π Lecture 11 β 1973 Constitution of Pakistan
π Overview: This lecture examines the constitutional framework of Pakistan's government as established by the 1973 Constitution. It explains the foundational principles, structure of government, and key constitutional bodies that shape public administration in Pakistan, making it essential for understanding how the state operates.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Preamble of the 1973 Constitution, the definition of the Republic of Pakistan and its territories, state religion, the definition of the state, the distinction between government and state, the Federation and its President, the bicameral Parliament (National Assembly and Senate), Federal Government and Cabinet, and key constitutional bodies including the National Economic Council, National Finance Commission, Courts, and Public Service Commission.
π Lecture Summary
Preamble
The Preamble serves as the preface or introduction to the Constitution, outlining its main focus. It states that sovereignty over the entire universe belongs to Allah alone, and the authority exercised by the people of Pakistan is a sacred trust within limits prescribed by Him.
The Republic of Pakistan
The Constitution defines Pakistan as a Federal Republic to be known as the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. "Federal Republic" means the country has provinces that together constitute the federation. The term "Islamic Republic" reflects that Pakistan is an ideological state, as Islam was the basis of the country's independence.
The Territories
According to the Constitution, the territories of the state include: a. The Provinces of Balochistan, the North-West Frontier (now Khyber Pakhtunkhwa), Punjab, and Sindh b. The Islamabad Capital Territory (Federal Capital) c. The Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) d. Such states and territories as may be included in Pakistan, whether by accession or otherwise
Section (d) provides for the future inclusion of Kashmir in Pakistan.
π Definition β Federal Republic: A country with provinces that together constitute a federation, with a central government and regional governments sharing power.
State Religion
Article 2 of the Constitution provides: "Islam shall be the State Religion of Pakistan."
Definition of the State
Article 7 defines the state as: "the Federal Government, Parliament, a Provincial Government, a Provincial Assembly, and such Local or other Authorities in Pakistan as are by Law empowered to impose any Tax."
The state comprises all permanent institutions: Federal and Provincial Governments, Assemblies, and local or other authorities.
What does Government Comprise?
The lecture distinguishes between government and state, though the terms are often used interchangeably. The key difference is that state institutions are fixed, while the people occupying positions may change. Government comes every 5 years through elections and goes after 5 years. Government (in generic sense) comprises:
- Elected Representatives (Politicians: members of Political Parties)
- Judiciary
- Executive (career civil servants)
The government sector and private sector interact and influence each other, as shown by overlapping boundaries in a diagram.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the distinction between state (permanent institutions) and government (temporary officeholders) is crucial for comprehending how administrative continuity is maintained despite political changes.
The Federation of Pakistan
The Federation is the unity of all constituent units. Article 41 defines the President as the symbol of unity: "There shall be President of Pakistan who shall be the Head of State and shall represent the unity of State."
The Parliament
Article 50 explains that Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament) consists of the President and two houses:
- The National Assembly
- The Senate
The National Assembly
Article 51 states the National Assembly shall consist of 332 Muslim members elected by direct and free vote, plus 10 non-Muslim members, bringing the total to 342. It is called the Lower House.
Table: Seats in the National Assembly
| Province | General seats | Women | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balochistan | 14 | 3 | 17 |
| The NWFP | 35 | 8 | 43 |
| The Punjab | 148 | 35 | 183 |
| Sindh | 61 | 14 | 75 |
| The FATA | 12 | - | 12 |
| Capital | 2 | - | 2 |
| Total | 272 | 60 | 332 |
| Non-Muslims | 10 | - | - |
π Example: The total number of members in the National Assembly is 342, comprising 332 Muslim members and 10 non-Muslim members, with provincial distribution as shown in the table.
The Senate
The Senate is the Upper House. According to Article 59(1):
- 14 elected by each Provincial Assembly (56 total)
- 8 elected from FATA
- 2 on general seats, 1 woman, 1 technocrat (4 total)
- 4 women elected by each Provincial Assembly (16 total)
- 4 technocrats including ulema elected by each Provincial Assembly (16 total)
Total: 100 members.
