📘 Lecture 10 — Extracting Gold from Data; Understanding Conversion of Data into Knowledge
📖 Overview: This lecture clarifies the critical distinctions between data, information, and knowledge, and explains how raw data is transformed into valuable knowledge that enables action and decision-making. It also explores different classifications and perspectives of knowledge, including subjective vs. objective views, declarative vs. procedural knowledge, and the various repositories where knowledge resides within organizations.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by differentiating data from knowledge using examples like cricket spectators and computer prices, then justifies that information contains data but not all data is information. It explains why the same data can be useful to some and useless to others, describes the hierarchical and advanced views of knowledge, and emphasizes knowledge's role in creating and utilizing information. The lecture compares subjective vs. objective views of knowledge (as state of mind, practice, objects, access, capability), distinguishes declarative "know what" from procedural "know how" knowledge, differentiates general from specific knowledge, defines expertise, and concludes by contrasting knowledge in people, artifacts, and organizational entities.
📝 Lecture Summary
Q#1 How do the terms “data” and “knowledge” differ? Describe each term with the help of a similar example, elucidating the difference between the two.
Data comprises facts, observations, or perceptions that by themselves represent raw numbers or assertions, and may therefore be devoid of context, meaning, or intent. Examples include: the age and gender of each spectator in a cricket match, or the price of each computer model from every vendor at a particular time.
Knowledge has been distinguished from data in two ways. The more simplistic view places knowledge at the highest level in a hierarchy with information in the middle and data at the bottom. For example, an e-mail address is data; knowing it belongs to a customer is information; knowing this customer needs weekly reminders to pay dues is knowledge. The second way defines knowledge as justified beliefs about relationships among concepts relevant to a particular area.
Using the cricket example: age and gender of spectators is only data, but when combined with buying preferences, stadium planners can forecast products that will sell during a game. Similarly, computer prices plus shipping costs and rebates provide a buyer the knowledge of how much they will likely spend on each model.
💡 Why this matters: Knowledge differs from data because it helps produce information from data or more valuable information from less valuable information, which in turn facilitates an action.
🔑 Definition — Data: Facts, observations, or perceptions that represent raw numbers or assertions, often devoid of context, meaning, or intent.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge (simplistic view): The highest level in a hierarchy (data → information → knowledge) — information that enables action and decisions, or information with direction.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge (advanced view): Justified beliefs about relationships among concepts relevant to a particular area.
📌 Example: An e-mail address is data; knowing it belongs to a customer is information; knowing this customer needs weekly reminders to pay dues is knowledge.
Q#2 “Information” contains “data” but not all “data” is “information.” Justify this statement.
Data is devoid of context, meaning, or intent. Information is a subset of data — it only includes those data that possess context, relevance, and purpose. Information typically involves the manipulation of raw data to obtain a more meaningful indication of trends or patterns.
Examples: The total number of TV viewers who watched the Super Bowl is mere data. However, knowing that maximum viewers occur during the third and fourth quarters is information for companies deciding when to place commercials. The price of a large bag of popcorn at a theatre is data, but averaging popcorn prices across competing theatres to stay competitive is useful information.
Thus, information is derived from data through manipulation. All information is data, but not all data is information.
🔑 Definition — Information: A subset of data that possesses context, relevance, and purpose; data that has been manipulated to reveal meaningful trends or patterns.
📌 Example: The raw number of Super Bowl viewers is data; knowing viewership peaks in the third and fourth quarters is information for commercial placement decisions.
Q#3 Explain why the same set of data can be considered as useful information by some and useless data by others. Further, could this useful information be termed as “knowledge”? Why?
Whether certain facts are information or only data depends on the individual who is using those facts — their context, relevance, and purpose vary by person. The same data may be useful information to one person and meaningless data to another.
Useful information can be termed as knowledge only if it enables action and decisions, or provides information with direction. Knowledge is intrinsically similar to information and data, but is the richest and deepest of the three, and consequently the most valuable.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge (action-oriented): Information that enables action and decisions; information with direction.
📌 Example: Raw sales figures may be meaningless data to a new employee but become useful information and then knowledge to a manager who uses them to decide inventory levels.
Q#4 Describe the ways in which “knowledge” differs from “data” and “information.” Justify your answer with a relevant diagram.
Knowledge can be distinguished from data and information in two ways:
The basic view considers knowledge as being at the highest level in a hierarchy with information at the middle and data at the lowest level. Knowledge refers to information that enables action and decisions — it is intrinsically similar to data and information but is the richest, deepest, and most valuable.
