📘 Lecture 7 — Strategic Corporate Assets of a 3rd Millennium Organization, Knowledge Characteristics
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the unique characteristics of knowledge that distinguish it from traditional economic resources, and explores the lifecycle of knowledge within organizations—how it is born, can die, can be owned, exists in both immanent and extant forms, can be stored, and categorized. Understanding these characteristics is crucial for developing effective knowledge management strategies in modern organizations.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the six special characteristics of explicit knowledge according to Harlan Cleveland (expandable, compressible, substitutable, transportable, diffusive, shareable), followed by an exploration of tacit knowledge's unique properties and management challenges. It then examines the philosophical nature of knowledge involving human interaction with reality, belief, judgment, and its social and dynamic nature. The lecture also covers what can happen to knowledge—its birth, death, ownership, immanent vs. extant forms, storage capabilities and challenges, and finally different categories of organizational knowledge including label, process, skill, and people knowledge.
📝 Lecture Summary
Characteristics of Knowledge
Knowledge defies normal economic rules. Harlan Cleveland describes six special characteristics of information or explicit knowledge. It is Expandable—unlike other resources managed because of their scarcity value, the more knowledge is used, the more is generated. It is Compressible—it can be summarized for easier handling and packaged into small physical formats. It is Substitutable—in many situations it can replace physical and other forms of resource, for example telecommunications reduces the need for physical transport. It is Transportable—it can move from place to place, quickly and easily, ready for collecting when the recipient chooses. It is Diffusive—it tends to leak, and as technology improves, it becomes ever more difficult to stop reproduction and transmission. It is Shareable—if it is given to another person, the first person does not lose it.
Tacit knowledge is also expandable, diffusive and shareable, but is not as easily transmitted or diffused. It is intangible and difficult to identify and describe. It is context dependent. These characteristics present interesting management challenges. Making knowledge explicit means that it can be more readily copied, diffused and shared, but this makes it 'leaky' and it could reach undesirable parties. The increasing rate of knowledge generation means much existing knowledge has a short 'half-life' and its value decays quite quickly, needing constant refreshing and revalidating through use.
💡 Why this matters: These characteristics explain why knowledge cannot be managed like physical assets—its expandability and shareability create unique opportunities for value creation, while its diffusiveness creates risks of unwanted dissemination.
Knowledge involves a human interaction with reality (or with information about reality, or information about other knowledge or information), where the human is the subject and acts as the active, creative element, and modifies the latter by way of reconstructing it. Knowledge involves attribution of meaning and significance by the knower as a person. Every reconstruction is a reinterpretation as well.
When I know something, it is relative to me. There can be no knowledge without me. It is always in relation to my existence and my knowing it. With my death dies my world, and with it my knowledge. In knowing something, I individualize, subjectify, and appropriate it and make it my own.
Knowledge is essentially social in nature. We need universal categories for generation, expression, representation, storage, retrieval, and expropriation of knowledge. The categories are universal in the sense that (a) they are capable of holding the same meanings for all humans belonging to the same community and (b) the categories can be socialized in terms of being shared, reconstructed, and applied by other humans belonging to the concerned universe of discourse.
In knowing something, I believe it to be true. Without this belief, it could just be some information, without that stamp of individualized identity marked on it. This belief is a part of a system of beliefs, values, and rationality, and hence constitutes a responsibility and potential commitment.
Knowing takes place in relation to existing knowledge—it is placing things in context, in relation to existing constructions of reality, content, and concepts.
Knowledge involves a judgment, a subsumption of the particular under the universal. It involves a certain amount of synthesis and integration of discreet information under a category, a construction, or an attribution of a causality or justifiability, relative to the knower's frame of reference.
Knowledge has a moment of categorical imperative and can induce a cognitive dissonance between belief and practice, between the past and the present, between the present and the future, between what is and what ought to be, and so on. It can therefore form a springboard for potential action. In other words, knowledge by definition is driven into practice.
Knowledge is always a part of a dynamic system. Knowledge has the tendency to go for more of itself, to bypass itself, and to constantly develop itself. It is only limited by mental and environmental constraints.
Knowledge is gregarious by nature and has a tendency to socialize itself. Socialization is the means by which individual knowledge gets reinforced, challenged, modified, improved, and validated.
Knowledge processes are always a part of an open system. It is like a game where the goalpost keeps shifting itself. The meanings, the dictionaries, and even the rules of the language are always in flux—as volatile as the turns in modern life. Knowledge creation, by definition, is a process of innovation.
