π Lecture 6 β Power and Politics
π Overview: This lecture examines the concepts of power and politics within organizations, explaining how managers use different types of power to influence behavior and achieve goals. It also explores the nature of conflict and political behavior, highlighting that while often viewed negatively, these elements can be harnessed for positive organizational outcomes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of power as personal characteristics enabling influence over others, and politics as the control and distribution of resources. It details four types of power used by managers: legitimate, reward/punish, expert, and referent. The lecture also discusses conflict as a natural outcome of human interaction, its positive and negative impacts, managerial reactions to politics, and concludes with Farrell and Peterson's three-dimensional typology for understanding political behavior.
π Lecture Summary
Concept of power and politics
Power is defined as personal characteristics by which one person can influence or dominate another person. In organizations, power is the ability of one person or department to influence other people or departments to bring about desired results. Without power, organizations cannot achieve their goals, because managers exert influence to force people to do things they want. Power is aimed in all directions in organizations β from top to bottom, sideways, and can be understood as the presence of an individual being felt. Power is synonymously defined with authority, but authority comes with the job one holds. The "Power and Politics School" views authority as only one of the available sources of organizational power.
Politics is about controlling resources (material, human, financial, information etc.). It is also about distribution of resources: who gets what, how, when and where (Harold Laswell, 1936). Politics is often understood as undesirable because it is perceived as "maneuvering" and "manipulation" by people.
π Definition β Power: personal characteristics by which one person can influence or dominate another person; in organizations, the ability of one person or department to influence others to bring about desired results.
π Definition β Politics: the control and distribution of resources β determining who gets what, how, when, and where.
π Example: A manager using their position to require an employee to complete a task demonstrates power. The same manager deciding which department receives the year-end bonus allocation is engaging in politics.
Types of Power
There are various types of power that managers use in organizations. These are:
- Legitimate Power
- Reward/Punish Power
- Expert Power
- Referent Power
Legitimate Power is the authority given by the organization to the formal management position a manager holds. For example: Power of DCO, Nazim, and Policeperson. These personnel have power because they hold certain positions.
Reward/Punish Power stems from the ability to bestow rewards which include benefits like food allowance, overtime cash allowance, and other fringe benefits. Example: Adults can reward or punish children; managers give cash awards to their subordinates for good performance.
Expert Power is the power possessed by an individual based on experience, or some skills and ability. Example: computer expert, specialist doctor.
Referent Power β Organizations are always finding ways of using the effective and suitable way of utilizing the experience and knowledge of reputable managers as far as employee referrals are concerned.
π Definition β Legitimate Power: authority given by the organization to the formal management position a manager holds.
π Definition β Reward/Punish Power: power that stems from the ability to bestow rewards or impose punishments.
π Definition β Expert Power: power possessed by an individual based on experience, skills, and ability.
π Definition β Referent Power: power based on using the experience and knowledge of reputable managers for employee referrals.
π Example: A police officer stopping a driver uses legitimate power (position). A supervisor giving a bonus to a top performer uses reward power. A senior software engineer debugging a complex code problem uses expert power. A respected manager whose employees follow them loyally even without formal authority uses referent power.
Conflict
Conflict is a natural outcome of the close interaction of people. It is defined as difference, disagreement, and dissension. When there is disagreement and dissension, people will have a viewpoint and suggestion that is different. In order to have their views prevail, people will try to find means by which give and take will occur. Therefore, individuals and groups will use power and political activity to handle their differences and manage conflict.
Conflict β as Positive and Negative Conflict can have positive or negative effects on the organization. The positive effect is when a manager agrees to some new viewpoints of the disagreeing group/individual. Conflict can be a positive force because it challenges the status quo, encourages new ideas and approaches, and leads to change.
However, too much conflict can be harmful to any organization because too much conflict can lead to deadlock and things may not move. Some degree of conflict always occurs in all human relationships.
π Definition β Conflict: difference, disagreement, and dissension arising from the close interaction of people.
π‘ Why this matters: Recognizing that conflict can be both positive (challenging the status quo, sparking innovation) and negative (causing deadlock) helps managers know when to allow healthy debate and when to intervene to prevent organizational paralysis.
Reactions of Managers
Most managers have a negative view toward politics and believe that politics will more often hurt than help an organization in achieving its goals. Politics is also seen as a negative element. But some kind of politics is always there in organization and if that is understood, managers can use it in a positive way. Political behaviour is common to practically all public or private organizations, and should be used positively by involving people in decision making.
