📘 Lecture 37 — MARKET SEGMENTATION
📖 Overview: This lecture focuses on key marketing issues critical to strategy implementation, including market segmentation, the marketing mix, and product positioning. It explains how marketing decisions revolve around the controllable 4 P's (Product, Price, Place, Promotion) and why understanding customer expectations is paramount for successful product positioning.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the marketing mix and its four controllable categories: Product, Price, Place, and Promotion. It then delves into specific decision areas within each P, such as branding, pricing strategy, distribution channels, and promotional tactics. Finally, it covers the concept of product positioning, common positioning strategies, and a step-by-step process for effective product positioning in the market.
📝 Lecture Summary
Marketing Mix
Marketing decisions generally fall into the following four controllable categories: Product, Price, Place (distribution), and Promotion. The term "marketing mix" became popularized after Neil H. Borden published his 1964 article, The Concept of the Marketing Mix. E. Jerome McCarthy later grouped Borden's ingredients into the four categories known today as the 4 P's of marketing. These four P's are the parameters that the marketing manager can control, subject to the internal and external constraints of the marketing environment. The goal is to make decisions that center the four P's on the customers in the target market in order to create perceived value and generate a positive response.
💡 Why this matters: The marketing mix is the foundational framework for all marketing decisions; understanding it is essential for aligning a company's offerings with customer needs.
Product Decisions
The term "product" refers to tangible, physical products as well as services. Key product decisions to be made include: Brand name, functionality, styling, quality, safety, packaging, repairs and support, warranty, and accessories and services.
Price Decisions
Pricing decisions to be made include: Pricing strategy (skim, penetration, etc.), suggested retail price, volume discounts and wholesale pricing, cash and early payment discounts, seasonal pricing, bundling, price flexibility, and price discrimination.
Distribution (Place) Decisions
Distribution is about getting the products to the customer. Distribution decisions include: Distribution channels, market coverage (inclusive, selective, or exclusive distribution), specific channel members, inventory management, warehousing, distribution centers, order processing, transportation, and reverse logistics.
Promotion Decisions
In the context of the marketing mix, promotion represents the various aspects of marketing communication—the communication of information about the product with the goal of generating a positive customer response. Marketing communication decisions include: Promotional strategy (push, pull, etc.), advertising, personal selling & sales force, sales promotions, public relations & publicity, and marketing communications budget.
Product Positioning
Positioning is how a product appears in relation to other products in the market. After segmenting markets so that the firm can target particular customer groups, the next step is to find out what customers want and expect. A severe mistake is to assume the firm knows what customers want and expect. Countless research studies reveal large differences between how customers define service and rank the importance of different service activities and how producers view services. Many firms have become successful by filling the gap between what customers and producers see as good service. What the customer believes is good service is paramount, not what the producer believes service should be.
🔑 Definition — Product Positioning: How a product appears in relation to other products in the market.
Product positioning strategy
The ability to spot a positioning opportunity is a sure test of a person's marketing ability. Successful positioning strategies are usually rooted in a product's sustainable competitive advantage. The most common basis for constructing a product positioning strategy include: Positioning on specific product features, positioning on specific benefits, needs, or solutions, positioning on specific use categories, positioning on specific usage occasions, positioning on a reason to choose an offering over the competition, positioning against another product, positioning through product class dissociation, and positioning by cultural symbols.
The following steps are required in product positioning:
- Select key criteria that effectively differentiate products or services in the industry.
- Diagram a two-dimensional product-positioning map with specified criteria on each axis.
- Plot major competitors' products or services in the resultant four-quadrant matrix.
- Identify areas in the positioning map where the company's products or services could be most competitive in the given target market. Look for vacant areas (niches).
- Develop a marketing plan to position the company's products or services appropriately.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The core of marketing strategy implementation revolves around the controllable 4 P's of the marketing mix: Product, Price, Place, and Promotion, which must be centered on the target market. Product positioning is the critical next step after market segmentation, defining how a product appears relative to competitors. A crucial insight is that successful positioning requires understanding customer expectations, which often differ from producer assumptions, and filling that perception gap. Effective positioning strategies are rooted in a product's sustainable competitive advantage and follow a systematic five-step process involving criteria selection, mapping, competitor plotting, niche identification, and plan development.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four controllable categories of the marketing mix, and who grouped them into this classification?
- List three specific decisions that must be made under each of the four P's: Product, Price, Place, and Promotion.
- According to the lecture, what is the definition of product positioning?