What Can Happen To Knowledge
Knowledge Can Be Born
What apparently distinguishes Homo sapiens from the rest of the animal world is our ability to conceive, store, and manipulate ideas linguistically apart from the stimuli that gave rise to them. We can think about and name apples—make recipes for their use, use their visual image for decoration, even name computers after them—without being under the influence of the smell, taste, feel, and appearance of actual apples. We can give birth to ideas as well as manipulate and change them.
Every company desires such intellectual fertility on the part of its employees, particularly its leaders. Questions arise about what circumstances prove most conducive to the birth of new knowledge, which individuals are most fertile in their ability to generate new knowledge, and how these individuals can be discovered and nurtured. These are questions asked by organizations and human enterprises of all kinds. Organizations carve knowledge spanners much as living organisms carve reproductive opportunities and capabilities. In both cases, the motive is the same: survival and maximization of life experience.
Knowledge spanners equip their organizations to confront change successfully. For example, rapidly changing global markets can threaten the viability of even the most established businesses. These companies rely upon new knowledge to maintain and extend their markets. The companies highly value knowledge spanners who come up with the biomedical formula, the algorithm for a faster chip, the alloy for a lighter auto-body, or the economic model for a better deployment of resources that allow their organizations to thrive when others are failing.
Increasingly, the spanning of knowledge involves a partnership between human cognition and machine-based intelligence. When a pharmaceutical company conducts a complex series of drug tests by means of computer analysis, when a physician makes a diagnosis based primarily on output from an expert system, or when an aeronautics corporation designs an aircraft from computer-based flight test data, the question of where requisite knowledge resides is not easily answered. Traditionally based on human inputs, this artificial knowledge is increasingly self-generated by artificial intelligence capabilities. Any plan for knowledge management must make provision for both direct human knowledge and indirect human knowledge, as mediated by machines.
Knowledge Can Die
In terms of sheer quantity, the vast majority of things known by human beings die with them. Few of us record even one-thousandth part of our knowledge accumulated from life experiences. Put in organizational terms, we are individually quite poor at "transition planning." Our stores of knowledge go with us to the grave almost entirely whole, leaving each new generation to reinvent much knowledge that could have been its birthright.
It could be argued that most important knowledge achieved during individual human lives gets preserved in books, journals, patents, documentaries, oral histories, and other means. By this logic, we are the tip of the iceberg and therefore do not mourn the loss of the great unformed and unexamined mass of knowledge beneath the surface. For example, we cling to the works of Mozart and are hardly aware of what it means to lose the capacity (the genius) to produce such works.
The death of knowledge for an organization occurs by means other than the mortality of its members. Firms that downsize without provision to preserve and extend necessary intellectual capital can find themselves brain dead after terminations and layoffs. Knowledge resides primarily within human heads; when "head count" is reduced, inevitably the sum of knowledge within the organization is reduced, sometimes critically so. This happens especially when a firm looks first to its highest paid, longest tenured employees as prime candidates for corporate bloodletting. From a financial management perspective, terminating a few high paid employees may be less traumatic, but from a knowledge management perspective, cutting off the experienced head from the working body may be foolish surgery.
Knowledge can also die due to paradigm shifts. Aspects of knowledge that were important or sacred for one generation may cease to matter for another generation. Interpreting human character and health, for example, was inconceivable for Western medieval men and women apart from the theory of bodily "humors" (behavior-influencing fluids) such as phlegm, choler, and black bile. Their knowledge of these mysterious substances has become obsolete because the paradigms we use to understand mental and physical health have changed.
When paradigm shifts occur, little intellectual effort is spent proving the past wrong. All knowledge resources quickly turn to the larger task of proving the new vision right. When the paradigm shifts, the knowledge of the past is not "killed" or proven wrong. Instead, it is allowed to die from inattention. In this sense, paradigm shifts are largely rhetorical acts arising from the ability of new paradigm thinkers to provide powerful explanations of anomalies in the old paradigm.
Knowledge management takes the death of knowledge seriously and accepts no paradigm shift on blind faith. Knowledge management seeks to understand causes for the failing health or death of knowledge. It memorializes and perpetuates what can and should be salvaged from the demise of a paradigm.
Knowledge Can Be Owned
In spite of high literacy rates in developed countries, most knowledge valuable for increasing wealth is privately held. Knowledge unrelated to or marginally related to wealth is freely available because it serves no one's specific interest in the marketplace. Such free knowledge is the stuff of general education—history, literature, music, art, philosophy, cultural appreciation, languages, and so forth. The works of Shakespeare are available to all of us not because Shakespeare willed it so, but because since Shakespeare's death no one has built an industry based on any kind of special or proprietary knowledge contained within his plays and poetry. The same cannot be said for the knowledge necessary to make paint, preserve food, make or repair computers, or remove air pollution. These functions are based on knowledge that is not made generally available. A company's competitive advantage often lies precisely in its privately held knowledge.