Most managers think political behaviour occurs more often at upper rather than lower levels in organization. But political behaviour is common to people in organization, therefore, it occurs at all levels, but it is more at the top. Political behaviour arises in certain decision domains, such as structural change, but is absent from other decisions, such as handling employee grievances.
Organizational decision-making and problem-solving is also a political process. Organizational actors seek to satisfy not only organizational interests, but also their own wants and needs; driven by self-interest.
Three Dimensional Typology
For the purposes of understanding organizational political behaviour, Farrell and Peterson (1982) proposed a three-dimensional typology. The dimensions are:
- Where the political activity takes place β inside or outside the organization
- The direction of the attempted influence β vertically or laterally in the organization
- The legitimacy of the political action
The purpose of the three-dimensional typology is to identify if the political activity is within the organization or outside, where the influence of politics is, and whether the actions are legitimate. This helps in controlling and managing political behaviour in organizations.
π Three-Dimensional Typology (Farrell & Peterson, 1982): A framework analyzing political behavior based on: (1) location (inside/outside organization), (2) direction of influence (vertical/lateral), (3) legitimacy of action β Helps in controlling and managing political behavior in organizations.
β Key Takeaways
Power is the ability to influence others to achieve desired results and is essential for organizational goal attainment, while politics concerns the control and distribution of resources. Managers have four types of power at their disposal: legitimate, reward/punish, expert, and referent, each derived from different sources. Conflict is a natural consequence of human interaction and can be either positive (stimulating innovation and change) or negative (causing deadlock). Although most managers view politics negatively, political behavior is inevitable in all organizations and occurs at all levels, though more frequently at upper levels. Farrell and Peterson's three-dimensional typology helps identify where, in what direction, and how legitimately political activity occurs, enabling better management of organizational politics.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Define power and politics as taught in this lecture. How do they differ from authority?
- List and explain the four types of power that managers use in organizations, giving one example for each.
- What is conflict, and how can it have both positive and negative effects on an organization?
- Why do most managers view politics negatively, and how can political behavior be used positively?
- What are the three dimensions of Farrell and Peterson's typology of organizational political behavior, and what is its purpose?
π Lecture 7 β History of Public Administration β I
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Management Science School and traces the historical evolution of public administration in the Indian sub-continent, from the Indus Valley Civilization through the Moghul and British periods. Understanding these roots is essential because Pakistanβs current administrative systems, structures, and procedures are directly shaped by these historical layers, particularly the British colonial legacy.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the Management Science School, explaining its origins in World War II operations research and its application of mathematics, statistics, and economic models to organizational problems. It then covers the traditional functions of government (law and order, tax collection, defence, and maintenance of mint). The core historical content examines administrative practices in three major periods: the Indus Valley Civilization (focusing on Mohenjodaro and Harrapa), the Moghul Period (especially under Sher Shah Suri and Akbar), and the British Period (from the East India Company to the Regulating Act 1773 and the beginning of direct rule).
π Lecture Summary
The Management Science School
At the beginning of World War II, Great Britain formed a team of mathematicians, physicists, and other scientists to solve complex warfare problems, achieving technological breakthroughs. After the war, the applicability of Operations Research (OR) to industry became clear. Over time, ORβthe use of mathematics and statisticsβcame to be called the management science. It is the application of mathematics, statistics, and economic models to organizational problems, and it involves determining relationships between two or more variables. For example, relationships like age and learning, income and expenditure, or training and efficiency.
Public Administration in the Sub-Continent
Todayβs administrative systems and procedures in Pakistan have their roots particularly in the British period. Two hundred years of British rule still leave vestiges and remnants on the structure, rules, procedures, and organizational behaviours. However, the British changed the structure only to the extent of their goals in the sub-continent; they retained the structure at the district level which they inherited from the Moghuls. The sub-continent is a bedrock of many civilizations, as it stood at the crossroads of Central Asia, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia by sea, and was influenced by Greeks, Arabs, and Central Asians. Thus, the administrative process in Pakistan is the result of years of assimilation of cultural and administrative practices from the Indus Valley Civilization, Aryans, Greeks, Persians, Mauryas, Moghuls, and British.
Traditional Functions of Government
Before discussing the historical administrative structures, it is essential to understand the traditional functions of government:
- Maintain law and order (peace and security): For any government to rule, it must maintain internal peace and security. Without peace and security, the government cannot perform its other functions.
