π Lecture 14 β Dimensions of and Multiple Views of KM in Organizations
π Overview: This lecture explores the multidimensional nature of knowledge management (KM) in organizations, highlighting its economic significance and the confusion surrounding its implementation. It examines the current state of KM, its importance for value creation, and provides practical principles for managing customer knowledge, deploying knowledge in information technology, and monitoring knowledge assets.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the overview of knowledge management as a preeminent economic resource, the relationship between knowledge management and value creation with tangible benefits from companies like Chevron and Dow Chemical, the current state of KM research revealing numerous conflicting definitions and implementation strategies, why KM is crucial for competitive advantage in the Information Age, and practical principles for managing customer knowledge, deploying knowledge in IT, and monitoring and measuring knowledge assets.
π Lecture Summary
Knowledge Management Overview
Knowledge has become the preeminent economic resource, more important than raw material or money. In today's Information Age economy, knowledge is regarded as the preeminent contributor to value creation across industrial and service landscapes. However, the proliferation of tools enabling companies to manage and leverage information has led to a proliferation of KM approaches, measurement tools, initiatives, definitions, and procedures, creating confusion that inhibits companies.
According to leading practitioner in the field, the potential impact of knowledge management on the national and global economy is immense. International Data Corporation (IDC) believes the market impact of KM will be analogous to that of the Internet. Primary points include: KM will be a catalyst for many IT product and service markets; KM will allow companies to establish exclusive market niches; and KM will be an integral enhancement for many existing offerings.
Principal difficulties associated with designing and implementing KM practices include: culture change can be painful and exceptionally slow; investment in necessary tools can be tenuous and incremental; KM is a high-level solution sell; and a wall of confusion about knowledge measurement inhibits growth. Most practitioners have focused on qualitative issues; few have employed reliable measurement tools or applied rigorous quantitative analysis.
Companies like Chrysler, Ford, General Motors, Amoco, Dow, Monsanto, Columbia/HCA Healthcare Corp., and Fruit of the Loom have embraced KM. KM offers opportunities for companies to: capture and analyze corporate information and apply it strategically through data warehousing and data mining; create processes for worldwide access to information enabling faster decisions through intranets, groupware, and group decision support systems; and leverage accumulated knowledge of past experiences across the company.
Knowledge Management And Value Creation
Companies making the investment in knowledge management can realize huge bottom line benefits, while those neglecting to do so can suffer tremendous costs in terms of lost revenues, customers, and markets.
π Definition β Tangible benefits: Real, measurable financial gains realized through KM implementation.
π Example: Chevron realized a $170 million annual savings by pooling and sharing knowledge that had been scattered and localized in various offices around the world. One team saved $150 million by sharing ways to reduce the use of electric power and fuel. Another team saved $20 million by comparing data on gas compressors.
π Example: Dow Chemical increased its annual licensing revenues by $100 million by strategically managing its patents and licenses.
| Initiative Type | External Structure | Internal Structure | Competency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goal | Gain knowledge from customers | Build knowledge-sharing culture | Create careers based on KM |
| Goal | Offer customers additional knowledge | Create new revenues from existing knowledge | Create microenvironments for tacit knowledge transfer |
| Goal | Capture individualsβ tacit knowledge, store it, spread it, and reuse it | Measure knowledge-creating processes and intangible assets | |
| Companies | Benetton, General Electric, National Bicycle, Netscape, Ritz Carlton, Agro Corp., Frito-lay, Dow Chemical, Skandia, Steelcase | 3M, Analog Devices, Boeing, Buckman Labs, Chaparral Steel, Ford Motor Co., Hewlett-Packard, Chevron, British Petroleum, Telia, Celemi, Skandia | Buckman Labs, IBM, Pfizer, Hewlett-Packard, Honda, Xerox, National Technological University, Matsushita |
KM should be seen as a remedy for earlier attempts at "reengineering" rather than its latest version. KM's focus on identifying and maximizing knowledge value creation stands in sharp contrast to the "slash-and-burn" techniques associated with many reengineering strategies. Many reengineering efforts have led to downsizing that actually cut huge swaths out of the knowledge base of these companies.