Several implications fan out from the notion of privately owned knowledge. First, the identity of the owner must be clarified. Research and development personnel at computer, drug, cosmetic, and other similar companies routinely sign explicit and binding agreements with their employer that all knowledge accumulated, discovered, or developed during and after their employment remains the sole possession of the employer.
No matter how careful the wording of ownership agreements, truly advantageous knowledge often has a way of "getting out," usually with devastating results in the marketplace. Netscape's "ownership" of Internet browsing technologies, for example, was closely imitated—some have said stolen—by Microsoft, with substantial market losses to Netscape. Knowledge management devises ways to determine what knowledge should be privately held and how it can be protected from competitors and clients.
Modern organizations find unique ways to pierce the shield of privately held knowledge. In many industries, companies acquire proprietary knowledge through friendly or hostile acquisitions, hiring away key employees, and reverse engineering products. Then that knowledge is openly imitated, with the often-cynical strategy that legal challenges will take years in the courts to resolve—years during which the war for market share and profitability will be won and the issue of knowledge ownership will become moot.
By and large, companies have been unsuccessful in attempting to protect knowledge that drives sustained competitive advantage. Even products and processes that are patented or trademarked under the laws of one country are stolen by companies not vulnerable to legal or political sanctions from that country. The blatant theft of U.S. television technology in the 1960s by Asian competitors is a classic example. So devastating was this loss of proprietary knowledge that the U.S. television manufacturing industry ceased to exist by 1980. Similar "borrowing" has occurred more recently in the chip making, disk drives, and telecommunication device industries. U.S. manufacturers have largely given up efforts to stop knowledge piracy through international courts. Instead, they have adopted a "first/best/least" philosophy of hitting the marketplace first and hard with new products, maintaining quality standards, and pricing products at levels that discourage start-up enterprises from copying them.
At best, this appears to be a desperation strategy that conceives and develops new markets only to give them over eventually to the idea pirates. Effective knowledge management assesses what knowledge must be protected for competitive advantage, how that knowledge will be protected, and to what degree legal and political entities can be trusted to enforce laws related to ownership of intellectual properties.
Knowledge is Immanent as Well as Extant
Not all knowledge worth managing in an organization is explicit and visible. Much organizational knowledge is held in creative reserve in the form of human resources and computer expert systems. This immanent and preformed knowledge has the potential for becoming extant and formed at any moment, just as the energy within a battery can be tapped when needed.
A brain surgeon's expertise and capacity for action is an example of immanent knowledge. After years of study and practice, few brain surgeons can list the items within their knowledge bases. Surgeons' core competencies lie in immanent knowledge—deep wells of insight, reflection, memory, and intuition that can be summoned when the need arises. The visible, extant "spark" of correct decisions and actions come to the fore in life-and-death circumstances. Similar knowledge banks are in the minds of virtually all personnel who exercise creative, thinking functions within organizations.
Immanent knowledge remains a challenging but crucially important aspect of knowledge management. Just as brain surgeons must create and maintain their immanent knowledge, organizations may use knowledge management to preserve such vital knowledge. This forces us to confront several key questions: How does one nurture immanent knowledge without force-feeding it in a disruptive way? How does one monitor immanent knowledge to ensure its store of resources is increasingly vital and relevant to the organization's needs? How does an organization prevent unnecessary redundancy in immanent knowledge? A degree of redundancy in immanent knowledge resources probably is desirable if it encourages wholeness of vision and broad perspective in decision making.
Knowledge Can be Stored
It can safely be estimated that more knowledge has been externalized (made observable and preservable) in the last 20 years than in the entire previous history of mankind. On paper, film, tape, and above all by electronic storage means we have "lent our minds out." For example, 12,000 new sites per week continue to appear on the Internet.
But now that we have so energetically externalized knowledge, we face an unexpected and ironic problem: how to internalize knowledge again. Getting knowledge out of our heads and onto disks or paper was a feat of technology; getting facts back into our heads for practical and creative use is a task that involves much more than technology.
The central intellectual work of the 21st century may lie not so much in accumulating externalized banks of knowledge as in developing time-efficient ways to process selected portions of that knowledge through a chip whose essential circuits have not and will not change: the chip between the ears. "Real-time" internalization of knowledge may be the most imposing challenge. A training videotape or movie cannot be internalized by the human mind using a "fast-forward" technique—it must be played in real time for human learning to take place. Traditional lectures and much educational software are similarly bound by real-time constraints. By contrast, still photos and book or magazine pages can be accessed in "mind time," with the roving intellectual eye free to locate and select bits of content without involving the entire surrounding context. CD, videodisk, and "computer search" technologies offer similar accessibility without the necessity to play through a cohesive context.
