π Lecture 16 β ASSESSING THE CHARACTER OF THE CONFLICT I
π Overview: This lecture examines Morton Deutsch's theory of constructive and destructive conflict, focusing on the fundamental distinction between cooperative and competitive conflict. It explains why cooperation tends to produce constructive outcomes while competition leads to destructiveness, and why it is easier for cooperative conflict to become competitive than vice versa. Understanding these dynamics is critical for transforming competitive conflicts into cooperative ones.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture explores Morton Deutsch's four-component theory of constructive and destructive conflict, including the premises of cooperative versus competitive conflict. Key concepts examined include autistic hostility, reactive devaluation, and meta-conflict. The lecture then analyzes how conflict characterization affects communication, coordination of effort, responses to suggestions, feelings between disputants, ego effects, perception of similarity, and task focus in both cooperative and competitive contexts.
π Lecture Summary
Morton Deutsch's Theory of Constructive and Destructive Conflict
Deutschβs ideas about what makes conflict constructive and destructive are well summarized in his 1973 work, "The Resolution of Conflict: Constructive and Destructive Processes." His theory rests on four key propositions. First, conflict is either cooperative or competitive. Second, cooperation tends to be constructive, and competition tends to be destructive. Third, cooperation and competition tend to be self-fulfilling prophecies: perception becomes reality. Fourth, cooperation easily turns into competition, but not vice versa.
π‘ Why this matters: This "crude axiom" that perception becomes reality means that how disputants frame their conflict fundamentally determines whether it will escalate productively or destructively.
Premises of Deutsch's Theory
1. Cooperative conflict A conflict in which the disputants believe that, when one disputant helps him- or herself, the other disputant is also helped.
2. Competitive conflict A conflict in which the disputants believe that, when one disputant helps him- or herself, the other disputant is humble or quiet or less powerful.
3. Autistic hostility A phenomenon in which hostile feelings promote a lack of communication, leading to negative attributions about the acts, attitudes, and motivations of the other person is termed as autistic hostility. Because of the lack of effective communication, neither disputant is able to correct misperceptions.
π Definition β Autistic hostility: a phenomenon in which hostile feelings promote a lack of communication, leading to negative attributions about the acts, attitudes, and motivations of the other person.
4. Reactive Devaluation A phenomenon present in escalating conflict, in which a suggestion made by one disputant, or members of his or her team, is met with suspicion by the other disputant, or members of his or her team may be described as reactive devaluation.
π Definition β Reactive devaluation: a phenomenon in which a suggestion made by one disputant is met with suspicion by the other disputant, simply because of who made the suggestion.
5. Meta-Conflict (meta-dispute) An interpersonal conflict (dispute) over the way another interpersonal conflict is being handled.
π Definition β Meta-conflict: an interpersonal conflict over the way another interpersonal conflict is being handled.
How the conflict is characterized in the minds of the disputants
Since a cooperative conflict is perceived as promotively interdependent, the disputant perceiving a conflict as cooperative will tend to see the conflict as a joint problem to be solved i.e. if the problem is solved for one disputant, it will also tend to be solved for the other.
Communication in cooperation and competition
Since the disputant in a cooperative conflict sees the goals of the other disputant as promoting his or her own interests, it appears to be in his or her best interests to share as much information as possible. Cooperation is characterized by open, honest communication of relevant information. In contrast, since the interests of disputants in a competitive conflict are seen to be in opposition, competition is characterized by efforts on the part of the perceiving disputant to avoid open and honest communication. In competitive conflict, disputants tend to be suspicious of one another, fearing that information they share will be used against them.
Coordination of Effort in cooperation and competition
Since a disputant who sees the conflict as cooperative believes that the other disputant's efforts will help him or her, the disputant will tend to try to coordinate his or her efforts with those of the other disputants.
Efforts of the disputants on One Another's Behalf
Obviously, a disputant who believes that meeting the other disputant's interests will meet his or her own interests has good reason to help the other disputants: it will help him or her as well.
