π Lecture 21 β Assessing the Impediments to Resolving the Conflict II
π Overview: This lecture continues the examination of barriers that prevent cooperative settlement of interpersonal conflicts. It covers the remaining eleven impediments from the comprehensive list, explaining how each one operates and what strategies can be used to overcome them. Understanding these impediments is critical for effective conflict diagnosis and resolution.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers eleven impediments to conflict resolution: over-commitment and entrapment, lack of ripeness, jackpot syndrome, loss aversion, linkage, conflicts of interest among team members, excluded stakeholders, disempowered disputant, unpleasant disputant, and competitive culture or subculture. Each impediment is explained with its definition, characteristics, and practical strategies for addressing it, concluding with the importance of interest analysis in identifying active impediments.
π Lecture Summary
Summary impediments to cooperative settlement of interpersonal conflict
The lecture begins with a comprehensive summary table of all fourteen impediments, which were introduced across Lecture 20 and Lecture 21. The table provides each impediment's explanation and a concrete example.
π Definition β Over-commitment and entrapment: A disputantβs team commits so much time, resource, or psychological energy to a competitive position that they feel that to settle would be a waste or would create intolerable loss of face. π Example: After committing $50,000 to preparing for trial, a plaintiff refuses an eleventh-hour offer to settle for an amount the plaintiff originally felt would be in his best interests.
π Definition β Jackpot syndrome: One of the parties is willing to take a huge risk that he or she will lose for the opportunity to obtain a huge recovery. π Example: A plaintiff sues for $10 million and refuses to settle, despite her attorneyβs warning that sheβs unlikely to beat the defendantβs latest offer.
π Definition β Loss aversion: A disputant would rather gamble on a likely huge loss than pay out a smaller loss now. π Example: A defendant, faced with an offer of settlement if he pays $2,500, prefers to try the case although his lawyer warns that heβs very likely to lose more than that.
π Definition β Linkages: Settling this case will affect other situations in unpredictable or damaging ways. π Example: A prosecutor refuses to accept a plea-bargain offer from a defendant accused of accounting fraud β even though the evidence in the case is weak β because of the slap-on-the-wrist message that might be sent to others with similar cases pending.
π Definition β Excluded stakeholders: One of the important stakeholders in the conflict is left out of the negotiations and therefore sabotages efforts to complete a settlement. π Example: During negotiations over custodial arrangements for a teenager, parental efforts to institute visitation arrangements fall apart when the teenager refuses to go to the motherβs house as specified in the agreement.
π‘ Why this matters: The table provides a quick-reference diagnostic tool for conflict managers to identify which impediments may be active in any given dispute.
Over-commitment and entrapment
Over-commitment occurs when a disputant pours so much time, money, and energy into preparing for a battle that it is seemingly wasteful to back out of the project. The result is that the disputants feel trapped. Over-commitment is a toxic combination of inattention and fear of losing face. It is insidious β it happens inch by inch, creating entrapment by degrees. The best ways to combat entrapment are to make disputants attentive to the process of commitment and to avoid the loss of face issue that comes with it.
Rubin, Pruitt, and Kim (1994, 114-16) recommended four tactics designed to avoid over-commitment and entrapment:
- Before entering into a negotiation, it helps to set some boundaries on how much the disputant will lay on the line.
- During the negotiation, one can schedule "points of decision", at which the decision to stay involved is periodically reevaluated.
- Attention should be paid, during analysis of whether to continue committing resources to a conflict, on the costs, non-monetary and monetary, of continuing the conflict.
- It is very useful to build in ways to save face wherever possible. As entrapment builds, the participants continue to persist in the dispute to avoid loss of face.
Lack of Ripeness
Resolving a conflict is perceived as costly, difficult, and unpleasant. Many times, disputants won't confront the work needed to resolve a conflict until they find no alternative. This situation of conflict is called ripeness.
In legal disputing, ripeness is often created by the proximity of the trial. A trial usually has many unexpected twists and turns; it is expensive, time consuming, and emotionally disturbing.
