๐ Lecture 19 โ Knowledge Market Model and KVA Case Study
๐ Overview: This lecture explores two key approaches to knowledge management: the knowledge market framework, which views knowledge exchanges as marketplace transactions within organizations, and the Knowledge Value Added (KVA) methodology, applied through a detailed case study of Exodus Communications Inc. The lecture demonstrates how KVA can be used to measure the value created by knowledge assets in core business processes, particularly valuable for companies not amenable to traditional financial analysis.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the Knowledge Market Framework, defining buyers (local and global), sellers, and brokers in organizational knowledge markets. It then presents a comprehensive KVA case study of Exodus Communications Inc., an Internet infrastructure company, showing how KVA analysis works at both the aggregate level (core areas of Management, S&GA, and Operations) and the operational level (the sales provisioning process with its six sub-processes). The lecture concludes with practical applications and benefits of KVA analysis for management.
๐ Lecture Summary
Knowledge Market Framework
Within the economic school, knowledge transfers occur in knowledge markets. This is a transactional perspective where knowledge exchanges happen in a marketplace. In defining any market, one must be clear about who the buyers and sellers are, and what pricing system exists to determine what the consumer pays. Knowledge markets exist within every organization, including not only codified knowledge in processes, structure, technology, or strategy, but also all dynamic exchanges of knowledge between buyers and suppliers.
According to Grover and Davenport (2001), organizations have two categories of buyers of knowledge: local buyers and global buyers. Local buyers are people searching for knowledge assets to address an issue they need to resolve โ they require more than information, needing expertise, experience, insight, and judgment. They could pay for knowledge in hard currency via a consultant from outside, or buy the knowledge from internal suppliers. The global knowledge buyer is the firm itself, which has a vested interest in realizing knowledge assets into valuable products and services. The global knowledge buyer, represented by organizational stakeholders, has a strong interest in transferring local knowledge to global knowledge to reduce dependency on knowledge sellers.
Knowledge sellers are people who have knowledge (usually tacit) to sell. The quality of this knowledge might be high or low depending on the credibility of the source. Davenport and Prusak's approach to knowledge management is concerned with knowledge markets. A knowledge market can be defined as a system in which participants exchange a scarce unit for present or future value. Buyers, sellers, and brokers play roles on knowledge markets.
๐ Definition โ Knowledge Market: A system in which participants exchange a scarce unit for present or future value, with buyers, sellers, and brokers.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding knowledge markets helps organizations recognize that tacit knowledge is a valuable asset that can be exchanged internally, reducing reliance on external consultants and retaining critical expertise when employees leave.
KVA: Case Study of Exodus Communications Inc.
The following example shows how KVA (Knowledge Value Added) can be applied to a company in the Internet infrastructure marketplace. The same general approach can be extended to any company โ the KVA methodology is generic and robust enough to be applicable to companies and core processes in any industry.
Exodus Communications Inc. Financial Summary: Exodus is a leading provider of web hosting services, offering data center, Internet access, and managed services. Key facts:
- Price: $34, 52-week Range: $15-$89
- Shares outstanding: 412.4 million
- EPS 99A: $(0.36), EPS 2000E: $(0.6)
- P/E: NM (not meaningful), Market capitalization: NM
The company is a typical Internet infrastructure company that cannot be meaningfully evaluated by traditional financial ratios โ the P/E ratio is not derivable because the company has no positive net income. The price-to-book value of Exodus is 44.59 while the industry average is 16.69 and the S&P 500 is 9.66. The price-to-tangible value is 67.99 while the industry average is 20.51 and the S&P 500 is 12.77. This shows that Exodus stock is being valued more richly relative to the value of its assets than the S&P 500, illustrating that most of the company's value comes from underlying knowledge assets embedded in the company structure and culture, not reflected on traditional accounting statements.
Company Description: Founded in 1994, Exodus offers system and network management solutions and technology professional services. As of December 31, 1999, the company had over 2,200 customers under contract and managed over 27,000 customer servers worldwide. Customers include Yahoo!, USA TODAY.com, weather.com, priceline.com, British Airways, and Nordstrom. The company operates Internet data centers in nine U.S. metropolitan areas plus London and Tokyo. Exodus offers three types of services: (1) Internet server hosting, (2) Network solutions, and (3) System management and monitoring services.
