๐ Lecture 11 โ Project Selection
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the critical process of project selection, where organizations choose which projects to implement given limited resources. It covers the criteria for choosing project selection models, the nature of numeric and non-numeric models, and the fundamental decision-making framework that separates successful organizations from failing ones. Understanding these concepts is essential because poor project selection can mean the difference between organizational survival and failure.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with an introduction to project selection as the process of choosing projects to implement, explaining why it is vital for organizational success. It then covers project decisions, the nature of risk and uncertainty in these decisions, and the use of decision-aiding models. The lecture presents criteria for choosing project selection models including realism, capability, flexibility, ease of use, cost, and easy computerization. It examines the nature of project selection models, distinguishing between numeric and non-numeric types, and concludes with detailed explanations of five non-numeric models: Sacred Cow, Operating Necessity, Competitive Necessity, Product Line Extension, and Comparative Benefit Model.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction
Project selection is the process of choosing a project or set of projects to be implemented by the organization. Since projects require substantial investment in money and resources, both of which are limited, it is vital that selected projects provide good returns on resources and capital invested. This requirement must be balanced with the need for an organization to move forward and develop. The high level of uncertainty in the modern business environment has made this area of project management crucial to continued success, with the difference between choosing good projects and poor projects literally representing the difference between operational life and death.
Because a successful model must capture every critical aspect of the decision, more complex decisions typically require more sophisticated models. "There is a simple solution to every complex problem; unfortunately, it is wrong." This creates a major challenge for tool designers. Project decisions are often high-stakes, dynamic decisions with complex technical issuesโprecisely the kinds of decisions that are most difficult to model:
- Project selection decisions are high-stakes because of their strategic implications. The projects a company chooses can define the products it supplies, the work it does, and the direction it takes in the marketplace. Project decisions can impact every business stakeholder including customers, employees, partners, regulators, and shareholders. A sophisticated model may be needed to capture strategic implications.
- Project decisions are dynamic because a project may be conducted over several budgeting cycles, with repeated opportunities to slow, accelerate, re-scale, or terminate the project. Also, a successful project may produce new assets or products that create time-varying financial returns and other impacts over many years.
- Project decisions produce many different types of impacts on the organization. For example, a project might increase revenue or reduce future costs. It might impact how customers or investors perceive the organization. It might provide new capability or learning important to future success. Making good choices requires understanding all of the ways that projects add value.
๐ก Why this matters: The high-stakes, dynamic, and multi-impact nature of project decisions means that simple models will fail to capture critical elements, potentially leading to disastrous choices.
Project Decisions
Project decisions often entail risk and uncertainty. The significance of a project risk depends on the nature of that risk and on the other risks the organization is taking. A more sophisticated model is needed to correctly deal with risk and uncertainty.
Project selection is the process of evaluating individual projects or groups of projects, and then choosing to implement some set of them so that the objectives of the parent organization will be achieved. This same systematic process can be applied to any area of the organization's business in which choices must be made between competing alternatives. Examples include:
- A manufacturing firm choosing which machine to adopt in a part-fabrication process
- A television station selecting which syndicated comedy show to rerun
- A construction firm selecting the best subset of potential projects on which to bid
- A hospital finding the best mix of beds for a new wing
Each project will have different costs, benefits, and risks. Rarely are these known with certainty. Choosing a number of different projects, a portfolio, is even more complex than selecting a single project.
To deal with these problems, we use decision aiding models. We need such models because they abstract the relevant issues about a problem from the plethora of detail in which the problem is embedded. This process of carving away the unwanted reality from the bones of a problem is called modeling the problem. The idealized version of the problem that results is called a model.
The model represents the problem's structure, its form. Models may be quite simple to understand, or they may be extremely complex. Introducing more reality into a model tends to make the model more difficult to manipulate. If input data are not known precisely, we often use probabilistic information; that is, the model is said to be stochastic rather than deterministic.
๐ Definition โ Model: An explicit statement of our image of reality. It is a representation of the relevant aspects of the decision with which we are concerned. It represents the decision area by structuring and formalizing the information we possess about the decision and, in doing so, presents reality in a simplified organized form. A model provides us with an abstraction of a more complex reality. (Cooke and Slack, 1991)
When project selection models are seen from this perspective, the need for them arises from the fact that it is impossible to consider the environment within which a project will be implemented in its entirety. The challenge for a good project selection model is to balance the need to keep enough information from the real world to make a good choice with the need to simplify the situation sufficiently to make it possible to come to a conclusion in a reasonable length of time.
