📘 Lecture 5 — The Evolution of OD
📖 Overview: This lecture traces the historical evolution of Organization Development, focusing on the major intellectual stems that shaped modern OD practice. It covers Participative Management, Quality of Work Life initiatives, and Strategic Change, concluding with a comprehensive five-stage model for implementing organizational development programs. Understanding this evolution is critical for grasping why OD practitioners use specific interventions today.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture examines three major stems of OD evolution: Likert's Participative Management (System 1-4), the Quality of Work Life movement in two phases, and Strategic Change interventions. It then presents a detailed five-stage model of organization development covering anticipation of need, practitioner-client relationship, diagnosis, action planning, and self-renewal. The lecture concludes with discussions on continuous improvement and the role of power in OD.
📝 Lecture Summary
Participative Management
The intellectual advances from laboratory training and action research led to the belief that a human relations approach represented the one-best-way to manage organizations. This was exemplified by Likert's Participative Management (System 4) framework, which characterized organizations as having one of four management systems. System 1 (Exploitative authoritative) exhibits an autocratic, top-down approach with motivation based on punishment and occasional rewards — resulting in mediocre performance. System 2 (Benevolent authoritative) is similar but more paternalistic, allowing slightly more interaction within management-defined boundaries. System 3 (Consultative) increases employee interaction and consultation, though management still makes final decisions. System 4 (Participative group) is almost the opposite of System 1, designed around group methods of decision making and supervision, fostering high degrees of member involvement and participation. System 4 achieves high levels of productivity, quality, and member satisfaction.
Likert applied System 4 management using a survey-feedback process. The intervention started with members completing the Profile of Organizational Characteristics, which asked about present and ideal conditions of six features: leadership, motivation, communication, decisions, goals, and control. Data were fed back to work groups, who examined discrepancies between present and ideal situations using System 4 as the benchmark, then generated action plans.
🔑 Definition — System 4 (Participative Group System): Organizations designed around group methods of decision making and supervision that foster high member involvement and participation, achieving high productivity, quality, and satisfaction. 📐 Formula: None explicitly stated in text 📌 Example: An organization using System 4 would have work groups highly involved in setting goals, making decisions, improving methods, and appraising results, with communication occurring both laterally and vertically.
Quality of Work Life
The QWL contribution to OD can be described in two phases. The first phase (starting in the 1950s) aimed at better integrating technology and people, involving joint participation by unions and management in work design. The most distinguishing characteristic was the development of self-managing work groups — composed of multiskilled workers given autonomy and information to design and manage their own task performances.
Two definitions of QWL emerged initially. The first defined QWL in terms of people's reaction to work, focusing on individual outcomes like job satisfaction and mental health. The second defined QWL as an approach or method, synonymous with techniques like job enrichment, self-managed teams, and labor-management committees.
The second phase of QWL started in 1979, driven by growing international competition, especially from Japan. Programs expanded beyond work design to include reward systems, work flows, management styles, and the physical work environment. This phase added organizational efficiency to what had been primarily a human dimension concern. Quality circles — groups of employees trained in problem-solving methods who meet regularly to resolve work-environment, productivity, and quality-control concerns — became particularly popular.
Today, this second phase continues primarily under the banner of "employee involvement" (EI) rather than QWL. More recently, "employee empowerment" has been used interchangeably with EI, though EI is considered broader and less restrictive. The QWL approach has gained new momentum by joining forces with the total quality movement advocated by Deming & Juran, where the organization is viewed as a set of processes linked to quality, modeled through statistical techniques and improved continuously.
🔑 Definition — Quality Circle: Groups of employees trained in problem-solving methods who meet regularly to resolve work-environment, productivity, and quality-control concerns and develop more efficient ways of working. 📌 Example: A manufacturing company might form quality circles where workers from different departments meet weekly to identify production bottlenecks and propose solutions, implementing changes that improve both quality and efficiency.
