π Lecture 09 β Project Feasibility (Contd.)
π Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive examination of feasibility studies, their purpose, scope, and structure. It explains how feasibility studies serve as decision-making tools for determining project viability, distinguishing them from business plans and other project documents, while outlining the critical elements and assessment components needed for thorough project evaluation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and purpose of feasibility studies, explaining why organizations conduct them before project implementation. It clarifies what a feasibility study is not, distinguishing it from business plans and other documents. The scope of feasibility analysis is examined through seven key elements including need analysis, process work, engineering, cost estimation, financial analysis, project impacts, and conclusions. Finally, the elements of a feasibility assessment are detailed, covering executive summary, need analysis, engineering, advantages/disadvantages, market analysis, financial analysis, risk analysis, comparative analysis, and recommendations.
π Lecture Summary
9.1 What is a Feasibility Study?
A feasibility study is essentially a process for determining the viability of a proposed initiative or service and providing a framework and direction for its development and delivery. It is a process for making sound decisions and setting direction. This process is driven by research and analysis, usually involves some form of consultation with stakeholders, community, and users, focuses on analyzing, clarifying and resolving key issues and areas of concern or uncertainty, and very often involves basic modeling and testing of alternative concepts and approaches.
There is no universal format for a feasibility study, as studies can be adapted and shaped to meet the specific needs of any given situation. A feasibility study is designed to provide an overview of the primary issues related to a business idea, with the purpose being to identify any "make or break" issues that would prevent your business from being successful in the marketplace. In other words, a feasibility study determines whether the business idea makes sense.
A thorough feasibility analysis provides necessary information for the business plan. For example, a good market analysis is necessary to determine the project's feasibility, and this information provides the basis for the market section of the business plan. Because putting together a business plan represents a significant investment of time and money, you want to ensure there are no major roadblocks facing your business idea before making that investment.
A feasibility study looks at three major areas: market issues, organizational/technical issues, and financial issues. This is meant to be a "first cut" look at these issues. For example, a feasibility study should not do in-depth long-term financial projections, but it should do a basic break-even analysis to see how much revenue would be necessary to meet your operating expenses.
π Definition β Feasibility Study: A process for determining the viability of a proposed initiative or service and providing a framework and direction for its development and delivery.
9.2 Why Do Feasibility Studies?
Developing any new business venture is difficult, and taking a project from the initial idea through the operational stage is a complex and time-consuming effort. Most ideas, whether from a cooperative or an investor-owned business, do not develop into business operations. If these ideas make it to the operational stage, most fail within the first 6 months. Before potential members invest in a proposed business project, they must determine if it can be economically viable and then decide if investment advantages outweigh the risks involved.
Many cooperative business projects are quite expensive to conduct and involve operations that differ from those of the members' individual business. These operations involve risks with which the members are unfamiliar. The study allows groups to preview potential project outcomes and to decide if they should continue. Although the costs of conducting a study may seem high, they are relatively minor when compared with the total project cost. The small initial expenditure on a feasibility study can help to protect larger capital investments later.
Feasibility studies are useful and valid for many kinds of projects. Evaluation of new business ventures is the most common usage, but studies can help groups decide to expand existing services, build or remodel facilities, change methods of operation, add new products, or even merge with another business. A feasibility study assists decision makers whenever they need to consider alternative development opportunities.
Feasibility studies permit planners to outline their ideas on paper before implementing them, which can reveal errors in project design before their implementation negatively affects the project. Applying the lessons gained from a feasibility study can significantly lower project costs. The study presents the risks and returns associated with the project so prospective members can evaluate them. There is no "magic number" or correct rate of return a project needs to obtain before a group decides to proceed. The acceptable level of return and appropriate risk rate will vary for individual members depending on their personal situation.
The proposed project usually requires both risk capital from members and debt capital from banks and other financers to become operational. Lenders typically require an objective evaluation of a project prior to investing. A feasibility study conducted by someone without a vested interest in the project outcome can provide this assessment.
π‘ Why this matters: The feasibility study acts as a risk management tool that protects against significant capital losses by identifying potential problems before major investments are made.