Current Issues: Exodus has three areas of concern:
- Decreasing profit margin: Bandwidth and co-location services are becoming commodities with smaller margins due to increased competition.
- Expansion opportunity: Core customers are mostly "blue chip" Fortune 500 companies; opportunities exist for smaller customers requiring standardized solutions, but the current labor-intensive process of service selection and network architecture and design (NAD) makes expansion difficult.
- Emerging competition: Will lower the average revenue per user.
The goal of the KVA exercise is to identify areas for focus on increasing revenue from existing knowledge assets, rather than just cutting costs.
Aggregate-Level KVA
A rough-cut estimate KVA on Exodus is targeted at the aggregate level of analysis. Top executives can benchmark the company's use of knowledge assets against other industries, and management can look at the level of performance in core processes before deciding how to improve.
Assumptions and Methodology: The KVA team interviews process subject matter experts (SMEs), makes observations, and talks with process employees and managers to obtain average learning-time estimates and the number of roughly equivalent process instructions required to complete each sub-process. Numbers such as number of employees and expenses were annualized figures from 1999 financial statements.
Step 1: Determine the core areas โ Executives categorize the company's functions at the aggregate level into three areas: a. Management: Includes finance and strategic management b. S&GA (Sales and General Administration): Includes all supporting functions such as HR, public relations, and marketing c. Operations: Includes sales support and design, service selection and NAD, procurement, integration, troubleshooting, and final testing
Step 2: Gather data on knowledge embedded using the learning time approach: a. Ranking: Executives rank the three areas from hardest to easiest to learn (or most to least complex). This creates a framework for first-cut analysis of knowledge created in each area and is assumed to correlate with the 100-month learning time estimate. b. Learning time estimation: Executives estimate how long it would take the average person to learn to produce the outputs of each core area using the 100-month approach โ there is a total of only 100 months for an average person to learn everything in the above areas necessary to generate the annual revenue at Exodus.
Step 3: Weight the amount of knowledge executed in the process: a. Determine the number of employees within each core area b. Ask for the percentage of the process that is automated c. Calculate the percentage of knowledge contained in each process, including its supporting technology (amount of knowledge = relative learning time ร number of employees + automation) d. Determine the annual budget for each core process e. Calculate the ROK ratio (Return on Knowledge) to estimate the value added by given knowledge assets in each process
Table 7.2 High-Level Aggregate KVA Analysis:
| Core areas | Rank | Learning time | Employees | Automation% | Knowledge in automation | Total knowledge | Knowledge% | Revenue ($M) | Expense ($M) | ROK |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S&GA | 1 | 20 | 855 | 80% | 13,680 | 30,780 | 34.18% | $82.7 | $118.8 | 70% |
| Operations | 3 | 45 | 600 | 60% | 16,200 | 43,200 | 47.98% | $116.1 | $197.2 | 59% |
| Management | 2 | 35 | 255 | 80% | 7,140 | 16,065 | 17.84% | $43.2 | $51.0 | 85% |
Key calculations from the table:
-
Column 6 (Knowledge in automation): Learning time ร Employees ร Automation%
- S&GA: 20 ร 855 ร 80% = 13,680
- Operations: 45 ร 600 ร 60% = 16,200
- Management: 35 ร 255 ร 80% = 7,140
-
Column 7 (Total knowledge): (Learning time ร Employees) + Knowledge in automation
- S&GA: (20 ร 855) + 13,680 = 30,780
- Operations: (45 ร 600) + 16,200 = 43,200
- Management: (35 ร 255) + 7,140 = 16,065
-
Column 8 (Knowledge allocation %): Total knowledge for area รท Total knowledge for all areas ร 100%
- Total knowledge = 30,780 + 43,200 + 16,065 = 90,045
- S&GA: (30,780/90,045) ร 100% = 34.18%
- Operations: (43,200/90,045) ร 100% = 47.98%
- Management: (16,065/90,045) ร 100% = 17.84%
-
Column 9 (Revenue allocation): Total revenue ($242M) ร Knowledge allocation%
- S&GA: $242 ร 34.18% = $82.7M
- Operations: $242 ร 47.98% = $116.1M
- Management: $242 ร 17.84% = $43.2M
-
Column 11 (ROK): Allocated revenue รท Cost to use knowledge
- S&GA: $82.7/$118.8 = 70%
- Operations: $116.1/$197.2 = 59%
- Management: $43.2/$51.0 = 85%
๐ Definition โ ROK (Return on Knowledge): The ratio of revenue allocated to each core area compared to its corresponding expenses, used to compare efficiency in performance of core areas.
