π Lecture 16 β Power and Authority
π Overview: This lecture examines the foundational concepts of power and authority within public administration and organizational structures. It distinguishes between line and staff functions, explains the scalar principle and functional authority, and explores the critical organizational dynamics of centralization, decentralization, and delegation, which are essential for understanding how decisions are made and implemented.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and distinction between power and authority, followed by a detailed explanation of the line and staff concepts. It then explores delegation, the scalar principle, and functional authority, including the delegation of functional authority. Finally, it discusses the nature, benefits, and limitations of staff functions, along with the concept of decentralization, its forms, and how it relates to centralization along a continuum.
π Lecture Summary
Power and Authority
Authority is defined as a force for achieving desired outcomes, but only as prescribed by the formal hierarchy and reporting relationships. Authority is vested in organizational positions, not in the personalities or personal characteristics of individuals.
Power is the ability to influence others to modify behavior to achieve stated objectives. Authority is also defined as the right in a position to exercise discretion in making decisions affecting others.
π Definition β Authority: The right in a position to exercise discretion in making decisions affecting others, prescribed by the formal hierarchy. π Definition β Power: The ability to influence others to modify behaviour to achieve stated objectives. π‘ Why this matters: Understanding this distinction is crucial because a person can have power without formal authority (e.g., an influential colleague), while authority is always tied to a formal role.
Line and Staff Concept
There is much confusion on what exactly is "line" and "staff" in management literature and practice. But line and staff relationships are important as an organizational way of life and authority relationship.
Line Concept: Line functions are those that have direct impact on the accomplishment of the objectives of an organization. Example: policeperson controlling the mob.
Staff Concept: Staff functions are those that help the line persons work most effectively in accomplishing the objectives. Example: A person managing the budget of the organization.
Delegation
Delegation is the assignment to another person of formal authority (legitimate power) and responsibility for carrying out specific activities.
Nature of Relationship
Scalar Principle
The Scalar Principle states that the clearer the line of authority from the ultimate management position in an organization to every subordinate position, the clearer will be the responsibility for decision making and effective will be organization communication. In many large organizations the steps are long and complicated. It should become clear from the scalar principle that line authority is that relationship in which superior exercises direct supervision over subordinate.
π Definition β Scalar Principle: The clearer the line of authority from the ultimate management position to every subordinate position, the clearer the responsibility for decision making and organizational communication.
Functional Authority
Functional authority is the right that is delegated to an individual or a department to control specified processes, practices, policies, or other matters relating to activities undertaken by persons in other departments. If the principle of unity of command were followed, authority over these activities would be exercised by their line supervisor.
π Definition β Functional Authority: The right delegated to an individual or a department to control specified processes, practices, policies, or other matters relating to activities undertaken by persons in other departments.
Delegation of Functional Authority
Delegation of functional authority can be understood as a small slice of the authority of a line supervisor. The Chairman or head of institution has complete authority to manage the organization. In a pure staff situation, advisors on personnel, accounting, purchasing, etc., have no part of this line authority; their duty is to offer advice. But when the head of institution delegates his advisor to issue instructions to the line organization, that is called "functional authority."
Benefits of Staff
Today, staff advice is far more critical for business, government, and other enterprises than it was in the past. Operating managers are now faced with making decisions that require expert knowledge in economics, technical, political, and legal areas. Another major advantage of staff is that the specialists may be given time to think, to gather data, and to analyze to advise superiors, whereas busy managers cannot do this. It is rare that operating managers will find time to do analysis which the staff assistant can do as well.
Limitations of Staff
- Danger of undermining Line Authority: The advice of staff officers is taken by the executive with enthusiasm which may not be acceptable to line (operating) people because they think that staff has no experience of the work of line people.
- Lack of Staff Responsibility: Advisory departments only propose plans while line has to implement. When there is a problem in the implementation of plans, the blame is shifted to those who have advised. This creates a situation for shifting blame for mistakes on staff.
- Thinking in a Vacuum: Because staff people do not implement, they only advise, so what they advise, they are blamed for thinking in a vacuum.
