π Lecture 7 β The Project Manager (Contd.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of the project manager role, focusing on what makes a project manager successful, their responsibilities, and the critical relationships they must manage. It also examines project champions, the power and authority of project managers, and the differences between functional and project organizations, including matrix structures.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the characteristics of a successful project manager and their dependence on line managers. It details the role, responsibilities, and required skills of a project manager, including risk management. The concept of a project sponsor and the project champion is introduced, along with the differences between a champion and a manager. The lecture then explores the power and authority of a project manager, their different sources, and potential problems. Finally, it compares functional and project organizations, detailing the advantages and disadvantages of functional structures and the three types of matrix organizations: weak, balanced, and strong.
π Lecture Summary
Successful Project Manager
A good project management methodology provides a framework to increase success, but project management is not purely a science. A successful Project Manager is strongly dependent on a good daily working relationship with line managers who assign resources and the ability of functional employees to report vertically to their line manager and horizontally to one or more project managers. This creates a critical dynamic where employees favor the manager who controls their "purse strings," often putting project managers at the mercy of line managers.
π Definition β Classical Management: A process in which the manager does not necessarily perform things for himself, but accomplishes objectives through others in a group situation.
Role of the Project Manager
A Project Manager is the person with overall responsibility for the successful planning and execution of a project. They must possess a combination of skills, including the ability to ask penetrating questions, detect unstated assumptions, resolve interpersonal conflicts, and apply systematic management skills. The Project Manager's key duty is to recognize that risk directly impacts the likelihood of success and must be formally and informally measured. A good PM can reduce risk through open communication, ensuring every significant participant can express opinions.
Roles and Responsibilities of Project Manager
The role encompasses many activities, including planning, scheduling, budgeting, controlling quality, managing risks, and team leadership. The project manager operates within time, cost, and performance constraints, reminding line managers of all three, not just performance. Success is like a three-legged stool composed of the Project Manager, the line manager, and senior management. The critical interface is between the project and line managers, who must share authority, responsibility, and accountability.
A project sponsor (often an executive) provides behind-the-scenes assistance, advice, and guidance, especially during a crisis. The sponsorβs responsibility is to make effective and timely decisions based on accurate data provided by the Project Manager. The line manager must cope with numerous challenges like unlimited work requests, predetermined deadlines, and unscheduled changes.
When staffing, a candidate's interpersonal and communication skills are crucial. An individual qualified for a vertical promotion (line management) may not be suitable for a horizontal promotion (project management). A good Project Manager understands both their own strengths and weaknesses and those of their employees.
π Formula: Project Success = Project Manager + Line Manager + Senior Management
π Example: A major utility company starts each computer project with a feasibility study. Project Managers perform the study without functional support. Functional managers argue the results are inaccurate. The PMs argue they lack time and money for a complete analysis. This demonstrates organizational conflict.
Project Champions
Corporations encourage employees to think up new ideas. One reward for an idea generator is the title of "Project Champion." However, if the Champion becomes the Project Manager, the project may fail because championing an idea requires different skills than managing a project.
Power and Authority of Project Manager
Authority is the legal or rightful power to command or direct others. Power is granted by subordinates and is a measure of their respect. In a traditional structure, power comes from hierarchy; in a project structure, it comes from credibility, expertise, and good decision-making. Project authority is the way of thinking to unify all activities towards the project's goal. A good PM knows where their authority ends and must have more authority than their responsibility calls for, especially when risk is high.
Common sources of power and authority problems include poorly documented authority, dual accountability, and shifting personnel loyalties. The project environment is an arena of continuous conflict and negotiation. Ground rules for negotiations include taking place at the lowest level, defining the problem first, and escalating only if agreement cannot be reached.
π‘ Why this matters: A project manager's authority is not always clearly defined. Understanding its sources and limitations is critical for navigating conflicts and successfully managing across functional lines.
π Definition β Influence Project Manager: A project manager who has only monitoring authority.
Functional and Project Organizations
A Functional Organization is a structure where authority rests with functional heads and is sectioned by departmental groups. Advantages: Simple, clear, reduces overhead, and provides clear career paths. Disadvantages: Coordination of tasks is difficult, and there is little reward for cross-functional cooperation, leading to departmental blaming.
Matrix Organizations fall between fully functional and fully projectized structures. Three types exist:
- Weak/Functional Matrix: A Project Administrator with limited authority tracks progress and enhances communication; functional managers control resources.
- Balanced/Functional Matrix: Power is shared equally between the Project Manager and functional managers. This is the most difficult system to maintain.
