π Lecture 30 β GRAND STRATEGY MATRIX
π Overview: This lecture covers the final matrix of the matching stage in the strategy formulation framework, the Grand Strategy Matrix (GS Matrix). It then introduces the Quantitative Strategic Planning Matrix (QSPM) as the sole decision-stage tool used to objectively evaluate and select among alternative strategies. Understanding QSPM is critical because it provides a systematic, data-driven method for choosing the best strategic direction.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the Grand Strategy Matrix as a matching tool, but the primary focus is on the Quantitative Strategic Planning Matrix (QSPM), its role in the decision stage of strategy formulation, the step-by-step process for its preparation, and its advantages and limitations. Key factors for consideration, such as internal and external factors, are also outlined.
π Lecture Summary
The Quantitative Strategic Planning Matrix (QSPM)
The final stage of strategy formulation is the decision stage. This stage uses the QSPM, which is the only tool for the objective evaluation of alternative strategies. It is a quantitative method used to collect data and prepare a matrix for strategic planning, based on identified internal and external crucial success factors. This technique is designed to determine the relative attractiveness of feasible alternative actions, objectively indicating which alternative strategies are best.
The QSPM uses input from Stage 1 analyses (EFE Matrix, IFE Matrix, Competitive Profile Matrix) and matching results from Stage 2 analyses (TOWS Matrix, SPACE Analysis, BCG Matrix, IE Matrix, GS Matrix) to decide objectively among alternative strategies.
Preparation of matrix
To prepare a QSPM, first list key internal factors (strengths and weaknesses) and external factors (opportunities and threats). Relate these to the previous IFE and EFE, assigning a weight to all factors. The sum of all weights must equal 1. After assigning weights, examine Stage-2 matrices to identify alternative strategies the organization should consider. The top row of the QSPM lists these alternative strategies. Strategists should use good intuitive judgment to select which strategies to include. Next, determine the Attractiveness Score (AS) for each strategy factor-by-factor, and then compute the Total Attractiveness Score (TAS) by multiplying the weight by the AS. The strategy with the highest sum of Total Attractiveness Scores is the most feasible.
Steps in preparation of QSPM
- List the firm's key external opportunities/threats and internal strengths/weaknesses in the left column.
- Assign weights to each key external and internal factor.
- Examine the Stage 2 (matching) matrices and identify alternative strategies to consider.
- Determine the Attractiveness Scores (AS).
- Compute the Total Attractiveness Scores (TAS = Weight x AS).
- Compute the Sum Total Attractiveness Score (sum of all TAS for each strategy).
Limitations
- Requires intuitive judgments and educated assumptions.
- Is only as good as the prerequisite inputs.
- Only strategies within a given set are evaluated relative to each other.
Advantages
- Sets of strategies can be considered simultaneously or sequentially.
- Allows for the integration of pertinent external and internal factors in the decision-making process.
Key Internal Factors
These include: Management, Marketing, Finance/Accounting, Production/Operations, Research and Development, and Computer Information Systems.
Key External Factors
These include: Economy conditions, Social/Cultural/Demographic/Environmental, Political/Legal/Governmental, Technological, Competitive, and Consumer attitude.
π‘ Why this matters: The QSPM is the only tool that forces strategists to objectively consider both internal and external factors side-by-side when choosing a strategy, moving beyond intuition to a more defensible and analytical decision.
β Key Takeaways
The QSPM is the sole objective decision-making tool in the strategy formulation framework, requiring input from all Stage 1 and Stage 2 analyses. Its core process involves assigning weights to key success factors and calculating Total Attractiveness Scores (TAS) to compare alternative strategies. The strategy with the highest Sum Total Attractiveness Score is considered the best choice. While highly systematic, the QSPM is limited by the quality of its inputs and the intuitive judgments required for assigning Attractiveness Scores. A student must remember that the QSPM does not replace judgment but organizes and quantifies it for a more transparent strategic selection.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary purpose of the Quantitative Strategic Planning Matrix (QSPM)?
- List the three stages of the strategy formulation framework and name the matrix/tool associated with the decision stage.
- In the QSPM, what does the Total Attractiveness Score (TAS) for a single factor represent, and how is it calculated?
- What is one major limitation of the QSPM, according to the lecture?
