📘 Lecture 15 — Diagnosing Organizations
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the concept of organizational diagnosis, moving beyond the medical model to a collaborative process between consultants and organization members. It introduces the critical task/process distinction, the diagnostic process cycle, performance gap analysis, and the open-systems model as a foundational framework for understanding organizational functioning.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining the task/process relationship and its importance in diagnosis, then defines what diagnosis means in organization development. It describes the cyclical diagnostic process, introduces the performance gap concept and gap analysis, discusses the need for diagnostic models, and concludes with the open-systems model and a case study of the Old Family Bank.
📝 Lecture Summary
Diagnosing Organizations
The lecture opens by noting that diagnosis is medical jargon for the gap between sickness and health. As biology grew in the late 19th century, doctors became industrial engineers of the human body, claiming expertise by factoring in every relevant variable. Similarly, in industrial science, diagnosis is conceived as identifying and closing gaps between how things are and how they should be.
🔑 Definition — Task/Process Relationship: The subtle interplay between ends and means, methods and goals. A task is concrete, observable, and thing-oriented—referring to what is to be done. Process refers to how—reflecting perceptions, attitudes, and reasoning. Process diagnosticians ask “Why aren’t we making progress?” rather than when, where, or how many.
📌 Example: Task/process thinking is likened to the Old Woman/Young Woman visual paradox—you cannot see both at once but can learn to shift between them. Through trained observation, you can diagnose linkages between task and process, such as when work stops, determining what is not being talked about.
💡 Why this matters: Left-brain diagnostic thinking leads people to focus on task (the compass) and consider process (the altimeter) a frill. Group dynamics’ great contribution was its relentless gaze at process as inseparable from task, the diagnoser inseparable from the diagnosis, and a leader’s effectiveness inseparable from follower contributions.
What is Diagnosis?
Diagnosis is the process of understanding how the organization is currently functioning, providing information necessary to design change interventions. It generally follows successful entry and contracting, which set the stage for diagnosis by helping OD practitioners and client members jointly determine organizational issues to focus on, how to collect and analyze data, and how to work together to develop action steps.
🔑 Definition — Diagnosis in OD: A collaborative process between organization members and the OD consultant to collect pertinent information, analyze it, and draw conclusions for action planning and intervention. It may be aimed at uncovering causes of specific problems, understanding effective processes, or assessing overall functioning to discover areas for future development.
The lecture emphasizes two critical distinctions from the medical model:
- Collaborative nature: Both organization members and change agents should be involved in discovering determinants of effectiveness and developing appropriate interventions.
- Not problem-focused only: Diagnosis can be problem oriented (seeking reasons for problems) or development oriented (assessing current functioning to discover areas for future development).
Organizational diagnosis examines two broad areas:
- Interacting sub-elements: Divisions, departments, products, and relationships between them, including comparisons of top, middle, and lower levels of management.
- Organizational processes: Communication networks, team problem-solving, decision-making, leadership and authority styles, goal-setting and planning methods, and management of conflict and competition.
The Process
Diagnosis is a cyclical process involving data gathering, interpretations, and identification of problem areas and possible action programs.
📐 Formula — The Diagnostic Process (9 steps):
- Preliminary identification of possible problem areas (often brings out symptoms)
- Gather data based on preliminary problems
- Categorize data
- Analyze and present data to client in feedback session
- Determine if enough data are available
- Jointly diagnose and identify likely problem areas
- Determine client’s level of motivation to work on problems
- Identify target systems and design change strategy
- Monitor results to determine degree of change versus desired goals
The Performance Gap
Performance gap is the difference between what the organization could do by virtue of its opportunity in its environment and what it actually does.
🔑 Definition — Gap Analysis: A method where data are collected on the actual state of the organization and the ideal or desired state (where the organization should be). The gap or discrepancy between actual state and ideal forms a basis for diagnosis and intervention design.
The gap may result from:
- Ineffective performance by internal units
- Competitive changes or new innovations
- Failure to adapt to changes in the external environment
Important problems are often hidden or obscure, while obvious problems are relatively unimportant. A performance gap may continue for some time before recognition, or its awareness may unfreeze functions most in need of change.