- Tax collection: This is a second but important function. Taxes are collected to provide for defence against external threats and to provide for welfare and public goods like roads.
- Defence: The government must protect the country from external threats and maintain an army.
- Maintenance of mint: Governments have to supply currency and coins. It is the governmentβs responsibility to maintain mints and print notes.
Indus Valley Civilization
In the sub-continent, two ancient civilizations, Mohenjodaro and Harrapa, were very developed cities between 3250β2750 BC. The ruins indicate that rulers maintained a good sewage and water supply system. The city had a granary, and bricks were used in house construction. Gordon Childe writes that the remains of well-planned streets and a municipal system of drains, regularly cleaned, reflect the vigilance of a regular municipal government, whose authority was strong enough to secure observance of town planning bye-laws. Granaries at Harrapa were constructed in a planned and coordinated manner, as grain was a source of wealth and collected as taxes.
The Maurya Empire in the early 4th century BC had government officials who looked after agricultural improvement, measured land, and inspected irrigation systems. During this period, government employees were divided into three categories:
- District Officials: Responsible for irrigation, land measurement, hunting, agriculture, roads, and distance stones.
- Military Officials: The army was maintained to defend the borders and was well looked after.
- Capital Management: There were six boards, each managing: (i) supervision of factories, (ii) care of foreigners, (iii) births and deaths, (iv) trade and commerce, (v) inspection of manufactured articles, and (vi) collection of sales tax (taken from Kautilya, Arthasastra, Book II, Ch. XXXVI).
π Definition β Arthasastra: One of the oldest books on Public Administration, written by Kautilya during the Maurya period. It was written for officials responsible for running the government, so they could understand their duties and responsibilities.
Moghul Period
The Moghul administrative system has clear imprints on present-day public management in Pakistan. The Moghul period lasted over two centuries (16thβ18th), during which many rulers, including Sher Shah Suri and Akbar, reigned. Though Suri was not a Moghul ruler, his administrative system was adopted by succeeding rulers. Suri developed a centralized system of administration, divided the empire into 47 divisions, with several sub-divisions under each division. He organized a survey of land under cultivation, an effective tax system, a criminal justice system, and a road network for defence and postal service. He constructed the present Grand Trunk (GT) Road, which runs from Peshawar to Calcutta. He established gardens and hospitals and promoted public welfare, guided by the principle that βno one should be deprived of state benefaction and no one should have superfluity of the sameβ.
Many Moghul rulers followed Sher Shah Suri, but Akbar's period is the longest and saw many developments. Akbar ruled for nearly 50 years and developed an administrative system mainly borrowed from Sher Shah Suri. The empire was divided into provinces, divisions, districts, and villagesβterms used even now. The village was the lowest unit and was governed by a headman, an accountant, and a watchman. The British did not change this system, and it existed up to the partition of the sub-continent and later. During Akbar's time, human resource management was practiced. A career civil service system with a hierarchical structure existed, and entry to the civil service was not restricted based on religion or geographic origin. Akbar further improved the system:
- Revenue collection system: Based on the survey and classification of soil. Land was classified as agricultural and non-agricultural, and within agriculture, the land was graded. State tax was then fixed and charged according to the type of soil.
- Judicial system: Judicial officers were appointed at the district, town, and village levels.
- Law enforcement: A Kotwal (chief police officer) with civil authority was appointed in important towns. In rural areas, a faujdar (army chief) was appointed to control crime.
After Akbar, for over a hundred years, no real administrative system could develop, mainly because the disarray of the empire began with Jahangir, who first allowed the East India Company to set up a factory in 1642 at Balasore for medical service provided by the companyβs surgeon on the ship.
British Period
The beginning of British rule in the sub-continent started with the East India Company, a trading company with a Board of Governors. It was granted a charter on 31 December 1600 by the British Parliament to trade freely into and from the East Indies. The Company gradually expanded its operations. In 1609, the authority to trade was further extended. In 1661, the Company was empowered to declare war on and have peace with any ruler. The Regulating Act 1773 was passed by the British Parliament, granting the British government powers to regulate the affairs of the Company in India. At this point, the British government was not ruling India directly; all matters and powers were given to the Company to rule. In 1757, the victory at Plassey paved the way for British rule. There were innumerable battles and conflicts before the British governmentβs direct rule, which really started after 1857 (the War of Independence).
