π Lecture 01 β Introduction
π Overview: This introductory lecture establishes the foundation for the course on Public Administration by defining its meaning, tracing its historical practice, and explaining its emergence as a formal academic discipline. It connects the study of public administration to the structure of government, democratic values, and core managerial concepts essential for understanding how public organizations function.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the meaning and definitions of public administration, its historical practice from ancient civilizations to modern discipline, reasons for its emergence as a subject, key definitions from multiple scholars, the institutions of state (legislature, judiciary, executive), the concept of government under Pakistan's 1973 Constitution, democracy and democratic values (individualism, equality, liberty), and foundational concepts including organization, management, process, efficiency, government, state, and democracy.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction: definitions, concepts & setting
This lecture introduces students to the course on Public Administration, which has seven core objectives: understanding the concept of public administration/management/organization, its evolution and importance, the role of government, the role and core functions of a public manager, the structure of government/organizations, skills required by public managers, and the changing role of government. The course is important for every citizen to understand government functioning, regardless of their profession.
The Meaning
The word 'administration' is derived from Latin words 'ad' = to and 'ministiare' = serve, while 'Public' means people or citizens. Thus, administration means to execute the policy of government to serve public. Management is defined as cooperative human endeavour to achieve given goals. Traditionally, management is defined as POSDCORB which stands for Planning, Organizing, Staffing, Directing, Coordination, Reporting, Budgeting. In general, administration and management are used interchangeably.
π Definition β Administration: To execute the policy of government to serve public. π Definition β Management: Cooperative human endeavour to achieve given goals. π Definition β POSDCORB: Planning, Organizing, Staffing, Directing, Coordination, Reporting, Budgeting.
Public Administration
Public administration as a practice is as old as human civilization. When humans started living in society in an organized way, the practice of administration began through cooperative living. The construction of Egyptian Pyramids (1491 BC) is an example of practice of administration, involving cooperative effort of thousands of people. In Pakistan, Mohenjodaro and Harrapa civilizations are magnificent examples of practice of administration, with well-planned roads, granary, wells, and protective walls around the city.
However, Public Administration as a discipline to be taught in formal educational institutions started after World War I (1914) in USA and then in Europe. The emergence was due to the changing role of government. The Great Depression in USA and Europe brought large scale unemployment, low wages, and falling demand for goods. It was felt that government should invest to provide jobs, thus the role of government was seen as prime mover in economy.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that public administration existed as practice long before it became a formal academic subject helps students appreciate that management principles are rooted in real human cooperation, not just theoretical frameworks.
Why Public Administration Received Impetus as A Subject?
Following were the reasons for the emergence of public administration as a subject:
- Expanding welfare role (distributive) of the government
- The emergence of private sector and regulatory role of government
- The need for increased efficiency in the Organization
- Development of Science and Technology
- Better management of public matters through training in USA
Definition of Public Administration
Several definitions help comprehend the concept:
- "Public administration.... is the action part of government, the means by which the purposes and goals of government are realized."
- "Public administration as a field is mainly concerned with the means for implementing political values."
- "The process of public administration consists of the actions involved in effecting the intent or desire of a government. It is thus the continuously active, 'business' part of government, concerned with carrying out the law, as made by legislative bodies (or other authoritative agents) and interpreted by the courts, through the processes of organization and management."
- It is a cooperative group effort in a public setting
- It covers all the three branches β executive, legislative, and judicial β and their interrelationships
Two things definitely emerge from these definitions:
- The study of public administration overlaps a number of other disciplines, including political science, sociology, economics, psychology, and business administration.
- Public administration is the use of managerial, political, and legal theories and processes to fulfill the goals of government (welfare of public).
Institutions of State
The diagram shows that citizens of any country are users of services and providers of services. The institutions of state are as follows:
- Legislature: Parliament (National and Provincial Assemblies) makes laws for the organization
- Judiciary: (Supreme Court & Provincial Courts - and Session Courts) interpret laws
- Executive: (National, Provincial) implements laws
The Ministries, Division, Departments/Directorates are the organizations that function under the executive to implement law. For example, the police department has the responsibility to maintain peace & order.