- Strong/Project Matrix: The Project Manager is primarily responsible; functional managers provide technical expertise. Conflicts can arise over resource assignment.
π‘ Why this matters: The choice of organizational structure directly impacts a project manager's authority and ability to manage resources, making it a critical strategic decision for any project.
β Key Takeaways
The success of a project manager hinges on a strong, collaborative relationship with line managers, who are the true controllers of resources. While a project manager's formal authority may be limited, their effectiveness relies on earning power through credibility, expertise, and negotiation. The project manager's primary role is to balance time, cost, and performance constraints while managing risk through open communication. Organizational structures, whether functional or matrix (weak, balanced, or strong), define the distribution of power and are a major source of conflict and negotiation in project management. Finally, the skills of a project champion and a project manager are distinct; a person good at generating ideas is not necessarily good at executing them.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "three-legged stool" analogy for project management success, and who represents each leg?
- What is the critical difference between authority and power as defined for a project manager?
- Name the three types of matrix organizations and briefly describe where the power lies in each.
- Why is it often risky to make a "Project Champion" the "Project Manager"?
- List two potential problems that can arise from a failure to establish clear authority relationships on a project.
π Lecture 08 β Project Conception and Project Feasibility
π Overview: This lecture introduces the initial stage of project developmentβproject conception and feasibility assessment. It explains how project ideas originate, how alternatives are formulated and selected, and why a thorough feasibility analysis is critical before committing resources to a project.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of project conception and its three main stages: defining a requirement or opportunity, formulating preliminary alternatives, and initial selection of alternatives. It then provides a detailed explanation of feasibility analysis, including its purpose and process, followed by the nine distinct types of feasibility that must be assessed. The lecture concludes with a discussion on distinguishing between tangible and intangible benefits and costs in project evaluation.
π Lecture Summary
Project Conception
Project conception is the initial step in defining the actual scope of a project. It generally starts with a manifestation of a requirement or an opportunity that will benefit the corporate interests and culminates when one or more preliminary options have been formulated. The process, while illustrated by an industrial project, has features directly translatable to conceptual evolution in many diverse applications.
Stages of Project Conception
Initial conceptualization of a project has various degrees of complexity, depending on the nature of the specific project. The company's planning strategy may require formulations of programs involving several projects; conception of the overall program should then precede conception of the individual specific projects.
The conceptual stage involves the following activities:
- Definition of a requirement or an opportunity that commands the interests of the company.
- Formulation of a set of preliminary alternatives capable of fulfilling the initial requirement.
- Selection of alternative(s) that might satisfy the requirements in terms and conditions attractive to the company.
Definition of the Requirement or Opportunity: The continuity of efficient operations and the opening of new business areas are the main drives for capital investments. Investment opportunities are detected through operational analysis of current performance and by forecasts of the most likely future scenarios. Initially, the scope of any new investment is likely to be vague; subsequent definition involves consideration of all available relevant facts, required resources, and constraints.
Preliminary Formulation of the Alternatives: Project conception continues with development of alternatives capable of fulfilling the expressed objectives. The preliminary formulation of alternatives is important as it sets the pace of the subsequent definition and elaboration of the project scope. The company calls upon the experience and creativity of its technicians, managers, and directors to generate an adequate group of alternatives.
Initial Selection of Alternatives: After alternatives have been identified, comparative analyses are made to select the most beneficial and reject the least attractive. The selection process employs a basic feasibility analysis of each alternative and the establishment of criteria that will allow the identification of the most attractive options. The cost, schedule, profitability, and other salient advantages and disadvantages of each of the selected alternatives are assessed in terms of order of magnitude.
Feasibility Analysis
A feasibility study is an analytical tool used during the project planning process that shows how a business would operate under an explicitly stated set of assumptions. These assumptions include the technology used (facilities, types of equipment, manufacturing process, etc.) and the financial aspects of the project (capital needs, volume, cost of goods, wages, etc.).
What is Feasibility Assessment?
A feasibility study is an analysis of the viability of an idea. It focuses on helping answer the essential question: "Should we proceed with the proposed project idea?" Determining early on that a business idea will not work saves time, money, and heartache later.
A feasible business venture is one where the business will generate adequate cash flow and profits, withstand the risks it will encounter, remain viable in the long-term, and meet the goals of the founders.
A feasibility study is usually conducted after producers have discussed a series of business ideas or scenarios. It helps to "frame" and "flesh-out" specific business alternatives so they can be studied in-depth. A pre-feasibility study may be conducted first to help sort out relevant alternatives. A market assessment may be conducted to help determine the viability of a proposed product in the marketplace.
