📘 Lecture 11 — Creating a Climate for Change
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the foundational elements of the practitioner-client relationship in Organization Development, emphasizing the importance of openness, trust, and value alignment. It explains who the true client is in OD, identifies five distinct practitioner styles, and explores four modes of practitioner-client relationships. The lecture also includes a case study to apply these concepts.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the concept of the true client in OD as the relationship or interface between individuals and units, not any single person or group. It details five practitioner styles—Stabilizer, Cheerleader, Analyzer, Persuader, and Pathfinder—based on emphasis on effectiveness versus morale. The four practitioner-client relationship modes (apathetic, gamesmanship, charismatic, consensus) are explained based on sharing of ideas and acceptance of responsibility. Important dimensions for building effective relationships and a case study of Grayson Chemical Company are also presented.
📝 Lecture Summary
Creating a Climate for Change
OD practitioners agree that an open give-and-take relationship with the client is desirable. This depends on the practitioner's ability to form relationships of openness and trust. The change agent should act congruently, practicing what they preach, to create a positive climate for participation and learning. The basic value system of the OD practitioner may conflict with the organization's culture, so an assessment of the degree of difference and the likelihood of working through these differences should be part of the initial intervention. The practitioner must also examine the degree of conflict and collaboration between organization units to avoid being party to existing conflicts.
Who is Client?
The correct answer is (7), "none of the above." The client in OD consultation is never one individual, group, team, or subsystem. The client is the relationship and/or interface between individuals and units within and related to the system. The arrows in a system diagram represent the true client. The degree to which a consultant is effective is a function of maintaining a certain social distance and operating on the boundaries of units rather than exclusively within them, allowing the consultant to maintain an objective stance between persons and units in conflict.
OD Practitioner Styles:
The OD practitioner initiates, stimulates, or facilitates a change program. Intervention refers to the practitioner's entry into the client system. Practitioner styles are based on emphasis upon two dimensions: effectiveness (goal accomplishment) and morale (relationships and participant satisfaction).
The Stabilizer Style:
The goal of the stabilizer style is neither effectiveness nor participant satisfaction. The practitioner tries to keep from rocking the boat and maintain a low profile. The underlying motivation is often survival or following directives of top management. This style is typically found in large organizations where development programs are not highly regarded by top management.
The Cheerleader Style:
The cheerleader style places emphasis on the satisfaction of organization members and is chiefly concerned with employee motivation and morale. The cheerleader practitioner seeks warm working relationships and is more comfortable in non-confrontational situations. Effectiveness per se is not emphasized, with the assumption that high member satisfaction will lead to effectiveness. This assumption is contradicted by evidence.
The Analyzer Style:
The analyzer style places great emphasis on efficiency and gives little emphasis to member satisfaction. The analyzer feels comfortable with rational assessment of problems and assumes facts will lead to solutions. Practitioners may be confrontational, relying on authority and rational problem-solving. This style is based on specialized expertise and the belief that the client cannot learn the skills to solve its own problems.
The Persuader Style:
The persuader style focuses on both effectiveness and morale but optimizes neither. It provides a low-risk strategy that avoids direct confrontation. This approach is used when the practitioner has little power or leverage. A great deal of effort is applied to satisfy different forces, often resulting in a watered-down change program where organization improvement is unlikely.
The Pathfinder Style:
The pathfinder style seeks both high effectiveness and high member satisfaction, believing that greater effectiveness is possible when all members are involved and problem-solving is done through teamwork. Confrontation and conflict are seen as means to a more effective organization. This approach uses collaborative problem solving and challenges underlying patterns of member behavior. The pathfinder practitioner helps the organization focus on its most critical issues and focuses on six essential processes: (1) communication, (2) member role and functions in groups, (3) group problem-solving and decision-making, (4) group norms and growth, (5) leadership and authority, and (6) inter-group cooperation and competition.
💡 Why this matters: These five styles are not mutually exclusive. All can be effective and are interrelated. A practitioner may transition from one style to another to meet changing client system needs.
Practitioner-Client Relationship Modes:
Eric H. Neilsen identified dimensions based on whether members (1) share ideas, assumptions, perceptions, and feelings, and (2) accept personal responsibility for their behavior.
The Apathetic Mode:
Members keep their true ideas to themselves, assuming sharing will not make a difference. They follow established routines, take no responsibility, and do as they are told. They view change with skepticism, assuming higher authority has sanctioned it.