Responses to the Suggestions of the other disputant
The reactions of one disputant to suggestions by the other disputants are controlled by the attitudes engendered by their perceptions. In cooperative conflict, a disputant will tend to see the suggestions of the other disputants as motivated by a sincere desire to help, since everyone's goals are perceived to be complementary. In cooperative conflict, suggestions tend to be welcomed, approved of, or at least taken at face value.
Feelings of the Disputants for one another
There is a great deal of evidence from social psychological research indicating that disputants in a cooperative relationship tend to develop feelings of friendliness and positive regard for one another.
Effect of Cooperation behavior on the disputants' Egos
In a cooperative conflict, cooperating with the other disputant is a comfortable outgrowth of the self interest of each disputant. The feelings of friendliness that tend to grow out of a cooperative relationship further motivate the disputants to be helpful to one another.
Perception of Similarity and difference
The positive and negative regard that cooperating and competing disputants hold for each other have indication for their perceptions about one another. People who like one another tend to focus on, and even inflate, mutual similarities, while they tend to ignore differences.
Task focus in cooperation and competition
The disputant who perceives a conflict as cooperative believes that he or she helps him or herself by helping the other disputant; he or she tends to stay focused on the task at hand. Thus cooperation tends to be characterized by task focus and efficiency.
Productivity, containment, and escalation of cooperative and competitive conflict
A cooperative conflict tends to be characterized by contained size and maximal productivity. There are several reasons for this feature of cooperative conflict.
β Key Takeaways
The single most important idea from this lecture is Deutsch's "crude axiom" that perception becomes reality: how disputants frame their conflict as cooperative or competitive fundamentally determines whether it becomes constructive or destructive. Students must remember the four key premises of Deutsch's theory, especially that cooperation easily turns into competition but not vice versa. The five premisesβcooperative conflict, competitive conflict, autistic hostility, reactive devaluation, and meta-conflictβprovide the vocabulary for analyzing real conflicts. Understanding that cooperation is characterized by open communication, coordinated effort, positive regard, and task focus while competition breeds suspicion, guarded communication, negative feelings, and misperception is essential for practitioners who want to transform destructive conflicts into constructive ones.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to Deutsch, what is the relationship between perception and reality in conflict?
- What is autistic hostility and how does it affect communication between disputants?
- Define reactive devaluation and explain how it operates in escalating conflict.
- Why is it easier for a cooperative conflict to become competitive than for a competitive conflict to become cooperative?
- How does a disputant's perception of the conflict (cooperative vs. competitive) affect their response to suggestions made by the other party?
π Lecture 17 β Assessing the Character of the Conflict II
π Overview: This lecture continues the assessment of conflict character by examining the features of cooperation and competition. It explains Deutsch's major premises about how cooperation tends to be constructive while competition is destructive, and introduces techniques for transforming competitive conflict into cooperative conflict. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for effective conflict management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the features of cooperation and competition while in conflict, Deutsch's premise that cooperation is constructive and competition destructive, Deutsch's Crude Axiom about self-fulfilling prophecies in conflict, the competition and cooperation cycles, the premise that it is easier to move from cooperation to competition than vice versa, and ten specific techniques to transform competitive conflict into cooperative conflict with detailed examples for each technique.
π Lecture Summary
Features of Cooperation and Competition while in conflict
The lecture presents a comprehensive comparison of features when disputants adopt a cooperative versus competitive approach to conflict. In cooperation, the conflict is seen as a joint problem to be solved, characterized by open, honest communication of relevant information. Disputants pool efforts to gather information (efficient in time and money), try to help one another, and generate feelings of friendliness where they see similarities rather than differences. The dispute tends to be contained in size and does not spread. One disputant's suggestions are welcomed and respected by the other. Cooperating gives an ego boost, disputants tend to be task-oriented, and total productivity is maximized.
In contrast, competition involves seeing the conflict as a contest with a winner and loser, characterized by avoidance of communication, miscommunication, and misleading communication. Disputants duplicate efforts to gather information due to mistrust (inefficient in time and money), try to obstruct one another, and generate feelings of enmity and hostility where they ignore similarities and focus on differences. Meta-conflicts and beliefs about hostile intentions cause the original conflict to spread and escalate. One disputant's suggestions are mistrusted and seen as a devious effort to gain the upper hand (reactive devaluation). Cooperating feels like losing face and is psychologically intolerable. "Defeating the enemy" becomes more important than staying on task, and total productivity is impaired.