- What types of inputs (from which matrices) are needed before a QSPM can be prepared?
π Lecture 31 β The Nature of Strategy Implementation
π Overview: This lecture explores the critical gap between strategy formulation and strategy implementation, revealing that most organizations fail not because of bad strategies but because of poor execution. It covers the fundamental differences between formulation and implementation, the management perspectives required for successful execution, and the essential roles of annual objectives and policies in translating strategic plans into action.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by defining the nature of strategy implementation, highlighting startling statistics about execution failure rates and contrasting strategy formulation with implementation across multiple dimensions. It then examines management perspectives, emphasizing the shift in responsibility from strategists to divisional managers and the importance of participative decision-making. The lecture further details annual objectives, including corporate and functional levels, SMART criteria, and their role as guidelines for action and performance standards. Finally, it covers policies as instruments for strategy implementation, explaining how they set boundaries and guide day-to-day behavior.
π Lecture Summary
The Nature of Strategy Implementation
Most companies have strategies, but between 70% and 90% of organizations that formulate strategies fail to execute them. A Fortune Magazine study revealed that 7 out of 10 CEOs who fail do so not because of bad strategy, but because of bad execution. In a study of Times 1000 companies, 80% of directors said they had the right strategies but only 14% thought they were implementing them well. Only 1 in 3 companies were achieving significant strategic success.
Successful strategy formulation does not guarantee successful strategy implementation. Strategy formulation is positioning forces before action, focuses on effectiveness, is primarily an intellectual process requiring good intuitive and analytical skills, and requires coordination among a few individuals. Strategy implementation is managing forces during action, focuses on efficiency, is primarily an operational process requiring special motivation and leadership skills, and requires coordination among many persons.
Strategy-formulation concepts and tools do not differ greatly for small, large, for-profit, or nonprofit organizations. However, strategy implementation varies substantially among different types and sizes of organizations. Implementing strategies requires actions such as altering sales territories, adding new departments, closing facilities, hiring new employees, changing pricing strategies, developing financial budgets, developing new employee benefits, establishing cost-control procedures, changing advertising strategies, building new facilities, training new employees, transferring managers among divisions, and building a better computer information system.
Management Perspectives
In all but the smallest organizations, the transition from strategy formulation to strategy implementation requires a shift in responsibility from strategists to divisional and functional managers. Implementation problems can arise because of this shift, especially if strategy-formulation decisions come as a surprise to middle- and lower-level managers. Managers and employees are motivated more by perceived self-interests than by organizational interests, unless the two coincide. Therefore, it is essential that divisional and functional managers be involved as much as possible in strategy-formulation activities, and strategists should be involved as much as possible in strategy-implementation activities.
π‘ Why this matters: The disconnect between those who formulate strategy and those who implement it is the primary cause of execution failure. Bridging this gap through active participation is essential.
Management issues central to strategy implementation include establishing annual objectives, devising policies, allocating resources, altering organizational structure, restructuring and reengineering, revising reward and incentive plans, minimizing resistance to change, matching managers with strategy, developing a strategy-supportive culture, adapting production/operations processes, developing an effective human resource function, and downsizing if necessary. Management changes are necessarily more extensive when strategies move a firm in a major new direction.
Managers and employees throughout an organization should participate early and directly in strategy-implementation decisions. Strategists' genuine personal commitment to implementation is a necessary and powerful motivational force. The rationale for objectives and strategies should be understood and clearly communicated throughout the organization. Major competitors' accomplishments, products, plans, actions, and performance should be apparent to all organizational members. A top-down flow of communication is essential for developing bottom-up support. Firms should provide training for both managers and employees to ensure they have and maintain the skills necessary to be world-class performers.
Annual Objectives
Introduction Objectives set out what the business is trying to achieve. Objectives can be set at two levels:
(1) Corporate level β objectives that concern the business or organization as a whole. Examples include: aiming for a return on investment of at least 15%, achieving an operating profit of over Β£10 million on sales of at least Β£100 million, or increasing earnings per share by at least 10% every year.
(2) Functional level β specific objectives for functional activities. Examples include: building a customer database of at least 250,000 households within 12 months, achieving a market share of 10%, or achieving 75% customer awareness of a brand in target markets.