Jackpot Syndrome
The Jackpot Syndrome, identified by prominent law professors Frank Sander and Stephen Goldberg (Sander & Goldberg 1994), involves apparently irrational behavior by a disputant who is risk-tolerant. Disputants afflicted with this syndrome believe that they have a chance of "winning big" if they hold out and refuse to settle. The irrationality comes because their chances of actually getting the big payoff are miniscule.
Key characteristics:
- Apparently irrational behavior by a disputant who is risk-tolerant
- Believe in a chance of winning big
- Need to be educated: jackpot syndrome is unrealistic
- Differing views about reality and expecting a chance to become rich or famous
Loss Aversion
Loss aversion is the propensity of many people to prefer to gamble on an uncertain outcome rather than to take on a certain but manageable loss. Loss aversion is the complement of Jackpot Syndrome β it involves people who would rather gamble, knowing they have a good chance of losing, than give up a sure thing of lesser value.
Linkage
A linkages problem (Sander & Goldberg 1994) occurs when the conflict under consideration is interlinked with other conflicts and other parties. The implications of settlement may be hard to clarify or may overwhelm the stakes in the current conflict. It may seem safer just to avoid settlement altogether. Linkages are a reality of many interpersonal conflicts, and an effective conflict diagnostician deals with linkages by performing detailed interest analyses to determine the nature of each interdependent relationship affecting the conflict.
π‘ Why this matters: Interest analysis is necessary to understand the linked conflicts or parties. Being unaware about underlying interests of disputants, agents, and constituents will be harmful in conflict management.
Conflicts of interest among team members
Non-disputants can put a variety of barriers in the way of conflict resolution. Constituent agents and other influential parties can all impede the otherwise effective work of disputants. Conflicts of interest can sometimes be treated as separate interpersonal conflicts, subject to creative resolution. When advocates and agents have clear conflicts of interests with their disputants, sometimes they must withdraw from representing the disputants to prevent the conflict of interest from doing harm to those they ostensibly represent.
Excluded Stakeholder
Another group of people who frequently impede the smooth resolution of a conflict are those who are not at the negotiation table but feel they should be. In a complex conflict, sometimes the disputants are difficult to identify. There may be a number of advocacy groups, each of which claims to be an interested party. Or, within a single group of disputants, there may be conflict over who should be physically performing the negotiation of the conflict.
Any individual who feels a need to contribute to the resolution of a conflict, but who isn't invited to do so, is likely to feel slighted about the lack of consideration. This psychological sting typically prompts the person who has been left out to dislike any settlement being considered (in a phenomenon closely related to reactive devaluation), and this person will often seek to sabotage the settlement process.
π‘ Why this matters: At times, unimaginable forces or interests could impede resolution of conflicts. They could duly become part of negotiation. For example, an adult ward (child) may like to sit on the negotiation table on property dispute.
Disempowered Disputant
A disempowered disputant is a disputant who feels he or she has insufficient power in the relationship with the other disputant. For example, one brother or partner is active while other is passive or a sleeping partner. A disempowered disputant fears coming to agreement because he or she is afraid to be taken advantage of and doesn't know how to protect him- or herself. Often, the disempowered disputant cannot assess the utility of a proposed settlement because he or she lacks essential knowledge. A disempowered disputant is very likely to dig his or her heels into the sand and become paralyzed.
A seeming paradox is that a very powerful disputant in negotiation with a much disempowered disputant often benefits from conferring power on the latter. A conflict diagnostician who finds a disempowered disputant impeding settlement should look at ways that the disputant can be empowered.
Unpleasant Disputant
Some disputants are so irritating that no one wants to please them. Their unpleasant personalities generate intense hostility in those who have to deal with them. They push conflicts into a competitive cycle by directly generating enmity between the participants. Helping the irritating person may feel psychologically intolerable to the other participants (contrient interdependence results). Sometimes, the problem is "goodness of fit" β a disputant is only unpleasant to a single other disputant β but sometimes the unpleasant disputant is directed almost universally as impossible to work with.
