📘 Lecture 8 — Action Research Model
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the Action Research Model as a foundational framework for Organization Development (OD), emphasizing planned change as a cyclical, iterative process of research and action. It covers the seven main phases of the model, the role of collaboration between OD practitioners and organization members, and contemporary adaptations including participatory action research and appreciative inquiry.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Action Research Model's cyclical phases including entry, contracting, diagnosis, feedback, planning change, intervention, evaluation, and termination of OD efforts. It distinguishes between phases and steps, discusses the collaborative nature of data gathering and feedback, and explains contemporary adaptations such as participatory action research and appreciative inquiry in various organizational and international settings.
📝 Lecture Summary
The Action Research Model
The action research model focuses on planned change as a cyclical process in which initial research about the organization provides information to guide subsequent action, then results are assessed to provide further information to guide further action. This iterative cycle of research and action involves considerable collaboration among organization members and OD practitioners. Action research is traditionally aimed both at helping specific organizations implement planned change and at developing general knowledge that can be applied to other change settings.
Entry (Problem Identification)
This stage usually begins when a key executive or someone with power senses that the organization has one or more problems that might be solved with the help of an OD practitioner. Contact between consultant and client initiates the entry phase.
🔑 Definition — Entry: The initial phase where the OD practitioner and client begin exploring the possibility of a working relationship.
During this process, the consultant assesses:
- The probability of relating with the client
- The motivation and values of the client
- The client's readiness for change
- The extent of resources available
- Potential leverage points of change
Contracting (Consultation with a Behavioral Science Expert)
During initial contact, the OD practitioner and client carefully assess each other. The practitioner has their own normative, developmental theory and must be conscious of those assumptions and values. Sharing them with the client from the beginning establishes an open and collaborative atmosphere.
🔑 Definition — OD Contract: Unlike other types of contracts, the OD contract states three critical areas:
- What each expects to get from the relationship
- How much time each will invest, when, and at what cost
- The ground rules under which the parties will operate
Diagnosis (Data Gathering and Preliminary Diagnosis)
This step involves gathering appropriate information and analyzing it to determine the underlying causes of organizational problems.
🔑 Definition — Diagnosis: The process of collecting and analyzing data to understand organizational problems and their root causes.
Four basic methods of gathering data:
- Interviews
- Process observation
- Questionnaires
- Organizational performance data (often overlooked)
One approach to diagnosis begins with observation, proceeds to a semi-structured interview, and concludes with a questionnaire to measure precisely the problems identified. In OD, "every action on the part of the consultant constitutes an intervention" that will have some effect on the organization.
Feedback (Feedback to a Key Client or Group)
Because action research is collaborative, diagnostic data are fed back to the client, usually in a group meeting. The feedback step helps members determine the strengths and weaknesses of the organization under study.
🔑 Definition — Feedback: The process of returning gathered information to organization members to validate findings and determine next steps.
The feedback session has three steps:
- Consultant provides summary of data and preliminary analysis
- General discussion for clarification questions
- Time devoted to interpretation and possible changes to analysis
💡 Why this matters: The action research process is very different from the doctor-patient model where the consultant makes a diagnosis and prescribes a solution. Failure to establish a common frame of reference may lead to faulty diagnosis or a communications gap where the client is unwilling to believe or accept the prescription.
Case Example: An OD practitioner interviewed senior management with four questions:
- What are the strengths? (Senior management experience, workforce commitment, good people throughout)
- What are the weaknesses? (Marketing & servicing system, lack of priorities, individual priorities over organizational, lack of management depth)
- Are you in favor of the off-site meeting?
- What should be the objective? (Agree on regional structure, set financial objectives, list of things to do/stop doing)
Planning Change (Joint Action Planning)
The OD practitioner and client members jointly agree on actions to be taken. This begins the moving process from Lewin's change model, as the organization decides how to reach a different quasi-stationary equilibrium.
🔑 Definition — Joint Action Planning: Collaborative process where specific actions are determined based on diagnosis, culture, technology, environment, and resources.
