expression 'public order', and if an order is passed by the District Magistrate to prevent danger to human life and safety and the disturbance of public tranquility, it is an order passed in the interest of public order."
π Definition β Tranquility: Meaning harmony.
Determining reasonableness of restrictions
In determining the reasonableness of restrictions, several circumstances shall have to be taken into consideration, including the conditions prevailing at that time, and the nature, extent, and duration of the restrictions of the fundamental rights. Having regard to all the surrounding circumstances, the restriction imposed may be quite unreasonable, while in a different set of circumstances that may be reasonable. There cannot be laid down any absolute and fixed standard by which the reasonableness of restrictions upon fundamental rights may be tested, but it can be safely assumed that in judging the same an objective standard i.e., the standard of the average prudent man shall have to be applied.
The concept of reasonableness is nothing but that of harmonizing individual's right with collective interest.
Freedom of assembly in the state of national emergency
Freedom of assembly may be restricted to a greater extent in time of national emergency than in normal times. The restriction should be certain and well defined and imposed directly by law rather than by the discretionary authority of the Police or other executive authority. In Nawab Zada Nasrullah Khan vs. Government of West Pakistan (P.L.D. 1965 Lah. 642), it was ruled that freedom of assembly is not in its nature absolute. It is a relative right subject to imposition of reasonable restrictions with necessary conditions to safeguard the public interest.
According to American Law, there must be grave and immediate danger to the interest of public order to restrict the right. In other words, any attempt to restrict freedom of assembly must be justified by clear public interest threatened, not doubtfully or remotely, but by clear and present danger, and only the gravest abuses, endangering paramount interests, give occasion for permissible limitation on the right.
π‘ Why this matters: The freedom of assembly is not unlimitedβit must be balanced against public order. During emergencies, greater restrictions are permissible, but they must be justified by a clear and present danger, not by vague or remote threats. Courts play the crucial role of determining whether restrictions are reasonable in each specific context.
π Definition β Grave: Meaning serious. π Definition β Paramount: Meaning supreme; dominant.
β Key Takeaways
The right to remain in Pakistan under Article 15 is absolute and unqualified, but movement, residence, and settlement are subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the public interest. The purpose of Article 15 is to remove territorial barriers and check provincialism and regional discrimination. Freedom of assembly under Article 16 guarantees the right to assemble peacefully without arms, subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of public order. Courts determine reasonableness by considering prevailing conditions, the nature, extent, and duration of restrictions, and all surrounding circumstances using an objective standard. During national emergencies, greater restrictions on assembly are permissible, but they must be justified by a clear and present danger to paramount interests.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between an "externment order" and an "internment order," and what two conditions must a law authorizing such orders satisfy to be valid?
- According to the Supreme Court of the United States, what does the idea of a republican government imply about the right of citizens to assemble?
- In Abdul Hameed Qadri vs. D.M. Lahore, what two situations were held to fall within the purview of "public order"?
- What standard must be applied to judge the reasonableness of restrictions on fundamental rights, according to the lecture?
- Under American Law, what kind of danger must exist to justify restricting the freedom of assembly, and what term is used to describe this requirement?
π Lecture 25 β Fundamental Right---Freedom of Association
π Overview: This lecture explains the constitutional right to freedom of association under Article 17 of the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973. It covers the meaning, scope, limitations, and judicial interpretations of this fundamental right, including the formation of associations, unions, and political parties. Understanding this lecture is essential for grasping how individual liberties are balanced against state interests like sovereignty and public order.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the phrase "freedom of association" and then examines Article 17 of the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973, in detail. It outlines the three freedoms guaranteed by this article: formation of associations, unions, and political parties. The lecture then discusses the objects of associations, the legal documents containing their aims, landmark case laws on reasonable restrictions, and the writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 199 for enforcement of these rights.
π Lecture Summary
Meaning of the phrase βFreedom of Associationβ
Freedom of association means forming and belonging to political parties, trade unions, societies, and other organizations. A person is at liberty to join an association provided it does not amount to criminal conspiracy under the criminal law. Conversely, no one is obliged by law to join any association against their will.