Both corporate and functional objectives need to conform to the commonly used SMART criteria:
- Specific β the objective should state exactly what is to be achieved
- Measurable β capable of measurement to determine whether it has been achieved
- Achievable β realistic given circumstances and available resources
- Relevant β relevant to the people responsible for achieving them
- Time Bound β set with a realistic time-frame
Establishing annual objectives is a decentralized activity that directly involves all managers in an organization. Active participation in establishing annual objectives can lead to acceptance and commitment. Annual objectives are essential for strategy implementation because they:
- Represent the basis for allocating resources
- Are a primary mechanism for evaluating managers
- Are the major instrument for monitoring progress toward achieving long-term objectives
- Establish organizational, divisional, and departmental priorities
The purpose of annual objectives can be summarized as follows: they serve as guidelines for action, directing and channeling efforts of organization members; provide a source of legitimacy by justifying activities to stakeholders; serve as standards of performance; serve as an important source of employee motivation and identification; give incentives for managers and employees to perform; and provide a basis for organizational design.
Annual objectives should be measurable, consistent, reasonable, challenging, clear, communicated throughout the organization, characterized by an appropriate time dimension, and accompanied by commensurate rewards and sanctions. Terms such as "maximize," "minimize," "as soon as possible," and "adequate" should be avoided. Annual objectives should be compatible with employees' and managers' values and should be supported by clearly stated policies.
It is important to tie rewards and sanctions to annual objectives so that employees and managers understand that achieving objectives is critical to successful strategy implementation. However, overemphasis on achieving objectives can result in undesirable conduct, such as faking numbers, distorting records, and letting objectives become ends in themselves.
Policies
Changes in a firm's strategic direction do not occur automatically. On a day-to-day basis, policies are needed to make a strategy work. Policies facilitate solving recurring problems and guide the implementation of strategy. Broadly defined, policy refers to specific guidelines, methods, procedures, rules, forms, and administrative practices established to support and encourage work toward stated goals.
π Definition β Policy: Specific guidelines, methods, procedures, rules, forms, and administrative practices established to support and encourage work toward stated goals.
Policies are instruments for strategy implementation. They set boundaries, constraints, and limits on the kinds of administrative actions that can be taken to reward and sanction behavior; they clarify what can and cannot be done in pursuit of an organization's objectives. For example, Carnival's Paradise ship has a no-smoking policy anywhere, anytime aboard ship. About 40% of companies today do not have a formal policy preventing employees from surfing the Internet at work, but monitoring software is becoming available.
Policies let both employees and managers know what is expected of them, thereby increasing the likelihood that strategies will be implemented successfully. They provide a basis for management control, allow coordination across organizational units, and reduce the amount of time managers spend making decisions. Policies also clarify what work is to be done by whom and promote delegation of decision making to appropriate managerial levels where various problems usually arise. Many organizations have a policy manual that serves to guide and direct behavior.
Policies can apply to all divisions and departments (e.g., "We are an equal opportunity employer") or to a single department (e.g., "Employees in this department must take at least one training and development course each year"). Whatever their scope and form, policies serve as a mechanism for implementing strategies and obtaining objectives. Policies should be stated in writing whenever possible and represent the means for carrying out strategic decisions.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that strategy implementation is fundamentally different from and more difficult than strategy formulationβit is an operational process requiring motivation, leadership, and coordination across many individuals rather than an intellectual process of a few. Students must remember that between 70-90% of organizations fail to execute their strategies, making implementation the true determinant of strategic success. The shift in responsibility from strategists to divisional and functional managers is a major source of implementation problems, which can only be overcome through early and direct participation of all levels in both formulation and implementation decisions. Annual objectives must be SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) and tied to rewards and sanctions to guide behavior, while policies provide the day-to-day boundaries and guidelines that translate strategy into consistent action across the organization.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to the lecture, what percentage of organizations that formulate strategies fail to execute them, and what does this reveal about the relative difficulty of formulation versus implementation?
- List four ways in which strategy formulation differs from strategy implementation.
- What does the acronym SMART stand for in the context of setting annual objectives, and why is each element important?
- What are the four specific purposes of annual objectives in strategy implementation?
- How do policies differ from objectives in supporting strategy implementation, and what specific functions do policies serve?