Criteria for Choosing Project Model
When a firm chooses a project selection model, the following criteria based on Souder (1973) are most important:
-
Realism: The model should reflect the reality of the manager's decision situation, including the multiple objectives of both the firm and its managers. Without a common measurement system, direct comparison of different projects is impossible. The model should take into account the realities of the firm's limitations on facilities, capital, personnel, and so forth. The model should also include factors that reflect project risks, including technical risks of performance, cost, and time as well as market risks of customer rejection and other implementation risks.
-
Capability: The model should be sophisticated enough to deal with multiple time periods, simulate various situations both internal and external to the project (for example, strikes, interest rate changes), and optimize the decision. An optimizing model will make the comparisons that management deems important, consider major risks and constraints on the projects, and then select the best overall project or set of projects.
-
Flexibility: The model should give valid results within the range of conditions that the firm might experience. It should have the ability to be easily modified, or to be self-adjusting in response to changes in the firm's environment; for example, tax laws change, new technological advancements alter risk levels, and the organization's goals change.
-
Ease of Use: The model should be reasonably convenient, not take a long time to execute, and be easy to use and understand. It should not require special interpretation, data that are difficult to acquire, excessive personnel, or unavailable equipment. The model's variables should relate one-to-one with those real-world parameters the managers believe significant to the project. Finally, it should be easy to simulate the expected outcomes associated with investments in different project portfolios.
-
Cost: Data gathering and modeling costs should be low relative to the cost of the project and must surely be less than the potential benefits of the project. All costs should be considered, including the costs of data management and of running the model.
-
Easy Computerization: It should be easy and convenient to gather and store the information in a computer database, and to manipulate data in the model through use of a widely available, standard computer package such as Excel, Lotus 1-2-3, Quattro Pro, and like programs. The same ease and convenience should apply to transferring the information to any standard decision support system.
๐ก Why this matters: These six criteria form the checklist against which any project selection model should be evaluated before adoption. A model that fails on any criterion may lead to poor decisions.
The Nature of Project Selection Models
There are two basic types of project selection models: numeric and nonnumeric. Both are widely used. Many organizations use both at the same time, or they use models that are combinations of the two. Nonnumeric models do not use numbers as inputs. Numeric models do, but the criteria being measured may be either objective or subjective. The qualities of a project may be represented by numbers, and subjective measures are not necessarily less useful or reliable than objective measures.
Two critically important facts must never be forgotten:
- Models do not make decisionsโpeople do. The manager, not the model, bears responsibility for the decision. The manager may "delegate" the task of making the decision to a model, but the responsibility cannot be abdicated.
- All models, however sophisticated, are only partial representations of the reality they are meant to reflect. Reality is far too complex for us to capture more than a small fraction of it in any model. Therefore, no model can yield an optimal decision except within its own, possibly inadequate, framework.
A model should evaluate potential projects by the degree to which they will meet the firm's objectives. To construct a selection/evaluation model, it is necessary to develop a list of the firm's objectives, which should be generated by the organization's top management. The list should go beyond typical clichรฉs about "survival" and "maximizing profits." Other objectives might include maintenance of share of specific markets, development of an improved image, expansion into a new line of business, decrease in sensitivity to business cycles, maintenance of employment for specific categories of workers, and maintenance of system loading at or above some percent of capacity.
When the list of objectives has been developed, each item should be weighted to reflect different degrees of contribution each element makes in accomplishing a set of goals. The probable contribution of each project to each of the goals should then be estimated. If the estimated level of goal achievement is sufficiently large, the project is selected; if not, it is rejected.
A major consulting firm (Booz, Allen, and Hamilton, 1966) argued that the primary cause for the failure of Research and Development (R and D) projects is insufficient care in evaluating the proposal before the expenditure of funds. Careful analysis of a potential project is a sine qua non (essential condition) for profitability.