The advanced view considers knowledge as intrinsically different from information. It defines knowledge in an area as justified beliefs about relationships among concepts relevant to that particular area.
To sum up, knowledge helps produce information from data or more valuable information from less valuable information, and this information facilitates action. Based on the newly generated information and relationships with other concepts, knowledge enables the beholder to make decisions.
📐 Diagram Concept (Hierarchical View): Data (lowest) → Information (middle) → Knowledge (highest)
💡 Why this matters: The basic view treats knowledge as "high-value information," while the advanced view treats knowledge as fundamentally different — a system of justified beliefs about relationships.
Q#5 Explain the importance of knowledge in creation and utilization of information.
Knowledge helps produce information from data or more valuable information from less valuable information, resulting in the facilitation of an action or decision. Knowledge helps convert data into information, and the use of information to make decisions requires knowledge as well.
Decisions, along with certain unrelated factors, lead to events, which cause generation of further data. The events, the use of information, and the information system might cause modifications in the knowledge itself.
Knowledge is vital in the ongoing cycle: creation of data → information → decision making → events → further data and information. Knowledge is both the catalyst and the end product of this continuous cycle.
📐 Cycle: Data → (Knowledge applied) → Information → (Knowledge applied) → Decision → Event → New Data → (Knowledge modified) → ...
Q#6 How does the subjective view of knowledge differ from the objective view? Explain how knowledge can be viewed as a state of mind, as a practice, as objects, as access to information and as capability.
The Subjective view of knowledge refers to it as an ongoing accomplishment that continuously affects and is influenced by social practices. It has no existence independent of social practices and human experiences. Two perspectives:
- Knowledge as a state of mind: Knowledge is a state of an individual's mind; organizational knowledge is the beliefs of individuals within the organization.
- Knowledge as a practice: Knowledge is held by a group and cannot be broken down into separate elements possessed by individuals. It resides in practice, not in anyone's head — reflected in organizational activities.
The Objective view holds that reality is independent of human perceptions and can be structured in terms of categories and concepts. Knowledge can be located as an object or capability that can be discovered or improved. Three perspectives:
- Knowledge as Objects: Knowledge can be stored, transferred, manipulated, and exist in various locations.
- Knowledge as Access to Information: Knowledge enables access and utilization of information, emphasizing accessibility of knowledge objects.
- Knowledge as Capability: Knowledge is a strategic capability that can be applied to seek a competitive advantage.
🔑 Definition — Subjective view of knowledge: An ongoing accomplishment that continuously affects and is influenced by social practices, without independent existence.
🔑 Definition — Objective view of knowledge: Reality independent of human perceptions; knowledge can be located as objects or capabilities discovered/improved by human agents.
Q#7 What is the difference between knowledge characterized as “know what” and “know how”? In these situations, how would you classify the knowledge a computer programmer has?
Knowledge can be classified into Declarative Knowledge and Procedural Knowledge.
- Declarative Knowledge (Substantive Knowledge): Focuses on beliefs about relationships among variables. Can be stated as propositions, expected correlations, or formulas. Characterized as "know what." Example: The average fuel consumption of a particular car.
- Procedural Knowledge: Focuses on beliefs relating sequences of steps or actions to achieve a certain outcome. Characterized as "know how." Example: Following steps to fix a car to improve its petrol mileage.
A computer programmer has both types: knowing the syntax of the programming language is declarative knowledge; knowing the logic steps to develop a program is procedural knowledge.
🔑 Definition — Declarative Knowledge: Beliefs about relationships among variables; "know what" — can be stated as propositions, correlations, or formulas.
🔑 Definition — Procedural Knowledge: Beliefs about sequences of steps or actions to achieve an outcome; "know how."
📌 Example: A programmer knows the syntax of Java (declarative/"know what") and the logical steps to write a sorting algorithm (procedural/"know how").
Q#8 What is general knowledge? How does it differ from specific knowledge? Describe the types of specific knowledge with suitable examples.
General Knowledge is possessed by a large number of people and is easily transferred from one person to another. Example: It is general knowledge that the earth revolves around the sun.
Specific Knowledge (Idiosyncratic Knowledge) is possessed by a very limited number of individuals and is difficult to transfer. Example: Scientists who know the exact distance between the earth and the sun based on its orbit.
Two types of specific knowledge:
- Technically-specific knowledge: Deep knowledge about a specific area, including tools and techniques to address problems in that area. Often acquired through formal training and augmented by experience. Example: The exact distance between earth and sun.
- Contextually-specific knowledge: Knowledge of particular circumstances of time and place in which work is performed. Pertains to organization and subunit context; cannot be acquired through formal training but must be obtained from within the specific context. Example: An astrophysicist calculating the exact duration and time an eclipse will occur based on experience.