๐ Example: The ROK for Operations is 59%, meaning for every dollar spent, only $0.59 in revenue is generated from knowledge assets in that area. This is lower than S&GA (70%) and Management (85%), indicating Operations needs improvement.
๐ก Why this matters: The theory predicts that rankings (column 2) and learning times (column 3) should be 100% correlated. However, due to measurement error, the level of correlation should reach a minimum of 85% for rough-cut aggregated estimation and 95% for more detailed core process analyses.
Management Implication
Among the three core function areas, the performance of Operations (59% ROK) is relatively low compared to S&GA (70%) and Management (85%). To make the company profitable, KVA analysis can identify areas where the company can be more effective in exploiting its knowledge resources.
Currently, the sales provisioning process is one of the core processes in Exodus' Operations. It presents a major opportunity for further business expansion with the explosive growth in demand for data storage. However, it is also the area where customer turnaround is the slowest due to lack of automation. Five out of the six sub-processes of sales provisioning fall within the Operations area. The lower ROK in the Operations area confirms management's guess that the sales provisioning process needs improvement.
KVA: Sales Provisioning Process
Assumptions and Methodology:
- Data center: Exodus has 22 Internet data centers worldwide; the analysis is based on the El Segundo center in Los Angeles, assuming all centers are staffed and operated similarly
- Learning time and process instruction approach: Two independent measures of knowledge โ learning time estimates and number of process instructions required to produce outputs. Both measures should be defined in terms of roughly equal complexity. The higher the correlation between the two, the better the estimates
Seven Steps of KVA on Sales Provisioning Process:
Step 1: Identify core and sub-processes โ six processes: sales support and design, service selection and NAD, procurement, integration, troubleshooting, and final testing
Step 2: Establish a common definition of learning time โ SMEs estimate how long it would take to teach an "average" person to learn to produce outputs. Total learning time for the whole sequence is approximately 2,000 weeks.
Step 3: Calculate total time to learn each sub-process:
- Learning time approach: Distribution of 2,000 weeks โ Sales: 240, Service selection and NAD: 400, Procurement: 60, Integration: 500, Troubleshooting: 500, Final testing: 300
- Process instruction approach: For example, sales support required 240 learning weeks or 280 process instructions
Table 7.3 KVA on the Sales Provisioning Process:
| Sub-process | Learning time (weeks) | Employees | Knowledge in IT (35%) | Total knowledge | Knowledge% | Revenue ($M) | Process costs ($M) | ROK | Industry avg ROK |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | 240 | 8 | 672 | 2,592 | 15% | $13.7 | $12.2 | 112% | 100% |
| Service selection & NAD | 400 | 8 | 1,120 | 4,320 | 25% | $22.8 | $24.3 | 94% | 150% |
| Procurement | 60 | 5 | 105 | 405 | 2.5% | $2.3 | $3.0 | 77% | 150% |
| Integration | 500 | 5 | 875 | 3,375 | 20% | $18.3 | $20.3 | 90% | 80% |
| Troubleshooting | 500 | 6 | 1,050 | 4,050 | 23.5% | $21.4 | $19.0 | 113% | 100% |
| Final testing | 300 | 6 | 630 | 2,430 | 14% | $12.8 | $6.4 | 200% | 125% |
| Total | 2,000 | 38 | 17,172 | 100% | $91.3 | $85.2 | 107% |
Table 7.4 Learning Time and Process Instructions Correlation (0.8903 or 89% correlation, indicating high accuracy)
Step 4: Designate a sampling time period โ annualized period was used, so number of employees was the weighting factor
Step 5: Multiply learning time for each sub-process by the number of times the sub-process executes during the sample period (employees ร learning time + automation = total knowledge)
Step 6: Calculate cost to execute each sub-process (Table 7.5) โ based on assumption that all 22 data centers share the same cost structure as El Segundo