- Why is it a severe mistake for a firm to assume it knows what customers want and expect regarding service?
- Describe the first three steps required in the product positioning process.
📘 Lecture 38 — FINANCE/ACCOUNTING ISSUES
📖 Overview: This lecture addresses critical finance and accounting issues that arise during strategy implementation. It explains how organizations acquire capital, develop pro forma financial statements, prepare financial budgets, and evaluate the worth of a business—all essential for turning strategic plans into actionable financial decisions that drive organizational success.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers acquiring capital to implement strategies, including debt and equity analysis and EPS/EBIT analysis for capital structure decisions. It then explains pro forma financial statements and their uses in business planning, detailing the six steps for performing pro forma financial analysis. The lecture also addresses financial budgets, their types and limitations, and concludes with three main approaches for evaluating the worth of a business: net worth, earnings-based, and market-based methods.
📝 Lecture Summary
Acquiring Capital to Implement Strategies
Without sufficient capital, strategies cannot proceed. Two basic sources of capital for an organization are debt and equity. Creditors have a debt right and owners have an equity right in the business. An appropriate mix of debt and equity in a firm's capital structure plays an important role for strategy implementation. The most important is debt and equity analysis.
🔑 Definition — Debt to Equity Ratio (D/E): A financial ratio equal to an entity's total liabilities divided by shareholders' equity. It is used to calculate a company's "financial leverage" and indicates what proportion of equity and debt the company is using to finance its assets.
📐 Formula 1: D/E = Debt (total liabilities) / Equity 📐 Formula 2: Debt to Total Assets (D/A) = Debt / Assets = Debt / (Debt + Equity)
The EPS/EBIT analysis is the most widely used technique for determining whether debt, stock, or a combination of both is the best alternative for raising capital to implement strategies. This technique examines the impact that debt versus stock financing has on earnings per share under various assumptions as to EBIT.
🔑 Definition — EBIT (Earnings Before Interest and Taxes): A financial measure defined as revenues less cost of goods sold and selling, general, and administrative expenses. In other words, operating and non-operating profit before the deduction of interest and income taxes.
🔑 Definition — EPS (Earnings Per Share): A company's profit divided by its number of outstanding shares. If a company earning Rs. 2 million in one year had Rs. 2 million shares outstanding, its EPS would be Rs. 1 per share.
Theoretically, an enterprise should have enough debt in its capital structure to boost its return on investment by applying debt to projects earning more than the cost of the debt. In low earning periods, too much debt can endanger stockholders' return and jeopardize company survival. Fixed debt obligations generally must be met, regardless of circumstances. Some special concerns with stock issuances are dilution of ownership, effect on stock price, and the need to share future earnings with all new shareholders.
💡 Why this matters: EPS/EBIT analysis is a valuable tool for making capital financing decisions, but several considerations should be made: profit levels may be higher for stock or debt alternatives when EPS levels are lower, and flexibility is critical—using all debt or all stock may impose fixed obligations or restrictive covenants that reduce a firm's ability to raise additional capital in the future.
Pro Forma Financial Statements
Pro forma (projected) financial statement analysis is a central strategy-implementation technique because it allows an organization to examine the expected results of various actions and approaches.
🔑 Definition — Pro Forma Financial Statement: A financial statement showing the forecast or projected operating results and balance sheet, as in pro forma income statements, balance sheets, and statements of cash flows.
Uses of Pro Forma Statements:
- Business Planning — A company uses pro forma statements in business planning and control. Management employs them to compare and contrast alternative business plans by arranging data for operating and financial statements side-by-side.
- Identifying assumptions about financial and operating characteristics that generate scenarios
- Developing various sales and budget projections
- Assembling results in profit and loss projections
- Translating data into cash-flow projections
- Comparing resulting balance sheets
- Performing ratio analysis to compare projections against each other and against similar companies
- Reviewing proposed decisions in marketing, production, R&D, etc., and assessing their impact on profitability and liquidity
Pro forma income statement is similar to a historical income statement, except it projects the future rather than tracks the past. It provides an important benchmark or budget for operating a business throughout the year.
Pro forma balance sheet is similar to a historical balance sheet, but it represents a future projection. It projects how the business will be managing its assets in the future and can quickly show projected relative amounts in receivables, inventory, and equipment, as well as overall financial soundness.