The most poignant example of this dilemma lies in the efforts of elementary schools to "get wired" to the Internet. When well-intentioned teachers advise students to search for information on topics of interest, both teachers and students quickly confront the chaos of knowledge that currently characterizes the Internet. A second-grader searching for information on "goldfish" using the Info-seek search engine was dumfounded and discouraged to confront more than 100,000 "hits" for his search term—with the option of seeing them 10 at a time. Where does one begin to make sense or use out of a knowledge base that lacks familiar search paths, or heuristics, congenial to human learning and reflection?
Knowledge Can Be Categorized
In addition to the distinctions already suggested between immanent and extant knowledge, the various types of knowledge common within an organization can be enumerated.
Label knowledge is the vast catalog of names that we attach to the flora and fauna that make up the jungle of our particular organization. As a practical organizational necessity, names for things matter for day-to-day operations and efficiency. But label knowledge too often becomes an obsessive-compulsive totem for minds that equate organizational learning with mastery of jargon and labels. In such an environment, newcomers to the organization are pilloried by old-timers until they are able to speak the specialized language of terms, tags, and titles correctly. Entire cultures within branches of the military, academic disciplines, and the professions are built up in large part of such sensitivity to label knowledge. Label knowledge makes up an exclusionary wall by which lawyers separate themselves from the world of common sense.
Process knowledge involves knowing how things work, even if one cannot name all components active within the process (label knowledge). Business environments value process knowledge on the micro-level—engineers who know how a heating system operates—but often fail to recognize the importance of process knowledge at the macro-level. This has occurred in spite of nearly a decade of Business Process Reengineering that explicitly focused management attention on gaining knowledge about processes. Knowledge management should pay attention to both the micro- and macro-levels of process knowledge. If the macro-level process is the building of a pyramid, that knowledge influences the specific work of stonecutters and laborers at the micro-level.
Skill knowledge knows how to do something of value to the organization. This level of knowledge has long been managed by companies through job descriptions, training programs, performance evaluations, and other means. But once skill sets have been determined, companies tend to look upon them as unchanging constellations. These skill sets become the basis of most hiring and define the overall core competencies of the organization. The coming era requires a much more fluid view of skill knowledge. Computer companies have already found that an employee's ability to learn quickly and well is an infinitely more valuable skill in a rapidly changing business environment than a vocationally oriented, specific skill. Knowledge management for the new century requires that skill knowledge be defined and developed so that new patterns can come together quickly to meet emerging market needs.
People knowledge is a diffuse but vitally important category comprising all the insights, intuitions, and relational information we use to work with other people. In the iceberg analogy, this kind of knowledge is truly subsurface within organizations. Usually it is managed ineffectively or not at all precisely because of its lack of visibility. Few companies think about what knowledge their employees should have about one another's motives, communication styles, or professional goals. Interestingly, the same companies expect employees to congeal into efficient, cohesive work teams but devote little thought to the people knowledge that makes such teams possible. Knowledge management brings people knowledge to visibility and to a position of prominence in a framework for understanding and using knowledge within the corporation.
💡 Why this matters: Categorizing knowledge helps organizations identify what types of knowledge they possess and need, enabling more targeted management strategies for each type.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Knowledge has six unique characteristics (expandable, compressible, substitutable, transportable, diffusive, shareable) that defy normal economic rules of scarcity. Knowledge can be born through human creativity and machine-based intelligence, can die through mortality, downsizing, or paradigm shifts, and can be owned as a private asset that provides competitive advantage but is vulnerable to theft and piracy. Knowledge exists in both immanent (latent, unexpressed) and extant (explicit, formed) forms, and while external storage has exploded, the challenge of internalizing knowledge back into human minds remains paramount. Four categories of organizational knowledge—label, process, skill, and people knowledge—each require different management approaches, with people knowledge being the most overlooked yet essential for team effectiveness.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six special characteristics of explicit knowledge according to Harlan Cleveland, and how do they differ from the characteristics of tacit knowledge?
- How can knowledge "die" in an organization, and what are the implications of downsizing from a knowledge management perspective?
- What is the "first/best/least" philosophy adopted by U.S. manufacturers to protect proprietary knowledge, and why is it considered a desperation strategy?
- What is the difference between immanent and extant knowledge, and why is redundancy in immanent knowledge potentially desirable?
- What are the four categories of organizational knowledge, and why is people knowledge considered the most challenging to manage?
