π Lecture 16 β Three Schools of Thought and Approaches to KM. Economic School and KVA
π Overview: This lecture introduces the growing recognition of knowledge as a critical organizational resource and presents Earlβs (2001) taxonomy of knowledge management schools. It focuses in depth on the Economic School, which treats knowledge as an asset to be exploited for revenue, and explains key concepts including intellectual capital accounting and the Knowledge Value Added (KVA) methodology for measuring return on knowledge.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining knowledge management and its purpose in organizations. It then introduces Earlβs three schools of KM: economic, organizational, and strategic. The primary focus is the Economic School, covering intellectual capital accounting, the three components of intellectual capital (human, relational, structural), market-to-book value ratios, and the Knowledge Value Added (KVA) methodology for calculating return on knowledge (ROK). A detailed numerical example illustrates KVA application.
π Lecture Summary
Approaches to KM: Introduction
Knowledge is increasingly recognized as a critical resource for organizations, yet traditionally it has not been managed with the same systematic effort as human, material, or financial resources. Firms that leave knowledge to its own devices may face severe jeopardy. Knowledge management (KM) can be defined as a method to simplify and improve the process of sharing, distributing, creating, capturing, and understanding knowledge in a company. It involves describing, organizing, sharing, and developing knowledge, managing knowledge-intensive activities, and identifying and leveraging collective knowledge to help the company compete. The purpose of KM is to help companies create, share, and use knowledge more effectively, leading to fewer errors, less work, more independence for knowledge workers, fewer questions, better decisions, less reinventing of wheels, improved customer relations, improved service, and improved profitability.
Earl (2001) developed a taxonomy for KM that he labeled schools of knowledge management, each representing an ideal type. These schools are not mutually exclusive. Three relevant schools are:
- Economic School: Focus on income; aim is to exploit knowledge assets.
- Organizational School: Focus on networks; aim is knowledge pooling.
- Strategic School: Focus on competitive advantage; aim is to identify, exploit, and explore knowledge capabilities.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these schools helps organizations choose their KM orientation based on their strategic objectives.
The Economic School
According to Earl (2001), the Economic School is explicitly concerned with both protecting and exploiting a firmβs knowledge or intellectual assets to produce revenue streams (or rent). It manages knowledge as an asset, where knowledge or intellectual assets include patents, trademarks, copyrights, and know-how. Intellectual property is another way to describe the object being managed. This school focuses more on exploitation of knowledge and less on exploration. A critical success factor is developing a specialist team or function to aggressively manage knowledge property through intellectual capital accounting, intellectual capital management, and creation of an effective and efficient knowledge marketplace.
π Definition β Intellectual Capital Accounting: The process of measuring and reporting intellectual capital, recognizing that intellectual capital provides a crucial source of value for contemporary business enterprises that requires careful management.
Intellectual Capital Accounting
Intellectual capital is the focus of significant discussion across management disciplines, reflecting recognition that it provides crucial value for contemporary business enterprises. For publicly quoted businesses, success in managing intellectual capital is increasingly mirrored in their market values, which are often many times their book values. Bridging this gap constitutes one motivation for accounting for intellectual capital. Another motivation is the need to manage intellectual capital successfully, requiring new approaches to performance measurement.
Stewart (1997) suggested tools for measuring intellectual capital. Value is defined by the buyer, not the seller. Therefore, market value = price per share Γ total number of shares outstanding. One measure of intellectual capital is the difference between market value and book equity, assuming everything left in market value after accounting for fixed assets must be intangible assets.
π Formula: Intellectual Capital = Market Value β Book Equity β This formula calculates the intangible asset value of a firm by subtracting its recorded book value from its market capitalization.
π Example: If Microsoft is worth 100 billion dollars and its book value is 10 billion dollars, then its intellectual capital is 90 billion dollars (100 β 10 = 90).
Three components of intellectual capital are identified:
- Human Capital: The know-how, capabilities, skills, and expertise of human members of an organization.
- Relational Capital: Any connection that people outside the organization have with it, together with customer loyalty, market share, the level of backorders, and so forth.
- Structural Capital: Systems and networks, cultures and values, together with elements of intellectual property such as patents, copyrights, trademarks, and so forth.