The Gamesmanship Mode:
Members keep their true feelings to themselves, assuming sharing may threaten personally desired outcomes. They take responsibility for their behavior, conforming outwardly but manipulating strategic factors for personal gain. Members may favor change if it serves their personal interest.
The Charismatic Mode:
A limited number of members openly share ideas and feelings, based on perceptions of leadership. Followers look for cues from leaders, so responsibility is low for most members. Members view change as desirable if leaders approve but rely on leaders to interpret results.
The Consensus Mode:
Members continuously share perceptions and feelings openly. Personal viewpoints are seen as relevant and expressed. Decisions are made and differences resolved through sharing viewpoints, involving both data sharing and maintaining responsibility for actions. Members see the OD process as consistent with their way of operating.
Important Dimensions in Practitioner-Client Relationship:
- The practitioner's attitudes and behavior create a climate where feelings can be freely expressed.
- Ability to listen effectively and express ideas clearly.
- The practitioner is honest with the client; facades have no place.
- Power equalization ensures the power differential is not too great, allowing a collaborative relationship.
- All key parties must be involved in the OD program; ignoring key people leads to increased resistance and ineffectiveness.
- A good relationship increases the probability of a successful OD program; a superficial relationship increases the probability of failure.
Case: The Grayson Chemical Company
The Grayson Chemical Company was a 40-year-old industrial chemical manufacturer with stagnant management. Declining earnings led the board to recruit a new CEO, Tom Baker, from outside. Baker faced a culture where decisions were made by the book, things were done because "they have always been done this way," and incompetent managers were promoted. Three board members gave conflicting advice: one suggested motivating existing people, another recommended bringing in a new team of people Baker knew, and a third advised bringing in proven managers from different industries.
🔑 Definition — OD Practitioner: The person who initiates, stimulates, or facilitates a change program, who may come from inside or outside the organization.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The true client in OD is never an individual or single group but rather the relationship and interface between individuals and units within the system. Five practitioner styles exist—Stabilizer, Cheerleader, Analyzer, Persuader, and Pathfinder—each emphasizing effectiveness and morale to different degrees, with the Pathfinder style being the most comprehensive. The practitioner-client relationship can exist in four modes: apathetic, gamesmanship, charismatic, and consensus, with consensus being the most desirable. Key relationship dimensions include creating a climate for open expression, honest communication, power equalization, and involving all key parties. The Grayson Chemical case illustrates how conflicting board advice and a stagnant culture require the practitioner to choose an appropriate style for organizational renewal.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Who is the true "client" in an OD consultation?
- What are the two dimensions that define the five practitioner styles?
- Which practitioner style seeks both high effectiveness and high member satisfaction?
- What are the four practitioner-client relationship modes identified by Eric Neilsen?
- Why is power equalization important in the practitioner-client relationship?
📘 Lecture 12 — OD Practitioner Skills and Activities
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the competencies, skills, and knowledge required for effective Organizational Development (OD) practitioners. It covers the evolving role of OD professionals, including basic skills like intrapersonal and interpersonal abilities, consultation skills, and theory knowledge. The lecture also examines the differences between internal and external consultants, the concept of marginality, emotional demands of the role, and the continuum of using client versus consultant knowledge.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the ongoing projects to define OD practitioner competencies, basic skills required for all practitioners (intrapersonal, interpersonal, general consultation, and OD theory), the practitioner skills profile including leadership and project management, the ten primary abilities of an effective OD consultant, the roles of internal versus external consultants, the concept of marginality and its importance, emotional demands on practitioners, and the continuum of using client-centered versus consultant-centered knowledge.
📝 Lecture Summary
Much of the literature about the competencies of an effective OD practitioner reveals a mixture of personality traits, experiences, knowledge, and skills
Research on successful change practitioners yields attributes like diagnostic ability, basic knowledge of behavioral science techniques, empathy, goal-setting ability, problem-solving ability, self-assessment, objectivity, imagination, flexibility, honesty, consistency, and trust. Two ongoing projects attempt to define and categorize these skills. The first effort, updated annually by fifty well-known practitioners, lists 187 statements in nine areas: entry, start-up, assessment and feedback, action planning, intervention, evaluation, adoption, separation, and general competencies. The second project, by the Academy of Management's Organization Development and Change Division, seeks to guide graduate curriculum development with two competency lists: foundation competencies (knowledge from organization behavior, psychology, group dynamics, management theory, research methods, and business practices) and core competencies (knowledge of organization design, system dynamics, OD history, and skills to manage the consulting process, diagnose systems, design interventions, and evaluate change).