Government
Government is the process of governing. It is the use of power derived from the law that is made/approved by the legislature. It is means, methods, manner, or system of governing society and organization. The government of Islamic Republic of Pakistan derives its systems and methods from the Constitution (1973). Article 90-99 of the Constitution gives provision for Rules of Business. The Rules of Business 1973 provide the roles, responsibilities and function of government organizations (ministries, departments etc).
π Definition β Government: The process of governing; the use of power derived from the law made/approved by the legislature.
What is Democracy
Pakistan is a parliamentary Democracy. The word democracy is a Greek word where "demos" means people and "Krates" means authority.
Values of Democracy
Democracies have certain values:
- Individualism: The dignity and integrity of individual is of supreme importance. Achieving the fullest potential of each individual is the best measure of the success of political system and government.
- Equality: All normal individuals are equal in their talents but also each individual has an equal claim to life, liberty and the pursuit to happiness.
- Liberty: Citizens should have the right to the maximum opportunity to select own purpose in life and choose means to accomplish these. The citizen should be facilitated rather than hindered in their pursuit to a meaningful life.
Concepts
The students must understand the following concepts:
- Organization: The structure and framework created to perform certain functions to achieve goals.
- Management: Cooperative human effort to achieve goals.
- Process: A systematic mechanism to complete an activity.
- Efficiency: Efficiency = Output/Input. Efficiency relates to maximization of goals. Example: 10 input β output = 2 = efficient (2/10); 10 input β 6 output = 1.66 = less efficient (6/10).
- Government: The process of governing; it comprises organization, system, rules etc.
- State: As State has territorial jurisdiction, it has people and institutions.
- Democracy: A form of government in which people has authority and right to elect their representative.
- Democratic values: Life, liberty & individualism.
π Definition β Efficiency: Output/Input; relates to maximization of goals. π Formula: Efficiency = Output Γ· Input β A higher ratio indicates greater goal achievement per unit of input. π Example: Input 10 β Output 2 = 2/10 = 0.2 (efficient). Input 10 β Output 6 = 6/10 = 0.6 (less efficient).
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that public administration is both an ancient practice and a modern academic discipline that emerged after World War I due to government's expanding welfare role. The core definition positions public administration as the "action part of government" implementing political values through managerial, legal, and political processes. Students must understand the three branches of state (legislature, judiciary, executive) and how Pakistan's 1973 Constitution provides the framework for government through Articles 90-99 and Rules of Business. Democratic values of individualism, equality, and liberty form the philosophical foundation for public administration in a parliamentary democracy like Pakistan. Finally, foundational concepts of organization, management, process, and efficiency (measured as output/input) provide the analytical tools for understanding public sector functioning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the etymological meaning of the word "administration" and what does POSDCORB stand for?
- Why did Public Administration emerge as a formal academic discipline after World War I, particularly in the USA?
- List and explain the three institutions of state and their respective functions in Pakistan's governing system.
- What are the three core democratic values, and how does each relate to the role of government?
- What is the formula for efficiency, and how would you interpret a situation where input is 8 and output is 4?
π Lecture 2 β EVOLUTION OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between public administration, democracy, and citizens' constitutional rights in Pakistan. It then traces the historical evolution of public administration as a field of study, focusing primarily on the Classical School and its key contributors who laid the foundation for modern administrative theory and practice.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by connecting public administration to democratic values and citizens' rights, listing fundamental rights from Pakistan's 1973 Constitution. It then presents a diagram of factors affecting public agencies (international, economic, social, political systems). Next, it introduces the six schools in the evolution of public administration, but focuses entirely on the Classical School and its main contributors: Woodrow Wilson, Leonard D. White, W.F. Willoughby, Frederick Winslow Taylor (including his shovelling experiment), Henry L. Gantt, Frank and Lillian Gilbreth, Max Weber, and Henri Fayol. Key concepts like scientific management, "one best way," and "value free" administration are also defined.