📌 Example — Self-assessment version of gap analysis uses questionnaires to gather information in four key areas:
- The organization’s strengths
- What can be done to take advantage of strengths
- The organization’s weaknesses
- What can be done to alleviate weaknesses
In organizational diagnosis, the practitioner looks for causality—a cause-effect relationship where change in one factor (e.g., compensation) will cause change in another (e.g., productivity). The client is often aware of symptoms (declining sales, high turnover, loss of market share), but the practitioner tries to identify what factors are causing the problem.
The Need for Diagnostic Models
Diagnostic models are conceptual frameworks that describe relationships among different features of the organization, its context, and its effectiveness. They point out what areas to examine and what questions to ask in assessing how an organization is functioning.
⚠️ Caution: All models represent simplifications of reality and choose certain features as critical, which can result in biased diagnosis. For example, a model relating team effectiveness to handling interpersonal conflict would focus on relationships, decision-making, and conflict resolution—ignoring skill composition, task complexity, and member interdependencies.
Sources of diagnostic models include:
- Thousands of articles and books discussing how organizations function (employee stress, leadership, motivation, group dynamics, job design, career development)
- OD practitioners’ experience in organizations (only a small part translated into diagnostic models)
The lecture introduces a general framework based on the systems perspective prevalent in OD today.
Open-Systems Model
Systems theory describes properties and behaviors of systems (organizations, groups, people). Systems are unitary wholes composed of parts or subsystems; the system integrates parts into a functioning unit.
🔑 Definition — Open-Systems Model: The general diagnostic model based on systems theory that underlies most of OD. Open systems (organizations and people) exchange information and resources with their environments and are influenced by external forces.
Key Properties of Open Systems:
- Hierarchical ordering: Each higher level comprises lower-level systems (society → organizations → groups → individuals)
- Inputs, transformations, and outputs
- Boundaries
- Feedback
- Equifinality
- Alignment
Case: The Old Family Bank
📌 Example: A large bank studied turnover, absenteeism, and productivity. Two departments tied for lowest turnover and absenteeism but had opposite productivity rankings:
- Check-sorting department: Ranked #1 most productive despite undesirable working conditions (hot in summer, cold in winter, working alone, rotating breaks). Workers showed high loyalty to the company, felt wages and benefits were competitive, and were committed to high performance.
- Data-processing department: Ranked last in productivity despite perfect working conditions (air-conditioned, quiet, comfortable). Workers liked each other but felt management emphasized production over staff units, and pay gaps did not reflect skill differences.
Interview Data: Check-sorting workers showed loyalty to the company; data-processing workers displayed little loyalty to the company despite high cohesion among themselves.
Case Analysis Form:
Problems:
- Macro: Lack of loyalty to entire bank could affect effectiveness; poor process for setting pay policies
- Micro: Data-processing team not loyal to larger organization; personnel believe management doesn't appreciate them; potentially underpaid compared to similar workers
Causes:
- Data-processing workers don't recognize all factors affecting pay and rewards
- They may have access to more company-wide information without understanding how managers make decisions based on that data
Systems Affected: The attitude of data-processing personnel likely affects the entire bank’s operations
Alternatives:
- Gather more data to confirm/disprove initial diagnosis
- Use force-field analysis to better understand the problem
- Check regional employment data for competitive pay; adjust if warranted
- Meet with the department to explain pay-setting procedures and rationale
Recommendations: All alternatives can be undertaken
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts to remember are: diagnosis in OD is a collaborative process, not a medical one where an expert prescribes solutions—both consultant and client jointly discover issues and develop interventions. The task/process distinction is fundamental: task refers to what is done, while process refers to how it is done, and effective diagnosis requires shifting attention between both like a pilot scanning instruments. The diagnostic process is cyclical with nine steps, and the performance gap (difference between actual and ideal states) provides a basis for gap analysis and intervention design. Diagnostic models are simplifications that focus on certain features and can create bias, so they must be chosen carefully, and the open-systems model with its key properties (inputs, transformations, outputs, boundaries, feedback, equifinality, alignment) provides the foundational framework for most OD diagnosis.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key differences between diagnosis in organization development and the medical model of diagnosis?
- What is the task/process relationship, and why can't we see both aspects simultaneously according to the lecture?
- List the nine steps of the diagnostic process in order.