Good diagnosis determines the intervention. The purposes are to:
- Generate alternative steps for corrective response to identified problems
- Decide on the step or order of steps to take
Intervention (Action)
This stage involves the actual change from one organizational state to another. It may include installing new methods and procedures, reorganizing structures and work designs, and reinforcing new behaviors.
🔑 Definition — Intervention: The implementation phase where planned changes are executed, typically requiring a transition period.
Examples by level:
- Individual level: Job redesign and enrichment, training and management development, quality of working life changes, management by objectives, career development
- Group level: Team building, autonomous work groups, quality control circles
Evaluation (Data Gathering After Action)
Because action research is cyclical, data must be gathered after action to measure effects and feed results back to the organization, which may lead to re-diagnosis and new action.
🔑 Definition — Evaluation: The systematic assessment of change effects to inform subsequent cycles of diagnosis and action.
Termination of the OD Effort
An organization has a constant need for periodic, objective diagnostic check-ups by external consultants. Termination is not an applicable phase for internal OD practitioners—they may conclude specific programs but should not terminate the relationship. A primary role of internal practitioners is to serve as guardians of the new culture and help regulate social change.
Phases not Steps
Phases are a more appropriate term than steps because steps imply discrete actions, while phases connote a cycle of changes. In actual practice, phases blend, overlap, and do not follow one from the other. For example, when collecting information for diagnosis, an intervention is occurring simultaneously.
Contemporary Adaptations of Action Research
Trends in application:
- Movement from smaller subunits to total systems and communities
- Application in international settings, particularly developing nations
- Use to promote social change and innovation in community development
Key Adaptation 1: Participatory Action Research Contemporary applications have increased member involvement in the change process. Referred to as "participatory action research," "action learning," "action science," "self-design," or "appreciative inquiry," this approach emphasizes organization members learning firsthand about planned change. Both parties become "co-learners" in diagnosing, designing, implementing, and assessing changes.
Key Adaptation 2: Appreciative Inquiry This model proposes that words and conversations determine what is important in organizational life. It challenges the assumption that organizations are problems to be solved—instead, it suggests the most important change an organization can make is to begin conversations about what the organization is doing right.
Five steps of Appreciative Inquiry:
- Focus inquiry on successful aspects (e.g., successful collaborations, customer satisfaction)
- Gather data about the "best of what is" in the organization
- Examine data to find stories for "possibility propositions" bridging current best practices with ideal possibilities
- Bring stakeholders together to construct a vision of the future ("what should be")
- Implement changes similarly to action research
💡 Why this matters: Research on expectation effects supports that people tend to act in ways that make their expectations occur—a positive vision energizes and directs behavior to make that expectation come about.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The Action Research Model is a cyclical, collaborative process where research guides action and action generates new research, distinguishing it from the doctor-patient model of consulting. Students must remember the seven phases—entry, contracting, diagnosis, feedback, planning change, intervention, and evaluation—and understand that these are overlapping phases, not discrete steps. The feedback process is especially critical because it validates findings collaboratively and prevents the common failure of consultants' recommendations being rejected or misunderstood. Two contemporary adaptations are essential: participatory action research (where members become co-learners) and appreciative inquiry (which focuses organizational conversations on strengths and positive possibilities). Finally, internal OD practitioners should never fully terminate their relationship with the organization but serve as guardians of the new culture.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven phases of the Action Research Model, and why are they called "phases" rather than "steps"?
- Explain the difference between the doctor-patient model and the action research model in OD consulting.
- What are the three steps of a feedback session, and why is establishing a common frame of reference critical?
- Describe the two key contemporary adaptations of action research discussed in the lecture.
- How does appreciative inquiry differ from traditional action research in its starting point and focus?