π Lecture Summary
Relationship between public administration, democracy and rights (Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan 1973)
Public administration is deeply connected to democratic values and citizens' rights. People often do not know their rights or government procedures, which affects how they interact with public agencies. The 1973 Constitution contains Fundamental Rights and Principles of Policies that give basic rights to citizens. These include: security of persons; safeguards as to arrest and detention; prohibition of slavery and forced labor; inviolability of dignity of man and privacy of home; freedom of movement, assembly, association, trade/business/profession, speech and press; freedom to profess religion and manage religious institutions; safeguard against taxation for other religions; safeguard regarding religious instruction in schools; equality of citizens before law and equal protection of law (no discrimination on sex alone, but special provisions for women and children allowed); and non-discrimination in access to public places.
π‘ Why this matters: Democracy functions differently in each country's political tradition, and this directly influences how public organizations work. The lecture illustrates this with a diagram showing public administration at the center, surrounded by international, economic, social, and political systems β all influencing it. Thus, public administration exists and functions under these influences.
π Definition β Fundamental Rights: Basic rights guaranteed to citizens by the constitution, which government agencies must respect and uphold.
Evolution of Public Administration
Public administration is about management of public programmes. Although its practice is ancient (e.g., Indus Valley civilization's planned cities), as a subject it is new. The study of public administration is divided into these Schools:
- The Classical School
- Human Relations School
- Behavioural School
- System School
- Management Science School
- Power and Politics School
The growth of public administration relates to the growth of markets and market imperfection. For example, a manufacturer emitting smoke pollutes the environment without caring β this is a market failure. Governments intervene to correct such imperfections, e.g., by taxing the polluter. Similarly, if private schools charge high fees, the government must open affordable schools. Thus, government institutions must be effective to control market imperfections.
π Definition β Market Imperfection: A situation where markets fail to account for negative externalities (e.g., pollution) or fail to provide services equitably, requiring government intervention.
Classical School
This school focuses on increasing organizational efficiency through standards and scientific management. Its main contributors are: Woodrow Wilson, Leonard D. White, W.F. Willoughby, Fredrick Winslow Taylor, Henry L. Gantt, Frank and Lillian Gilbreth, Max Weber, and Henri Fayol.
Woodrow Wilson (American scholar and later President of USA) wrote the first essay, "The Study of Administration" (1887). He addressed inefficiency and corruption in the US government in the late 1880s. Key points: political scientists had given little attention to how government operates; he was impressed by business, industry, and technology; he believed government work should be accomplished with the efficiency of the private sector; and he advocated for separation of politics from administration.
Leonard D. White wrote "Introduction to the Study of Public Administration" (1926). He commented that government should function in the context of democratic values (role of states in human affairs). According to him, there are 2 concerns in public administration:
- Efficiency: to improve the functioning of organization.
- Democratic values: organizations should keep these in view when providing services.
W.F. Willoughby in "Principles of Public Administration" (1927) emphasized the idea of 'value free' science of management. By value free service, he meant that those executing public programmes should be neutral, unbiased, and provide services without discrimination.
Fredrick Winslow Taylor is called the 'father of scientific management'. While working as a machine operator at Midvale Steel Company in USA, he observed workers using shovels for unloading coal and iron ore. He noticed that when workers shoveled rice coal they could lift 3.75 lbs, but when they shoveled iron ore they could lift 38 lbs. His question: "Which is the right load?" Instead of just asking people, he decided to conduct an experiment.
The Shovelling Experiment: Taylor selected 2 best shovelers and offered them double wages if they followed instructions. The two men shovelled all day in two different places until tired but not over-tired (a good day's work). Their supervisor noted: (1) number of shovelfuls per day and (2) weight of load in shovel (38-39 lbs). Results showed that if different kinds of shovels were used, the shoveller could lift loads between 21.5 lbs to 38 lbs β provided the worker was well-trained and worked consistently.
Results of the Experiment:
- There is a scientific way of doing things β 'one best way'
- Replace rule of thumb with science
- Obtain harmony in group action rather than discord
- Achieve cooperation of human beings rather than chaotic individualism
- Work for maximum output rather than restricted output (productivity)
- Develop all workers to the fullest extent for their own and company's prosperity
- Workers should be carefully selected
π‘ Why this matters: Taylor's time was mid-19th century, during the Industrial Revolution. Organizations demanded more output from labour, but workers feared that giving more output would lead to even higher expectations. Taylor's scientific management aimed to overcome this conflict through standards and incentives.
