📘 Lecture 22 — Strategic School: Stock, Flow, and Growth Strategy in KM
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how knowledge management is viewed as a dimension of competitive strategy. It explores the strategic school's three perspectives (information, technology, culture), contrasts codification and personalization strategies for managing knowledge, and introduces the stock, flow, and growth strategies based on business type. Understanding these frameworks helps organizations align their KM approach with their competitive goals.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the strategic school and its three perspectives (information-based, technology-based, culture-based); the codification strategy (people-to-documents) and personalization strategy (person-to-person) for knowledge management, including their differences in competitive strategy, economic model, IT use, and HR approach; three questions for choosing the right strategy (standardized vs. customized products, mature vs. innovative products, explicit vs. tacit knowledge); the stock, flow, and growth strategies linked to expert-driven, experience-driven, and efficiency-driven businesses; and a table of characteristics of each KM strategy.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Strategic School
The strategic school sees knowledge management as a dimension of competitive strategy, possibly even the essence of a firm’s strategy. Approaches to KM depend on management perspective. Three distinctions are made:
- Information-based perspective is concerned with access to information: "I have a problem, and I am looking for someone in the organization who has knowledge that can solve my problem."
- Technology-based perspective is concerned with applications of information technology: "How can we use this technology to systematize, store and distribute information to knowledge workers?"
- Culture-based perspective is concerned with knowledge sharing: "We can draw on each other’s expertise."
All three perspectives are needed for a successful KM project. However, the main focus varies depending on corporate situation. If reinventing the wheel is the big problem, the information-based perspective should dominate. If the technology cannot provide basic services, the technology-based perspective should dominate. If knowledge workers are isolated and reluctant to share, the culture-based perspective should dominate.
Codification and Personalization Strategy
Some companies automate KM, while others rely on people to share knowledge through traditional means. In some companies, the strategy centers on the computer. Knowledge is carefully codified and stored in databases, where it can be accessed and used easily. These companies use a people-to-documents approach: knowledge is extracted from the person who developed it, made independent of that person, and reused for various purposes. Knowledge objects (e.g., interview guides, work schedules, benchmark data, market segmentation analysis) are stored in an electronic repository. This allows many people to search and retrieve codified knowledge without contacting the original developer. Hansen et al. (1999) call this the codification strategy.
In other companies, knowledge is closely tied to the person who developed it and is shared mainly through direct person-to-person contacts. The chief purpose of computers is to help people communicate knowledge, not store it. These companies focus on dialogue between individuals. Knowledge is transferred in barnstorming sessions, one-on-one conversations, over the telephone, by email, and via video conferences. Networks are fostered by transferring people between offices, supporting a culture of prompt response, creating directories of experts, and using knowledge managers. These firms may have electronic document systems, but the purpose is to find out who has done work on a topic and then approach those people directly. Hansen et al. (1999) call this the personalization strategy.
🔑 Definition — Codification Strategy: A KM strategy where knowledge is carefully codified and stored in databases for easy access and reuse by anyone in the company, using a people-to-documents approach.
🔑 Definition — Personalization Strategy: A KM strategy where knowledge is closely tied to the person who developed it and is shared mainly through direct person-to-person contacts and dialogue.
Codification and personalization can be contrasted using several criteria:
- Competitive strategy: Codification provides high quality, reliable, fast information-systems implementation by reusing codified knowledge. Personalization provides creative, analytically rigorous advice on high-level strategic problems by channeling individual expertise.
- Economic model: Codification uses reuse economics—investing once in a knowledge asset and reusing it many times. Personalization uses expert economics—charging high fees for highly customized solutions to unique problems.
- KM strategy: Codification uses people-to-documents (developing an electronic document system that codifies, stores, disseminates, and allows reuse of knowledge). Personalization uses person-to-person (developing networks for linking people so tacit knowledge can be shared).
- IT investment: Codification invests heavily in IT to connect people with reusable codified knowledge. Personalization invests moderately in IT to facilitate conversations and exchange of tacit knowledge.
- Human resources: Codification trains people in groups and through computer-based distance learning. Personalization trains people through one-on-one mentoring.
💡 Why this matters: The choice between codification and personalization is not arbitrary—it must align with the company's competitive strategy and how it creates value for customers.
Choosing the Right Strategy
Competitive strategy must drive KM strategy. Executives must articulate why customers buy their products or services and how knowledge adds value. Assuming the competitive strategy is clear, managers consider three questions (Hansen et al., 1999):
- Do you offer standardized or customized products? Standardized products fit the codification strategy; customized products fit the personalization strategy.
- Do you have mature or innovative products? Mature products fit the codification strategy; innovative products fit the personalization strategy.
- Do your people rely on explicit or tacit knowledge to solve problems? Explicit knowledge (knowledge that can be codified, such as simple software code and market data) fits the people-to-documents approach. Tacit knowledge (difficult to articulate, acquired through personal experience—including scientific expertise, operational know-how, business judgment, and technological expertise) fits the person-to-person approach.