π Definition β Freedom of Association: the right to form and belong to political parties, trade unions, societies, and other organizations.
Article 17 of the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973
Article 17 provides that every citizen shall have the right to form associations or unions, subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of the sovereignty or integrity of Pakistan. Additionally, every citizen not being in the service of Pakistan shall have the right to form or be a member of a political party, subject to similar restrictions. If the Federal Government declares a political party is operating in a manner prejudicial to sovereignty or integrity, the matter must be referred to the Supreme Court within fifteen days, and the Court's decision is final.
π Formula: Article 17 β Right to form associations/unions/political parties, limited by reasonable restrictions for sovereignty/integrity/public order/morality.
π Example: In Abul Aβla Maudoodi vs. Government of West Pakistan (P.L.D 1964 S.C 673), Section 16 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1908, which authorized the Provincial Government to declare an association unlawful based on subjective satisfaction, was held to be an unconstitutional interference with the right of freedom of association. The Court determined that the reasonableness of a restriction must be examined by the court, including the mode of application.
Three freedoms guaranteed by Article 17
Article 17 guarantees three freedoms: (1) Freedom to form associations, (2) Freedom to form unions, and (3) Freedom to form political parties. The first two freedoms are subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of sovereignty or integrity of Pakistan, public order or morality. The third freedom (political parties) is subject only to reasonable restrictions in the interest of sovereignty or integrity of Pakistan. The right flows from other fundamental rights like freedom of movement, profession, speech, and religion.
π Definition β Vicarious Liability: liability that a supervisory party bears for the actionable conduct of a subordinate or associate based on the relationship between the two parties.
Objects of Associations
An association may take the form of a political party, company, institute, firm, union, society, or club. When persons combine for a common object, they generally set out their aims and objects in a document and establish an organizational structure. They may associate for political, economic, or social purposes, or for promoting science, religion, art, culture, literature, or charity. So long as the purpose is lawful, the law imposes no restriction.
π Definition β Documents containing aims and objects: written documents outlining the purpose and organizational structure of an association.
π Example: The dissolution of Imdadi companies by the Undesirable Companies Act 1958 was upheld in Progress of Pakistan Co. Ltd. Vs. Registrar Joint Stock Companies (P.L.D. 1958 Lah.887) because the companies encouraged immoral gambling, thus falling outside lawful purposes.
Deputing person to attend meeting in violative of Rights
A law that authorizes a District Magistrate to depute a person to attend a public meeting for reporting purposes and to compel the meeting organizer to admit that person is an unjustified invasion of the right of free assembly and association.
π Example: In Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan vs. Government of West Pakistan (P.L.D. 1965 Lah. 642), it was held that such a law violates the right of free assembly and association.
Compulsory registration and rendition of accounts by political parties
Compulsory registration of political parties violates Article 17(2) of the Constitution. However, provisions requiring the rendition of accounts for audit by political parties are in consonance with Article 17(3), which mandates that every political party shall account for the source of its funds in accordance with law.
π Example: In Benazir Bhutto vs. Federation of Pakistan (P.L.D. 1988 S.C. 416), it was held that Article 17(3) requires every political party to account for the sources of its funds. The purpose is to identify foreign-aided parties whose activities are prejudicial to the sovereignty or integrity of Pakistan, as fund sources provide a guideline for determining a party's true character.
Writ Jurisdiction of High Court
Article 199 of the Constitution is very wide in scope and is introduced to correct actions of government functionaries suffering from lack of jurisdiction or excess of jurisdiction. If citizens are deprived of their constitutional guarantee illegally or not in accordance with law, Article 199 can be invoked for redress.
π Definition β Revoked: cancelled.