Beginning intellectual capital accounting requires accepting that it is possible to include objective measures of value within financial statements, as with tangible assets. Intangible assets like goodwill are already problematic in accounting. In the UK, only purchased goodwill can be reported in accounts. Intellectual capital, as "new goodwill," multiplies these difficulties, taking many more forms than goodwill. According to Roslender and Fincham (2001), we can think in terms of degrees of intangibility: brands, patents, and know-how count as intangible assets; customer data, distribution channels, and employee qualification profiles are more intangible; employee commitment, organizational culture, and corporate values are even more intangible yet ensure impressive market-to-book value ratios.
π Formula: Market-to-Book Value Ratio = Market Value / Book Value β This ratio indicates the value of intellectual capital in an organization. Three decades ago it was close to 1; today it averages about 4.
π Example: In 1997, Microsoft had a book value of 11 billion dollars and a market value of 200 billion dollars, giving a market-to-book ratio of approximately 18.2 (200/11). Afuah and Tucci (2003) argue this ratio is caused by intellectual capital.
Knowledge Value Added (KVA)
The knowledge-value-added (KVA) methodology as described by Housel and Bell (2001) addresses the need to leverage and measure knowledge resident in employees, information technology, and core processes. KVA analysis produces a return-on-knowledge (ROK) ratio to estimate the value added by given knowledge assets, regardless of location. The essence of KVA is that knowledge utilized in core processes is translated into numerical form, allowing allocation of revenue in proportion to the value added by the knowledge as well as the cost to use that knowledge.
Tracking the conversion of knowledge into value while measuring bottom-line impacts enables managers to increase productivity of these critical assets.
π Definition β Knowledge Value Added (KVA): A methodology for allocating revenue and cost to a companyβs core processes based on the amount of change each produces, using the knowledge required to make these changes as a way to describe the conversion process.
π Definition β Knowledge (in KVA): The know-how required to produce process outputs, proportionate to the time it takes to learn it. Learning time is a quick and convenient way to measure the amount of knowledge contained in any given process.
π Example: In a widget company, there is one owner who makes and sells widgets for $1. The ownerβs sales production knowledge can be used as a surrogate for the dollar of revenue generated. We determine how long it would take a new owner to learn all necessary sales and production knowledge, then use these learning times to allocate the dollar of revenue between sales and production processes.
Assume it takes 100 hours for the new owner to learn the processes: 70 hours learning how to make the widget (production) and 30 hours learning how to sell it (sales). This indicates 70% of knowledge and value added is in production and 30% in sales. Therefore:
- $0.70 of revenue allocated to production knowledge
- $0.30 of revenue allocated to sales knowledge
Next, determine the cost to use sales and production knowledge. Assume total cost to sell and produce a widget is $0.50: $0.25 for sales and $0.25 for production. Cost is directly tied to how long the new owner spends performing each process.
π Formula: Return on Knowledge (ROK) = Revenue Allocated to Process / Cost to Use Knowledge in That Process β This ratio measures the productivity of knowledge assets in each process.
π Example (continued):
- Production ROK = $0.70 / $0.25 = 280%
- Sales ROK = $0.30 / $0.25 = 120%
Conclusion: The production process is a more productive use of the knowledge asset (280%) than the sales process (120%).
π‘ Why this matters: KVA enables managers to quantify which knowledge assets are generating the most value relative to their cost, guiding investment in knowledge processes and human capital development.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical things a student MUST remember from this lecture are: (1) Earlβs three schools of KMβeconomic (exploit knowledge assets for income), organizational (pool knowledge through networks), and strategic (leverage knowledge for competitive advantage)βeach have distinct focuses and aims. (2) The Economic School treats knowledge as an asset including patents, trademarks, copyrights, and know-how, and uses intellectual capital accounting to measure its value. (3) Intellectual capital has three components: human capital (skills and expertise), relational capital (external connections and loyalty), and structural capital (systems, culture, intellectual property). (4) Market-to-book value ratio is a simple indicator of intellectual capital value, calculated as market value divided by book value, and has risen from ~1 to ~4 on average. (5) The KVA methodology allocates revenue and cost to core processes based on learning time as a proxy for knowledge, producing a Return on Knowledge (ROK) ratio that compares value added to the cost of using knowledge.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three schools of knowledge management according to Earl (2001), and what is the focus of each?
