π Lecture Summary
REVIEWING BASES OF STRATEGY
Reviewing the underlying bases of an organization's strategy can be approached by developing a revised EFE Matrix and IFE Matrix. A revised IFE Matrix should focus on changes in the organization's management, marketing, finance/accounting, production/operations, R&D, and computer information systems strengths and weaknesses. A revised EFE Matrix should indicate how effective a firm's strategies have been in response to key opportunities and threats. This analysis addresses questions about competitor reactions, strategy changes, competitor strengths/weaknesses, why competitors make changes, and how far competitors can be pushed before retaliating.
Numerous external and internal factors can prohibit firms from achieving long-term and annual objectives. Externally, actions by competitors, changes in demand, changes in technology, economic changes, demographic shifts, and governmental actions may prohibit objectives from being accomplished. Internally, ineffective strategies may have been chosen or implementation activities may have been poor. Objectives may have been too optimistic. Failure to achieve objectives may not result from unsatisfactory work by managers and employeesβall organizational members need to know this to encourage support for strategy-evaluation activities.
External opportunities and threats and internal strengths and weaknesses that represent the bases of current strategies should continually be monitored for change. Key questions include: Are our internal strengths still strengths? Have we added other internal strengths? Are our internal weaknesses still weaknesses? Are our external opportunities still opportunities? Are our external threats still threats? Are we vulnerable to a hostile takeover?
Measuring Organizational Performance
Another important strategy-evaluation activity is measuring organizational performance. This activity includes comparing expected results to actual results, investigating deviations from plans, evaluating individual performance, and examining progress being made toward meeting stated objectives. Both long-term and annual objectives are commonly used. Criteria for evaluating strategies should be measurable and easily verifiable. Criteria that predict results may be more important than those that reveal what already has happened. Really effective control requires accurate forecasting.
Failure to make satisfactory progress toward accomplishing long-term or annual objectives signals a need for corrective actions. Many factorsβunreasonable policies, unexpected turns in the economy, unreliable suppliers or distributors, or ineffective strategiesβcan result in unsatisfactory progress. Problems can result from ineffectiveness (not doing the right things) or inefficiency (doing the right things poorly).
Determining which objectives are most important in strategy evaluation can be difficult. Strategy evaluation is based on both quantitative and qualitative criteria. Selecting the exact set depends on a particular organization's size, industry, strategies, and management philosophy. Quantitative criteria commonly used are financial ratios, used to make three critical comparisons: (1) comparing the firm's performance over different time periods, (2) comparing the firm's performance to competitors', and (3) comparing the firm's performance to industry averages.
π Definition β Key Financial Ratios for Strategy Evaluation: Return on investment, Return on equity, Profit margin, Market share, Debt to equity, Earnings per share, Sales growth, Asset growth
π Example: Rather than simply being informed that sales last quarter were 20 percent under what was expected, strategists need to know that sales next quarter may be 20 percent below standard unless some action is taken to counter the trend.
Potential problems with quantitative criteria include: most quantitative criteria are geared to annual objectives rather than long-term objectives; different accounting methods can provide different results; intuitive judgments are almost always involved in deriving quantitative criteria. For these reasons, qualitative criteria are also important. Human factors such as high absenteeism and turnover rates, poor production quality and quantity rates, or low employee satisfaction can be underlying causes of declining performance.
Seymour Tilles identified six qualitative questions useful in evaluating strategies:
- Is the strategy internally consistent?
- Is the strategy consistent with the environment?
- Is the strategy appropriate in view of available resources?
- Does the strategy involve an acceptable degree of risk?
- Does the strategy have an appropriate time framework?
- Is the strategy workable?
Additional key qualitative questions include: How good is the firm's balance of investments between high-risk and low-risk projects, between long-term and short-term projects, between slow-growing and fast-growing markets, and among different divisions? To what extent are alternative strategies socially responsible? How are major competitors likely to respond to particular strategies?