π Definition β East India Company: A company (like a modern multinational) that came to trade goods, especially spices, but in the process of trade, they found other goods like cotton.
β Key Takeaways
The Management Science School emerged from WWII operations research and applies mathematical, statistical, and economic models to solve organizational problems. The traditional functions of any government are to maintain law and order, collect taxes, provide defence, and maintain a mint. Pakistan's administrative system is a layered legacy, beginning with the well-planned municipal governance of the Indus Valley Civilization and the detailed bureaucratic structures described in Kautilya's Arthasastra. The Moghul period, especially under Sher Shah Suri and Akbar, established the core territorial divisions (provinces, districts, villages), a classification-based revenue system, and a structured civil service that the British largely retained and built upon. The British period, initiated by the East India Company and formalized by acts like the Regulating Act of 1773, ultimately laid the foundation for the modern administrative state in the sub-continent.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four traditional functions of government as explained in this lecture?
- Name two key features of urban planning found in the Indus Valley Civilization (Mohenjodaro and Harrapa) that indicate a strong municipal government.
- Who was Sher Shah Suri, and what were three major administrative contributions he made that were later adopted by the Moghuls?
- How did Akbar improve the revenue collection system, and what was the lowest administrative unit in his empire?
- What was the Regulating Act of 1773, and how did it change the relationship between the British government and the East India Company?
π Lecture 08 β History of Public Administration β II
π Overview: This lecture covers the history of public administration in the subcontinent during the British period, starting from the 1857 War of Independence. It explains the constitutional changes, the evolution of the civil service, and the administrative systems left by the British, as well as the challenges Pakistan faced at independence.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the 1857 War of Independence as a turning point, leading to the Government of India Act 1858 and direct British rule. It then discusses the structure of the civil service under the East India Company, including the covenanted and un-covenanted services, and the Atchison Commission's recommendations. The training of civil servants at East India College, key acts like the Indian Civil Service Act 1861 and Government of India Act 1935, and British contributions to law, finance, police, and education are covered. Finally, it examines the administrative challenges Pakistan faced at independence, including dearth of trained labor, refugees, inadequate infrastructure, and constitution-making.
π Lecture Summary
History of Public Administration during British Period
The 1857 War of Independence was a turning point. The British had tried to divide the two religions and had become lax in administration, not expecting locals to rise up. After the war, the British government in London stepped in to rule directly, taking control from the East India Company. In 1858, the Government of India Act 1858 was passed. The Secretary of State now exercised powers previously given to the Company, including the power to suppress all local uprisings and use force. A Council of 15 members was created to conduct all business relating to the Government of India in the UK. This Act was a comprehensive written constitution for the subcontinent. It was unitary, meaning provincial governments derived their powers by devolution from the central government under the control of the Governor General. The ultimate control was in London, with the Secretary of State answerable to the British Parliament.
π‘ Why this matters: This established a highly centralized administrative system where all major decisions were made in London, setting the pattern for colonial administration.
Structure of Civil Service
The initial structure was laid by the East India Company (EIC). Employees were divided into covenanted (higher employees) and un-covenanted (lower level). Covenanted civil servants signed an agreement with the Company regarding terms and conditions. Un-covenanted employees did not sign any agreement and could be removed anytime without benefits.
The Atchison Commission (1886-87) recommended abolishing this distinction and establishing an Imperial Civil Service, later renamed the Indian Civil Service (ICS). It also recommended creating a Provincial Civil Service. The ICS was organized on the principle that it would be characterized by integrity and ability, developing high standards of honesty and conduct.
π Definition β Covenanted Service: Higher-level civil servants who signed a formal agreement with the East India Company regarding their terms and conditions of service.
π Definition β Un-covenanted Service: Lower-level employees who did not sign any agreement and could be removed at any time without benefits.
Training and Salaries
To train men for the ICS, the East India College was established in 1806 at Haileybury, England. Initially, entry was open only to natural-born British. The Government of India Act 1853 allowed young men from the subcontinent to compete for entry, irrespective of religion, place of birth, descent, color, or race. The College offered a two-year residential course taught by eminent scholars, instilling a sense of pride. Civil servants were paid salaries that allowed a proper standard of living according to their responsibilities, so they would not resort to unfair means of earning.
Key Acts and Contributions
The Indian Civil Service Act 1861 freed the service from the rule of seniority; seniority was no longer the only criteria for promotion. It allowed appointment from outside with some safeguards. A Public Service Commission was established in 1926 as a recruiting agency. The Government of India Act 1935 provided security of tenure: no officer could be dismissed until heard in his defense and had the right to appeal up to the Secretary of State.
