π Lecture 21 β Decision Making
π Overview: This lecture explores the critical relationship between decision making and planning in public administration. It defines decision making as the selection of a course of actionβthe core of planningβand examines various theories, models, and limitations that shape how managers make decisions. Understanding these concepts is essential for effective administration, as decision making is the most important action performed by managers.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining decision making and establishing its centrality to planning. It then examines the Organizational Process Model and the concept of Rationality in Decision Making, including the crucial idea of Limited Rationality. The steps in rational decision making are outlined, followed by a discussion of programmed and non-programmed types of decisions. Decision making situations and approaches to improve decision qualityβincluding Risk Analysis, Decision Trees, and Preference Theoryβare covered, concluding with factors that affect the decision-making process.
π Lecture Summary
Definition
First of all we will define decision making. It is defined as the selection of course of action. It is the core of planning. A plan cannot exist unless decision has been made. Decision making is the most important action by managers.
Theories on Decision Making
There are many theories of decision making but we will discuss the following:
- Organizational Process Model
- Rationality in Decision Making
Organizational Process Model All organizations follow rules, procedures & systems. Decisions in organizations are made according to the procedures and systems that organizations have. For example, in a centralized organization, decisions will come from the top down. In an organization where authority is dispersed, participative decisions will be made. So the processes and standard operating procedure (SOP) will determine the quality of decisions made.
Rationality in Decision Making It is said that effective decision making must be rational. But what is rationality? When is a thinking person deciding rationally? People deciding rationally are attempting to reach goals in a systematic way. They collect all:
- relevant information,
- analyze information,
- evaluate and
- make choice
So these are 4 basic steps in making a rational decision. If we follow these steps can we make the βbest decisionβ? Can we get all information for all alternatives?
Limited Rationality People have worked on the issues pertaining to all information to be collected for all alternatives. What has been analyzed is that it is humanly impossible to collect all information for all alternatives. A manager must settle for limited rationality. Information is limited, time is limited and certainty is limited. Therefore managers dislike risk and do not reach the best solution. The decision making is βsatisficingβ, that is, picking a course of action that is good enough.
Steps in Rational Decision Making
-
Search for alternatives: Given that we know our objectives, the first step in decision making is to search for alternatives. Search for alternatives is based on the concept of βlimiting factorβ. The Principle of the limiting factor is to recognize and overcome factors that stand critically in the way of goals; the best course of action can be selected.
-
Evaluation of Alternatives: The next step in decision making is to evaluate and select one that contributes best to the goals.
When deciding about one alternative, managers can use three basic approaches:
- Experience
- Experimentation
- Research and Analysis
Usually managers use their experience and judgment to select an alternative. Experience and judgment is really reliance on the past. The other method by which managers select alternatives is experimentation, i.e., managers would try an alternative and see its results. The 3rd method is arriving at alternatives through researching and analysis. The interrelationship between the 3 methods is shown in Figure 1.
Types of Decision
It would be better to know the types of decision that organizations usually take. These are:
-
Programmed
-
Non Programmed
-
Programmed decision is structured or repetitive or routine decision. Example: Reordering of standard inventory item, checking at a check post.
-
Non-Programmed decisions are used for unstructured, novel and ill-defined situations of non-recurring nature. Example: Introduction of new product in the market.
At the lowest level in hierarchy, structured and programmed decisions are made. Whereas non-programmed and unstructured decisions are made at the highest level in an organization.
Decision Making Situations
All decisions are made in some degree of uncertainty. Uncertainty is related to the unknown future. Certainty varies from relative certainty to uncertainty. With increase in uncertainty the risk increases. This increase in risk is based on the degree of information about future. The more distant the decision is to be made in future, the more uncertain is the situation.
There are two methods by which quality of decision and certainty can be improved. These are:
- Mathematical model (objective probabilities)
- Judgement and experience (subjective probabilities)
Approaches to Decision making
A number of modern techniques are used to improve the quality of decision making under normal conditions of uncertainty. The most important are:
-
Risk Analysis
-
Decision tree
-
Preference theory
-
Risk Analysis: An intelligent decision maker would like to know the size of risk they are taking in deciding to choose a course of action. π Definition β Risk Analysis: A technique that helps a decision maker understand the probability of different outcomes (gains or losses) associated with a particular course of action. π Example: There is a situation where you have to take a decision and you have worked out the probabilities of gains:
- For situation 1, the gain is 0 and the probability is 90%.
