π Lecture 11 β Sources and Causes of Conflict I
π Overview: This lecture explores the underlying reasons why conflicts emerge, emphasizing that the obvious cause is rarely the only or most important one. Understanding the multiple, often hidden sources of conflict is crucial for effective conflict mapping and resolution. The lecture introduces 12 main sources of conflict, providing explanations, examples, and useful approaches for each.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the source of conflict and explaining why understanding it matters, then introduces the concept of multiple sources operating simultaneously. It presents 12 main sources of conflict in detail: control over resources, data-type conflicts (over facts or law), preferences and nuisances, communication difficulties, differences in conflict orientation, values conflicts, threats to self-concept and world view, structural and interpersonal power issues, identity, displaced and misattributed conflict, and differing attributions of causation. Each source is explained with a definition, example, and suggested approach for resolution.
π Lecture Summary
Main objectives of this lecture
This lecture aims to teach that the obvious cause of an interpersonal conflict is seldom the only cause or even the most important one. Students will learn that sources of conflict are usually multiple and many of them are hidden, and there is a need to determine and understand many sources of conflict. The lecture covers 12 main sources of many conflicts.
Source of conflict
The source of an interpersonal conflict is the underlying reason for the emergence of conflict. Understanding and conceptually organizing the sources of conflict can greatly help improve the chances of resolving the conflict. Understanding human behavior can help reveal the motivations of individuals involved in the conflict. While interest analysis illuminates the motivations of individual conflict participants, the process of identifying the sources of conflict illuminates the features of the relationship among conflict participants that foster conflict.
Main Sources of Conflict
Following are the main sources of conflict:
- Resources
- Data-type or about facts or laws
- Preferences and nuisances
- Differing attributions of causation
- Communication problems
- Differences in conflict orientation
- Structural or interpersonal power
- Identity
- Values
- Displaced and misattributed
Multiple sources of conflict
It is vital to know that there are usually multiple sources of any given conflict. Leaving one or more sources of conflict may aggravate conflict. That is why you have to think through coolly and sleep over it. It will improve your understanding about the conflict.
Conflict between two partners
The lecture illustrates the concept of multiple sources with a diagram showing a conflict between Partner 1 (who does day-to-day work) and Partner 2 (who supplied the venture capital). The conflict appears to be about the distribution of revenues. At the tip of the iceberg, this appears to be a resource and data-type conflict (who's entitled to how much revenue?), but the hidden conflict involves threats to identity and self-concept.
Control over resources
Conflict type: Control over resources Explanation: Disputant's degree over control of valued items or struggle over ownership of scarce commodities Example: The dispute is between neighbours over property boundaries Useful approach: Many conflicts that appear at first glance to be resource conflicts can be resolved by understanding and dealing with deeper sources of conflict that may be operating (tactics aimed at expanding the pie).
Data-type conflicts: conflicts over facts
Conflict type: Data-type conflicts over facts Explanation: The conflict is over reality, either past or present Example: Two drivers disagree over who drifted into whose traffic lane Useful approach: Sometimes, a focus on satisfying the underlying interests of the disputants avoids the need to resolve the factual issue. If not, these types of conflicts can be resolved through fact finding, non-binding evaluation, or adjudication. Many disputes over facts mask other, deeper conflicts.
Data-type conflicts: conflicts over law
Conflict type: Data-type conflicts over law Explanation: The disagreement is over how the law impacts the relationship between the disputants Example: The disagreement is between divorcing spouses over the appropriate appraisal and allocation of property rights Useful approach: Ironically, litigation is probably the least desirable way to handle most of these kinds of conflicts, because they typically arise when the law is vague. Often, the best tactic is for the disputants to educate themselves about the law (to verify the degree of uncertainty), then to engage in principle negotiation aimed at developing solutions that accommodate mutual interests. Litigation should be used primarily when the legal conflict masks a dispute over social structure and interpersonal power imbalance.
Preferences and nuisances
Conflict type: Preferences and nuisances Explanation: One disputant's behaviour disturbs the other Example: Factory runoff pollutes the stream of a landowner who loves to fish Useful approach: These types of disputes are particularly amenable to creative problem solving that acknowledges and seeks to preserve the underlying interests of the disputant but rearranges the environment, modify people's schedules, and so on.