📘 Lecture 8 — Perspectives of Knowledge Management and the Forces Driving KM
📖 Overview: This lecture explores why Knowledge Management (KM) has become essential in modern business, examining the forces that drive KM adoption and the benefits it provides. It defines KM, distinguishes it from related concepts, and outlines the key drivers—technological, process, personnel, knowledge-related, and financial—that make KM a critical competitive advantage in today's complex, fast-paced business environment.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining “Why Knowledge Management?” and the rise of the prosumer, then details the benefits and justifications for KM implementation, including Botkin's six attributes of knowledge products. It examines common pitfalls of KM adoption and the four key forces driving KM: increasing domain complexity, accelerating market volatility, intensified speed of responsiveness, and diminishing individual experience. The lecture then analyzes five categories of KM drivers—technology, process, personnel-specific, knowledge-related, and financial—before providing multiple definitions of KM, describing the knowledge organization structure, and clarifying what KM is not (e.g., reengineering, intellectual capital, or data management).
📝 Lecture Summary
Why Knowledge Management?
The lecture introduces the concept of the prosumer—a consumer who is educated, demands more, and provides feedback on product design. This shift has initiated radical changes in business. KM provides benefits by making business processes faster and more effective through knowledge sharing, creating exponential benefits as people learn from shared knowledge. The main constraint in KM is initially capturing tacit knowledge, but successful capture and dispersal allows a company to leverage intellectual assets, respond quickly to customers, create new markets, and dominate emergent technologies.
🔑 Definition — Prosumer: An educated consumer who is no longer passive in the market, demands more from products and services, and provides feedback to manufacturers.
📌 Example: Microsoft's Hotmail advanced the wide use of e-mail, allowing users to exchange information through any Web browser, which became the norm for most Internet service providers.
💡 Why this matters: The shift from passive consumers to active prosumers forces businesses to continuously learn and adapt, making KM essential for survival.
KM Justification
KM justifies itself through several key benefits:
- Creates exponential benefits from shared knowledge
- Has a positive impact on business processes
- Enables quick response to customers, new market creation, and product development
- Builds mutual trust between knowledge workers and management
- Builds sensitivity to brain drain (loss of expertise)
- Ensures successful partnering with suppliers, vendors, and customers
- Shortens the learning curve for new employees
- Enhances employee problem-solving capacity
Botkin (1999) suggests six top attributes of knowledge products and services:
- Learn – The more you use them, the smarter they get
- Improve with use – Enhanced rather than depleted when used
- Anticipate – Knowing what you want, they recommend what you might want next
- Interactive – Two-way communication between you and them
- Remember – Record and recall past actions to develop a profile
- Customize – Offer unique configuration to individual specifications in real time
📌 Example: Andersen Consulting (Accenture) developed ANet, an electronic system connecting employees to share knowledge globally. ANet allows employees to use the total knowledge of the entire organization to solve customer problems through electronic bulletin boards, visual and data contacts, and compiled subject files. However, Accenture found that technological changes alone were insufficient—major organizational changes in incentives and culture were needed for successful adoption.
Pitfalls of KM Implementation
Companies that fail to embed viable KM suffer from several oversights:
- Failing to modify compensation systems to reward teamwork rather than individual information-hoarding
- Building a huge, generalized database that fails to address specialized areas of expertise
- Viewing KM as solely a technology or HR area, leading to poorly coordinated efforts
- Placing too much emphasis on technology, forgetting that technology is only the enabler, not the solution itself
- Introducing KM via a simple, low-risk project instead of starting with a strategy and high-profile champion
- Pursuing KM without organizational readiness—classical management principles require major cultural changes
- Having poor leadership—KM requires determined champions and top management commitment
📌 Example: General Electric (GE) under CEO Jack Welch established a knowledge management university where Welch himself taught classes. GE encourages best-practice sharing at all levels, successfully using employee input and knowledge to produce strategic advantage.
The Forces Driving KM
Four major forces drive the need for KM:
-
Increasing Domain Complexity — The complexity of underlying knowledge domains is increasing due to globalization, requiring organizations to meet diverse customer needs across the globe.
-
Accelerating Market Volatility — The pace of change within market domains has increased rapidly. Example: The September 11, 2001 attacks crippled the travel industry overnight, forcing companies to reduce prices below break-even, leading many to bankruptcy.
-
Intensified Speed of Responsiveness — The time required to take action based on subtle changes is decreasing. Rapid technological advances make it imperative that decisions be made quickly. Example: Three-year-old IT curriculums are considered outdated in "Internet years."
-
Diminishing Individual Experience — High employee turnover rates mean decision-makers have less tenure. The dot-com explosion lured IT professionals away, leaving organizations with talent lacking business experience and understanding of organizational culture.