🔑 Definition — General Knowledge: Knowledge possessed by a large number of people and easily transferred.
🔑 Definition — Specific Knowledge (Idiosyncratic Knowledge): Knowledge possessed by very few individuals and difficult to transfer.
Q#9 What is “expertise”? Distinguish among the three types of expertise.
Expertise is defined as knowledge of higher quality, which addresses the degree of knowledge. It refers to very specific knowledge; those who possess expertise can perform a task much better than those who do not. A person can be an expert at a particular task regardless of how sophisticated that area is.
To understand expertise, skill levels of experts from different domains should not be compared to each other. All experts require more or less the same cognitive skills. The difference lies in the depth of expertise when compared to others from their own domain. Example: A race car driver has more skill than the average car driver.
Note: The lecture text mentions "three types of expertise" in the question but only provides one general description without explicitly delineating three distinct types in the provided content.
🔑 Definition — Expertise: Knowledge of higher quality; very specific knowledge enabling superior task performance.
📌 Example: A race car driver has greater expertise (more skill) than an average car driver, but both are drivers.
Q#10 Contrast the differences between knowledge in people and knowledge in artifacts. Describe the various repositories of knowledge within organizational entities.
Knowledge resides in several different locations or reservoirs:
- Knowledge in People: A considerable component of knowledge is stored in individuals within organizations. Knowledge also resides within groups due to relationships among members — groups form beliefs about what works. Communities of practice develop as individuals interact frequently on topics of mutual interest.
- Knowledge in Artifacts: Significant knowledge is stored in practices, organizational routines, or sequential patterns of interaction. Often embedded in procedures, rules, and norms developed through experience. Also stored in technologies, systems, and knowledge repositories (e.g., a log of customer calls to develop an FAQ section).
- Knowledge in Organizational Entities (three levels):
- Organizational units/parts: Formal groupings of individuals due to organizational structuring. When incumbents depart, successors inherit knowledge via systems, practices, and relationships.
- Entire organization (business unit/corporation): Stores norms, values, practices, and culture. Organizational response to environmental events depends on knowledge stored in individuals, units, and overall organizational knowledge from experiences.
- Interorganizational relationships: Organizations draw upon knowledge embedded in relationships with customers and suppliers. They learn from customer experiences to improve products.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge in People: Knowledge stored in individuals and groups, including communities of practice.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge in Artifacts: Knowledge stored in practices, routines, procedures, rules, norms, technologies, systems, and knowledge repositories.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge in Organizational Entities: Knowledge stored at three levels: organizational units, entire organization, and interorganizational relationships.
Q#11 Determine the various types of knowledge you are used to. You should be able to state at least one of each type.
Knowledge can be classified in several ways:
- Declarative Knowledge – Used in understanding meanings of English words (e.g., "physical," "cognitive") and punctuation marks.
- Procedural Knowledge – Used in the actual reading of the book, e.g., knowing to turn the page when reaching the end.
- Tacit Knowledge – Gained from reading the preface, which helps understand the chapter's contents.
- Explicit Knowledge – Contained in the text of the chapter, helping understand tables and figures.
- General Knowledge – About topics like restaurants, coins, and hurricanes, used to understand concepts in the chapter.
- Specific Knowledge – Used to apply concepts read in the chapter to real-world situations encountered at work.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical understanding from this lecture is that data, information, and knowledge form a hierarchy where data is raw and context-free, information is data with context and purpose, and knowledge is information that enables action and decision-making. Knowledge differs from data and information in that it helps produce information from data and facilitates decisions, and it can be viewed subjectively (as a state of mind or practice) or objectively (as objects, access to information, or capability). Students must remember the key classifications: declarative vs. procedural knowledge, general vs. specific knowledge (with technically-specific and contextually-specific subtypes), and the distinction between knowledge in people (individuals and groups), knowledge in artifacts (routines, rules, repositories), and knowledge in organizational entities (units, entire organizations, interorganizational relationships). Expertise represents the highest quality of knowledge, enabling superior task performance in specific domains.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between the basic (hierarchical) view and the advanced view of knowledge?
- How does knowledge serve as both a catalyst and an end product in the data-information-decision cycle?
- Contrast the subjective view of knowledge as a "state of mind" versus knowledge as a "practice."
- What distinguishes technically-specific knowledge from contextually-specific knowledge, and how is each acquired?
- Name and describe the three levels at which knowledge is stored in organizational entities.