Incentives are critical. In the codification model, managers need to reward people for writing down what they know and getting documents into the electronic repository—the level and quality of contributions should be part of annual performance reviews. In the personalization model, managers need to reward people for sharing knowledge directly with other people.
Stock, Flow, and Growth Strategy
Approaches to KM are dependent on knowledge focus in the organization. Three business types are distinguished:
- Expert-driven business: Solves large, complex, risky, new, and unusual problems. Competitive advantage is achieved through continuous improvisation and innovation. Knowledge workers apply general high-level knowledge to understand, solve, and learn. Characterized by new problems and new methods for solution.
- Experience-driven business: Solves large and complicated problems that are new but can be solved with existing methods in a specific context. Competitive advantage is achieved through effective adaptation of existing problem-solving methodologies. Characterized by new problems and existing methods for solution.
- Efficiency-driven business: Solves known problems. Quality is found in fast and inexpensive application. Competitive advantage is achieved in making small adjustments at a low price. Characterized by known problems and known methods for solution.
Few knowledge-intensive firms are active in only one business. For example, medical doctors are mainly in experience-driven business but sometimes in expert-driven business. Lawyers are often in expert-driven business but most often in experience-driven business. Some engineers are in efficiency-driven business but most often in experience-based business.
These differences lead to three KM strategies:
- Stock strategy: Focused on collecting and storing all knowledge in information bases. Information is stored in databases and made available to knowledge workers. Workers use databases to keep updated on relevant problems, methods, news, and opinions. Information accumulates over time. This can also be called person-to-knowledge strategy.
- Flow strategy: Focused on collecting and storing knowledge as long as it is used in knowledge work processes. If certain knowledge work disappears, that information becomes obsolete and can be deleted. This is a yellow-pages strategy where information on knowledge areas covered by individuals is registered, and the person source can be identified. When starting a new project, a worker searches databases to find colleagues with experience in those problems. This can also be called person-to-per strategy.
- Growth strategy: Focused on developing new knowledge. New knowledge is developed in innovative work processes when solving new problems with new methods. Several persons are involved in the innovation through a learning process. When starting a new project, a worker uses intra-organizational and inter-organizational networks to find information on work processes and learning environments that colleagues have used successfully.
There is a strong link between these three KM strategies and the three business types. Typically, efficiency-driven businesses apply the stock strategy, experience-driven businesses apply the flow strategy, and expert-driven businesses apply the growth strategy.
The table of characteristics is presented below:
| Characteristics | Stock strategy | Flow strategy | Growth strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Knowledge focus | Efficiency-driven business | Experience-driven business | Expert-driven business |
| Important persons | Chief knowledge officer, Chief information officer, Database engineers | Chief knowledge officer, Experienced knowledge workers | Management experts |
| Knowledge base | Databases and information systems | Information networks | Networks of experts, work processes and learning environments |
| Important elements | Access to databases and information systems | Access to knowledge space | Access to networks of experts and learning environments |
| Management task | Collecting information and making it available | Connecting persons to experienced knowledge workers | Providing access to networks |
| Learning | Efficiency training applying existing knowledge | Experience accumulation applying existing knowledge | Growth training developing new knowledge |
🔑 Definition — Stock strategy: A KM strategy focused on collecting and storing all knowledge in information bases (databases) for accumulation and availability to all knowledge workers.
🔑 Definition — Flow strategy: A KM strategy focused on collecting and storing knowledge as long as it is used, with a yellow-pages approach to connect knowledge workers to colleagues with experience.
🔑 Definition — Growth strategy: A KM strategy focused on developing new knowledge through innovative work processes and learning environments.
💡 Why this matters: The choice of stock, flow, or growth strategy must align with the business type (efficiency-driven, experience-driven, or expert-driven) and the nature of problems and solutions the organization typically handles.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) The strategic school views KM as central to competitive strategy, with three perspectives (information, technology, culture) that must all be present but may vary in emphasis based on organizational problems. (2) Codification strategy uses people-to-documents and reuse economics for standardized/mature products relying on explicit knowledge, while personalization strategy uses person-to-person and expert economics for customized/innovative products relying on tacit knowledge. (3) Three questions help choose the right strategy: standardized vs. customized products, mature vs. innovative products, and explicit vs. tacit knowledge. (4) Stock, flow, and growth strategies correspond to efficiency-driven, experience-driven, and expert-driven businesses respectively, with different knowledge bases, important persons, management tasks, and learning approaches. (5) Incentive systems must align with the chosen strategy—rewarding document contributions for codification/stock strategies and direct knowledge sharing for personalization/flow strategies.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three perspectives of the strategic school, and under what circumstances should each dominate a KM project?
- What is the difference between codification and personalization strategies in terms of economic model (reuse economics vs. expert economics)?
- What three questions should managers consider when choosing between codification and personalization strategies?
- What are the three knowledge management strategies (stock, flow, growth), and which business type (efficiency-driven, experience-driven, expert-driven) does each typically serve?
- What incentive systems are appropriate for codification/stock strategies versus personalization/flow strategies?