The State Of Knowledge Management
Research into knowledge management reveals interesting anecdotal evidence and varied literature on current methodologies, techniques, tools, and case studies. The current state is characterized by: numerous and conflicting definitions of KM; wide diversity of implementation strategies with many companies in disparate industries engaged in KM initiatives; no comprehensive understanding of the best techniques for designing and launching KM initiatives; very few detailed case studies of corporate experiences with KM and knowledge gaps; restricted access to information on how companies have resolved specific problems; ad hoc and non-comprehensive discussion of techniques for measuring the value of KM; unclear links between knowledge asset utilization and financial results; and general confusion about the difference between information retrieval and knowledge management.
Why is Knowledge Management Important?
Knowledge management is crucial because it points the way to comprehensive and clearly understandable management initiatives and procedures. When companies fail to utilize tangible assets, they suffer economic consequences, and this failure is clearly observable. Although knowledge assets are harder to quantify, they are just as critical for the long-term survival and growth of the company.
Success in today's competitive marketplace depends on the quality of knowledge and knowledge processes organizations apply to key business activities. For example, maximizing the efficiency of the supply chain depends on applying knowledge of diverse areas such as raw materials sources, planning, manufacturing, and distribution. Likewise, product development requires knowledge of consumer requirements, recent scientific developments and new technologies, and marketing.
Deployment of knowledge assets to create competitive advantage becomes even more crucial as: the marketplace becomes increasingly competitive and the rate of innovation continues to rise; corporations reorganize business units to create customer value; competitive pressures reduce the workforce that holds corporate knowledge; employees have less unstructured time to acquire knowledge; and technologies increase complexity by allowing small operating companies to link with suppliers into transnational sourcing operations.
Restructuring often results in changes in strategic direction and loss of knowledge in specific functional areas. Effective KM initiatives can help eliminate the need for drastic restructurings as they help companies evolve with the changing economic environment. They can also capture knowledge assets that would otherwise be lost due to necessary restructurings, retirement, and departing employees. This can result in increased revenues, increased customer satisfaction and loyalty, enhanced competitive standing, and the ability to respond easily to changing market conditions. In this sense, KM is as critical for companies in the Information Age as the assembly line and production management were in the Industrial Age.
π‘ Why this matters: This section establishes that knowledge has replaced physical assets as the primary driver of economic value. Unlike tangible assets, knowledge assets are invisible and harder to measure, making their management a distinct strategic challenge requiring new approaches.
Practical Principles for Managing Knowledge
Theorists and practitioners are struggling to find a common set of principles to apply in successfully managing knowledge. Principles have been categorized according to how to create, collaborate, disseminate, reuse, embed, store, monitor, and measure knowledge. Customer knowledge, deploying knowledge in information technology, and monitoring and measuring knowledge assets are the places where KM principles can be practically applied.
Customer Knowledge
The first set of principles aims to lower transaction costs, increase the volume of transactions, and improve customer satisfaction by embedding customer knowledge and fail-safeing the transaction process.
1. Identify the knowledge that customers really value and make sure it is deployed in products, services, and self-service opportunities. Following this principle leads the manager to ask how much knowledge a customer employs in completing a transaction with the company. For example, an "e-tailer" such as eToys created a transaction process where the customer visits their website and uses the company Web interface to obtain a desired toy, seek suggestions, find out what others have purchased, or review the company's toy inventory. By visiting the company website, the customer becomes part of the transaction process by activating the knowledge embedded in company sales, order, provisioning, and production software.
The customer-activated knowledge costs the company next to nothing, as long as the site is well designed. Costs are incurred only if the site interface is so bad that customers make errors requiring human intervention. A site with a robust technology platform allows a very large number of customers to complete transactions at the same time.
To prevent customer induced errors, company interfaces must facilitate customers' self-service without generating errors. One method is to use the notion of "e-Poke-Yoke". The concept of mistake-proofing or Poke-Yoke originated in Japanese manufacturing practice. "Mistake-proofing is a powerful and comprehensive method for eliminating mistakes and defects, ensuring quality products and services."