Decentralization of Authority
Nature of Decentralization
Organization authority is given to people to use judgment to make decisions and give instructions. Decentralization is the tendency to disperse decision-making authority in an organized structure. It is a fundamental aspect of delegation; to the extent authority is not delegated, it is centralized. How much authority should be concentrated in or dispersed throughout the organization? There could be absolute centralization of authority in one person, but that means no subordinate managers and therefore, no structured organization. Some decentralization exists in all organizations. The degree of centralization and decentralization would vary from organization to organization.
π Definition β Decentralization: The tendency to disperse decision-making authority in an organized structure.
Centralization and Decentralization
The degree to which formal authority is delegated by a manager throughout the organization runs along a continuum from centralization to decentralization. In a relatively decentralized organization, considerable authority and responsibility is passed down the organizational hierarchy.
Different Kinds of Centralization
- Centralization of performance: It pertains to geographic concentration; it characterizes an organization operating in a single location.
- Departmental centralization: It refers to centralization of specialized activities, generally in one department. For example, maintenance for a whole plant may be carried out by a single department.
- Centralization as an aspect of management: It is the tendency to restrict delegation of decision making. A high degree of authority is held at or near the top by managers in the hierarchy.
β Key Takeaways
For an exam, a student must remember the clear distinction between power (the ability to influence) and authority (the formal right to decide based on one's position). The line and staff concepts are fundamental: line functions directly achieve organizational objectives, while staff functions provide expert advice and support. The scalar principle defines the clear chain of command, while functional authority is a delegated slice of a line manager's authority to a specialist. Finally, decentralization is the dispersion of decision-making authority, which exists on a continuum from centralization to decentralization, and is distinct from delegation and geographic concentration.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Compare and contrast "power" and "authority" as defined in the lecture.
- What is the primary difference between a "line function" and a "staff function" in an organization?
- Explain the "scalar principle" and its importance for organizational communication.
- Describe what "functional authority" is and how it differs from a pure staff advisory role.
- Define "decentralization of authority" and identify the three different kinds of centralization discussed in the lecture.
π Lecture 17 β Delegation of Authority
π Overview: This lecture explains the process of delegating authority within an organization and the personal attitudes that influence effective delegation. It covers guidelines to overcome weak delegation, factors determining the degree of delegation, and introduces the concept of coordination as a critical organizational process.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the step-by-step process of how authority is delegated, personal attitudes that help or hinder delegation, guidelines for overcoming weak delegation, factors that determine how much authority to delegate, and the concept of coordination as a process for integrating specialized activities across departments. The importance of specialization and its effects on organizational behavior are also discussed.
π Lecture Summary
How is Authority Delegated?
Authority is delegated through a structured process. First, results expected from a position are determined. Second, specific tasks and activities are assigned to that position. Third, the authority needed to accomplish those tasks is delegated to the position holder. Finally, the person is held responsible for completing the tasks.
π Definition β Delegation of Authority: The process of assigning tasks, granting authority to perform those tasks, and creating responsibility for their completion.
The Art of Delegation
Effective delegation often fails because managers are unwilling or unable to apply its principles. This is largely due to personal attitude. Positive attitudes that help delegation include: receptiveness β the willingness to give subordinates a chance to make decisions; willingness to let go β managers who have risen up must part with decisions they made at lower levels; willingness to let others make mistakes β if the cost is low, mistakes can be an investment in personal development; and willingness to trust subordinates β superiors must trust that subordinates can make decisions.
Guides to Overcoming Weak Delegation
There are several ways to overcome weak delegation. First, define assignments and delegate authority in light of results expected, giving sufficient authority to achieve goals. Second, select the right person suitable for the job. Third, maintain open lines of communication so you can tell subordinates and listen to them. Fourth, establish proper control by setting standards of work. Fifth, reward effective delegation and successful assumption of authority.
Determinants of Degree of Delegation of Authority
Several factors determine how much authority to delegate. The cost of the decision is a major factor β costly actions (in money or good will) are decided at upper levels. The desire for uniformity of policy favours centralization, e.g., standardized accounting procedures. The size and character of the organization matter β larger organizations tend to delegate more to speed decision-making. The history and culture of the enterprise influence whether to decentralize. Management philosophy β top management's thinking β sets the degree of delegation. Desire for independence means far-flung offices need delegated authority to avoid frustration from long lines of communication. Availability of managers β a shortage of well-trained managers leads to centralized decision-making. Finally, control techniques β effective delegation requires good control systems.