9.3 What a Feasibility Study is not:
Feasibility studies are conducted on "real-world" projects and are not academic or research papers. Simulations or projection models, though useful on some projects, do not replace a feasibility study. The study should not be a "cookie cutter" approach to a project and should not merely be a generic source of information. Once completed, a study should permit a group to make better decisions for the strategic issues of their specific project.
A feasibility study is not a business plan. A business plan is elaborated later in the project development process than the feasibility study. The main purpose of a business plan is to function as a blueprint for the group's business operations. The business plan presents the group's intended responses to the critical issues raised in the feasibility study. The feasibility study results form the basis for developing a business plan.
The purpose of a feasibility study is not to identify new ideas or concepts for a project. These ideas should be clearly identified before a study is initiated. The group needs to accomplish a number of steps before a feasibility study is instituted. The closer the assumptions lie to the "real-world", the more value the feasibility study will hold for the group.
A feasibility study should not be conducted as a forum merely to support a desire that the project will be successful. The study should be an objective evaluation of the project's chance for success. Negative results can be just as useful for decision-makers as positive results. Financers may require a feasibility study before providing loans, but this should not be the only purpose of a study. A feasibility study should enhance a banker's ability to evaluate a project, but the primary goal should be to aid a group's decision-making, not to secure financing.
A feasibility study will not determine whether or not a project should be undertaken. The potential members have to decide if the economic returns justify the risks involved in their continuing the project. The results of the feasibility study assist them in this. A feasibility study serves as an analytical tool to present the basic assumptions of a project idea, shows how results vary when these assumptions change, and provides guidance as to critical elements of a project.
9.4 Scope of Feasibility Analysis:
In general terms, the elements of a feasibility analysis for a project should cover the following:
1. Need Analysis: This indicates recognition of a need for the project. The need may affect the organization itself, another organization, the public, or the government. A preliminary study is then conducted to confirm and evaluate the need, followed by a proposal of how the need may be satisfied. Pertinent questions include: Is the need significant enough to justify the proposed project? Will the need still exist by the time the project is completed? What are the alternate means of satisfying the need? What are the economic, social, environmental, and political impacts of the need?
2. Process Work: This is the preliminary analysis done to determine what will be required to satisfy the need. The work may be performed by a consultant who is an expert in the project field. The preliminary study often involves system models or prototypes. For technology-oriented projects, artist's conception and scaled-down models may be used for illustrating the general characteristics of a process. A simulation of the proposed system can be carried out to predict the outcome before the actual project starts.
3. Engineering and Design: This involves a detailed technical study of the proposed project. Written quotations are obtained from suppliers and subcontractors as needed. Technology capabilities are evaluated as needed. Product design, if needed, should be done at this time.
4. Cost Estimate: This involves estimating project cost to an acceptable level of accuracy. Levels of around -5% to +15% are common at this level of a project plan. Both the initial and operating costs are included in the cost estimation. Estimates of capital investment and of recurring and nonrecurring costs should also be contained in the cost estimate document. Sensitivity analysis can be carried out on the estimated cost values to see how sensitive the project plan is to the estimated cost values.
5. Financial Analysis: This involves an analysis of the cash flow profile of the project. The analysis should consider rates of return, inflation, sources of capital, payback periods, breakeven point, residual values, and sensitivity. This is a critical analysis since it determines whether or not and when funds will be available to the project. The project cash flow profile helps to support the economic and financial feasibility of the project.
6. Project Impacts: This portion of the feasibility study provides an assessment of the impact of the proposed project. Environmental, social, cultural, political, and economic impacts may be some of the factors that will determine how a project is perceived by the public. The value added potential of the project should also be assessed. A value added tax may be assessed based on the price of a product and the cost of the raw material used in making the product.
7. Conclusions and Recommendations: The feasibility study should end with the overall outcome of the project analysis. This may indicate an endorsement or disapproval of the project. Recommendations on what should be done should be included in this section of the feasibility report.
π Formula: Cost Estimate Accuracy: -5% to +15% β The acceptable range of accuracy for project cost estimates at the feasibility study level.