The Drivers
Technology Drivers — The proliferation of technology, data communications, networking, and wireless transmission has revolutionized knowledge storage and exchange. The World Wide Web changed KM from a fad to e-business reality. Technology acts as a core capability leveler, leaving knowledge as a competitive differentiator. While technology moves information at lightning speed, it is people who turn knowledge into timely and creative decisions.
Process Drivers — These drivers aim to improve work processes by eliminating duplicate mistakes and transferring best experiential knowledge across the organization. “Just in time” approaches minimize inventory investment and meet consumer demands more expeditiously. Responsiveness that exceeds competition requires knowledge of control processes.
Personnel-Specific Drivers — These focus on creating cross-functional teams of knowledge workers to serve anywhere in the organization and minimize personnel turnover as a threat to collective knowledge. Another critical driver is minimizing knowledge walkouts—when highly marketable employees with unique knowledge leave, potentially to competitors, causing a competence drain.
Knowledge-Related Drivers — These include revisiting overlooked employee knowledge, making critical knowledge available when needed, and finding mechanisms to expedite knowledge for immediate use. Companies often know what they know but have difficulty locating it.
📌 Example: A customer wanted to return a product purchased from a chain store in a different city. Only one employee at the local store knew the code to transfer funds between stores—and she was on vacation. The customer service employee spent nearly an hour contacting the other store for instructions while the customer waited.
Financial Drivers — Knowledge follows the law of increasing returns: the more knowledge is used, the more value it provides. Unlike physical assets that diminish with use, knowledge assets increase in value as more people use them. The goal of KM is to produce a positive return on investment (ROI) in people, processes, and technology.
What is Knowledge Management?
Knowledge management (KM) is a newly emerging, interdisciplinary business model focusing on knowledge within the framework of an organization. It is rooted in business, economics, psychology, and information management. KM involves people, technology, and processes in overlapping parts.
Each definition of KM contains several integral parts:
- Using accessible knowledge from outside sources
- Embedding and storing knowledge in business processes, products, and services
- Representing knowledge in databases and documents
- Promoting knowledge growth through culture and incentives
- Transferring and sharing knowledge throughout the organization
- Assessing the value of knowledge assets and impact regularly
KM is the process of capturing and making use of a firm's collective expertise anywhere in the business—on paper, in documents, in databases (explicit knowledge), or in people's heads (tacit knowledge). Up to 95% of information is preserved as tacit knowledge. It is the fuel for innovation—the only sustainable competitive advantage in an unpredictable business environment.
Alternative Definitions of Knowledge Management
The lecture provides multiple definitions from various researchers:
- Hibbard (1997): "Knowledge management is the process of gathering a firm's collective expertise wherever it resides—in databases, on paper, or in people's heads—and distributing it to where it can help produce the biggest payoff."
- Sveiby (2000): "Knowledge management is the art of creating value from an organization's intangible assets."
- Malhotra (2000): "KM is a framework within which the organization views all its processes as knowledge processing, where all business processes involve creation, dissemination, renewal, and application of knowledge toward organizational sustenance and survival."
- O'Dell et al. (2000): "KM is a conscious strategy of getting the right knowledge to the right people at the right time; it is also helping people share and put information into action in ways that strive to improve organizational performance."
The Knowledge Organization
The conceptual structure of the knowledge organization has a middle layer addressing the KM life cycle: knowledge creation, knowledge collection/capture, knowledge organization, knowledge refinement, and knowledge dissemination. The ideal knowledge organization is one where people exchange knowledge across functional areas using technology and established processes, freely producing knowledge assets in an environment that supports exchange.
KM is Not About…
The lecture clarifies what KM is not:
- Not reengineering — Reengineering implies one-shot, radical change; KM implies continuous learning, unlearning, and relearning
- Not a discipline — It is another way of improving quality, profitability, and growth
- Not a philosophic calling — KM goes to the core of an organization's intangible assets
- Not intellectual capital (IC) — IC represents value of trademarks, patents, or brand names; knowledge is the consequence of actions and interactions of people
- Not based on information — Information becomes knowledge after people use it in ways that create value
- Not about data — Data (facts without context) or information (patterns of data) is not knowledge
- Not information value chain — Knowledge value chains view humans as key components assessing information
- Not limited to gathering from experts or retirees and creating databases
- Not digital networks — KM is about improving business processes with people and technology in mind
- Not about "knowledge capture" per se — Knowledge cannot be captured in its entirety
📌 Example: A British supermarket chain used customer data-mining to assess buying behavior and discovered a clear association between diaper and beer purchases by male customers on Friday afternoons. The store began stacking diapers and beer together.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Knowledge Management is an interdisciplinary business model focused on capturing, sharing, and leveraging organizational knowledge—both explicit (documents, databases) and tacit (people's minds)—to create sustainable competitive advantage. The four major forces driving KM are increasing domain complexity, accelerating market volatility, intensified speed of responsiveness, and diminishing individual experience, all of which make traditional decision-making inadequate. Five categories of KM drivers—technology, process, personnel-specific, knowledge-related, and financial—provide compelling justification for KM implementation. Successful KM requires organizational readiness, top management commitment, cultural change, proper incentive systems, and recognition that technology is merely an enabler, not the solution itself. KM is distinguished from related concepts: it is not reengineering, intellectual capital, data management, or simply digital networks—it is a continuous process of learning and adaptation focused on "doing the right thing" rather than "doing things right."