- How is intellectual capital calculated using market value and book equity? Provide a formula and example.
- What are the three components of intellectual capital, and what does each include?
- In the KVA methodology, how is knowledge defined, and how is it measured?
- Using the widget company example, calculate the Return on Knowledge (ROK) for both the production and sales processes, and explain which process is more productive.
π Lecture 17 β Economic School: Management and Knowledge Metrics
π Overview: This lecture explains how organizations must measure and manage knowledge assets to directly impact their bottom-line profitability. It introduces knowledge metrics as a tool for translating creative knowledge into value, and critically reviews four traditional valuation approaches (cost, income, market, and real options) that can be adapted for measuring intangible knowledge assets.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first discusses the need for knowledge metrics to tie core process performance to profitability, distinguishing between creative (non-modifiable) and modifiable knowledge. It then introduces and explains four fundamental valuation methodologies: the cost approach (asset-based valuation), the income approach (present value of future earnings), the market approach (comparable company multiples), and the real options approach (valuing investment opportunities under uncertainty). Each method's applicability to knowledge assets is examined.
π Lecture Summary
Management and Knowledge Metrics: Transforming Knowledge into Value
To remain competitive, an organizationβs core processes must produce bottom-line profitability that attracts investors, maintains market capitalization, and enhances corporate value while delivering customer value. Managers need measures that quantify the performance of core process knowledge assets and tie them directly to the bottom line. Current management design options rely on heuristics ("rules-of-thumb") that provide semi-empirical support but cannot produce modifiable insights about whether actual or proposed process changes impact the firm's bottom line.
The use of creative knowledge represents a special case for knowledge measurement because it is by definition not modifiable. Trying to manage and measure this type of knowledge is problematic. For example, the value of creative knowledge in R&D can only be determined after its outputs have been translated into core processes that produce final products. Knowledge metrics become useful here because managers can track the speed with which creative knowledge results in changes in core processes and the amount of new "modifiable" knowledge embedded in those processes. This provides a means to identify, quantify, and help manage the transformation of knowledge into value.
π‘ Why this matters: Knowledge metrics enable managers to measure what was previously unmeasurable β the transformation of creative, non-modifiable knowledge into tangible value through core processes.
Additional Valuation Methodologies Vis-Γ-Vis Knowledge Metrics
It is critical for the successful and widespread use of knowledge metrics that they be interoperable with traditional accounting and finance valuation approaches whenever possible. Just as the theory of relativity drove physics into the next millennium, so knowledge metrics will be the driver of accounting and finance valuation methodologies.
Cost, Income, Market, And Real Options Approaches
The cost, income, and market approaches are the three fundamental approaches used by the business valuation profession to value ownership interests in privately held companies. The real options approach was developed to value stock options but also can be applied to valuing intangible assets. A review of these approaches frames a discussion of valuing assets, including intangibles such as knowledge.
The Cost Approach
The cost approach is based on the concept that a company is worth the market value of all its assets minus the market value of all its liabilities. Not only each balance sheet asset/liability but also each off-balance-sheet asset/liability (tangible and intangible) is identified, valued, and included on the balance sheet. Bringing the historical cost of each asset and liability to its current market value is time-consuming and difficult, potentially requiring additional experts to value specific asset categories (e.g., real estate, machinery).
Variations of the cost approach are generally used to value holding and investment companies and asset-intensive companies (natural resources, utilities). Asset-based methods are reliable in early-stage companies where book values proxy for fair market value. A particular form β the excess earnings approach β is regularly used to value professional practices and service companies.
π Definition β Cost Approach: A valuation method where a company is worth the market value of all its assets minus the market value of all its liabilities, including off-balance-sheet items. π Formula: Company Value = Market Value of All Assets β Market Value of All Liabilities β This calculates the net asset value, requiring all assets and liabilities to be stated at current market value. π Example: For an early-stage technology startup with few assets, the book value of equipment ($500,000) minus liabilities ($100,000) gives a cost approach value of $400,000, serving as a reasonable proxy until future earnings can be projected.