Taking Corrective Actions
The final strategy-evaluation activity, taking corrective actions, requires making changes to reposition a firm competitively for the future. Examples include altering an organization's structure, replacing key individuals, selling a division, or revising a business mission. Other changes could include establishing or revising objectives, devising new policies, issuing stock to raise capital, adding salespersons, allocating resources differently, or developing new performance incentives. Taking corrective actions does not necessarily mean abandoning existing strategies or formulating new ones.
The probabilities and possibilities for incorrect or inappropriate actions increase geometrically with an arithmetic increase in personnel. Any person directing an overall undertaking must check on the actions of participants as well as the results achieved. If either the actions or results do not comply with planned achievements, corrective actions are needed.
No organization can survive as an island; no organization can escape change. Alvin Toffler coined the term future shock, which occurs when the nature, types, and speed of changes overpower an individual's or organization's ability to adapt. Strategy evaluation enhances an organization's ability to adapt successfully to changing circumstances. Brown and Agnew referred to this notion as corporate agility.
Taking corrective actions raises employees' and managers' anxieties. Research suggests that participation in strategy-evaluation activities is one of the best ways to overcome individuals' resistance to change. According to Erez and Kanfer, individuals accept change best when they have a cognitive understanding of the changes, a sense of control over the situation, and an awareness that necessary actions will be taken.
Strategy evaluation can lead to strategy-formulation changes, strategy-implementation changes, both, or no changes at all. Resistance to change is often emotionally based and not easily overcome by rational argumentβit may be based on loss of status, implied criticism of present competence, fear of failure, annoyance at not being consulted, lack of understanding, or insecurity. It is necessary to overcome such resistance by creating situations of participation and full explanation.
Corrective actions should place an organization in a better position to capitalize upon internal strengths, take advantage of key external opportunities, avoid/reduce/mitigate external threats, and improve internal weaknesses. They should have a proper time horizon and appropriate risk, be internally consistent and socially responsible, and most importantly, strengthen an organization's competitive position in its basic industry.
π‘ Why this matters: Continuous strategy evaluation keeps strategists close to the pulse of an organization and provides information needed for an effective strategic-management system.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: (1) Strategy evaluation requires continuously monitoring the bases of strategy through revised EFE and IFE Matrices, asking whether strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats have changed. (2) Measuring organizational performance involves comparing expected to actual results using both quantitative criteria (especially financial ratios compared across time, competitors, and industry averages) and qualitative criteria (including Tilles' six questions about consistency, environment, resources, risk, time, and workability). (3) Taking corrective actions is the final evaluation activity and may involve structural changes, personnel changes, resource reallocation, or mission revisionβbut does not necessarily mean abandoning current strategies. (4) Success in evaluation requires accurate forecasting, not just reporting past results, and overcoming resistance to change through participation and explanation. (5) The ultimate goal of corrective actions is to strengthen competitive position while managing the balance between high-risk/low-risk and long-term/short-term investments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three critical comparisons made using quantitative financial ratios in strategy evaluation?
- What are Seymour Tilles' six qualitative questions for evaluating strategies?
- What is "future shock" according to Alvin Toffler, and how does strategy evaluation help prevent it?
- What are the potential problems associated with using only quantitative criteria for strategy evaluation?
- According to Erez and Kanfer, what three conditions help individuals accept change best?
π Lecture 44 β MEASURING ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE
π Overview: This lecture addresses the challenge of determining which objectives are most important when evaluating strategies. It introduces both quantitative and qualitative criteria for strategy evaluation, explains key financial ratios used for comparison, and highlights potential problems with purely quantitative approaches. The lecture matters because effective strategy evaluation requires a balanced set of criteria tailored to an organization's specific context.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers measuring organizational performance, quantitative criteria commonly used to evaluate strategies including eight key financial ratios, potential problems associated with using quantitative criteria, qualitative criteria for evaluating strategies including Seymour Tilles' six questions, and additional key questions that reveal the need for qualitative or intuitive judgments in strategy evaluation.