Federal Government
Article 90 provides for executive authority: "The Executive Authority of the federation shall vest in the President and shall be exercised by him, either directly or through officers subordinate to him."
The Cabinet
According to Article 91(1), there shall be a Cabinet of Ministers with the Prime Minister as its head, to aid and advise the President. The Prime Minister is the functional head who helps the President fulfill duties.
Constitutional Bodies
These bodies have functions defined by the constitution and regulate and make policy decisions with long-term impact:
National Economic Council (NEC)
Article 156(1) states the President shall constitute a NEC consisting of the Prime Minister (as Chairman) and other members as determined. NEC reviews the overall economic condition of the country and formulates plans for financial, commercial, social, and economic policies.
π Definition β National Economic Council: The highest body that provides the framework for economic, financial, and social policies in Pakistan.
National Finance Commission (NFC)
Article 160 provides for NFC, consisting of the Minister of Finance of Federal Government and Ministers of Finance of Provincial Governments. NFC decides every five years how tax revenues should be distributed between provinces and the federal government, and the criteria for resource allocation among provinces.
π Definition β National Finance Commission: A constitutional body constituted every five years that decides the criteria for distributing resources between the Federal Government and Provincial Governments and amongst provinces.
The Courts
Article 175 provides for a Supreme Court of Pakistan, a High Court for each Province, and such other courts as established by law.
Article 176 states the Supreme Court consists of a Chief Justice and other judges determined by Act of Majlis-e-Shoora or fixed by the President.
The High Court
Article 192 provides that a High Court consists of a Chief Justice and other judges determined by law or fixed by the President.
Courts interpret law and give decisions on cases brought before them.
π Example: A case was brought before the Court by an affected party against legislation passed by the Provincial Assembly banning serving of food at marriages. The court, after reviewing the case, upheld the legislation.
Provisions of the Services
Article 240 provides that appointments and conditions of service of persons in the service of Pakistan shall be determined by Act of Parliament (for Federation and All-Pakistan services) or by Act of Provincial Assembly (for Provincial services). The Act referred to is the Civil Service Act 1973.
Public Service Commission
Article 242 provides for the establishment of a Public Service Commission as the recruiting agency for Federal and Provincial Governments.
π Definition β Public Service Commission: A constitutional body responsible for recruiting civil servants for the Federal and Provincial Governments.
β Key Takeaways
The 1973 Constitution establishes Pakistan as an Islamic Federal Republic with a bicameral Parliament (National Assembly with 342 members and Senate with 100 members) and a President as head of state with the Prime Minister as functional head of government. The Constitution defines the state to include federal and provincial governments, assemblies, and local authorities, while distinguishing these permanent state institutions from temporary governments formed through elections every five years. Key constitutional bodies like the National Economic Council and National Finance Commission play crucial roles in formulating economic policies and distributing resources between federal and provincial governments. The Constitution also provides for an independent judiciary with the Supreme Court and High Courts, and establishes the Public Service Commission for civil service recruitment under the Civil Service Act 1973.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four provinces and other territories of Pakistan according to the 1973 Constitution?
- How many total members are in the National Assembly, and how are they distributed among provinces?
- What is the difference between the state and the government as defined in the Constitution?
- What are the functions of the National Economic Council (NEC) and the National Finance Commission (NFC)?
- Which constitutional article provides for the establishment of the Public Service Commission, and what is its role?
π Lecture 12 β Structure of Government
π Overview: This lecture explains the organizational structure of the federal government, focusing on how ministries, divisions, and attached departments operate. It introduces the concept of Rules of Business and provides a detailed example using the Ministry of Finance to illustrate how government functions are organized and executed.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the constitutional basis for government structure, the relationship between the Prime Minister, Cabinet, and ministries, the concept of Rules of Business that govern administrative functioning, the distinction between ministries and divisions, the organizational hierarchy within a ministry (Minister β Secretary β Joint Secretaries), and the difference between attached departments and autonomous bodies, using the Ministry of Finance as a case study.
