π Lecture 34 β Restructuring
π Overview: This lecture explores corporate restructuring and reengineering as strategic tools for improving organizational efficiency and profitability. It covers the characteristics, benefits, and drawbacks of both approaches, alongside strategies for linking pay to performance, managing resistance to change, addressing natural environment concerns, and creating a strategy-supportive culture.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers restructuring including its characteristics and results, reengineering and its criticisms, linking performance and pay to strategies through various compensation methods, managing resistance to change with different change strategies, managing the natural environment in business operations, and creating a strategy-supportive culture by aligning organizational culture with new strategies.
π Lecture Summary
Restructuring
Restructuring is the corporate management term for the act of partially dismantling and reorganizing a company for the purpose of making it more efficient and therefore more profitable. It generally involves selling off portions of the company and making severe staff reductions. Restructuring is often done as part of a bankruptcy or of a takeover by another firm, particularly a leveraged buyout by a private equity firm such as KKR. It may also be done by a new CEO hired specifically to make the difficult and controversial decisions required to save or reposition the company.
The selling of portions of the company, such as a division that is no longer profitable or which has distracted management from its core business, can greatly improve the company's balance sheet. Staff reductions are often accomplished partly through the selling or closing of unprofitable portions of the company and partly by consolidating or outsourcing parts of the company that perform redundant functions (such as payroll, human resources, and training) left over from old acquisitions that were never fully integrated into the parent organization.
Other characteristics of restructuring can include:
- Changes in corporate management (usually with golden parachutes)
- Sale of underutilized assets, such as patents or brands
- Outsourcing of operations such as payroll and technical support to a more efficient third party
- Moving of operations such as manufacturing to lower-cost locations
- Reorganization of functions such as sales, marketing, and distribution
- Renegotiation of labor contracts to reduce overhead
- Refinancing of corporate debt to reduce interest payments
- A major public relations campaign to reposition the company with consumers
A company that has been restructured effectively will generally be leaner, more efficient, better organized, and better focused on its core business. If the restructured company was a leverage acquisition, the parent company will likely resell it at a profit when the restructuring has proven successful.
Firms often employ restructuring when various ratios appear out of line with competitors as determined through benchmarking exercises. Benchmarking simply involves comparing a firm against the best firms in the industry on a wide variety of performance-related criteria. Some benchmarking ratios commonly used in rationalizing the need for restructuring are headcount-to-sales-volume, or corporate-staff-to-operating-employees, or span-of-control figures.
The primary benefit sought from restructuring is cost reduction. For some highly bureaucratic firms, restructuring can actually rescue the firm from global competition and demise. But the downside of restructuring can be reduced employee commitment, creativity, and innovation that accompany the uncertainty and trauma associated with pending and actual employee layoffs.
Another downside of restructuring is that many people today do not aspire to become managers, and many present-day managers are trying to get off the management track. Sentiment against joining management ranks is higher today than ever. About 80 percent of employees say they want nothing to do with management, a major shift from just a decade ago when 60 to 70 percent hoped to become managers. Managing others historically led to enhanced career mobility, financial rewards, and executive perks; but in today's global, more competitive, restructured arena, managerial jobs demand more hours and headaches with fewer financial rewards. Managers today manage more people spread over different locations, travel more, manage diverse functions, and are change agents even when they have nothing to do with the creation of the plan or even disagree with its approach. Employers today are looking for people who can do things, not for people who make other people do things. Restructuring in many firms has made a manager's job an invisible, thankless role. More workers today are self-managed, entrepreneurs, or team managed. Managers today need to be counselors, motivators, financial advisors, and psychologists. They also run the risk of becoming technologically behind in their areas of expertise. "Dilbert" cartoons commonly portray managers as enemies or as morons.
π Definition β Restructuring: The act of partially dismantling and reorganizing a company for the purpose of making it more efficient and therefore more profitable. π Example: A company in bankruptcy sells off an unprofitable division, reduces staff through layoffs, and renegotiates labor contracts to reduce overhead and become profitable again.