Communication difficulties
Conflict type: Communication difficulties Explanation: The meanings of language and behaviour may be misunderstood Example: Frequently, self-interested tactics on the part of one disputant are misunderstood by an opponent Useful approach: Approaches include becoming familiar with the other disputant and his or her cultural practices; using active listening; hiring a mediator, an agent, a consultant who shares the cultural background of the other disputant, or a translator.
Differences in conflict orientation
Conflict type: Differences in conflict orientation Explanation: There are differences in the basic approach to relationship. One disputant sees the relationship of the parties as mutually cooperative. The other disputant is basically competitive. Example: Not explicitly given, but suggested by the explanation Useful approach: It helps resolve the conflict if the disputants recognize the style differences to minimize communication difficulties that result from differences in conflict orientation. The cooperative disputant can refuse to negotiate unless the parties agree to use a set of objective principles to guide the negotiation. The cooperator may need to signal a willingness to fight hard if the other disputant fails to act cooperatively.
Values conflicts
Conflict type: Values Explanation: Conflicts are over personal beliefs and deeply held values Example: Ongoing conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan may have religious origins, which include values conflicts Useful approach: Sometimes, values conflicts can be resolved if the disputants can agree to disagree about the underlying values, as when a disputant agrees to go along with a settlement without admitting liability. Values conflicts are difficult to resolve peacefully if the values involved are central to the self-concepts or world views of the disputants or if coupled with many other sources of conflict, such as disputes over limited resources.
Threats to self-concept and world view
Conflict type: Threats to self-concept and world view Explanation: What disputant's viewpoint threatens the other disputant's central ideas about him- or herself or about how the world works Examples:
- In a medical malpractice case, the patient's allegations of negligence threaten the physician's self-concept as a competent professional
- An employee's allegation of racism on the part of a supervisor threatens the supervisor's self-concept as racially tolerant
Useful approach: As with values conflicts, occasionally these conflicts can be managed by having the disputants agree to disagree while implementing a solution that threatens neither disputant's self-concept or world view. It helps to use negotiation tactics that confirm and protect the dignity of each participant. Sometimes, these conflicts can be handled through the use of negotiating agents. Conflicts based on the negative stereotypes held by one social group about another social group are very difficult to resolve.
Structural and inter-personal power issues
Conflict type: Structural and inter-personal power issues Explanation: A disputant perceives an unjust balance of power and struggles to rectify it Example: School integration and affirmative action disputes are examples Useful approach: The more powerful disputant is generally unwilling to give up power and may honestly fail to see that a power imbalance exists. If this disputant is made aware of this imbalance, sometimes he or she can be convinced to give up power to preserve long-term social structure, avoid violence struggle, or make his or her own actions consistent with deeply held values (as when discriminatory laws are pointed out as being inconsistent with national values of equality and equal rights). Frequently, however, appeal to a more powerful authority (e.g., litigation) is the only method that produces lasting change.
Summary
Understanding the sources of conflict will make you go through the multiple sources of conflict. It has been noted that identifying all the sources of conflict is very important for mapping the conflict and then resolving the conflict. While mapping the conflict, try to keep in mind all the sources of the conflict.
β Key Takeaways
The single most critical insight from this lecture is that conflicts rarely have a single causeβthe visible disagreement (like a dispute over money or property) is often just the "tip of the iceberg," masking deeper, hidden sources such as threats to identity, values conflicts, or power imbalances. Students must memorize the 12 main sources of conflict and understand that effective conflict resolution requires identifying and addressing ALL sources, not just the most obvious one. For each source type, remember the specific useful approach: resource conflicts may require expanding the pie; data conflicts may need fact-finding or principle negotiation; values and identity conflicts may need "agree to disagree" strategies with dignity protection; power conflicts may require appeal to higher authority. The "conflict between two partners" example perfectly illustrates how a seemingly simple resource conflict can hide deeper identity threats. Finally, the lecture emphasizes that litigation is often the least desirable option for legal conflicts, useful primarily when the legal dispute masks a power imbalance.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does it mean that the "obvious cause" of an interpersonal conflict is the "tip of the iceberg"?
- List at least 8 of the 12 main sources of conflict covered in this lecture.
- Why is litigation described as "probably the least desirable way" to handle data-type conflicts over law?
- What is the recommended approach for resolving conflicts involving "threats to self-concept and world view"?