- What is a performance gap, and what are three possible causes of such a gap?
- What are the key properties of open systems, and why is the open-systems model important for organizational diagnosis?
📘 Lecture 16 — Organization as Open Systems
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of organizations as open systems that continuously exchange information and resources with their environments. It explains why understanding external forces is crucial for explaining internal organizational behavior, and it presents the key properties of open systems along with a comprehensive model for diagnosing organizations at multiple levels.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of open vs. closed systems, then explores five key properties of open systems: inputs/transformations/outputs, boundaries, feedback, equifinality, and alignment. It then introduces a comprehensive model for diagnosing organizational systems at three levels (organization, group, and individual), with a deep dive into organization-level diagnosis including inputs like general environment and industry structure (Porter's five forces), design components, and the strategic orientation.
📝 Lecture Summary
Organization as Open Systems
Systems vary in how open they are to their environments. Open systems, such as organizations and people, exchange information and resources with their environments and are influenced by external forces like raw material availability, customer demands, and government regulations. Open systems display a hierarchical ordering: society comprises organizations, organizations comprise groups (departments), and groups comprise individuals. Despite differences in size and complexity, open systems share common properties, including inputs, transformations, and outputs; boundaries; feedback; equifinality; and alignment.
Inputs, Transformations, and Outputs
Any organizational system is composed of three related parts: inputs, transformations, and outputs. Inputs consist of human or other resources (information, energy, materials) coming into the system from the external environment. For example, a manufacturer acquires raw materials from an outside supplier. Transformations are the processes of converting inputs into outputs, carried out by a production or operations function composed of both social (people and work relationships) and technological (tools, techniques, methods) components. Banks transform deposits into mortgage loans; schools transform students into educated people. Outputs are the results of what is transformed and sent to the environment. Group health insurance companies receive premiums and medical bills, transform them through physician visits, and export treated patients and payments.
🔑 Definition — Open System: A system that exchanges information and resources with its external environment and cannot completely control its own behavior.
Boundaries
Boundaries are the borders or limits of a system. Closed systems have relatively rigid and impenetrable boundaries, whereas open systems have far more permeable borders. Defining boundaries in social systems is difficult because there is continuous inflow and outflow through them. For example, when a fire alarm sounds in Sweden, the address is put into a computer terminal, and the information is stored in Cleveland, Ohio—challenging traditional notions of organizational boundaries. The definition of a boundary is somewhat arbitrary because social systems have multiple subsystems. The boundaries used for studying leadership may differ from those used to study intergroup dynamics. The permeability of boundaries varies from fixed to diffuse; a police force has more rigid boundaries than political parties.
🔑 Definition — Boundary: The border or limit of a system that distinguishes it from its environment; in open systems these are permeable.
Feedback
Feedback is information regarding the actual performance or results of the system, but only when it is used to control the future functioning of the system. Feedback can maintain the system in a steady state (e.g., keeping an assembly line at a certain speed) or help the organization adapt to changing circumstances. McDonald’s uses strict feedback processes to ensure meals are consistent across outlets. A salesperson reporting poor sales may insist on organizational change, and a market research study may lead to changes in an advertising campaign.
🔑 Definition — Feedback: Information about actual performance or results that is used to control the future functioning of the system.
Equifinality
Equifinality suggests that similar results may be achieved with different initial conditions and in many different ways. In closed systems, a direct cause-and-effect relationship exists between initial conditions and final state (e.g., pushing a computer's "on" switch powers it up). Biological and social systems operate differently. This concept means a manager can use varying degrees of inputs and transform them in various ways to obtain satisfactory outputs. The function of management is not to seek a single rigid solution but to develop a variety of satisfactory options. Organizations and departments providing routine services, like AT&T and MCIWorldCom's long-distance phone services, can be designed quite differently and still achieve the same result.
🔑 Definition — Equifinality: The principle that similar results may be achieved with different initial conditions and in many different ways.
Alignment
A system's overall effectiveness is determined by the extent to which different parts are aligned with each other. This alignment concerns relationships between inputs and transformations, between transformations and outputs, and among subsystems of the transformation process. Diagnosticians who view relationships among various parts of a system as a whole take a systemic perspective. Alignment represents the extent to which features, operations, and characteristics of one system support the effectiveness of another. For example, General Electric uses a diversification strategy supported by a divisional structure; a functional structure would not fit because one division should focus on one product line. The systemic perspective suggests that diagnosis is the search for misfits among various parts and subsystems.