π Lecture Summary
The Concept of Rules of Business
The Constitution of Pakistan under Article 90-99 provides for the formulation of Rules of Business. These rules govern the working of ministries and divisions. 'Business' means all work done by the Federal Government, which includes all ministries, divisions, attached departments, and autonomous bodies. The Rules of Business explain the responsibilities of the Secretary who heads each division and delineate which ministries and departments fall under each ministry. Similar rules exist for provincial governments.
π Definition β Rules of Business: Rules framed under the Constitution that explain the working of government, including responsibilities of Secretaries and the organization of ministries and departments.
Structure of Government
The structure flows from the Constitution, which provides the broad framework for the three branches of government: legislature (National Assembly, Provincial Assemblies, Senate), judiciary (courts), and executive. The operational level functioning is regulated by specific Acts approved by the legislature. The President is the Head of State, while the Prime Minister is the Chief Executive who heads the Cabinet. The Cabinet comprises ministers who head the 39 ministries.
π Definition β Cabinet: A group of ministers working under the guidance of the Prime Minister.
Ministries of Federal Government (39)
In 2004, there were 39 ministries. Selected examples include:
- Cabinet Secretariat
- Ministry of Commerce
- Ministry of Culture, Sports & Youth Affairs
- Ministry of Communication
- Ministry of Defence Production
- Ministry of Finance & Revenue
- Ministry of Information & Technology
- Ministry of Interior
- Ministry of Housing and Works
The Cabinet Secretariat maintains all paperwork for the Cabinet.
Structure of Ministry
A Ministry is a Division or Group of Divisions. A Division is entrusted with one specific task. For example, the Ministry of Finance has four divisions: Finance Division, Economic Affairs Division, Statistics Division, and Revenue Division. The Ministry oversees the work of all these divisions.
π Definition β Ministry: A group of more than one Division. π Definition β Division: A unit assigned with a specific task (e.g., Finance Division).
Main Functions of Finance Division
The Finance Division is responsible for:
- Finances of Federal government and financial matters affecting the whole country
- The Annual Budget Statement and supplementary/excess Budget to be placed before the National Assembly
- Allocation of shares of proceeds from taxes collected by the Federal Government
- Public debt of the Federation (both internal and external)
- Currency, coinage, legal tender, Pakistan Security Printing Corporation, and Pakistan Mint
- Regulatory functions pertaining to banking sector, stock exchanges, foreign currency, etc.
Main Functions of the Economic Affairs Division
The Economic Affairs Division handles:
- Negotiations with foreign governments and organizations regarding economic assistance requirements
- Matters relating to technical assistance to foreign countries
- Review and appraisal of international and regional economic trends and their impact on the national economy
π Definition β Functions: The work to be performed by the Division.
Organization of Finance Division
The Minister is the political head (usually a politician) who provides policy guidelines to the Ministry. The Division is headed by the Secretary, who is a career civil servant. The Secretary Finance is assisted by three Joint Secretaries: JS (Expenditure & Administration), JS (Budget), and JS (Finance).
The organizational hierarchy is:
- Minister for Finance (political head)
- Secretary Finance (career civil servant heading the division)
- Joint Secretaries (assisting the Secretary in day-to-day working)
- Special Assistant/Advisor (advisory roles)
Attached Departments
An attached department is administratively under the control of the Ministry but has offices throughout the country. For the Ministry of Finance, examples include:
- Finance Division Military
- Office of the Controller General of Pakistan
- Auditor General of Pakistan
- Central Directorate of Savings
π‘ Why this matters: Attached departments extend the Ministry's reach across the entire country while remaining under administrative control.