Reengineering
Reengineering (or re-engineering) is the radical redesign of an organization's processes, especially its business processes. Rather than organizing a firm into functional specialties (like production, accounting, marketing, etc.) and looking at the tasks that each function performs, we should, according to the reengineering theory, be looking at complete processes from materials acquisition, to production, to marketing and distribution. The firm should be re-engineered into a series of processes.
The main proponents of re-engineering were Michael Hammer and James Champy. In a series of books including Reengineering the Corporation, Reengineering Management, and The Agenda, they argue that far too much time is wasted passing-on tasks from one department to another. They claim that it is far more efficient to appoint a team who are responsible for all the tasks in the process. In The Agenda they extend the argument to include suppliers, distributors, and other business partners.
Re-engineering is the basis for many recent developments in management. The cross-functional team, for example, has become popular because of the desire to re-engineer separate functional tasks into complete cross-functional processes. Also, many recent management information systems developments aim to integrate a wide number of business functions. Enterprise resource planning, supply chain management, knowledge management systems, groupware and collaborative systems, Human Resource Management Systems and customer relationship management systems all owe a debt to re-engineering theory.
Reengineering has earned a bad reputation because such projects have often resulted in massive layoffs. This reputation is not all together warranted. Companies have often downsized under the banner of reengineering.
Further, reengineering has not always lived up to its expectations. The main reasons seem to be that:
- Reengineering assumes that the factor that limits organization's performance is the ineffectiveness of its processes (which may or may not be true) and offers no means of validating that assumption
- Reengineering assumes the need to start the process of performance improvement with a "clean slate", i.e. totally disregard the status quo
- According to Eliyahu M. Goldratt (and his theory of constraints) reengineering does not provide an effective way to focus improvement efforts on the organization's constraint.
There was considerable hype surrounding the book's introduction. Abrahamson (1996) showed that fashionable management terms tend to follow a lifecycle, which for Reengineering peaked between 1993 and 1996. While arguing that Reengineering was in fact nothing new (as e.g. when Henry Ford implemented the assembly line in 1908, he was in fact reengineering, radically changing the way of thinking in an organization), Dubois (2002) highlights the value of signaling terms as Reengineering, giving it a name, and stimulating it. At the same there can be a danger in usage of such fashionable concepts as mere ammunition to implement particular reforms.
The argument for a firm engaging in reengineering usually goes as follows: Many companies historically have been organized vertically by business function. This arrangement has led over time to managers' and employees' mind-sets being defined by their particular functions rather than by overall customer service, product quality, or corporate performance. The logic is that all firms tend to bureaucratize over time. As routines become entrenched, turf becomes delineated and defended, and politics takes precedence over performance. Walls that exist in the physical workplace can be reflections of "mental" walls.
In reengineering, a firm uses information technology to break down functional barriers and create a work system based on business processes, products, or outputs rather than on functions or inputs. Cornerstones of reengineering are decentralization, reciprocal interdependence, and information sharing. A firm that exemplifies complete information sharing is Springfield Remanufacturing Corporation, which provides to all employees a weekly income statement of the firm, as well as extensive information on other companies' performances.
A benefit of reengineering is that it offers employees the opportunity to see more clearly how their particular jobs impact the final product or service being marketed by the firm. However, reengineering also can raise manager and employee anxiety that, unless calmed, can lead to corporate trauma.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the distinction between restructuring (incremental cost-cutting and reorganization) and reengineering (radical process redesign) helps strategists choose the appropriate approach based on whether the organization needs incremental improvement or fundamental transformation.
π Definition β Reengineering: The radical redesign of an organization's processes, especially its business processes, by breaking down functional barriers and creating a work system based on complete processes rather than functions. π Example: Instead of having separate departments for order entry, credit check, and shipping that pass work along, a cross-functional team handles the entire order-to-delivery process.
Linking Performance and Pay to Strategies
Most companies today are practicing some form of pay-for-performance for employees and managers other than top executives. The average employee performance bonus is 6.8 percent of pay for individual performance, 5.5 percent of pay for group productivity, and 6.4 percent of pay for companywide profitability.