π‘ Why this matters: These eight factors help managers decide whether to centralize or decentralize authority, balancing efficiency with flexibility.
Coordination
Coordination is the process of integrating activities of separate departments to achieve organizational goals effectively and efficiently. Without coordination, people lose sight of their roles within the total organization and pursue their own departmental interests. Coordination is essential because of specialization or division of work β when people do specialized work, they develop narrow views. Specialization leads to four types of effects: 1) Own perception of organizational goals β e.g., an accountant sees cost control as most important; 2) Different time orientation β production people handle crises immediately, while R&D works in a relaxed way; 3) Effects on interpersonal styles β production people need clear answers, while research and marketing value relationships; 4) Degree of formality β production requires clear standards of performance.
π Definition β Coordination: The process of integrating activities of separate departments to achieve organizational goals effectively and efficiently.
π Definition β Specialization: Also referred to as division of labour, where work is broken down into specific tasks performed by individuals or departments.
β Key Takeaways
The process of delegating authority involves four steps: determining expected results, assigning tasks, delegating authority, and holding the person responsible. Effective delegation requires a positive personal attitude, including receptiveness, willingness to let go, tolerance for minor mistakes, and trust in subordinates. Weak delegation can be overcome by defining assignments clearly, selecting the right person, maintaining open communication, establishing proper controls, and rewarding delegation. The degree of delegation is determined by factors such as decision cost, policy uniformity, organization size, culture, management philosophy, independence needs, manager availability, and control techniques. Finally, coordination is essential to integrate specialized departments and counteract the narrow perspectives that specialization creates.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four steps in the process of delegating authority?
- List four personal attitudes that help a manager delegate effectively.
- What are five guidelines for overcoming weak delegation?
- Name four factors that determine how much authority should be delegated.
- What is coordination, and why is it important in organizations with high specialization?
π Lecture 18 β Planning β I
π Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational management function of planning. It defines planning as a future-oriented, rational process essential for achieving organizational goals. The lecture explains the importance, levels, and four major aspects of planning, and categorizes the different types of plans used in organizations, from broad mission statements to specific rules and budgets.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by establishing the critical importance of planning for organizational success and provides several formal definitions of the term, highlighting the common element of "future course of action." It then outlines the different levels of planning, from national to personal. The core of the lecture examines the four major aspects of planning: its contribution to objectives, its primacy in managerial tasks (illustrated by a foundational diagram), its pervasiveness across all management levels, and the distinction between plan efficiency and effectiveness. Finally, it categorizes the eight types of plans: Purpose/Mission, Objectives/Goals, Strategies, Policies, Procedures, Rules, Programs, and Budgets, with examples for each.
π Lecture Summary
Importance of Planning
Planning is identified as the most important activity of an organization and its managers. Without it, organizations may not be able to achieve their goals and objectives. π‘ Why this matters: Planning provides direction, reduces uncertainty, and sets the standard for all other management functions.
Definition
The term planning comes from the French word βprevoyanceβ, meaning "to look ahead."
- Pfiffner and Presthus: Planning is βa rational process characterized of all human behaviour.β
- Dimock and Dimock: βPlanning is an organized attempt to anticipate and to make rational arrangement for dealing with future problems by projecting trends.β
- Simon, Smithburg and Victor A. Thomson: βPlanning is that activity that concern itself with proposal for future, evaluation of alternative proposals and with method by which these proposals may be achieved.β
- Common Element: In all definitions, the core concept is a "future course of action."
π Definition β Planning: A future course of action.
Levels of Planning
Planning is done at different levels, varying in size and magnitude.
- National level: Made at the country level.
- Provincial level: Made at the provincial level.
- Organization level: Made at the organization level.
- Department level: Made at the department level.
- Unit level: Made at the unit level.
- Personal level: Could be a professional plan or a private plan.
Four Major Aspects of Planning
The nature of planning is understood by examining four key aspects:
1. Its contribution to purpose and objectives: Every plan must contribute to the accomplishment of the organization's purpose. This concept derives from the nature of an organized enterprise, which exists to accomplish a group purpose.
2. The importance of planning to the managerial tasks: Planning precedes all other managerial tasks (organizing, staffing, leading, motivating, controlling, budgeting, and evaluating). It is unique because it involves setting objectives.