- In the "conflict between two partners" example, what is the visible source and what is the hidden source of the conflict?
π Lecture 12 β Sources and Causes of Conflict II
π Overview: This lecture continues the inventory of major sources of conflict, providing a detailed typology of conflict types. Understanding these sources is crucial for identifying the root cause of a dispute, which is the first step toward effective resolution. The lecture covers eight distinct conflict types, each with explanations, examples, and tailored approaches for resolution.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture presents a comprehensive table of conflict types, including preferences and nuisances, communication difficulties, differences in conflict orientation, values conflicts, threats to self-concept and world view, structural and interpersonal power issues, differing attributions of causation, displaced conflict, and misattributed conflict. Each type is defined with an example and a recommended useful approach for management.
π Lecture Summary
Continuing Inventory of Major Sources of Conflict
The lecture emphasizes that knowing the sources of conflict can help resolve conflicts more easily and successfully. The inventory continues from the previous lecture.
Preferences and Nuisances
This conflict type arises when one disputant's behavior disturbs the other. Example: Factory runoff pollutes the stream of a landowner who loves to fish. The useful approach involves creative problem solving that acknowledges and seeks to preserve the underlying interests of the disputants but rearranges the environment, modifies peopleβs schedules, and so on.
π Definition β Preferences and Nuisances: A conflict type where one disputantβs behavior disturbs the other. π Example: Factory runoff pollutes a fishing landowner's stream. Steps: Acknowledge both parties' interests (landowner wants clean water for fishing; factory needs to operate), then creatively rearrange the environment (e.g., install filtration) or modify schedules.
Communication Difficulties
This conflict type occurs when the meanings of language and behavior may be misunderstood. Example: Self-interested tactics on the part of one disputant are misunderstood by an opponent. Useful approaches include becoming familiar with the other disputant and their cultural practices, using active listening, and hiring a mediator, an agent, a consultant who shares the cultural background of the other disputant, or a translator.
π Definition β Communication Difficulties: A conflict type where the meanings of language and behavior may be misunderstood. π Example: Self-interested tactics are misunderstood by an opponent. Steps: Use active listening, hire a mediator, or become familiar with the other party's cultural practices.
Differences in Conflict Orientation
This conflict type arises from differences in the basic approach to relationship: one disputant sees the relationship as mutually cooperative, while the other is basically competitive. Useful approaches include: recognizing the style differences to minimize communication difficulties; having the cooperative disputant refuse to negotiate unless the parties agree to use a set of objective principles; and signaling a willingness to fight hard if the other disputant fails to act cooperatively.
π Definition β Differences in Conflict Orientation: A conflict type where there are differences in the basic approach to relationship, such as one party being cooperative and the other competitive. π Example: A cooperative partner negotiates with a competitive partner. Steps: Recognize style differences; refuse to negotiate without objective principles; signal willingness to fight hard if needed.
Values
Conflicts over personal beliefs and deeply held values. Example: Ongoing conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan may have religious origins. Sometimes resolvable if disputants agree to disagree, as when a disputant agrees to a settlement without admitting liability. Values conflicts are difficult to resolve peacefully if the values involved are central to self-concepts or world views, or if coupled with other sources like disputes over limited resources.
π Definition β Values Conflicts: Conflicts over personal beliefs and deeply held values. π Example: Religious conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan. Steps: Agree to disagree on underlying values; implement a settlement without admitting liability. π‘ Why this matters: These are very difficult to resolve if values are central to identity.
Threats to Self-Concept and World View
This conflict type occurs when what one disputant's viewpoint threatens the other disputant's central ideas about him/herself or about how the world works. Example: In medical malpractice, allegations threaten the physician's self-concept as competent; an employee's allegation of racism threatens a supervisor's self-concept as tolerant. Useful approaches: agree to disagree while implementing a solution that threatens neither side; use negotiation tactics that confirm and protect dignity; use negotiating agents. Conflicts based on negative stereotypes are very difficult to resolve.
π Definition β Threats to Self-Concept and World View: A conflict type where a disputant's viewpoint threatens the other's central ideas about themselves or how the world works. π Example: Medical malpractice allegations threaten a physician's self-concept. Steps: Agree to disagree; use dignity-confirming tactics; hire negotiating agents.