π Example: The High Court, on the application of an aggrieved party, has the power to make an order directing a person performing functions within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court (in connection with affairs of the Federation, Province, or a local authority) to refrain from doing anything against the fundamental rights conferred by the Constitution.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points for exam preparation are: Article 17 guarantees three distinct rightsβto form associations, unions, and political partiesβeach with specific limitations. The first two are subject to reasonable restrictions for sovereignty, integrity, public order, or morality, while political party formation is restricted only for sovereignty or integrity. Forced attendance at meetings by government deputies is unconstitutional, and compulsory registration of political parties is invalid, but mandatory accounting of funds is lawful. The High Court's writ jurisdiction under Article 199 provides broad remedies against any infringement of fundamental rights by government functionaries.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three freedoms guaranteed by Article 17 of the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973?
- In what ways do the restrictions on forming political parties differ from those on forming associations or unions?
- Why was the dissolution of Imdadi companies upheld in the Progress of Pakistan Co. Ltd. case?
- What was the ratio decidendi in Abul Aβla Maudoodi vs. Government of West Pakistan regarding the reasonableness of restrictions?
- According to Benazir Bhutto vs. Federation of Pakistan, why does Article 17(3) require political parties to account for their funds?
π Lecture 26 β Fundamental Rightβ(1) Freedom of Trade, Business or Profession (2) Safeguards Against Taxation for the Purposes of any Particular Religion
π Overview: This lecture explains two fundamental rights guaranteed under the Pakistan Constitution 1973. First, it examines Article 18 which provides citizens the freedom to engage in lawful professions, trades, and businesses, along with the limitations the state may impose. Second, it discusses Article 21 which safeguards individuals from being forced to pay taxes for the propagation of religions other than their own.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the provisions of Article 18 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 regarding freedom of trade, business, or profession, including the conditions and provisos that allow regulation through licensing systems, free competition measures, and government monopolies. It also addresses Munir's interpretation of the word "lawful" and Cornelius J.'s observations on regulation versus licensing systems. The second part examines Article 21's safeguard against compulsory taxation for religious purposes, distinguishing between taxes and fees. Finally, it discusses the writ jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 199 for enforcing fundamental rights.
π Lecture Summary
Fundamental RightβFreedom of Trade, Business or Profession
Article 18 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provides that "subject to such qualifications, if any, as may be prescribed by law, every citizen shall have the right to enter upon any lawful profession or occupation and to conduct any lawful trade or business."
π‘ Why this matters: This article establishes the constitutional basis for economic freedom while allowing reasonable state regulation.
π Definition β Subject to: having regard to π Definition β Qualification: prerequisites; criterion π Definition β Lawful: permitted by law π Definition β Profession: line of work; career π Definition β Trade: buying & selling
Thus Article 18 provides that having regard to such prerequisites or criteria, if any, as may be prescribed by law, every citizen shall have the right to enter upon any career or occupation permitted by law and to conduct any lawful buying and selling or business.
Provided that nothing in this Article shall prevent: (a) The regulation of any trade or profession by a licensing system; or (b) The regulation of trade, commerce or industry in the interest of free competition therein; or (c) Carrying on, by the Federal Government or a Provincial Government, or by a corporation controlled by any such Government, of any trade, business, industry or service to the exclusion, complete or partial, of other persons.
π Definition β Provided: proviso; adds condition or exception or addition to whatever is said earlier π Definition β Regulation: parameter π Definition β Licensing system: authorization system π Definition β Exclusion: keeping out; leaving out π Definition β Complete: total; whole π Definition β Partial: part
Simple Sense of the Fundamental Right: Freedom of Trade, Business or Profession
The sense of this fundamental right may be stated by saying that every citizen of Pakistan is entitled to engage himself in any lawful profession and occupation and do any lawful trade or business, but the state may by law: (i) Prescribe qualification for the practice of a profession, occupation, trade or business; (ii) Regulate any trade or profession by a licensing system; (iii) Regulate any trade, commerce or industry in the interest of free competition; and (iv) Assume for itself or grant to a Government controlled corporation, the monopoly, complete or partial, of any trade, business, industry or service.
Munir Says the Word βLawfulβ Implies Complete Banning of Profession etc.
