๐ Lecture 6 โ Conflict Diagnosis
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of conflict diagnosis as a structured process for understanding and responding to interpersonal conflicts. It explores how different perspectives (time, person, issues) affect conflict evaluation, outlines ten specific steps for diagnosing conflicts, and explains the Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) movement, including its efficiency and radical perspectives.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers conflict diagnosis as a framework for understanding interpersonal conflicts, including its definition and importance. It examines various perspectives on conflict handling (time, person, and issues) and identifies who benefits from conflict diagnosis (conflict gamers, conflict phobics, and conflict professionals). The lecture details ten steps in conflict diagnosis, from mapping the conflict to considering diversity issues. Finally, it discusses the ADR movement, comparing efficiency and radical perspectives on ADR and addressing quality concerns.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction
Conflict is everywhere and part of everyday life. Some periods of conflict provoke periods of great creativity. Competition is a form of conflict that helps individuals, groups, communities, societies, and countries to outpace others, resulting in excellence. Conflict may be constructive as well as destructive.
Conflict Diagnosis
Conflict diagnosis is a structured process for understanding and responding to interpersonal conflicts, disputes, and transactions. Conflict diagnosis provides a rigorous and clear framework for understanding and appreciating the multiple facets of any conflict. It also serves as a clear guide for the development of strategies for addressing conflict, including the selection of dispute resolution processes and providers. In a sense, conflict diagnosis provides the basis for designing methods of producing maximally good conflict in any conflict situation. Conflict resolution poses the most pain and the least gain when the parties are able to cooperate rather than having an adversarial approach.
Perspectives on the Handling of Interpersonal Conflict
An evaluation of interpersonal conflict depends on how it is handled. Conflict diagnosis allows the user to choose the best blueprint and the best tools to handle a conflict well. Conflict can have positive and negative consequences. Perspective is critical in discussing positive and negative consequences of interpersonal conflict.
a. Time perspective
- Short-term
- Intermediate-term
- Long-term
b. Person perspective
- Individual-disputant
- Joint-disputant
- Systemic
- Institution or society-wide
c. Issues perspective
- Process versus outcome
- Narrow versus broad focus
- Monetary or economic versus non-monetary, tangible or intangible
- Prospective versus retrospective
Who Needs to Know About Conflict Diagnosis?
Everyone can benefit from understanding conflict diagnosis. Legal and dispute professionals, such as lawyers, paralegals, professional negotiators, and others involved in dispute resolution, need to know the principles of conflict diagnosis so that they can do their job intelligently.
I. Conflict gamers and conflict phobics Conflict gamers love interpersonal conflict and feel the most alive when up to their necks in it. They donโt seem to need to prepare for a negotiationโtheir innate personality and temperament alone seem to be preparation enough. They jump at the chance for a rumble. In a negotiation, they seem utterly fearless. They are always ready to inflict punishment on their adversaries. After litigation is over, win or lose, over drinks or lunch conflict gamers express what a profound pleasure it all was, what a rush, and how it resembled the happy days they once spent in high school.
On the other hand, for a conflict phobic, the conflict diagnosis has many important advantages to offer. It will give clear guidance when conflict arises. It will help the conflict phobic to understand what to do when he/she feels unprepared and doesnโt know how to prepare.
II. Conflict professionals Conflict diagnosis is also for conflict professionals and professionals-in-training seeking to enrich their understanding of their field. For example, for a lawyer, a judge, a paralegal, etc., the course will help a lot in diagnosing conflict and applying ADR techniques for conflict management. Applying these techniques to conflicts enables conflict professionals to find the magic keys to unlocking their clientsโ potential power to settle their differences.
Why Conduct Conflict Diagnosis?
Conflict diagnosis empowers and calms โconflict phobics.โ It provides additional options for โconflict gamers.โ It allows better choice of dispute resolution processes.
Steps in Conflict Diagnosis
- Describe/map the conflict โ Map out the conflict, identifying the roles of the participants.
- Identify sources โ Identify the sources and the causes of the conflict.