The British left a notable administrative heritage in law, finance, education, railways, public works, and public health. The Police Act 1861 introduced a uniform police system with a Superintendent of Police in each district, supported by Deputy Superintendents and inspectors. In public financial management, land revenue collection was greatly improved, as it provided 15% of total revenue. The British reconstituted revenue committees as Boards of Control over districts administered by collectors. Treasury functions were reorganized under an Auditor General, and income tax was introduced. Under the Act of 1935, the federal budget was presented to the legislature showing separate estimates for votable and non-votable expenditure. The British codified the law and expanded the court system with three levels: small courts, district/city courts, and provincial courts. The Charter of 1833 provided for an Indian Law Commission (1833) which led to the first Indian Penal Code. The Indian Universities Act 1904 improved education by employing better teachers, reducing cramming, and increasing college inspection. The British gave institutions like post and telegraph, railways, irrigation systems, and the public works department.
π‘ Why this matters: These administrative structures and institutions formed the foundation of Pakistan's public administration system at independence.
Problems of Public Administration at Independence
Pakistan came into existence under conditions that caused strain. At independence, professional non-Muslims outnumbered Muslims, and there was a large exodus of non-Muslims from areas forming Pakistan. Non-Muslims were more educated and held more important positions. The new country faced these problems:
- Dearth of trained labor: There was a grave vacuum of trained civil servants, economists, doctors, and engineers. At independence, there were only around 100 civil servants.
- Refugees: Millions of displaced people moved between Pakistan and India.
- Inadequate physical infrastructure: The part that became Pakistan had no industry, and roads were inadequate.
- Constitution making: Pakistan faced a leadership crisis after the death of Quaid-i-Azam. This shelved the constitution-making process until 1973, when Pakistan finally got its constitution.
β Key Takeaways
The 1857 War of Independence led to direct British rule via the Government of India Act 1858, creating a centralized, unitary system controlled from London. The civil service evolved from covenanted/un-covenanted divisions under the East India Company to the Indian Civil Service (ICS), established by the Atchison Commission. Key British contributions included a uniform police system, a codified legal system with an Indian Penal Code, a structured financial system with an Auditor General, and improvements in education. At independence, Pakistan faced severe administrative challenges including a dearth of trained civil servants, a massive refugee crisis, inadequate infrastructure, and a prolonged constitution-making process that was not completed until 1973.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the main constitutional change brought by the Government of India Act 1858 after the War of Independence?
- What was the difference between covenanted and un-covenanted civil servants under the East India Company?
- What did the Atchison Commission (1886-87) recommend regarding the civil service structure?
- Name three key British administrative contributions in the areas of law, police, and finance in the subcontinent.
- List four major problems Pakistan's public administration faced at the time of independence.
π Lecture 9 β Civil Service
π Overview: This lecture defines civil service and its structure, particularly in the context of Pakistan at independence. It explains the functions of modern government and details the inherited colonial service structure, including the All-Pakistan Services and Central Services. Understanding this foundation is critical for analyzing subsequent administrative reforms.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining civil service and the methods of recruiting public servants at federal and provincial levels. It then outlines the functions performed by government, both traditional and modern, explaining why these functions have increased. The core of the lecture is a detailed breakdown of the civil service structure inherited by Pakistan at independence, specifically the All-Pakistan Services (CSP and PSP) and the Central Services (including 13 distinct services).
π Lecture Summary
What is Civil Service?
The term "civil service" is defined in the Civil Servant Act 1973, but also has a general meaning. "Civil" means "public," referring to the citizens of a country. By this connotation, civil servants are a group of people who serve the public, differentiating civil service from military service. Words like Public, Civil, and Government are used interchangeably. All officers and officials working in government organizations are public servants because they draw their salaries from the public exchequer.
Recruitment of Public Servants
The recruitment of civil servants takes place by two methods:
- Public Service Commissions (Federal & Provincial) β constitutionally responsible for recruiting officers of Grade 15 and above.
- Autonomous organizations β recruit people directly through their own tests and interviews.