π Lecture 32 β Resource Allocation
π Overview: This lecture examines the critical process of resource allocation in strategic management and its role in successful strategy execution. It also explores the nature of conflict within organizations, including its types, levels, and modes, providing insight into how conflict can be managed effectively.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers resource allocation as a major management activity for strategy execution, detailing the two parts of resource allocation plans (basic allocation decision and contingency mechanisms), the four types of organizational resources (financial, physical, human, technological), and factors that prohibit effective resource allocation. It then transitions to examining conflict β its definition, levels of analysis from intrapersonal to international, types based on concern for outcomes, and the importance of identifying the root cause of conflict (facts, goals, methods, or values). The lecture concludes with discussion of organizational structure types (functional, divisional, SBU, matrix) and symptoms of ineffective structure.
π Lecture Summary
Resource Allocation
In strategic planning, a resource-allocation decision is a plan for using available resources, especially human resources in the near term, to achieve goals for the future. It is the process of allocating resources among various projects or business units. The plan has two parts: the basic allocation decision and contingency mechanisms.
The basic allocation decision is the choice of which items to fund in the plan, what level of funding each should receive, and which to leave unfunded β resources are allocated to some items, not to others. There are two contingency mechanisms: a priority ranking of items excluded from the plan (showing which to fund if more resources become available) and a priority ranking of items included in the plan (showing which to sacrifice if total funding must be reduced).
Resource allocation is a major management activity that allows for strategy execution. In organizations that do not use a strategic-management approach, resource allocation is often based on political or personal factors. Strategic management enables resources to be allocated according to priorities established by annual objectives. Nothing could be more detrimental to strategic management and organizational success than for resources to be allocated in ways not consistent with priorities indicated by approved annual objectives.
All organizations have at least four types of resources: financial resources, physical resources, human resources, and technological resources. Allocating resources to particular divisions and departments does not mean that strategies will be successfully implemented. Factors that commonly prohibit effective resource allocation include an overprotection of resources, too great an emphasis on short-run financial criteria, organizational politics, vague strategy targets, a reluctance to take risks, and a lack of sufficient knowledge.
Managers normally have many more tasks than they can do and must allocate time and resources among these tasks. Strategy formulation and implementation activities often get deferred because today's problems soak up available energies and resources. The real value of any resource allocation program lies in the resulting accomplishment of an organization's objectives. Effective resource allocation does not guarantee successful strategy implementation because programs, personnel, controls, and commitment must breathe life into the resources provided. Strategic management itself is sometimes referred to as a "resource allocation process."
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding resource allocation is fundamental because it bridges strategic planning with actual strategy execution β even the best strategies fail if resources are diverted to immediate problems rather than strategic priorities.
Conflict
Conflict is a state of opposition, disagreement, or incompatibility between two or more people or groups, sometimes characterized by physical violence. In political terms, "conflict" refers to an ongoing state of hostility between two groups of people. For graduate and professional work in conflict resolution, conflict is defined as: "when two or more parties, with perceived incompatible goals, seek to undermine each other's goal-seeking capability."
One should not confuse the distinction between the presence and absence of conflict with the difference between competition and cooperation. In competitive situations, two or more parties each have mutually inconsistent goals, so when either party tries to reach their goal it will undermine the other's attempts β therefore, competitive situations will by their nature cause conflict. However, conflict can also occur in cooperative situations where two or more parties have consistent goals, because the manner in which one party tries to reach their goal can still undermine the other.
π Definition β Conflict: When two or more parties, with perceived incompatible goals, seek to undermine each other's goal-seeking capability.
Types and Modes of Conflict
A conceptual conflict can escalate into a verbal exchange and/or result in fighting. Conflict can exist at a variety of levels of analysis:
- Intrapersonal conflict (though this usually gets delegated to psychology)
- Interpersonal conflict
- Group conflict
- Organizational conflict
- Community conflict
- Intra-state conflict (for example: civil wars, election campaigns)
- International conflict
Conflicts in these levels may appear "nested" in conflicts residing at larger levels of analysis. For example, conflict within a work team may play out the dynamics of a broader conflict in the organization as a whole.
Theorists have claimed that parties can conceptualize responses to conflict according to a two-dimensional scheme: concern for one's own outcomes and concern for the outcomes of the other party. This scheme leads to the following hypotheses:
- High concern for both one's own and the other party's outcomes leads to attempts to find mutually beneficial solutions.