📘 Lecture 9 — General Model of Planned Change
📖 Overview: This lecture presents a comprehensive framework for understanding how planned change unfolds in organizations. It covers the four basic activities of organization development, different types of planned change based on magnitude and organizational context, and critiques of the planned change model. The lecture concludes with a case study applying these concepts.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the general model of planned change with four sequential activities: entering and contracting, diagnosing, planning and implementing change, and evaluating and institutionalizing change. It then explores three dimensions along which planned change varies: magnitude of change (incremental vs. quantum), degree of organization (over-organized vs. under-organized), and domestic vs. international settings. Finally, the lecture presents a critique of planned change regarding its conceptualization and practice, followed by the Dim Lighting Co. case study for application.
📝 Lecture Summary
General Model of Planned Change
The three theories of planned change—Lewin's change model, the action research model, and contemporary adaptations—suggest a general framework for planned change. This framework describes four basic activities that practitioners and organization members jointly carry out in organization development. The arrows connecting the different activities show the typical sequence of events: from entering and contracting, to diagnosing, to planning and implementing change, to evaluating and institutionalizing change. The lines connecting the activities emphasize that organizational change is not a straightforward, linear process but involves considerable overlap and feedback among the activities.
Entering and Contracting
The first set of activities in planned change concerns entering and contracting. These events help managers decide whether they want to engage further in a planned change program and to commit resources to such a process. Entering an organization involves gathering initial data to understand the problems facing the organization or the positive opportunities for inquiry. Once this information is collected, the problems or opportunities are discussed with managers and other organization members to develop a contract or agreement to engage in planned change. The contract spells out future change activities, the resources that will be committed to the process, and how OD practitioners and organization members will be involved. In many cases, organizations do not get beyond this early stage because disagreements about the need for change surface, resource constraints are encountered, or other methods for change appear more feasible.
When OD is used in nontraditional and international settings, the entering and contracting process must be sensitive to the context in which the change is taking place.
Diagnosing
In this stage of planned change, the client system is carefully studied. Diagnoses can focus on understanding organizational problems, including their causes and consequences, or on identifying the organization's positive attributes. The diagnostic process is one of the most important activities in OD. It includes choosing an appropriate model for understanding the organization and gathering, analyzing, and feeding back information to managers and organization members about the problems or opportunities that exist.
Diagnostic models for analyzing problems explore three levels of activities:
- Organization issues represent the most complex level of analysis and involve the total system.
- Group-level issues are associated with department and group effectiveness.
- Individual-level issues involve the way jobs are designed.
Gathering, analyzing, and feeding back data are the central change activities in diagnosis. Data can be gathered through interviews, observations, survey instruments, or archival sources such as meeting minutes and organization charts. Organization members, often in collaboration with an OD practitioner, jointly discuss the data and their implications for change.
Planning and Implementing Change
In this stage, organization members and practitioners jointly plan and implement OD interventions. They design interventions to achieve the organization's vision or goals and make action plans to implement them. There are several criteria for designing interventions, including the organization's readiness for change, its current change capability, its culture and power distributions, and the change agent's skills and abilities.
Depending on the outcomes of diagnosis, there are four major types of interventions in OD:
- Human process interventions at the individual, group, and total system levels.
- Interventions that modify an organization's structure and technology.
- Human resource interventions that seek to improve member performance and wellness.
- Strategic interventions that involve managing the organization's relationship to its external environment and the internal structure and process necessary to support a business strategy.
Implementing interventions is concerned with managing the change process. It includes motivating change, creating a desired future vision of the organization, developing political support, managing the transition toward the vision, and sustaining momentum for change.
Evaluating and Institutionalizing Change
The final stage in planned change involves evaluating the effects of the intervention and managing the institutionalization of successful change programs. Feedback to organization members about the intervention's results provides information about whether the changes should be continued, modified, or suspended. Institutionalizing successful changes involves reinforcing them through feedback, rewards, and training. It demonstrates how traditional planned change activities, such as entry and contracting, survey feedback, and change planning, can be combined with contemporary methods, such as large-group interventions and high levels of participation.