Based on available studies, all OD practitioners should have the following basic skills and knowledge:
- Intrapersonal skills. OD is a human craft requiring practitioners to process complex, ambiguous information and make informed judgments. Practitioners must have personal centering to know their own values, feelings, and purposes, active learning skills, a balance between rational and emotional sides, and the ability to manage stress to avoid burnout.
- Interpersonal skills. Practitioners must create and maintain effective helping relationships with individuals and groups. This requires understanding the organization's perspective, listening to members' perceptions, establishing trust and rapport, giving and receiving feedback, serving as credible role models, providing counseling and coaching, and negotiating acceptable roles while managing changing expectations.
- General consultation skills. Practitioners need to carry out effective diagnosis by engaging organization members, asking the right questions, and collecting/analyzing information using methods like interviews or surveys and techniques like force-field analysis. They also need to design and execute interventions, define action plans, gain commitment, and tailor interventions based on progress.
- Organization development theory. Practitioners should have general knowledge of OD including planned change, the action research model, contemporary change management approaches, the range of available interventions, and the need for evaluating and institutionalizing change programs. They must understand their own role in the emerging field.
Susan Gebelein lists six key skill areas critical for internal practitioners:
- Leadership: Keeping members focused on key company values and opportunities for improvement.
- Project Management: Involving the right people and departments to keep the change program on track.
- Communication: Communicating key values to everyone in the organization.
- Problem-Solving: Implementing solutions and focusing on future problems, not just today's.
- Interpersonal: Giving everyone tools and confidence to be involved in the change process, including facilitating, building relationships, and process skills.
- Personal: Having confidence to help the organization make tough decisions, introduce new techniques, and try new things.
Consultant’s Abilities
Ten primary abilities are key to an OD consultant’s effectiveness:
- Ability to tolerate ambiguity. Every organization is different; enter with few preconceived notions.
- Ability to influence. The consultant must enjoy power and have talent for persuasion.
- Ability to confront difficult issues. Much OD work involves exposing issues members are reluctant to face.
- Ability to support and nurture others. Important in times of conflict, stress, and before a manager's first team-building experience.
- Ability to listen well and empathize. Especially important during interviews, conflict situations, and when client stress is high.
- Ability to recognize one’s feelings and intuition quickly. Important to distinguish own perceptions from client's and use feelings as timely interventions.
- Ability to conceptualize. Think and express cause-and-effect and if-then linkages within the systemic context of the client organization.
- Ability to discover and mobilize human energy. Effective interventions tap existing energy within the organization and provide direction for productive use.
- Ability to teach or create learning opportunities. Should be utilized on the job, during meetings, and within the mainstream of the change effort.
- Ability to maintain a sense of humor. Useful for reducing tension and sustaining perspective; not taking oneself too seriously is critical.
Role of Organization Development Professionals Position
OD professionals have positions that are either internal or external to the organization.
- Internal consultants are members of the organization, often in the human resources department. They have advantages during entry: ready access to clients, relationships, knowledge of company jargon, insights into root causes, time efficiency, and steady pay. They are obligated to work with everyone.
- External consultants are not members of the client organization; they work for a consulting firm, university, or themselves. They can select clients according to their own criteria, have higher status during diagnosis allowing objective probing, and have formal contracts with the ability to terminate projects at will.
🔑 Definition — Marginality: The state of successfully straddling the boundary between two or more groups with differing goals, value systems, and behavior patterns.
During the entry process, internal consultants have advantages like ready access, relationships, and knowledge. External consultants can select clients. In diagnosis, internal consultants know members and enjoy rapport, while external consultants have higher status and objectivity. In intervention, both rely on valid information, free and informed choice, and internal commitment. A promising approach is the internal-external consulting team, combining external expertise and objectivity with internal knowledge and acceptance. Effectiveness depends on strong, supportive collegial relationships, continuous feedback, and commitment to learning.
Marginality
The marginal person successfully straddles boundaries between groups with differing goals, values, and behaviors. Marginality is now seen positively. Those good at marginal roles have personal qualities of low dogmatism, neutrality, open-mindedness, objectivity, flexibility, and adaptable information-processing ability. They thrive on conflict, ambiguity, and stress, and are more likely to develop integrative decisions reconciling opposing viewpoints.