The structure of Federal and Provincial Government is as follows:
- Federal Government: Ministries β Divisions β Attached Departments β Autonomous Bodies β Public Enterprises
- Provincial Government: Departments β Directorates β Autonomous Bodies (e.g., Development Authorities) β District/Tehsil Office
At the federal level, the apex organization is a ministry (e.g., Ministry of Health and Population), headed by a Minister. Each ministry may have two or more divisions, usually located in Islamabad. Below a division is an attached department, which is under the administrative control of that division. Autonomous bodies are more independent because they have their own Board of Governors that makes policy decisions.
What are the Functions Performed by the Government?
The government performs these traditional functions:
- Maintains Peace
- Provides Defence
- Collects Revenues
- Maintains Currency
It performs these functions through its representatives: public servants or civil servants, who are paid a salary from the government treasury (exchequer).
In addition to traditional functions, modern governments perform many additional functions:
- Provides Utilities (electricity, telephone, gas)
- Maintains Government Accounts
- Maintains Foreign Relations
- Maintains Cantonments
- Regulates, distributes, and allocates goods and services in society.
The functions of today's government have increased because of:
- Population that is provided services has increased manifold, and the nature of problems (social, economic, political, global) has become complex.
- The territory of the government has increased in size.
- Technological improvement and advancement.
- Because of technological improvement, the nature of specialization/division of labour has changed and become more complex.
Therefore, to perform new functions, governments changed their structure and added more functions.
Structure at the Time of Independence
At the time of independence, Pakistan inherited the civil service structure laid out by the East India Company and subsequently modified by the British government. The structure existing in the pre-partition sub-continent was adopted with little modifications. Two categories of services were maintained:
- All-Pakistan Services
- Central Services
1. The All Pakistan Services
The All Pakistan Service was a descendant of the All-India Services. It comprised the Civil Service of Pakistan (CSP) and the Police Service of Pakistan (PSP). Officers of these services served under both central and provincial governments. When serving under a Provincial Government, they were controlled by that government, but the basic control remained with the centre.
-
Civil Services of Pakistan (CSP): The CSP was the descendant of the Indian Civil Service (ICS) in India. At independence, it consisted of:
- Former ICS officers
- Officers who served in World War 2
- Finance service officers
- Officers selected by Competitive Examination held in 1949 & 1950
-
Police Service of Pakistan (PSP): The PSP was the same as the Indian Police Service (IPS) in the sub-continent. At partition, it consisted of officers who opted for Pakistan. Posts held by PSP officers included Inspectors-General, Superintendents, Deputy Superintendents, and Assistant Superintendents. Most PSP officers served under Provincial Governments.
2. Central Services
Like the Central Services before partition, the Central Services in Pakistan were controlled by the Central government. Before the Administrative Reforms (1973), there were 13 Central Services:
i. Pakistan Foreign Services (PFS): PFS officers work in diplomatic missions abroad. In the beginning, specialized duties were also performed by PFS officers, but separate services were later constituted for specialized jobs in foreign missions.
ii. Accounts Services: These included the Pakistan Audit and Accounts Service (PAAS), Pakistan Military Accounts Service (PMAS), and Pakistan Railway Accounts Service (PRAS). Officers held posts pertaining to finance and accounts, such as financial advisors, accountant-general, and auditors-general.
iii. Pakistan Customs and Excise Services (PCES): Formally formed in 1959, it was a combination of Sea Customs Service and Central Land Customs and Excise Services. Posts included Assistant Collector, Deputy Collector, and corresponding posts in the CBR.
iv. Pakistan Taxation Service: It consisted of junior officers promoted from provincial and class II services on an ad-hoc basis. In 1957, it was upgraded to class I status. It held posts of commissioner of income tax, deputy commissioner of income tax, and income tax officer.
v. Pakistan Military & Land Cantonment Service: Officers were appointed as Cantonment Executive Officers, in charge of maintenance and control of lands within cantonment areas and local governments.
vi. Pakistan Postal Service: It was constituted by combining Pakistan Postal Service, Telegraph Traffic Service, and Telegraph Engineering Service. In 1965, the Telegraph Service was separated.
vii. Trade Service of Pakistan: Created to meet requirements in commercial fields in Pakistan and in missions abroad. This cadre was formally constituted in 1970.
viii. Information Service of Pakistan (ISP): Formed in 1963 for posts requiring journalistic qualifications for appointments in Pakistan and in foreign missions.
ix. Economic Pool: Constituted in 1950, its officers were drawn from CSP and accounts/finance services. It was not made a regularly constituted service.