The Income Approach
The income approach is based on the concept that a company is worth the present value of its future earning power. Future economic income is projected from the valuation date using historical trends and management's professional judgment about future growth. If recent cash flows are stable and future growth is incremental and sustainable, a single projection is made into perpetuity. If cash flows have peaks and valleys or future growth involves high/uneven rates, projections are made for each year of five years (one business cycle), then a single projection is made from year five into perpetuity. Projected cash flows are converted back to present value using a total rate of return comparable to market rates for investments of similar risk. The resulting estimate is adjusted for whether a controlling or minority ownership interest is being valued and for marketability. The income approach is generally used to value operating companies and specific projects proposed by management.
π Definition β Income Approach: A valuation method where a company is worth the present value of its projected future earnings, discounted by a rate of return comparable to similar-risk investments. π Formula: Present Value = Ξ£ (Future Cash Flows / (1 + Discount Rate)^n) β This converts projected earnings into today's value, accounting for risk and time. π Example: A stable company projects $1 million in annual cash flows forever. Using a 10% discount rate, the present value is $10 million ($1M / 0.10). If cash flows are uneven, each year's flow is discounted separately for the first five years, then a terminal value is computed.
The Market Approach
The market approach is based on the concept that the value of a privately held company can be reasonably estimated by examining, adjusting, and using the market multiples (such as price/earnings ratios) of "guideline" publicly held companies that bear enough similarity to the "subject" privately held company. First, the fundamental financial variables of both the subject and guideline companies are adjusted for comparability. Financial ratios are calculated and compared. One or several guideline company market multiples are selected and adjusted to reflect the relative growth prospects and risks (strengths and weaknesses) of the subject company. Finally, these adjusted multiples are weighted by degree of importance and applied to the fundamental financial variable of the subject company. The resulting estimate is adjusted for controlling/minority interest and marketability. Variations of the market approach are used in conjunction with the cost and/or income approaches for valuing all kinds of companies.
π Definition β Market Approach: A valuation method where a privately held company's value is estimated by applying adjusted market multiples from similar publicly held "guideline" companies to the subject company's financial variables. π Formula: Subject Company Value = Adjusted P/E Multiple Γ Subject Company Earnings β This applies a comparable company's valuation ratio to generate the subject's estimated value. π Example: A publicly traded competitor (guideline company) has a P/E ratio of 15. The subject private company has earnings of $2 million. After adjusting the P/E to 12 (reflecting higher risk/lower marketability), the market approach value is $24 million (12 Γ $2M).
The Real Options Approach
The real options approach has grown out of options theory. The value of an option increases as the variability in the value of the underlying asset (cash flow per unit) increases. There are six key parameters that affect the value of a real option: the market value of the asset, the exercise price of the option, the time remaining until the option matures, the volatility of the underlying asset, the risk-free rate of the asset, and the amount of dividends paid by the underlying risky asset. This measure not only values a project's immediate return but allows inclusion of the potential value generated in multiple investment outcomes. The real options approach is a basic capital budgeting technique that focuses on measuring the value of an individual project, in conditions of uncertainty, before the project begins. It is not used to value ownership interests in privately held companies but to value internal and external investment opportunities for an individual company, public or private. As such, it is a strategic business valuation tool. It is widely used by the Internet venture capital community for determining the potential future value of companies with no economic history and has been applied to the valuation of patents and licenses.
π Definition β Real Options Approach: A capital budgeting technique for valuing individual projects under uncertainty by treating investment opportunities as options, incorporating potential value from multiple outcomes. π Formula: Option Value = f(Market Value of Asset, Exercise Price, Time to Maturity, Volatility, Risk-Free Rate, Dividends) β This captures the value of flexibility and future choices in uncertain investments. π Example: A pharmaceutical company has a patent (license) for a new drug. Using the real options approach, the investment in clinical trials is valued as an option: if trials succeed (high future cash flows), the company exercises the option to launch; if they fail, the company lets the option expire, limiting losses. Volatility increases option value because of greater upside potential.