Munir opined that the word 'lawful' that occurs in the principal paragraph has the import of enabling the state completely to ban a profession, occupation, trade or business by declaring it to be unlawful. According to him, "unlawful" in common parlance means anything forbidden by law and this is also the meaning assigned to it in law.
π Definition β Parlance: manner of speaking
Therefore the right to enter upon a profession or occupation or to conduct any trade or business can hardly be described to be an unqualified constitutional right when such right may be denied by law.
In the case of East & West Steamship Co. vs. Pakistan P.L.D 1958 S.C. 41, Cornelius, J., in the light of the provisions of the Control of Shipping Act, 1947, made observations which illustrate the concepts of "regulation", "license" and "licensing system" as under:
"I consider that the law constitutes a violation of the main provisions under Article 12, guaranteeing a right to conduct a lawful trade, and I consider also that a law expressed in the terms of the Control of Shipping Act relating to any trade cannot fall within the saving clause provided for regulation of trade by a licensing system..."
Cornelius, J. also observed that "the freedom which the citizens had guaranteed to themselves is thus placed entirely at the disposal of the Executive to respect or destroy as it pleases."
Right to Apply for License is a Valuable Right
The fundamental right authorizes the regulation of any trade or profession by a licensing system. The state therefore may by law direct that certain trades or professions will not be carried on except under a license, and it may by license determine the place where and the time when certain businesses are to be conducted. But the right to apply for a license is not a fake but a valuable right, as held by Shamim Textile Mills vs. Republic of Pakistan P.L.D. 1972, and therefore a law may be attacked on the ground that the rule-making power under it amounts to excessive delegation of legislative power.
π Definition β Right: an interest protected by law
Government Trading & Monopolies
Clause (c) of the Proviso to Article 18 permits the Government or a Government-controlled corporation to have a monopoly in any trade, business, industry or service. But the clause does not permit the State to confer any such privilege on a private person or a corporation, as any such measure would amount to an ouster of other citizens from the trade or industry.
π Definition β Monopoly: domination; cartel π Definition β Confer: bestow π Definition β Privilege: advantage π Definition β Ouster: expulsion
On the other hand, as would appear from proviso (b) to Article 10, the Government should, where a monopoly exists, regulate the trade or industry in the interest of free competition.
Safeguards Against Taxation for Purposes of Any Particular Religion
Article 21 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 provides that "no person shall be compelled to pay any special tax, the proceeds of which are to be spent on the propagation or maintenance of any religion other than his own."
π Definition β Tax: impost; burden; charge π Definition β Proceed: revenue π Definition β Propagation: promulgation; spreading
Thus Article 21 provides that no person shall be obliged to pay any special tax, the revenue of which is to be spent on the promulgation or maintenance of any religion other than his own.
π Definition β Promulgation: spread; proliferation
In order to attract the provision of this article, the levy must be a tax. Where the imposition is in the nature of a fee, it does not fall within the prohibition of this article. There is no generic difference between a tax and a fee. Both are different forms in which the taxing power of a state manifests itself.
π Definition β Levy: charge π Definition β Generic: basic
Tax is undoubtedly in the nature of a compulsory exaction of money by a public authority for public purposes, the payment of which is imposed by law. Tax is a common burden and the only return which the taxpayer gets is the participation in the common benefits of the state. Fee, on the other hand, are payments primarily in the public interest but for some special services rendered or some special work done for the benefit of those from whom payments are demanded.
π Definition β Exaction: the act of demanding
Writ Jurisdiction of High Court
Provisions of Article 199 are not confined to cases where the person against whom the order is proposed to be passed has been performing judicial or quasi-judicial functions. Administrative or executive authorities also fall within the orbit of the jurisdiction conferred by this Article on the superior courts.
Article 199 is very wide in scope, and has been introduced to correct the actions of Government functionaries which suffer either from lack of jurisdiction or excess of jurisdiction. This article is an omnibus article under which relief can be granted to the citizens of the country against infringement of any provision of law or of the Constitution. If the citizens of this country are deprived of the guarantee given to them under the Constitution illegally, or not in accordance with law, then Article 199 can always be invoked for redress.