9.5 Elements of a Feasibility Assessment:
As a first step, a feasibility assessment should define the business idea, be it a new project, product or service. The project or business idea feasibility can then be determined. The feasibility needs to account for the current circumstances of the proponent. For example, for a business intender it should take into account personal readiness, skills, resources, knowledge and goals. For established businesses, linkages to existing lines of business, customers, suppliers, employees and other stakeholders need to be accounted for.
A feasibility report should have the following structure:
1. Executive Summary: Provides a quick overview of the main points of the assessment, helping to form a picture of the proposal along with the recommendations. It should be concise and include the major findings covered in the main body of the report.
2. Need Analysis: Provides context to the business proposition. It analyzes the justification of the idea, with a study of possible alternatives. It links the business idea to the current circumstances and helps to inform evaluation of the business idea.
3. Engineering: Description of the technical aspects of the business idea, including any changes needed to be made to existing processes or the need to add items to existing range of products and services.
4. Advantages and Disadvantages: Advantages and disadvantages of the business idea compared to alternatives, such as competing products; or for a new concept, its relevance to current practices, and to unmet or potential demand.
5. Market for the Product Offerings: States the number of customers, expected frequency and size of average purchase, and any reduction in costs across the business arising from the new product or service. Any assumptions about customer purchase behavior should be identified. Research should focus on customers, products and services, competition, mapping, costing, suppliers, location, resources, and staff.
- Customers: You need to be clear about the type of customer you will target and why they will respond to your offering. Identify target market segments or groups.
- Products and Services: Create a list showing the products/services you will be offering to each segment and how much customers will pay.
- Competition: List competitors, note their perceived strengths and weaknesses, and understand why they are competition. Price should not be the only answer; whole of life value, product features, distribution, promotion strategies, and after sales options may all be part of the purchase decision.
- Map: Obtain a map and define market boundaries, your location, access routes, competitors, suppliers, and demographic information.
- Costing: Assess how long it will take to produce or obtain products/services, work out the cost of that time, and determine costs for buying, assembling, or producing them. This approach should account for all costs over and above existing activity.
- Suppliers: Identify preferred and alternative suppliers; collect catalogues and price lists.
- Location: Identify site, whether rented, owned or at home, and consider advantages and disadvantages.
- Resources: Assess assets and equipment required, cost of acquiring them, and alternative methods of acquisition such as outright purchase versus hire purchase or leasing.
- Staff: Determine what staff you need, what skills they require, and what you need to pay them.
6. Financial analysis: Work out the profits from a given level of operations, the capital required, and how the capital will be found to commence operating.
7. Risk analysis of the Preferred Solution: Risk analysis may take the form of basic break-even analysis, i.e., the level of business operation that will ensure that the business does not incur a loss. Sophisticated analysis may consider various business scenarios based on assumptions made in costing and market analyses.
8. Comparative Analysis: Comparative analysis of alternatives should reflect the objectives of the project. Decision making may be based on maximizing profit or minimizing loss for various business scenarios. Some alternatives may be riskier with higher financial payoffs under certain scenarios and potential losses under other scenarios, while some may be less risky with low financial profits or losses under a wide variety of circumstances.
9. Recommendations: Recommendations of the preferred alternative with an associated plan of action; or a decision not to proceed. Possible plans of action include going back to the drawing board, developing more promising alternatives, further research to minimize possibility of failure, or moving forward to develop a detailed business plan.
β Key Takeaways
A feasibility study is fundamentally a decision-making tool that determines project viability by analyzing market, organizational/technical, and financial issues, serving as a crucial risk management step before committing significant resources. The study must be distinguished from a business plan β the feasibility study comes first and provides the foundation for developing the business plan, which is created later as a blueprint for operations. The scope of feasibility analysis encompasses seven critical elements: need analysis, process work, engineering and design, cost estimation (typically with -5% to +15% accuracy), financial analysis, project impacts assessment, and conclusions with recommendations. A comprehensive feasibility report must include nine components: executive summary, need analysis, engineering, advantages/disadvantages, market analysis (covering customers, products, competition, mapping, costing, suppliers, location, resources, and staff), financial analysis, risk analysis (including break-even analysis), comparative analysis of alternatives, and final recommendations. The feasibility study should be an objective evaluation conducted by someone without vested interest, and negative results are equally valuable to decision-makers as positive outcomes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three major areas that a feasibility study examines, and why is this considered a "first cut" analysis?