📘 Lecture 11 — Understanding Data for Analysis and Decision/Policy Making
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental distinctions between data, information, and knowledge through practical, everyday examples. It demonstrates how these three concepts interact in decision-making processes and examines various theoretical perspectives on knowledge, including objective and subjective views, types of expertise, and different knowledge classifications.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with practical examples illustrating how data, information, and knowledge operate in daily decisions like sending emails, watching TV, and driving to work. It then examines how decisions would be hindered without pre-existing data, information, or knowledge. The text presents two ways of distinguishing knowledge from information and data, provides examples from fast food restaurant contexts, describes various perspectives on knowledge (subjective vs. objective), lists three types of objective knowledge, explains classifications including procedural/declarative, tacit/explicit, and general/specific knowledge, and covers how explicit knowledge transfers to tacit knowledge. The lecture concludes with three types of expertise: associational, motor skill, and theoretical.
📝 Lecture Summary
1. Consider five decisions you might have made today
This section presents five everyday actions and breaks down the data, information, and knowledge involved in each. For sending an email, data is the email addresses of all university individuals, information is the specific friend's email address, and knowledge is how to send an email. For watching a favorite TV program, data is opening the TV guide, information is referring to the guide for air time, and knowledge is turning on the TV and setting the channel. For driving to work, data is details about car functions (brakes, steering), information is directions from home to work, and knowledge is how to drive and maneuver. For answering a ringing telephone, data is hearing the phone ring, information is where the phone is located, and knowledge is how to pick up the receiver and answer. For setting a clock for Daylight Saving Time, data is dates with and without DST, information is the date and time to make the change, and knowledge is which direction and by how much to adjust.
2. How decisions would be influenced by lack of pre-existing data, information, or knowledge
Each action would be hindered or impossible without pre-existing data, information, or knowledge. Sending an email is impossible without the information of the friend's email address, though lack of data on all student emails is not a problem if the specific address is known. Basic knowledge of how to open an email program is necessary. Watching a TV program is possible without a TV guide, but it is a hindrance without knowing the air time. Driving to work absolutely requires knowledge of how to drive and the directions, but not detailed data about car functions. Answering a phone makes hearing the ring vital; information about phone location may be less important since one can move toward the sound. Setting a clock requires information on when and how to make the change and knowledge about direction and extent of adjustment.
3. Inventing a new product and collecting demographic data
This answer focuses on identifying specific kinds of data (e.g., age, gender, education, income) and manipulating this data based on characteristics of the invented product. For example, if the new product targets older men, the average education level and income of men in higher age groups would help identify pricing and the target audience for advertising.
4. Contrasting views of knowledge between manufacturing and services managers
Possible differences include: The manager in the manufacturing organization might identify greater examples of procedural knowledge, while the manager in the services organization might identify greater examples of declarative knowledge. The manufacturing manager might identify greater examples of tacit knowledge, whereas the services manager might identify greater examples of explicit knowledge.
Q1: Two ways for distinguishing knowledge from information and data
The simpler view distinguishes by value: data has little value, information has more value, and knowledge has the greatest value. In this view, knowledge is at the top of an information hierarchy with information value as the vertical axis. The second view states that knowledge is what enables us to produce more valuable information from less valuable information, with importance on the transformation process—it is about relationships between pieces of information.
Q2: Examples of data, information, and knowledge from fast food restaurant perspective
Data: number of burgers ordered, number of burgers served, server and chef salaries, burgers in stock, sales price of an order, cost of a burger. Information: daily sales numbers (rupees, quantity, or percent) for each item, daily reduction in inventory for each item, total number of customers, percentage of customers ordering burgers/shakes/other, reorder quantities, average time spent by a server on each customer. Knowledge: trend of customer numbers indicating future customers and ordering patterns, relationship between projected burger sales and bread inventory, relationship between projected customers and average server time to determine staffing needs.
Q3: Various perspectives on knowledge
Knowledge may be examined either subjectively or objectively. The subjective view ties knowledge to an individual's experience in social interactions and is classified as either a state of mind or as a practice. The objective view claims that knowledge exists in a priori categories or concepts independent of any individual, and may exist as an object, a capability, or simply as access to information.
Q4: Three types of objective knowledge
- Knowledge as an object: something that can be stored, transferred, and manipulated.
- Knowledge as access to information: enables access and utilization of information.
- Knowledge as capability: emphasis on knowledge as a strategic capability, how knowledge may be applied to influence action.
Q5: Three classifications of knowledge
- Procedural or declarative: knowledge classified as either data-oriented or task-oriented.
- Tacit or explicit: knowledge held in the heads of individuals/groups or alternately encoded in some other storage medium.