Autonomous Bodies under Ministry of Finance
Autonomous bodies are not administratively controlled by the ministry. They have their own Board of Governors and do not receive directives from the ministry. Examples include:
- Monopoly Control Authority
- Nationalized Commercial Banks
- Pakistan Security Printing Corporation
π Definition β Autonomous Body: An organization that has its own Board of Governors that sets policy for it. Autonomous bodies are more independent in decision making.
Conclusion
The Federal executive branch comprises ministers who head 39 ministries. Federal Secretaries assist ministers in formulation of policies, execute policies, write proposals for legislation to be submitted to the cabinet, and keep the minister informed. The Minister is responsible for the working of the Division and answers questions raised on the Ministry's working in the National Assembly.
β Key Takeaways
The government structure flows from the Constitution, with the Prime Minister heading the Cabinet of ministers who oversee 39 ministries. Each ministry may contain multiple divisions, each headed by a career civil servant Secretary who is assisted by Joint Secretaries. The Rules of Business (Article 90-99) govern all administrative functioning. Attached departments operate under ministry control but have field offices nationwide, while autonomous bodies have independent Boards of Governors. The Ministry of Finance exemplifies this structure with its four divisions (Finance, Revenue, Economic Affairs, Statistics) and specific functions ranging from budget preparation to debt management and banking regulation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under which articles of the Constitution are the Rules of Business formulated?
- What is the difference between an attached department and an autonomous body?
- How many ministries did the Federal Government have in 2004, and who heads each ministry?
- What are the four divisions under the Ministry of Finance, and what is the hierarchy within a division?
- What is the role of the Secretary in a division, and how does he/she differ from the Minister?
π Lecture 13 β Public and Private Administration
π Overview: This lecture explores the distinctions and similarities between public and private sector administration. It examines why public administration is often compared to business management, and clarifies the fundamental differences in their operating environments, objectives, and constraints. Understanding these differences is crucial for appreciating the unique challenges faced by public managers.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by noting that early writers suggested government should become more like business due to perceived efficiency in the private sector, with profit being the primary distinction. It then details seven key differences between public and private administration: Constitutions, The Public Interest, Ambiguity, Pluralistic Decision Making, Visibility, The Market, and Less Efficiency. Additionally, it discusses the distinct forms of power that government possesses. Each difference is explained with examples and comparisons to the private sector.
π Lecture Summary
Lesson 13: Public and Private Administration
The lecture explains that public organizations are guided by commitments to public service ideals, which is the basic difference from the private sector. However, because public organizations are involved in management, public administration is often confused with business management. Early writers suggested government should become more like business because private organizations were considered more efficient, often attributed to profit. The primary distinction is that government provides services or regulates behavior in the public interest, while business focuses on profit. The scope of government is much broader, serving all citizens, unlike a business that serves specific customers. For example, a car company deals with those who can afford cars, while government provides roads used by everyone.
π‘ Why this matters: This fundamental difference in purpose (public service vs. profit) changes the entire context and nature of the work in public administration.
Differences
The basic differences between public and private sector are seven: Constitutions, The Public Interest, Ambiguity, Pluralistic Decision Making, Visibility, The Market, and Less Efficient.
Constitutions
In Pakistan, the federal constitution defines the environment of public administration, from which laws affecting the executive branch originate. It dictates that laws are legislated by the legislature, and public administration implements them. In the private sector, there is no constitution, though there is legal binding of a different nature. The executive, legislature, and courts are responsive to different constituencies and political pressures, all with legitimate interests in public administration. The constitutional framework creates federalism, allowing overlap in federal and provincial administration, which is not found in private business.
The Public Interest
Public interest refers to the good of a larger number of people, where any good or service is provided for the benefit of many citizens. Private interest is limited in comparison. For example, education for all is public interest, while education for a selected few is private interest. The private sector provides education to those who can pay, while government provides education to all with low tuition fees. Similarly, the benefit of maintaining law and order is for everyone, not just a selected few.