-
Plan as Foundation of Management: The lecture presents a diagram showing that plans set objectives. This determines the kind of organization structure needed to achieve them. Managers then select the right people, who must be effectively led. Finally, control standards are developed to see if the plan achieved its objectives.
-
Relationship of Planning and Controlling: A second diagram illustrates the inextricable link between planning and controlling. After a plan is implemented, controlling involves comparing results with the plan. If there is no deviation, the process continues. If there is a deviation, corrective action is taken, which feeds back into the planning process.
3. The Pervasiveness: Planning is a function of all managers. If managers are not allowed to plan to a certain degree, they may not be able to function as managers. All managers plan, from the chief executive to the first-level supervisor.
π Definition β Pervasiveness of Plan: The existence of plan at all levels of the organization.
4. The efficiency vs. effectiveness of plans:
- A plan is efficient if it achieves its purpose while minimizing cost. If the cost is higher than the benefits, the plan is inefficient. It is about the contribution of the plan to the objectives.
- Effectiveness is the achievement of the goals and objectives set out in the plan.
π Definition β Control: Establishing standards and measuring performance against them.
Types of Plans
Plans are future courses of action and are classified by their time frame and purpose. The eight types are:
1. Purpose or Mission: The mission or purpose identifies the basic task of the organization. Every organization should have one. π Example: The purpose of the National Highway Authority is to design, build, and operate national highways. The purpose of courts is to interpret laws.
2. Objectives or Goals: Objectives or goals are the ends towards which activity is aimed. They represent the end point of planning and the end toward which organizing, staffing, leading, and controlling are aimed. Departmental objectives are more specific and are sometimes called "targets." π Example: An organization's objective might be to make a profit by producing television sets. The production department's objective would be to produce 2000 television sets in a year of a given design and quality at a given cost.
3. Strategies: Strategies mean a βgrand planβ made in light of what an opponent might do or not do. It is defined as the determination of a long-term plan of an organization, the following course of action, and the allocation of resources necessary to achieve the goals.
4. Policies: Policies are general statements or understandings that guide or channel thinking in decision-making. They define an area within which a decision is to be made to ensure consistency with objectives. π Example: A Policy of Privatization.
5. Procedures: Procedures are plans that establish a required method of handling future activities. They are guides to action, spelling out the exact manner in which activities are to be accomplished. π Example: The procedure of making a passport, or how police should issue a challan to a traffic violator.
6. Rules: Rules spell out specific action or non-action, allowing no discretion. Unlike procedures, they guide action without specifying a time sequence. π Example: Traffic Rules, Pension Rules.
π Definition β Plan: A document which delineates a future course of action.
β Key Takeaways
- Planning is the foundational management function, preceding and informing all others (organizing, staffing, leading, controlling). It is a rational process focused on a "future course of action."
- Planning is pervasive, meaning it is done at all levels of the organization, from top management to first-line supervisors, and at all levels (national to personal).
- The efficiency of a plan measures its cost-effectiveness (output vs. cost), while effectiveness measures whether it achieved its stated goals. An ideal plan is both efficient and effective.
- There are eight distinct types of plans, ranging from the broad mission and objectives to the specific procedures and rules, each serving a different purpose in guiding action.
- Planning and controlling are inextricably linked. Control involves measuring results against the plan, and deviations trigger corrective action, which informs future planning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the single common element found in all definitions of planning?
- What is the difference between a "procedure" and a "rule" as types of plans?
- How does planning act as a "foundation" for the other managerial functions?
- Explain the difference between an efficient plan and an effective plan.
- What are the four major aspects of planning discussed in the lecture?
π Lecture 19 β Planning β II
π Overview: This lecture completes the discussion of plan types by examining programmes and budgets. It then presents the eight-step planning process as a rational, sequential method for setting and achieving organizational objectives, and concludes with three key principles for effective planning and the hierarchy of objectives.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the remaining types of plansβprogrammes and budgetsβfollowed by the detailed eight-step planning process: recognizing the need for planning, determining objectives, forecasting, determining and evaluating alternatives, selecting a course of action, implementing, and revising. It explains planning as a rational process using a diagram of progress over time, and introduces three principles of plans: time horizon, commitment principle, and coordination of short- and long-term plans. The lecture ends with the hierarchy of objectives, from socio-economic purpose down to individual employee objectives.