There are two other boundaries: the activities boundary and the membership boundary. For change activities, the consultant must help but not be directly involved. For membership, the consultant is never quite in nor quite out—involved enough to understand client feelings but distant enough to see them objectively. The internal OD practitioner cannot be a consultant to their own group or any group within the same vertical path of the managerial hierarchy.
Emotional Demands
The OD practitioner role is emotionally demanding. Emotional intelligence refers to the ability to recognize and express emotions appropriately, use emotions in thought and decisions, and regulate emotion in oneself and others. It supplements rational thought and helps prioritize thinking. Emotional intelligence increases with age and experience and can be developed through personal growth processes like sensitivity training, counseling, and therapy.
🔑 Definition — Emotional intelligence: The ability to recognize and express emotions appropriately, to use emotions in thought and decisions, and to regulate emotion in oneself and in others.
Use of Knowledge and Experience
The professional OD role ranges from client-centered (using the client's knowledge and experience) to consultant-centered (using the consultant's knowledge and experience). Traditionally, OD consultants worked at the client-centered end, remaining neutral and refusing to offer expert advice. With the proliferation of interventions in structural, human resource, and strategy areas, the role has expanded to include the consultant-centered end. The consultant may take on a modified role of expert, with consent and collaboration of organization members. For example, in major structural redesign, the consultant presents basic concepts and jointly selects approaches with managers. Expertise is always shared rather than imposed.
📐 Continuum of Use of Knowledge and Experience: Client-centered (using client's knowledge) ↔ Consultant-centered (using consultant's knowledge). The consultant's role falls along this entire continuum, moving between reliance on members' knowledge and taking on the expert role as needed.
⭐ Key Takeaways
OD practitioners require a blend of intrapersonal skills (personal centering, active learning, stress management), interpersonal skills (building trust, rapport, and helping relationships), general consultation skills (diagnosis, intervention design, action planning), and knowledge of OD theory. The consultant's ten primary abilities include tolerating ambiguity, influencing, confronting issues, supporting others, listening, recognizing feelings, conceptualizing, mobilizing energy, teaching, and maintaining humor. A critical distinction exists between internal and external consultants: internal consultants have ready access and relationships but may lack objectivity and face career risks, while external consultants bring higher status and objectivity but need to build trust from scratch. The internal-external consulting team approach combines both advantages. The concept of marginality is essential—the consultant must straddle boundaries without being fully inside or outside the client system to maintain objectivity while understanding client perspectives. Emotional intelligence is as important as cognitive intelligence, and the consultant's role operates along a continuum from client-centered to consultant-centered, adapting to the situation and sharing expertise rather than imposing it.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four basic skills and knowledge areas that all OD practitioners should possess, according to the studies cited in this lecture?
- What are the key differences between internal and external OD consultants during the entry, diagnosis, and intervention stages of the action research process?
- What is meant by "marginality" in the context of the OD practitioner's role, and why is it considered important for effectiveness?
- List at least five of the ten primary abilities that are key to an OD consultant's effectiveness.
- How has the OD professional's role evolved along the continuum from client-centered to consultant-centered, and what factors have driven this expansion?
📘 Lecture 13 — Professional Values
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the core values underlying Organization Development, including humanistic values, the spirit of inquiry, and democracy. It examines how OD practitioners balance the tension between individual freedom and organizational constraints, and addresses the critical ethical dilemmas that arise in OD practice, providing guidelines for professional conduct.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers traditional humanistic values in OD including concern for inquiry, democracy, and helpfulness, along with extended values focused on organizational effectiveness and performance. It discusses the tension between freedom and constraint in organizations, professional ethics and the five types of ethical dilemmas (misrepresentation, misuse of data, coercion, value and goal conflict, and technical ineptness), along with ethical guidelines and approaches to resolving dependency issues in the helping relationship.
📝 Lecture Summary
Professional Values
Values have played an important role in organization development from its beginning. Traditionally, OD professionals have promoted a set of values under a humanistic framework, including a concern for inquiry and science, democracy and being helpful. They have sought to build trust and collaboration; to create an open, problem-solving climate; and to increase the self-control of organization members.