π Definition β Classical School of Management: A school of thought that believes the efficiency of organizations can be increased by following standards (scientific management).
π Definition β Value free: Without bias; being neutral and impartial in executing public programmes.
π Definition β Theory: A set of assumptions based on observation or experiment which explain a phenomenon or situation.
π Formula: Scientific Management β Using systematic observation and experimentation to find the "one best way" to perform work, replacing arbitrary rules of thumb with science.
π Example: Taylor's shovelling experiment β By comparing loads of rice coal (3.75 lbs) and iron ore (38 lbs), and then experimenting with different shovel sizes, Taylor found that a well-trained worker could consistently lift 21.5 to 38 lbs per shovelful, leading to maximum productivity. Workers were paid double wages as incentive.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture's core message is that public administration is deeply embedded in democratic values and constitutional rights, as exemplified by the 1973 Constitution of Pakistan. The evolution of public administration as a discipline began with the Classical School, whose pioneers like Woodrow Wilson advocated separating politics from administration for efficiency, Leonard White stressed balancing efficiency with democratic values, and W.F. Willoughby promoted value-free, unbiased service delivery. Frederick Winslow Taylor's scientific management revolution through his shovelling experiment introduced concepts like the "one best way," replacing rule-of-thumb with science, and emphasizing cooperation, maximum output, and careful worker selection. A student must remember that public administration exists at the intersection of international, economic, social, and political systems, and that the Classical School's core belief is that organizational efficiency can be increased by following scientific standards.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six schools in the evolution of public administration?
- According to Woodrow Wilson, what should be separated from administration?
- What was the key question Taylor asked before his shovelling experiment at Midvale Steel Company?
- What did Taylor mean by "one best way" and "replace rule of thumb with science"?
- According to Leonard D. White, what are the two main concerns in public administration?
π Lecture 03 β Classical School of Thoughts β I
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of the Classical School of Public Administration, focusing on key contributors like Henry L. Gantt, Frank and Lillian Gilbreth, Max Weber, and Henri Fayol. It explains their core conceptsβsuch as efficiency, bureaucracy, and general management principlesβand introduces the Human Relation Approach as a reaction to classical ideas. Understanding these foundational theories is critical for grasping the evolution of modern public administration.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the work of Henry L. Gantt and his Gantt chart, Frank and Lillian Gilbreth's time and motion studies, Max Weber's theory of bureaucracy with its characteristics and types of authority, and Henri Fayol's general principles of management. It also summarizes the main features of the Classical School and introduces the Human Relation Approach as a counter-movement.
π Lecture Summary
Henry L Gantt
Gantt, a member of the classical school, focused on efficiency and maximizing output. He emphasized the need for mutuality of interests between management and labour, meaning a βharmonious cooperation.β He asserted that the human element is the most important in all management problems and highlighted the importance of time and cost in planning and controlling work.
π Definition β Gantt chart: A visual tool that enables managers to break work into tasks and determine the time and resources required to complete each task. It is the basis for modern techniques like Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT). π Formula: Not applicable. π Example: A Gantt chart for a process improvement project shows tasks (e.g., "Form BPM team," "Identify problem") plotted against weeks in January, February, and March. Each task has a start milestone (e.g., 1/7 for "Form team") and an end milestone (e.g., 2/14 for "All data collected"), represented by bars and marker symbols.
Frank and Lillian Gilbreth
Frank and Lillian Gilbreth strongly supported Taylor's scientific management. Frank Gilbreth observed wasted motions in work, such as bricklayers, and found that movements could be reduced from 18 to 5. They combined their ideas with Taylor to improve productivity.
π Definition β Time and motion study: The analysis of workers' movements to eliminate unnecessary and inefficient motions. π Formula: Not applicable. π Example: By studying a bricklayer's 18 movements, Gilbreth identified that only 5 were essential, thereby increasing efficiency through motion reduction. π‘ Why this matters: This principle directly improves worker productivity without requiring additional effort.
Theory of Bureaucracy β Max Weber (1864-1920)
Max Weber, a lawyer studying organizations, believed that a specific type of organization called bureaucracy would help markets grow. He defined bureaucracy as a formal organization characterized by specific features.