- Analyze interests โ Identify each participantโs aspirations, positions, interests, principles and values, and basic needs, and consider how they interrelate logically. Identify any linked conflicts and consider how the conflicts affect one another.
- Characterize the conflict โ Characterize the conflict as cooperative, competitive, or in between. If a cooperative conflict, identify attributes of the situation that could cause it to become competitive.
- Consider trust โ Analyze the kinds and level of trust present in the relationship between the disputant and other participants in the conflict.
- Identify impediments to settlement โ Identify any impediments to cooperative settlement.
- Address negotiation styles and preferences โ Assess the negotiation styles of the participants in the conflict, consider how these styles have an impact on the conflict, and if possible develop plans for encouraging cooperation and collaboration among the participants.
- Consider power โ Analyze each participantโs power. Analyze the sources of power, the ways in which each participant could exercise each source of power, the likely impact of its exercise, and ways that this source of power could be increased.
- Identify/maximize the Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement (BATNA) โ Develop a list of alternatives to a negotiated agreement, including the best alternative to a negotiated agreement, or BATNA. If you are a disputant, agent, or an advocate, develop plans for clarifying these alternatives and improving them.
- Consider diversity issues โ Choose a dispute resolution process, or a series of processes, appropriate to the conflict diagnosis. Select practitioners best able to meet your goals in the processes. If necessary, negotiate the dispute resolution selection processes with other conflict participants.
๐ Step 9 Formula: BATNA = Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement โ The best available option if negotiation fails; used as leverage and a fallback position in negotiations.
Using Conflict Diagnosis Ideas to Understand the ADR Movement
ADR as Movement (in USA and in India) Some forms of ADR, such as religion-based or community-based mediation and commercial arbitration, have been around for centuries. In the USA, mediation and other forms of ADR have been used for legal disputes since about 1970 and became mainstream in the late 1980s and 1990s.
Efficiency and radical perspectives on ADR
Efficiency perspective In this root of the ADR tree, ADR is seen primarily through the prism of efficiency. ADR is useful for cutting costs, speeding settlements, and avoiding overburdening the courts. From this perspective, the type of ADR used is less important than the availability and use of ADR in any form.
Radical perspective The radical wing of ADR takes a very different perspective. ADR is useful for improving the resolution of conflicts, allocating resources among disputants, improving disputant relationships, and reforming overall cultural attitudes about conflict resolution.
Prevalence of efficiency perspective Economic forces tend to support ADR to save time, money, and court resources. The efficiency wing has been more influential, and because this wing cares less about the form of ADR used, certain looseness with ADR terminology is rampant. Traditional culture has influenced the development of language about ADR. Efficiency of ADR is important. ADR is controlled by the invisible veil, structure, or wisdom. Conclusions about ADR tend to be colored by the invisible veil or wisdom.
Radical-wing Concerns Differences (even small ones) among ADR processes matter greatly in terms of quality of the process (so understanding these differences matters greatly). A lack of rigor in defining, identifying, and understanding distinctions in ADR processes has led to marketplace confusion. Individual users of dispute resolution processes and providers can become better-informed consumers using conflict diagnosis. Society as a whole is not benefiting from the full panoply of options for dispute resolution. Use of non-adversarial ADR can lead to positive macro-system changes and should be encouraged.
Quality of ADR Though saving time and money are important goals, if the process is flawed, long-term efficiency is lost, and so the quality of dispute resolution process and outcome must be considered. There is little evidence that this longer-term assessment of long-term efficiency and effectiveness is taking place. Assessments of the quality of ADR are confounded by the lack of empirical research to adequately discriminate among forms of ADR. Conflict diagnosis ideas will also help researchers and policy makers to design better studies and to interpret studies more effectively.
The ADR Revolution
- โEfficiency wingโ adopts ADR to save time and money, divert cases out of litigation.