The High Court, on application of an aggrieved party, has power to make an order directing a person performing, within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court, functions in connection with affairs of the Federation, Province or a local authority, to refrain from doing anything against the fundamental rights conferred by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
β Key Takeaways
Article 18 guarantees every citizen the right to engage in any lawful profession, trade, or business, but this right is subject to state-imposed qualifications and regulations through licensing systems, competition measures, and government monopolies. The word "lawful" is critically important because it enables the state to completely ban certain professions or trades by declaring them unlawful, making this a qualified rather than absolute right. The right to apply for a license is a valuable right that cannot be treated lightly, and excessive delegation of legislative power in licensing matters can be challenged in court. Article 21 protects individuals from being compelled to pay special taxes whose proceeds are used to propagate or maintain religions other than their own, though this prohibition applies only to taxes and not to fees. Finally, Article 199 provides broad writ jurisdiction to High Courts to correct illegal or unconstitutional actions by government functionaries, including executive authorities, serving as a crucial remedy for citizens whose fundamental rights have been violated.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the three exceptions (provisos) to the fundamental right of freedom of trade, business, or profession under Article 18 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973?
-
According to Justice Munir's interpretation, what is the significance of the word "lawful" in Article 18, and how does it affect the nature of this fundamental right?
-
In the case of East & West Steamship Co. vs. Pakistan, what did Justice Cornelius observe about the relationship between regulation and licensing systems?
-
What is the key difference between a "tax" and a "fee" as explained in the context of Article 21's safeguard against taxation for religious purposes?
-
Under Article 199, what categories of authorities fall within the writ jurisdiction of the High Court, and what is the purpose of this jurisdiction?
π Lecture 27 β Fundamental Right --- Freedom of Speech, Expression and Press
π Overview: This lecture examines Article 19 of the Pakistan Constitution, 1973, which guarantees the right to freedom of speech, expression, and press, subject to reasonable restrictions. It explains the scope, limitations, and importance of these freedoms, along with the constitutional provisions for contempt of court and the writ jurisdiction of High Courts.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Article 19 of the Pakistan Constitution with its key terms and definitions, limitations on freedom of expression including treason, sedition, defamation, blasphemy, and obscenity, the scope of freedom of speech and press as defined by Alexander Hamilton, the importance of these freedoms in democratic governance, reasonableness of restrictions including the landmark case of Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan vs. Government of West Pakistan, contempt of court under Article 204 of the Constitution and the Contempt of Court Act 1976, and the writ jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 199.
π Lecture Summary
Fundamental Right --- Freedom of Speech, Expression and Press
Article 19 of the Pakistan Constitution, 1973 provides that "every citizen shall have the right to freedom of speech and expression, and there shall be freedom of the press, subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of the glory of Islam or the integrity, security or defense of Pakistan or any part thereof, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality, or in relation to contempt of court, defamation, commission of or incitement to an offence."
π Definition β Subject to: having regard to π Definition β Reasonable: logical; sensible π Definition β Restrictions: limitations π Definition β Glory: grandeur π Definition β Integrity: honor π Definition β Any part thereof: any part of Pakistan π Definition β Contempt of court: the act of disrespecting the court π Definition β Defamation: the act of harming the reputation of other π Definition β Commission of an offence: act of doing an offence π Definition β Incitement to an offence: provocation to an offence π Definition β Offence: crime; violation of law
Thus the Article 19 provides that every citizen shall have the right to freedom of speech and expression, and there shall be freedom of the press, having regard to any logical limitations imposed by law in the interest of the grandeur of Islam or the honor, security or defense of Pakistan or any part of Pakistan, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality, or in relation to act of disrespecting the court, act of harming the reputation of other, act of doing or provocation to do a crime.
Limitation on the freedom of expression
Limitation on the freedom of expression includes treason, sedition, incitement to racial hatred, official secrets, contempt of court or Parliament and incitement to mutiny or disaffection among the armed forces and Police. The other limitations are defamation, civil and criminal seditious libel, blasphemy, obscenity and the application of the restrictions, imposed by these areas of law on newspaper, wireless, television and theaters.