Staff control of pay systems often prevents line managers from using financial compensation as a strategic tool. Flexibility regarding managerial and employee compensation is needed to allow short-term shifts in compensation that can stimulate efforts to achieve long-term objectives. NBC recently unveiled a new method for paying its affiliated stations. The compensation formula is 50 percent based on audience viewing of shows from 4 p.m. to 8 p.m. and 50 percent based on how many adults aged 25 to 54 watch NBC over the course of a day.
How can an organization's reward system be more closely linked to strategic performance? How can decisions on salary increases, promotions, merit pay, and bonuses be more closely aligned to support the long-term strategic objectives of the organization? There are no widely accepted answers to these questions, but a dual bonus system based on both annual objectives and long-term objectives is becoming common. The percentage of a manager's annual bonus attributable to short-term versus long-term results should vary by hierarchical level in the organization. A chief executive officer's annual bonus could, for example, be determined on a 75 percent short-term and 25 percent long-term basis. It is important that bonuses not be based solely on short-term results because such a system ignores long-term company strategies and objectives.
DuPont Canada has a 16 percent return-on-equity objective. If this objective is met, the company's four thousand employees receive a "performance sharing cash award" equal to 4 percent of pay. If return-on-equity falls below 11 percent, employees get nothing. If return-on-equity exceeds 28 percent, workers receive a 10 percent bonus.
In an effort to cut costs and increase productivity, more and more Japanese companies are switching from seniority-based pay to performance-based approaches. Toyota Motor switched in mid-1999 to a full merit system for twenty thousand of its seventy thousand white-collar workers. Fujitsu, Sony, Matsushita Electric Industrial, and Kao also have switched to merit pay systems. Nearly 30 percent of all Japanese companies have switched to merit pay from seniority pay. This switching is hurting morale at some Japanese companies that have trained workers for decades to cooperate rather than to compete and to work in groups rather than individually.
Profit sharing is another widely used form of incentive compensation. More than 30 percent of American companies have profit-sharing plans, but critics emphasize that too many factors affect profits for this to be a good criterion. Taxes, pricing, or an acquisition would wipe out profits, for example. Also, firms try to minimize profits in a sense to reduce taxes.
Still another criterion widely used to link performance and pay to strategies is gain sharing. Gain sharing requires employees or departments to establish performance targets; if actual results exceed objectives, all members get bonuses. More than 26 percent of American companies use some form of gain sharing; about 75 percent of gain-sharing plans have been adopted since 1980. Carrier, a subsidiary of United Technologies, has had excellent success with gain sharing in its six plants in Syracuse, New York; Firestone's tire plant in Wilson, North Carolina, has experienced similar success with gain sharing.
Criteria such as sales, profit, production efficiency, quality, and safety could also serve as bases for an effective bonus system. If an organization meets certain understood, agreed-upon profit objectives, every member of the enterprise should share in the harvest. A bonus system can be an effective tool for motivating individuals to support strategy-implementation efforts. BankAmerica, for example, recently overhauled its incentive system to link pay to sales of the bank's most profitable products and services. Branch managers receive a base salary plus a bonus based on the number of new customers and on sales of bank products. Every employee in each branch is also eligible for a bonus if the branch exceeds its goals. Thomas Peterson, a top BankAmerica executive, says, "We want to make people responsible for meeting their goals, so we pay incentives on sales, not on controlling costs or on being sure the parking lot is swept."
π Definition β Pay-for-performance: Compensation systems where employee bonuses are tied to individual performance, group productivity, or companywide profitability. π Definition β Profit sharing: An incentive compensation plan where employees receive bonuses based on company profits; used by more than 30% of American companies. π Definition β Gain sharing: A compensation plan requiring employees or departments to establish performance targets; if actual results exceed objectives, all members get bonuses. π Dual Bonus System: A bonus system based on both annual objectives and long-term objectives. The percentage of a manager's annual bonus attributable to short-term versus long-term results should vary by hierarchical level. π Example: DuPont Canada's performance sharing plan - 16% return-on-equity target triggers 4% pay bonus; below 11% = no bonus; above 28% = 10% bonus.