π Lecture Summary
Measuring organizational performance
To determine which objectives are most important in the evaluation of strategies can be difficult. Strategy evaluation is based on both quantitative and qualitative criteria. Selecting the exact set of criteria for evaluating strategies depends on a particular organization's size, industry, strategies, and management philosophy. An organization pursuing a retrenchment strategy, for example, could have an entirely different set of evaluative criteria from an organization pursuing a market-development strategy.
Quantitative criteria commonly used to evaluate strategies are financial ratios, which strategists use to make three critical comparisons: (1) comparing the firm's performance over different time periods, (2) comparing the firm's performance to competitors', and (3) comparing the firm's performance to industry averages.
Some key financial ratios that are particularly useful as criteria for strategy evaluation are as follows:
- Return on investment
- Return on equity
- Profit margin
- Market share
- Debt to equity
- Earnings per share
- Sales growth
- Asset growth
π Definition β Strategy Evaluation: The process of determining which objectives are most important for assessing organizational performance, based on both quantitative and qualitative criteria.
But there are some potential problems associated with using quantitative criteria for evaluating strategies. First, most quantitative criteria are geared to annual objectives rather than long-term objectives. Also, different accounting methods can provide different results on many quantitative criteria. Third, intuitive judgments are almost always involved in deriving quantitative criteria.
For these and other reasons, qualitative criteria are also important in evaluating strategies. Human factors such as high absenteeism and turnover rates, poor production quality and quantity rates, or low employee satisfaction can be underlying causes of declining performance. Marketing, finance/accounting, R&D, or computer information systems factors can also cause financial problems.
Seymour Tilles identified six qualitative questions that are useful in evaluating strategies:
- Is the strategy internally consistent?
- Is the strategy consistent with the environment?
- Is the strategy appropriate in view of available resources?
- Does the strategy involve an acceptable degree of risk?
- Does the strategy have an appropriate time framework?
- Is the strategy workable?
Some additional key questions that reveal the need for qualitative or intuitive judgments in strategy evaluation are as follows:
- How good is the firm's balance of investments between high-risk and low-risk projects?
- How good is the firm's balance of investments between long-term and short-term projects?
- How good is the firm's balance of investments between slow-growing markets and fast-growing markets?
- How good is the firm's balance of investments among different divisions?
- To what extent are the firm's alternative strategies socially responsible?
- What are the relationships among the firm's key internal and external strategic factors?
- How are major competitors likely to respond to particular strategies?
π‘ Why this matters: The selection of evaluation criteria must align with the organization's specific strategy. Using only quantitative criteria can lead to short-term focus and ignore underlying human and operational factors that drive long-term performance.
β Key Takeaways
Strategy evaluation must balance both quantitative and qualitative criteria, with the selection depending on the organization's specific size, industry, strategies, and management philosophy. Financial ratios are the primary quantitative tool used for three key comparisons: over time, against competitors, and against industry averages. However, quantitative criteria have limitations including a focus on annual rather than long-term objectives, sensitivity to different accounting methods, and reliance on intuitive judgments. Qualitative factors such as human issues (absenteeism, turnover, satisfaction), operational quality, and Seymour Tilles' six questions about consistency, environment, resources, risk, timing, and workability are essential for comprehensive strategy evaluation. The specific set of questions used for evaluation must be tailored to the organization's strategic context.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three critical comparisons that strategists make when using financial ratios to evaluate strategies?
- List five of the eight key financial ratios mentioned as particularly useful for strategy evaluation.
- What are three potential problems associated with using quantitative criteria for evaluating strategies?
- What six qualitative questions did Seymour Tilles identify as useful for evaluating strategies?
- Why might a pursuing retrenchment strategy require different evaluative criteria than a pursuing market-development strategy?