- General or specific: indicates breadth of ownership—general knowledge held by many, specific knowledge held by few.
Q6: How explicit knowledge can be transferred to tacit knowledge
Explicit knowledge is articulated (and frequently encoded) and may be easily transferred to another individual or group. When an individual acquires knowledge from an explicit form (through reading/hearing/feeling/observing), the knowledge must be remembered to become tacit and is transformed to conform to or modify the individual's existing belief system. Example: An employee looks into a manual to determine how to install new hardware—the manual is explicit procedural information. After performing a few installs, the employee learns the specified procedures and possible improvements, transforming explicit knowledge into tacit knowledge.
Q7: Three types of expertise
- Associational expertise: comes from years of experience and recognizing patterns in data. Example: a mechanic diagnosing car problems just from listening to sounds.
- Motor skill expertise: predominantly physical instead of cognitive, resulting from a very large number of practice sessions to develop a particular physical skill such as shooting a basketball.
- Theoretical or deep expertise: knowledge of a particular topic far beyond the average individual. The ability to go beyond superficial understanding and create novel solutions based on theoretical foundations of the domain.
Test Your Understanding Questions:
-
Select one definition of KM: Any definition is a candidate because of aspects like using accessible knowledge from outside sources, embedding knowledge in business processes, representing knowledge in databases, promoting knowledge growth through culture and incentives, transferring knowledge throughout the organization, and assessing knowledge assets regularly.
-
KM involves people, technology, and processes: The ideal organization exchanges knowledge across functional areas by using technology and established processes. The exchange may be for policy formulation, strategy, training, development, or problem solving in teams. None of the three areas can function independently.
-
KM indicator—thinking ahead: Progress, advancement, and growth are future-oriented and require people to think ahead.
-
Why KM is not about: Reengineering—KM is a mechanical shift, not a one-shot drastic change. A discipline—KM is another way to improve quality, profitability, and growth. Data—Data is facts without context; KM is actionable information to create value. Knowledge capture—Knowledge cannot be captured in its entirety because of implied human maturation over time that upgrades knowledge quality and value, especially tacit knowledge.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The critical distinction between data, information, and knowledge lies in their value hierarchy and the transformation process where knowledge enables creating more valuable information from less valuable information. Knowledge can be viewed subjectively (tied to individual experience) or objectively (existing in a priori categories). Three key knowledge classifications are procedural vs. declarative, tacit vs. explicit, and general vs. specific. Expertise takes three forms: associational (pattern recognition from experience), motor skill (physical practice-based), and theoretical (deep domain knowledge enabling novel solutions). KM operates at the intersection of people, technology, and processes, and cannot function if any one area is independent.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two ways presented in the text for distinguishing knowledge from information and data?
- Give one example each of data, information, and knowledge from a fast food restaurant perspective.
- What are the three types of objective knowledge, and what does each emphasize?
- How can explicit knowledge be transferred to tacit knowledge? Provide an example.
- What are the three types of expertise discussed in the text, and what differentiates them?
📘 Lecture 12 — Knowledge Hierarchy... Individual vs Organization
📖 Overview: This lecture explores how humans think and learn, contrasting human cognitive processes with artificial intelligence. It examines the three types of human learning—by experience, by example, and by discovery—and their implications for knowledge management in organizations. Understanding these learning mechanisms is essential for capturing and leveraging expert knowledge effectively.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers human thinking and learning processes, comparing them with computer processing; the three types of human learning (experience, example, discovery); implications for knowledge management at organizational level including knowledge sharing and preservation; attributes of intelligent behavior; classifications of knowledge (procedural, declarative, semantic, episodic, tacit, explicit); and reasoning types including deductive, inductive, and case-based reasoning.
📝 Lecture Summary
Human Thinking and Learning
Scientists study the human brain to build computers that may someday duplicate human expert thought processes. According to Marvin Minsky (1991), the human mind is a “society of minds” that is hierarchically structured and interconnected. Both mind and machine accept data and information, manipulate symbols, store items in memory, and retrieve items on command. However, humans receive information via sensing—seeing, smelling, tasting, touching, and hearing—which promotes unique thinking and learning. On a micro level, both the central processing unit of a computer and the human brain receive information as electrical impulses. The key difference is that computers must be programmed to do specific tasks; performing one job does not transcend onto other jobs as it does with humans.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge: Understanding gained through experience
🔑 Definition — Intelligence: The capacity to acquire and apply knowledge
💡 Why this matters: Understanding the differences between human and machine thinking helps knowledge developers design better systems for capturing expertise.