Ambiguity
In the private sector, profit is the basic measure of performance. This is not true for public agencies, where making or losing money is not the main criterion for success or failure. The objectives of public organizations are stated in terms of service provision. For example, an agency's mission may be to protect the environment or provide rehabilitative services. Government may spend more without the purpose of making profit but to provide service. Thus, the goals of public agencies are less clear and less quantifiable, creating ambiguity.
π Definition β Ambiguity: Vague and unquantifiable goals.
Pluralistic Decision Making
Pluralistic decision making occurs when more than one type of group is the beneficiary or affected party. Pluralism means people belong to different ethnic, racial, regional, and cultural backgrounds. Since people are different, their demands and needs vary, leading to divergent views on public interest issues. For example, people of one region may need roads, while others need dams, but only one budget exists, requiring consensus building. In the private sector, a company decides to manufacture a product without seeking such consensus. This makes pluralistic decision making in the public sector different from the private sector.
π Definition β Pluralistic decision making: People with diverse ethnic backgrounds are involved in decision making.
Visibility
In parliamentary democracies, managers operate with much greater visibility than their private sector counterparts because they are constantly watched by the media. Reports about inefficient, undemocratic, or unjust behavior of public organizations get reported, unlike the behavior of private managers. This is because public managers' actions affect a large number of people.
π Definition β Visibility: That public officials working in public agencies are reported in the press.
The Market
The final major difference includes distinct differences regarding the market:
- Public agencies do not face competition from other firms as private sector organizations do.
- The price of governmental operations is established through budgetary routines, not fixed at the market. In the private sector, prices are determined by demand and supply, but government does not fix prices on this principle.
- The remoteness of market forces from most public administrative operations has profound consequences for public financial management.
- Some government-provided services are referred to as public goods, such as defence, roads, and street lights. The characteristics of public goods are that individuals cannot be excluded from enjoying them, and they are not exhausted or diminished by use (non-rival). An example is a road used by all whose value does not diminish.
Less Efficient
There is an allegation that public organizations are less efficient, meaning they do not maximize output with given resources. This has led to efforts to make public organizations as efficient as private organizations.
Power
There are different kinds of power that organizations possess, but the power of government is different and omnipresent. The distinctive powers of government are:
- Power to regulate: Government can regulate the private sector by formulating binding laws.
- Power to coerce: Only government has the power to use force and put people behind bars for violating law. No private organization has this power of punishment.
- Pervasiveness: Government laws and regulations have general applicability, such as traffic laws being applied and accepted across the entire country.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical distinction between public and private administration is that public organizations are driven by public service ideals and the public interest, while private organizations are driven by profit. This fundamental difference leads to seven key dissimilarities: the public sector operates within a constitutional framework with oversight from multiple branches of government, faces ambiguous and less quantifiable goals, requires pluralistic decision-making to build consensus among diverse groups, operates with high visibility and media scrutiny, does not face the same market pressures, is often accused of being less efficient, and wields unique power including the power to regulate and coerce. A core concept is the idea of public goods, which are non-excludable and non-rival, meaning they are provided by government because the market would not supply them adequately.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary distinction between public and private administration mentioned in the lecture?
- Explain the concept of "ambiguity" as it applies to public administration goals.
- What are the four characteristics that differentiate the public sector's relationship with "the market" from the private sector's?
- List the three distinct types of power that only government possesses and provide an example for each.
- What are "public goods"? Give two examples and explain their two key characteristics.
π Lecture 14 β Organization
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of organization within public administration, including organizational roles, the process of organizing, and different types of organizations. It explains how formal and informal structures coexist and examines key principles like span of control and departmentalization that are essential for effective management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers organizational roles and their requirements, the steps involved in organizing, the distinction between formal and informal organizations, organizational levels and span of management, factors determining effective span of control, and the concept of departmentalization with its various types. Key definitions for organization, roles, span, and hierarchy are also provided.