Six Steps in Performing Pro Forma Financial Analysis:
- Prepare income statement before balance sheet (forecast sales)
- Use percentage-of-sales method to project CGS and expenses
- Calculate projected net income
- Subtract dividends to be paid from Net Income and add remaining to Retained Earnings
- Project balance sheet items beginning with retained earnings
- List comments (remarks) on projected statements
Example — Pro Forma Analysis (partial):
| Item | Prior Year 2005 | Projected Year 2005 | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | 1000 | 1500 | 50% increase |
| Cost of Goods Sold | 700 | 1050 | 70% of sales |
| Gross Margin | 300 | 450 | |
| Net Income | 25 | 50 | |
| Dividends | 10 | 20 | |
| Retained Earnings | 15 | 30 |
Financial Budgets
🔑 Definition — Financial Budget: A document that details how funds will be obtained and spent for a specified period of time.
Types of Budgets:
- Cash budgets
- Operating budgets
- Sales budgets
- Profit budgets
- Factory budgets
- Capital budgets
- Expense budgets
- Divisional budgets
- Variable budgets
- Flexible budgets
- Fixed budgets
Annual budgets are most common, although the period can range from one day to more than ten years. Fundamentally, financial budgeting is a method for specifying what must be done to complete strategy implementation successfully. Financial budgets should not be thought of as a tool for limiting expenditures but rather as a method for obtaining the most productive and profitable use of an organization's resources.
Limitations of Financial Budgets:
- Budgetary programs can become so detailed that they are cumbersome and overly expensive
- Financial budgets can become a substitute for objectives—a budget is a tool, not an end in itself
- Budgets can hide inefficiencies if based solely on precedent rather than periodic evaluation
- Budgets are sometimes used as instruments of tyranny resulting in frustration, resentment, absenteeism, and high turnover
To minimize the effect of the last concern, managers should increase the participation of subordinates in preparing budgets.
Evaluating the Worth of a Business
Evaluating the worth of a business is central to strategy implementation because integrative, intensive, and diversification strategies are often implemented by acquiring other firms. Other strategies, such as retrenchment and divestiture, may result in the sale of a division or the firm itself.
All methods for determining a business's worth can be grouped into three main approaches:
1. What a firm owns — Determining its net worth or stockholders' equity. Net worth represents the sum of common stock, additional paid-in capital, and retained earnings.
2. What a firm earns — The worth of any business should be based largely on the future benefits its owners may derive through net profits.
3. What a firm will bring in the market — Involves three methods:
- Method 1: Base the firm's worth on the selling price of a similar company
- Method 2: Price-earnings ratio method — Divide the market price of the firm's common stock by the annual EPS and multiply by the firm's average net income for the past five years
- Method 3: Outstanding shares method — Multiply the number of shares outstanding by the market price per share and add a premium (a per share dollar amount a person or firm is willing to pay to control the other company)
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that the debt-to-equity ratio and EPS/EBIT analysis are fundamental for determining the optimal capital structure when raising funds for strategy implementation, and that debt financing offers tax advantages but carries fixed obligations while stock financing dilutes ownership. The six-step pro forma financial analysis process—starting with sales forecasting and ending with remarks—is essential for projecting the financial impact of strategic decisions, and these projections are required by nearly all financial institutions when seeking capital. Financial budgets serve as planned resource allocation tools, not expenditure limiters, and their four key limitations (detail overload, substitution for objectives, hiding inefficiencies, and potential tyranny) can be mitigated through subordinate participation. When evaluating business worth, the three approaches—net worth, earnings-based, and market-based—each serve different strategic contexts, with the price-earnings ratio and outstanding shares methods being particularly relevant for acquisition and divestiture decisions.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the debt-to-equity ratio formula, and what does it measure about a company's capital structure?
- What are the six steps in performing pro forma financial analysis, and why is step 1 (forecasting sales) the most critical?
- What four limitations of financial budgets should managers be aware of, and how can the negative effects of the last limitation be minimized?
- When evaluating the worth of a business using the market approach, what are the three specific methods, and how is the price-earnings ratio method calculated?
- In EPS/EBIT analysis, what are two special concerns associated with issuing stock versus debt for raising capital, and why might a company choose debt even though it carries fixed obligations?
📘 Lecture 39 — Research and Development Issues
📖 Overview: This lecture examines critical Research and Development (R&D) issues in strategy implementation, focusing on how firms manage innovation, new product development, and technology transfer. It covers the decision to go public, R&D approaches for implementing strategies, and guidelines for whether to develop R&D internally or acquire it externally, making it essential for understanding how firms align R&D with strategic objectives.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture addresses going public as a capital-raising strategy with its advantages, costs, and requirements for firms. It then explores Research and Development (R&D) management in strategy implementation, including R&D activities for different types of organizations, guidelines for internal versus external R&D development, three major R&D approaches for implementing strategies, and the trend toward collaborative R&D among competitors.