π Definition β Treason: disloyalty π Definition β Sedition: trouble making π Definition β Incitement: provocation π Definition β Racial: ethnic π Definition β Hatred: hate π Definition β Contempt of court: act of disrespecting court π Definition β Contempt of parliament: act of disrespecting Parliament π Definition β Mutiny: revolt π Definition β Disaffection: hostility π Definition β Defamation: the act of harming the reputation of other π Definition β Libel: defamation by the medium of writing π Definition β Restrictions: limitations
Thus Limitation on the freedom of expression includes disloyalty, trouble making, provocation to ethnic hate, official secrets, act of disrespecting court or act of disrespecting Parliament and provocation to revolt or hostility among the armed forces and Police. The other limitations are the act of harming the reputation of other, civil and criminal trouble making written defamation, blasphemy, obscenity and the application of the limitations, imposed by these areas of law on newspaper, wireless, television and theaters.
Scope of Freedom of Speech & Press
Alexander Hamilton said: "The liberty of press is the right to publish with impunity, truth, with good motives, for justifiable ends though reflecting on government, magistracy, or individuals."
π Definition β Liberty: freedom; independence π Definition β Impunity: exemption from punishment π Definition β Motive: intention; object π Definition β Justifiable: reasonable; acceptable π Definition β Ends: purposes
Thus the freedom of press is the right to publish with exemption from punishment, truth, with good intentions for reasonable purposes though reflecting on government, magistracy, or individuals.
Freedom of speech and freedom of press are fundamental personal rights and liberties which are the corner stones of democratic institutions.
The liberty of the press is not confined to newspapers and periodicals but necessarily embraces pamphlets, leaflets and every sort of publication.
π Definition β Embrace: hold; grip
The right to speech is not limited to public addresses, pamphlets or words of an individual, but it also embraces every form and manner of dissemination of ideas that appear best fitted to bring such idea and views to the attention of the populace and to the attention of those most concerned with them.
π Definition β Dissemination: propagation π Definition β Populace: public; population
The privilege of free speech carries with it freedom of choice as to the mode of expression that may be employed; it includes of mechanical and manual instrumentalities of communication, such as press and banners as a natural and appropriate means of conveying information on matters of public concern, which may be protected under the Constitutional guarantee of free speech and press.
π Definition β Mechanical: motorized π Definition β Manual: physical π Definition β Instrumentalities: appliances; electrical devices
Importance of the freedom
The freedom of speech and expression means the right to express one's convictions and opinions freely by words of mouth, writing, printing, pictures or any other mode.
A democratic government attaches great importance to this freedom because without freedom of speech, the appeal to reason which is the basis of democracy cannot be made.
It is said that freedom of speech and of the press lays at the foundation of all democratic organizations, for without free political discussion on public education, so essential for the proper functioning of the process of popular government, is possible.
The Journal of the International Commission of Jurist states that it needs no emphasis that a free press, which is neither directed by the executive nor subjected to censorship, is a vital element in a free state; in particular, a free, regularly published, political press is essential in modern democracy.
The citizens called upon to make political decisions, must be comprehensively informed, know the opinions of others and be able to weigh them up against each other. The press keeps the dialogue alive, it provides the information, adopts its own point of view, and thus works as a directive giving force to the public debate. It stands as a permanent means of communication and control between the people and their elected representatives in Parliament and Government.
Reasonableness of Restrictions on freedom of speech and expression
The freedom of speech and expression, including the liberty of the press under Pakistan Constitution is subject to any reasonable restrictions that may be imposed by law in the interest of glory of Islam, the security of Pakistan, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality, or in relation to contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an offence.
Reasonable restrictions under these heads can be imposed only by a duly enacted law and not by executive action. An absolute test of reasonableness of restrictions cannot be laid down.
π Definition β Test: examination; check; analysis
π Example: In Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan vs. Government of West Pakistan P.L.D. 1965 Lah.642, the Lahore High Court held that freedom of speech and press is not absolute at all times and in all circumstances, and it does not means that one can talk or distribute where, when and how one chooses.