Table 7.5 Cost Calculation:
| Sub-process | Execution time (months) | Monthly rate | Process cost per center | Annual process cost per center | Total cost (22 centers, $M) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales | 3 | $15,400 | $46,200 | $554,400 | $12.2 |
| Service selection & NAD | 12 | $7,680 | $92,160 | $1,105,920 | $24.3 |
| Procurement | 3 | $3,840 | $11,520 | $138,240 | $3.0 |
| Integration | 20 | $3,840 | $76,800 | $921,600 | $20.3 |
| Troubleshooting | 15 | $4,800 | $72,000 | $864,000 | $19.0 |
| Final testing | 5 | $4,800 | $24,000 | $288,000 | $6.4 |
| Total | $3,872,160 | $85.2 |
Step 7: Compute ROKs โ revenue allocated for each sub-process divided by cost for each sub-process
๐ Example: Final testing has ROK of 200% (highest in the process), meaning for every dollar spent, $2.00 in revenue is generated. This significantly outperforms the industry average of 125%. In contrast, Procurement has only 77% ROK versus the industry average of 150%, indicating serious underperformance.
Benefits of KVA analysis (twelve applications):
- Tool to control operations: Provides contemporaneous feedback about how well the company is self-organizing and adapting to the dynamic market environment
- New set of raw data: Uses validated data for ROP and ROK calculations that are harder to manipulate when value and cost are matched for given core areas
- Increase employee understanding: Helps employees understand the value they contribute, even those not familiar with finance and accounting
- Enhance employee productivity: Creates a framework encouraging managers and employees to think and behave like owners
- Efficient resource allocation: Increases shareholder value through improved allocation of knowledge assets and capital resources
- Tool to measure manager performance: Makes managers responsible for operations they control, focusing on knowledge-created value rather than external market factors
- Benchmark with industry or competitors: Provides a value-based method for comparing knowledge asset performance
- Starting point to improve financial and business policy: Helps companies identify and invest in processes, technologies, and people providing the greatest return
โญ Key Takeaways
The Knowledge Market Framework conceptualizes organizations as internal marketplaces where tacit knowledge is exchanged between buyers (local and global) and sellers, with pricing mechanisms determining value. The KVA methodology provides a systematic way to measure the value created by knowledge assets by allocating revenue to core processes based on learning time and automation estimates, then calculating Return on Knowledge (ROK) ratios. For Exodus Communications, the aggregate-level analysis revealed Operations had the lowest ROK (59%), confirming management's intuition about the sales provisioning process being the biggest problem area. The detailed KVA of the sales provisioning process showed wide variation in ROK across sub-processes, from 200% (final testing) to 77% (procurement), enabling targeted improvement decisions. The use of two independent knowledge measures (learning time and process instructions) with correlation testing (minimum 85-95%) provides confidence in the accuracy of knowledge asset valuations.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two categories of knowledge buyers according to Grover and Davenport, and how do they differ in their goals?
- In the aggregate-level KVA analysis for Exodus, which core area had the lowest ROK and what management implication did this suggest?
- How is the total amount of knowledge in a process calculated in KVA analysis, and why is automation included in this calculation?
- In the sales provisioning process KVA, what was the correlation between learning time and process instruction estimates, and why is this correlation important?
- List at least four practical ways that KVA analysis can benefit managers in making resource allocation and performance improvement decisions.