- What is the key difference between a feasibility study and a business plan in terms of timing and purpose?
- What is the acceptable level of accuracy for cost estimates in a feasibility study, and what is sensitivity analysis used for?
- List the nine structural elements required in a comprehensive feasibility assessment report.
- Why should a feasibility study not be conducted merely to secure financing or to support a predetermined desire for project success?
π Lecture 10 β Project Feasibility (Contd.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of project feasibility, focusing on the characteristics of a feasibility study, what bankers look for in such studies, and a detailed value-chain-based feasibility assessment process. It provides a practical framework for evaluating technical, operational, and economic viability before committing major resources to a project.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the key characteristics and objectives of a feasibility study, including the critical role of user involvement and the typical checklist items. It then examines the feasibility study from a banker's perspective, detailing what lenders need to see, such as an executive summary and financial package blueprint. The core of the lecture is the Feasibility Assessment Process, which uses a value chain approach to evaluate technical and economic feasibility across all stages: from input sourcing and procurement, through operations and production, warehousing and delivery, to sales and marketing, non-market factors, data collection, customer service, and finally the decision recommendation with cost/revenue projections and sensitivity analysis.
π Lecture Summary
10.1 Characteristics of a Feasibility Study:
The feasibility study phase provides a firmer basis for deciding whether to undertake a project by considering the technical aspects of conceptual alternatives. Its purpose is to plan project development activities, estimate time, staffing, and equipment needs, and identify probable costs and consequences. The objective is to provide management with predictable results of implementing a specific project in the form of a feasibility study report, which is used to decide whether to proceed with the costly development and implementation phases.
User involvement during the feasibility study is critical. The user must supply effort and information and judge the impact of alternative approaches. The primary user must be highly qualified and intimately familiar with the organization's workings. Improper technical or operating decisions made during this step may go undetected and could result in the termination of a valid project or the continuation of an infeasible one.
A typical feasibility study checklist includes summary-level items (evaluate alternatives, market potential, cost effectiveness, producibility, technical base) and detail-level items (specific problem determination, analysis of state-of-the-art technology, assessment of in-house capabilities, test validity of alternatives, quantify unknowns, conduct trade-off analysis, prepare initial goals and preliminary cost estimates).
The end result of the feasibility study is a management decision to terminate the project or approve its next phase. This decision is especially critical because later phases require a major commitment of resources. Once a project is deemed feasible and approved, it must be prioritized with other approved projects given limited resources.
10.2 The Feasibility Study - What Bankers Like to See in Them:
A cardinal rule in banking is to borrow from a lender who understands your business. A feasibility study is often done with an eye towards explaining the project to potential financiers. Bankers can have different requirements than group members. The feasibility study should contain the following information:
π Definition β Executive Summary: Short, complete, and to the point. It must allow the banker to understand the project basics. It should contain: project purpose, repayment possibility, projected financial returns (revenues, costs, net income), and economic benefits (ROI and IRR).
π Definition β Financial Package Blueprint: Clearly shows what resources the group wants from the bank and allows calculation of potential project risk. It should contain: characteristics of assets to be financed, expected rate of conversion to cash-liquidity, risk evaluation data (internal and external risks), evaluation of economic consequences (net reserves covering capital cost), financial forecast (three years of projected cash flows, operating statements, balance sheets), and documentation supporting assumptions.
10.3 The Feasibility Assessment Process:
Feasibility studies should encompass at least two assessments: technical feasibility (physical, technical, technological dimensions) and economic feasibility (economic viability within its defined domain). The value chain approach allows these two assessments to be embedded into a single initiative, facilitating understanding of the domain's effects on different stages from input sourcing to customer support. It also facilitates appreciation of resources, technology, customer expectations, and infrastructure required for success.
π‘ Why this matters: The value chain approach provides a systematic way to identify bottlenecks and ensure all critical aspects of a project are evaluated before committing resources.