The state can impose reasonable restrictions on the freedom of speech in the interest of friendly relations with foreign state. It is a recognized principle of international law that State in their relation with other States are responsible for the acts committed by persons within their jurisdiction. In accordance with this principle the most modern systems of law have made provisions for the punishment of libel against the heads of foreign states.
π Definition β Libel: to defame someone in a permanent character
The English common Law punishes such libel on the ground that they imperil the peaceful relation of Her Majesty with foreign states.
π Definition β Imperil: put in danger
A law which makes it an offence to publish any libel tending to degrade or expose to hatred or contempt any foreign prince, ambassador or other foreign dignitaries will fall within this expression and will be held valid provided that the restrictions are not unreasonable.
The freedom of speech and expression does not extend to indecent or immoral publications and utterances. But as this concept of decency and morality differ historically and geographically, the court must decide the matter in the light of the existing and generally accepted notions of decency and morality in a given society.
Contempt of Court
Article 204 of the Pakistan Constitution 1973 and the Contempt of Court Act 1976 make provisions and confer jurisdiction on the Supreme Court and the High Courts to punish any person who---
(a) Abuses, interferes with or obstructs the process of the Court in any way or disobeys any order of the court; or
(b) Scandalized the court or otherwise does anything which tends to bring the court or a judge in relation to his office in to hatred, ridicule or contempt; or
(c) Does anything which tends to prejudice the determination of a matter pending before the court; or
π Definition β Prejudice: bigotry; unfairness
(d) Does any other thing which, by law constitutes contempt of court.
Writ Jurisdiction of High Court
Provisions of Article 199 are not confined to cases where the person against whom the order is proposed to be passed has been performing judicial or quasi judicial functions. Administrative or executive authorities also fall within the orbit of the jurisdiction conferred by this Article on the superior courts.
π Definition β Orbit: track; range; scope
Article 199 is very wide in scope, and has been introduced to correct the actions of Government functionaries which suffer either from lack of jurisdiction or excess of jurisdiction. This article is an omnibus article under which relief can be granted to the citizens of the country against infringement of any provision of law or of the constitution. If the citizens of this country are deprived of the guarantee given to them under the Constitution illegally, or not in accordance with law, then Article 199 can always be invoked for redress.
High Court on application of an aggrieved party has power to make an order directing person performing, within territorial jurisdiction of High Court functions in connection with affairs of Federation, Province or a local authority to refrain from doing anything against the fundamental rights conferred by the Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
π‘ Why this matters: Article 199 serves as a powerful constitutional remedy for citizens whose fundamental rights are infringed, allowing High Courts to correct unlawful actions by government functionaries at federal, provincial, and local levels.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that Article 19 of the Pakistan Constitution guarantees freedom of speech, expression, and press but subjects these rights to reasonable restrictions in the interest of Islam's glory, national security, foreign relations, public order, decency, morality, contempt of court, defamation, and incitement to offences. The scope of these freedoms extends beyond newspapers to include pamphlets, leaflets, and all forms of dissemination, while limitations include treason, sedition, racial hatred, official secrets, blasphemy, and obscenity. The landmark case of Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan established that these freedoms are not absolute in all circumstances. Contempt of court under Article 204 covers abuse of court process, scandalizing the court, and prejudicing pending matters. Finally, Article 199 provides the writ jurisdiction of High Courts as a remedy for citizens against infringement of their fundamental rights by government functionaries at any level.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the specific grounds on which reasonable restrictions can be imposed on freedom of speech under Article 19 of the Pakistan Constitution, 1973?
-
According to Alexander Hamilton's definition, what four elements constitute the liberty of the press?
-
What did the Lahore High Court hold in the case of Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan vs. Government of West Pakistan (P.L.D. 1965 Lah.642)?
-
Under Article 204 of the Constitution and the Contempt of Court Act 1976, what four categories of conduct constitute contempt of court?
-
What is the scope of Article 199 of the Pakistan Constitution, and how can citizens invoke it for redress?