Different Types of Planned Change
The general model of planned change describes how the OD process typically unfolds in organizations. In actual practice, the different phases are not nearly as orderly as the model implies. OD practitioners tend to modify or adjust the stages to fit the needs of the situation. Steps in planned change may be implemented in a variety of ways, depending on the client's needs and goals, the change agent's skills and values, and the organization's context. To understand these differences, planned change can be contrasted across situations on three key dimensions: the magnitude of organizational change, the degree to which the client system is organized, and whether the setting is domestic or international.
Magnitude of Change
Planned change efforts can be characterized as falling along a continuum ranging from incremental changes that involve fine-tuning the organization to quantum changes that entail fundamentally altering how it operates.
Incremental changes tend to involve limited dimensions and levels of the organization, such as the decision-making processes of work groups. They occur within the context of the organization's existing business strategy, structure, and culture and are aimed at improving the status quo. Planned change traditionally has been applied in situations involving incremental change, where the focus is on resolving specific social problems in bureaucratic structures.
Quantum changes, on the other hand, are directed at significantly altering how the organization operates. They tend to involve several organizational dimensions, including structure, culture, reward systems, information processes, and work design. They also involve changing multiple levels of the organization, from top-level management through departments and work groups to individual jobs.
In recent years, OD has been concerned increasingly with quantum change due to greater competitiveness and uncertainty. Because quantum change involves most features and levels of the organization, it is typically driven from the top, where corporate strategy and values are set. Change agents help senior managers create a vision of a desired future organization and energize movement in that direction.
💡 Why this matters: It is important to emphasize that quantum change may or may not be developmental in nature. Organizations may drastically alter their strategic direction without developing their capacity to solve problems and achieve high performance and quality of work life. The OD approach to quantum change is particularly relevant in today's rapidly changing and competitive environment.
Degree of Organization
Planned change efforts also can vary depending on the degree to which the organization or client system is organized.
In over-organized situations, such as in highly mechanistic, bureaucratic organizations, various dimensions such as leadership styles, job designs, organization structure, and policies and procedures are too rigid and overly defined for effective task performance. Planned change in over-organized situations is generally aimed at loosening constraints on behavior. Changes are designed to liberate suppressed energy, increase the flow of relevant information, and promote effective conflict resolution.
In under-organized organizations, there is too little constraint or regulation for effective task performance. Leadership, structure, job design, and policy are poorly defined. Communication is fragmented, job responsibilities are ambiguous, and employees' energies are dissipated because they lack direction. Underorganized situations are typically found in areas such as product development, project management, and community development.
When applied to under-organized situations, planned change is aimed at increasing organization by clarifying leadership roles, structuring communication, and specifying job responsibilities. This requires a modification of the traditional phases of planned change and includes the following four steps:
- Identification: Identifies the relevant people or groups who need to be involved in the change program.
- Convention: The relevant people or departments are brought together to begin organizing for task performance.
- Organization: Different organizing mechanisms are created to structure the newly required interactions among people and departments.
- Evaluation: The outcomes of the organization step are assessed, signaling the need for adjustments or further activities.
Domestic vs. International Settings
Planned change efforts traditionally have been applied in North American and European settings but increasingly are used outside of those cultures. The action research model reflects the underlying values and assumptions of these geographic settings, including equality, involvement, and short-term time horizons. In other societies, however, a very different set of cultural values may operate. For example, the cultures of most Asian countries are more hierarchical and status conscious, less open to discussing personal issues, more concerned with saving "face," and have a longer time horizon for results.
The cultural values that guide OD practice in the United States include a tolerance for ambiguity, equality among people, individuality, and achievement motives. When OD is applied outside of the North American or European context, the action research process must be adapted to fit the cultural context. Each step in the general model of planned change must be carefully mapped against the cultural context.
Conducting OD in international settings is highly stressful on OD practitioners. To be successful, they must develop a keen awareness of their own cultural biases, be open to seeing issues from another perspective, be fluent in the values and assumptions of the host country, and understand the economic and political context of business there. Most OD practitioners adopt a "cultural guide," often a member of the organization, to help navigate the cultural nuances of change.