π Definition β Reactive Devaluation: The tendency for one disputant's suggestions for resolving the dispute to be mistrusted by the other and seen as a devious effort to gain the upper hand.
Cooperation constructive, competition destructive
Deutsch's second major premise is that cooperation tends to be constructive, whereas competition tends to be destructive. The many benefits of using cooperation rather than competition to resolve conflict follow directly from the ten major features of cooperation and competition outlined above. This premise forms the foundation for why conflict managers should strive to create cooperative conditions.
Premise 3: Deutsch's Crude Axioms
Deutsch's Crude Axiom states that cooperation begets cooperation and competition begets competition. A disputant's perception regarding whether the conflict is cooperative or competitive will produce conduct that tends to reinforce this perception. In other words, cooperation and competition tend to be self-fulfilling prophecies. The basic idea is: if a disputant thinks of a conflict as cooperative, it will tend to become more cooperative, and if a disputant thinks of a conflict as competitive, it will become more competitive.
The reason for this is that a disputant who thinks their interdependence with the other disputant is promotive will tend to try to help the other in an act of self-aggrandizement, actually creating more promotive interdependence. But a disputant who thinks the interdependence is contrient will avoid promoting the interests of the other out of a desire to protect themselves, thus increasing the contrience of the interdependence. One recurring theme in conflict diagnosis is that conflict participants who are unable to read the minds of other participants tend to use the conflict itself as a source of information about their motivations. The more objective information about the conflict possessed by each disputant, the less likely the disputant is to be swayed by the other's behavior.
π Definition β Deutsch's Crude Axiom: Cooperation begets cooperation and competition begets competition; perceptions of conflict type produce conduct that reinforces those perceptions as self-fulfilling prophecies. π‘ Why this matters: This explains why conflicts often escalate or de-escalate on their own β early perceptions set the trajectory for the entire conflict process.
Competition Cycle
The Competition Cycle shows the internal dynamism of competitive conflict. Understanding this dynamism can be used to transform competitive conflict into cooperative conflict. The cycle illustrates how competitive behaviors reinforce each other in a self-perpetuating pattern.
Cooperation Cycle
The understanding of internal dynamics of cooperative conflict can lead to reaping the promotive benefits of conflict. The peaceful nature of conflict assures good quality of life to the participants. However, the lecture notes that some individuals enjoy competition and conflict.
Premise 4: It is easier to move from cooperation to competition than vice versa
Deutsch's final premise about cooperation and competition is that cooperation is relatively fragile. People never have perfect knowledge about one another, and in their fear and suspicion, they tend to set in motion protective actions that promote competition. This means maintaining cooperation requires conscious effort and safeguards against the natural tendency toward competitive escalation.
Techniques to transform competitive conflict into cooperative
The lecture presents ten methods and techniques to transform competitive conflict into cooperative conflict, each targeting specific steps in the competitive cycle:
-
Choose Language with Care - Affects perception of contrient interdependence. Example: Instead of calling disputants "opponents," call them "Saleem" and "Naila." Instead of referring to the conflict as "dispute," refer to it as "the problem we need to solve." Instead of asking disputants to "state their positions," ask them to "talk about their goals for the process."
-
Assign Joint Tasks - Affects perception of contrient interdependence and perception of inefficiency in conflict resolution. Example: Business partners disputing over appropriate assignment of the venture's profits are assigned to interview jointly a CPA to learn steps they can take to increase overall profitability.
-
Expand the Pipe - Affects perception of contrient interdependence. Example: Spouses disputing over a property settlement are encouraged to characterize a payment as alimony β the wealthier spouse receives a tax deduction bigger than the tax the other spouse will have to pay on the amount received. The overall benefit is allocated between spouses so both are better off.
-
Establish ground rules for civility in communication - Affects perception of enmity between disputants. Example: An ADR neutral requires each disputant to refrain from "bad-mouthing" the other and takes time to guide each disputant in using complimentary, polite discourse.