Structural and Interpersonal Power Issues
Occurs when a disputant perceives an unjust balance of power and struggles to rectify it. Example: School integration and affirmative action disputes. The more powerful disputant is often unwilling to give up power and may not see the imbalance. If made aware, the powerful party can sometimes be convinced to give up power to preserve social structure, avoid violence, or align actions with values. Frequently, however, appeal to a more powerful authority (e.g., litigation) is the only method that produces lasting change.
π Definition β Structural and Interpersonal Power Issues: A conflict type where a disputant perceives an unjust balance of power and struggles to rectify it. π Example: School integration disputes. Steps: Make the powerful party aware of the imbalance; appeal to authority (litigation) if necessary.
Differing Attributions of Causation
Each disputant believes the existing state of affairs is due to a different cause and thus warrants a different remedy. Example: In a products liability case, the manufacturer contends the product was treated improperly, while the consumer contends the product is defective. Some attributional disputes are data-type conflicts (e.g., did she kick the washing machine?) while others are values conflicts (e.g., the machine should be built to handle occasional violence). The most effective treatment depends on the kind of attributional conflict involved.
π Definition β Differing Attributions of Causation: A conflict type where each disputant believes the existing state of affairs is due to a different cause. π Example: Manufacturer says product was misused; consumer says it's defective. Steps: Determine if it's a data conflict or a values conflict; treat accordingly.
Displaced Conflict
Occurs when there is an unacknowledged conflict and the disputants are disputing over something else. Example: Business partners with an unacknowledged conflict over allocation of rights dispute about a minor aspect of the business. The underlying conflict should be uncovered and diagnosed. A mediator is often useful. Unfortunately, the underlying conflict is often deep-rooted and difficult to resolve.
π Definition β Displaced Conflict: A conflict type where there is an unacknowledged conflict and the disputants are disputing over something else. π Example: Business partners argue over a minor issue due to a hidden conflict over rights and responsibilities. Steps: Uncover and diagnose the real conflict; use a mediator.
Misattributed Conflict
Occurs when there is an unacknowledged conflict and one disputant picks a fight with someone else. Example: A teen living in grinding poverty loses his temper and fights with a neighbor. It is important to uncover the real conflict to avoid repetitions. Often, the underlying conflict is a structural/power issue the disputant feels powerless to change. Sometimes, former disputants, once aware of the misattribution, can band together to address the real problems.
π Definition β Misattributed Conflict: A conflict type where there is an unacknowledged conflict and one disputant picks a fight with someone else. π Example: A poor teen takes out anger on a neighbor instead of addressing poverty. Steps: Uncover the real conflict (structural/power issue); band together to address the real problem.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember the nine distinct types of conflict sources: Preferences and Nuisances, Communication Difficulties, Differences in Conflict Orientation, Values, Threats to Self-Concept and World View, Structural/Interpersonal Power Issues, Differing Attributions of Causation, Displaced Conflict, and Misattributed Conflict. Each type has a specific cause and requires a tailored resolution approach, ranging from creative problem solving and active listening to agreeing to disagree, using mediators, or appealing to higher authorities. Critically, values conflicts and threats to self-concept are the most difficult to resolve, especially when coupled with other issues. Displaced and misattributed conflicts require uncovering the real, often deep-rooted, underlying issue.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a displaced conflict and a misattributed conflict?
- Explain why values conflicts are particularly difficult to resolve peacefully.
- What is the recommended approach for managing communication difficulties in a conflict?
- In a structural and interpersonal power issue dispute, what is a common limitation of trying to persuade the more powerful party to give up power?
- According to the lecture, what distinguishes a "data-type" attributional dispute from a "values" attributional dispute?
π Lecture 13 β Interest Analysis I
π Overview: This lecture introduces interest analysis as a critical step in conflict diagnosis. It explains the distinction between positions (what people say they want) and interests (why they want it), and explores the negative consequences of positional bargaining. The lecture emphasizes the importance of analyzing both one's own interests and those of the other disputant to achieve optimal conflict resolution.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition of interests and interest analysis, the distinction between positions and underlying interests, the process of analyzing one's own interests during conflict, the concept of positional bargaining and its three negative consequences, the advantages of knowing one's team's interests, the seven purposes of interest analysis, and the five key points for analyzing the other disputant's interests.
π Lecture Summary
Quotations
The lecture opens with a quote from La Bruyere: "The shortest and best way to make your fortune is to let people see clearly that is in their best interests to promote yours."