Strategic Change
The strategic change stem is a recent influence on OD's evolution, arising as organizations and their environments became more complex and uncertain. Strategic change involves improving the alignment among an organization's environment, strategy, and organization design. Interventions include efforts to improve both the organization's relationship to its environment and the fit between its technical, political, and cultural systems.
The need for strategic change is usually triggered by major disruptions such as lifting of regulatory requirements, a technological breakthrough, or a new CEO from outside. One of the first applications was Richard Beckhard's open system planning, which proposed that an organization's environment and strategy could be described and analyzed. Since then, change agents have proposed various large-scale or strategic change models, each recognizing that strategic change involves multiple levels of the organization, culture change, is often driven from the top by powerful executives, and has important effects on performance.
💡 Why this matters: Implementing strategic change requires OD practitioners to be familiar with competitive strategy, finance, and marketing in addition to team building, action research, and survey feedback — significantly expanding OD's relevance to organizations.
🔑 Definition — Strategic Change: Improving the alignment among an organization's environment, strategy, and organization design, involving multiple levels and culture change, often driven from the top.
A Model for Organization Development
Organization development is a continuing process of long-term organizational improvement consisting of a series of stages, emphasizing a combination of individual, team, and organizational relationships. The primary difference between OD and other behavioral science techniques is the emphasis on viewing the organization as a total system of interacting and interrelated elements.
Many OD programs use the action research model, which involves collecting information about the organization, feeding it back to the client system, and developing action programs. The lecture presents a five-stage model of total organization development, where each stage depends on the preceding one.
Stage One: Anticipate a Need for Change
The organization must anticipate a need for change, beginning with the manager's perception that the organization is in a state of disequilibrium or needs improvement. This disequilibrium may result from growth, decline, or competitive, technological, legal, or social changes. There must be a felt need, because only felt needs convince individuals to adopt new ways.
📌 Example: A new AT&T CEO brought in the company's top 20 officers and told them the tradition of keeping people in top jobs as long as they didn't mess up was over, saying "You are going to be in my boat or out of it."
Stage Two: Develop the Practitioner-Client Relationship
After an organization recognizes a need for change and an OD practitioner enters, a relationship develops. The client is the person or organization being assisted. The exchange of expectations and obligations (formation of a psychological contract) depends on a good first impression or match between practitioner and client. The practitioner attempts to establish open communication, trust, and shared responsibility.
📌 Example: At one company, OD started at the vice-presidential level using internal practitioners; at another, an external practitioner from a university was invited by the industrial relations group.
Stage Three: The Diagnostic Phase
The practitioner and client gather data to understand client system problems — the diagnosis. One rule: question the client's diagnosis, as their perspective may be biased. The diagnostic phase determines the exact problem, identifies causal forces, and provides a basis for selecting change strategies.
📌 Example: A company with high employee turnover (34% vs. industry) used a questionnaire to discover employees felt it had become bureaucratic. OD programs then reduced turnover to 19%.
Stage Four: Action Plans, Strategies, and Techniques
The diagnostic phase leads to interventions aimed at resolving problems. Programs apply OD techniques such as Total Quality Management (TQM), job design, role analysis, goal setting, team building, and inter-group development. More time is typically spent on this stage than any other.
Stage Five: Self-Renewal, Monitor, and Stabilize
This final step monitors results and stabilizes desired changes. Each stage needs monitoring to gain feedback on member reactions. Once a problem is corrected, means must be devised to ensure new behavior is stabilized and internalized — otherwise the system regresses. The client system needs to develop the capability to maintain innovation without outside support.
Continuous Improvement
In today's environment, there are only two kinds of companies — those that are changing and those going out of business. The five-stage model shows how different OD methods are used to continuously improve performance. As an OD program stabilizes, the need for the practitioner should decrease. If the client moves toward independence and self-renewal capacity, termination is easily accomplished.