-
Create or focus on a common enemy - Affects perception of enmity, hostility, and perception of contrient interdependence. Example: In a custody dispute, the parent's advocate reframes the issue into a problem of how the parents can convince a mother-in-law who has created friction in the past of the merits of a proposed parenting plan.
-
Point out areas of agreement - Affects perception of difference in values and principles. Example: The disputant's advocate makes sure to comment "so, you agree about that" each time the disputants mention something that has already been resolved.
-
Focus blame away from the disputant and towards process - Affects perception that the other disputant is at fault for failure to progress in conflict. Example: In response to a disputant's complaint about the other disputant's non-compliance with a prior agreement, counsel says, "so those arrangements didn't work for you. Let's work on making some new, more effective and workable arrangements."
-
Prepare "the case" - Minimizes the impact of Deutsch's Crude Axiom. Example: The disputant is encouraged to get all the information they can about the factual and legal aspects of the dispute and to perform in-depth conflict diagnosis.
-
Use trust-building exercises - Addresses lack of trust between disputants. Example: Disputants are encouraged to confirm the accuracy of one another's statements. The ADR professional gently guides the suspicious disputant into realizing that the other disputant has, in fact, been behaving as the disputant would have believed in the same thing.
-
Set up structure to create sharing of information - Addresses the tendency to mislead. Example: The mediator requires the sharing of information to both disputants. The mediator asks each disputant to back up claims about expenditures with receipts and other documentation.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are that cooperation is constructive and competition is destructive in conflict, and Deutsch's Crude Axiom explains how these orientations become self-fulfilling prophecies. Understanding the ten features distinguishing cooperation from competition allows practitioners to diagnose conflict character, while knowledge that cooperation is more fragile than competition highlights the need for deliberate intervention. Ten specific techniques exist to transform competitive conflict into cooperative conflict, each targeting a specific step in the competitive cycle. The key to transformation lies in changing perceptions of interdependence, communication patterns, and trust levels between disputants.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the ten features that distinguish cooperation from competition in conflict?
- Explain Deutsch's Crude Axiom and why cooperation and competition tend to be self-fulfilling prophecies.
- Why is cooperation considered more fragile than competition according to Deutsch's fourth premise?
- Name five techniques to transform competitive conflict into cooperative conflict and explain which step in the competitive cycle each technique affects.
- What is reactive devaluation and how does it manifest in competitive conflict?
π Lecture 18 β TRUST AND ITS SIGNIFICANCE I
π Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental concept of trust and its critical role in conflict management and human relationships. It introduces a prominent three-level theory of trustβcalculus-based, knowledge-based, and identification-basedβand explains how each level functions, how they differ, and their applicability in various contexts including business and intimate relationships.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining trust and mistrust as distinct phenomena, discusses the role of trust in business relationships, and examines the relationship between trust and conflict. The core of the lecture analyzes the three levels of trust in detail: calculus-based trust, knowledge-based trust, and identification-based trust, including their characteristics, how they are established, and their respective advantages and limitations.
π Lecture Summary
What is Trust?
Trust can be defined as a state of mind in which a person believes that another person intends to be helpful and, accordingly, that it is appropriate to take risks in the relationship. It is a basic component of human relationships and plays a vital role in improving the quality of every relationship. The behaviors essential to maintaining a constructive or cooperative relationship involve an element of risk. To risk open communication and altruistic behavior that makes cooperative sharing of tasks possible, each disputant must believe that the other will not exploit the situation. The attitude that allows this risk-taking behavior is called βtrustβ.
What is Mistrust?
Mistrust is not the absence of different forms of trust; it is a separate and distinct phenomenon. Disputants in a state of mistrust are actively motivated to protect themselves from the other disputant. Lack of trust involves uncertainty, while mistrust is a state in which one individual actively believes that the other is likely to harm him or her. Trust is difficult to establish when mistrust is present. Mistrust is associated with aggressive behavior and the escalation of destructive conflict.