The other services were: x. Central Secretariat Services xi. General Administrative Service
Conclusions
The service structure of the colonial period was adopted. The political situation of the country did not permit a review of the structure. The inherited structure was more biased towards maintaining law and order and was not geared towards the development of the new country.
β Key Takeaways
The civil service is a body of public servants who are distinct from the military and are recruited either through Public Service Commissions or by autonomous bodies. Modern governments perform a wide range of functions beyond traditional law and order, driven by population growth, territorial expansion, and technological change. At independence, Pakistan inherited a colonial civil service structure consisting of the All-Pakistan Services (CSP and PSP) and 13 Central Services, which were biased toward maintaining law and order rather than development. This structure remained largely un-reformed until the Administrative Reforms of 1973 due to the political situation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two methods of recruiting civil servants in Pakistan?
- List four traditional functions of government and four additional functions of modern governments.
- What were the two main services that comprised the All-Pakistan Services?
- Which institution was the CSP a descendant of?
- Name three of the 13 Central Services that existed before the 1973 Administrative Reforms.
π Lecture 10 β Civil Service Reforms
π Overview: This lecture examines the historical evolution of civil service reforms in Pakistan, focusing on key expert reports and committees that shaped the current administrative structure. It addresses the persistent tension between generalist and specialist officers, the need for merit-based recruitment, and the importance of training in building a professional civil service.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the major reform efforts in Pakistan's civil service, beginning with the Egger Report (1953) and Gladieux Report (1955), followed by the Pay and Service Commission (1962), Working Group (1969), and Administrative Reforms Committee (1972). It details the implementation of these reforms, including the unified grading system and occupational groups, before discussing the current structure of civil service, recruitment procedures, appointing authorities, and training institutions.
π Lecture Summary
Reforms of the Civil Service
Soon after independence, the government invited foreign experts to review the administrative system. The two most famous reports were the Egger Report (1953) and the Gladieux Report (1955).
In 1953, Rowland Egger of USA made the following observations about Pakistan's civil service:
- It is oriented towards an academic notion of intelligence and ability and is obsessed with the interests of those already in service.
- Recruitment standards are out-dated and techniques are far removed from currently accepted good practices.
- The selection system is self-perpetuating and tends to repeat its own type, as though the civil service drew most of its inspiration from looking in the mirror.
- Members of the civil service are supposed to be like a box of interchangeable parts in an assembly line.
Egger recommended: a. Unification of all employees into a single Civil Service of Pakistan with internal grouping (e.g., Administration, Foreign Service, Accounts). b. Standardized pay scales based on comprehensive job analysis. c. The generalists should not dominate other services. d. There is a need for specialization in the civil service.
In 1955, Mr. Bernard Gladieux (also from USA) was engaged as a consultant. He was strongly critical of the superiority of the generalists over the specialists. He argued that technical and professional civil servants also possessed administrative skills and should be encouraged to hold higher positions.
In 1955, the First Five Year Plan of Pakistan also noted the dominance of the generalist cadre. It recommended that non-technical Central Superior Services be converted into branches of a combined civil service, all having identical pay scales, promotion prospects, and leave.
Pay and Service Commission (1962)
The Pay and Service Commission (1962) criticized the reservation of senior posts for the CSP (Civil Service of Pakistan), especially at the centre. This report recommended that the entire public service be built up in seven tiers of groups:
- Group F: 4 Grades β Unskilled workers
- Group E: 4 Grades β Semi-skilled workers
- Group D: 5 Grades β Skilled workers and rank-and-file staff
- Group C: 5 Grades β Lower inspectional and middle supervisory staff
- Group B: 4 Grades β Basic officer class
- Group A: 4 Grades β Managerial class, District level up to Divisional level
- PAS (Pakistan Administrative Service): 4 Grades β Top directly and higher administrative posts
Working Group (1969)
A Working Group, comprised of both CSP and non-CSP officers, was appointed to study the structure of the civil service. Its recommendations included:
- All branches of civil service should have the same status, though they should retain their individuality.
- For ex-cadre positions, the same criteria should be used as for cadre services.
- There should be no difference in pay scales for provincial and central civil servants.
π Definition β Cadre post: a post or position that belongs to one of the occupational groups. π Definition β Ex-cadre post: a post that does not belong to the occupational groups but is a managerial post.
Administrative Reforms Committee (1972)
This committee was appointed to study all aspects of the civil service and made the following recommendations:
- All services and cadres should be merged into a unified graded structure with equality of opportunity for all, based on the required professional and specialized competence necessary for the job.