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four forces driving KM, and how does each one create the need for more effective knowledge management?
- Explain the difference between explicit knowledge and tacit knowledge, and state what percentage of organizational information is preserved as tacit knowledge.
- List Botkin's six attributes of knowledge products and services, and explain how each attribute adds value.
- What are the common pitfalls of KM implementation, and how did GE under Jack Welch avoid these pitfalls?
- How does the law of increasing returns apply to knowledge assets, and why is this different from traditional physical assets?
📘 Lecture 9 — Knowledge Hierarchy .... From Data and Information to Knowledge and Wisdom
📖 Overview: This lecture debunks common myths surrounding Knowledge Management and then builds a foundational understanding of the core concept: knowledge. It provides precise definitions for key terms like data, information, knowledge, intelligence, experience, and common sense, clarifying their distinct roles and hierarchical relationships within an organization. The lecture is crucial for understanding what KM truly is and why it is not merely a technology or data management initiative.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture is divided into two main parts. The first part systematically addresses ten common myths about Knowledge Management, clarifying misconceptions about it being a fad, mere technology, or the same as reengineering. The second part delves into the fundamental understanding of knowledge, defining it in relation to intelligence, experience, and common sense, and then clearly distinguishing between data, information, and knowledge. It concludes by exploring different kinds of knowledge, such as deep vs. shallow, procedural vs. declarative, and tacit vs. explicit.
📝 Lecture Summary
KM Myths
This section presents and refutes several common misconceptions about Knowledge Management. It establishes that effective KM is interwoven into all organizational processes and is not limited to technology or data collection. The myths highlight that KM is a people-centric discipline focused on culture, trust, and ongoing learning.
Myth 1: Knowledge management is a fad. Unlike other trends, true KM becomes embedded in the way people work. Knowing what you know cannot be a fad.
Myth 2: Knowledge management and data warehousing are essentially the same. Data warehousing is a repository of data, not knowledge. Knowledge is how you take information and transform it into action. For example, Sears uses a customer data warehouse to help its sales force identify prospects, showing how data mining supports KM by revealing patterns.
Myth 3: Knowledge management is a new concept. KM has been practiced since the early 1980s by firms like Ford and General Motors. Today's version, like customer profiling, uses advanced technology, but the core idea of sharing and using knowledge is not new.
Myth 4: Knowledge management is mere technology. This is a serious misconception. KM is about people, relationships, and a new way of working. Over 80 percent of technology-centered KM efforts fail because of a lack of attention to people.
Myth 5: Technology can store and distribute human intelligence. While data can be stored, technology cannot predict who needs what information. Tacit knowledge exists in a person’s brain and cannot be stored. Knowledge repositories do not allow for the creation of new knowledge.
Myth 6: Knowledge management is another form of reengineering. Reengineering is an efficiency-driven, one-time radical change. KM is an ongoing renewal of processes to learn about future opportunities, focusing on innovation and creativity.
Myth 7: Company employees have difficulty sharing knowledge. This depends on factors like company culture, trust, and attitude. Knowledge sharing requires a "give to get" attitude. Mature people in a stable environment tend to share more.
Myth 8: Knowledge management works only within an organization. Valuable knowledge also comes from outside sources like suppliers and customers, though this presents challenges with technology compatibility and security.
Myth 9: Technology is a better alternative than face-to-face. The best knowledge resides in human minds, making face-to-face interaction a better alternative for knowledge acquisition and sharing.
Myth 10: It is a "no brainer" to share what you know. Traditional cultures often encourage hoarding knowledge for job security. To promote sharing, businesses need special training and trust-building.
Understanding Knowledge
The most critical word in KM is knowledge. It is a myth that knowledge resides only in documents. Knowledge is neither data nor information, though related to both. Essential criteria for knowledge and learning include memory. A knowledge base is different from a database; it is a set of facts and inference rules for creating new knowledge. Knowledge can be classified as explicit or tacit knowledge.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge: "Understanding gained through experience or study." It is "know-how" or an accumulation of facts, procedural rules, or heuristics.