Managing Resistance to Change
No organization or individual can escape change. But the thought of change raises anxieties because people fear economic loss, inconvenience, uncertainty, and a break in normal social patterns. Almost any change in structure, technology, people, or strategies has the potential to disrupt comfortable interaction patterns. For this reason, people resist change. The strategic-management process itself can impose major changes on individuals and processes. Reorienting an organization to get people to think and act strategically is not an easy task.
Resistance to change can be considered the single greatest threat to successful strategy implementation. Resistance in the form of sabotaging production machines, absenteeism, filing unfounded grievances, and an unwillingness to cooperate regularly occurs in organizations. People often resist strategy implementation because they do not understand what is happening or why changes are taking place. In that case, employees may simply need accurate information. Successful strategy implementation hinges upon managers' ability to develop an organizational climate conducive to change. Change must be viewed as an opportunity rather than as a threat by managers and employees.
Resistance to change can emerge at any stage or level of the strategy-implementation process. Although there are various approaches for implementing changes, three commonly used strategies are:
- A force change strategy involves giving orders and enforcing those orders; this strategy has the advantage of being fast, but it is plagued by low commitment and high resistance.
- The educative change strategy is one that presents information to convince people of the need for change; the disadvantage of an educative change strategy is that implementation becomes slow and difficult. However, this type of strategy evokes greater commitment and less resistance than does the force strategy.
- A rational or self-interest change strategy is one that attempts to convince individuals that the change is to their personal advantage. When this appeal is successful, strategy implementation can be relatively easy. However, implementation changes are seldom to everyone's advantage.
π‘ Why this matters: Successfully managing resistance to change is critical because it is considered the single greatest threat to successful strategy implementation; choosing the right change strategy can determine whether strategic initiatives succeed or fail.
π Definition β Resistance to change: Opposition to organizational changes that can manifest as sabotaging production machines, absenteeism, filing unfounded grievances, and unwillingness to cooperate; considered the single greatest threat to successful strategy implementation. π Definition β Force change strategy: A change implementation approach involving giving orders and enforcing those orders; fast but with low commitment and high resistance. π Definition β Educative change strategy: A change implementation approach that presents information to convince people of the need for change; slow and difficult but evokes greater commitment. π Definition β Rational or self-interest change strategy: A change implementation approach that attempts to convince individuals that the change is to their personal advantage.
Managing the Natural Environment
The natural environment comprises all living and non-living things that occur naturally on Earth. In its purest sense, it is thus an environment that is not the result of human activity or intervention. The natural environment may be contrasted to "the built environment."
All business functions are affected by natural environment considerations or striving to make a profit. However, both employees and consumers are especially resentful of firms that take from more than they give to the natural environment; likewise, people today are especially appreciative of firms that conduct operations in a way that mends rather than harms the environment.
The ecological challenge facing all organizations requires managers to formulate strategies that preserve and conserve natural resources and control pollution. Special natural environmental issues include ozone depletion, global warming, depletion of rain forests, destruction of animal habitats, protecting endangered species, developing biodegradable products and packages, waste management, clean air, clean water, erosion, destruction of natural resources, and pollution control. Firms increasingly are developing green product lines that are biodegradable and/or are made from recycled products. Green products sell well.
Managing as if the earth matters requires an understanding of how international trade, competitiveness, and global resources are connected. Managing environmental affairs can no longer be simply a technical function performed by specialists in a firm; more emphasis must be placed on developing an environmental perspective among all employees and managers of the firm. Many companies are moving environmental affairs from the staff side of the organization to the line side, to make the corporate environmental group report directly to the chief operating officer.
Societies have been plagued by environmental disasters to such an extent recently that firms failing to recognize the importance of environmental issues and challenges could suffer severe consequences. Managing environmental affairs can no longer be an incidental or secondary function of company operations. Product design, manufacturing, and ultimate disposal should not merely reflect environmental considerations, but be driven by them. Firms that manage environmental affairs will enhance relations with consumers, regulators, vendors, and other industry playersβsubstantially improving their prospects of success.