Superior interfaces that embed customer knowledge within the transaction process on a personalized basis can lead to faster and more satisfying transactions. Several points to consider in designing a superior customer interface include: the time an average customer is willing to spend activating transaction knowledge; the amount of knowledge a customer will employ before losing interest; and how much value is added each time they execute knowledge.
The goal is to find the optimal upper and lower limits and develop an interface that: reduces the time a customer needs to complete the transaction process; reuses a customer's knowledge by embedding it in the transaction process; and ensures that value is added for the customer each time they execute knowledge.
A further step in providing customer value occurs when customers can compare their transaction behavior to that of others through social comparison. This is facilitated by the use of collaborative filters, which compare user input with that of other users. For example, movie ratings and CD purchases can be tabulated to generate composite scores and recommend purchases of popular items.
Personalized knowledge may be obtained from customers by providing financial incentives, such as lower prices or discounts, or using Web-based client-server technologies to track browser behavior. Benefits include: customer perception of more control over the transaction process; closer bonding with customers; lower company transaction costs; and greater volume of transactions per time period.
2. Make sure the customer product description and company description are as close as possible. Customers expect that products and services will match their descriptions. Knowledge-based descriptions can be used to ensure they are delivered as specified. This is especially true for business-to-business transactions, where outsourcing decisions are predicated on the belief that the outsourced service is delivered as specified.
Customers use lists of ingredients, fat content, calories per serving, certifications, and so forth as guides. Brand names often serve as a surrogate for products and services that meet customer expectations. Over time, customers have become more discerning and look for more than brand names. Companies can use this principle to guide their advertising, requirements for outsourcers, and production processes to ensure the knowledge required to produce a high-quality product/service has actually been applied.
Deploying Knowledge in Information Technology
Getting technology to do the work of humans has been the Holy Grail of the Information Age. The essence of the problem is deciding what human knowledge to deploy in information technology (IT). In general, the more complex the knowledge, the harder it is to deploy in IT.
1. Move simple, procedural knowledge that is employed frequently to IT. The focus of early automation efforts followed this principle as companies developed file-processing systems to do much of the tedious work in accounting, billing, and basic manufacturing. Since this knowledge is employed frequently and follows very specific, well-defined rules, moving it to IT allowed companies to dramatically lower the cost per use of the knowledge.
The latest attempt to follow this principle can be found in enterprise resource planning (ERP) software from companies such as SAP, PeopleSoft, Baan, JD Edwards, and Oracle. These systems have succeeded largely where they have stuck to this principle. They have failed where they have attempted to tackle more complex knowledge or knowledge used infrequently. For example, attempts to use an ERP system at Hewlett-Packard Labs failed largely because the system attempted to embed engineering knowledge. Studies on Nova Corporation and CBPO found that attempts to automate simple knowledge used infrequently resulted in costs that far exceeded those of leaving the knowledge in human operators' heads and hands.
2. Capture and embed knowledge in IT that is volatile and might be lost when employees leave the company. When employees leave a company, they often take with them knowledge critical to continued smooth operations. In one case, a business development executive of an Internet start-up company described his strategy as "a knowledge redundancy strategy": two key technical employees for every key technical job. This is a rational approach because such complex knowledge is not in ready supply in the employment marketplace and is nearly impossible to embed in IT. However, management realized that its long-term sustainability depends on capturing and embedding critical technical knowledge in less volatile forms such as IT.
The field of artificial intelligence supports this general principle and has spawned expert systems and neural networks. Many of the earliest commercial attempts to embed complex knowledge in IT systems were based on what would be lost when "experts" in well-defined areas retired or left the company. Neural networks use an inductive approach, learning from the patterns that evolve from the behaviors of quasi-animate objects such as electronic ant colonies.
Groupware systems have attempted to capture critical complex knowledge assets so they can be indexed and reused by others. Large consulting firms such as Arthur Andersen and Ernst & Young use groupware systems like Lotus Notes for this purpose. Ernst & Young has a system named Ernie that allows clients to "ask Ernie" when they confront problems involving relatively complex consulting knowledge.
As information technology advances allow for greater embedding of complex human knowledge, they will provide a way to capture and reuse critical employee knowledge. However, until someone discovers the algorithm for creativity, it is unlikely that all employee knowledge will be amenable to embedding in IT.