β Key Takeaways
Knowledge metrics are essential for quantifying how creative, non-modifiable knowledge transforms into value through changes in core processes, and these metrics must interoperate with traditional accounting and finance approaches. The cost approach values a company by its net asset value, suitable for asset-intensive or early-stage companies but difficult for knowledge assets that are off-balance-sheet. The income approach values future earning power discounted to present value, applicable to operating companies but requiring stable or predictable cash flows. The market approach uses comparable company multiples to estimate value, relying on the availability of similar publicly traded firms. The real options approach values flexibility under uncertainty by considering six key parameters, making it uniquely suited for valuing patents, licenses, and internet ventures with no economic history. For the exam, remember the distinguishing features of each method and specifically that real options is the only approach designed for uncertain, pre-project investment opportunities where variability increases value.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is creative knowledge difficult to measure directly, and how do knowledge metrics help overcome this challenge?
- What are the four fundamental valuation approaches discussed in this lecture, and which one is specifically used for valuing projects under uncertainty before they begin?
- In the cost approach, what must be included beyond balance sheet items, and what form of this approach is used for professional practices?
- What are the six key parameters that affect the value of a real option, and what happens to option value when asset volatility increases?
- Under what conditions does the income approach use a single perpetuity projection versus separate projections for five years?
π Lecture 18 β Measures of Intellectual Capital
π Overview: This lecture introduces the knowledge-value-added (KVA) methodology as a robust approach to measuring the value of knowledge assets within an organization. It explains how to calculate a return-on-knowledge (ROK) ratio to estimate the value added by knowledge assets, regardless of where they are located in the organization.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the measurement of return on knowledge, the knowledge-value-added (KVA) methodology with a practical example of a widget company, and the KVA theory including its fundamental assumptions. It also details three approaches to KVA: the learning time method, the process description method, and the binary query method, along with a seven-step knowledge audit process.
π Lecture Summary
Measuring Return on Knowledge
The lecture provides a broad review of approaches to valuing knowledge assets, noting that reliable approaches require a common language to discuss the underlying value of an organizationβs knowledge assets. The knowledge-value-added methodology is presented as one of the most robust approaches because it conforms to this requirement. Understanding how this methodology works requires a detailed review to work through practical issues involved in measuring knowledge at a granular level. This granular level will provide new raw data for Information Age financial and accounting professionals, who can then provide analysis and insight for investors, managers, and customers.
Knowledge-Value-Added Methodology
The knowledge-value-added (KVA) methodology addresses a need recognized by executives by showing how to leverage and measure the knowledge resident in employees, information technology, and core processes. KVA analysis produces a return-on-knowledge (ROK) ratio to estimate the value added by given knowledge assets regardless of where they are located. The essence of KVA is that knowledge utilized in corporate core processes is translated into numerical form. This translation allows allocation of revenue in proportion to the value added by the knowledge as well as the cost to use that knowledge. Tracking the conversion of knowledge into value while measuring its bottom-line impacts enables managers to increase the productivity of these critical assets.
KVA Example
The lecture begins with an example of an "average" person who needs to learn how to produce all the outputs of a given company. This person's knowledge of the company would be the embodiment of the company's value-adding processes, including selling, marketing, producing, accounting for, financing, servicing, and maintaining. These core processes add value while converting inputs into outputs that generate the company's revenue.
KVA provides a methodology for allocating revenue and cost to a company's core processes based on the amount of change each produces. Knowledge is defined as the know-how required to produce process outputs. This knowledge is proportionate to the learning time it takes to learn it. Learning time is a quick and convenient way to measure the amount of knowledge contained in any given process.
In the widget company example, one owner makes and sells widgets for $1. If it takes 100 hours for a new owner to learn the processes, with 70 hours learning how to make the widget and 30 hours learning how to sell it, this indicates that 70 percent of the knowledge and value added was in the production process and 30 percent in the sales process. Therefore, $0.70 of the revenue would be allocated to production knowledge and $0.30 to sales knowledge.
To measure return on knowledge (ROK), the cost to use the knowledge must be determined. Assuming the total cost to sell and produce a widget was $0.50, with $0.25 for sales and $0.25 for production, and the new owner spends equal time on both, the cost to use the knowledge of each process is the same. The ROK for the production process is 0.70/0.25 = 280 percent, and for the sales process is 0.30/0.25 = 120 percent, indicating that the production process is a more productive use of the knowledge asset.