🔑 Definition — Alignment: The extent to which the features, operations, and characteristics of one system support the effectiveness of another system. 💡 Why this matters: Alignment is the core concept driving organizational diagnosis—if parts don't fit, the organization will be ineffective.
Diagnosing Organizational Systems
When viewed as open systems, organizations can be diagnosed at three levels. The highest level is the overall organization (strategy, structure, processes). The next level is the group or department (group design, norms, work schedules). The lowest level is the individual position or job (how jobs are designed). Diagnosis can occur at all three levels or be limited to a particular level. The key is knowing what to look for at each level and how levels affect each other. For example, diagnosing a work group requires knowledge of group variables and how the larger organization design affects the group. The lecture presents a comprehensive model (Figure 22) showing for each level: (1) inputs, (2) key design components of the transformation subsystem, and (3) system outputs. Cross-level relationships emphasize that organizational levels must fit with each other for effective operation.
Organization-Level Diagnosis
The organization level is the broadest systems perspective in diagnostic activities. The model proposes that an organization's transformation processes, or design components, represent how the organization positions and organizes itself within an environment (inputs) to achieve specific outputs. The combination of design component elements is called a strategic orientation.
Inputs: Two key inputs affect how an organization designs its strategic orientation:
- General environment — external elements and forces that can affect attainment of objectives, described in terms of uncertainty in social, technological, economic, ecological, and political forces. More uncertainty makes it harder to design an effective strategic orientation. For example, the Swiss watch industry was caught off guard by Timex's mass production in the 1960s and later by digital technology.
- Industry structure (task environment) — defined by Michael Porter's five forces: supplier power (unions as powerful labor suppliers), buyer power (airlines forcing Boeing to lower prices), threats of substitutes (frozen yogurt replacing ice cream), threats of entry (ease of starting restaurants reducing profits), and rivalry among competitors (multiple organizations competing for same customers).
In addition to content, inputs must be understood for their rate of change and complexity. Dynamic environments change rapidly and unpredictably, requiring flexible strategic orientations. Complexity refers to the number of important elements in the environment. Software development organizations face dynamic and complex environments; glass jar manufacturers face more stable and less complex environments.
🔑 Definition — Strategic Orientation: The combination of design component elements that represents how an organization positions and organizes itself within its environment.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Organizations must be understood as open systems that constantly exchange resources with their environments, meaning they are always influenced by external forces. The five key properties—inputs/transformations/outputs, boundaries, feedback, equifinality, and alignment—provide a complete framework for analyzing any organizational system. Equifinality is critical because it means there is no single best way to design an organization; managers should develop multiple satisfactory options. Alignment is the essence of diagnosis: effectiveness depends on how well all parts fit together, and diagnosis is the search for misfits. Finally, diagnosis must occur at three levels (organization, group, individual) while recognizing that higher levels serve as critical inputs to lower levels.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What distinguishes an open system from a closed system, and why are organizations considered open systems?
- What are the three parts of any organizational system, and how do they relate to the environment?
- Explain the concept of equifinality and why it means there is no "one best way" to design an organization.
- According to Porter's five forces model, what are the five forces that make up an organization's task environment?
- What does it mean for organizational parts to be "aligned," and why is the search for misfits important in diagnosis?
📘 Lecture 17 — Diagnosing Organizations
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the comprehensive model for diagnosing organizational systems at the organization level, focusing on how to analyze an organization's strategic orientation through its five design components: strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems. It emphasizes the importance of alignment between these components and with the external environment, using Nike as a real-world case study.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers organization-level diagnosis by examining five major design components of a strategic orientation—strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems—and their intermediate output of culture. It then discusses organizational outputs (performance, productivity, stakeholder satisfaction), the critical concept of alignment among components and with inputs, and provides a detailed diagnostic analysis of Nike's strategic orientation as an application example.
📝 Lecture Summary
Organization-Level Diagnosis: Design Components
Figure 23(A) shows that a strategic orientation is composed of five major design components—strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems—and an intermediate output—culture. Effective organizations align their design components to each other and to the environment.