More recently, OD practitioners have extended those humanistic values to include a concern for improving organizational effectiveness (for example, to increase productivity or to reduce turnover) and performance (for example, to increase profitability). They have shown an increasing desire to optimize both human benefits and production objectives.
The lecture traces these values back to sensitivity training, which has a humanistic value orientation — the belief that it is worthwhile to have the opportunity throughout their lives to learn and develop personally toward a full realization and actualization of individual potential. From sensitivity training came the value that people's feelings are just as important as facts for diagnosis and change. Another value is that conflict, whether interpersonal or intergroup, should be brought to the surface and dealt with directly, rather than ignored, avoided, or manipulated.
Two main value systems from sensitivity training are: the spirit of inquiry (from science), which includes the hypothetical spirit (being tentative, checking assumptions, allowing for errors) and experimentation (putting ideas to the test); and democratic values, which include collaboration and conflict resolution through rational means.
🔑 Definition — Spirit of inquiry: "All experienced behavior is subjected to questioning and examination, limited only by the threshold of tolerance to truth and new ideas."
🔑 Definition — Democratic value: The learning process in sensitivity training is collaborative between participant and trainer, not a traditional authoritarian student-teacher relationship. Conflict resolution through rational means means "there is a problem-solving orientation to conflict rather than the more traditional approaches based on bargains, power plays, suppression, or compromise."
💡 Why this matters: The lecture emphasizes that most organizations treat employees as expendable, and OD helps correct imbalances between human needs and organizational demands.
The Right Goal for OD
OD's right goal grows from its proper setting. If the proper setting is organizations, then there is only one right goal for OD: to confront an issue that is the tension between freedom and constraint. OD's right purpose is to redress the balance between freedom and constraint.
There is always tension between the autonomy of the individual and the requirements of the organization. It is practically impossible to determine the proper balance, but when either factor is obviously out of balance, the OD consultant's goal is to work toward reducing the heavier side.
The joint values of humanizing organizations and improving their effectiveness have received widespread support. However, practitioners face serious challenges in simultaneously pursuing greater humanism and organizational effectiveness. For example, expensive capital equipment may run most efficiently if highly programmed and routinized, but people may not derive satisfaction from working with such technology. These are the value dilemmas often faced when trying to optimize both human benefits and organizational effectiveness.
External Value Conflicts
OD practitioners are dealing more with value conflicts with powerful outside groups. Organizations are open systems existing within increasingly turbulent environments. For example, hospitals face complex task environments with multiple external stakeholders including patients, suppliers, medical groups, insurance companies, employers, government, stockholders, unions, the press, and various interest groups.
These external groups often have different and competing values for judging the organization's effectiveness. Stockholders may judge the firm in terms of earnings per share, the government in terms of compliance with equal employment opportunity legislation, patients in terms of quality of care, and ecology groups in terms of hazardous waste disposal.
Recent attempts to help firms manage external relationships suggest the need for new interventions and competence in OD. Practitioners must have not only social skills but also political skills. Under conditions of power and dominance relationships and competition for scarce resources, OD practitioners may need power-oriented interventions such as bargaining, coalition forming, and pressure tactics.
For example, firms in the tobacco industry have formed a powerful industry coalition to lobby against anti-smoking legislation, spending enormous sums on advertising, public relations, and refuting research showing the dangers of smoking.
Professional Ethics
Ethical issues in OD are concerned with how practitioners perform their helping relationship with organization members. Inherent in any helping relationship is the potential for misconduct and client abuse. OD practitioners can let personal values stand in the way of good practice or use the power inherent in their professional role to abuse organization members.
Ethical Guidelines
The field of OD has always shown concern for the ethical conduct of its practitioners. Statements of ethics governing OD practice have been sponsored by the Organization Development Institute, the American Society for Training & Development, and a consortium of professional associations in OD. The consortium jointly sponsored an ethical code derived from a large-scale project at the Center for the Study of Ethics in the Professions at the Illinois Institute of Technology.
Ethical Dilemmas
Figure 17 presents a process model explaining how ethical dilemmas occur in OD. Antecedent conditions include an OD practitioner and a client system with different goals, values, needs, skills, and abilities. During the entry and contracting phase, these differences may or may not be addressed. If the contracting process is incomplete, the subsequent intervention process is subject to role conflict and role ambiguity. This produces five types of ethical dilemmas:
1. Misrepresentation: Occurs when OD practitioners claim that an intervention will produce results that are unreasonable for the change program or the situation. The client can also contribute by portraying inaccurate goals and needs.