- High concern for one's own outcomes only leads to attempts to "win" the conflict.
- High concern for the other party's outcomes only leads to allowing the other to "win" the conflict.
- No concern for either side's outcomes leads to attempts to avoid the conflict.
In Western society, practitioners usually suggest that attempts to find mutually beneficial solutions lead to the most satisfactory outcomes, but this may not hold true for many Asian societies.
Often a group finds itself in conflict over facts, goals, methods, or values. It is critical to properly identify the type of conflict it is experiencing if it hopes to manage the conflict through to resolution. The more difficult type of conflict is when values are the root cause β it is extremely difficult to "prove" that a value is "right" or "correct." In some instances, a group will benefit from the use of a facilitator or process consultant to help identify the specific type of conflict.
There is no one optimal organizational design or structure for a given strategy or type of organization. Successful firms in a given industry do tend to organize themselves in a similar way. Small firms tend to be functionally structured (centralized). Medium-size firms tend to be divisionally structured (decentralized). Large firms tend to use an SBU (strategic business unit) or matrix structure. As organizations grow, their structures generally change from simple to complex as a result of concatenation, or the linking together of several basic strategies.
Numerous external and internal forces affect an organization; no firm could change its structure in response to every one of these forces because to do so would lead to chaos. When a firm changes its strategy, the existing organizational structure may become ineffective. Symptoms of an ineffective organizational structure include too many levels of management, too many meetings attended by too many people, too much attention directed toward solving interdepartmental conflicts, too large a span of control, and too many unachieved objectives. Changes in structure can facilitate strategy-implementation efforts, but changes in structure should not be expected to make a bad strategy good, to make bad managers good, or to make bad products sell.
π‘ Why this matters: Structure undeniably can and does influence strategy β strategies formulated must be workable, so if a certain new strategy required massive structural changes it would not be an attractive choice. The key concern is determining what types of structural changes are needed to implement new strategies and how these changes can best be accomplished.
β Key Takeaways
Resource allocation is a critical management activity that translates strategic priorities into actual execution by distributing financial, physical, human, and technological resources according to annual objectives rather than political or personal factors. Managers must guard against common barriers to effective allocation such as overprotection of resources, short-term financial focus, organizational politics, and vague strategy targets. Conflict is a normal organizational phenomenon that can arise in both competitive and cooperative situations, and its resolution depends on properly identifying whether the root cause involves facts, goals, methods, or values β with value-based conflicts being the most difficult to resolve. Organizational structure must align with strategy, and ineffective structures show symptoms like too many management levels, excessive meetings, interdepartmental conflicts, and unachieved objectives.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two parts of a resource allocation plan, and what does each part determine?
- List the four types of resources that all organizations have available for achieving objectives.
- What are six factors that commonly prohibit effective resource allocation in organizations?
- According to the two-dimensional scheme for responding to conflict, what outcomes result from high concern for both one's own and the other party's outcomes versus high concern for one's own outcomes only?
- What are the symptoms of an ineffective organizational structure, and why should structural changes not be expected to fix bad strategies or bad products?
π Lecture 33 β ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE
π Overview: This lecture examines different types of organizational structures, including functional, divisional, and matrix designs, as well as the Strategic Business Unit (SBU) structure. It also explores restructuring, reengineering, and e-engineering as critical strategy-implementation tools. Understanding these structures is essential for managers to align organizational design with strategic objectives.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining organizational structure and then thoroughly explains the functional structure, divisional structure (with its four variations: geographic area, product, customer, and process), and the Strategic Business Unit (SBU) structure. It covers the matrix structure and concludes with a comparison of restructuring and reengineering, including the concept of e-engineering.
π Lecture Summary
Organizational Structure
Organizational structure refers to how an organization arranges its activities, tasks, and authority relationships to achieve its strategic objectives. The choice of structure is a critical strategy-implementation decision that affects coordination, accountability, and efficiency.
Functional Structure
The functional structure organizes the organization according to functional areas (such as production/operations, marketing, finance/accounting, R&D, and computer information systems) instead of product lines. This structure groups specialists with similar skills in separate units and is best used when creating specific, uniform products. It is particularly well suited to organizations that have a single or dominant core product because each subunit becomes extremely adept at performing its particular portion of the process.