📝 Lecture Summary
Research and Development (R&D) Issues
Going public means selling off a specific percentage of the business to others in order to raise capital; consequently, it shifts the owners' control of the firm. Going public is not recommended for companies where initial costs can be too high for the firm to generate sufficient cash inflows to make going public worthwhile. The firm must have sufficient capital to bear lawyer, underwriter, and other documentation costs to form the business. In addition to initial costs involved with a stock offering, there are costs and obligations associated with reporting and management in a publicly held firm.
For firms with more than $10 million in sales, going public can provide major advantages:
- It can allow the firm to raise capital to develop new products
- To build plants
- Expand, grow, and market products and services more effectively
Before going public, a firm must have quality management with a proven track record for achieving quality earnings and positive cash flow. The company also should enjoy growing demand for its products. Sales growth of about 5 or 6 percent a year is good for a private firm, but shareholders expect public companies to grow around 10 to 15 percent per year.
Research and Development (R&D) Issues
Research and development (R&D) management plays a part in strategy implementation. R&D is defined as "New products and improvement of existing products that allow for effective strategy implementation." These individuals are generally charged with developing new products and improving old products in a way that will allow effective strategy implementation.
R&D employees and managers perform tasks that include:
- Transferring complex technology
- Adjusting processes to local raw materials
- Adapting processes to local markets
- Altering products to particular tastes and specifications
Strategies such as product development, market penetration, and concentric diversification require that new products be successfully developed and that old products be significantly improved. But the level of management support for R&D is often constrained by resource availability.
Technological improvements that both affect consumer and industrial products and services shorten product life cycles. Companies in virtually every industry are relying on the development of new products and services to fuel profitability and growth.
Surveys suggest that the most successful organizations use an R&D strategy that ties external opportunities to internal strength and is linked with objectives. Well-formulated R&D policies match market opportunities with internal capabilities and provide an initial screen to all ideas generated.
R&D policies can enhance strategy-implementation efforts to:
- Develop robotics or manual-type processes
- Spend a high, average, or low amount of money on R&D
- Perform R&D within the firm or contract R&D to outside firms
- Use university researchers or private sector researchers
- Emphasize product or process improvements
- Stress basic or applied research
- Be leaders or followers in R&D
There must be effective interactions between R&D departments and other functional departments in implementing different types of generic business strategies. Conflicts between marketing, finance/accounting, R&D, and information systems departments can be minimized with clear policies and objectives.
The following table gives examples of R&D activities required for successful implementation of various strategies:
Research and Development Involvement in Selected Strategy-Implementation Situations
| TYPE OF ORGANIZATION | STRATEGY BEING IMPLEMENTED | R&D ACTIVITY |
|---|---|---|
| Cosmetic Manufacturer | Concentric diversification | Add face wash for the user in addition to other make-up items |
| Plastic container manufacturer | Market penetration | Develop a biodegradable container |
| Electronics company | Market development | Develop a telecommunications system in a foreign country |
| Pharmaceutical company | Product development | Develop a procedure for testing the effects of a new drug on different subgroups |
Many American utility, energy, and automotive companies are employing their research and development departments to determine how the firm can effectively reduce its greenhouse gas emissions.
Guidelines for Acquiring R&D Expertise
Many firms wrestle with the decision to acquire R&D expertise from external firms or to develop R&D expertise internally. The following guidelines can be used to help make this decision:
-
If the rate of technical progress is slow, the rate of market growth is moderate, and there are significant barriers to possible new entrants, then in-house R&D is the preferred solution. The reason is that R&D, if successful, will result in a temporary product or process monopoly that the company can exploit.
-
If technology is changing rapidly and the market is growing slowly, then a major effort in R&D may be very risky, because it may lead to development of an ultimately obsolete technology or one for which there is no market.
-
If technology is changing slowly but the market is growing fast, there generally is not enough time for in-house development. The prescribed approach is to obtain R&D expertise on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis from an outside firm.
-
If both technical progress and market growth are fast, R&D expertise should be obtained through acquisition of a well-established firm in the industry.
💡 Why this matters: These guidelines help managers make critical resource allocation decisions by matching R&D strategy to market conditions and technological change rates.