Interests
Interests may be defined as a sense of concern with and curiosity about someone or something. The motivations that individuals have during a conflict, including positions (demands), aspirations, underlying interests, principles, values, and basic needs may be described as interests.
Interests analysis
Interest analysis is perhaps the most critical step in the conflict diagnosis process. A systematic exploration of a conflict participant's interests is called interest analysis. Briefly stated, interests analysis is the development of an accurate and complete understanding of each conflict participant's positions, aspirations, interests, needs and values in relation to the interpersonal conflict. Interest analysis includes an explanation of all the underlying interests, needs, and values of each conflict participant, as well as an exploration of how all link together and are organized.
An effective interest analysis can mean the difference between grudging settlement and real satisfaction. Interests motivate people; they are the silent movers behind the positions people take. Your position is something you have decided upon your interests. So, interest is something what caused someone to decide something. What people normally say they want out of a conflict are positions, whereas the why of people shows what people want are interests.
π Definition β Interests: The motivations that individuals have during a conflict, including positions, aspirations, underlying interests, principles, values, and basic needs.
Analyzing your interests
When you are involved in an interpersonal conflict, your thought processes are often clouded or diverted by strong emotions and stress. People caught up in a conflict often focus on the lines they have drawn in the sand β their positions β and on beating the other disputant β rather than on getting what is best for them.
Analyzing your interests also allows you to develop flexibility in your bargaining position, so that you can find better ways of attaining an agreement. In most negotiated agreements, "the devil is in the details"; failing to make effective arrangements for delivery, payment, and so forth can make the difference between a good sale and a very bad one.
Finally, using interest analysis allows you to avoid the negative consequences of drawing lines in the sand, known in the conflict resolution field as positional bargaining.
Positional bargaining
A process of negotiation that involves each disputant taking successively more moderate positions in hopes that eventually a compromise will result is described as positional bargaining.
π Definition β Positional bargaining: A negotiation process involving each disputant taking successively more moderate positions in hopes that eventually a compromise will result.
Negative consequences of positional bargaining
There are three negative consequences of positional bargaining:
- Becoming locked into position psychologically β regardless of whether a better option is available
- Becoming blinded to issues unrelated to your position
- Seeing the other disputant as the enemy, leading to an unnecessary impasse and additional "spinoff" conflicts
π‘ Why this matters: Positional bargaining creates a competitive, win-lose dynamic that often prevents parties from discovering creative solutions that could satisfy everyone's underlying interests.
Advantages of knowing your team's interests
Following are the advantages of knowing the team's interests:
- Gain a clearer understanding of your goals
- Clarify what interests would be best met in resolving this conflict and what interests would be better met elsewhere
- Develop flexibility in bargaining, so that a good settlement is more attainable
- Avoid the problems of positional bargaining
- Positional bargaining makes enemies.
Purpose of Interest Analysis
Here are the purposes of interest analysis:
- It promotes clear thinking and prevents inappropriate decision making resulting from emotional arousal and stress
- It helps clarify what one wants and needs, and helps the user rank interests in relation to one another
- It helps user visualize and recognize alternate ways to meet goals
- It creates greater flexibility in coming to settlement
- It ensures user isn't diverted by details, hot emotion, heat of the moment, and so on
- It ensures user doesn't miss an optimal resolution
- It enables user to evaluate whether some interests could be met outside the conflict
Analyzing the other disputant's interests
Besides analyzing one's own interests and those of one's principal, it is also important to analyze the interests of the other disputant. Here are important points regarding analysis of other disputant's interests:
- Greater likelihood of settlement on optimal terms: ability to appeal to other disputant's desires while meeting your own goals
- Avoid settling for less than you could get
- Minimizing the likelihood of settlement sabotage by appealing to the other disputant's interests
- Avoid positional bargaining
- If coercion becomes necessary, allows one to design more effective pressure
β Key Takeaways
The central lesson is that interests β the underlying motivations, needs, and values β drive conflict behavior, not the surface-level positions people state. Effective conflict resolution requires systematic interest analysis of both yourself and the other disputant. Positional bargaining (taking successively moderate positions to reach compromise) has three major negative consequences: psychological lock-in, blindness to other issues, and perceiving the other as an enemy. Knowing your team's interests provides five advantages including clarity of goals, flexibility, and avoiding the problems of positional bargaining. Finally, analyzing the other disputant's interests increases likelihood of optimal settlement and allows for more effective pressure if needed.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a "position" and an "interest" in conflict resolution?