π Lecture Summary
Organizational Roles
Organizational roles are the part or position that a person is assigned in the organization, for example, the role of manager sales or your role as a student. People will cooperate effectively in organizations if they know the part they have to play in the organizations, i.e., if they know their roles in the organization.
Following are the requirement of organizational goals:
- Clear objectives: People must know the objectives that they have to achieve clearly; students must know their objectives.
- Clear idea of duties or activities: People must know their duties and activities that they must perform, e.g., student duties are to study and be disciplined.
- Clear area of authority: In organization, people must know the extent of authority that they have.
What is Organizing
Organizing means that there should be clear line of authority and all should know who reports to whom. Following are the main steps in organizing:
- Classification of activities: First, all activities in organization must be classified, i.e., activities similar in nature should be identified separately.
- Grouping of activities to achieve objectives: Similar activities should be grouped.
- Assigning a manager to each group of activities: A manager should be assigned.
- Coordination of group of activities both horizontally and vertically: Coordination means the interrelationship among activities.
Organization
Now we have talked about concepts of 'roles' and 'organizing', we will connect these two concepts with the concept of organization. Organization means a formalized intentional structure of roles and positions. Here we refer to organization as a structure in which people work, e.g., school is organization.
Types of Organization
Organizations can be categorized into following types:
- Formal Organizations
- Informal Organizations
Formal Organizations
Formal organizations mean the intentional structure of roles in a formally organized enterprise. The structures are created by people to achieve certain defined goals. The formal organizations could be hospitals, schools, Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA).
Informal Organizations
A network of personal and social relations not established or required by the formal organization but arising spontaneously as people associate with each other is called informal organization. The example of informal organization is friendship within the organization amongst people working at various levels.
Figure-1 illustrates the concept of formal and informal organization. The formal organization is the people working who are assigned roles and given a position in a box. There are four levels in an organization and the straight lines show formal structure. However, the irregular lines show informal relationship or informal structure.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the difference between formal and informal organizations helps managers recognize that official structures are not the only source of power or communication within an organization.
Organizational Levels and Span of Management
Organizational levels exist because there is a limit to the number of persons a manager can supervise effectively, even though this limit varies depending on situations. Organizational span (or span of management), therefore, means the number of people a manager can supervise. It is generally believed that the number of people that a manager can effectively supervise are between 7 and 10. But this is not a principle.
While span refers to number of people a person can supervise, organizational level refers to "ties" or levels. In figure-2, the horizontal arrow indicates span and the vertical arrow shows the organizational level. In figure-1, the organizational levels are shown by numbers 1, 2, 3, and 4.
π Definition β Span of Control: The number of subordinates a manager can effectively supervise.
Principle of Span of Control
There is a limit to the number of subordinates a manager can effectively supervise, but the exact number will depend on the impact of the following factors:
Factors Determining an Effective Span
- Training of subordinates: The more trained and experienced the employees, the less supervision they require, and therefore, the manager can supervise more employees.
- Clear delegation of authority: Delegation of authority means to give part of authority to a subordinate. Thus, if managers can delegate authority clearly to each subordinate being supervised, more employees can be brought under supervision.
- Clarity of plans: When the plans are clearly understood by the employees, the manager can supervise more people.
- Use of objective standards to determine whether employees are following plans
- Rate of change
- Communication techniques
- Amount of personal contact needed
- Variation by organization level
- Personal abilities of managers
- Need for balance
π‘ Why this matters: The span of control determines the shape of an organizationβa wide span results in a flat structure, while a narrow span creates a tall hierarchy, each with different implications for communication and supervision.
Department
One way of grouping activities is establishing a 'department'. A department is a distinct area, division, or branch of organization over which a manager has authority for performance of specified activities.