Three Major R&D Approaches for Implementing Strategies
There are at least three major R&D approaches for implementing strategies:
-
First firm to market new technological products — This is a glamorous and exciting strategy but also a dangerous one.
-
Be an innovative imitator of successful products — This minimizes the risks and costs of start-up. This approach entails allowing a pioneer firm to develop the first version of the new product and to demonstrate that a market exists. Then, laggard firms develop a similar product. This strategy requires excellent R&D personnel and an excellent marketing department.
-
Low-cost producer of similar but less expensive products — This involves mass-producing products similar to but less expensive than products recently introduced.
Perhaps the most current trend in R&D management has been lifting the veil of secrecy whereby firms, even major competitors, are joining forces to develop new products. Collaboration is on the rise due to new competitive pressures, rising research costs, increasing regulatory issues, and accelerated product development schedules.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember the definition and role of R&D in strategy implementation, including the four tasks performed by R&D employees and managers. The decision guidelines for in-house versus external R&D based on technological progress rate, market growth rate, and barriers to entry are critical for exam questions. The three major R&D approaches (first to market, innovative imitator, low-cost producer) and their respective risk profiles must be understood. Additionally, the relationship between generic strategies and specific R&D activities as shown in the table, and the trend toward collaborative R&D among competitors due to rising costs and regulatory pressures, are essential concepts.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the four guidelines for deciding whether to develop R&D internally or acquire it from external firms?
-
What are the three major R&D approaches for implementing strategies, and what are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
-
For what type of organization and strategy would developing a biodegradable container be an appropriate R&D activity?
-
What requirements must a firm meet before going public, and what sales growth percentages do shareholders expect compared to private firms?
-
What is the current trend in R&D management regarding collaboration, and what factors are driving this trend?
📘 Lecture 40 — Strategy Review, Evaluation and Control
📖 Overview: This lecture covers the final step of the strategic management framework: strategy evaluation and control. It defines evaluation, explains Michael Porter’s Five Forces model for industry analysis, and details the purpose, activities, and criteria for evaluating strategies. Understanding this topic is vital because without proper evaluation, even the best strategies can fail due to changing internal and external conditions.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a general definition of evaluation and its distinction from assessment. It then introduces strategy evaluation as a complex and sensitive undertaking, highlighting why systematic review is necessary. A major section is dedicated to Michael Porter’s Five Forces model, explaining each force and its determinants. The lecture concludes with the purpose of strategy evaluation, its basic activities, Richard Rummelt’s four evaluation criteria (Consistency, Consonance, Feasibility, Advantage), and a structured Strategy-Evaluation Framework.
📝 Lecture Summary
Evaluation
Evaluation is the systematic determination of merit, worth, and significance of something or someone. It is used across many fields, including business, education, and government. There is debate over whether ‘evaluation’ and ‘assessment’ are the same. When distinguished, assessment involves objective descriptions (characterizations), while evaluation involves judgments of merit and/or worth. Merit is about generalized value, and worth is about instrumental value. For example, two teachers may have equal merit in their fields, but one may have greater worth due to higher market demand. The lecture lists many common evaluation methods, including Benchmarking, Cost-benefit analysis, Delphi Technique, Environmental scanning, Focus group, and Six Sigma.
🔑 Definition — Evaluation: The systematic determination of merit, worth, and significance of something or someone.
🔑 Definition — Assessment: (when distinguished from evaluation) Objective descriptions and characterizations of something, without judgments of value.
🔑 Definition — Merit: Judgments about generalized value (e.g., mastery of a discipline).
🔑 Definition — Worth: Judgments about instrumental value, often influenced by supply and demand (e.g., higher demand for math teachers).
Strategy Evaluation
Strategy evaluation is a complex and sensitive undertaking that alerts management to potential or actual problems in a timely fashion. The lecture warns that organizations are most vulnerable when they are at their peak of success. An overemphasis on evaluation can be costly and counterproductive. Systematic review, evaluation, and control are needed because: (1) strategies become obsolete, (2) internal environments are dynamic, and (3) external environments are dynamic.
Michael Porter's Five Forces
Michael Porter’s 1979 framework uses concepts from Industrial Organization (IO) economics to derive five forces that determine the attractiveness of a market. These forces are part of the microenvironment, contrasting with the general macro environment. A change in any force requires a company to re-assess the marketplace. The five forces are: the bargaining power of customers, the bargaining power of suppliers, the threat of new entrants, the threat of substitute products, and the intensity of competitive rivalry.