- Fact: A statement of some element of truth. (e.g., milk is white)
- Procedural rule: A rule that describes a sequence of relations. (e.g., check traffic when entering a freeway)
- Heuristic: A rule of thumb based on years of experience. (e.g., driving 5 km above the speed limit is unlikely to get you a ticket)
🔑 Definition — Intelligence: The capacity to acquire and apply knowledge. It includes the ability to understand language and store/retrieve relevant experience. 📌 Example: A thermos bottle keeps hot stuff hot and cold stuff cold. The joke highlights that this is not "intelligence"; a machine lacks the cognitive ability to "know" how it does this.
🔑 Definition — Experience: Relates to what we have done and what has happened. It leads to expertise. An expert knows what they do not know.
🔑 Definition — Common Sense: The unreflective opinions of ordinary humans (e.g., a child knows not to touch a hot stove). Machines lack common sense, making them "brittle."
💡 Why this matters: Understanding these definitions is the foundation for effective KM. You cannot manage what you do not understand.
Cognition and Knowledge Management
Cognitive psychology provides essential background for understanding knowledge and expertise. It helps identify the cognitive structures and processes of skilled performance. Understanding human limitations (e.g., memory capacity) is crucial for knowledge elicitation (capture) . Experts may have difficulty verbalizing their thought processes, especially for procedural knowledge. Knowledge developers need a strong background in cognitive psychology.
Data, Information, and Knowledge
This section defines the three core concepts in the knowledge hierarchy.
🔑 Definition — Data: Unorganized and unprocessed facts. It is static. (e.g., "Ali is 6 feet tall"). It offers no judgment or basis for action. It is a prerequisite to information.
🔑 Definition — Information: An aggregation of data that makes decision making easier. It is "shaped" data with meaning, purpose, and relevance. (e.g., A profit and loss statement). The focus of information is qualitative.
🔑 Definition — Knowledge: A higher level of abstraction that resides in people's minds. It is "human understanding of a specialized field of interest that has been acquired through study and experience." It is broader, richer, and harder to capture than data or information. (e.g., An investor requires knowledge to evaluate two companies' profit and loss statements).
📌 Example: A store records "number of socks sold" (data). Analyzing sales patterns over time reveals "customers who buy socks often buy shoes" (information). A manager's insight from experience that "stocking more socks before winter drives footwear sales" is knowledge.
💡 Why this matters: The key takeaway is the hierarchy: Data -> Information -> Knowledge. Data becomes information when meaning is added; information becomes knowledge when it is understood and applied for decision-making.
Kinds of Knowledge
This section classifies knowledge in several ways.
- Deep Knowledge: Acquired through years of proper experience.
- Shallow Knowledge: Minimal understanding of the problem area.
- Knowledge as Know-How: Accumulated lessons of practical experience.
- Reasoning and Heuristics:
- Reasoning by analogy: Relating one concept to another.
- Formal Reasoning: Using deductive (general to specific) or inductive (specific to general) reasoning.
- Common Sense: Knowledge possessed by almost all humans.
- Classification by type:
- Procedural knowledge: Understanding how to carry out a procedure.
- Declarative knowledge: Routine, conscious, shallow knowledge (e.g., facts readily recalled).
- Semantic knowledge: Highly organized, "chunked" knowledge in long-term memory (e.g., major concepts).
- Episodic knowledge: Knowledge based on personal experiences or episodes.
- Tacit vs. Explicit Knowledge:
- Tacit knowledge: Embedded in the human mind through experience (hard to articulate).
- Explicit knowledge: Codified and digitized in documents, books, reports, spreadsheets, memos, etc.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Knowledge Management is not a fad, a new concept, or mere technology; it is fundamentally about people, relationships, and organizational culture, where trust is critical for knowledge sharing. The lecture establishes a crucial hierarchy: data (unprocessed facts) leads to information (data with meaning), which leads to knowledge (understanding applied for action). Key concepts include the distinction between explicit (codified) and tacit (personal, experience-based) knowledge, and between deep and shallow knowledge. Finally, human intelligence, experience, and common sense are essential attributes that technology cannot replicate, making face-to-face interaction a vital component of KM.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- List three common myths about Knowledge Management and explain why each is incorrect.
- What is the fundamental difference between data, information, and knowledge? Give a real-world example for each.
- Define "tacit knowledge" and "explicit knowledge." Why is it more difficult to manage tacit knowledge in an organization?
- According to the lecture, what is the role of cognitive psychology in Knowledge Management?
- Explain the difference between procedural and declarative knowledge, and give an example of each.