- What are the three negative consequences of positional bargaining?
- List at least four of the seven purposes of interest analysis.
- What are the five advantages of knowing your team's interests?
- Why is it important to analyze the other disputant's interests, in addition to your own?
π Lecture 14 β Interest Analysis II
π Overview: This lecture deepens the analysis of conflict interests introduced previously. It explains how to analyze the interests of all participants, including constituents, stakeholders, and agents, to prevent sabotage and craft better solutions. The lecture introduces the Interest Tree diagram as a tool to map the hierarchical relationship between superficial and fundamental interests, and the Conflict Onion model to visualize the layers of a conflict.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers analyzing the interests of constituents and stakeholders, and the advantages of interest analysis for different parties. It then explores the interests analysis of agents and advocates, defines what interests are, explains why we diagram interests, and teaches how to build an Interest Tree with a detailed example and tips. Finally, it introduces the Conflict Onion model, explaining its layers: positions, aspirations, deeper interests, principles/values, and basic human needs.
π Lecture Summary
Analyzing the interests of constituents and stakeholders
Constituents and stakeholders are affected by a conflict's course and outcome. Their connection to the disputants can significantly affect potential settlements, for good or ill. It is crucial to uncover conflicting interests that might lead to undermining negotiation or sabotaging a settlement. The ultimate result can be improved by taking account of what others are likely to do. For example, in a divorce case, the children's interests should be analyzed carefully, as without understanding them, the children may themselves contribute to the destruction of the agreements. An interest analysis should also include the agents and advocates for the other disputant, as their interests add to the complexity of motivations.
Advantages of interests analysis
The analysis provides specific advantages for different participants. For the disputant, it clarifies what they really want, enables consideration of whether interests are better met outside the conflict, enables greater flexibility, and avoids positional bargaining. For the other disputant, it enables crafting appealing proposals, avoids errors of judgment, prevents sabotage from unaddressed deep-seated interests, and allows tailoring coercive measures. For constituents and stakeholders, it allows proactive action to avoid later sabotage. For disputants' own agents and advocates, it reveals possible conflicts of interest. For agents or advocates for the other disputant, it reveals how their conflicts of interest may make resolution more difficult.
Interests analysis of agents and advocates
An interest analysis should explore the interests, values, and needs of the agents and advocates on all sides of the conflict. The principal reason to include one's own agents and advocates is to clarify whether they have problematic conflicts of interest with their principal. This analysis helps to better understand the complexities of what is motivating the "other team" and to develop coping strategies. Developing an understanding of the motivators of other team members allows one to strategize to cope with such conflicts.
What are interests?
Interests are emotions, drives, needs, principles, values, preferences, likes and dislikesβthe forces that move you to an action. These interests are the drives or motivators of human behavior. Since one individual has many interests related in a complex way, and parties to a conflict are multiple, understanding the logical relationship among them is hard. That is why we diagram the relationships among various interests.
π Definition β Interests: Emotions, drives, needs, principles, values, preferences, likes and dislikes, or the forces that move you to an action.
Why diagram interests?
Superficial interests are logically connected to more fundamental interests. The concept of an interest tree diagram is used to represent the hierarchical and logical relationships between interests. It clarifies which fundamental interests underlie more superficial interests. Because superficial interests are "driven" by the deeper ones, clarifying these logical connections allows one to concede on superficial interests while standing firm on more fundamental interests. Looking at interests of others allows one to appeal to deeper interests as an "end run" around more superficial demands. Diagramming the interests of others creates the knowledge base needed to develop effective negotiation and other resolution strategies.
Interest Tree Example
The lecture provides an example of an Interest Tree for a conflict participant whose position is "I demand $20,000 or I sue!" The tree maps from a POSITION ("I demand $20,000 or I sue!") to:
- ASPIRATIONS: "I'd take anything over $10,000 if I can avoid court!"
- INTERESTS: "Get back out-of-pocket losses" and "Avoid court: risky!"