Types of Project Selection Models
Of the two basic types of selection models (numeric and nonnumeric), nonnumeric models are older and simpler and have only a few subtypes:
Non-Numeric Models:
-
The Sacred Cow: In this case, the project is suggested by a senior and powerful official in the organization. Often the project is initiated with a simple comment such as, "If you have a chance, why don't you look into..." followed by an undeveloped idea. The immediate result is the creation of a "project" to investigate whatever the boss has suggested. The project is "sacred" in the sense that it will be maintained until successfully concluded, or until the boss personally recognizes the idea as a failure and terminates it.
-
The Operating Necessity: If a flood is threatening the plant, a project to build a protective dike does not require much formal evaluation. If the project is required to keep the system operating, the primary question becomes: Is the system worth saving at the estimated cost of the project? If the answer is yes, project costs will be examined to make sure they are kept as low as is consistent with project success, but the project will be funded.
-
The Competitive Necessity: Using this criterion, a firm undertakes a project because it is needed to maintain the company's competitive position in the market. For example, many business schools restructure their undergraduate and MBA programs to stay competitive with more forward-looking schools. Investment in an operating necessity project takes precedence over a competitive necessity project, but both types may bypass more careful numeric analysis used for less urgent projects.
-
The Product Line Extension: In this case, a project to develop and distribute new products is judged on the degree to which it fits the firm's existing product line, fills a gap, strengthens a weak link, or extends the line in a new, desirable direction. Sometimes careful calculations of profitability are not required. Decision makers can act on their beliefs about what will be the likely impact on total system performance.
-
Comparative Benefit Model: For this situation, assume an organization has many projects to consider but they are not easily comparable (e.g., potential new products, changes in production methods, computerization of records, creating a daycare center). The organization has no formal method of selecting projects, but members of the selection committee think some projects will benefit the firm more than others. The concept of comparative benefits is widely adopted for selection decisions on all sorts of projects. Most United Way organizations use this concept to make decisions about which social programs to fund. Senior management examines all projects with positive recommendations and attempts to construct a portfolio that best fits the organization's aims and its budget.
โญ Key Takeaways
Project selection is a high-stakes, dynamic process that requires models to abstract reality while balancing simplification with sufficient complexity for good decision-making. The six critical criteria for choosing a project selection model are realism, capability, flexibility, ease of use, cost, and easy computerization. Models do not make decisionsโpeople do, and all models are only partial representations of reality. There are two fundamental types of project selection models: numeric (using numbers as inputs) and nonnumeric (not using numbers as inputs). The five non-numeric models are Sacred Cow, Operating Necessity, Competitive Necessity, Product Line Extension, and Comparative Benefit Modelโeach with specific applications and levels of urgency. The primary cause for project failure is often insufficient care in evaluating the proposal before expenditure of funds.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six criteria for choosing a project selection model according to Souder (1973)?
- What is the fundamental difference between numeric and nonnumeric project selection models?
- In the Sacred Cow model, what determines when a project is terminated?
- How does an Operating Necessity project differ from a Competitive Necessity project in terms of priority?
- Why is it critically important to remember that "models do not make decisionsโpeople do"?
๐ Lecture 12 โ Project Selection (Contd.)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of project selection models, focusing on both non-numeric and numeric approaches. It covers the Q-Sort model for ordering projects, various profitability-based numeric models including payback period, average rate of return, discounted cash flow (NPV), and internal rate of return (IRR). The lecture also introduces the concept of project proposals, their types, and related procurement documents like RFPs, RFQs, and RFIs, which are essential for initiating and evaluating projects in organizational contexts.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Q-Sort model as a non-numeric project selection technique, followed by detailed explanations of numeric profitability models: payback period, average rate of return, discounted cash flow (NPV), internal rate of return (IRR), and profitability index. It also discusses advantages and disadvantages of profit-profitability models, introduces the real options approach, and provides a comprehensive overview of project proposals including types (internal, external, solicited, unsolicited), the Request for Proposal (RFP) process, and variations like RFQ and RFI.
๐ Lecture Summary
12.1 Types of Project Selection Models (Continued):
Non-Numeric Models: Q-Sort Model
The Q-Sort model is a straightforward technique for ordering projects. First, projects are divided into three groupsโgood, fair, and poorโaccording to their relative merits. If any group has more than eight members, it is subdivided into two categories (e.g., fair-plus and fair-minus). When all categories have eight or fewer members, the projects within each category are ordered from best to worst based on relative merit.