๐ Lecture 20 โ SVEIBYโS INTELLIGENT ASSET MONITOR
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces Sveiby's knowledge-based theory of the firm and his Intelligent Asset Monitor framework for managing intellectual capital. It explains the three families of intangible assetsโexternal structure, internal structure, and individual competenceโand maps the nine possible knowledge transfers between and within these families, providing a strategic tool for intellectual capital management.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the classification of intangible assets into three families (external structure, internal structure, and individual competence), the definition of competence as part of intellectual capital, the distinctive features of knowledge transfers compared to tangible goods transfers, and a detailed examination of all nine knowledge transfer types with corresponding strategic questions and management activities.
๐ Lecture Summary
Intellectual Capital Management
One of the key authors in the area of intellectual capital is Sveiby (2001), who developed a knowledge-based theory of the firm to guide strategy formulation. He distinguished between three families of intangible assets. The external structure family consists of relationships with customers and suppliers and the reputation (image) of the firm. Some of these relationships can be converted into legal property such as trademarks and brand names. The value of such assets is primarily influenced by how well the company solves its customers' problems, and there is always an element of uncertainty here. The internal structure family consists of patents, concepts, models, and computer and administrative systems. These are created by the employees and are thus generally owned by the organization. The structure is partly independent of individuals, and some of it remains even if a large number of employees leave. The individual competence family consists of the competence of the professional staff, the experts, the research and development people, the factory workers, sales and marketingโin short, all those that have a direct contact with customers and whose work is within the business idea.
๐ Definition โ Competence: the sum of knowledge, skills, and abilities at the individual level. With this definition, knowledge is part of competence, and competence is part of intellectual capital.
These three families of intangible resources have slightly different definitions when compared to the capital elements. The external structure seems similar to relational capital, the internal structure seems similar to structural capital, while individual competence seems similar to human capital.
To appreciate why a knowledge-based theory of the firm can be useful for strategy formulation, Sveiby (2001) considers some of the features that differentiate knowledge transfers from tangible goods transfers. In contrast to tangible goods, which tend to depreciate in value when they are used, knowledge grows when used and depreciates when not used. Competence in a language or a sport requires huge investments in training to build up; managerial competence takes a long time on-the-job to learn. If one stops speaking the language it gradually dissipates.
Knowledge Transfer Within and Between Families of Intangible Assets (Sveiby, 2001)
Given three families of intangible assets, it is possible to identify nine knowledge transfers. These knowledge transfers can occur within a family and between families, as illustrated in a nine-cell matrix (not fully reproduced here). Each of the nine knowledge transfers is explained as follows:
-
Knowledge transfers between individuals concern how to best enable the communication between employees within the organization. The strategic question is: How can we improve the transfer of competence between people in the organization? Activities for intellectual capital management focus on trust building, enabling team activities, induction programs, job rotation, and master/apprentice schemes.
-
Knowledge transfers from individuals to external structure concern how the organization's employees transfer their knowledge to the outer world. The strategic question is: How can the organization's employees improve the competence of customers, suppliers, and other stakeholders? Activities focus on enabling employees to help customers learn about products, getting rid of red tape, enabling job rotation with customers, holding product seminars, and providing customer education.
-
Knowledge transfers from external structure to individuals occur when employees learn from customers, suppliers, and community feedback through ideas, new experiences, and new technical knowledge. The strategic question is: How can the organization's customers, suppliers, and other stakeholders improve the competence of the employees? Activities focus on creating and maintaining good personal relationships between the organization's own people and people outside the organization.
-
Knowledge transfers from competence to internal structure concern the transformation of human capital into more permanent structural capital through documented work routines, intranets, and data repositories. The strategic question is: How can we improve the conversion from individually held competence to systems, tools, and templates? Activities focus on tools, templates, processes, and systems so they can be shared more easily and efficiently.
-
Knowledge transfers from internal structure to individual competence is the counterpart of the above. Once competence is captured in a system, it needs to be made available to other individuals in such a way that they improve their capacity to act. The strategic question is: How can we improve individuals' competence by using systems, tools, and templates? Activities focus on improving the human-computer interface of systems, action-based learning processes, simulations, and interactive e-learning environments.