Firms should formulate and implement strategies from an environmental perspective. Environmental strategies could include developing or acquiring green businesses, divesting or altering environment-damaging businesses, striving to become a low-cost producer through waste minimization and energy conservation, and pursuing a differentiation strategy through green product features. In addition to creating strategies, firms could include an environmental representative on the board of directors, conduct regular environmental audits, implement bonuses for favorable environmental results, become involved in environmental issues and programs, incorporate environmental values in mission statements, establish environmentally oriented objectives, acquire environmental skills, and provide environmental training programs for company employees and managers.
π Definition β Natural environment: All living and non-living things that occur naturally on Earth, as contrasted to "the built environment." π Example: A firm develops biodegradable packaging, conducts regular environmental audits, includes an environmental representative on the board, and provides environmental training for all employees.
Creating a Strategy-Supportive Culture
Strategists should strive to preserve, emphasize, and build upon aspects of an existing culture that support proposed new strategies. Aspects of an existing culture that are antagonistic to a proposed strategy should be identified and changed. Substantial research indicates that new strategies are often market-driven and dictated by competitive forces. For this reason, changing a firm's culture to fit a new strategy is usually more effective than changing a strategy to fit an existing culture. Numerous techniques are available to alter an organization's culture, including recruitment, training, transfer and promotion, restructure of an organization's design, role modeling, and positive reinforcement.
π‘ Why this matters: Since new strategies are usually market-driven and dictated by competitive forces, changing culture to fit the strategy is more effective than changing the strategy to fit the existing culture.
β Key Takeaways
Restructuring involves partially dismantling and reorganizing a company through selling portions, staff reductions, and other changes to improve efficiency, with cost reduction as its primary benefit but with significant downsides including reduced employee commitment and creativity. Reengineering is the radical redesign of business processes by breaking down functional barriers using information technology, focusing on complete processes rather than functions, though it has earned a bad reputation due to its association with massive layoffs. Linking performance and pay to strategies requires flexible compensation systems like pay-for-performance, dual bonuses, profit sharing, and gain sharing, with bonuses based on both short-term and long-term objectives to motivate strategy implementation. Managing resistance to change is critical for successful strategy implementation, with three main approaches being force change strategy (fast but low commitment), educative change strategy (slow but higher commitment), and rational/self-interest change strategy (easiest but seldom universally advantageous). Finally, firms must consider the natural environment in their strategies, moving environmental affairs from staff to line functions, developing green products, and fostering an environmental perspective among all employees, while also creating a strategy-supportive culture by preserving supportive aspects and changing antagonistic ones.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between restructuring and reengineering in terms of their approach to organizational change?
- What are the three commonly used strategies for implementing changes, and what are the main advantages and disadvantages of each?
- Name and briefly explain four different methods discussed in the lecture for linking performance and pay to organizational strategies.
- What are the three main criticisms of reengineering as identified in the lecture?
- Why is it generally more effective to change a firm's culture to fit a new strategy rather than changing the strategy to fit the existing culture?
π Lecture 35 β PRODUCTION/OPERATIONS CONCERNS WHEN IMPLEMENTING STRATEGIES
π Overview: This lecture examines the critical role of production/operations and human resource functions in strategy implementation. It details how production systems must be adjusted to support different strategies, explains the Just-In-Time (JIT) inventory philosophy, and addresses key human resource concerns that can make or break strategic execution.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers production/operations concerns when implementing strategies, including specific system adjustments required for various strategies like market development and product development. It explores the Just-In-Time (JIT) inventory strategy, its philosophy, benefits, and drawbacks. The lecture also addresses factors for plant location, the importance of production flexibility for high-technology companies, cross-training of employees, and human resource concerns including staffing, motivation, performance incentives, ESOPs, and the three common causes of human resource problems in strategy implementation.
π Lecture Summary
Production/Operations Concerns When Implementing Strategies
Strategy implementation requires a complete transparent process, and the production/operations department is mainly concerned with achieving organizational goals and targets. Production processes typically constitute more than 70 percent of a firm's total assets. The production department plays a crucial role in implementing organization strategy.