The rater may use specific criteria or general overall judgment to rank each project. This process can be carried out by one person or by a committee. If a committee handles the task, individual rankings can be developed anonymously, and the set of anonymous rankings can be examined by the committee for consensus. Rankings rarely vary strikingly because committee members rarely differ widely on what is appropriate for the parent organization.
Projects can be selected in order of preference, though they are usually evaluated financially before final selection. While it is easy to dismiss nonnumeric models as unscientific, they should not be discounted casually as they are clearly goal-oriented and directly reflect the primary concerns of the organization. The sacred cow model has an added featureโsacred cow projects are visibly supported by top management, and full support by top management is an important contributor to project success.
Numeric Models: Profit/Profitability
A large majority of firms using project evaluation and selection models use profitability as the sole measure of acceptability.
1. Payback Period: The payback period for a project is the initial fixed investment in the project divided by the estimated annual net cash inflows from the project. The ratio gives the number of years required for the project to repay its initial fixed investment.
๐ Formula: Payback Period = Initial Fixed Investment / Annual Net Cash Inflows
๐ Example: Assume a project costs $100,000 to implement and has annual net cash inflows of $25,000. Then: Payback Period = $100,000 / $25,000 = 4 years.
This method assumes that cash inflows will persist at least long enough to pay back the investment, and it ignores any cash inflows beyond the payback period. The method also serves as an inadequate proxy for riskโthe faster the investment is recovered, the less the risk to which the firm is exposed.
2. Average Rate of Return: The average rate of return is the ratio of the average annual profit (either before or after taxes) to the initial or average investment in the project. Because average annual profits are usually not equivalent to net cash inflows, the average rate of return does not usually equal the reciprocal of the payback period.
๐ Formula: Average Rate of Return = Average Annual Profit / Initial or Average Investment
๐ Example: Using the same $100,000 project, assume average annual profits are $15,000. Then: Average Rate of Return = $15,000 / $100,000 = 15%.
Neither payback period nor average rate of return is recommended for project selection. The major advantage of these models is their simplicity, but neither takes into account the time-value of money. Unless interest rates are extremely low and the rate of inflation is nil, failure to reduce future cash flows or profits to their present value will result in serious evaluation errors.
3. Discounted Cash Flow (Net Present Value - NPV): Also referred to as the Net Present Value (NPV) method, the discounted cash flow method determines the net present value of all cash flows by discounting them by the required rate of return (also known as the hurdle rate, cutoff rate, etc.).
๐ Formula: NPV = ฮฃ [Rt / (1 + k + pt)^t] - A0, where: Rt = expected cash inflow in period t, k = required rate of return, pt = predicted rate of inflation during period t, and A0 = initial investment.
๐ Example: Using a $100,000 investment with net cash inflow of $25,000 per year for 8 years, a required rate of return of 15%, and an inflation rate of 3% per year:
- Present value of inflows = $117,280
- Present value of outflow = -$100,000
- Net present value = $17,280
Because the net present value is positive, the project is deemed acceptable.
Detailed Example - PsychoCeramic Sciences, Inc. (PSI): PSI is considering installing a new marketing software package. The investment requirements include:
- $125,000 upfront to Pottery Software Corporation
- $100,000 to modify and install the software
- $90,000 to integrate into the overall information system
Delivery and installation takes one year; integration requires an additional year. Scheduled software updates require $15,000 every second year beginning in the fourth year (not updated in the last year). Projected additional profits start at $50,000 in the first year of operation, peak at $120,000 in the second year, then gradually decline. Project life is 10 years with a salvage value of $35,000. The company has a 12% hurdle rate and expects 3% inflation.
The Net Present Value analysis shows a positive NPV, so the project can be accepted. (The project would have been rejected if the hurdle rate were 14%). The total inflow is $759,000, or $75,900 per year on average. The required investment is $315,000. Assuming straight line depreciation of $31,500 per year, the payback period would be: $315,000 / ($75,900 + $31,500) = 2.93 years.
๐ก Why this matters: The NPV method properly accounts for the time value of money, inflation, and provides a clear go/no-go decision based on whether the net present value is positive.