- All βclassesβ among government servants would be abolished and replaced by a unified graded structure: a peon at the bottom and a Secretary at the top.
- The correct grading of each post will be determined by job evaluation.
- There should be provision for lateral entry of talented individuals from the private sector in fields such as banking and insurance.
Implementation of the Reforms
The measures taken to implement the reforms included:
- The head of each Ministry was a Secretary in Grade 22, the Additional Secretary in Grade 21, with lower grades for junior executives.
- About 600 pay scales were reduced to 22 grades, applicable to all government organizations and professions.
- Grade 1 was the lowest and Grade 23 was the highest (Secretary General, with only 2-3 positions).
- Technical posts were integrated into the unified system.
To emphasize professionalism, 15 Occupational Groups were formed:
- District Management Group
- Police Group
- Income Tax Group
- Customs and Excise Group
- Accounts Group
- Information Group
- Postal Group
- Commerce Group
- Foreign Affairs Group
- Office Management Group
- Military Land and Cantonment Group
- Railways Group
- Secretariat Group
- Tribal Areas Group
- Economists and Planners Group
Additionally:
- The age limit for competitive examination was raised from 28 to 30 years.
- Promotion was made purely on the basis of merit and performance.
- The concept of lateral entry was introduced.
- Common training was given to all officers at the Academy for Administrative Training in Lahore.
- Rules and regulations were framed for implementation.
The Civil Service Today
The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan 1973 states:
βExecutive Authority of federation is exercised by the Government in the name of President. The PM is the Chief Executive of the Federation and the Federal Cabinet exercises its authority to him.β
According to the 4th schedule, there is a Federal list and a Concurrent list of areas/responsibility. The concurrent list gives responsibilities to both Federal and Provincial governments.
Categories of the Civil Service
Services and posts under the government of Pakistan can be classified into 3 categories:
- Generalist Services: Recruitment is based on the general education of the candidate.
- Semi-Technical Specialized Services: Recruitment is based on advanced academic attainment at university without formal professional training.
- Purely Technical Services: Recruitment is on technical qualifications (e.g., doctors, engineers).
π Definition β Generalist: a non-technical position. A person who is a generalist can be posted anywhere in government on positions that do not require special technical expertise.
Civil Service Recruitment in Pakistan
The criteria for recruitment to the civil service are:
- Based on pure merit.
- All posts must be advertised before selection.
- Assessment is based on selection boards and selection committees.
- Due representation is given to every province.
Appointing Authority
The appointing authority for various grades is:
- Grade 20 and Above: President
- Grade 17 to 19: Establishment
- Grade 3 to 16: Ministry
- Grade 1 and 2: Head Office
Main Recruiting Agencies
The main recruiting agencies are:
- Federal Public Service Commission (FPSC) at the federal level
- Provincial Public Service Commission at the provincial level
- Departmental Selection/Promotion Committees
Training
Training of civil servants is divided into:
- Pre-Service Training: Given before entry to service, after selection by FPSC.
- In-Service Training: Given during the service to currently serving civil servants.
The major training institutions are:
- National Institute of Public Administration
- Pakistan Academy for Rural Development
- Pakistan Administrative Staff College
π Definition β Reforms: improvement in the civil service structure according to the changing social, political, and economic needs.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture traces a 20-year struggle to break the dominance of the generalist CSP cadre over specialists, culminating in the 1972 reforms that abolished class distinctions, unified pay scales into 22 grades, and created 15 occupational groups. The core tension between generalists and specialists was identified by every major reform commission, from Egger (1953) to the Administrative Reforms Committee (1972). Students must remember the three civil service categories (Generalist, Semi-Technical, Technical), the graded pay structure (Grades 1β23), and the distinction between cadre and ex-cadre posts. The three types of training (pre-service, in-service) and the main recruiting agencies (FPSC, Provincial PSCs) are also essential for understanding Pakistan's current civil service structure.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were the four main observations made by Rowland Egger in 1953 about Pakistan's civil service?
- Explain the seven-tier group structure recommended by the Pay and Service Commission (1962), from Group F to PAS.
- What were the three key recommendations of the Administrative Reforms Committee (1972) regarding the structure of the civil service?
- Describe the unified grading system implemented after the 1972 reforms: how many grades were created, what were the highest and lowest, and what was the highest grade for a Secretary?
- What are the three categories of civil service in Pakistan, and how is recruitment conducted for each?