Critique of Planned Change
Despite continued refinement, the models and practice of planned change are still in a formative stage of development, and there is considerable room for improvement. Critics have pointed out several problems with how planned change has been conceptualized and practiced.
Conceptualization of Planned Change: Planned change has typically been characterized as involving a series of activities for carrying out effective organization development. However, considerably more information is needed to guide how steps should be performed in specific situations. Porras and Robertson argued that planned change activities should be guided by information about (1) the organizational features that can be changed, (2) the intended outcomes, (3) the causal mechanisms by which outcomes are achieved, and (4) the contingencies upon which successful change depends. They noted that the key to organizational change is change in the behavior of each member and that information about causal mechanisms producing individual change is lacking.
A related deficiency is knowledge about how the stages of planned change differ across situations. Most models specify a general set of steps intended to be applicable to most change efforts, but considerably more effort needs to be expended identifying situational factors that may require modifying the general stages.
Planned change also tends to be described as a rationally controlled, orderly process, but critics argue this is seriously misleading. Planned change has a more chaotic quality, often involving shifting goals, discontinuous activities, surprising events, and unexpected combinations of changes.
Finally, the relationship between planned change and organizational performance and effectiveness is not well understood. OD traditionally has had problems assessing whether interventions are producing observed results due to the complexity of the change situation, lack of sophisticated analyses, and long time periods for producing results.
Practice of Planned Change: A growing number of OD practitioners have acquired skills in a specific technique and have chosen to specialize in that method. Although specialization may be necessary, it can lead to myopia. Some OD practitioners favor particular techniques and ignore other strategies that might be more appropriate, tending to interpret organizational problems as requiring the favored technique.
Effective change depends on a careful diagnosis of how the organization is functioning. Diagnosis requires both time and money, and some organizations are not willing to make the necessary investment. Rather, they rely on preconceptions about what the problem is and hire consultants with skills appropriate to solve that problem.
In situations requiring complex organizational changes, planned change is a long-term process involving considerable innovation and learning on site. Some organizations demand more rapid solutions and seek quick fixes from experts. Unfortunately, some OD consultants are more than willing to provide quick solutions, selling prepackaged programs that have trouble gaining wide organizational support and seldom produce advertised positive results.
Other organizations have not recognized the systemic nature of change. They believe that intervention into one aspect of the organization will be sufficient and are unprepared for the other changes that may be necessary to support a particular intervention. Changing any one part of an organization often requires adjustments in other parts to maintain appropriate alignment.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The general model of planned change comprises four core activities—entering and contracting, diagnosing, planning and implementing change, and evaluating and institutionalizing change—that form the foundation of organization development. Planned change varies significantly across three critical dimensions: the magnitude of change (incremental vs. quantum), the degree of organization (over-organized vs. under-organized), and cultural context (domestic vs. international settings). Quantum change is more complex and requires long-term commitment from top management, while incremental change is more bounded and problem-focused. The critique of planned change highlights serious deficiencies in both its conceptualization (overly rational and orderly, lacking contingency thinking) and practice (technique myopia, quick fixes, failure to recognize systemic nature of change). The Dim Lighting Co. case demonstrates how these concepts apply to real organizational decisions about resource allocation, innovation, and managing competing stakeholder interests.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four basic activities in the general model of planned change, and how do they relate to each other?
- What are the key differences between incremental change and quantum change in terms of scope, organizational levels affected, and duration?
- How does the planned change process differ when applied to over-organized versus under-organized organizations?
- What cultural adaptations must be made when applying OD in international settings, particularly in Asian contexts compared to North American settings?
- According to Porras and Robertson, what four types of information should guide planned change activities, and what is the key mechanism for organizational change?
📘 Lecture 10 — The Organization Development Practitioner
📖 Overview: This lecture provides a personal perspective on OD practitioners, examining who they are, their roles, and the essential character of OD as a helping profession. It explores the three main categories of practitioners—specialists, related-field professionals, and line managers—along with the advantages and disadvantages of internal versus external practice, and the critical importance of trust in practitioner-client relationships.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three sets of OD practitioners: professionals specializing in OD, those in related fields like reward systems and business strategy, and line managers who apply OD to their work areas. It examines external and internal practitioners' advantages and disadvantages, the external-internal practitioner team approach, the practitioner style model, and developing trust relationships through various communication responses.