An important issue is whether the practitioner can deal effectively with power and its use. Hierarchical organizations rely on power, and political infighting is a reality. OD practitioners act as facilitators to promote team problem solving and collaboration, encouraging values like trust, openness, and consensus. While OD is not a political/power intervention, practitioners must be aware of politics and use problem-solving approaches compatible with power-oriented situations.
📌 Example: A study by Eisenhardt and Bourgeois found that politics influence decisions and political conflicts within top management teams are associated with poor firm performance.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that OD evolved through three major intellectual stems: Participative Management (Likert's System 4), Quality of Work Life (from job enrichment to employee involvement), and Strategic Change (aligning environment, strategy, and design). The five-stage model of OD — anticipate need, develop practitioner-client relationship, diagnose, implement action plans, and self-renew — provides a systematic framework for any change effort. Students must remember that System 4 represents the ideal participative benchmark, that QWL evolved from work design to broader organizational improvement under the banner of employee involvement, and that strategic change requires OD practitioners to master business skills beyond traditional behavioral science. Crucially, successful OD requires recognizing power dynamics while maintaining a facilitative, non-political role, and ensuring the client system develops self-renewal capacity so changes are sustained without external dependency.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four management systems in Likert's framework, and how does System 4 differ from System 1?
- What were the two phases of the Quality of Work Life movement, and what drove the shift from the first to the second phase?
- What triggers the need for strategic change, and what three elements does strategic change seek to align?
- What are the five stages of the organization development model, and why is each dependent on the preceding stage?
- Why must OD practitioners be aware of organizational power and politics, even though OD is not considered a political intervention?
📘 Lecture 6 — The Organization Culture
📖 Overview: This lecture explores organizational culture as the "personality" of an organization, examining both its visible and invisible manifestations. It explains how culture is created, maintained, and changed, and why understanding cultural norms is critical for organizational effectiveness and employee success. The lecture emphasizes that culture can be a powerful hidden asset or a dangerous liability.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture defines organizational culture and its visible/invisible manifestations, explains the role of norms (pivotal and peripheral), describes the socialization process for new employees, examines how individuals adjust to cultural norms, discusses psychological contracts between employees and organizations, and presents a real-world case study (Setpoint) demonstrating the tangible value of corporate culture.
📝 Lecture Summary
Organizational Culture: Definition and Overview
Organizational culture is the personality of the organization, comprised of the assumptions, values, norms, and tangible signs (artifacts) of organization members and their behaviors. Culture is difficult to express distinctly, but everyone knows it when they sense it. For example, the culture of a large for-profit corporation is quite different from that of a hospital or a university. You can tell an organization's culture by looking at the arrangement of furniture, what members brag about, what they wear, and similar cues.
🔑 Definition — Organizational Culture: "The culture of an organization is its customary and traditional way of thinking and doing things, which is shared to a greater or lesser degree by all its members, and which new members must learn and at least partially accept, in order to be accepted into service in the firm. Culture covers a wide range of behavior: the methods of production; job skills and technical knowledge; attitudes towards discipline and punishment; the custom and habit of managerial behavior; its way of doing business; the methods of payment; the values placed on different types of work; beliefs in democratic living and joint consultation."
Culture shows up in both visible and invisible ways. The surface layer of culture includes easy-to-observe manifestations like dress code, work environment, perks, and titles. However, the far more powerful aspects of culture are invisible. The cultural core is composed of beliefs, values, standards, paradigms, worldviews, moods, internal conversations, and private conversations of the people in the group. This invisible foundation underlies all actions and decisions within a team, department, or organization.
Visible Manifestations of Culture: Dress Code, Work Environment, Benefits, Perks, Conversations, Work/Life Balance, Titles & Job Description, Organizational Structure
Invisible Manifestations of Culture: Values, Private Conversations (with self or confidants), Invisible Rules, Attitudes, Beliefs, Worldviews, Moods and Emotions, Unconscious Interpretations, Standards of Behavior, Paradigms, Assumptions
💡 Why this matters: Business leaders often assume their company's vision, values, and strategic priorities are synonymous with culture. However, these may only be "words hanging on a plaque on the wall." What creates embodiment (or lack thereof) is the actual culture that permeates employees' psyches, bodies, conversations, and actions.