4. Internal Rate of Return (IRR): The Internal Rate of Return is the discount rate that equates the present values of expected cash inflows and expected cash outflows.
๐ Formula: ฮฃ [Rt / (1 + k)^t] = ฮฃ [At / (1 + k)^t], where At is expected cash outflow in period t, Rt is expected inflow for period t, and k is the internal rate of return (found by trial and error).
5. Profitability Index: Also known as the benefit-cost ratio, the profitability index is the net present value of all future expected cash flows divided by the initial cash investment. If this ratio is greater than 1.0, the project may be accepted.
6. Other Profitability Models: These variations fall into three general categories: a) Those that subdivide net cash flow into the elements that comprise the net flow. b) Those that include specific terms to introduce risk into the evaluation. c) Those that extend the analysis to consider effects on other projects or activities.
12.1.1 Advantages of Profit-Profitability Numeric Models:
- Undiscounted models are simple to use and understand.
- All use readily available accounting data to determine cash flows.
- Model output is in terms familiar to business decision makers.
- With few exceptions, model output is on an absolute profit/profitability scale allowing absolute go/no-go decisions.
- Some profit models account for project risk.
12.1.2 Disadvantages of Profit-Profitability Numeric Models:
- These models ignore all non-monetary factors except risk.
- Models without discounting ignore the timing of cash flows and the time-value of money.
- Models that reduce cash flows to present value are strongly biased toward the short run.
- Payback-type models ignore cash flows beyond the payback period.
- The internal rate of return model can result in multiple solutions.
- All are sensitive to errors in input data for early years of the project.
- All discounting models are nonlinear, and effects of changes or errors are generally not obvious.
- All depend on determining cash flows, but it is not clear how cash flow is properly defined for evaluating projects.
12.1.3 Profit-Profitability Numeric Models โ An Overview:
In general, net present value models are preferred to internal rate of return models. The commonly seen phrase "Return on Investment" (ROI) does not denote any specific method of calculationโit usually involves NPV or IRR calculations but is also used for undiscounted average rate of return models and (incorrectly) payback period models.
The payback period model, occasionally using discounted cash flows, is one of the most commonly used models for evaluating projects. Managers generally feel that insistence on short payout periods tends to minimize risks associated with outstanding monies over time.
Real Options: A project selection model based on the notion that when one invests, one foregoes the value of alternative future investments (the opportunity cost). A project may have greater net present value if delayed to the future because uncertainties will be reduced. The real options approach acts to reduce both technological and commercial risk.
12.2 Introduction to Project Proposal:
A Project Proposal is the initial document that converts an idea or policy into details of a potential project, including outcomes, outputs, major risks, costs, stakeholders, and an estimate of resource and time required. A proposal is an offer or bid to do a certain project for someone. What makes a proposal a proposal is that it asks the audience to approve, fund, or grant permission to do the proposed project.
A proposal should contain information that enables the audience to decide whether to approve the project, approve hiring you to do the work, or both. To write a successful proposal, put yourself in the place of your audience and think about what information that person would need to feel confident having you do the project.
Proposals are different from feasibility reports. A feasibility report studies the merits of a project and recommends for or against it. A proposal asks management for approval to go ahead with the project.
12.3 Types of Project Proposals:
1. Internal Proposal: Written to someone within your organization (a business, government agency, etc.). With internal proposals, you may not have to include certain sections or as much information.
2. External Proposal: Written by a separate, independent consultant proposing to do a project for another firm. It can be a proposal from one organization or individual to another such entity.
3. Solicited Proposal: The recipient in some way requested the proposal. Typically, a company will send out Requests for Proposals (RFPs) through the mail or publish them in news sources. Proposals can also be solicited at a local level, such as when a boss asks an employee to write up a proposal.
4. Unsolicited Proposal: The recipient has not requested proposals. With unsolicited proposals, you sometimes must convince the recipient that a problem or need exists before you can begin the main part of the proposal.