📌 Example: In "The Undercover Change Agent" case, a consultant sold T-groups as the intervention that would solve organizational problems. After the president made a surprise visit and found the T-group in direct contradiction to his leadership concepts, the consultant was fired.
2. Misuse of Data: Occurs when information gathered during the OD process is used punitively. Large amounts of information are obtained during entry and diagnostic phases. It is a human tendency to use data to enhance a power position. To minimize this, practitioners should reach agreement upfront about how data will be used, reviewed periodically.
3. Coercion: Occurs when organization members are forced to participate in an OD intervention. People should have freedom to choose whether to participate. However, freedom to choose requires knowledge about OD. Many members have little information about OD interventions.
Coercion also involves manipulation and dependency. Kelman pointed out that behavior change "inevitably involves some degree of manipulation and control." The dilemma has two horns: (1) any attempt to change is manipulation, and (2) no formula exists to structure a change situation so that manipulation is totally absent.
Dependency issues arise because helping relationships invariably create dependency. A major goal in OD is to lessen clients' dependency on consultants. Approaches to resolve dependency include:
- Openly discussing how to handle the dependency problem
- Focusing on problem finding rather than solutions
- Changing the client's expectation from being helped to managing the problem
4. Value and Goal Conflict: Occurs when the purpose of the change effort is not clear or when client and practitioner disagree on how to achieve goals.
OD pioneer Gordon Lippitt suggested the real question is: assuming change will occur anyway, doesn't the consultant have a responsibility to guide the change in the most constructive fashion possible?
Argyris takes an even stronger stand, maintaining that OD practitioners' responsibilities are comparable to lawyers or physicians who may not refuse to perform their services. He suggests providing "first aid" as long as it doesn't compromise the consultant's values.
📌 Example: Argyris suggests that if the Ku Klux Klan asked for assistance and was genuinely interested in self-assessment, the consultant should be willing to help. If later the Klan's objectives proved dishonest, the consultant could withdraw without being compromised.
5. Technical Ineptness: Occurs when OD practitioners try to implement interventions for which they are not skilled or when the client attempts a change for which it is not ready. Selecting an appropriate intervention depends on careful diagnosis of the organization. Many consultants emphasize a favorite intervention (team building, total quality management, self-managed teams) based on their own values rather than organizational needs.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical points for exam understanding are: OD's foundational values stem from humanistic psychology and sensitivity training, emphasizing inquiry, democracy, and the legitimacy of feelings as data. The right goal of OD is to constantly redress the balance between individual freedom and organizational constraint. Practitioners face five main ethical dilemmas — misrepresentation, misuse of data, coercion, value and goal conflict, and technical ineptness — which can be prevented through clear contracting, upfront agreements about data use, education of clients, and careful diagnosis. Modern OD requires both social and political skills to manage relationships with external stakeholders who have competing values. The dependency issue in the helping relationship must be actively managed by redirecting client energy toward problem finding and self-management.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the two main value systems derived from sensitivity training, and what elements does each contain?
-
According to the lecture, what is "the right goal" for OD, and how does it address the tension between freedom and constraint?
-
List the five types of ethical dilemmas that can occur in OD practice as shown in Figure 17.
-
How does Kelman's analysis of the coercion dilemma present two horns of a problem, and what solutions does he propose?
-
What three approaches does the lecture suggest for resolving dependency issues in the consultant-client relationship?
📘 Lecture 14 — Entering and Contracting
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the initial steps of the Organization Development (OD) process: entering and contracting. It explains how these foundational activities define the problems or opportunities for development, establish a collaborative relationship between the OD practitioner and the client, and set the parameters for diagnosis, intervention, and evaluation. Understanding entering and contracting is critical because improper execution can lead to confusion, misalignment, and failure in subsequent OD phases.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the two main phases of entering and contracting in OD. First, it examines entering into an OD relationship, including clarifying the organizational issue, determining the relevant client team members, and selecting an appropriate OD practitioner. Second, it addresses developing a contract, focusing on mutual expectations, time and resources, and ground rules. The lecture concludes with a detailed application example of contracting at Charity Medical Center, illustrating how these concepts play out in a real healthcare setting.