π Lecture Summary
Programmes
Programmes are a complex of goal, policies, rules, tasks, procedures, and resources to be employed. Programmes have a time period and are for specific purposes. Examples include Rural Support Programmes, Employees Development Programme, and Tawana Pakistan Programme.
Budgets
A budget is a statement of expected results expressed in numerical terms. It is referred to as a 'numberized' plan. For private sector organizations, the financial operating budget is called a 'profit plan'. For public sector organizations, a budget expresses income and expenditure. It expresses the effectiveness of the organization in accomplishing its goals and objectives. The Federal, Provincial, and District Budgets express the policies of respective governments in providing public services.
Planning Process
There are eight steps in the planning process:
- Recognizing the need for planning
- Determining the objectives
- Forecasting the future
- Determining alternatives
- Evaluating alternatives
- Selecting a course of action
- Implementing the plan
- Revising the plan
1. Recognizing the Need for Planning
This precedes planning and starts with the intention of either solving a problem or attaining some objectives. Organizations have a need for planning to use scarce resources efficiently, make the best use of opportunities, and prepare for threats. This is because plans are considered a future course of action. Organizations have to look ahead to solve their problems.
2. Determining Objectives
The second step in the planning process is establishing objectives for the organization and then for each subordinate/employee. Objectives specify expected results and indicate the end point of what is to be done by the organization and by its employees. Objectives are to be accomplished by the network of strategies, policies, procedures, rules, budgets, and programmes.
π Example:
- To increase literacy by 5% from the last year
- To open schools in 5 villages of the province
- To increase profits by 2%
3. Forecasting the Future
Forecasting is based on certain assumptions about the future in which the plan is to be carried out. The basis of forecasting is the understanding of markets, what services need to be provided, what technological change there will be, and what population changes there will be. Government publishes documents like 'Economic Survey', State Bank of Pakistan Report, and Bureau of Statistics Census, which are used by social scientists to forecast economic and social trends in the country.
4. Determining Alternatives
This involves examining alternative courses of action. There would hardly be a plan for which alternatives do not exist.
π Example: What are the alternatives to increase literacy? The alternatives could be:
- To open new schools
- To have more shifts in the existing schools
- To ask the private sector to open schools
The government may adopt one alternative or a combination of objectives.
5. Evaluating Alternatives
Each alternative is evaluated or examined in terms of cost and benefits. One course of action may have large investment and little benefit in the short run. Another alternative may be risky and have more benefits/profits.
π Example:
- To open new schools β This alternative may require more money
- To have more shifts in the existing schools β This alternative requires less money compared to alternative 1 because of the use of existing facilities
- To ask the private sector to open schools β This alternative may not require money from the government at all
π‘ Why this matters: In evaluation of alternatives, the estimation of cost and benefits is very important because the decision is taken on its basis.
6. Selecting One Alternative
At this point, the decision has to be taken to adopt an alternative from the various alternatives. The choice could be to pick one or more than one alternative, depending on the emphasis on objectives to be achieved and the cost. At this stage, the plans are made part of the budget. Budgets become the means of tying up the plans.
7. Implementing the Plan
Implementation of a plan is the most crucial aspect. The implementation determines whether the plan was able to achieve the objectives or not.
8. Revising the Plan
Planning as a Rational Process. As indicated by the planning process, it is a rational approach to accomplish objectives.
The Planning Process Diagram
In this diagram, progress (high profits, more services, etc.) is shown on the vertical axis and time on the horizontal axis. Point X indicates where we are (tβ) and point Y indicates where we want to be at a future time (tβ). Often we do not have all the data, but we start planning, and we may start our planning at Xβ. The arrows shown around the line XY are the assumptions that we make about the future. When we plan, we are charting an unknown territory. The line XY is the decision path. If the future were completely certain, the line XY would be relatively easy to draw. But since the future is uncertain, we make assumptions about the future.
Three Principles of Plans
There are three principles of plans:
- Time Horizon: There are long-term and short-term plans. The question is how long-term plans can be coordinated with short-term plans. What is the duration of a plan? These questions suggest multiple horizons of plans.
- Commitment Principle: The key to choosing the right planning periods seems to be in the commitment principle: logical planning encompasses a future period of time necessary to fulfil the series of actions, the commitment in decisions made today.