Culture is created and constantly reinforced on a daily basis through conversations, symbols, rituals, written materials, and body language. Small, mundane actions and behaviors create and can shift culture. Failure to discuss values, purpose, and rules often leads to a culture at cross purposes with the group's stated intentions. Poor communication creates confusion and often a crisis of meaninglessness.
Since culture is created every time a group of people comes together to form a team, a company will have many sub-cultures within its main culture. For example, marketing and technology teams may have different worldviews, jargon, work hours, and ways of doing things. A big challenge for today's company is to create a strong, cohesive corporate culture that pulls all sub-cultures together.
Corporate culture starts when the organization begins and develops as it grows. It controls how people interact with each other and stakeholders outside the organization. Over time, culture changes as people come and go. In a well-established company, the culture is so strong that even new top management may not be able to change it. Employees who feel comfortable with the company culture will stay; those who don't will leave or underperform.
Culture is extremely powerful. The rules of the game, what behavior is ethical and accepted, the mood of the organization, and employee enthusiasm are all contained in culture. Culture can be a powerful, hidden asset or a liability — a time-bomb waiting to go off. If leadership has not proactively created a corporate culture to support the company's purpose, the culture is likely a hidden liability.
Every time people come together with a shared purpose, culture is automatically created out of the combined thoughts, energies, and attitudes of the group.
New employees, consultants, or visitors who cannot adapt to corporate culture have slight chances for success. Members of the culture will reject the person outright and work against them. This happens because people tend to prefer conformity in their culture, which represents a harmonious environment where behavior and actions are predictable. Most people have a deeply rooted desire for order and stability, which conformity provides.
Culture determines a company's dress code, work environment, work hours, rules for getting ahead and getting promoted, how the business world is viewed, what is valued, who is valued, and much more.
Norms
Norms are organized and shared ideas regarding what members should do and feel, how behavior should be regulated, and what sanctions should be applied when behavior does not coincide with social expectations. The values and behaviors of every organization are unique. Some patterns of behavior may be functional and facilitate organizational goals; others may inhibit or restrict goal accomplishment.
🔑 Definition — Pivotal Norms: Norms essential to accomplishing the organization's objectives. 🔑 Definition — Peripheral Norms: Norms that support and contribute to pivotal norms but are not essential to the organization's objectives.
For example, dress codes enforced Monday through Thursday are probably peripheral in light of Friday's casual dress day. Pivotal and peripheral norms constantly confront individuals in an organization, and they must decide whether to conform. The pressure to conform varies, allowing individuals some degree of freedom depending on how they perceive rewards or punishments.
The Socialization Process
Even with effective recruiting, new employees must adjust to organizational culture. Because they are unaware of the culture, new employees are likely to disagree with or question existing customs and values.
🔑 Definition — Socialization: The process that adapts employees to the organization's culture.
Example: The socialization of employees at Procter and Gamble Co. starts at an early age because employees often begin their careers there and grow up together. The culture is resistant to new ideas and insular. P&G promotes from within, is located in Cincinnati where employees live near one another, and CEO Alan Lafley admitted, "I am worried that I will ask the organization to change ahead of its understanding, capability, and commitment."
New Employee Expectations
To function effectively, managers and members must be aware of the organization's norms — how sharply they are defined and how strongly they are enforced. Entry into a new situation often results in anxiety or stress. The less an individual can relate the new situation to previous situations, the greater the feelings of anxiety and discomfort. The more the individual can meet expectations, the less the discomfort.