A strategy represents the way an organization uses its resources (human, economic, or technical) to gain and sustain a competitive advantage. It can be described by the organization’s mission, goals and objectives, strategic intent, and functional policies. A mission statement describes the long-term purpose of the organization, the range of products or services offered, the markets to be served, and the social needs served by the organization’s existence. Examples include Walt Disney ("To make people happy"), Wal Mart ("To give ordinary folk the chance to buy the same thing as rich people"), Merck ("To preserve and improve human life"), and Mary Kay Cosmetics ("To give unlimited opportunity to women").
🔑 Definition — Goals and objectives: statements that provide explicit direction, set organization priorities, provide guidelines for management decisions, and serve as the cornerstone for organizing activities, designing jobs, and setting standards of achievement. Goals and objectives should set a target of achievement (such as 50-percent gross margins, an average employee satisfaction score of four on a five-point scale, or some level of productivity); provide a means or system for measuring achievement; and provide a deadline or timeframe for accomplishment.
🔑 Definition — Strategic intent: a succinct label that describes how the organization intends to achieve its goals and objectives. For example, an organization can achieve goals through differentiation of its product or service, by achieving the lowest costs in the industry, or by growth.
🔑 Definition — Functional policies: the methods, procedures, rules, or administrative practices that guide decision making and convert plans into actions. In the semiconductor business, for example, Intel has a policy of allocating about 30 percent of revenues to research and development to maintain its lead in microprocessors production.
Technology is concerned with the way an organization converts inputs into products and services. It represents the core of the transformation function and includes production methods, workflow, and equipment. Automobile companies have traditionally used an assembly-line technology to build cars and trucks. Two features of the technological core influence other design components: interdependence and uncertainty. Technical interdependence involves ways in which the different parts of a technological system are related. High interdependence requires considerable coordination among tasks, such as might occur when departments must work together to bring out a new product. Technical uncertainty refers to the amount of information processing and decision making required during task performance. Generally, when tasks require high amounts of information processing and decision making, they are difficult to plan and routinize. The technology of car manufacturing is relatively certain and moderately interdependent, so automobile manufacturers can specify workers' behaviors and coordination in advance.
The structural system describes how attention and resources are focused on task accomplishment. It represents the basic organizing mode chosen to (1) divide the overall work of an organization into subunits that can assign tasks to individuals or groups and (2) coordinate these subunits for completion of the overall work. Structure needs to be closely aligned with the organization’s technology.
Two ways of determining how an organization divides work are to examine its formal structure or to examine its level of differentiation and integration. Formal structures divide work by function (accounting, sales, or production), by product or service (Chevrolet, Buick, or Pontiac), or by some combination of both (a matrix composed of functional departments and product groupings). The second way to describe how work is divided is to specify the amount of differentiation and integration in a structure. Applied to the total organization, differentiation refers to the degree of similarity or difference in the design of two or more subunits or departments. In a highly differentiated organization, there are major differences in design among the departments—some are highly formalized with many rules, others have few rules, and others are moderately formal or flexible.
The way an organization coordinates work across subunits is called integration. Integration can be achieved in a variety of ways—using plans and schedules; using budgets; assigning special roles such as project managers, liaison positions, or integrators; or creating cross-departmental task forces and teams. The amount of integration required in a structure is a function of (1) the amount of uncertainty in the environment, (2) the level of differentiation in the structure, and (3) the amount of interdependence among departments. As uncertainty, differentiation, and interdependence increase, more sophisticated integration devices are required.
Measurement systems are methods of gathering, assessing, and disseminating information on the activities of groups and individuals in organizations. Such data tell how well the organization is performing and are used to detect and control deviations from goals. Closely related to structural integration, measurement systems monitor organizational operations and feed data about work activities to managers and members so they can better understand current performance and coordinate work. Effective information and control systems are clearly linked to strategic objectives; provide accurate, understandable, and timely information; are accepted as legitimate by organization members; and produce benefits in excess of their cost.