Production-concerned decisions include: plant location, plant size, product design, choice of equipment, size of inventory, inventory control, quality control, cost control, use of standards, shipping and packaging, technological innovation, job specialization, employee training, equipment and resource utilization. All these factors have an important impact on the success or failure of the strategy.
Examples of adjustments in production systems required to implement various strategies:
- A hospital adding a TB center (Product Development) must purchase specialized equipment and add specialized people.
- A bank opening ten new branches (Market Development) must perform site location analysis.
- A computer company purchasing a retail distribution chain (Forward Integration) must alter the shipping, packaging, and transportation systems.
- A steel manufacturer acquiring a fast-food chain (Conglomerate Diversification) must improve the quality control system.
Just In Time (JIT)
π Definition β Just In Time (JIT): An inventory strategy implemented to improve the return on investment of a business by reducing in-process inventory and its associated costs.
π Process: The process is driven by a series of signals, or Kanban, that tell production processes to make the next part. Kanban are usually simple visual signals, such as the presence or absence of a part on a shelf.
JIT can lead to dramatic improvements in a manufacturing organization's return on investment, quality, and efficiency when implemented correctly. New stock is ordered when stock reaches the re-order level, saving warehouse space and costs.
π Example: To meet a 95% service rate a firm must carry about 2 standard deviations of demand in safety stock. Forecasted shifts in demand should be planned for around the Kanban until trends can be established to reset the appropriate Kanban level. Manufacturers have touted a trailing 13 week average as a better predictor than most forecasters could provide.
β οΈ Drawback: The re-order level in JIT is determined by historical demand. If demand rises above the historical average planning duration demand, the firm could deplete inventory and cause customer service issues.
π‘ Why this matters: JIT significantly reduces the costs of implementing strategies by ensuring parts and materials are delivered to a production site just as they are needed, rather than being stockpiled as a hedge against later deliveries.
JIT Philosophy
Just-in-time inventory systems have a whole philosophy that the company must follow, drawing from statistics, industrial engineering, production management, and behavioral science.
Key views within the JIT inventory philosophy:
- Inventory is seen as incurring costs instead of adding value, contrary to traditional thinking. Businesses are encouraged to eliminate inventory that doesn't add value to the product.
- Inventory is seen as a sign of subpar management as it is simply there to hide problems within the production system, including backups at work centers, lack of flexibility for employees and equipment, and inadequate capacity.
π Definition β JIT Philosophy Core Principle: Having "the right material, at the right time, at the right place, and in the exact amount."
Plant Location Factors
The factors that must be studied while placing a plant are: transportation costs related to shipping and receiving, the location of major markets, availability of major resources, availability of skilled labor, wage rates, and political risks in the area or country.
For high-technology companies, production costs may not be as important as production flexibility because changes in a product are needed often. Industries such as biogenetics and plastics rely on production systems that must be flexible enough to allow frequent changes and rapid introduction of new products.
A change in product strategy alters the tasks of a production system. These tasks, stated in terms of requirements for cost, product flexibility, volume flexibility, product performance, and product consistency, determine which manufacturing policies are appropriate. As strategies shift over time, so must production policies covering the location and scale of manufacturing facilities, the choice of manufacturing process, the degree of vertical integration, the use of R&D units, the control of the production system, and the licensing of technology.
Cross-Training of Employees
Cross-training of employees can facilitate strategy implementation and yield many benefits. Employees gain a better understanding of the whole business and can contribute better ideas in planning sessions.
Problems associated with cross-training:
- It can necessitate substantial investments in training and incentives.
- It can be very time-consuming.
- Skilled workers may resent unskilled workers who learn their jobs.
- It can thrust managers into roles that emphasize counseling and coaching over directing and enforcing.
- Older employees may not want to learn new skills.
Human Resource Concerns When Implementing Strategies
Human resource is the backbone of any organization. Without efficient human resources, an organization cannot perform well and will fail to achieve organizational strategy. Staffing needs of the organization and their cost is an important function of the human resource manager.