🔑 Definition — Microenvironment: Forces close to a company that affect its ability to serve customers and make a profit (Porter’s Five Forces).
The bargaining power of customers: Determined by buyer concentration, bargaining leverage, buyer volume, switching costs, information availability, ability to backward integrate, availability of substitutes, price sensitivity, and the price of the total purchase.
The bargaining power of suppliers: Determined by supplier switching costs, degree of differentiation of inputs, presence of substitute inputs, supplier concentration, threat of forward integration by suppliers, cost of inputs relative to selling price, and importance of volume to the supplier.
The threat of new entrants: Determined by barriers to entry, including economies of product differences, brand equity, switching costs, capital requirements, access to distribution, absolute cost advantages, learning curve advantages, expected retaliation, and government policies.
The threat of substitute products: Determined by buyer propensity to substitute, relative price performance of substitutes, buyer switching costs, and perceived level of product differentiation.
The intensity of competitive rivalry: This is influenced by the power of buyers, power of suppliers, threat of new entrants, threat of substitute products, number of competitors, rate of industry growth, intermittent industry overcapacity, exit barriers, diversity of competitors, informational complexity, brand equity, and fixed cost allocation.
Some argue for a sixth force: the Relative Power of Other Stakeholders, including governments, local communities, creditors, and shareholders. The Five Forces analysis is part of a larger set of Porter models that also include the value chain and generic strategies.
💡 Why this matters: Porter’s Five Forces is a foundational tool for analyzing an industry’s structure and profitability. A firm must understand these forces to build a sustainable competitive advantage.
Purpose of Strategy Evaluation
The purpose of strategy evaluation is to ensure the organization’s well-being by alerting management to potential or actual problems in a timely fashion. Erroneous strategic decisions can have severe negative impacts on organizations.
Basic Activities
- Examining the underlying bases of a firm’s strategy.
- Comparing expected to actual results.
- Taking corrective actions to ensure performance conforms to plans.
In many organizations, evaluation is an appraisal of performance, asking questions like: Have assets increased? Has profitability increased? Have sales increased? Have profit margins, ROI, and EPS ratios increased?
Four Criteria (Richard Rummelt)
Richard Rummelt proposed four criteria for evaluating a strategy: Consistency, Consonance, Feasibility, and Advantage.
Consistency: The strategy should not present inconsistent goals and policies. Conflict and interdepartmental bickering are symptomatic of managerial disorder and strategic inconsistency.
Consonance: Strategies need to examine sets of trends as an adaptive response to the external environment. Trends are the results of interactions among other trends.
Feasibility: The strategy should neither overtax resources nor create unsolvable sub-problems. The organization must demonstrate the abilities, competencies, skills, and talents to carry out the strategy.
Advantage: The strategy should create or maintain a competitive advantage through superiority in resources, skills, or position.
The Process of Evaluating Strategies
- Strategy evaluation is necessary for all sizes and kinds of organizations. It should initiate questioning of expectations and assumptions, trigger a review of objectives and values, and stimulate creativity.
- Evaluating strategies on a continuous rather than a periodic basis allows for benchmarking and more effective monitoring.
- Managers and employees should be continually aware of progress. As critical success factors change, organization members should be involved in determining appropriate corrective action.
A Strategy-Evaluation Framework
The Strategy-Evaluation Framework involves three key steps:
- Review Underlying Bases: Examine if the strategic foundation is still valid.
- Measure Firm Performance: Compare expected results with actual results.
- Take Corrective Actions: If there are significant differences, corrective actions are needed. Corrective actions are almost always needed, except when (1) external and internal factors have not significantly changed, and (2) the firm is progressing satisfactorily toward achieving stated objectives.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Strategy evaluation is a critical, ongoing process that alerts management to problems and ensures a firm’s strategy remains relevant in a dynamic environment. Porter’s Five Forces model is a key tool for analyzing the industry’s competitive landscape, focusing on the bargaining power of buyers and suppliers, the threat of new entrants and substitutes, and the intensity of rivalry. Successful evaluation requires examining a strategy’s underlying bases, measuring performance, and taking corrective action as needed. Richard Rummelt’s four criteria—Consistency, Consonance, Feasibility, and Advantage—provide a comprehensive checklist for judging a strategy’s quality and potential for success. Organizations are most vulnerable at their peak, making continuous monitoring and review essential for long-term survival.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Richard Rummelt, what does the criterion of "Consonance" require a strategy to do?