Departmentalization
Departmentalization is grouping activities and people into departments, which makes it possible to expand organizations to an indefinite degree.
Types of Departmentalization
- By Number
- By Time
- By Function
- By Geography
- By Production
- By Customer
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that an organization is a formalized structure of roles and positions, requiring clear objectives, duties, and authority for each role. The core distinction between formal organizations (intentional, goal-oriented) and informal organizations (spontaneous social networks) is critical for understanding organizational dynamics. The span of management principle states that there is a limit to how many subordinates a manager can effectively supervise, though this number varies based on factors like subordinate training, delegation clarity, and communication techniques. Organizing involves classifying and grouping activities, assigning managers, and ensuring coordination both horizontally and vertically. Finally, departmentalizationβgrouping activities into departments by function, geography, or other criteriaβenables organizational expansion and specialization.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three requirements of organizational roles that must be clearly communicated to people in an organization?
- List the four main steps involved in the process of organizing.
- What is the difference between a formal organization and an informal organization?
- According to the lecture, what is the generally believed effective number of people a manager can supervise, and what is this concept called?
- Name at least four of the ten factors that determine an effective span of control.
π Lecture 15 β Departmentalization
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of departmentalization in public administration, exploring how organizations group activities into departments for efficient management. It covers various bases of departmentalization, their advantages and disadvantages, and introduces the matrix organization structure. Understanding these concepts is crucial for designing effective organizational structures and improving administrative efficiency.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture defines a department and departmentalization, then examines five main types: by simple numbers, time, enterprise function, geography, customer, and product. It also covers matrix organizations combining functional and project patterns, and concludes with key concepts including authority and decentralization issues in each type.
π Lecture Summary
Department
A department is defined as "a distinct area, division, or branch of organization over which manager has authority for performance of specified activities." When activities and tasks are grouped according to some basis of similarity, it is called departmentalization.
Departmentalization by simple numbers
Departmentalization by number is done by putting people in a group who are to perform the same duties. They are placed under supervision of a manager or supervisors. Example: Armies in old times, unskilled labour in construction.
Departmentalization by time
Departmentalization by time is done at operational or lower levels of organizations where activities are grouped together on the basis of time. Example: People working in shifts in steel company, hospitals etc.
Advantages:
- The usual timings of offices are eight hours, but if departmentalization is to be done beyond 8 hours, second shift or round the clock service can be provided.
- Equipment can be used more often in shifts: The tools, equipment and physical facilities can be used to full capacity.
Disadvantages:
- Lack of supervision: People working in shifts may not be supervised.
- Increase of overtime rates: There may be increase in expenditure due to payment to workers in shift.
Departmentalization by Enterprise Function
Departmentalization by function is the grouping of the activities in accordance with the functions of the enterprise (Functional Departmentalization). Example of functions of organization: Production, Budgeting, Accounts, Sales etc.
Figure 1 shows an organization chart of a private company with 4 functional departments: marketing, engineering, production, and finance. Under the marketing department all market related activities are grouped i.e. marketing research, marketing planning, advertising and promotion, sales and administration. Departmentalization by function is the most common form of departmentalization.
Advantages of Departmentalization by Function:
- It is logical reflection of functions: This is more common and logical way of grouping activities.
- Maintains power of major functions: Certain functions in organization are more important as the main or core area. For example in universities the academic department will be major function.
- Simplifies training: Since people are grouped according to functional departmentalization, it becomes easier to provide training to employees in a particular functional area wise.
- Tight control on the top: Each department head can exercise control over its own functional area.
Disadvantages of Departmentalization by Function:
- Reduces coordination among functions: Since employees work in respective department; therefore, coordination amongst various department is reduced.
- Slow adaptation to changing environment: When people work for a long time in a department they become used to with the working and their styles become rigid. For example a police officer style of working would be different from that of a teacher. Therefore, they are slow to changing environment.
- Limits development of managers: Development of managers is limited to a particular function only.