Trust and Business
A business relationship is designed for people who must be involved in a relationship but who have very low levels of trust in each other. A business relationship has the following components:
- Explicit and detailed agreement
- Formality
- Restraint of emotional expression
- Balanced, neutral facilitating and evaluation
If you succeed in building mutual trust with your business partner, it will serve as a strong foundation that will free you to respond together to the unexpected, which is essential for mutual creativity in conflict resolution. Business is too complex to expect ready agreement on all issues, and trust does not imply easy harmony. However, in a trusting relationship, conflicts motivate you to probe for deeper understanding and search for constructive solutions. Trust creates good will, which sustains the relationship when one firm does something the other dislikes.
Trust and Conflict
When one puts faith and trust in another, and that confidence is broken, it can create an emotional response that elevates to conflict. To trust someone is to place a high confidence level that the relationship will not be compromised in any way. A trusting relationship leads to feelings of confidence and security. A breach of trust unleashes our strongest emotions that frequently lead to conflict.
Breach of Trust and its Consequences
Even a single threat to mutual trust can turn a cooperative relationship into an escalating competition. When trust is threatened, the mistrustful person suspects that the other may harm or exploit him or her, and risky behaviors, such as information and effort sharing, are abandoned as dangerous. Moreover, a mistrustful person in a conflict is likely to see his or her own well-being as dependent on self-defense. Mistrust is therefore associated with aggressive behavior and the escalation of destructive conflict.
Three Levels of Trust
The three levels of trust are: (1) Calculus-based trust (2) Knowledge-based trust (3) Identification-based trust
Some forms of trust are hard to establish, and some forms of trust are more useful than others.
Calculus-based Trust
The first and most basic level of trust is called calculus-based trust. It is based on knowledge of the consequences of compliance or noncompliance. In legal disputes, calculus-based trust is more commonly used, such as in settlement agreements and court judgments. The incentives that can produce calculus-based trust are as varied as the individuals involved in the conflict, and they do not always involve money. Disputants are made aware of the fact that refusal to comply with settlement provisions can mean being hauled into court, made to produce information about assets, and enforced to sell property. These threats of inconvenience and penalty are usually enough to promote compliance and to create minimal levels of peace of mind.
π Definition β Calculus-based trust: Trust based on knowledge that the other person wonβt want to incur the consequences of betrayal.
π Formula: Compliance = Threat of Penalty + Limited Trust β Minimal Peace of Mind
π Example: In a legal settlement, a disputant complies with the agreement because they know that refusal can result in being taken to court and having assets seized.
Calculus-based Trust at a glance
- Trust based on knowledge that the other person wonβt want to incur the consequences of betrayal
- Narrow applicability to the action for which consequences are in place
- Easiest type of trust to establish (you just need a contract)
π‘ Why this matters: Calculus-based trust is the foundation of most formal agreements and legal systems, but it is limited in scope and does not foster deep relationships.
Knowledge-based Trust
The second level of trust is known as knowledge-based trust. It is based on one disputantβs knowledge and understanding of the other disputant. For example, if a woman needs to leave her children with their regular babysitter while she attends a business meeting, she can trust that the babysitter will keep them safe because of her long-standing history of having done so in the past. Knowledge-based trust is usually unwarranted in new relationships, in very short relationships, and in relationships that are caught up in a competition cycle. After a period of effective functioning, we may convert calculus-based trust into knowledge-based trust. This type of trust is based on knowledge of the other personβs habits, traits, attitudes, principles, and values.
π Definition β Knowledge-based trust: Trust based on knowledge of the other personβs habits, traits, attitudes, principles, and values.
π Example: A mother trusts a long-time babysitter because of her past reliability, background, skills, education, and values observed over numerous interactions.
Knowledge-based Trust at a glance
- Trust based on knowledge of the other personβs habits, traits, attitudes, principles, and values
- Applicability to all actions about which relevant characteristics of the person are known
- Establishment depends on knowing the other person well enough to acquire relevant knowledge
Identification-based Trust
The highest level of trust is identification-based trust. It is founded on the disputantβs sense of identification with one another. Because the disputants identify with one another, they tend to see themselves as being βas oneβ in their goals, values, and needs. Thus, it is intrinsically satisfying to a disputant in a relationship characterized by identification-based trust to meet the perceived needs of the other disputant. In intimate relationships such as those between family members, preserving identification-based trust is more important than specific substantive agreements. For example, two spouses arguing over the best color to paint a bedroom generally have a much greater need to preserve their mutual sense of identification than to resolve the issue of paint color. Business organizations that indoctrinate their new employees into the company and devote resources to building company spirit are exploiting the advantages of this type of trust.