-
Knowledge transfers within the external structure concern what customers and others tell each other about the service of an organization. The strategic question is: How can we enable the conversations among customers, suppliers, and other stakeholders so they improve their competence? Activities focus on partnering and alliances, improving the image of the organization and the brand equity of its products and services, improving the quality of the offering, and conducting product seminars and alumni programs.
-
Knowledge transfers from external to internal structure concern what knowledge the organization can gain from the external world and how the learning can be converted into action. The strategic question is: How can competence from customers, suppliers, and other stakeholders improve the organization's systems, tools, processes, and products? Activities focus on empowering call centers to interpret customer complaints, creating alliances to generate ideas for new products, and research and development alliances.
-
Knowledge transfers from internal to external structure is the counterpart of the above. The strategic question is: How can the organization's systems, tools, processes, and products improve the competence of customers, suppliers, and other stakeholders? Activities focus on making the organization's systems, tools, and processes effective in servicing customers, extranets, product tracking, help desks, and e-business.
-
Knowledge transfers within the internal structure involves the internal structure as the backbone of the organization. The strategic question is: How can the organization's systems, tools, processes, and products be effectively integrated? Activities focus on streamlining databases, building integrated information technology systems, and improving the office layout.
๐ก Why this matters: These nine knowledge transfers provide a comprehensive diagnostic tool for any organization to identify gaps in their intellectual capital management and to design targeted strategies for improving knowledge flow and value creation.
โญ Key Takeaways
Sveiby's framework classifies intangible assets into three familiesโexternal structure, individual competence, and internal structureโwhich correspond to relational, human, and structural capital respectively. Knowledge is unique because it grows when used and depreciates when not used, unlike tangible goods. The nine knowledge transfers represent all possible flows between and within these three families, each with a specific strategic question and set of management activities. Master/apprentice schemes and job rotation facilitate individual-to-individual knowledge transfer, while documented work routines, intranets, and data repositories convert individual competence into permanent structural capital. Effective intellectual capital management requires organizations to actively manage all nine transfers to maximize knowledge creation, sharing, and utilization.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three families of intangible assets in Sveiby's framework, and which traditional capital elements do they correspond to?
- How does knowledge differ from tangible goods in terms of value depreciation and growth?
- What is the strategic question for knowledge transfer from individuals to external structure, and name two management activities for this transfer?
- In transfer type 4 (competence to internal structure), what is the primary activity focus, and why is this conversion important?
- What distinguishes knowledge transfers within the internal structure from other transfers, and what activities support it?
๐ Lecture 21 โ STRATEGIC PERSPECTIVE OF KNOWLEDGE AND STRATEGIC SCHOOL APPROACH IN KM
๐ Overview: This lecture examines knowledge as a strategic resource from the resource-based theory of the firm, arguing that intangible knowledge assets can provide sustainable competitive advantage. It explains the link between knowledge and strategy through frameworks like SWOT analysis and knowledge gap analysis, and introduces the strategic school perspective on knowledge management.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the strategic view of knowledge through the resource-based theory of the firm, knowledge as a strategic resource including its sustainability and increasing returns property, distinctions between data/information/knowledge/wisdom, the knowledge-strategy link via SWOT analysis and knowledge mapping, and the strategic school perspective that treats knowledge management as a dimension of competitive strategy.
๐ Lecture Summary
Strategic View of knowledge
Business strategy has traditionally focused on products and services for competitive advantage. Recent work in strategic management and economic theory focuses on the internal sideโthe firm's resources and capabilities. This is the resource-based theory of the firm, which states that performance differences across firms can be attributed to variance in firms' resources and capabilities. Resources that are valuable, unique, and difficult to imitate provide the basis for competitive advantages and produce positive returns.
The essence of the resource-based theory lies in emphasis on internal resources rather than external opportunities and threats dictated by industry conditions. Firms are considered highly heterogeneous, with different bundles of resources due to different initial endowments and managerial decisions affecting resource accumulation and utilization.
To generate sustainable competitive advantage, a resource must provide economic value and be presently scarce, difficult to imitate, non-substitutable, and not readily obtainable in factor markets. This theory rests on two key points: resources are determinants of firm performance, and resources must be rare, valuable, difficult to imitate and non-substitutable.