Monitoring and Measuring Knowledge
The basic goal for monitoring knowledge is to determine how well it is producing value in corporate processes. This requires following the use of knowledge throughout an organization's core processes and its interactions with the marketplace. The rate at which learning can be transformed into corporate core process knowledge will determine how quickly value is created through new products and services.
1. Accelerate the learning-knowledge-value cycle through monitoring of the transformation process. This principle requires corporate management to go beyond the traditional view of "build it and they will come." Management must accelerate the pace at which they embed critical marketplace learnings within their core processes and determine what value the introduction of this new knowledge produces. If embedding does not produce good return on the new knowledge, then management has done a poor job of synthesizing learnings from the marketplace or the marketplace has changed.
Conducting a knowledge-gap assessment aids management in determining the gaps in knowledge necessary for current operations. The assessment can identify knowledge assets that will be required to produce future value. Combining the concepts of sense, monitor and respond with a knowledge-gap assessment will help management identify the most promising knowledge for embedding in core processes.
2. Identify existing and future knowledge gaps. Monitoring the learning-knowledge-value cycle will reveal gaps in current performance. Planning for future products and services will reveal gaps in knowledge required to produce these future products and services. The knowledge-gap assessment is a powerful method for identifying the gaps:
- Begin with a definition or mapping of core processes in terms of the knowledge required to conduct normal operations.
- Make a list of the knowledge potential not currently in use within the core processes.
- Make a list of the knowledge no longer necessary to successfully generate the outputs.
- List the kinds of knowledge the company will need in the future to meet its long-and short-term goals.
- Compare the current knowledge assets deployed in the processes and identify the gaps.
Enhancing, maintaining, and acquiring knowledge assets to fill knowledge gaps involves: listing methods to maintain the current level of knowledge assets deployed; listing methods to remove knowledge no longer needed; listing methods to narrow or remove the gaps; and listing current strategies for knowledge maintenance and acquisition through hiring, training, outsourcing, information systems, and work rules.
3. Identify the best practices for embedding knowledge in IT, people, and processes. Best practices in knowledge management have been benchmarked by the American Productivity and Quality Center and at Arthur Andersen and are available in various forms from both organizations.
4. Measure the value-added by knowledge to create an internal marketplace. This principle can be followed best by creating a simple knowledge accounting system to monitor knowledge utilization. The system should allow managers to establish a price and cost per unit of knowledge, tied directly to companies' normal financial performance measures such as ROI, cash flow, and earnings per share. This provides management with feedback about how well they are managing the learning-knowledge-value cycle.
Providing price and cost per unit of knowledge will lead to new performance ratios such as: knowledge in use compared to knowledge in inventory; total knowledge compared to amount reused; and knowledge in people compared to knowledge in IT. Such measurement systems will lead to better protections for investors in companies with large market capitalization based on intangible assets contained in intellectual capital.
β Key Takeaways
Knowledge management is the preeminent economic resource in the Information Age and is fundamentally different from Industrial Age reengineeringβit focuses on identifying and maximizing knowledge value rather than "slash-and-burn" cost-cutting. The lecture establishes that while KM offers immense benefits (Chevron saved $170 million annually; Dow Chemical increased licensing revenues by $100 million), the field suffers from confusion and a lack of standardized measurement tools. Three critical domains for practical application are identified: customer knowledge (embedding knowledge in self-service interfaces using Poke-Yoke principles to prevent errors and using collaborative filters), deploying knowledge in IT (moving simple procedural knowledge to IT while capturing volatile knowledge that would be lost when employees leave), and monitoring and measuring knowledge (accelerating the learning-knowledge-value cycle, conducting knowledge-gap assessments, and creating knowledge accounting systems with price and cost per unit of knowledge). Success in today's marketplace depends on the quality of knowledge applied to key business activities, and the ability to transform learning into core process knowledge determines how quickly value is created.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four principal difficulties associated with designing and implementing knowledge management practices according to the lecture?
- How did Chevron realize a $170 million annual savings through knowledge management, and what were the two specific team savings mentioned?
- What is the concept of "Poke-Yoke" (or "e-Poke-Yoke") and how does it apply to embedding customer knowledge in transaction interfaces?