Other main concerns include health, safety, and security of workers. The plan must also include how to motivate employees and managers during a time when layoffs are common and workloads are high.
The human resource department must develop performance incentives that clearly link performance and pay to strategies. The process of empowering managers and employees through involvement in strategic-management activities yields the greatest benefits when all organizational members understand clearly how they will benefit personally if the firm does well. Linking company and personal benefits is a major new strategic responsibility of human resource managers.
π Definition β Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP): Corporations owned in whole or in part by their employees. Employees are usually given a share of the corporation after a certain length of employment or they can buy shares at any time. A corporation owned entirely by its employees (a worker cooperative) will not have its shares sold on public stock markets. Employee-owned corporations often adopt profit sharing and often have boards of directors elected directly by the employees.
Causes of Human Resource Problems in Strategic Management
A well-designed strategic-management system can fail if insufficient attention is given to the human resource dimension.
Three causes of human resource problems when implementing strategies:
- Disruption of social and political structures
- Failure to match individuals' aptitudes with implementation tasks
- Inadequate top management support for implementation activities
Inadequate support from strategists for implementation activities often undermines organizational success. Chief executive officers, small business owners, and government agency heads must be personally committed to strategy implementation and express this commitment in highly visible ways. Strategists' formal statements about the importance of strategic management must be consistent with actual support and rewards given. Otherwise, stress created by inconsistency can cause uncertainty among managers and employees at all levels.
The best method for preventing and overcoming human resource problems in strategic management is to actively involve as many managers and employees as possible in the process. Although time-consuming, this approach builds understanding, trust, commitment, and ownership and reduces resentment and hostility. The true potential of strategy formulation and implementation resides in people.
β Key Takeaways
Production/operations departments constitute over 70% of a firm's total assets and must make specific system adjustmentsβlike site location analysis or equipment purchasesβto support different strategies. JIT is a philosophy-driven inventory strategy using Kanban signals to have "the right material at the right time," significantly reducing implementation costs but with the drawback of relying on historical demand. Plant location decisions depend on transportation, markets, resources, labor, and political risks, while high-tech firms prioritize production flexibility over cost. Cross-training benefits strategy implementation but creates problems including resentment, time costs, and managerial role shifts. Finally, human resource problems in strategy implementation stem from disrupting social structures, mismatching aptitudes, and inadequate top management support, with employee involvement being the best preventive measure.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What percentage of a firm's total assets do production processes typically constitute?
- Explain the JIT philosophy regarding inventory and the role of Kanban signals.
- What is the main drawback of the Just-In-Time inventory system?
- List the five factors that must be studied when placing a plant.
- What are the three causes of human resource problems when implementing strategies?
π Lecture 36 β MARKET SEGMENTATION
π Overview: This lecture explains the concept of market segmentation, which is the process of dividing a broad market into smaller, homogeneous subgroups of customers. It is a critical tool for strategy implementation, as it allows firms to tailor their marketing mix to specific customer needs, enabling even small firms to compete effectively. The lecture covers the need for segmentation, its bases (geographic, demographic, psychographic, and behavioralistic), and its link to strategy implementation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining market segmentation and explaining its role in target marketing versus mass marketing. It then outlines the requirements for successful segmentation and introduces the Four Ps of the Marketing Mix (Product, Place, Promotion, Price). The core of the lecture details the four bases for segmentation in consumer markets: geographic, demographic, psychographic, and behavioralistic, providing examples for each. Finally, it discusses the link between market segmentation and strategy implementation, highlighting its importance for small firms and strategic growth.
π Lecture Summary
Market segmentation
Market segmentation is the process in marketing of grouping a market (i.e., customers) into smaller subgroups. This is derived from the recognition that the total market is often made up of submarkets called segments. These segments are homogeneous within (i.e., people in the segment are similar to each other in their attitudes about certain variables). Because of this intra-group similarity, they are likely to respond similarly to a given marketing strategy.
π Definition β Market segmentation: The process of subdividing a market into distinct subsets of customers according to needs and buying habits.