📝 Lecture Summary
Entering into an OD Relationship
An OD process begins when an organization member contacts an OD practitioner about addressing an organizational issue. Determining whether to enter into an OD relationship involves clarifying the nature of the organization’s current functioning and the issue, identifying the relevant client system, and assessing the appropriateness of the particular OD practitioner. The practitioner may need to collect preliminary data about the organization, while the organization may gather information about the practitioner's competence.
💡 Why this matters: Proper entry ensures both parties have enough information to make informed choices about proceeding to develop a contract. Without this, subsequent efforts may be misdirected.
Clarifying the Organizational Issue
Organizations typically start with a presenting problem—the issue that caused them to consider an OD process. This may be specific (e.g., decreased market share, increased absenteeism) or general (e.g., “we’re growing too fast”). Often, the presenting problem includes an implied or stated solution. However, the presenting problem is often only a symptom of an underlying problem. For example, team conflict may result from ineffective reward systems, personality differences, inappropriate structure, or poor leadership.
Gaining clarity may require collecting preliminary data through examining company records and interviewing key members over a short period (a few hours to two days). This provides rudimentary knowledge to enable informed choices about proceeding.
🔑 Definition — Presenting problem: The issue that has caused an organization to consider an OD process, which may be a symptom of a deeper underlying problem.
📌 Example: A manager may say, "We need some team building," believing conflict is the problem. But deeper diagnosis might reveal that the conflict stems from an ineffective reward system or poor leadership—issues that team building alone cannot solve.
Determining the OD Team Members
A second activity is defining who the relevant client system or team members are—those organization members who can directly impact the change issue. Unless these members are identified and included in the entering and contracting process, they may withhold support and commitment. The complexity varies: if the issue is within a single unit, members of that unit must be included. If the issue crosses multiple units, hierarchical levels, or includes external parties (suppliers, customers), the team expands accordingly.
🔑 Definition — Client system: The group of organization members who are directly involved in or affected by the organizational issue and need to be included in the OD process.
📌 Example: For improving productivity in a unionized plant, the team must include union officials, not just managers and staff. Excluding them can cause the project to fail.
Selecting an OD Practitioner
The final entry activity is selecting an OD practitioner with appropriate expertise and experience. The late Gordon Lippitt suggested criteria including: ability to form sound interpersonal relationships, degree of focus on the problem, skills relative to the problem, extent the consultant clearly informs the client about their role, and membership in a professional association. References from other clients are highly important.
OD consulting is as much a person specialization as a task specialization. The practitioner must have both technical skills and the interpersonal competence to use themselves as an instrument of change. The most important question is: how effective has the person been in the past, with what kinds of organizations, using what techniques?
Consultants also bear responsibility for seeking an appropriate match. If a good match does not exist, practitioners should inform clients and help them find more suitable help.
🔑 Definition — Instrument of change: The OD practitioner’s ability to use their own personality, interpersonal competence, and technical skills as a tool to facilitate organizational change.
Developing a Contract
Contracting is a natural extension of the entering process that clarifies how the OD process will proceed. It establishes expectations of the parties, time and resources to be expended, and ground rules. The goal is to make a good decision about how to carry out the OD process.
Contracting can range from informal (a verbal agreement) to formal (a written document, especially with outside practitioners and government agencies). Regardless of formality, all OD processes require some explicit contracting.
🔑 Definition — Contracting: The step in OD that clarifies mutual expectations, time and resources, and ground rules for how the client and practitioner will work together.
Mutual Expectations
This part focuses on what each party expects to gain. The client states the services and outcomes expected from the practitioner (e.g., decreased turnover, higher job satisfaction). The OD practitioner states what they expect to gain, such as opportunities to try new interventions, report results to other potential clients, and receive appropriate compensation or recognition.
📌 Example: A client may state they want a diagnosis of poor productivity causes. The practitioner may expect access to workers to conduct that diagnosis—a critical point of negotiation.
Time and Resources
Both parties must commit time and resources. Essential requirements are things absolutely necessary for success (e.g., access to key people, enough time, commitment from certain individuals). Desirable requirements are nice to have but not absolutely necessary (e.g., written rather than verbal reports). Failure to make these requirements explicit can ruin an OD effort.
🔑 Definition — Essential requirements: Resources or conditions that are absolutely necessary for the change process to be successful. 🔑 Definition — Desirable requirements: Resources or conditions that would be helpful but are not absolutely necessary for success.