- The highest gain is 35 points and the probability is 40%.
- The probability of gain is highest where gain is 10 and probability is 80%.
| Gain | 0 | 10 | 15 | 20 | 25 | 30 | 35 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Probability of achieving this gain | .90 | .80 | .70 | .65 | .60 | .50 | .40 |
π‘ Why this matters: A manager who is not risk-averse will go for the highest gain (35) despite its lower probability (40%), while a more cautious manager might choose the option with the highest probability of gain (10 with 80% probability).
- Decision Tree: A decision tree approach makes it possible to see major alternatives and the subsequent decisions may depend on events in future. π Example: Figure 3 depicts a decision tree for an organization to choose between either having permanent security staff of its own or contracting out security service.
- Option 1 (Permanent Security Staff): Successful implementation gives a gain of Rs. 100,000; failure costs Rs. 200,000.
- Option 2 (Contracting Out): Success gives a gain of Rs. 200,000; failure costs Rs. 100,000.
In the final analysis, contracting out appears to give more potential gains.
- Preference or utility theory explains individual attitude toward risk. Some people are willing to take small risk (risk averters), others are willing to take greater risk (gambler). π Example: If there is a 60% chance of being right and having 20 gains, or a 40% chance of being wrong and having 30 gains, would the person take the risk of taking that decision for 40 chances and having higher gains?
Factors Affecting Decision-Making Process
Following are some of the factors that influence decision making:
- Personal Differences: People have different personality, experiences and perception and that influences their decision making.
- Role of Knowledge: The knowledge of people varies, therefore, individual managers will make decisions based on the amount of knowledge they possess.
- Institutional Factors: Institutional factors such as organization structure, procedure and system affect decision making.
Concepts
π Definition β Rational decision: a systematic and sequential process of making decisions and achieving objectives. π Definition β Limited rationality: managers have limited time and information therefore their decisions are not fully rational but are "satisficing".
β Key Takeaways
Decision making is the core of planning, defined as the selection of a course of action, and is the most critical action performed by managers. While rational decision making involves a systematic process of searching for alternatives and evaluating them, managers must accept the reality of limited rationality, where they have limited time and information and must settle for a "satisficing" rather than optimal solution. Decisions can be classified as programmed (routine and structured, made at lower levels) or non-programmed (novel and unstructured, made at higher levels). To improve decision quality under uncertainty, managers can use modern techniques like Risk Analysis, Decision Trees, and Preference Theory, which help assess probabilities and risk tolerance. Finally, personal differences, knowledge, and institutional factors all significantly influence the decision-making process in organizations.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of decision making, and why is it considered the "core of planning"?
- What is "limited rationality" and why does it lead managers to "satisfice" rather than find the best solution?
- What is the difference between a programmed decision and a non-programmed decision, and at what organizational level is each typically made?
- In the risk analysis example, which gain option has the highest probability of being achieved, and which option is most attractive to a risk-taking manager?
- What are the three approaches managers can use to evaluate alternatives during the decision-making process?
π Lecture 22 β Human Resource Management (HRM)
π Overview: This lecture introduces Human Resource Management (HRM) as the most vital function in any organization. It explains why human resources are critical, outlines the seven-step HRM process, and provides detailed coverage of human resource planning, recruitment, job analysis, and selection. Understanding HRM is essential because it ensures organizations have the right people in the right positions at the right time.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of staffing and human resource management, the importance of HRM to organizations, the complete HRM process including human resource planning, recruitment, job and position descriptions, sources for recruitment, and the selection process. Key concepts such as job description, position description, and hiring specification are defined.
π Lecture Summary
Concept of Staffing (Human Resource Management)
All organizations have three important resources: material, capital, and human. The human resource is the most vital because it drives or moves all other resources in the organization. This resource can increase the efficiency, economy, and effectiveness of other resources. Human beings are the most unpredictable resource, making them most difficult to control; however, if managed properly, human resources can give wonderful results that no other resource can provide.
Human Resource Management (HRM) is both a management function and a staff function through which managers recruit, select, train, and develop organization members. HRM managers advise line managers throughout the organization about what people to recruit for different departments.
π Definition β Human Resource Management (HRM): The management and staff function through which managers recruit, select, train, and develop organization members to keep the organization supplied with the right people in the right positions when they are needed.