- PRINCIPLES and VALUES: "People should be fairly paid," "Wrongdoers should be punished," and "Brother-in-law will think I'm spineless if I don't get good result"
- NEEDS: Deficiency needs (food, shelter, safety, clothing), Esteem needs, Identity needs, and Security needs
The diagram shows how the position "Get fair settlement" connects to deeper principles and ultimately to basic human needs like "Need money now: can't pay rent" and "Avoid time, expense of court."
Tips for Interest Trees
An interest tree must include the following points:
- There must always be needs β other elements are optional
- There may be multiple levels of underlying interests
- Each position, aspiration, interest, and principle/value rectangle must logically relate (directly or indirectly) to one or more need rectangles
- Don't confuse interests with facts or contentions
π‘ Why this matters: The "Always ask WHY!" rule is the core technique for building an Interest Tree. For example, asking "Why is it important for you to get compensated fairly?" reveals the underlying value of justice.
Conflict Onion
The Conflict Onion is a model that visualizes a conflict as having multiple layers. The layers, from outermost to innermost, are:
Positions: A stated demand of a conflict participant; no stated demand means no position. Aspirations: Concrete aspirations may also be absent. For example, highly experienced negotiators may avoid either positions or aspirations altogether and start their analysis with interests. Underlying interests: There may be more than one level of underlying interests, with more superficial interests being driven by deeper ones. Principles, values: The core principles and values that drive the deeper interests. Basic human needs: The most fundamental layer, representing core human needs.
For example, an auto purchaser may have an interest in reliable transportation, and his deeper interest may be to get reliably to work every day.
π Definition β Conflict Onion: A model showing the layers of a conflict: positions (outermost), aspirations, underlying interests, principles/values, and basic human needs (innermost).
β Key Takeaways
The lecture emphasizes that understanding and analyzing interests is crucial for successful conflict resolution. The Interest Tree is a practical tool for visualizing the logical connection between superficial demands and deeper, fundamental needs, allowing a negotiator to concede on surface issues while standing firm on core values. The Conflict Onion provides a complementary model showing the layers of a conflict from positions down to basic human needs. A key rule is to always include needs in an Interest Tree and to avoid confusing interests with facts. Finally, analyzing the interests of all participants, including constituents, stakeholders, and agents, is essential to prevent sabotage and craft lasting settlements.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is it important to analyze the interests of constituents and stakeholders in a conflict?
- List three specific advantages of interest analysis for the disputant themselves.
- Explain the core reason for diagramming interests using an Interest Tree.
- According to the tips for Interest Trees, what is the one element that must always be present?
- What are the five layers of the Conflict Onion, listed from outermost to innermost?
π Lecture 15 β Interest Analysis II
π Overview: This lecture delves deeper into the layers of the Conflict Onion, moving beyond underlying interests to explore principles, values, and basic human needs. It explains how these deep-seated drivers influence conflict behavior and provides theoretical frameworks like Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs and Erikson's Psychosocial Development to diagnose and understand disputants' core motivations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture examines principles and values as a layer of the conflict onion, distinguishing genuine beliefs from rationalizations. It introduces distributive and procedural justice as key concepts. It then explores basic human needs, using Maslow's hierarchy of needs and Erik Erikson's theory of psychosocial development to understand the deep motivations that drive conflict behavior, which are often not directly articulated by disputants.
π Lecture Summary
Quotations
Kehlog Albran's quote humorously suggests that even the most difficult tasks can be accomplished with a little clever lubrication. Philip D. Armour's quote reveals that his stated interest in money is a surface-level expression of a deeper interest in personal success and winning in business conflicts, illustrating that true interests often lie beneath the surface.
Principles and values
Principles and values are a key layer in the conflict onion, representing the moral codes and beliefs that influence a disputant's interests. A conflict diagnostician must be able to distinguish between values held as honest, deeply held beliefs and those used disingenuously as a rationalization for a position. Principles and values are closely tied to basic human needs, especially the need for esteem from others and a stable, positive sense of self. π‘ Why this matters: Understanding whether a stated principle is a core value or a tactical argument is critical for finding a resolution that addresses the real conflict.
Justice and basic principles/values
The need for justice is one of the most basic human needs and is an intrinsic part of almost all interpersonal conflict. An outcome that violates a participantβs sense of justice is likely to fail. There are two major types of justice: distributive justice and procedural justice.
π Definition β Distributive Justice: Concerned with whether the outcome of a conflict is fair. π Formula: Fair outcome β determined by three principles:
- Equity: Resources allocated based on contributions. Most relied upon when groups need to be motivated as a group.