Bossy attitude, unpleasant face, body, or outlook may also be the impediments. The solution may be to create distance between disputants.
Competitive culture or sub-culture
A competitive culture or subculture breeds competitive conflict escalation in numerous ways. Alternative ways of behaving are misunderstood, decried, or ridiculed. Efforts to create a cooperation cycle are met with efforts to exploit the opening thus created. It is difficult to deal with conflict in such an environment without retreating to the self-protective illusion of competition. The most common competitive subculture is the legal subculture. Lawyers are inculcated in the ways of competitive conflict resolution.
Trying to establish a cooperative relationship within a competitive culture or subculture involves one of two approaches:
- Creating enough incentive for the other disputant to break cultural traditions
- Moving the site of the conflict out of the competitive setting
Both of these approaches are used for legal disputes.
Summary
The importance of fourteen impediments to resolve conflict may have been known to you by now. If you can identify the active impediments by doing interest analysis, you will be able to resolve conflict easily.
β Key Takeaways
The fourteen impediments to cooperative conflict resolution fall into psychological, structural, and cultural categories, each requiring specific diagnostic and intervention strategies. Over-commitment and entrapment can be prevented by setting boundaries, scheduling decision points, analyzing costs, and creating face-saving mechanisms. Jackpot syndrome and loss aversion represent opposite risk-taking behaviors β one chasing unlikely big wins, the other preferring uncertain gambling over certain losses β both requiring education and reality testing. Linkage problems demand detailed interest analysis to understand interconnected relationships, while excluded stakeholders and disempowered disputants often need to be brought into the process or empowered for settlement to succeed. The most critical skill for a conflict manager is performing thorough interest analysis to identify which impediments are actively blocking resolution in any given dispute.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four tactics recommended by Rubin, Pruitt, and Kim (1994) to avoid over-commitment and entrapment?
- How does "lack of ripeness" typically become resolved in legal disputing, and what role does the proximity of trial play?
- What is the fundamental difference between Jackpot Syndrome and Loss Aversion in terms of disputant psychology?
- Why would a powerful disputant benefit from conferring power on a disempowered disputant during negotiations?
- What two approaches can be used to establish cooperative relationships within a competitive culture or subculture?
π Lecture 22 β Assessing the Negotiating Style I
π Overview: This lecture introduces negotiation as a key method of conflict management and examines how different negotiation styles emerge depending on the conflict and the disputants. It critiques Deutschβs theory of cooperation and competition for being incomplete and presents the dual concern model with five distinct negotiation styles, each symbolized by an animal to illustrate when and how each style is used.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining negotiation and its role in alternative dispute resolution. It then critiques Deutschβs model of cooperation and competition, explaining why it fails to fully capture behavior in conflict. The core focus is the dual concern model, which outlines five negotiation styles: avoiding, dominating, obliging, integrating, and compromising. Each style is explained with its level of concern for self and other, a symbolic animal, and examples of when it is appropriately applied.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
Conflict is resolved through various methods, including arbitration, mediation, adjudication, and negotiation. This lecture focuses on understanding negotiation. The choice of negotiation style depends on the nature of the conflict and the disputants. The main points of discussion include: why Deutschβs theory is incomplete, how to cooperate without being taken advantage of, the five negotiation styles, and the dual concern model.
Quotations
The lecture begins with three relevant quotations:
- John F. Kennedy: "Let us never negotiate out of fear, but let us never fear to negotiate."
- Adnan Khasoggi: "Making a billion dollars on a new deal is not difficult for me. Making it in a way that gives me satisfaction is the real challenge."
- G. K. Chesterton: "Compromise used to mean that half a loaf was better than no bread. Among modern statesmen it really seems to mean that half a loaf is better than a whole loaf."
Negotiation
Negotiation is one of three primary methods of alternative dispute resolution. It is a dialogue, discussion, or written exchange aimed at resolving a dispute or consummating a transaction. Virtually all cooperative conflicts are resolved through discussion and negotiation.
π Definition β Negotiation: A dialogue, discussion, or written exchange aimed at resolving a dispute or consummating a transaction.