The go/no-go decision is one of the most critical in business developmentβit is the point of no return. The feasibility study will be a major information source in making this decision.
A feasibility study is not a business plan. The feasibility study provides an investigating function (addressing "Is this a viable business venture?"), while the business plan provides a planning function (outlining actions needed to take the proposal from "idea" to "reality"). The feasibility study outlines and analyzes several alternatives; the business plan deals with only one alternative or model. The feasibility study is conducted before the business plan.
From a financial perspective, project selection is basically a two-part process: first, the organization conducts a feasibility study to determine whether the project can be done; second, it performs a benefit-to-cost analysis to see whether the company should do it.
Types of Feasibility
1. Technical Feasibility: Reviews the engineering feasibility of the project, including structural, civil, and other relevant engineering aspects. The technical capabilities of the personnel as well as the capability of the projected technologies are considered. In third world countries, technology transfer between geographical areas and cultures needs to be analyzed.
2. Managerial Feasibility: Demonstrated management capability and availability, employee involvement, and commitment are key elements. This addresses the management and organizational structure of the project, ensuring the proponent's structure is well suited to the type of operation undertaken.
3. Economic Feasibility: Involves the feasibility of the proposed project to generate economic benefits. A benefit-cost analysis and a break-even analysis (when appropriate) are required aspects. The tangible and intangible aspects of a project should be translated into economic terms to facilitate a consistent basis for evaluation.
4. Financial Feasibility: Should be distinguished from economic feasibility. Financial feasibility involves the capability of the project organization to raise the appropriate funds needed to implement the proposed project. Loan availability, credit worthiness, equity, and loan schedule are reviewed as aspects of financial feasibility analysis.
5. Cultural Feasibility: Deals with the compatibility of the proposed project with the cultural environment of the project. In labor-intensive projects, planned functions must be integrated with the local cultural practices and beliefs.
6. Social Feasibility: Addresses the influences that a proposed project may have on the social system in the project environment. The effect of the project on the social status of the project participants must be assessed to ensure compatibility.
7. Safety Feasibility: Refers to an analysis of whether the project is capable of being implemented and operated safely with minimal adverse effects on the environment.
8. Political Feasibility: Requires an evaluation of the compatibility of project goals with the prevailing goals of the political system. Political considerations often dictate directions for a proposed project, particularly for large projects with significant visibility.
9. Environmental Feasibility: Often a killer of projects through long, drawn-out approval processes and active opposition. Concern must be shown and action must be taken to address any and all environmental concerns. This component also addresses the ability of the project to timely obtain needed permits, licenses, and approvals.
10. Market Feasibility: Should not be confused with Economic Feasibility. The market needs analysis views the potential impacts of market demand, competitive activities, and market share available. Possible competitive activities by competitors must be analyzed for early contingency funding and impacts on operating costs.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the distinct types of feasibility ensures that a project is evaluated from all critical anglesβtechnical, financial, social, and environmentalβpreventing costly failures that arise from a narrow assessment focus.
Tangible and Intangible Benefits
Estimating benefits and costs in a timely manner is very difficult.
Benefits are often defined as:
- Tangible benefits for which dollars may be reasonably quantified and measured.
- Intangible benefits that may be quantified in units other than dollars or may be identified and described subjectively.
Minimum costs that must be determined include:
- The current operating costs or the cost of operating in today's circumstances.
- Future period costs that are expected and can be planned for.
- Intangible costs that may be difficult to quantify and are often omitted if quantification would contribute little to the decision-making process.
There must be careful documentation of all known constraints and assumptions made in developing costs and benefits. The go or no-go decision to continue with a project could very well rest upon the validity of the assumptions.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that project conception begins with identifying a requirement or opportunity, followed by formulating and selecting preliminary alternatives. A feasibility study is a critical analytical tool that answers whether a project should proceed, and it must be conducted before a business plan is developed. There are ten distinct types of feasibilityβtechnical, managerial, economic, financial, cultural, social, safety, political, environmental, and marketβeach examining a different dimension of project viability. Benefits and costs are categorized as tangible (quantifiable in dollars) or intangible (subjective or measured in other units), and all assumptions must be clearly documented. The go/no-go decision is a point of no return that relies heavily on the findings of a properly conducted feasibility study.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main activities involved in the conceptual stage of a project?
- What is the fundamental question that a feasibility study is designed to answer?
- How does a feasibility study differ from a business plan in terms of its purpose and scope?
- List and briefly describe the ten types of feasibility discussed in the lecture.
- What is the difference between a tangible benefit and an intangible benefit, and why must assumptions be carefully documented when estimating costs and benefits?