The functional or centralized type is the most widely used structure because it is the simplest and least expensive of the seven alternatives. A university, for example, may structure its activities by major functions including academic affairs, student services, alumni relations, athletics, maintenance, and accounting.
π Definition β Functional Structure: An organizational design that groups tasks and activities by business function such as production/operations, marketing, finance/accounting, research and development, and computer information systems.
Advantages of a functional structure include:
- Simple and inexpensive
- Promotes specialization of labor
- Encourages efficiency
- Minimizes the need for an elaborate control system
- Allows rapid decision making
Disadvantages include:
- Forces accountability to the top
- Minimizes career development opportunities
- Sometimes characterized by low employee morale
- Line/staff conflicts
- Poor delegation of authority
- Inadequate planning for products and markets
π Example: A university structuring its activities by major functions such as academic affairs, student services, alumni relations, athletics, maintenance, and accounting.
Divisional Structure
A divisional structure is formed when an organization is split up into a number of self-contained business units, each of which operates as a profit centre. Such a division may occur on the basis of product or market or a combination of the two, with each unit tending to operate along functional or product lines, but with certain key functions (e.g., finance, personnel, corporate planning) provided centrally at company headquarters.
The divisional or decentralized structure is the second most common type used by American businesses. As a small organization grows, it has more difficulty managing different products and services in different markets. The divisional structure can be organized in one of four ways: by geographic area, by product or service, by customer, or by process. With a divisional structure, functional activities are performed both centrally and in each separate division.
π Definition β Divisional Structure: An organizational design that creates self-contained business units, each operating as a profit centre, organized by geographic area, product, customer, or process.
Advantages include:
- Clear accountability (divisional managers responsible for sales and profit levels)
- Based on extensive delegation of authority
- Higher employee morale than in centralized structures
- Creates career development opportunities for managers
- Allows local control of local situations
- Leads to a competitive climate within an organization
- Allows new businesses and products to be added easily
Disadvantages include:
- Costly (each division requires functional specialists who must be paid)
- Duplication of staff services, facilities, and personnel
- Requires well-qualified managers who demand higher salaries
- Requires an elaborate, headquarters-driven control system
- Certain regions, products, or customers may receive special treatment
- Difficult to maintain consistent, companywide practices
Four Types of Divisional Structure:
-
Divisional structure by geographic area β Appropriate for organizations whose strategies need to be tailored to fit the particular needs and characteristics of customers in different geographic areas. It allows local participation in decision making and improved coordination within a region.
-
Divisional structure by product β Most effective when specific products or services need special emphasis. Widely used when an organization offers only a few products or services, or when products or services differ substantially. It allows strict control and attention to product lines but may require a more skilled management force.
-
Divisional structure by customer β Most effective when a few major customers are of paramount importance and many different services are provided to these customers. It allows an organization to cater effectively to the requirements of clearly defined customer groups.
-
Divisional structure by process β Similar to a functional structure because activities are organized according to the way work is actually performed. However, the key difference is that functional departments are not accountable for profits or revenues, whereas divisional process departments are evaluated on these criteria.
π Example (by customer): Book publishing companies often organize their activities around customer groups such as colleges, secondary schools, and private commercial schools. Merrill Lynch is organized into separate divisions catering to wealthy individuals, institutional investors, and small corporations.
π Example (by process): A manufacturing business organized into six divisions: electrical work, glass cutting, welding, grinding, painting, and foundry work. Each process division is responsible for generating revenues and profits.
The Strategic Business Unit (SBU) Structure
A Strategic Business Unit (SBU) is a business unit within the overall corporate identity that is distinguishable from other businesses because it serves a defined external market where management can conduct strategic planning in relation to products and markets. When companies become really large, they are best thought of as being composed of a number of businesses (or SBUs).
These organizational entities are large enough and homogeneous enough to exercise control over most strategic factors affecting their performance. They are managed as self-contained planning units for which discrete business strategies can be developed. An SBU can encompass an entire company or can simply be a smaller part of a company set up to perform a specific task.
π Definition β Strategic Business Unit (SBU): A business unit within the overall corporate identity that serves a defined external market where management can conduct strategic planning in relation to products and markets, with its own business strategy, objectives, and competitors.