12.3.1 Request for Proposal (RFP):
A Request for Proposal (RFP) is an invitation for suppliers, through a bidding process, to submit a proposal on a specific product or service. An RFP typically involves more than just price. Other requested information may include:
- Basic corporate information and history
- Financial information (can the company deliver without risk of bankruptcy)
- Technical capability
- Product information such as stock availability and estimated completion period
- Customer references
In the military, an RFP is often raised to fulfill an Operational Requirement (OR). In civilian use, RFP is usually part of a complex sales process known as enterprise sales. RFPs often include specifications of the item, project, or service. Generally, RFPs are sent to an approved supplier or vendor list. Bidders return proposals by a set date and time. The proposals are used to evaluate suitability as a supplier, vendor, or institutional partner. Discussions may be held, and selected bidders may be asked to submit their Best and Final Offer (BAFO).
12.3.2 RFP Variations:
Request for Quotation (RFQ): Used where discussions are not required with bidders (mainly when specifications are already known), and price is the main or only factor in selecting the successful bidder. RFQ may also be used as a step prior to going to a full-blown RFP to determine general price ranges.
12.3.3 Request for Information (RFI):
A Request for Information (RFI) is a proposal requested from a potential seller or service provider to determine what products and services are potentially available in the marketplace to meet a buyer's needs and to know the capability of a seller. RFIs are commonly used on major procurements. An RFI is not an invitation to bid, is not binding on either party, and may or may not lead to an RFP or RFQ.
โญ Key Takeaways
Project selection models fall into two main categories: non-numeric (like Q-Sort and sacred cow) and numeric profitability models (payback period, average rate of return, NPV, IRR, and profitability index). The Q-Sort model organizes projects into good, fair, and poor groups based on relative merit. Payback period and average rate of return are simple but fail to account for the time value of money. Discounted cash flow (NPV) is preferred over IRR because it properly accounts for the time value of money and avoids multiple solution problems. A project proposal is a formal document asking for approval to undertake a project, and it differs from a feasibility report. Proposals can be internal/external and solicited/unsolicited, with RFPs being formal invitations for suppliers to bid on specific products or services.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the Q-Sort model and how does it categorize projects?
- How is payback period calculated, and what are its major limitations?
- What is the formula for Net Present Value, and how is the inflation rate incorporated?
- What distinguishes a project proposal from a feasibility report?
- What are the differences between an RFP, RFQ, and RFI in the procurement process?
๐ Lecture 13 โ Project Proposal
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive overview of project proposals, covering their key characteristics, preparation strategies, and the specific activities involved in developing them. It details the essential components of a typical Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) proposal and discusses necessary modifications to standard proposal formats to meet specific owner requirements. Understanding this lecture is critical for successfully initiating, structuring, and winning project bids.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by outlining the seven key characteristics of a project proposal, including its high-priority, short-duration nature and the need to adhere to owner specifications. It then details the preparatory work for future proposals, such as establishing a data bank and pre-writing standard sections. The specific proposal effort process is explained, covering steps from preliminary assignments to final delivery. The typical contents of an Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) proposal are broken down, from the introduction to qualifications. Finally, the lecture discusses the necessity of modifying standard proposals to comply with specific owner formats.
๐ Lecture Summary
13.1 Characteristics of a Project Proposal:
A project proposal is a high-stakes, time-sensitive undertaking. These projects are high priority, short duration efforts that must meet the owner's schedule, often under heavy workload. The proposal must adhere to the owner's specifications for payment methods, format, and preferred project location, though contractors may suggest alternatives. The owner may also have preferences for the construction labor arrangement. A successful proposal requires forming a cross-functional team from sales, project management, and technical support. These proposal projects are normally costed against corporate overhead, making them tightly budgeted and closely monitored by senior management.
๐ Definition โ Proposal Project: High priority, short duration efforts that must be completed to the owner's schedule, regardless of other demands.
13.2 Preparation for Future Proposals:
To manage the repetitive nature and tight budgets of proposals, companies should collect information in advance. This includes identifying a proposal project managerโsomeone with verbal skills and tolerance for tight schedules and criticism. A dedicated proposal publication staff with editing and graphic art skills should be in place. Essential pre-built resources include a technical information data base of past projects, standard scope of services that can be customized, and comprehensive definitions for cost estimate levels. Work plans for basic project types and a data bank of standard commercial terms and overhead costs are also vital. Finally, qualification materialโsuch as past project data, personnel resumes, and descriptions of support areas like project controls and quality assuranceโshould be updated frequently and maintained in standard formats.