Some organizations assign mentors to new employees. Example: W. L. Gore & Associates assigns each new hire a sponsor who acts as a mentor. Twenty percent of Gore's associates are sponsors, and the sponsor is typically the person with the most at stake in making the new associate successful. The philosophy is that if you sponsor someone, you want them to be successful, so you offer them opportunities. If the new associate is successful, the team will be successful, and the company will be successful.
Encounter Organization's Culture
Organizational culture provides a way for members to meet and get along. Three important aspects of socialization when joining an organization are:
- Deciding who is a member and who is not
- Developing an informal understanding of behavioral norms
- Separating friends from enemies
To work together effectively, individuals need to understand power, status, rewards, and sanctions for specific behaviors. While individual employees experience a new situation, the organization may be attempting to influence them. If new members come expecting a certain set of norms and those expectations reflect actual norms, the integration process is relatively painless.
Adjustment to Cultural Norms
New members often find norms unclear, confusing, and restrictive. They may react in different ways:
- Conformity (extreme): Accepting all norms, resulting in uniformity, stagnation, non-responsiveness, and loss of creativeness
- Rebellion (extreme): Rejecting all values or leaving the organization
- Creative Individualism (ideal): Accepting pivotal norms while seriously questioning peripheral norms
Creative individualism is the ideal behavior for a healthy and effective organization, but it is often difficult for newcomers to correctly determine which norms are peripheral and which are pivotal. What is pivotal in one department may be peripheral in another. Since norms are changing and dynamic, organization members must have awareness to discern these differences.
Results
Only the more healthy organizations allow members to challenge their norms. The aim of Organization Development (OD) is to develop an organizational climate appropriate to the organization's mission and members. OD involves changing the culture so that more effective means of interacting, relating, and problem-solving result. OD seeks to develop the organization to the point where it feels comfortable allowing members to openly examine both pivotal and peripheral norms, with the ultimate goal of building a more effective organization.
In both types of organizations, each person tends to:
- Separate more important from less important goals
- Develop ways to measure their accomplishments
- Create explanations for why goals may not always be met
Psychological Contracts
🔑 Definition — Psychological Contract: An unwritten agreement between individuals and the organization of which they are members. It describes certain expectations that the organization has of the individual and the individual's expectations of the organization.
Because both parties are growing and changing, the contract must be open-ended so that old and new issues can be renegotiated.
The organization has certain expectations of members (being on time, quality/quantity of work, loyalty, appearance). For a lasting, healthy relationship, individuals must comply with these expectations. Unfulfilled expectations often result in high turnover, absenteeism, sabotage, and worker alienation.
Similarly, the individual has expectations of the organization (work experience, security, advancement, social relationships, remuneration). For the individual to be satisfied and stay, the organization must meet these expectations.
When either party's expectations are not adequately satisfied, friction and difficulties develop. If unsolved, these problems may culminate in the individual leaving. All too often, the problem is "solved by not solving it" — both parties continue with a tenuous, unharmonious relationship.
Sometimes the psychological contract does not address certain key expectations. Unstated or assumed expectations can lead to an organization of individuals who feel cheated or managers disappointed in subordinates. To avoid misunderstandings, both parties should formulate a psychological contract that can be continually renegotiated.
OD in Practice: What's your culture worth?
Case Study: Setpoint
The founders of Setpoint had a good idea of the company culture they wanted to build, but didn't realize it would become one of the company's most valuable assets. Setpoint was a custom-manufacturing company with about 30 employees, designing and building factory-automation equipment.
Steve Peterson, owner of Peterson Inc. (about 300 employees), visited Setpoint. During a tour with CEO Joe Knight, Peterson noticed a large whiteboard in the shop with about 20 rows and 10 columns of numbers forming a table. When asked about it, Knight explained it tracked projects and whether they were making money.
Knight called a technician to explain the board. The technician walked through calculating gross profit earned the previous week on each project, explained gross profit per hour, discussed the ratio of overall gross profit to operating expenses (targeting about 2.0), and showed complete understanding of the company's financial position.