The SBU structure groups similar divisions into strategic business units and delegates authority and responsibility for each unit to a senior executive who reports directly to the chief executive officer. This change in structure can facilitate strategy implementation by improving coordination between similar divisions and channeling accountability to distinct business units.
Disadvantages of an SBU structure:
- Requires an additional layer of management, which increases salary expenses
- The role of the group vice president is often ambiguous
π Example: In a ninety-division conglomerate, the ninety divisions could be regrouped into ten SBUs according to common characteristics such as competing in the same industry, being located in the same area, or having the same customers. Atlantic Richfield and Fairchild Industries are examples of firms that successfully use an SBU-type structure.
π‘ Why this matters: The SBU structure solves the problem of excessive span of control in large, multidivisional organizations by creating an intermediate management layer that coordinates similar divisions, improving both coordination and accountability.
The Matrix Structure
A matrix structure is the most complex of all designs because it depends upon both vertical and horizontal flows of authority and communication (hence the term matrix). In contrast, functional and divisional structures depend primarily on vertical flows of authority and communication.
π Definition β Matrix Structure: An organizational design that uses both vertical and horizontal flows of authority and communication, creating dual lines of budget authority, dual sources of reward and punishment, shared authority, and dual reporting channels.
Characteristics contributing to complexity:
- Dual lines of budget authority (violation of the unity-of-command principle)
- Dual sources of reward and punishment
- Shared authority
- Dual reporting channels
- Need for an extensive and effective communication system
Advantages:
- Project objectives are clear
- Many channels of communication
- Workers can see visible results of their work
- Shutting down a project can be accomplished relatively easily
Disadvantages:
- Higher overhead because it creates more management positions
- Overall complexity
π Example: The matrix structure is widely used in many industries, including construction, healthcare, research, and defense.
Restructuring, Reengineering, and E-Engineering
Restructuring β also called downsizing, rightsizing, or delayering β involves reducing the size of the firm in terms of number of employees, number of divisions or units, and number of hierarchical levels in the firm's organizational structure. This reduction in size is intended to improve both efficiency and effectiveness. Restructuring is concerned primarily with shareholder well-being rather than employee well-being.
π Definition β Restructuring: Reducing the size of the firm in terms of employees, divisions or units, and hierarchical levels to improve efficiency and effectiveness, primarily concerned with shareholder well-being.
Reengineering β also called process management, process innovation, or process redesign β involves reconfiguring or redesigning work, jobs, and processes for the purpose of improving cost, quality, service, and speed. Reengineering does not usually affect the organizational structure or chart, nor does it imply job loss or employee layoffs.
π Definition β Reengineering: Reconfiguring or redesigning work, jobs, and processes to improve cost, quality, service, and speed, concerned more with employee and customer well-being than shareholder well-being.
Key Differences:
| Aspect | Restructuring | Reengineering |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Eliminating/establishing, shrinking/enlarging departments and divisions | Changing the way work is actually carried out |
| Impact on structure | Affects organizational structure or chart | Does not usually affect organizational structure or chart |
| Concern | Shareholder well-being | Employee and customer well-being |
| Job implications | Implies job loss or employee layoffs | Does not imply job loss or employee layoffs |
| Nature of decisions | Strategic (long-term, affecting all business functions) | Tactical (short-term, business function-specific) |
π Example: Restructuring might involve eliminating an entire division, while reengineering might involve redesigning the customer service process to reduce response time.
β Key Takeaways
The functional structure is simplest and cheapest but lacks flexibility and creates communication difficulties between areas, while the divisional structure offers clear accountability and higher morale but is costly and may create duplication. The SBU structure helps large multidivisional organizations manage diversity by grouping similar divisions under senior executives, though it adds management layers and expense. The matrix structure is the most complex design using dual authority flows but is valuable for projects in industries like construction and defense. Crucially, restructuring (downsizing for shareholder benefit) and reengineering (process redesign for customer and employee benefit) serve fundamentally different purposes and should not be confused when implementing strategy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four ways a divisional structure can be organized, and when is each type most appropriate?
- How does the SBU structure differ from a simple divisional structure, and what problem does it solve in large organizations?
- What makes the matrix structure the most complex organizational design, and what are its key advantages?
- What is the fundamental difference between restructuring and reengineering in terms of focus and impact on organizational structure?
- What are the main disadvantages of a functional structure, and why might an organization still choose to use it despite these limitations?