- What are the two basic principles for deploying knowledge in information technology, and why did the ERP implementation at Hewlett-Packard Labs fail?
- What are the five steps in conducting a knowledge-gap assessment, and what four types of new performance ratios does the lecture suggest for measuring knowledge value?
π Lecture 15 β How KM Impacts Organizations?
π Overview: This lecture explores the multifaceted ways knowledge management affects organizations across four critical levels: people, processes, products, and overall organizational performance. Understanding these impacts is essential for justifying KM investments and designing effective KM strategies that deliver tangible business value.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers how KM impacts people through enhanced learning and job satisfaction, improves organizational processes along dimensions of effectiveness, efficiency, and innovation, and contributes to both value-added and knowledge-based products. It also examines direct and indirect impacts on organizational performance through economies of scale and scope, sustainable competitive advantage, and specific industry examples such as Shell's oil exploration community of practice. Finally, it explores how internalization, externalization, socialization, and communities of practice facilitate employee learning.
π Lecture Summary
How KM Impacts Organizations
Knowledge management can impact organizations in various ways and at several levels by way of people, processes, products, and overall organizational performance. At all of these levels, knowledge management affects organizations in two ways: first, it can help create knowledge, which can then contribute to improved performance; second, it can directly cause improvements along these four levels.
The impact on people involves facilitating learning throughout the organization, allowing constant growth and change in response to market and technology, making employees more flexible, and enhancing their job satisfaction. The impact on processes enables improvements in organizational processes such as marketing, manufacturing, accounting, engineering, and public relations along three dimensions: effectiveness, efficiency, and degree of innovation. The impact on products can be seen in value-added products and knowledge-based products. The impact on organizational performance can occur either directly or indirectly.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these four levels helps managers target their KM initiatives precisely, ensuring resources are directed toward areas that will yield the greatest returns.
State the importance of KM with specific reference to its impact on employee adaptability and job satisfaction
On employee adaptability, knowledge management encourages employees to continually learn from each other, making them likely to possess the information and knowledge needed to adapt whenever organizational circumstances require. When employees are aware of ongoing and potential future changes, they are less likely to be caught by surprise. Awareness of new ideas and involvement in free-flowing discussions not only prepare them to respond to changes but also make them more likely to accept change. Thus, KM tends to facilitate greater adaptability among employees.
On job satisfaction, two benefits accrue directly to individual employees: they are able to learn better than employees in firms lacking KM, and they are better prepared for change. These impacts cause employees to feel better because of knowledge acquisition and skill enhancement, and also enhance their market value relative to other organizations' employees. KM also provides employees with solutions to problems they face in case those same problems have been encountered earlier and effectively addressed. This helps keep employees motivated, for a successful employee would be highly motivated, while an employee facing problems in performing their job is likely to be demotivated. As a result of their increased knowledge, improved market value, and greater on-the-job performance, KM facilitates employees' job satisfaction.
π Definition β Employee Adaptability: The ability of employees to respond effectively to organizational changes through awareness, learning, and acceptance of new circumstances.
Explain why poor KM reduces the effectiveness of organizational processes
Effectiveness is performing the most suitable processes and making the best possible decisions. Poor KM can result in mistakes by the organization because they risk repeating past mistakes or not foreseeing otherwise obvious problems. Organizations lacking in KM find it difficult to maintain process effectiveness when faced with turnover of experienced and new employees. In contrast, a good knowledge management system can enable organizations to become more effective by helping them to select and perform the most appropriate processes. Effective KM enables the organization's members to collect information needed to monitor external events, resulting in fewer surprises for leaders and consequently reducing the need to modify plans and settle for less effective approaches. Further, knowledge management enables organizations to quickly adapt their processes according to current circumstances, thereby maintaining process effectiveness in changing times.
π Definition β Process Effectiveness: Performing the most suitable processes and making the best possible decisions to achieve organizational goals.
What three dimensions are relevant for examining the impact of KM on business processes?
Knowledge management is an important factor for the effectiveness of organizational processes such as marketing, manufacturing, accounting, engineering, and public relations. The impact of KM can be seen along three major dimensions: effectiveness, efficiency, and degree of innovation of the processes.