๐ Definition โ Proposal Publication Staff: Individuals with skills in editing, word processing, reproduction, and graphic art to manage the production of proposal materials.
13.3 Proposal Effort for Specific Proposals:
Effort begins as soon as there is a positive indication the company will be on the bid list. Early steps include making preliminary assignments for the proposal project manager, the proposed project manager, and technical staff. A preliminary proposal plan, schedule, and budget should be developed. A rigorous assessment of the company's strengths and weaknesses regarding the project's technical aspects must be made, with immediate actions planned to boost capability. Finally, when the formal Request for Proposal (RFP) is received, it is reviewed, and a bid/no bid decision is made.
๐ Definition โ Preliminary Proposal Plan: A document that defines the outline of the proposal and the preliminary assignment of work.
13.4 Proposal Effort:
Once the decision to bid is confirmed, the proposal effort becomes a structured process. First, the assignment of team members is finalized. The proposal manager then calls a kick-off meeting to assign tasks, review technical and legal considerations, and set schedules. A preliminary review of the proposal text is conducted on typed drafts to check for omissions. A final review is submitted to operations management and legal, with all major changes flagged for quick approval. The process concludes with publication and signoff, followed by the delivery of the proposal to the owner.
๐ Example: A proposal for a new chemical plant. After the bid decision is confirmed, the project manager holds a kick-off meeting. At this meeting, the lead engineer is assigned to write the "Scope of Services," the scheduler to create the "Work Plan," and the controller to prepare the "Cost Estimates," each with a deadline for their draft.
13.5 Typical Engineering Procurement and Construction (EPC) Proposal Contents:
The standard contents of a cost-reimbursable EPC proposal are structured to provide a complete picture. The Introduction and Summary outlines the RFP conditions and the contractor's general approach. The Project Description summarizes the project from the RFP and any additional site visit information. The Scope of Services details all services the contractor will provide and all deliverables. The Work Plan and Schedule shows the interrelationship of project activities. The Project Organization describes the team structure and responsibilities, often with an organizational chart. The Estimates, Hours, and Costs section presents all direct and indirect cost estimates. The Compensation section finalizes commercial terms, including burdens, contingencies, and fees. Finally, the Qualifications section builds the owner's confidence by presenting relevant, accurate, and forceful examples of the contractor's past performance and capabilities.
๐ Definition โ Work Plan and Schedule: A section of the proposal that presents the project work plan in response to the owner's objectives, often in a graphic form showing the interrelationship of activities.
13.6 Modifications to the Standard Proposal:
Many owners have a very specific format for proposals. When this is the case, the contractor must depart from its standard proposal format. It is best to follow the specified format exactly, as this simplifies the proposal evaluation process for the owner's office and demonstrates responsiveness.
๐ก Why this matters: Even with a well-developed standard proposal, failing to comply with an owner's specific format can lead to disqualification, regardless of the proposal's technical merit. Adhering to the owner's request is a fundamental sign of professionalism.
๐ Definition โ Owner's Specified Format: A unique format for a proposal requested by an owner, which must be followed by the contractor to simplify the owner's evaluation process.
โญ Key Takeaways
A project proposal is a distinct, high-priority, and short-duration project in itself, requiring a dedicated team and tight budget controls that are monitored by senior management. To be efficient, a company must prepare in advance by building a robust data bank of reusable information, including standard scopes, work plans, and qualification material. The specific proposal effort follows a clear, sequential process, beginning with preliminary assignments and a bid/no-bid decision, and proceeding through a kick-off meeting, text reviews, and final publication and delivery. The standard EPC proposal must include eight essential sections, from the introduction and scope of services to cost estimates, compensation, and qualifications. Finally, while a standard proposal structure is a necessary foundation, it must always be modified to comply with any specific format required by the owner to ensure a fair evaluation.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven key characteristics of a project proposal?
- What are the three most important items to prepare in advance for future proposals to improve efficiency and quality?
- List the six steps in the specific proposal effort process, starting from the decision to bid.
- What are the eight typical sections of an Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) proposal?
- Why is it important to follow a specific format if an owner requires one, rather than using the contractor's standard proposal format?