Ground Rules
The final part specifies how the client and practitioner will work together. Parameters include confidentiality, how the practitioner will handle personal or interpersonal issues, how to terminate the relationship, and whether the practitioner makes expert recommendations or helps the manager make decisions. For internal consultants, handling sensitive information and delivering bad news are especially important.
Application 1: Contracting at Charity Medical Center
Charity Medical Center (CMC), a 500-bed acute-care hospital, was part of Jefferson Hospital Corporation (JHC). CMC faced declining market share for six months. Senior management invited several consultants, including external OD practitioner John Murray, to present on implementing Total Quality Management (TQM).
John conducted initial interviews with vice president Joan Grace, who noted the hospital's main advantage was being a level-one trauma center but that the hospital's reputation for patient care was low. John gathered additional materials (mission statement, strategic plan, organization chart, performance analysis) and interviewed the hospital president, observed a nursing unit, and spoke with JHC's HR vice president.
Key findings from preliminary data:
- CMC actually comprised two hospitals (a 150-bed suburban hospital also reported to CMC's president)
- Last year's strategic plan included a budget for patient-care quality improvement
- JHC was in flux—policies were still being established
- Management and nursing staff were extremely busy with meetings
- A large consulting firm had been awarded a contract for "job redesign" in two departments
- Most nursing units operated under outdated management principles
John identified several issues: the relevant client was difficult to identify (Joan Grace was responsible, but the president, physicians, suburban hospital, and corporate office were key stakeholders); the job redesign contract seemed disconnected from the TQM effort and the market share problem; and the consulting firm's packaged approach conflicted with John's OD-based philosophy.
In his presentation, John described the quality movement, its application in healthcare, and emphasized that TQM requires thorough diagnosis, considerable resource commitment, and senior management involvement. He noted that TQM could address certain problems but wasn't designed to directly address broader performance issues like market share.
After the presentation, Joan asked John to discuss how to proceed. John identified several "knotty issues":
- The relationship between market share problems and a quality program was unclear
- Managers were frustrated by their inability to influence change due to busy schedules
- A quality improvement process might solve some problems but not all
John proposed:
- A thorough diagnosis of reasons for market-share decline, patient-care quality, and managerial frustration
- Postponing the job redesign effort
- A two-day management meeting to examine diagnostic information and decide about TQM
Joan was uncomfortable—the two-day meeting seemed difficult given everyone's busy schedules, there was a sense of urgency, and postponing the politically supported job redesign was sensitive. John explained that diagnostic information was the first step in TQM (data-based decision making), that proceeding without it could implement the wrong change, and that the two-day meeting would allow fact-based decision making. Regarding the job redesign, he argued that redesign without considering TQM would likely need to be redone.
After discussion, Joan agreed that the two-day meeting was important and that access to corporate officers, employees, managers, and physicians was reasonable. She needed to speak with the senior management team about postponing the job redesign. A week later, Joan called and agreed to John's requests, asking him to submit a written proposal.
💡 Why this matters: This case demonstrates that effective contracting requires the practitioner to negotiate essential conditions (diagnosis, management commitment, coordination with other efforts) even when they create discomfort. John Murray's willingness to challenge the client's assumptions and requests ultimately led to a more informed and appropriate change process.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The entering and contracting phase is the critical foundation of any OD effort—it defines the issues, identifies who needs to be involved, and establishes how the process will unfold. The presenting problem is often only a symptom of deeper issues, so preliminary data collection is essential to clarify the real organizational issue. Determining the relevant client system requires including all parties who can directly impact the change, including those from multiple units, hierarchical levels, and even external stakeholders. Selecting an OD practitioner should be based on references, track record, interpersonal skills, and a match between the practitioner's expertise and the organization's needs, not on packaged solutions. Effective contracting requires explicit agreement on mutual expectations, essential and desirable resources, and ground rules for confidentiality and decision-making, even when these create discomfort—as the Charity Medical Center case demonstrates.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the difference between a presenting problem and an underlying problem in OD, and why is it important to distinguish between them during the entering stage?
-
What are the three key activities involved in entering an OD relationship, and what is the purpose of each?
-
What are the three key areas that an OD contract should address, and what does each area cover?
-
In the Charity Medical Center case, what "knotty issues" did John Murray identify before agreeing to proceed, and what were his three requests to address them?
-
What criteria did Gordon Lippitt suggest for selecting an OD practitioner, and why is checking references particularly important?