- Coordination of Short-term and Long-term Plans: Often, short-term plans are made without reference to long-range plans. There is a need to integrate the short- and long-term plans.
Hierarchy of Objectives
There is a hierarchy of objectives, which are a kind of plan and provide a guide for planning. The objectives start from the top of the organization and are formulated by the Board of Directors of the organization. These are then translated into the overall objectives of the organization (strategic), which in turn are made more specific for division objectives. Lower-level management objectives are performance-related and personal development objectives.
So, plans are formulated based on the socio-economic purpose of the organization and translated down to the lowest level.
β Key Takeaways
The planning process is a rational, sequential approach to problem-solving and goal attainment, moving from recognizing a need to revising the plan based on outcomes. Programmes and budgets are distinct types of plans that operationalize goals using specific resources and numerical targets. Evaluation and selection of alternatives are critical, as decisions depend on comparing the costs and benefits of each option. Planning must account for uncertainty through forecasting, and all plans are governed by the principles of time horizon, commitment, and the integration of short- and long-term objectives. The hierarchy of objectives ensures alignment from the organization's socio-economic purpose down to individual employee performance goals.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the eight steps of the planning process in their correct sequence?
- How does a budget differ from a programme as a type of plan?
- What is the commitment principle, and how does it relate to the time horizon of a plan?
- Using the example of increasing literacy, explain how the evaluation of alternatives (step 5) leads to the selection of a course of action (step 6).
- Describe the hierarchy of objectives and explain how the objectives of a lower-level manager are linked to the organization's socio-economic purpose.
π Lecture 20 β Planning Commission and Planning Development
π Overview: This lecture explains the evolution and role of Pakistanβs national and provincial planning organizations, focusing on the Planning Commission and Provincial Planning & Development Departments. It details the systematic process of project completion β from identification to evaluation β and how these organizations coordinate development efforts for socio-economic growth.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the historical need for planning in Pakistan, the creation of the Development Board (1948) and Planning Board (1953), the establishment of the Planning Commission (1958) with its organization and functions. It explains the complementary relationship between national plans and projects, defines what a project is with its characteristics, and walks through the seven-step project completion process. Finally, it describes the structure and functions of Provincial Planning & Development organizations and their approval authorities.
π Lecture Summary
The Need for Planning
At independence, Pakistan had inadequate social and physical infrastructure, requiring development of roads, industry, schools, dams, power houses, hospitals, and other government structures. In 1948, the Development Board was created in the Economic Affairs Division to plan socio-economic development, and it prepared a Six-Year Development Plan in 1950. In 1953, the Government created the Planning Board to develop the countryβs resources rapidly, promote welfare, provide adequate living standards, social welfare services, and secure social justice and equality of opportunity for all.
Organization Chart Planning Commission & Planning Development Division
In 1958, the Planning Board was re-designated as the Planning Commission. Its objectives remained similar but additionally included consulting Central, Provincial, and relevant agencies to prepare national plans and assess human and material resources. The Planning Commission became the highest body for making national plans, headed by a Deputy Chairman. The organization includes: Deputy Chairman, Chief Economist, Secretary, Members (Infrastructure, Social Sector, Production & Management), Admin, JCE (Operation), Sr. Chief Agri. & Food, Jr. Chief Economist (Macro), Additional Secretary Projects Wing, and various Chiefs of Section.
Functions
The major functions of the Planning Commission are:
- To prepare a comprehensive national plan for socio-economic development of the country.
- To formulate, within the national plan framework, an annual plan and annual development programme including projects and programs of national development.
- Monitoring the implementation of all major development projects and programmes (above Rs. 40 million).
- Continuous evaluation of the economic situation and coordination of economic policies.
- Examination and technical appraisal of development projects received from Federal Ministries and Provincial Government for consideration by the Central Development Working Party (CDWP) and Executive Committee of National Economic Council (ECNEC).
Relationship of Plan and Projects
There is a complementary relationship between plan and projects. Projects are to plan what bricks are to a building. A national plan comprises a number of small projects.
What is a Project?
A project is a work undertaken to achieve goals in a given time period. It has the following characteristics:
- Investment of resources: all projects require resources like capital, machinery, and equipment.
- Consumes inputs and gives outputs: when projects start producing, they consume inputs (raw material) to produce output.