Human resources systems include mechanisms for selecting, developing, appraising, and rewarding organization members. These influence the mix of skills, personalities, and behaviors of organization members. Strategy and technology provide important information about the skills and knowledge required for organizational success. Appraisal processes identify whether those skills and knowledge are being applied to the work, and reward systems complete the cycle by recognizing performance that contributes to goal achievement. Reward systems may be tied to measurement systems so that rewards are allocated on the basis of measured results.
💡 Why this matters: The alignment of human resources systems with strategy and technology ensures that employees have the right skills and are motivated toward organizational goals, directly impacting performance outcomes.
Organization culture is the final design component. It represents the basic assumptions, values, and norms shared by organization members. These cultural elements are generally taken for granted and serve to guide members’ perceptions, thoughts, and actions. For example, McDonald’s culture emphasizes efficiency, speed, and consistency. It orients employees to company goals and suggests the kinds of behaviors necessary for success. In Figure 23(A), culture is shown as an intermediate output from the five other design components because it represents both an outcome and a constraint. It is an outcome of the organization’s history and environment as well as prior choices about strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems. It is also a constraint because it is more difficult to change than the other components. In diagnosis, the interest is in understanding the current culture well enough to determine its alignment with the other design factors.
Outputs
The outputs of a strategic orientation can be classified into three components. First, organization performance refers to financial outputs such as profits, return on investment, and earnings per share. For nonprofit and government agencies, performance often refers to the extent to which costs were lowered or budgets met. Second, productivity concerns internal measurements of efficiency such as sales per employee, waste, error rates, quality, or units produced per hour. Third, stakeholder satisfaction reflects how well the organization has met the expectations of different groups. Customer satisfaction can be measured in terms of market share or focus-group data; employee satisfaction can be measured in terms of an opinion survey; investor satisfaction can be measured in terms of stock price.
Alignment
The effectiveness of an organization’s current strategic orientation requires knowledge of the above information to determine the alignment among the different elements. Two critical questions must be asked:
- Does the organization’s strategic orientation fit with the inputs?
- Do the design components fit with each other?
For example, if the elements of the external environment (inputs) are fairly similar in their degree of certainty, then an effective organization structure (design factor) should have a low degree of differentiation—departments should be designed similarly because each faces similar environmental demands. On the other hand, if the environment is complex and each element presents different amounts of uncertainty, a more differentiated structure is warranted. Chevron Oil Company’s regulatory, ecological, technological, and social environments differ greatly in uncertainty. The regulatory environment is relatively slow-paced and detail-oriented, so the regulatory affairs function is formal and bound by protocol. In the technological environment, new methods for discovering, refining, and distributing oil products are changing rapidly, so those departments are much more flexible and adaptive—very different from the regulatory affairs function.
Analysis: Application 2 — Nike's Strategic Orientation
In 1993, Nike was the leader in domestic-brand athletic footwear with more than 30 percent market share. It also produced sports apparel, hiking boots, and upscale men’s shoes. But after six years of solid growth, international sales were falling, sales of basketball shoes were down, and the firm’s stock price had dropped 41 percent since November 1992. Analysts were projecting declines in both total revenues and profits. In addition, Nike faced attacks from stakeholder groups—organized labor believed Nike exploited foreign labor; the African-American sector noted the lack of diversity in Nike’s workforce; and the general public was growing tired of sensationalizing athletes.
Nike’s traditional strategy was built around high-performance, innovative athletic shoes, aggressive marketing, and low-cost manufacturing. Using input from athletes, Nike developed strong competence in producing high-quality athletic shoes for running, basketball, and other sports. By contracting with well-known athletes to endorse its products, a Nike image of renegade excellence and high performance emerged. Nike contracted with low-cost foreign manufacturing plants to produce its shoes.
An athletic shoe retailer places orders with Nike representatives (who are not employees but contractors) for delivery in six to eight months through the Futures program, which offers the retailer 10 percent off wholesale for making advanced orders. Orders are compiled and production scheduled with one of Nike’s Asian manufacturing partners. On-site Nike employees guarantee quality standards.
Nike’s culture is distinctive—built by athletes for athletes, very entrepreneurial, with the "Just Do It" marketing campaign describing how things are done. As one senior executive put it: "It’s fine to develop structures and plans and policies, if they are viewed, and used, as tools. But it is so easy for them to become substitutes for good thinking, alibis for not taking responsibility..."