Peterson was amazed: "I could see that the board was a cherished possession... the people on the shop floor had it down like that. It was their scoreboard. It was the way they could tell if they were winning or losing."
Merger Negotiation: Shortly after, Peterson began negotiating to acquire Setpoint — not for market share, earnings, cash flow, or strategic advantage, but for their corporate culture. Peterson was willing to pay a substantial price for that particular type of culture.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Organizational culture is the invisible energy field that determines how people think, behave, and interact in an organization — it manifests visibly in dress, environment, and perks, but its real power lies in invisible beliefs, values, and assumptions. Norms are the shared expectations that regulate behavior, with pivotal norms being essential to organizational goals and peripheral norms being supportive but non-essential. New employees undergo socialization to adapt to culture, ideally achieving creative individualism where they accept pivotal norms while questioning peripheral ones. The psychological contract is an unwritten agreement of mutual expectations between individuals and organization — unfulfilled expectations destroy employee engagement and organizational health. The Setpoint case demonstrates that corporate culture can be so valuable that companies are willing to pay substantial premiums to acquire it.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the visible and invisible manifestations of organizational culture, and why are the invisible aspects more powerful?
- Distinguish between pivotal norms and peripheral norms, providing an example of each.
- What is creative individualism and why is it considered the ideal adjustment to cultural norms?
- Define psychological contract and explain what happens when the organization's or individual's expectations are unfulfilled.
- How did Setpoint's corporate culture become a valuable asset worth acquiring, and what did the whiteboard demonstrate about the employees' relationship with the organization?
📘 Lecture 7 — The Nature of Planned Change
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of planned organizational change and its central role in Organization Development (OD). It explores three major theories of planned change—Lewin’s Change Model, the Action Research Model, and contemporary adaptations—with a detailed application of Lewin’s model through the British Airways case study, demonstrating how organizations can systematically manage transformation.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by distinguishing planned change from unplanned change and defining Organization Development as directed at increasing organizational effectiveness. It then presents Lewin’s three-stage change model (Unfreezing, Movement, Refreezing) across three organizational levels (individual, structural, and climate/interpersonal). Detailed sub-processes for each stage are explained, including disconfirmation, psychological safety, identification with role models, and personal/relational refreezing. Finally, the British Airways privatization case is used to illustrate how each stage of Lewin’s model was applied in practice over a five-year period.
📝 Lecture Summary
Theories of Planned change
All approaches to OD rely on a theory about planned change. The three major theories of organization change that have received considerable attention in the field are: Lewin's change model, the action research model, and contemporary adaptations of action research.
Lewin’s Change Model
According to the open-systems view, organizations—like living creatures—tend to be homeostatic, or continuously working to maintain a steady state. This helps explain why organizations require external impetus to initiate change and why that change will be resisted even when necessary. Organizational change can occur at three levels, each requiring different change strategies:
- Changing the individuals who work in the organization—their skills, values, attitudes, and eventually behavior.
- Changing various organizational structures and systems—reward systems, reporting relationships, work design.
- Directly changing the organizational climate or interpersonal style—how open people are, how conflict is managed, how decisions are made.
According to Lewin, a pioneer in social psychology of organizations, the first step of any change process is to unfreeze the present pattern of behavior as a way of managing resistance to change. Depending on the organizational level, unfreezing might involve selectively promoting or terminating employees (individual level), developing experiential training programs (structural level), or providing data-based feedback (climate level).
The second step, movement, involves making the actual changes that will move the organization to another level of response. On the individual level, people behave differently with new skills. On the structural level, changes occur in reporting relationships and reward systems. On the climate level, behavior patterns indicate greater interpersonal trust and openness.
The final stage, refreezing, involves stabilizing or institutionalizing these changes by establishing systems that make these behavioral patterns “relatively secure against change.” This may involve redesigning recruitment processes or ensuring new behaviors become operating norms.