Negotiation Style
A negotiation style is a strategy, not a tactic. Choose a negotiation style that is suitable for the conflict you are dealing with. Most people have biases about choosing different styles of negotiation according to their own strengths and weaknesses.
π Definition β Negotiation Style: A strategy, not a tactic, chosen based on the conflict and the disputants.
Deutchβs Model
According to Deutschβs model, conflict is either cooperative or competitive. This approach is advantageous because it shows the course of conflict rather than the behaviors of individual disputants or agents. However, it fails because:
- It does not describe the self-perception of disputants, which is very important.
- Cooperation and competition are cyclical in nature, and Deutschβs model refers to conflict, not the positions of individual disputants.
- According to this model, there is only one form of cooperation. Actually, there could be different forms of cooperative strategies to resolve conflict. For example, a βpushoverβ cooperation strategy makes the other disputant cooperate forcefully, whereas a joint problem solving strategy entails looking after the interests of the other party.
The model illustrates that cooperation involves high concern for other, while competition involves high concern for self.
Dual Concern Model
The dual concern model identifies five negotiation styles based on levels of concern for self and concern for other:
- Avoiding style: Low concern for both self and other.
- Dominating (or competing) style: High concern for self and low concern for other.
- Obliging (or accommodating) style: Low concern for self and high concern for other.
- Integrating (or collaborating or problem-solving) style: High concern for both self and other.
- Compromising style: Moderate concern for both self and other.
π Definition β Pareto-efficiency: The quality of a settlement agreement or other social arrangement to maximize overall value to the participants by allocating specific resources to those who value them most.
Avoiding Style
The avoiding style represents a low level of concern for both self and other. A turtle is a symbol for this style because it can avoid everything by pulling its head and legs into its shell. A turtle also chooses other styles at times; it does not always stay in its shell, as it would miss out on everything from eating to swimming.
Dominating or Competition Style
The dominating or competition style represents a high level of concern for self and a low level of concern for other. A lion can be a symbol of this style. The lion's roar helps it satisfy its interests. For example, if the lion's family is hungry, the lion may use strength and its loud roar to get food. However, the lion can also choose compromising or accommodating styles when playing or resting with a lion cub.
Obliging or Accommodating Style
The obliging or accommodating style represents a low level of concern for self and a high level of concern for other. A chameleon is a symbol because it changes its color to match its environment. Although the chameleon may always change its color, it may choose other styles when hunting, caring for young, or hiding from enemies.
Integrating or Cooperative Style
The integrating or cooperative style represents a high level of concern for both self and other. A dolphin usually chooses this cooperative problem-solving style. Dolphins use whistles and clicks to communicate to catch food cooperatively and to summon help. For example, when a dolphin is sick or injured, other dolphins will help it to the surface to breathe. However, if a dolphin has a baby and a shark is nearby, it will choose a competitive style to deal with the shark, as continuing cooperation would endanger the baby.
Compromising Style
The compromising style represents a moderate level of concern for both self and other. A zebra is a symbol because its unique stripes suggest it "split the difference" between black and white. However, a zebra may choose cooperative or competitive styles depending on the situation.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that negotiation is a primary method of alternative dispute resolution, and the choice of negotiation style is a strategic decision based on the conflict. Deutschβs model is limited because it only sees cooperation and competition as binary and fails to account for individual self-perception, cyclical behavior, and multiple forms of cooperation. The dual concern model provides a more complete framework, categorizing five styles based on concern for self and concern for other. Each styleβavoiding, dominating, obliging, integrating, and compromisingβhas an animal symbol and is appropriate only in specific situations, meaning no single style is always correct.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main reasons Deutschβs model of cooperation and competition is considered incomplete?
- According to the dual concern model, what are the five negotiation styles and what levels of concern for self and other does each represent?
- Which animal symbolizes the integrating or cooperative style, and what is a specific example of when this dolphin might switch to a competitive style?
- What is the definition of Pareto-efficiency in the context of negotiation?
- Why is a negotiation style considered a "strategy, not a tactic"?