Human Learning
Memory is an essential component of learning because it accommodates learning. Healthy human memory never seems to run out of space. As humans acquire more knowledge, they integrate new facts with what they think is relevant and organize the resulting mix to produce valuable decisions, solutions, or advice.
For humans, learning occurs in one of three ways:
Learning By Experience: The ability to learn by experience is a mark of intelligence. Experts, who know a lot about a particular problem, remember facts in that problem area much more easily and quickly than non-experts. This type of information is important for knowledge developers to understand when evaluating a human expert’s range of knowledge.
🔑 Definition — Experience: The factor that changes unrelated facts into expert knowledge
🔑 Definition — Heuristic: A rule of thumb based on years of experience
Learning By Example: Specially constructed examples are used instead of a broad range of experience. Much classroom instruction is composed of teaching by example—providing examples, cases, or scenarios that develop concepts students are expected to learn. This method allows students to learn without requiring them to accumulate experience, making it more efficient than learning by experience.
Learning By Discovery: This is an undirected approach in which humans explore a problem area without advanced knowledge of the objective. No one understands why humans are so good at this. It is difficult to teach and will be years before we can benefit from this approach commercially.
🔑 Definition — Common sense: Innate ability to sense, judge, or perceive situations that grows stronger over time; inferences made from knowledge about the world
Implications for Knowledge Management at Organization
Knowledge awareness benefits entire organizations. With emphasis on sustainable competitive advantage, added value, and improved productivity, management needs to create, innovate, monitor, and protect its knowledge inventory. A KM environment means focusing on: generating new knowledge; transferring existing knowledge; embedding knowledge in products, services, and processes; developing an environment for facilitating knowledge growth; and accessing valuable knowledge from inside and outside the firm.
Some sources claim that 20 percent of an organization’s knowledgeable personnel can operate 80 percent of the organization’s day-to-day business. Human resources managers can identify the knowledge core of the organization and recommend ways to preserve this critical core. Without such preparation, corporate talent could erode through a brain drain.
Companies should emphasize tapping, sharing, and preserving tacit knowledge and the total knowledge base. A company’s knowledge base includes explicit and tacit knowledge and exists internally as well as within the firm’s external connections. Companies should focus on innovation and processes that convert innovation to new products and services.
Knowledge sharing is unnatural—one person’s knowledge is added value to that person’s career path. Knowledge management solves the problem of un-recycled knowledge. Systems developed to gather, organize, refine, and distribute knowledge should have six attributes: learning capability, improving with use, knowing what you want, two-way communication, recalling past actions to develop a profile, and unique configuration to individual specification in real time.
🔑 Definition — Tacit knowledge: “Know-how” stored in people’s minds, not easy to capture or share; includes intuitions, values, and beliefs stemming from experience
🔑 Definition — Explicit knowledge: Codified and digitized knowledge in the form of records, reports, or documents; reusable for decision making
Key Terms and Classifications
Knowledge classifications:
- Procedural knowledge: Knowledge used over and over again; involves understanding how to do a task (motor in nature)
- Declarative knowledge: Surface information that experts verbalize easily; shallow knowledge
- Semantic knowledge: Highly organized, “chunked” knowledge residing in long-term memory representing concepts, facts, and relationships among facts
- Episodic knowledge: Knowledge based on experiential information chunked as an entity and retrieved from long-term memory on recall
Reasoning types:
- Deductive reasoning: Exact reasoning; takes known principles (exact facts) and applies them to instances to infer an exact conclusion
- Inductive reasoning: Reasoning from a given set of facts or specific examples to general principles or rules
- Case-based reasoning: Reasoning by analogy; human experts reason about a problem by recalling similar cases encountered in the past
🔑 Definition — Chunking: Grouping ideas or details that are stored and recalled together as a unit
🔑 Definition — Compilation: The way a human translates instructions into meaning, language, or response
🔑 Definition — Inferencing: Deriving a conclusion based on statements that only imply that conclusion
🔑 Definition — Premise: Provides evidence from which the conclusion must necessarily follow; evaluates truth or falsehood with some degree of certainty
🔑 Definition — Logic: The scientific study of the process of reasoning and the set of rules and procedures used in the reasoning process
🔑 Definition — Reasoning: The process of applying knowledge to arrive at solutions based on the interactions between rules and data
🔑 Definition — Scenario: The formal description of how a problem situation operates
Summary Points
- Research in artificial intelligence has introduced more structure into human thinking about thinking
- Humans do not receive and process information exactly as machines do
- Human learning: humans learn new facts, integrate them, and organize results to produce solutions, advice, and decisions
- Humans learn through experience, by example, and by discovery
- Knowledge compilation or chunking enables experts to optimize memory capacity and process information quickly
- The more chunking a person does, the more efficient is recall
⭐ Key Takeaways
The three types of human learning—experience, example, and discovery—form the foundation for understanding how expertise develops, with learning by discovery being the least understood. Knowledge is compiled in long-term memory as chunks, which enables experts to process information quickly but can also make it difficult for them to describe their knowledge to others. The distinction between tacit knowledge (in people's minds) and explicit knowledge (codified) is crucial for knowledge management, as is understanding that sharing knowledge is unnatural and must be actively facilitated through culture, not just technology. Organizations must protect their knowledge core (the 20% who operate 80% of business) from brain drain while simultaneously promoting innovation through knowledge sharing. Knowledge classifications (procedural, declarative, semantic, episodic) and reasoning types (deductive, inductive, case-based) provide frameworks for understanding and capturing expert knowledge effectively.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three ways humans learn, and which one is the least understood?