π Definition β Identification-based trust: Trust based on a sense of identification, or βoneness,β with the other person.
π Example: Two spouses arguing about paint color prioritize preserving their mutual identification and relationship over the specific outcome of the argument.
Identification-based Trust at a glance
- Trust based on a sense of identification, or βoneness,β with the other person
- Broad applicability to entire relationship
- Establishment is very difficult: requires a period of intimacy, partnership during a crisis, or another intense interconnection
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that trust is a critical behavioral attribute for individuals and organizations, existing in three distinct levels: calculus-based, knowledge-based, and identification-based. Calculus-based trust, relying on consequences and contracts, is the easiest to establish but has narrow applicability. Knowledge-based trust, built on understanding the other personβs habits and values, requires time and interaction to develop. Identification-based trust, the highest and most difficult level, is founded on a sense of oneness and is vital for intimate relationships. A breach of trust can rapidly escalate conflict, while higher levels of trust lead to greater relationship outcomes and efficiency.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between a lack of trust (uncertainty) and active mistrust?
- List the four components of a business relationship designed for low-trust situations.
- What are the three levels of trust, and which one is easiest to establish?
- Explain how knowledge-based trust can be converted from calculus-based trust, using the example of an employee.
- Why is identification-based trust considered the highest level, and what does it require to be established?
π Lecture 19 β Trust and Its Significance II
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of trust in conflict management, detailing the different types of trust (calculus-based, knowledge-based, and identification-based), their origins, and their effects on relationships. It also provides practical strategies for building trust, drafting effective agreements, and managing low-trust situations, which is crucial for successful conflict resolution and cooperation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the advantages of high trust levels, then examines the three origins of trust: calculus-based, knowledge-based, and identification-based trust. It discusses the effects of both high and low trust levels on cycles of cooperation and competition. The lecture then provides methods for building trust and introduces the concept of a "business relationship" for low-trust situations, including how to draft effective agreements. Finally, it outlines strategies for dealing with low-trust situations and key points for developing a trusting environment.
π Lecture Summary
Trust and Its Significance II
Trust is a critical component of conflict management that can be built between individuals, companies, or countries. High levels of trust carry distinct advantages, though they are not always attainable. A "business relationship" can protect disputants when trust is low, and low levels of trust can be promoted into higher levels.
Advantages of high trust level
High levels of trust provide several advantages, including less guesswork, fewer formalities leading to greater efficiency, pleasant feelings and a comfortable work environment, fostering cooperation, and a better quality of life for everyone.
Origins of trust
Calculus-based trust comes from provisions in contracts that give people incentives not to harm one another, such as an agreement specifying penalties for breach. Since a contract is all that is needed to create this form of trust, it is relatively easy to establish, even between hostile adversaries. It can also come from the course of dealing itself, where each disputant counts on the other to preserve the relationship because of its intrinsic advantages.
Knowledge-based trust comes from any situation in which people become well-known to each other. It does not require intimate knowledge but can be based on a course of dealing. The cooperation cycle can promote this trust easily, especially when it is clear that interests are not in conflict. Regular communication also promotes knowledge-based trust.
Identification-based trust is the hardest to establish and is commonly found among intimate partners or families. It is created in situations involving a joint venture that both disputants care about deeply. Some multinational companies (MNCs) build this trust through inculcation of company-specific values, such as requiring employees to sing loyalty-promoting poems or songs.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the three origins of trust helps in selecting the right strategy to build trust based on the specific relationship and context.
Effects of trust
High levels of trust, particularly identification-based trust, increase the chances of perpetuating a cooperation cycle. In contrast, low levels of trust can trigger a competition cycle. Situations with little or no trust include brand new relationships, transactions between strangers, and situations involving a betrayal of trust. Mistrustfulness creates a perception of contrient interdependence, leading to hidden information and duplicated effort, which escalate the competition cycle.