Research on competitive implications of resources like knowledge, learning, culture, teamwork, and human capital was boosted by resource-based theory. Intangible resources are more likely than tangible resources to produce competitive advantage because they are difficult to change except over the long term. Firm-specific knowledge allows firms to add value to incoming factors of production.
๐ Definition โ Resource-based theory of the firm: A strategic management perspective holding that performance differences across firms are attributed to variance in firms' resources and capabilities, and that resources must be valuable, rare, difficult to imitate, and non-substitutable to generate sustainable competitive advantage.
Knowledge As A Strategic Resource
The knowledge-based view of the firm argues that products and services produced by tangible resources depend on how they are combined and applied, which is a function of the firm's know-how. Knowledge is embedded in individual employees and entities like organization culture, identity, routines, policies, systems, and documents. Knowledge assets may produce long-term sustainable competitive advantage because knowledge-based resources are socially complex to understand and difficult to imitate.
Companies with superior knowledge can coordinate and combine traditional resources in new ways, providing more value for customers than competitors. By having superior intellectual resources, an organization can exploit traditional resources better than competitors, even if those traditional resources are not unique. Therefore, knowledge can be considered the most important strategic resource, and the ability to acquire, integrate, store, share and apply it the most important capability for building and sustaining competitive advantage.
Long-term sustainable competitive advantage comes from the firm's ability to effectively apply existing knowledge to create new knowledge and take action. Knowledge existing at any given time alone is not sufficient; organizations must actively learn and create.
Knowledge-based competitive advantage is sustainable because the more a firm already knows, the more it can learn. This creates increasing returnsโunlike physical goods consumed with use, knowledge provides increasing returns as it is used, creating a self-reinforcing cycle. Sustainability also comes from knowing more about some things than competitors, combined with time constraints competitors face in acquiring similar knowledge.
Organizations should use learning experiences to build on knowledge positions that provide current or future advantage. Knowledge mappingโsystematically mapping, categorizing, and benchmarking knowledgeโhelps make knowledge accessible and allows organizations to focus learning efforts on strategic areas. While knowledge advantage may be sustainable, building it internally is long-term, explaining the attraction of strategic alliances for quicker knowledge access.
๐ก Why this matters: Knowledge has a strategic role only if unique firm knowledge can be successfully applied to value-creating tasks and capitalize on existing business opportunities. Since competitors benchmark against industry leaders, knowledge must remain difficult to imitate.
The lecture distinguishes between data, information, knowledge and wisdom:
- Data: letters and numbers without meaning; independent, isolated measurements, characters, numerical characters and symbols.
- Information: data included in a context that makes sense; data endowed with relevance and purpose. Example: "40 degrees" has different meanings in medical (fever), geographical (latitude), or technical (angle) contexts.
- Knowledge: information combined with experience, context, interpretation and reflection. Knowledge is a renewable resource that accumulates through use and combination with employees' experience. Knowledge cannot exist outside human heads.
- Wisdom: knowledge combined with learning insights and judgmental abilities. Wisdom is more personal and obscure, cannot be created like data or shared like knowledge, requiring introspection, retrospection, interpretation and contemplation.
From a resource-based perspective: data are raw numbers and facts, information is processed data, and knowledge is information combined with human thoughts. Information converts to knowledge once processed in the mind, and knowledge becomes information once articulated to others.
๐ Definition โ Knowledge-based view of the firm: A strategic perspective arguing that knowledge assets embedded in individuals and organizational entities may produce long-term sustainable competitive advantage because they are socially complex and difficult to imitate.
๐ Formula: Knowledge advantage sustainability = Existing knowledge depth + Learning ability + Time constraints on competitors โ Increasing returns (knowledge becomes more valuable with use, unlike physical goods)
The Knowledge-Strategy Link
The traditional SWOT framework, updated for knowledge-intensive environments, provides a basis for describing a knowledge strategy. Firms need to perform a knowledge-based SWOT analysis, mapping their knowledge resources and capabilities against strategic opportunities and threats to understand points of advantage and weakness.