The Need for Market Segmentation
The marketing concept calls for understanding customers and satisfying their needs better than the competition. Mass marketing refers to treatment of the market as a homogenous group and offering the same marketing mix to all customers. While this allows economies of scale, its drawback is that customer needs differ, and the same offering is unlikely to be viewed as optimal by all customers. Target marketing, on the other hand, recognizes the diversity of customers and does not try to please all of them with the same offering; the first step is to identify different market segments and their needs.
The requirements for successful segmentation are:
- Homogeneity within the segment
- Heterogeneity between segments
- Segments are measurable and identifiable
- Segments are accessible and actionable
- Segment is large enough to be profitable
The marketing mix is introduced as the Four Ps: Product (whatever is being sold), Place (where or what area the campaign covers, now including demographics), Promotion (the media vehicle and overall strategy), and Price (including price elasticity).
Bases for Segmentation in Consumer Markets
Consumer markets can be segmented on the following customer characteristics:
- Geographic
- Demographic
- Psychographic
- Behavioralistic
Geographic Segmentation
Examples of geographic variables used in segmentation include:
- Region: by continent, country, state, or neighborhood
- Size of metropolitan area: segmented according to size of population
- Population density: often classified as urban, suburban, or rural
- Climate: according to weather patterns common to certain geographic regions
Demographic Segmentation
Some demographic segmentation variables include:
- Age
- Gender
- Family size
- Family lifecycle
- Generation (e.g., baby-boomers, Generation X)
- Income
- Occupation
- Education
- Ethnicity
- Nationality
- Religion
- Social class
Many of these variables have standard categories. For example, family lifecycle often is expressed as bachelor, DINKS (Double Income, No Kids), full-nest, empty-nest, or solitary survivor.
Psychographic Segmentation
Psychographic segmentation groups customers according to their lifestyle. Activities, interests, and opinions (AIO) surveys are one tool for measuring lifestyle. Some psychographic variables include:
- Activities
- Interests
- Opinions
- Attitudes
- Values
Behavioralistic Segmentation
Behavioral segmentation is based on actual customer behavior toward products. Some behavioralistic variables include:
- Benefits sought
- Usage rate
- Brand loyalty
- User status: potential, first-time, regular, etc.
- Readiness to buy
- Occasions: holidays and events that stimulate purchases
Behavioral segmentation has the advantage of using variables that are closely related to the product itself. When numerous variables are combined to give an in-depth understanding of a segment, this is referred to as depth segmentation. When enough information is combined to create a clear picture of a typical member of a segment, this is referred to as a buyer profile. When the profile is limited to demographic variables it is called a demographic profile. A statistical technique commonly used in determining a profile is cluster analysis.
Market segmentation Link with strategy implementation
Market segmentation is an important variable in strategy implementation for at least three major reasons. First, strategies such as market development, product development, market penetration, and diversification require increased sales through new markets and products. Second, market segmentation allows a firm to operate with limited resources because mass production, mass distribution, and mass advertising are not required. Market segmentation can enable a small firm to compete successfully with a large firm by maximizing per-unit profits and per-segment sales. Finally, market segmentation decisions directly affect marketing mix variables: product, place, promotion, and price.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding market segmentation is crucial because it directly links marketing decisions to strategic goals, allowing firms to allocate resources efficiently and target specific customer groups for growth.
β Key Takeaways
Market segmentation is the process of dividing a market into distinct, homogeneous subgroups to better satisfy customer needs than competitors. It is essential for strategy implementation as it supports strategies like market development and penetration, and enables small firms to compete by maximizing per-unit profits. The four main bases for segmentation are geographic, demographic, psychographic, and behavioralistic, each offering different variables to categorize consumers. Successful segmentation requires segments to be homogeneous, heterogeneous, measurable, accessible, and profitable. Finally, segmentation decisions directly shape the marketing mix variables of product, place, promotion, and price.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five requirements for successful market segmentation?
- List and describe the four bases for segmentation in consumer markets.
- What is the difference between mass marketing and target marketing?
- What are the four Ps of the marketing mix, and how does market segmentation directly affect them?
- What is a buyer profile, and what statistical technique is commonly used to determine it?