Building of trust
When confidence in a relationship is broken, it can create an emotional response that elevates to conflict. Trusting someone means placing a high confidence level that the relationship will not be compromised. Confidence building measures (CBMs) provide a good example, such as those used between India and Pakistan, which have led to increased trade.
π Definition β Confidence Building Measures (CBMs): Actions taken to build trust and reduce tensions between parties, often used in international relations.
Business Relationships
A business relationship is designed for people who must be in a relationship but have very low levels of trust. Its components include:
- Explicit and detailed agreements
- Formal, preferably written communication
- No sharing of emotion
- Balanced, neutral assessment methods
Achieving a Business Relationship through Effective agreement Drafting
Poor agreement drafting can lead to misunderstandings that are perceived as betrayal in a low-trust climate. Effective agreement drafting consists of five goals:
- Accuracy and completeness: The agreement must correctly and completely set down the parties' agreement without expanding upon or altering negotiation results.
- Clarity and certainty: All rights, responsibilities, and procedures (e.g., payment method, delivery dates, shipping responsibility) must be clear.
- Flexibility: The agreement should be workable despite unforeseen future developments, often balanced against certainty.
- Legal enforceability: The agreement should preserve the legal status of a contract, with appropriate signature lines, seals, and acknowledgements.
- Relationship preservation: The agreement should avoid damaging the relationship by preserving fairness and avoiding inflammatory or demeaning language.
Low trust situation
Situations where trust is low include new transactions and relationships, breakdowns in close relationships, historical enemies, and apparent betrayal of trust.
Dealing with low trust situations
In intimate relationships, preserving identification-based trust is the priority. In other situations, create calculus-based trust first.
π Key Concept β Ease of Establishing vs. Scope of Trust: Trust that is easier to establish (calculus-based) has a narrower scope and usefulness. Trust that is harder to establish (identification-based) has the broadest scope and highest usefulness.
Key Points to Remember
To develop a trusting environment, remember to:
- Be a model of calm and control
- Don't give in to emotional outbursts
- Don't assume people are being difficult intentionally
- Find a quiet place to resolve breaches of trust privately
Set ground rules for discussion:
- No raising of voices
- This is not a debate
- Speak only for yourself using "I" phrases
- Confront the issues, not the people
- Maintain or enhance self-esteem
β Key Takeaways
Trust exists in three levels: calculus-based (easiest, through contracts), knowledge-based (through familiarity), and identification-based (hardest, through deep shared values). High trust fosters cooperation, while low trust triggers competition cycles. When dealing with low trust, a formal "business relationship" with explicit agreements provides protection. Effective agreement drafting requires accuracy, clarity, flexibility, enforceability, and relationship preservation. Finally, trust can be deliberately built through confidence-building measures and respectful communication, moving parties from calculus-based to higher forms of trust.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of trust, and which is easiest to establish?
- What are five advantages of having a high level of trust in a relationship?
- Name all five goals of effective agreement drafting for business relationships.
- What is a key strategy for dealing with low trust in intimate versus non-intimate relationships?
- What ground rules should be set for a discussion about a breach of trust?
π Lecture 20 β ASSESSING IMPEDIMENTS TO RESOLVE THE CONFLICT I
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of impediments that block successful conflict resolution. It explores how culture, social systems, and individual psychology create barriers to resolving interpersonal disputes. Understanding these impediments is critical for any conflict manager, as awareness of these obstacles is the first step toward overcoming them.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers fourteen key factors that impede conflict resolution, beginning with the first five: motivation to seek vengeance, meta-disputes, mistrust, vastly different perceptions of reality, and other impediments such as over-commitment, lack of ripeness, jackpot syndrome, loss aversion, and linkages. It also examines the role of culture and social systems in creating conflict, and discusses how individual and community-level factors contribute to conflict escalation.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
Conflict is a product of the social and economic system. Culture plays an important role in creating conflict. At the individual level, individualism is rampant and is a source of conflict among people and societies. At the community level, the structure of society and the system of social relations are the sources of conflict.