- Equality: Resources allocated equally. Most prominent when there is a high need for group cohesion.
- Need: Resources allocated to those who need them most. For example, a judge orders child support based on the family's need. π Example: A work team receives a bonus. If the team is focused on motivation, the bonus would be distributed based on individual performance (Equity). If the team needs to improve cohesion, the bonus would be split equally (Equality).
π Definition β Procedural Justice: Refers to the fairness of the process used to reach a given outcome. It is extremely important for lending a sense of legitimacy to a conflict resolution process that imposes an outcome on the disputants.
Basic Human Needs
Basic human needs lie at the very heart of the conflict onion, deeper than principles and values. People often cannot easily verbalize these needs; they must be inferred from what they say and do and the circumstances they are in. A good interest analysis must include basic human needs, as failure to address them creates pressure for them to be expressed in other ways. Theories about human development provide guidance for a conflict diagnostician.
Interests and the Conflict Onion
The lecture provides a table defining the five layers of the conflict onion:
| Kind of Interest | Definition |
|---|---|
| Position | The demand the disputant makes to others |
| Aspiration | The bottom line the disputant is looking for |
| Underlying Interests | The reasons for the aspirations |
| Principles and Values | Beliefs and moral codes that influence the interests |
| Basic Human Needs | Underlying needs that drive the motivations of the disputant |
Maslowβs Need Theory
Abraham Maslow's theory explains that people have a drive to satisfy human needs organized hierarchically. The most basic deficiency needs (physiological, safety) must be mostly satisfied before a person is motivated to address higher-level being needs (self-actualization).
π Definition β Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs: A motivational theory in psychology comprising a five-tier model of human needs, often depicted as hierarchical levels within a pyramid. π Formula: Lower needs β must be satisfied β to be motivated by higher needs. π Example: A person who is struggling to find food and shelter (physiological and safety needs) is unlikely to be motivated by a conflict about their reputation or esteem. Their core motivation will be driven by their unmet basic needs. Conversely, a person whose basic needs are secure will be more motivated by needs for belonging, esteem, and self-actualization.
Erik Eriksonβs Theory
Erik Erikson's theory of psychosocial development posits that healthy development over the human lifespan follows a set course, with particular life stages associated with particular overriding concerns. Knowing a person's approximate age can provide clues to their deep-seated motivations. Poorly resolved stages can cause people to get "stuck," and these underlying motivations often drive irrational conflict.
| Stage | Approx. Age | Psychosocial Crisis (Challenge) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Birth-1 yr | Trust vs. Mistrust |
| 2 | 1-3 yr | Autonomy vs. Shame, Doubt |
| 3 | 3-6 yr | Initiative vs. Guilt |
| 4 | 6-12 yr | Industry vs. Inferiority |
| 5 | Adolescence | Identity vs. Role Confusion |
| 6 | Young adult | Intimacy vs. Isolation |
| 7 | Middle age | Generativity vs. Stagnation |
| 8 | Late adult | Ego Integrity vs. Despair |
π Example: An employee in late adulthood (Stage 8) who is embroiled in a conflict over a small procedural issue might be motivated by a deep need for ego integrityβa need to have the story of their career be one of being right and principled. A middle-aged manager (Stage 7) in conflict might be driven by a need for generativityβwanting to leave a legacy or mentor a team, and a process that denies them this feels like stagnation.
β Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must remember the conflict onion's five layers, with basic human needs being the deepest. Understand the critical distinction between distributive justice (fairness of outcome) and procedural justice (fairness of process) and their three principles (equity, equality, need). You must be able to apply both Maslow's hierarchy of needs and Erikson's eight stages of psychosocial development as diagnostic tools to infer the deep-seated motivations that drive irrational or persistent conflict. Finally, remember that disputants cannot always verbalize their basic human needs; these must be inferred from their behavior and circumstances.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between distributive justice and procedural justice?
- What are the three principles used to determine distributive justice, and give a scenario where each is most applicable?
- According to Maslow's hierarchy, why might a person not be motivated by a conflict over social recognition?
- In which of Erikson's stages would a person's primary life challenge involve developing enduring intimate relationships, and what is the associated crisis?
- Why is it important for a conflict diagnostician to distinguish between legitimately held principles and values and those used as a rationalization?