📝 Lecture Summary
Who is the Organization Development Practitioner?
The term organization development practitioner refers to at least three sets of people. The most obvious group are those specializing in OD as a profession—internal or external consultants who traditionally share a common set of humanistic values promoting open communications, employee involvement, and personal growth. In recent years, these professionals have expanded to include concern for organizational effectiveness, competitiveness, and bottom-line results, resulting in a more diverse set of professionals geared to helping organizations cope with competitive pressures.
Second, the term applies to people specializing in fields related to OD, such as reward systems, organization design, total quality, information technology, and business strategy. These content-oriented fields increasingly integrate with OD's process orientation, particularly as OD projects become more comprehensive. Professionals in these fields do not subscribe fully to traditional OD values nor have extensive OD training, but they apply their special competence within an OD-like process, often by engaging OD professionals and managers to design and implement change programs.
Third, the term applies to the increasing number of managers and administrators who have gained competence in OD and apply it to their own work areas. Studies suggest that OD applied by managers rather than OD professionals is growing rapidly. As Kanter studied, firms like General Electric, Hewlett-Packard, and 3M have managers and employees who have become "change masters." Managers gain competence through interacting with OD professionals in actual change programs, supplemented by formal training from organizations like the National Training Laboratories, the Center for Creative Leadership, and the Gestalt Institute.
🔑 Definition — "Change Masters": Managers and employees who have gained the expertise to introduce change and innovation into the organization.
In practice, the distinctions among these three sets of OD practitioners are blurring. A growing number of managers have transferred into the OD profession, while more OD practitioners gain professional competence in related specialties like business process reengineering, reward systems, and organization design. Cross-training and integration are producing a more comprehensive and complex kind of OD practitioner with greater diversity of values, skills, and experience.
External and Internal Practitioners
In every large-scale planned change program, some person or group is designated to lead the change—the change leader. The practitioner is the person leading or guiding the process of change. Internal practitioners are already members of the organization, either managers practicing OD with their work groups or OD specialists from human resources or organization development departments. External practitioners are brought in from outside the organization as OD specialists, often referred to as consultants.
🔑 Definition — Practitioner: The change leader, the person leading or guiding the process of change in an organization.
The External Practitioner
The external practitioner is someone not previously associated with the client system. Coming from the outside, they see things from a different viewpoint and from a position of objectivity. Because external practitioners are invited into the organization, they have increased leverage (the degree of influence and status within the client system) and greater freedom of operation than internal practitioners. Research suggests that top managers view external practitioners as having a more positive role in large-scale change programs.
🔑 Definition — Leverage: The degree of influence and status within the client system.
External practitioners are less in awe of power wielded by organization members and do not depend on the organization for raises, approval, or promotions. Because they usually have a broad career base and other clients, they tend to have a more independent attitude about risk-taking. For example, at McKinsey & Co., consultants are direct, outspoken, and challenge the client's opinions—though their work is not necessarily organization development.
The disadvantages of external practitioners result from the same factors. Outsiders are generally unfamiliar with the organization system, culture, communication networks, and formal or informal power systems. They may have difficulty gathering pertinent information simply because they are outsiders.
The Internal Practitioner
The internal practitioner is already a member of the organization—a top executive, an organization member who initiates change in their work group, or a member of the human resources or organization development department. Many large organizations (including Disney, IBM, General Electric, General Motors, Honeywell, Union Carbide, and the US Army and Navy) have created internal OD practitioner groups, often operating out of the human resources area.
Advantages include familiarity with the organization's culture and norms, knowledge of the power structure, being already known to employees, and having a personal interest in seeing the organization succeed.