General Characteristics of Bureaucracy:
- Hierarchy of authority
- Impersonality
- Written rules and documents
- Promotion based on achievement
- Specialized division of labor
- Efficiency
π Definition β Hierarchy: The various levels in an organization, forming a pyramid-like structure where each level controls the one below.
π Definition β Authority: The ability to exercise influence over a group of people. Weber distinguished three types:
- Traditional Authority: Authority inherited, e.g., the son of a king becomes the future king.
- Charismatic Authority: Authority from personal traits and abilities, e.g., a TV artist or sports star.
- Rational-legal Authority: Authority from a position, e.g., a policeman has authority because of his role.
π Definition β Impersonality: The official does not own the "means of administration"; the "self" of the individual is not involved in the work.
π Definition β Written rules and documents: All work in the organization is written, and officials must strictly follow written rules and remain loyal.
π Definition β Promotion based on achievement: Promotion is based on an official's skill, ability, and efficient and effective performance.
π Definition β Specialization/Division of Labour: Each person performs a given, assigned task to develop competence. π Formula: Not applicable. π Example 1: A typist should only type, not be asked to do other tasks, to develop competence. Example 2 (Adam Smith's pin making): If one person makes a pin, it takes longer; but if one person straightens wire, another cuts it, and a third rounds the head, output increases due to specialization.
Henri Fayol
Henri Fayol, the father of modern management theory, a French industrialist, grouped industrial activities into six parts: Production, Commercial, Financial, Security (protection of property), Accounting, and Managerial. He gave 14 general principles of management.
π Definition β General Principles of Management: Fayol's 14 principles for effective management:
- Division of work
- Authority & Responsibility
- Discipline: respect for agreement
- Unity of command: receive orders from one superior only (shown in a figure where a senior manager supervises three assistants, all receiving orders from one superior)
- Unity of direction: each group of activities with the same objective must have one head and one plan
- Subordination of individual interests to the general interest: managers work in the interests of the organization
- Remuneration: fair payment methods giving maximum satisfaction
- Centralization: the extent to which authority is concentrated or dispersed
- Scalar chain (line of authority) or chain of command
- Order: a place for everything and everything in its place
- Equity: justice and fairness from managers
- Stability of tenure of personnel
- Initiative: keenness to work
- Esprit de corps: union is strength (teamwork) π Formula: Not applicable. π Example: For "Unity of command," a senior manager supervises three assistants, and each assistant receives orders only from that one senior manager.
Main Feature of Classical School
The main focus of the classical school was technical, not political. It stressed material and methods over the human element, treating people as "cogs in the machines" βlike other machines and tools. Its goal was to increase productivity.
π Definition β Classical School Focus: The task of administration is to carry out the will of political authority technically, with efficiency and economic incentives. π Formula: Not applicable. π Example: Workers were considered interchangeable parts, similar to machine parts, to maximize output. π‘ Why this matters: This view improved efficiency but ignored human needs, leading to later reactions.
Human Relation Approach
This approach started as a reaction to the classical approach, initiated in the 1930s with the "Human Relation Movement." Research and theory development in the 1950s and 1960s provided further conceptual grounding.
π Definition β Productivity: Increasing output per worker. π Definition β Division of work/specialization: Assigning work clearly to one person to improve skills. π Definition β Authority: Ability to influence others. π Definition β Impersonality: "Self" of the individual is not involved in the work. π Definition β Hierarchy: Various levels or tiers in the organization. π Definition β Time & motion study: To study the movements of workers and eliminate unnecessary and inefficient movements.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaways from this lecture are: (1) Henry L. Gantt developed the Gantt chart for time and cost planning, while the Gilbreths pioneered time and motion studies to eliminate wasteful movements. (2) Max Weber's bureaucracy is defined by hierarchy, impersonality, written rules, promotion based on achievement, and specialization, and he distinguished three types of authority: traditional, charismatic, and rational-legal. (3) Henri Fayol's 14 principles of management, such as unity of command and division of work, form the basis of modern management theory. (4) The classical school's focus on efficiency and treating people as machine parts led to the Human Relation Approach as a necessary reaction emphasizing human elements. (5) The Human Relation Approach introduced concepts like productivity, specialization, authority, impersonality, hierarchy, and time and motion studies to counterbalance classical rigidity.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is a Gantt chart, and why is it important in planning?