π Definition β Process Efficiency: Performing the processes quickly and in a low-cost fashion. π Definition β Process Innovation: Performing the processes in a creative and novel fashion that improves effectiveness and efficiency.
State reasons how KM helps improve process effectiveness, efficiency, and innovation
Process Effectiveness: Poor KM can result in mistakes because organizations risk repeating past mistakes or not foreseeing obvious problems. Organizations lacking KM find it difficult to maintain process effectiveness when faced with employee turnover. A good knowledge management system enables organizations to become more effective by helping them select and perform the most appropriate processes. Effective KM enables members to collect information needed to monitor external events, resulting in fewer surprises and reducing the need to modify plans. KM also enables organizations to quickly adapt processes according to current circumstances.
Process Efficiency: KM can enable organizations to be more productive and efficient. The ability to effectively create and manage network-level knowledge sharing processes results in productivity advantages enjoyed by the organization.
Process Innovation: Organizations increasingly rely on knowledge shared across individuals to produce innovative solutions to problems as well as to develop more innovative organizational processes. Knowledge management has been found to enable riskier brainstorming and thereby enhance process innovation.
Describe how KM can contribute to an organization's products
Knowledge management can impact the organization's products in two respects: value-added products and knowledge-based products.
Impact on Value-Added Products: With the aid of KM processes, organizations can offer new products or improved products that provide significant additional value compared to earlier products. Value-added products also benefit from KM due to its effect on organizational process innovation.
Impact on Knowledge-Based Products: Knowledge-based products, such as those in consulting or software development industries, can also benefit from knowledge management. Using KM, consulting firms can quickly access and combine the best available knowledge and bid on proposals that would otherwise be too costly or too time-consuming to put together. In such industries, KM is necessary for mere survival. However, knowledge-based products can also sometimes play an important role in traditional manufacturing firms. For example, to design an automated machine to spin yarn, the organization must observe an expert hand-spinner to learn how the process takes place in order to give the machine proper functionality.
How can we assess the direct impact of KM on organizational performance?
Knowledge management affects the overall performance of the organization either directly or indirectly.
Direct impact on organizational performance occurs when knowledge is used to create innovative products that generate revenue and profit, or when the KM strategy is aligned with business strategy. Such a direct impact concerns revenues and/or costs and can be explicitly linked to the organization's vision or strategy. Consequently, measuring direct impact is relatively straightforward β it can be observed in terms of improvements in return on investment. Unlike indirect impacts, direct impacts can be associated with transactions and, therefore, are easily measured.
Describe the ways in which the indirect impacts of KM in an organization may be observed
Indirect impact on organizational performance comes about through activities that are not directly linked to the organization's vision, strategy, revenues, or costs. Such effects occur through the use of KM to demonstrate intellectual leadership within the industry, which, in turn, might enhance customer loyalty. Alternatively, it could occur through the use of knowledge to gain an advantageous negotiating position with respect to competitors or partner organizations. Indirect impact cannot be associated with transactions and, therefore, cannot be easily measured.
Further, a company's output is said to exhibit economy of scale if the average cost of production per unit decreases with increase in output. A company's output is said to exhibit economy of scope when the total cost of that same company producing two or more different products is less than the sum of the costs that would be incurred if each product was produced separately by a different company. Knowledge management can contribute to economies of scale and scope by improving the organization's ability to create and leverage knowledge related to products, customers, and managerial resources across businesses. Product designs, components, manufacturing processes, and expertise can be shared across businesses, thereby reducing development and manufacturing costs, accelerating new product development, and supporting quick response to new market opportunities. Economies of scope also result from the deployment of general marketing skills and sales forces across businesses.
Another indirect impact of KM is to provide a sustainable competitive advantage. Knowledge can enable the organization to develop and exploit other tangible and intangible resources better than competitors can. Knowledge, especially context-specific tacit knowledge, tends to be unique and therefore difficult to imitate, and it cannot easily be purchased in a ready-to-use form. To obtain similar knowledge, the company's competitors have to engage in similar experiences, but this takes time. Therefore, competitors are limited in the extent to which they can accelerate their learning through greater investment.