- Distinguish between tacit knowledge and explicit knowledge, and give an example of each.
- What is knowledge chunking, and why does it make it difficult for experts to describe their knowledge?
- Explain the difference between deductive reasoning and inductive reasoning.
- According to the lecture, what percentage of knowledgeable personnel operates what percentage of day-to-day business, and why is this important for knowledge management?
📘 Lecture 13 — Dimensions of Human Knowledge, Tree of Knowledge
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the distinction between core and innovative knowledge, focusing on how Japanese companies achieve continuous innovation through knowledge creation. It delves into the critical difference between tacit and explicit knowledge, introduces the two dimensions of knowledge creation (epistemological and ontological), and presents the foundation for the SECI model of knowledge conversion.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by contrasting the mindset of companies that embrace change versus those that defend existing advantages, then examines how Japanese companies externalize knowledge through continuous innovation. It introduces the concept of tacit knowledge with its technical and cognitive dimensions, contrasts this with explicit knowledge, and discusses the implications for organizational learning. Finally, it presents the epistemological and ontological dimensions of knowledge creation and introduces the SECI model of knowledge conversion as a social process.
📝 Lecture Summary
Core Vs Innovative Knowledge
Japanese companies bring about continuous innovation by looking outside and into the future, anticipating changes in market, technology, competition, or product. They are willing to abandon what has long been successful, treating change as an everyday event and a positive force. In contrast, other companies become preoccupied with defending their advantages and treat change with fear, seeking predictability and stability. During times of uncertainty, Japanese companies accumulate knowledge from external sources—suppliers, customers, distributors, government agencies, and even competitors—and share it widely within the organization, stored as part of the company’s knowledge base. This conversion process from outside to inside and back outside again in the form of new products, services, or systems is the key to understanding Japanese success. Continuous innovation leads to competitive advantage through knowledge creation.
💡 Why this matters: The willingness to abandon successful practices and seek external knowledge is a fundamental driver of long-term innovation.
🔑 Definition — Continuous Innovation: The ongoing process of turning external knowledge into new products and services through internal knowledge creation and sharing.
Tacit Knowledge and Its Two Dimensions
Japanese companies recognize that knowledge expressed in words and numbers represents only the tip of the iceberg. They view knowledge as primarily tacit—something not easily visible and expressible. Tacit knowledge is highly personal and hard to formalize, making it difficult to communicate or share with others. Subjective insights, intuitions, and hunches fall into this category. Tacit knowledge is deeply rooted in an individual’s action and experience, as well as in the ideals, values, or emotions they embrace.
Tacit knowledge has two dimensions:
- The technical dimension: Encompasses informal and hard-to-describe skills or crafts captured in the term "know-how." A master craftsman develops expertise "at his fingertips" after years of experience but often cannot articulate the scientific or technical principles behind what he knows.
- The cognitive dimension: Consists of schemata, mental models, beliefs, and perceptions so ingrained that we take them for granted. This dimension reflects our image of reality (what is) and our vision for the future (what ought to be).
🔑 Definition — Tacit Knowledge: Knowledge that is highly personal, context-specific, and hard to formalize, communicate, or share with others; includes subjective insights, intuitions, hunches, ideals, values, and emotions.
🔑 Definition — Explicit Knowledge: Knowledge that can be expressed in words and numbers, easily processed by a computer, transmitted electronically, or stored in databases.
Implications of Tacit Knowledge
The distinction between explicit knowledge and tacit knowledge is key to understanding differences between Western and Japanese approaches to knowledge. For tacit knowledge to be communicated and shared within the organization, it must be converted into words or numbers that anyone can understand. It is precisely during this conversion—from tacit to explicit, and back again into tacit—that organizational knowledge is created.