- How did the Gilbreths' time and motion study improve worker productivity?
- List the three types of authority according to Max Weber and give an example for each.
- What are the 14 principles of management proposed by Henri Fayol?
- Why did the Human Relation Approach emerge as a reaction to the Classical School?
π Lecture 4 β CLASSICAL SCHOOL OF THOUGHTS β II
π Overview: This lecture continues the evolution of public administration by introducing the Human Relations School as a response to the Classical School. It explores how thinkers like Elton Mayo, Chester I. Barnard, and Herbert Simon shifted focus from mechanical efficiency to human behavior, social factors, and decision-making in organizations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the Human Relations School as a response to the Classical School, the famous Hawthorne Experiments conducted by Elton Mayo and colleagues, Chester I. Barnard's theory of authority and cooperation, and Herbert Simon's focus on human behavior and decision-making in organizations. Key concepts such as the Hawthorne effect, zones of acceptance and rejection, and the limitations of rational decision-making are explained.
π Lecture Summary
Human relations school and the work of the main contributors
The Human Relations School was the response to the Classical School. Those who believed in the assumptions of the classical school ignored the human element in organizations. They looked at human beings as mechanical devices. Initially the methods of Classical Schools worked, but gradually these stopped giving intended results. Human relations theory has diverse tradition of models, techniques, research findings, and ideas that often trace their roots back to the Hawthorne Experiments.
The main contributors to the human relations school were Elton Mayo, Chester I. Barnard, and Herbert Simon.
Hawthorne studies
Elton Mayo, Roethlisberger, and others undertook the famous experiment at the Hawthorne plant of the Western Electric Company at Cicero, Illinois, USA, between 1927 and 1932. Before that, from 1924 to 1927, the National Research Council (USA) did a study in collaboration with Western Electric Company to determine the effect of illumination and other conditions on workers and their productivity.
Researchers conducting the experiments placed two groups of employees doing the same work into separate rooms. One group was treated as the control group, for which variables like light, temperature, and working conditions are not changed. The second was the test group, for which variables like light, temperature, etc., are changed. The test group in the Hawthorne Experiment was exposed to various experimental changes such as increased lighting, decreased lighting, rest pauses, and so on. For the test group, the light was gradually decreased to the extent that it was as little as moonlight.
π Example: The researchers expected the experiments to lead to different levels of performance for the control group and for the test group. To the amazement of the researchers, both groups increased their performance.
The researchers concluded that the experimental design was problematic, which allowed extraneous factors to enter the design that led to these unanticipated results. What Mayo and his colleagues found was that employees in the groups were treated as special. They were given attention by management, separated from other employees, and encouraged to perform. In general, improvements in productivity were due to social factors such as morale, good relations with managers, and members of the group. Employees who are given attention by management, who are treated as special, and who perceive their work as significant can become highly motivated and thus become more productive.
π Definition β Hawthorne effect: The phenomenon arising basically from people being βnoticedβ β when a group receives attention from a supervisor, their performance improves regardless of physical conditions.
What the Hawthorne studies emphasized is that organizations are not just machines and tools but are also social systems.
Chester I. Barnard
Chester I. Barnard wrote the most influential book entitled βThe Function of the Executiveβ. He was the president of Bell Telephone Company in New Jersey, USA from 1927 to 1948. Barnard was much influenced by Mayo and others of the Human Relations School. His analysis of the manager was that the manager has to understand the behavior of people in organization and maintain a system of cooperative effort in formal organizations.
In his book he emphasized the following:
- He focused on the social implications (aspects) of organization. In response to Scientific Management Theory, Barnard added the human component to the work situation.
- He argued that the manager's role included gaining cooperation, defining purposes, and providing a system of communication.
- He believed that the subordinate was the ultimate source of authority; he or she chooses whether to accept or reject orders given by the manager.