🔑 Definition — Homeostatic: Continuously working to maintain a steady state, like organizations resisting change even when it is necessary.
Stage 1: Unfreezing
Three ways of unfreezing an organization are: i. Disconfirmation ii. Induction of guilt or anxiety iii. Creation of psychological safety
i. Disconfirmation or lack of confirmation: Organizational members are not likely to embrace change unless they experience some need for it. Unfreezing involves reducing those forces maintaining the organization’s behavior at its present level. By introducing information that shows discrepancies between behaviors desired by organization members and those currently exhibited, members can be motivated to engage in change activities.
ii. Induction of guilt or anxiety: This is establishing a gap between what is current but not working well and some future goal that would make things work better. When people recognize a gap between what is and what would be better, they will be motivated via guilt or anxiety to reduce the gap. But disconfirmation and induction alone are not enough.
iii. Creation of psychological safety: To face disconfirmation and experience guilt or anxiety, people must believe that moving will not bring humiliation or loss of self-esteem. People must still feel worthy, psychologically safe. The consultant must take care that when people admit something is wrong, they will not be punished or humiliated.
Stage 2: Moving (Changing)
The second step, movement, involves making the actual changes. On the individual level, people behave differently with new skills. On the structural level, changes occur in organizational structures and reward systems. On the climate level, behavior patterns indicate greater interpersonal trust and openness.
Two main processes for accomplishing this stage: i. Identification with a new role model ii. Scanning the environment for new information
i. Identification with a new role model, mentor, boss, or consultant to “begin to see things from that other person’s point of view. If we see another point of view operating in a person to whom we pay attention and respect, we can begin to imagine that point of view as something to consider for ourselves.”
ii. Scanning the environment for new, relevant information. For example, a consultant working with a chairman and president might quote other chairman-president/CEO models from other client organizations—some that worked well and some that did not—bringing new relevant information to help them move forward.
Stage 3: Refreezing
This final stage involves stabilizing or institutionalizing changes by establishing systems (such as norms, policies, and structures) that make behavioral patterns “relatively secure against change.” The refreezing stage may involve:
- Redesigning the organization’s recruitment process to increase likelihood of hiring applicants who share the new management style and value system.
- Ensuring new behaviors become operating norms, reward systems reinforce those behaviors, and a new participative management style predominates.
This stage can be seen in two parts: i. Personal refreezing ii. Relational refreezing
i. Personal refreezing is the process of taking the new, changed way of doing things and making it fit comfortably into one’s total self-concept. This involves practice—trying out new roles and behaviors, getting feedback, and making adjustments until the new way feels reasonably comfortable.
ii. Relational refreezing is the process of assuring that the client’s new behavior will fit with significant others. When one person changes in a system, others must change as well to maintain the relationship. This involves openly engaging with others about the new way of doing things to help them see why the change is better than the old way.
Case Example: British Airways
In 1982, Margaret Thatcher’s government decided to convert British Airways (BA) from government ownership to private ownership. BA had regularly required large subsidies (almost $900 million in 1982). Growing deregulation of international air traffic placed BA at even greater risk of financial losses. To privatize, BA needed to become profitable. The internal changes transformed BA’s culture from “bureaucratic and militaristic” to “service-oriented and market-driven.”
Table: British Airways Success Story
| Metric | 1982 | 1987 |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Government | Private |
| Profit/loss | -$900 million | $435 million |
| Culture | Bureaucratic and militaristic | Service-oriented and market-driven |
Unfreezing in BA: The first step involved a massive reduction in the worldwide BA workforce (from 59,000 to 37,000). Within a year, all BA performance indices improved. The downsizing reduced hierarchical levels, giving more autonomy to operating people. No one was actually laid off—early retirement with substantial financial settlements was used. A second major change occurred in BA’s top management: Lord John King was appointed chairman, and Sir Colin Marshall was appointed CEO. Marshall had a marketing background, unlike his predecessors who were retired Royal Air Force officers. Marshall decided BA’s strategy should be to become “the World’s Favorite Airline.” To support unfreezing, “Putting People First” training was introduced, aiming to challenge prevailing wisdom about how things were done at BA.