π Lecture 45 β Characteristics of an Effective Evaluation System
π Overview: This lecture examines the essential qualities of an effective strategy evaluation system, including the need for economy, meaning, timeliness, and action-orientation. It then explores how contingency planning, auditing, and computer systems support robust strategy evaluation. The lecture concludes by emphasizing that strategy evaluation is a continuous, people-centered process that integrates intuition and analysis to help an organization shape its own future.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by outlining the key qualities of a good evaluation system, such as being economical, meaningful, timely, and providing a true picture. It then details the process and importance of contingency planning, followed by a discussion of auditing (including environmental audits) and the use of computers to evaluate strategies. The lecture concludes with a section on the nature of strategy evaluation and its critical role in the strategic-management process.
π Lecture Summary
Qualities of good evaluation system
A good strategy-evaluation system must be economical, as too much information or too many controls can be as harmful as too little. The activities must be meaningful, relating specifically to a firm's objectives and providing managers with useful information about tasks they control. Information must be timely; approximate, timely information is often more desirable for evaluation than accurate but outdated information. The system should provide a true picture of what is happening, for example, fairly portraying a situation where productivity drops due to a severe economic downturn despite harder work. The information derived should facilitate action and be directed to the individuals who need to act on it; controls need to be action-oriented rather than merely information-oriented. The evaluation process should not dominate decisions but foster mutual understanding, trust, and common sense. It should be simple, not too cumbersome or restrictive.
Large organizations require a more elaborate system due to the difficulty of coordinating efforts across divisions, while small managers often need less extensive reporting. The key to an effective system may be convincing participants that failing to accomplish objectives within a prescribed time is not necessarily a reflection of their performance. There is no single ideal system; the unique characteristics of an organization determine its final design. Robert Waterman noted that successful companies treat facts as friends and controls as liberating, maintaining tight, accurate financial controls that allow for creativity.
π Definition β Economical: Strategy-evaluation activities must be cost-effective; too much information is as bad as too little. π Definition β Meaningful: Strategy-evaluation activities should specifically relate to a firmβs objectives and provide managers with useful information about tasks they control. π Definition β Timely: Evaluative information must be provided when it is still useful; approximate, current information is generally more desirable than accurate, outdated information. π Definition β Action-oriented: Controls should be designed to facilitate action and be directed to those who need to take action, rather than being merely informational. π‘ Why this matters: An effective evaluation system must balance multiple, sometimes competing, qualitiesβlike economy vs. detail or timeliness vs. accuracyβto support sound strategic decisions without causing frustration or paralysis.
Contingency Planning
A basic premise of good strategic management is that firms plan for both unfavorable and favorable events before they occur. Contingency plans are alternative plans that can be implemented if certain key events do not occur as expected. They should be developed for high-priority areas and be as simple as possible. Common contingency plans address scenarios like a major competitor withdrawing, sales objectives not being met, higher-than-expected demand for a new product, certain disasters, or a new technology making a product obsolete.
Alternative strategies not selected for implementation can serve as valuable contingency plans. When a major change is needed quickly, an appropriate contingency plan can be executed in a timely way. Effective contingency planning involves a seven-step process: (1) Identify both beneficial and unfavorable events, (2) Specify trigger points, (3) Assess the impact of each contingent event, (4) Develop contingency plans, (5) Assess the counter impact of each plan, (6) Determine early warning signals for key contingent events, and (7) For events with reliable early warning signals, develop advance action plans.
π Definition β Contingency plans: Alternative plans that can be put into effect if certain key events do not occur as expected. π Seven-Step Contingency Planning Process:
- Identify beneficial and unfavorable events.
- Specify trigger points.
- Assess the impact of each contingent event.
- Develop contingency plans.
- Assess the counter impact of each contingency plan.
- Determine early warning signals for key contingent events.
- For events with reliable early warning signals, develop advance action plans.