π‘ Why this matters: This example demonstrates how learning time can be used as a surrogate measure for knowledge, allowing for a quantifiable allocation of revenue and cost to different processes.
The KVA methodology can be applied at any level in a company. For a quick-and-dirty KVA of a corporation like SBC, executives from core processes would estimate how long it takes the average person to learn how to produce the outputs of the core areas, with a boundary condition of a total of 100 months for the average person to learn everything necessary to generate the annual revenue. These estimates would be weighted by the number of employees in each core process to estimate how frequently the knowledge is employed in a typical year.
To make a back-of-the-envelope estimate of the knowledge embedded in information technology, the percentage of the process that is automated is asked. The percentage of knowledge for each process, including its supporting IT, is calculated by dividing process knowledge by the total amount of knowledge. Revenue is then allocated proportionately. The revenue attributable specifically to the knowledge embedded in IT and the cost to use it would provide the ROK for IT within and among processes. This can reveal that "all IT is not created equal," as some highly automated processes may provide much lower ROKs than others with less automation but more "bang for the buck."
KVA Theory
KVA is rooted in the Information Age and allows managers and investors to analyze the performance of corporate knowledge assets in core processes in terms of the returns they generate, whether the knowledge is embedded in information technology or employees' heads. This is accomplished by postulating a common unit of knowledge that can be observed in core processes and counted in terms of its price and cost. The results of a KVA analysis are ratios that compare the price and cost for these common units of knowledge.
The fundamental assumptions of KVA are:
- If input X equals output Y, no value has been added.
- Value is proportionate to change.
- Change can be measured by the amount of knowledge required to make the change.
The principle of replication states that if we have the knowledge necessary to produce a change, then we have the amount of change introduced by the knowledge. If we have not captured the knowledge required to make the necessary changes, we will not be able to produce the output as determined by the process.
The knowledge audit of KVA methodology can be delineated in seven steps:
| Steps | Learning Time | Process Description | Binary Query Method |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Identify core process and its sub processes | ||
| 2 | Establish common units to measure learning time | Describe the products in terms of the instructions required to reproduce them and select unit of process description | Create a set of binary yes/no questions such that all possible outputs are represented as a sequence of yes/no answers |
| 3 | Calculate learning time to execute each sub process | Calculate number of process instructions pertaining to each sub process | Calculate length of sequence of yes/no answers for each sub process |
| 4 | Designate sampling time period long enough to capture a representative sample of the core process's final product/service output | ||
| 5 | Multiply the learning time for each sub process by the number of times the sub process executes during sample period | Multiply the number of process instructions used to describe each sub process by the number of times the sub process executes during sample period | Multiply the length of the yes/no string for each sub process by the number of times this sub process executes during sample period |
| 6 | Allocate revenue to sub processes in proportion to the quantities generated by step 5 and calculate costs for each sub process |
The knowledge within a process can be represented as learning time, process instructions, or bits. Any approach that satisfies the basic KVA assumptions will work. Based on the fundamental assumption of KVA, the correlation between any two or more estimates should be at a high level to ensure an accurate estimate, and this simple matched correlation measures the reliability of an estimate.
The KVA approach is being embedded in the "Process Edge" TM process modeling tool suite, which will allow analysts to gather and represent KVA data within a process work-flow model and monitor the ongoing return on knowledge (ROK) and return on process (ROP).
β Key Takeaways
The KVA methodology is a robust approach for valuing knowledge assets by using learning time as a proxy for knowledge, which allows for the allocation of revenue and cost to core processes. The key output is the return-on-knowledge (ROK) ratio, which compares the revenue allocated to a process based on its knowledge content against the cost of using that knowledge. The fundamental assumption of KVA is that value is proportionate to change, and change can be measured by the amount of knowledge required to make it. Three main approaches to estimating knowledge are learning time, process instructions, and binary query methods, all of which can be used in a seven-step knowledge audit process.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does the KVA methodology stand for, and what is its primary purpose?
- How is "knowledge" defined within the KVA framework, and what is used as a convenient measure of it?
- In the widget company example, how is revenue allocated between the sales and production processes?
- What is the formula for calculating Return on Knowledge (ROK) in the context of the KVA methodology?
- What are the three different approaches to estimating the value of knowledge embedded in core processes, as summarized in the KVA table?