- List the five forces in Michael Porter’s Five Forces model.
- What are the three basic activities in the strategy evaluation process?
- Under what two conditions would corrective actions not be needed during strategy evaluation?
- When a distinction is made between the two terms, how does "evaluation" differ from "assessment"?
📘 Lecture 41 — PORTER SUPPLY CHAIN MODEL
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces Michael Porter's Value Chain framework, a model for analyzing specific organizational activities that create value and competitive advantage. It explains the distinction between primary and support activities, how firms can achieve cost advantages by managing value chain activities, and how these activities connect into broader supply chains and value networks. Understanding this model is critical for strategic analysis of a firm's internal operations.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Porter Supply Chain Model in detail, beginning with the Value Chain framework and its classification into primary activities (inbound logistics, operations, outbound logistics, marketing and sales, service) and support activities (procurement, technology development, human resource management, firm infrastructure). It then explains how firms create cost advantages by reducing costs of individual activities or reconfiguring the value chain, introduces Porter's 10 cost drivers, and concludes by discussing how a company's value chain connects with others in a broader supply chain or value network.
📝 Lecture Summary
Porter supply chain model
The Value Chain framework of Michael Porter is a model that helps to analyze specific activities through which firms can create value and competitive advantage.
The activities of the Value Chain
• Primary activities (line functions)
- Inbound Logistics: Includes receiving, storing, inventory control, transportation planning.
- Operations: Includes machining, packaging, assembly, equipment maintenance, testing and all other value-creating activities that transform the inputs into the final product.
- Outbound Logistics: The activities required to get the finished product at the customers: warehousing, order fulfillment, transportation, distribution management.
- Marketing and Sales: The activities associated with getting buyers to purchase the product, including: channel selection, advertising, promotion, selling, pricing, retail management, etc.
- Service: The activities that maintain and enhance the product's value, including: customer support, repair services, installation, training, spare parts management, upgrading, etc.
• Support activities (Staff functions, overhead)
- Procurement: Procurement of raw materials, servicing, spare parts, buildings, machines, etc.
- Technology Development: Includes technology development to support the value chain activities. Such as: Research and Development, Process automation, design, redesign.
- Human Resource Management: The activities associated with recruiting, development (education), retention and compensation of employees and managers.
- Firm Infrastructure: Includes general management, planning management, legal, finance, accounting, public affairs, quality management, etc.
💡 Why this matters: The value chain distinguishes between activities that directly create the product (primary) and those that support the overall process (support). Both categories are essential, and cost advantages can be found in either.
Creating a cost advantage based on the value chain
A firm may create a cost advantage: • By reducing the cost of individual value chain activities, or • By reconfiguring the value chain.
Note that a cost advantage can be created by reducing the costs of the primary activities, but also by reducing the costs of the support activities. Recently there have been many companies that achieved a cost advantage by the clever use of Information Technology.
Once the value chain has been defined, a cost analysis can be performed by assigning costs to the value chain activities. Porter identified 10 cost drivers related to value chain activities:
- Economies of scale.
- Learning.
- Capacity utilization.
- Linkages among activities.
- Interrelationships among business units.
- Degree of vertical integration.
- Timing of market entry.
- Firm's policy of cost or differentiation.
- Geographic location.
- Institutional factors (regulation, union activity, taxes, etc.).
A firm develops a cost advantage by controlling these drivers better than its competitors do. A cost advantage also can be pursued by "Reconfiguring" the value chain. "Reconfiguration" means structural changes such as: a new production process, new distribution channels, or a different sales approach.
💡 Why this matters: Cost advantage is not just about cutting expenses; it is about strategically managing the 10 cost drivers or fundamentally redesigning (reconfiguring) how the value chain operates.
Supply Chain Management and Value Networks
Normally, the Value Chain of a company is connected to other Value Chains and is part of a larger Value Chain. Developing a competitive advantage also depends on how efficiently you can analyze and manage the entire Value Chain. This idea is called: Supply Chain Management. Some people argue that network is actually a better word to describe the physical form of Value Chains: Value Networks.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The Porter Supply Chain Model is a fundamental strategic tool for analyzing how a firm creates value, divided into five primary activities (inbound logistics, operations, outbound logistics, marketing & sales, service) and four support activities (procurement, technology development, human resource management, firm infrastructure). Competitive advantage through cost can be achieved either by reducing costs of individual value chain activities or by reconfiguring the entire chain, guided by 10 specific cost drivers. A firm's value chain does not operate in isolation; it is linked to the value chains of suppliers, channels, and customers, forming a broader supply chain or value network that must be managed efficiently for sustained advantage.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five primary activities in Porter's Value Chain model, and what is the main purpose of each?