Although Phil Knight sets general direction, he rarely sets clear goals. Knight views Nike as a growth company, but others are concerned that going public produced pressures for profitability that sometimes work against growth. Implementation depends on people being tuned into day-to-day operations.
Nike changed from a functional organization in 1985 to a product division structure in 1987, with additional structural change in 1993. The new president, Tom Clark, implemented stronger communication and collaboration among manufacturing, marketing, and sales. The aim is to fit pieces together in ways that best meet product, customer, and market needs.
For coordination, Nike relies on meetings ranging from informal hallway gatherings to three-day off-site events. Membership is fluid, with only needed people invited. More formal systems are often localized and met with resistance. With the exception of the Futures program, there is little in the way of formal information systems.
Knight favors an annual performance review system with annual pay increases tied to performance, but the system is fairly unstructured—some managers do reviews well and others do not. No formal compensation policy exists, but most employees believe Nike is a "great place to work" where rewards come in the form of growth opportunities, autonomy, and responsibility.
Diagnosis questions for inputs:
- What is the company’s general environment? Nike’s environment is uncertain and complex. Technologically, Nike depends on the latest breakthroughs in shoe design and materials. Socially and politically, its international operations require awareness of demands from multiple countries, cultures, and governments.
- What is the company’s industry structure? Nike’s industry is highly competitive. The threat of entry is high; substitute products are a threat; supplier bargaining power is low; buyer bargaining power is moderate; and rivalry among firms is severe (Reebok, Adidas, New Balance, Puma, Converse, Tiger).
Diagnosis of strategic orientation:
- Strategy: No formal mission statement, but a clear sense of initial purpose in high-performance footwear that has blurred with expansion. Goals are nebulous—Knight sets only general direction. Strategic intent is fairly clear: differentiation through high-quality, high-performance shoes. Informal policies dominate.
- Technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems: Technology is moderately uncertain and interdependent. The product division structure appears moderately differentiated but not highly integrated. The contract relationships give it a fluid, network-like structure. Human resources and measurement systems are underdeveloped—no compensation policy, formal control systems resisted, except for the Futures program tracking orders.
- Culture: Dominant feature driven by athletic norms of winning, competition, achievement, and performance.
Alignment analysis:
- Inputs and strategic orientation: The complex and uncertain environment fits well with Nike’s focus on differentiation and flexible organization design—explaining its success through the 1970s, 1980s, and into the 1990s.
- Design components alignment: Individual elements of strategy are not aligned—differentiation intent conflicts with growth goals and a diversified mission. However, there appears good fit between strategy and other design components (flexible structure, informal systems, driving culture). Technology aligns with structure. The Futures program reduces market uncertainty and integrates activities. The lack of formal HR systems supports fluidity but creates problems for hiring and development.
Culture plays a powerful role—promoting coordination, socializing and developing people, and moving information. Any change effort must acknowledge culture's role and design interventions accordingly.
Suggested interventions: (1) Increase clarity about strategy without formalizing it (to avoid cultural resistance); (2) Increase integration and coordination of structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems without increasing formalization.
⭐ Key Takeaways
An organization's strategic orientation consists of five design components—strategy, technology, structure, measurement systems, and human resources systems—with culture as an intermediate output that both results from and constrains these components. Effective diagnosis requires examining the alignment between inputs (environment, industry structure) and the strategic orientation, as well as alignment among the design components themselves. The Nike case demonstrates that even a highly successful organization can have misalignments—such as growth goals conflicting with differentiation strategy—and that culture can be both a powerful coordinating mechanism and a barrier to change. Measurement systems (like Nike's Futures program) can strategically reduce environmental uncertainty by shifting risk to retailers and enabling advanced planning. Finally, any organizational intervention must respect the existing culture, as it can either sabotage or facilitate change efforts.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five design components of a strategic orientation, and how does culture relate to them?
- Explain the difference between differentiation and integration in organizational structure, and describe when more sophisticated integration devices are needed.
- What three categories of outputs are used to assess an organization's effectiveness?
- Using the Nike example, what misalignments exist between the elements of its strategy, and how do they create problems?
- How does Nike's Futures program function as both a measurement system and an integration mechanism, and what strategic advantage does it provide?