10.3.1 Input Sourcing and Procurement:
The feasibility assessment begins at the input sourcing and procurement stage. The technical dimension encompasses the availability of required inputs in appropriate levels of quality and quantity, including evaluation of cycles and trends, physical movement of inputs from origination to processing facilities, and assessment of different supply sources. If specific human resources and technologies are required, their availability is assessed.
The economics of input sourcing emanates from the technical assessment. The objective is to determine the range of prices typical in the domain over a reasonable period, not just a single price. Price trends and cycles can be matched against quantity and quality trends to provide insights into potential bottlenecks in the input sourcing and procurement function.
10.3.2 Operations and Production:
This stage transforms inputs into outputs and generally absorbs the largest share of investment capital. The objective of technical feasibility assessment is to determine if the envisaged technology is suitable for the desired quantity and quality of product. It also seeks to determine if equipment and associated technologies are at the appropriate operational scale.
Because of the specialized knowledge required, professionals with required experience must be recruited. You must encourage them to provide the full range of knowledge about available technologies and equipment. You need to assess the physical layout of equipment and its impact on operational efficiency. Professionals should also provide insights into how different technologies compare regarding people requirements, skill levels, and operational inputs (electricity, gas, maintenance protocols, etc.).
The best sources of economic data are equipment suppliers. Primary data can be collected by providing a detailed product description to potential suppliers in a Request for Quote (RFQ) offer. The principal advantage of using an RFQ is to improve knowledge of alternative solutions. Given the rate of technical obsolescence, capital investments should maximize longevity given technical and economic efficiency considerations. You should also consider strategic alliances with companies having existing processing capacity.
Unbiased, knowledgeable people should be hired to review RFQ responses. Arrange for suppliers to make presentations so you can ask necessary questions.
10.3.3 Warehousing, Storage and Delivery:
The feasibility analysis should assess the implications of warehousing, storage, and delivery systems. It should assess alternative sources of warehousing and storage (owning, renting, strategic alliance). The assessment should focus not only on physical facilities but also on management technologies of warehouse and storage facilities management. Product tracking systems that maximize space utilization and turnover are critical. Available infrastructure to support physical movement of products to warehouses and customers must also be assessed.
The economics of physical buildings, location, infrastructure, and technologies are brought to bear on technical options. The best sources of technical and economic information are suppliers of warehousing and storage services. The accuracy of data supplied depends on the clarity and precision of input information.
10.3.4 Sales and Marketing:
Marketing and sales provide direct insight into the project's potential market and the Structure, Conduct and Performance (SCP) characteristics of industry players. This assessment bridges intra-firm feasibility dimensions with extra-firm feasibility dimensions.
The conceptual backbone for SCP is the assessment of demand and supply conditions and behavior of other firms in the industry. Supply and demand conditions should cover size and scope economies, seasonality and trends, availability of substitutes, industry growth rates, and demand elasticities.
Industry structure refers to the number and size of firms in the industry. Industry conduct describes pricing behavior, price discovery mechanisms, product distribution, promotional initiatives, research and development intensity, and legal tactics. Industry performance assesses profitability of firms in the industry, requiring information on prices, product quality, technical progress, and capacity utilization.
10.3.5 Non-Market Factors:
A technically and economically feasible project can fail when confronted with government policies and/or regulations. Feasibility studies should assess existing and/or planned regulatory initiatives that impinge on the project. Environmental regulations and their technical and economic compliance effects must be analyzed. Similarly, policies targeted to the industry of interest and changes in these policies need assessment. The results form the backdrop for assessing feasibility and help position the product within the context of existing market conditions.
10.3.6 Data Collection:
Information on industry structure and performance may be obtained from government statistics (number of firms, employees, wages, value of shipments, gross margins). Specific industries collect their own statistics and commission reports. Interviews with industry experts can be a major information source. Significant information may be obtained from industry news and industry-specific publications. Academic publications and government documents also provide important insights on SCP situations.
For agricultural value-added initiatives, secondary data can suffice for input sourcing and procurement. In special cases, primary data collection may be necessary through formal surveys or interviews. Effective collection of primary data can be expensive and time consuming. An alternative when secondary data is not neatly available is to pull them together from different sources, ensuring measurements and definitions are similar.