- Has a beginning and an end: a project starts, gets completed, and then begins producing output or service. Examples: Tarbela Dam Project, School Construction Project, Highway Project (N-5).
Process of Project Completion
A project follows a sequential process of βbeginningβ and ending:
1. Project Identification: A project is identified by representatives of the people, experts, surveys, media, etc. Project identification means a need is felt by the community to have a project. For example, a community may need clean drinking water or a proper sewerage system and then approach the government to construct a water reservoir.
2. Project Feasibility: This is an in-depth study of the technical, financial, and economic viability of the project. It is based on surveys and research studies to determine if the project will cover its costs and remain in demand.
3. Project Preparation: The details of the project study are put into a form called PC-I, a Planning Commission form. It requires information such as sponsoring organization, time of completion, inclusion in the plan, cost, location, history, source of financing, inputs, etc.
4. Project Appraisal: This is a careful checking of the basic data collected through surveys, assumptions, and methodology used in project preparation. It is a review of project data and information undertaken by the concerned technical section of the Planning Commission.
5. Project Approval: After appraisal, the project goes to an approving body. The project approving bodies are:
- National Economic Council (NEC)
- Executive Committee of NEC (ECNEC) and Economic Coordination Committee of Cabinet
- Central Development Working Party (CDWP): Approves all provincial schemes costing up to Rs. 100 million
- Departmental Development Working Party
- Provincial Development Working Party (PDWP): Each province has one that scrutinizes projects for inclusion in Annual and Five Year Plans.
6. Project Implementation: The project becomes part of the annual programme, receives annual budget allocation, and is then implemented and completed.
7. Project Evaluation: When the project is completed, it is evaluated to assess problems faced during implementation and whether the project meets the need for which it was completed.
Provincial Planning Organization
At the provincial level, there is the Planning and Development Department (P&D). The P&D is headed by the Chairman P&D, while the Secretary P&D is the administrative head. The Chairman is assisted by a Chief Economist, Members, and Joint Chief Economist. Members are assisted by Chiefs of Section, each dealing with one or more sectors of the provincial economy (agriculture, forestry, tourism, livestock, irrigation, industry, water supply, social welfare, population planning, education, etc.). The Chief of Section may be an engineer, economist, or generalist.
π Definition β Chief of Section: A position in the P&D Department assisting Members, each responsible for one or more sectors of the provincial economy.
Functions
The functions of P&D are:
- To prepare the Annual Development Programme in coordination with other departments.
- To prepare Five Year and other development plans.
- To clear schemes to be sent to ECNEC/CDWP.
- To coordinate External Capital Assistance.
Approval Authority
The Planning Department is the Secretariat for PDWP (Provincial Development Working Party) and serves as a clearing house for development projects from different line departments. The PDWP can approve projects ranging from Rs. 100 million to Rs. 1000 million.
Conclusions
Planning organizations have evolved in Pakistan and perform functions for the overall development of the country. The process of planning is systematic and rational because there are established institutions and processes of planning.
π Definition β Project: a distinct activity which requires investment and has a beginning and end. π Definition β Project cycle: a sequential process of project identification, feasibility, preparation, appraisal, approval, implementation, and evaluation.
β Key Takeaways
The Planning Commission evolved from the 1948 Development Board and is the highest national planning body in Pakistan, tasked with preparing comprehensive national, annual, and five-year plans. A project is a distinct activity requiring investment with a beginning and end, and its completion follows a seven-step project cycle: identification, feasibility, preparation (PC-I), appraisal, approval (by CDWP, PDWP, ECNEC, etc.), implementation, and evaluation. At the provincial level, the Planning & Development Department coordinates development plans and approves projects between Rs. 100 million and Rs. 1000 million through the PDWP. The complementary relationship between plans and projects means that national plans are composed of multiple smaller projects. The entire planning process is systematic and rational, built on formal institutions and procedures to ensure socio-economic development.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the name of the first planning body created in Pakistan in 1948, and what plan did it prepare in 1950?
- List the seven steps in the project completion cycle in the correct sequential order.
- What is the difference between the approval authority of CDWP (Central Development Working Party) and PDWP (Provincial Development Working Party)?
- What information is typically recorded on a PC-I form during project preparation?
- What are the four main functions of the Provincial Planning and Development Department (P&D)?