First implication: The organization is viewed not as a machine for processing information but as a living organism. Sharing an understanding of what the company stands for, where it is going, and how to make that vision a reality becomes more crucial than processing objective information. Highly subjective insights, intuitions, and hunches are integral parts of knowledge, along with ideals, values, emotions, images, and symbols.
Second implication: Innovation is not just about putting together diverse bits of data and information. It is a highly individual process of personal and organizational self-renewal. The personal commitment of employees and their identity with the company and its mission become indispensable. Creating new knowledge means literally re-creating the company and everyone in it. Knowledge must be built on its own, frequently requiring intensive and laborious interaction among members of the organization—not simply a matter of learning from others.
🔑 Definition — Self-renewal: The ongoing process of recreating the company and everyone in it through personal and organizational knowledge creation.
Two Dimensions of Knowledge Creation
Our basic framework contains two dimensions:
The ontological dimension: In a strict sense, knowledge is created only by individuals. An organization cannot create knowledge without individuals. The organization supports creative individuals or provides contexts for them to create knowledge. Organizational knowledge creation must be understood as a process that "organizationally" amplifies the knowledge created by individuals and crystallizes it as part of the knowledge network of the organization.
The epistemological dimension: Based on Michael Polanyi's (1966) distinction between tacit knowledge and explicit knowledge. Tacit knowledge is personal, context-specific, and hard to formalize and communicate. Explicit or "codified" knowledge refers to knowledge transmittable in formal, systematic language. Polanyi contends that human beings acquire knowledge by actively creating and organizing their own experiences. As Polanyi states, "We can know more than we can tell."
In traditional epistemology, knowledge derives from the separation of the subject and the object of perception. In contrast, Polanyi contends that human beings create knowledge by involving themselves with objects through self-involvement and commitment, or what he called "indwelling." To know something is to create its image or pattern by tacitly integrating particulars. Indwelling breaks the traditional dichotomies between mind and body, reason and emotion, subject and object, and knower and known.
Knowledge of experience tends to be tacit, physical, and subjective. Knowledge of rationality tends to be explicit, metaphysical, and objective. Tacit knowledge is created "here and now" in a specific, practical context and entails an "analog" quality. Explicit knowledge is about past events or objects "there and then" and is created by "digital" activity.
🔑 Definition — Indwelling: The process of knowing something by self-involvement and commitment, breaking dichotomies between mind and body, reason and emotion, and subject and object.
📐 Formula: Polanyi's Principle → "We can know more than we can tell."
Knowledge Conversion/Creation: Interaction Between Tacit and Explicit Knowledge
Westerners tend to emphasize explicit knowledge; the Japanese tend to stress tacit knowledge. However, tacit knowledge and explicit knowledge are not totally separate but mutually complementary entities. They interact with and interchange into each other in the creative activities of human beings. Our dynamic SECI model of knowledge creation is anchored to a critical assumption that human knowledge is created and expanded through social interaction between tacit knowledge and explicit knowledge. We call this interaction "knowledge conversion." This conversion is a social process between individuals and not confined within an individual. Through this social conversion process, tacit and explicit knowledge expand in terms of both quality and quantity.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge Conversion: The social process through which tacit and explicit knowledge interact and interchange, creating and expanding human knowledge; the foundation of the SECI model.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that knowledge has two fundamental dimensions: tacit (personal, context-specific, hard to formalize) and explicit (codified, transmittable in systematic language). Tacit knowledge itself has two dimensions—technical (know-how, crafts, skills) and cognitive (mental models, schemata, beliefs, perceptions)—which shape how individuals perceive reality and envision the future. The key to organizational knowledge creation is the conversion of tacit knowledge into explicit knowledge and back again, a social process that expands knowledge in quality and quantity. Japanese companies achieve continuous innovation by treating the organization as a living organism, emphasizing personal commitment, and recognizing that knowledge creation requires intensive interaction rather than mere learning from others. The ontological dimension reminds us that while only individuals create knowledge, organizations amplify and crystallize it through expanding communities of interaction.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two dimensions of tacit knowledge, and how do they differ from each other?
- According to Polanyi, what does the term "indwelling" mean, and why does it break traditional dichotomies?
- How does Japanese companies' approach to knowledge differ from Western companies' emphasis on explicit knowledge?
- What are the two dimensions of the knowledge creation framework (epistemological and ontological), and why are both necessary?
- What is "knowledge conversion" in the SECI model, and why is it considered a social rather than individual process?