- Name the four support activities and explain how they differ from primary activities.
- What are the two fundamental ways a firm can create a cost advantage based on the value chain?
- List any five of the ten cost drivers identified by Porter that influence the cost of value chain activities.
- What is the relationship between a single firm's value chain and the concept of Supply Chain Management?
📘 Lecture 42 — Strategy Evaluation
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of strategy evaluation, a critical final stage in strategic management. It explains Richard Rummelt's four criteria for evaluating strategies and outlines the process and challenges involved in effectively assessing strategic performance.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers Richard Rummelt's four criteria for strategy evaluation: Consistency, Consonance, Feasibility, and Advantage. It also discusses the increasing difficulty of strategy evaluation in modern environments and outlines the continuous process of evaluating strategies to ensure organizational objectives are met.
📝 Lecture Summary
Four Criteria (Richard Rummelt)
Richard Rummelt explains four criteria for strategy valuation. These four criteria are Consistency, Consonance, Feasibility, and Advantage.
🔑 Definition — Consistency: Strategy should not present inconsistent goals and policies. Conflict and interdepartmental bickering are symptomatic of managerial disorder and strategic inconsistency.
🔑 Definition — Consonance: The need for strategies to examine sets of trends. This involves an adaptive response to the external environment, where trends are understood as results of interactions among other trends.
🔑 Definition — Feasibility: A strategy must neither overtax resources nor create unsolvable subproblems. Organizations must demonstrate the abilities, competencies, skills, and talents to carry out a given strategy.
🔑 Definition — Advantage: The creation or maintenance of competitive advantage through superiority in resources, skills, or position.
Difficulty in strategy evaluation
Several factors make strategy evaluation increasingly difficult:
- Increase in environment's complexity
- Difficulty predicting future with accuracy
- Increasing number of variables
- Rate of obsolescence of plans
- Domestic and global events
- Decreasing time span for planning certainty
💡 Why this matters: These six factors highlight why traditional, periodic strategy reviews are no longer sufficient. The accelerating pace of change requires a more dynamic and continuous approach to evaluation.
The process of evaluating Strategies
- Strategy evaluation is necessary for all sizes and kinds of organization. Strategy evaluation should initiate managerial questioning of expectations and assumptions, should trigger a review of objectives and values, and should stimulate creativity in generating alternatives and formulating criteria of evaluation.
- Evaluating strategies on a continuous rather than a periodic basis allows benchmarks of progress to be established and more effectively monitored.
- Managers and employees of the firm should be continually aware of progress being made towards achieving the firm's objectives. As critical success factors change, organization members should be involved in determining appropriate corrective action.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember Richard Rummelt's four criteria for strategy evaluation: Consistency (no conflicting goals), Consonance (adaptive response to environmental trends), Feasibility (not overtaxing resources), and Advantage (creating/maintaining competitive edge). Strategy evaluation is becoming increasingly difficult due to environmental complexity and the decreasing time span for planning certainty. Critically, evaluation should be a continuous, not periodic, process that involves questioning assumptions, reviewing objectives, and engaging all organization members as critical success factors change.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are Richard Rummelt's four criteria for evaluating strategies? Briefly explain each.
- Why is "Consonance" specifically concerned with the external environment and trend analysis?
- List three of the six factors that make strategy evaluation difficult in modern organizations.
- Why is continuous strategy evaluation more effective than periodic evaluation?
- What role should managers and employees play when critical success factors change?
📘 Lecture 43 — REVIEWING BASES OF STRATEGY
📖 Overview: This lecture focuses on the critical process of reviewing the underlying bases of an organization's strategy through revised EFE and IFE Matrices, measuring organizational performance against objectives, and taking corrective actions when necessary. It matters because continuous strategy evaluation enables firms to adapt to dynamic environments, maintain competitive positioning, and avoid future shock.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers reviewing bases of strategy through revised EFE and IFE Matrices with key diagnostic questions about competitors and internal/external factors, measuring organizational performance by comparing expected to actual results using both quantitative criteria (financial ratios) and qualitative criteria (Tilles' six questions), and taking corrective actions involving structural, personnel, or strategic changes to reposition the firm competitively while managing resistance to change.