Importance of Human Resource
HRM is a staff function that becomes important because organizations need employees and managers from time to time. The HRM process is an ongoing procedure that tries to keep the organization supplied with the right people in the right positions when they are needed.
The HRM process includes seven basic activities:
- Human resource planning
- Recruitment
- Selection
- Socialization
- Training and development
- Performance appraisal
- Promotion, transfers, and demotions
Human Resource Planning
Human resource planning is the first step in HRM. It deals with the future requirements of human assets for the organization. An organization that does not plan for human resources may find that it is not meeting either its personnel requirements or its overall goals effectively.
Human resource planning has the following components:
-
Planning for future needs: The organization must decide how many people it will need in the future and what kind of skills those people will possess. The organization should be able to forecast its future human requirements.
-
Planning for future balance: The organization must determine the future balance of its human resource by examining how many people will retire or likely leave the organization. HRM should compare the number of employees needed to the number of present employees who can be expected to stay.
-
Planning for recruiting or laying off employees: This determines how many employees will be recruited and how many will be laid off.
-
Planning for the development of employees: Once new employees are recruited, they need to be trained for the jobs in the organization.
Recruitment
The purpose of recruitment is to provide a group of candidates large enough to let managers select the qualified employees they need.
π Definition β Recruitment: The development of a pool of job candidates in accordance with a human resource plan.
Job and Position Descriptions
Before employees can be recruited, recruiters must have clear ideas regarding the activities, responsibilities, and qualifications required for the job being filled. Job analysis is therefore an early step in the recruitment process.
In Job analysis, each job in the organization is categorized. For each job, the activities and responsibilities are enumerated, and then the qualifications, experience, knowledge, and skills required to perform the job are written down.
The three components of job analysis are:
-
Job description: A written description of a non-management job, covering title, duties, and responsibilities, and including its location on the organization chart.
-
Position description: A written description of a management position, covering title, duties, and responsibilities, and including its location on the organization chart.
-
Hiring specification: A written description of the education, experience, and skills needed to perform a job or fill a position effectively.
Once a specific job has been analyzed, a written statement of its content and location is included in the organization chart. This statement is called either a job description or a position description.
π Definition β Job Description: A written description of a non-management job, covering title, duties, and responsibilities, and including its location on the organization chart.
π Definition β Position Description: A written description of a management position, covering title, duties, and responsibilities, and including its location on the organization chart.
π Definition β Hiring Specification: A written description of the education, experience, and skills needed to perform a job or fill a position effectively.
Sources for Recruitment
Recruitment takes place within the labour market β that is, the pool of available people who have the skills to fill vacant positions. The labour market changes over time in response to environmental factors.
The labour market for different jobs would be different. For example, the labour market for doctors, accountants, financial managers, history teachers, clerks, messengers, and cleaners will each come from their respective groups.
Selection
The selection process ideally involves mutual decision. The organization decides whether to make a job offer and how attractive the offer should be made so that the right people join the organization. The candidate has to decide whether the organization and the job offer fit his or her needs and goals, including whether it provides just income or also challenge in the job.
In reality, the selection process is often more one-sided because the organization has the upper edge. When the job market is extremely tight, several candidates will apply for each position, and managers will use a series of screening devices to identify the most suitable candidates.
On the other hand, when there is a shortage of qualified workers, or when the candidate is a highly qualified executive or professional, organizations will have to make the offer attractive to the candidate.
β Key Takeaways
Human Resource Management is the most vital organizational function because human resources drive all other resources and can increase their efficiency, economy, and effectiveness. The HRM process consists of seven sequential activities beginning with human resource planning and ending with promotions, transfers, and demotions. Job analysis, which produces job descriptions, position descriptions, and hiring specifications, is essential before any recruitment can take place. Recruitment aims to create a pool of qualified candidates from the labour market, while selection involves mutual decision-making where the organization typically holds the advantage. Understanding the distinction between job description (for non-management positions) and position description (for management positions) is critical for proper HRM implementation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three important resources of any organization, and why is the human resource considered the most vital?
- List the seven basic activities included in the HRM process in their correct order.
- What are the four components of human resource planning?
- What is the difference between a job description and a position description?
- How does the selection process differ when there is a tight job market versus when there is a shortage of qualified workers?