π Definition β Economy of Scale: Situation where the average cost of production per unit decreases with an increase in output. π Definition β Economy of Scope: Situation where the total cost of producing two or more different products by the same company is less than the sum of costs if each product was produced separately by different companies.
Knowledge management is an invaluable tool to the oil and gas industry
Oil exploration often involves extrapolating from sketchy data and comparing exploration sites to known ones. This allows geoscientists to decide if enough reserves exist on a site to make developing it worthwhile.
π Definition β Community of Practice: An organic and self-organized group of individuals who are dispersed geographically or organizationally but communicate regularly to discuss issues of mutual interest.
π Example β Shell's Community of Practice Savings: One site contained layers of oil-bearing sand less than an inch thick. To decide if thin sand beds could extend over a large enough area for efficient pumping, a Shell exploration team asked one of Shell's communities of practice, including geoscientists from several disciplines, for help. By comparing this site to others, the community helped in the team's analysis of where to drill more accurately, resulting in fewer expensive exploratory wells. The Shell team estimated that discussions enabled them to drill and test three fewer wells a year, saving US$20M in drilling and an additional US$20M in testing costs for each well β an annual saving of US$120M. The leader estimated the community could claim 25 percent of savings and was 80 percent sure of this estimate. So the community may be argued to have saved 25 percent of 80 percent of US$120M, i.e., US$24M annually. Since it costs between US$300K and US$400K annually to run the community, this represented an annual return of 40 times the investment.
Describe the impact of internalization, externalization, socialization, and communities of practice on employee learning
Knowledge management can help enhance employees' learning and exposure to the latest knowledge in their fields through externalization, internalization, socialization, and communities of practice.
Internalization is the conversion of explicit knowledge into tacit knowledge. It works in conjunction with externalization to help individuals learn. If an employee in an accounting firm reads a book on well-established accounting practices, he can use this externalized knowledge to acquire tacit knowledge and improve his daily work.
Externalization is the process of converting tacit knowledge into explicit forms. It works in conjunction with internalization to help individuals learn. Externalization could be demonstrated by means of a report made at the end of a project, indicating the procedures followed and the lessons learned.
Socialization also helps individuals acquire knowledge by means of joint activities, such as meetings, informal conversations, etc. By participating in these meetings or activities, individuals obtain both explicit and implicit knowledge.
Communities of Practice are an extension of socialization. They are an organic and self-organized group of individuals who are dispersed geographically or organizationally but communicate regularly to discuss issues of mutual interest. They result in increased learning among all the participants.
π Definition β Internalization: The conversion of explicit knowledge into tacit knowledge. π Definition β Externalization: The process of converting tacit knowledge into explicit forms. π Definition β Socialization: The acquisition of knowledge by individuals through joint activities such as meetings and informal conversations.
β Key Takeaways
Knowledge management impacts organizations at four critical levels β people, processes, products, and overall organizational performance β either by creating knowledge that improves performance or by directly causing improvements. For people, KM enhances employee adaptability and job satisfaction through continuous learning, problem-solving support, and increased market value. For processes, KM improves effectiveness (selecting and performing the best processes), efficiency (quick, low-cost performance), and innovation (creative, novel approaches). For products, KM enables both value-added enhancements and knowledge-based product development, particularly critical in consulting and software industries. Organizational performance benefits from KM through both direct impacts (measurable improvements in ROI through innovative products and aligned strategy) and indirect impacts (economies of scale and scope, sustainable competitive advantage through unique tacit knowledge, and intellectual leadership). The Shell oil exploration example demonstrates that communities of practice can deliver an ROI of 40 times the investment, while the four knowledge conversion modes (internalization, externalization, socialization, and communities of practice) form the foundation for employee learning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What four levels of organizational impact does KM affect, and what are the two main ways KM impacts organizations at these levels?
-
How does KM specifically contribute to employee job satisfaction, and why does poor KM reduce process effectiveness?
-
What are the three dimensions for examining KM's impact on business processes, and how does KM help improve each dimension?
-
What is the difference between direct and indirect impacts of KM on organizational performance, and provide one example of each?
-
In the Shell oil exploration example, how was the annual savings of the community of practice calculated, and what was the resulting return on investment?