Movement in BA: Marshall hired Nicholas Georgiades, a psychologist, as director of human resources. Georgiades developed specific tactics and programs including “Managing People First” and “Leading the Service Business”—experiential programs with heavy doses of individual feedback. These programs aimed to identify dysfunctional management styles and develop a new, open, participative management style. On the structural level, diagonal task forces composed of individuals from different functions and levels were used extensively. A bottom-up, less centralized budgeting process was introduced. Redefining BA’s business as service (rather than transportation) represented a critical shift on the climate level. Off-site team-building meetings were chosen to deal with these issues.
An important element was acceptance of the concept of “emotional labor” that Georgiades championed—the high energy levels required to provide quality service in an uncertain environment. Recognition that service is emotionally draining is critical to developing systems of emotional support. Another support mechanism was retraining traditional personnel staff to become internal change agents. A new bonus system demonstrated management’s commitment to sharing financial gains.
Refreezing in BA: Continued involvement of top management ensured changes became “fixed.” People who exemplified new BA values were more likely to be promoted. Additional programs like “Open Learning” and “Top Flight Academies” (including one leading to an MBA) were introduced. A new performance appraisal system based on both behavior and results was created to emphasize customer service and subordinate development. A performance-based compensation system was installed. Task forces continued to be used to solve emerging problems. Attention was paid to BA’s symbols—new uniforms, refurbished aircraft, and a new corporate coat of arms with the motto “We fly to serve.” Unique development was the creation of teams for consistent cabin-crew staffing. Continued use of data feedback on management practices throughout the system was maintained.
📌 Example — BA Unfreezing: BA reduced workforce from 59,000 to 37,000 employees. Within one year, on-time departures and arrivals improved, out-of-service aircraft decreased, lost bags decreased. Hierarchical levels were reduced, giving operating staff more autonomy. No layoffs occurred—early retirement with settlements was used.
📌 Example — BA Movement: Marshall hired Nicholas Georgiades as HR director. Georgiades created “Managing People First” training for middle and senior managers. These experiential programs provided individual behavioral feedback. Diagonal task forces were formed from different functions and levels to plan changes in MIS, staffing, and uniforms.
📌 Example — BA Refreezing: A new performance appraisal system was created based on both behavior and results, emphasizing customer service. A performance-based compensation system was installed. “Top Flight Academies” were established, including an executive program leading to an MBA. New uniforms, refurbished aircraft, and a new coat of arms (“We fly to serve”) were introduced.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is Lewin’s three-stage change model: Unfreezing (creating readiness for change through disconfirmation, anxiety induction, and psychological safety), Movement (actual change through identification with role models and environmental scanning), and Refreezing (stabilizing change through personal and relational integration). Change must be managed across three levels simultaneously: individual (skills and attitudes), structural (systems and rewards), and climate/interpersonal (trust and openness). The British Airways case demonstrates that successful transformation requires top management commitment, compassionate handling of resistance (like downsizing with early retirement), systematic training programs, and institutionalization of new values through performance systems and symbols. Emotional labor—the psychological cost of service work—must be recognized and supported with peer groups and internal change agents.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the three stages of Lewin’s Change Model, and what is the main purpose of each stage?
-
What are the three ways to unfreeze an organization, and why is psychological safety necessary for change to begin?
-
What is the difference between personal refreezing and relational refreezing, and why are both necessary for lasting change?
-
How did British Airways apply the unfreezing stage through workforce reduction, and what specific measures were taken to minimize pain during downsizing?
-
What was the concept of “emotional labor” introduced by Georgiades at BA, and what support mechanisms were created to address it?