10.3.7 Customer Service and Support:
The final step in the value chain framework is finding out what customer needs are not being satisfied. The purpose is to determine if the proposed project's offering can make a difference. Results provide input into the project's product differentiation index and allow identification of appropriate placement and promotional options. Customer service research allows the project to develop market segments and refocus other components.
Information can be obtained from reviewing consumer and industry publications. Direct information may be obtained through focus group interviews, surveys, and/or interviews. While these can be expensive, they are worthwhile if technical and economic assessments are supportive. The process is iterative, using information from one stage to dig deeper into earlier stages.
10.3.8 The Decision Recommendation:
The purpose of a feasibility study is to make a decision about whether to proceed with a business opportunity. The emphasis on recommendations is economic or financial. The easiest approach is to gather all information, identify items requiring capital expenditure, estimate those expenditures, identify types of people and skills required, determine wages and benefits, and identify other project-related costs. Then, using production capacity, projected market share growth rates, and estimated market size with price information, develop a projected revenue or sales statement. All assumptions driving projections must be specifically defined.
10.3.9 Cost and Revenue Projections:
Cost and revenue projections allow development of the net cash flow emanating from the business over the projected time frame. This statement can be subjected to capital investment analysis by selecting a reasonable discount rate and estimating Net Present Value (NPV) and/or Internal Rate of Return (IRR).
π Definition β Net Present Value (NPV): The difference between the present value of cash inflows and the present value of cash outflows over a period of time. π Formula: NPV = Ξ£(Cash Flow / (1 + r)^t) - Initial Investment β A positive NPV implies an economically feasible project.
π Definition β Internal Rate of Return (IRR): The discount rate that makes the NPV of all cash flows equal to zero. π Formula: 0 = Ξ£(Cash Flow / (1 + IRR)^t) - Initial Investment β If IRR exceeds the required rate of return, the project is economically feasible.
10.3.10 Sensitivity Analysis:
The project cash flow should be subjected to the full range of sensitivity analysis under a range of prices. This provides the full range of conditions supporting feasibility. The wider the band of feasible outcomes from varying critical assumptions, the more confident you can be about viability. If the band of feasibility is narrow, the project's viability is more susceptible to uncertain shifts.
These possibilities may be divided into three blocks: worst case, normal case, and best case scenarios. Sensitivity analysis must be conducted for different scenarios (e.g., best price with worst demand conditions) to provide insights into critical bottlenecks.
10.4 Conclusion:
The purpose of a feasibility study is to assess the viability of a business proposition technically, operationally, and economically. The value chain framework has the unique advantage of laying out the project in its logical configuration from input procurement to customer service. The advantage is revealed in exposing bottlenecks along the value chain. The iterative nature allows the analyst to revisit previous steps when new information suggests the need.
The report should cover input sourcing, operations, warehousing, storage and delivery (logistics aspects), and marketing, sales and customer service (external domain). Pulling all information together into financial units, the analyst can build projections and estimate NPV and/or IRR. A project returning a positive NPV is deemed feasible. If the required rate of return is lower than the estimated IRR, the project is feasible.
β Key Takeaways
The feasibility study is a critical decision-making tool that evaluates technical, operational, and economic viability before major resources are committed. The value chain approach provides a comprehensive framework that systematically assesses each stage from input sourcing to customer service, uncovering potential bottlenecks and ensuring all critical factors are considered. Bankers and financiers have specific requirements for feasibility studies, including a clear executive summary and financial package blueprint that demonstrate repayment ability and risk assessment. The ultimate decision hinges on financial metrics: a positive Net Present Value (NPV) or an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) exceeding the required rate of return indicates economic feasibility. Sensitivity analysis over worst, normal, and best-case scenarios is essential to understand how robust the project's viability is to changes in critical assumptions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main types of feasibility that should be assessed in a feasibility study?
- What are the key elements a banker wants to see in the executive summary of a feasibility study?
- How does the value chain approach help in assessing project feasibility?
- What is the primary advantage of using a Request for Quote (RFQ) for operations and production assessment?
- What does a positive Net Present Value (NPV) indicate about a project's feasibility?