Departmentalization by Geography
Activities of an organization in a given area or territory are grouped and assigned to a manager. Example: Electricity and gas is supplied by regional organizations, such as local electricity Supply Corporation, Sui Northern Gas Company and Sui Southern Gas Company.
Figure 2 shows an organization chart of an organization that has centralized marketing, personnel, purchasing and finance. Under the central region are shown personnel engineering, production, accounting and sales, and likewise these functions also exist for other four geographical regions.
Advantages:
- Emphasis on local market: The local markets can gain benefit as service is provided according to geography. It helps develop that market.
- Improves coordination: Coordination within the geographical unit is better because all functional departments operate at the geographic region.
- Face-to-face communication: There is better communication between the service provider and service receiver.
Disadvantages:
- Problems of control: As the functions are dispersed, therefore control cannot be exercised effectively.
- Requires more human capital: from the above it is deduced that more people are required.
- Makes maintenance more difficult: Maintenance of service become difficult.
Customer Departmentalization
It is grouping of activities so that these reflect primary interest of the customers in a variety of enterprises.
Figure 3 shows customer departmentalization in banking. The bank has grouped banking activities according to the types of loans that will be acquired by specific type of customer e.g., agricultural banking department will provide loans to farmers. Real estate loans will be provided to customers who plan to buy property. Institutional banking will deal with institutional customers.
Advantages:
- Encourages concentration on customer needs.
- The focus is on customer satisfaction.
- The staff develops expertise in customer area.
Disadvantages:
- Since everybody works in respective area coordination becomes difficult.
- There is underutilization of facilities and labour-specialized workers in customer groups.
Departments by Product
Grouping of activities on the basis of the products or the product lines of an organization is known as departmentalization by production or product. Some organizations may be producing more than one product or services. For example a firm may be producing soaps, detergents, toothpaste etc. So for each product it would have separate department. Figure 4 shows an organization with three separate services like punch-press, welding and electroplating.
Matrix Organizations
It is the combination of functional and project or product patterns of departmentalization in the same organization structure.
Figure 5 shows a matrix organization in engineering department, with functional managers in charge of engineering functions and an overlap of project managers responsible for the end product. This form of organization is common in research and engineering organizations; it has been used in product marketing organizations as well.
Problems with Matrix Management:
- A state of conflict exists between functional and product managers as both compete for limited resources (for example financial and human).
- There is conflict of roles and ambiguity because there is overlap of functions.
- There is imbalance of authority and power as well as horizontal and vertical influence of the project and functional managers which can lead to problems in matrix organization.
- Because of potential conflict, managers may want to protect themselves against blames by putting everything in writing which increases administrative cost.
- Matrix organization requires many time-consuming meetings.
Concepts
- Departmentalization: grouping of activities according to some specific activities over which manager has authority.
- Departmentalization by function: grouping of activities by functions.
- Departmentalization by geography: Activities of an organization in a given area or territory are grouped and assigned to a manager.
- Departmentalization by customer: It is grouping of activities so that these reflect primary interest of the customers.
- Matrix organizations: It is the combination of functional and project or product patterns.
β Key Takeaways
Departmentalization is the fundamental process of grouping organizational activities into distinct departments, with five main types discussed: by simple numbers, time, function, geography, customer, and product. The most common form is departmentalization by function, which maintains power of major functions and simplifies training but reduces coordination across functions. Each type has specific advantages and disadvantages that must be carefully considered when designing organizational structure. Matrix organizations combine functional and project patterns, offering flexibility but creating potential conflicts, role ambiguity, and increased administrative costs due to overlapping authority between functional and product managers.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five types of departmentalization discussed in this lecture?
- What are two major advantages and two major disadvantages of departmentalization by function?
- How does customer departmentalization differ from departmentalization by geography?
- What is a matrix organization and what are its major problems?
- Why might an organization choose departmentalization by geography over departmentalization by function?