Impediments to Resolving Interpersonal Conflict
There are fourteen important factors that impede the resolution of conflicts:
- Motivation to seek vengeance
- Meta-disputes
- Mistrust
- Vastly different perceptions about reality
- Over-commitment and entrapment
- Lack of ripeness
- Jackpot syndrome
- Loss aversion
- Linkages
- Conflicts of interest among team members
- Excluded stakeholders
- Disempowered disputant
- Unpleasant disputant
- Competitive culture or subculture
Motivation to seek vengeance
Vengeance makes an individual sacrifice the advantage of cooperation and presses for punishing the other disputant. A disputant who is motivated to seek vengeance is likely to sacrifice the advantages of cooperation to punish the other side. This phenomenon often occurs after a conflict has been in a competitive cycle and has escalated and spread.
Disputants have many reasons to seek revenge, including:
- Revenge to rectify injustice
- Revenge to prove self worth
- For preventing other disputant from further havoc
- Perception of hostility and hatred
- Vengeance as a difficult impediment to deal with conflict
- Disappointment of vengeful disputant
- Anger and angry attitude (rigidity of values/fixity of mind, lack of flexibility and creativity)
It can be difficult to admit to vengeful feelings, because they are considered socially unacceptable in many circumstances. The motivation to seek vengeance is a difficult impediment to deal with.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding vengeance as an impediment is crucial because it explains why otherwise rational people will sacrifice their own benefit simply to harm the other side, making resolution nearly impossible without intervention.
π Definition β Vengeance: The motivation to punish the other disputant even at the cost of sacrificing the advantages of cooperation. π Example: After a long legal dispute over a property boundary, one neighbor deliberately sells his land to a developer who will build a noisy factory, even though it lowers his own property value, simply to punish the other neighbor.
Meta Disputes
Meta-disputes are disputes about the way a conflict is being handled. Unresolved and escalating conflict breeds meta-disputes. The more the conflict is complex, the more the chances of evolving meta-disputes. The best way to deal with meta-disputes is to prevent them.
A cooperative conflict cycle minimizes meta-disputes through free and open communication. Disputants can avoid negative attributions of each other's behaviors. Meta-disputes generally are based on misunderstandings. A third party or mediator can untangle such misunderstandings.
π Definition β Meta-dispute: A dispute about the way a conflict is being handled. π Example: Two business partners are fighting not just about money (the original conflict), but about whether they should be talking at all, who gets to speak first, and whether emails or face-to-face meetings should be used (the meta-dispute).
Mistrust
Mistrust and low levels of trust are the engines driving conflict escalation. Low levels of trust create the suspicion, circumspection, and defensive tactics that promote inefficiency, bad feelings, and disputants' efforts to undermine one another.
Vastly different perceptions of reality
When disputants have dramatically differing perceptions of the facts or law that underlie the conflict, they usually have trouble achieving resolution without help. If each person has a strong, honest belief that his or her point of view is the correct one, then it is difficult to convince the person otherwise.
Summary
To resolve conflict, understanding about impediments to resolving conflict is important. There are fourteen impediments that are mentioned in this and the next lecture. Being aware and sensitive about these shall make you see those impediments operating in the conflict in hand; it will make you resolve the conflict comfortably.
β Key Takeaways
- Conflict arises from both individual factors (like individualism and vengeance) and systemic factors (like culture and social structures), so effective resolution requires addressing both levels.
- Vengeance is one of the most difficult impediments because it makes disputants sacrifice their own advantage to punish the other, often after a long escalation cycle.
- Meta-disputes are disputes about how the conflict is being handled; they compound original conflicts and are best prevented through open, cooperative communication.
- Mistrust is the engine that drives conflict escalation by creating suspicion and defensive tactics that make cooperation nearly impossible.
- When disputants have vastly different perceptions of reality, external help (like a mediator) is usually required because each side honestly believes their view is correct.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main categories of reasons why people seek vengeance in a conflict?
- How do meta-disputes differ from the original conflict, and what is the best way to deal with them?
- Why is mistrust described as the "engine driving conflict escalation"?
- What makes "vastly different perceptions of reality" such a difficult impediment to overcome without help?
- List the first five of the fourteen impediments to resolving interpersonal conflict mentioned in this lecture.