Knowledge strategy is balancing knowledge-based resources and capabilities with knowledge required for providing products/services in ways superior to competitors. Essential elements include identifying which knowledge-based resources are valuable, unique, and inimitable, and how they support product and market positions (Zack, 1999).
To explicate the link between strategy and knowledge, an organization must:
- Articulate its strategic intent
- Identify knowledge required to execute its intended strategy
- Compare that to actual knowledge, revealing strategic knowledge gaps
Every firm competes through a competitive strategyโeither from explicit decisions or accumulation of incremental decisions. Every strategic position is linked to intellectual resources and capabilities. Strategic choices regarding technologies, products, services, markets, and processes influence knowledge, skills, and core competencies required.
What a firm knows limits how it can compete. The firm's existing knowledge creates both opportunities and constraints for selecting viable competitive positions. Success requires dynamically aligning knowledge-based requirements and capabilities (Zack, 1999).
Assessing knowledge position requires cataloging resources through a knowledge map. Knowledge taxonomies distinguish between:
- Tacit vs. explicit knowledge
- General vs. context-specific knowledge
- Individual vs. collective knowledge
By type, knowledge includes: declarative (knowledge about), procedural (know-how), causal (know-why), conditional (know when), and relational (know-with) (Zack, 1999).
Every firm's strategic knowledge can be categorized by ability to support competitive position:
- Core knowledge: minimum required to compete
- Advanced knowledge: enables competitive parity or modest advantage
- Innovative knowledge: allows significant differentiation from competitors
Knowledge is not staticโwhat is innovative today becomes core knowledge tomorrow. The ability to learn, accumulate knowledge, and reapply it is itself a strategic competence (Zack, 1999).
The Strategic Knowledge Framework (Figure) allows taking a snapshot of where the firm is today vs. its desired knowledge profile. It can be applied by competency area, business unit, division, product line, function, or market position.
After mapping competitive knowledge position, organizations perform a gap analysis. The gap between what a firm must do to compete and what it actually does is a strategic gap. Underlying this is a potential knowledge gapโa gap between what the firm must know to execute strategy and what it does know.
The Knowledge Gap is derived from and aligned with the Business Gap (Figure). The greater the number, variety, or size of knowledge gaps, and the more volatile the knowledge base, the more aggressive the knowledge strategy required. A firm not capable of executing its strategy must either align strategy with capabilities or acquire the capabilities (Zack, 1999).
๐ Definition โ Knowledge strategy: Balancing knowledge-based resources and capabilities with the knowledge required for providing products or services in ways superior to competitors (Zack, 1999).
๐ Example: Knowledge gap analysisโA firm competing as an innovator must have innovative knowledge in certain areas. If its actual knowledge only reaches core or advanced levels, a knowledge gap exists. The firm must develop or acquire innovative knowledge to close this gap and execute its intended strategy.
The Strategic School Perspective
The strategic school sees knowledge management as a dimension of competitive strategy. Indeed, it may be seen as the essence of a firm's strategy. Approaches to knowledge management are dependent on management perspective.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical understanding from this lecture is that knowledge, particularly intangible and firm-specific knowledge, can be the most important source of sustainable competitive advantage according to the resource-based theory of the firm. Unlike physical resources that provide decreasing returns, knowledge provides increasing returnsโbecoming more valuable the more it is used. Students must remember the distinction between data, information, knowledge, and wisdom, as well as the three categories of strategic knowledge (core, advanced, innovative). The knowledge-strategy link requires firms to perform gap analysis comparing what they know with what they must know to execute their strategy. Finally, the strategic school perspective treats knowledge management not as a support function but as a core dimension of competitive strategy itself.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to the resource-based theory of the firm, what four characteristics must a resource have to generate sustainable competitive advantage?
- Why does knowledge produce "increasing returns" rather than decreasing returns like physical goods?
- What are the five types of knowledge identified by type in the lecture (declarative, procedural, etc.), and what does each refer to?
- How does the Strategic Knowledge Framework distinguish between core, advanced, and innovative knowledge?
- What is the relationship between a firm's strategic gap and its knowledge gap according to Zack (1999)?