According to Barnard, subordinates had three zones or ranges of orders that workers will operate under:
- The zone of rejection
- The zone of acceptance
- The zone of indifference
If employees are managed properly, the zone of acceptance can extend into the zone of indifference, thereby increasing the worker's tolerance for the manager's orders. If managed inappropriately, the zone of indifference will turn into the zone of rejection, thereby decreasing the worker's tolerance for the manager's orders.
Barnard believed that organizations could be improved by the adoption of:
- A cooperative attitude between functional units (workers & managers)
- Interdepartmental instruction (coordination among departments)
- The cross training of personnel (training of employees from different departments of the organization)
π‘ Why this matters: Barnard shifted the view of authority from a top-down command system to a consent-based model where workers actively choose to accept or reject orders.
Herbert Simon (1916 β 2001)
Herbert Simon was influenced by Barnard's work and his focus in the organization was human behavior, particularly focusing on decision making. He pointed out that the Classical School focused on rational processes of increasing output, ignoring that human beings have limited cognition and knowledge of complex problems.
According to Simon, group behavior requires not only the adoption of correct decisions, but also the adoption by all members of the group of the same decisions.
According to Herbert Alexander Simon, organizations are important because they:
- Provide the environments and structure that mold and develop personal qualities and habits
- Provide those in responsible positions with the means for exercising authority and influence over others
- Structure communications, determine the environments of information in which decisions are taken
The major contribution of Simon was to the understanding of decision making in organization and artificial intelligence. Simon got the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1978.
Concepts
π Definition β Illumination experiment: The experiment conducted at the Hawthorne Electric Plant to study group behavior on performance.
π Definition β Productivity: Output per worker.
π Definition β Human Relations School: The view that human behavior (group) has important influence on productivity and performance of organization.
β Key Takeaways
The Human Relations School emerged as a direct response to the Classical School's neglect of the human element. The Hawthorne Experiments demonstrated that social factors like attention, morale, and group dynamics significantly boost productivity, a phenomenon called the Hawthorne effect. Chester Barnard introduced the idea that authority flows from the subordinate's acceptance, defining three zones of orders: acceptance, indifference, and rejection. Herbert Simon shifted focus to decision-making, highlighting that humans have limited cognition and that organizations shape communication and authority structures.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the main finding of the Hawthorne Experiments, and what is the "Hawthorne effect"?
- According to Chester Barnard, what are the three zones of orders for workers, and how can a manager expand the zone of acceptance?
- What did Herbert Simon criticize about the Classical School's view of human behavior?
- List three ways Barnard believed organizations could be improved.
- Why did both the control group and the test group increase their performance in the Hawthorne Experiments?
π Lecture 05 β Human Relations Schools
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Human Relations School and its focus on individual behaviour, motivation, and interpersonal dynamics in organizations. It contrasts this with the Classical School and explores key behavioural theories including McGregor's Theory X and Y, Maslow's Need Hierarchy, and the System School approach to understanding organizations as interconnected systems.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the main features of Human Relations Schools, the concept of behaviour and common features of the Behavioural School and Human Relations, Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y, Abraham Maslow's hierarchy of needs theory, and the key concepts and features of the System School including subsystems, synergy, system boundaries, and feedback mechanisms.
π Lecture Summary
Main Features of Human Relation Approach
The Human Relations School focused on individuals' behaviour, cognitive decision-making processes, and the nature of authority in organizations. It also emphasized informal interpersonal relationships, group dynamics, and communication patterns within organizations.
Behavioural School
The Behavioural School examined human motivation and the social environment in which organizations operate. Its main contributors were Psychologists and Sociologists who studied how individual behaviour affects organizational performance.
What is behaviour?
π Definition β Behaviour: Actions of people that are seen or observed, driven by unseen attitudes, thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and motives. The visible behaviour is like the tip of an iceberg, while the underlying drivers remain hidden beneath the surface.
For example, a person violating a traffic signal shows visible behaviour from which we can infer their unseen perceptions and attitudes towards rules and cleanliness.