Auditing
A frequently used tool in strategy evaluation is the audit, defined by the American Accounting Association (AAA) as "a systematic process of objectively obtaining and evaluating evidence regarding assertions about economic actions and events..." Auditors are divided into three groups: independent auditors (CPAs who examine financial statements for GAAP compliance), government auditors (from the GAO or IRS who ensure compliance with federal laws), and internal auditors (employees who safeguard company assets, assess operational efficiency, and ensure business procedures are practiced). To evaluate the effectiveness of a strategic-management system, internal auditors often seek answers to specific questions.
π Definition β Audit: A systematic process of objectively obtaining and evaluating evidence to ascertain the degree of correspondence between assertions and established criteria, and communicating the results to interested users.
The Environmental Audit
Overseeing environmental affairs has become an important strategic-management concern. Product design, manufacturing, packaging, and corporate rewards should reflect environmental considerations. Instituting an environmental audit can involve moving environmental affairs to the line side of the organization and introducing environmental criteria into performance appraisals and compensation plans.
Using Computers to Evaluate Strategies
A well-designed computer network can acquire information promptly and accurately, allowing diverse reports to be generated for different levels of managers. For example, strategists may want reports on mission/objective achievement, while lower-level managers need reports on operational concerns like absenteeism. Software like Ciscoβs Virtual Close allows strategists to close financial books on a daily or hourly basis. In a competitive environment, the side with the best intelligence usually wins, and computers enable the rapid evaluation of vast amounts of information.
A limitation of such systems is that personal values, morals, and emotions are not programmable. Computers should be viewed as tools to enhance and extend judgment, not as decision-making devices. They provide a framework for bringing together science and judgment, allowing managers to explore "What if?" alternatives.
The Nature of Strategy Evaluation
Strategy evaluation is vital because erroneous strategic decisions can have severe, long-lasting consequences. Timely evaluations can alert management to problems before they become critical. Strategy evaluation includes three basic activities: (1) examining the underlying bases of a firmβs strategy, (2) comparing expected results with actual results, and (3) taking corrective actions. Adequate and timely feedback is the cornerstone of effective strategy evaluation.
Strategy evaluation can be complex and sensitive. Too much emphasis can be expensive and counterproductive, as people do not like to be evaluated too closely. Yet, too little or no evaluation can create worse problems. Strategy evaluation must have both a long-run and short-run focus, as strategies often do not affect short-term operating results until it is too late to make changes.
π Definition β Three basic activities of strategy evaluation: (1) examining the underlying bases of a firmβs strategy, (2) comparing expected results with actual results, and (3) taking corrective actions.
Conclusion
Effective strategy evaluation allows an organization to capitalize on internal strengths, exploit external opportunities, defend against threats, and mitigate internal weaknesses. Good strategists move their organization forward by continually evaluating and improving its strategic position. Strategic management allows organizations to make effective long-term decisions and take corrective actions as needed. A key to success is an integration of intuition and analysis. A potentially fatal problem is the tendency for analytical and intuitive issues to polarize. The real key to effective strategic management is to accept that the planning process is more important than the written plan, as the manager must continuously plan, measure, and revise to keep the plan from becoming obsolete.
β Key Takeaways
An effective strategy evaluation system must be economical, meaningful, timely, provide a true picture, and be action-oriented rather than merely informational. Organizations should develop contingency plans for high-priority events to minimize threats and capitalize on opportunities, using a structured seven-step process. Auditing, including environmental auditing, is a key evaluation tool performed by independent, government, and internal auditors. While computers are invaluable for acquiring and evaluating vast amounts of information, they are tools that must be integrated with human intuition and judgment. Finally, the most critical takeaway is that strategy evaluation is a continuous, people-centered process where the ongoing planning is more important than the final written plan.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven key qualities of an effective strategy evaluation system?
- What is a contingency plan, and what are the seven steps of the effective contingency planning process?
- What are the three groups of auditors, and what is the primary responsibility of each group?
- What is the primary limitation of using computer-based systems to evaluate strategy?
- What are the three basic activities that constitute strategy evaluation?