Disadvantages include potential lack of specialized OD skills (though this is becoming less significant with more university programs), lack of objectivity, being more likely to accommodate to management's needs, potential negative influence from previous work and relationships, and sometimes lacking necessary power and authority when in remote staff positions.
The External-Internal Practitioner Team
The external-internal practitioner team is probably the most effective approach for large-scale change. OD researcher John Lewis found that successful external OD practitioners assisted in the development of their internal counterparts. Each partner brings complementary resources—the external practitioner brings expertise, objectivity, and new insights, while the internal practitioner brings detailed knowledge of organization issues, long-time acquaintance with members, and awareness of system strengths and weaknesses.
The collaborative relationship provides integration of abilities, skills, and resources, serving as a model for the rest of the organization embodying trust, respect, honesty, confrontation, and collaboration. The team approach makes it possible to divide the workload and share in diagnosis, planning, and strategy.
💡 Why this matters: In the example of the U.S. Navy's Command Development Program, internal change agents recommended training seminars away from the Navy environment with civilian clothing to lessen authority issues, but higher authority ordered them held on naval bases in uniform. An external practitioner with greater leverage might have provided enough support to gain approval for the desired program.
Another reason for using this team approach is to achieve greater continuity. External practitioners are generally available only a few days a month, while the internal practitioner provides a continuing point of contact. Since many OD programs last three to five years, the external-internal combination provides the stimulation and motivation needed to keep change programs moving during periods of resistance.
Practitioner Style Model
There is often a gap between the practitioner's and the client's understandings about OD and change. The practitioner needs to assess this gap because a relationship is possible only if the practitioner can be flexible enough to understand where the client is and help them learn about the OD change process. The practitioner brings certain knowledge, skills, values, and experience, while the client system has its own values and expectations. The target organization has its own subculture and level of readiness for change.
Developing a Trust Relationship
The development of openness and trust between practitioner and client is an essential aspect of the OD program. Trust is necessary for cooperation and communication. When there is no trust, people tend to be dishonest, evasive, and not authentic, and communication is often inaccurate, distorted, or incomplete.
There are several basic responses the practitioner may use in the communication process aimed at developing a trust relationship:
• Questions — "How do you see the organization?" • Applied expertise (advising) — "One possible intervention is team building." • Reflection — "It sounds like you would like to see a participative form of leadership." • Interpretation — "From your description, inter-team conflict could be the problem." • Self-disclosure — "I've felt discouraged myself when my ideas were rejected." • Silence — Say nothing, let the client sort out their thoughts.
How these responses are used is important. The more balanced the practitioner's use of these responses and the more open the range of responses, the higher the level of trust. For example, practitioners who rely exclusively on questions create a one-way flow of information, while those who rely heavily on advising may develop a dependency relationship.
During early contacts with the client system, practitioners should reflect on: the attitude of the client system toward OD, the gut-level meaning of the client's problem, whether an OD program will alleviate the problem, and the practitioner's potential impact on the system. Once answered, the practitioner can decide whether to continue or terminate the relationship.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The three categories of OD practitioners—professionals specializing in OD, those in related fields, and line managers—are increasingly blurring through cross-training and integration, producing more comprehensive practitioners. External practitioners bring objectivity and leverage but lack organizational familiarity, while internal practitioners have cultural knowledge and continuity but may lack objectivity and power. The external-internal practitioner team is the most effective approach as it combines complementary strengths and provides both fresh perspective and ongoing support. Trust development is essential and depends on the practitioner's balanced use of communication responses including questions, advising, reflection, interpretation, self-disclosure, and silence. Practitioners must assess the gap between their own understanding and the client's to determine whether to continue or terminate the change relationship.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three sets of people referred to by the term "organization development practitioner"?
- What are three advantages and three disadvantages of using an external practitioner versus an internal practitioner?
- Why is the external-internal practitioner team considered the most effective approach for large-scale change programs?
- What are the six basic communication responses a practitioner can use to develop a trust relationship with the client?
- What four types of questions should a practitioner reflect on during early contacts with the client system?