Common Features of Human Relations and Behavioural Schools
Both schools share several common features:
- Both focus on motivation of people
- Both emphasize clarity of communication
- They emphasize interpersonal relationship β how people relate with each other
- Both look at individual and group behaviour β how people behave alone and in groups
Main Contributors of Behavioural School
Douglas McGregor: Theory X and Theory Y
Theory X contains negative assumptions about human behaviour:
- Dislike work: Human beings are lazy and docile, therefore they avoid work
- Avoid responsibility: Because they are lazy, they do not want to take responsibility
- Need to be supervised: To get work out of lazy people, they need close supervision
Theory Y contains positive assumptions about human behaviour, opposite to Theory X:
- People accept responsibility: They are willing to work, agile, and want to achieve organizational goals
- Can exercise control: Because they are responsible, they want control over things
- Have capacity to be creative: People want to be creative and look for challenge
- Can work as natural as rest or play: Work and rest are equally natural; people cannot rest all the time (becomes boring) nor work all the time (becomes dull)
Abraham Maslow: Maslow's Need Hierarchy
This theory views human motivation as a hierarchy of five needs, ranging from the most basic physiological needs to the highest level of need for "self actualization". According to Maslow, individuals will be motivated to fulfill the most pressing need at a time. The importance of a need depends on its deprivation and the current situation.
π Formula β Need Hierarchy (bottom to top): Basic Needs β Safety β Belongingness β Ego-Status β Self Actualization
π Example: If someone is starving (deprived of basic needs like food), they cannot think about higher-level needs like safety or belongingness. The lower-level needs must be satisfied before moving to higher levels.
π‘ Why this matters: Managers can use this hierarchy to understand what motivates employees at different stages β someone struggling financially needs salary and job security, while someone with secure basic needs may be motivated by recognition and personal growth.
System Schools
The word 'system' is borrowed from biological sciences to social science. Organizations are viewed like other systems (irrigation system, ecosystem, circulatory system, etc.). Systems can be:
- Mechanistic system: Static, does not change with external changes
- Organic system: Responds to external environment and is changeable
Two basic components of System Theory:
- Views organization as a "unified, purposeful system composed of interrelated parts"
- Provides opportunity to look at organization as a whole and as part of larger external environment
Parts of Organization
An organization comprises many parts or sub-systems. For example, a university may have three sub-systems: Examination, Registration, and Human Resource Management. These sub-systems together constitute one big organization. Since organizations are compared to organic systems, they are changeable and respond to the external environment.
Key Concepts in System School
π Definition β Subsystem: The parts that make up the whole organization
π Definition β Synergy: The whole is greater than the sum of its parts; the combined effect of the system
π Definition β System boundary: The boundary that separates the system from the external environment
π Definition β Open & closed system: A system that interacts with its environment is an open system
π Definition β Feedback: The return of information to the organization, showing how outputs (goods and services) inform inputs and transformation processes
Summary of System Model: Inputs (human, financial, physical) β Transformation (use of processes to change resources into goods and services) β Products (goods and services) β Feedback returns information to the organization
Conclusion on Theories
No single theory is better than another. All theories explain different aspects of organization:
- Classical theories help understand mechanical aspects like line of command, unity of direction, and hierarchy
- Human and Behavioural Schools help understand the human side of organizations
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts to remember are: McGregor's Theory X (negative assumptions: people dislike work, avoid responsibility, need supervision) versus Theory Y (positive assumptions: people accept responsibility, exercise control, are creative, work naturally); Maslow's five-level Need Hierarchy (Basic Needs β Safety β Belongingness β Ego-Status β Self Actualization) which states lower needs must be satisfied before higher needs motivate; and the System School's view of organizations as unified, purposeful systems composed of interrelated sub-systems that interact with the external environment through feedback mechanisms. Additionally, behaviour is defined as observable actions driven by unseen attitudes and motives, while synergy means the whole is greater than the sum of its parts.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four common features shared by the Human Relations School and the Behavioural School?
- List all the assumptions of Theory X and Theory Y as presented by Douglas McGregor.
- Explain Maslow's Need Hierarchy from the lowest to the highest level, and state the principle of need progression.
- Define the five key concepts in System Theory: subsystem, synergy, system boundary, open/closed system, and feedback.
- What is the difference between mechanistic and organic systems, and how does this apply to organizations?