- โRadical wingโ adopts ADR to attain better conflict resolution.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the tension between efficiency and quality in ADR helps practitioners choose appropriate dispute resolution processes and avoid sacrificing long-term effectiveness for short-term savings.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are the ten-step conflict diagnosis process, which provides a systematic framework for analyzing any interpersonal conflict, from mapping participants to considering diversity issues. Understanding the three perspectives (time, person, and issues) helps evaluate whether conflict consequences are positive or negative. The distinction between conflict gamers and conflict phobics explains different natural orientations to conflict and how diagnosis helps both types. The BATNA concept is essential for negotiation leverage and fallback planning. Finally, the contrast between the efficiency and radical perspectives on ADR highlights the ongoing debate between saving time/money versus achieving fundamentally better conflict resolution outcomes.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the ten steps in conflict diagnosis, and why is each important?
- How do the time, person, and issues perspectives affect the evaluation of interpersonal conflict?
- What is the difference between a conflict gamer and a conflict phobic?
- What does BATNA stand for, and how is it used in conflict diagnosis?
- How do the efficiency perspective and radical perspective differ in their views on ADR?
๐ Lecture 7 โ Recurrent Themes in Conflict Diagnosis I
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental concepts of interpersonal conflict diagnosis, emphasizing that conflict is often not what it seems. It introduces the "Seven Steps of Conflict Diagnosis" as a cognitive framework for understanding how disputants perceive, interpret, and respond to conflict, highlighting the subjective nature of perception and the many opportunities for error in social interactions.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the nature of interpersonal conflict as a complex, multifaceted phenomenon often hidden beneath the surface, likened to an iceberg, funny glasses, or a tornado. It discusses how disputants use each other's conduct to diagnose conflict, leading to perceptual errors. The core of the lecture is the detailed breakdown of the Seven Steps of Conflict Diagnosis, from the initial social stimulus to the creation of a new stimulus through action, explaining each step's potential for error.
๐ Lecture Summary
Understanding and diagnosing interpersonal conflict
Interpersonal conflict exists when there is incompatibility of goals and occurs in every type of relationship. What we think we see is often not what really goes on, and what the other disputant is responding to is often not what we think. Conflict is not necessarily negative; a relationship without visible conflict may have hidden conflicts that are more harmful. Hostility and resentment can destroy relationships, whereas conflict can be productive if taken positively.
Sources of conflict are usually hidden
Opposing needs, ideas, goals, and interests may be the sources of conflict. Conflicts may be real and/or perceived. Conflict is a very complex and multifaceted phenomenonโmost of the time, it is not what we see or perceive, but something else and somewhere else. Perception is often more important than reality, as our perceptions affect most of our behavior and attitude. ๐ก Why this matters: Diagnosing conflict requires understanding the predisposition of the issue, not just the surface-level behavior.
Conflict is never quite what it seems
Interpersonal conflict is like an iceberg (most of it is hidden), funny glasses (distorting perception), and a tornado (disorienting and disturbing). Disputants use one another's conduct to diagnose conflict, which leads to ever-widening errors of perception and judgment.
The Seven Steps of Social Behavior
Conflict is based on subjectivity and perception. Many opportunities for error exist in all social interactions. Experience is greatly subjective, hence interpersonal conflict is subjective. Perceptual distortions are very important for Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), as negotiation processes address perception and bring people closer in their views.
Seven Steps of Conflict Diagnosis
1. Social Stimulus
A stimulus is something in one's environment that stimulates a reaction. A social stimulus is a stimulus emanating from another individual or from the social setting or situation. Social stimuli can be verbal, nonverbal (e.g., body language), or contextual (e.g., where and when behavior took place).
2. Disputant receives the social stimulus with his or her senses
Receiving the stimulus is only the first part of perceptionโthe other essential part is interpretation. Stimulus reception can be prone to error.
3. Disputant interprets what he or she has seen/heard/sensed
This is the assigning of meaning to a received stimulus by the observer. This second half of perception often goes unrecognizedโperception is often misunderstood as an "objective" rendering of a real-world event, but in reality, it can be very subjective. "Error" occurs during interpretation because virtually every received stimulus has ambiguous components. During interpersonal conflict, disputants will tend to use one another's behavior to make guesses about motivations and next moves. The stress of conflict worsens the tendency to make errors.
Specific sources of interpretational error include: a. Actor did not intend his or her actions. b. Use of a heuristicโmental shortcuts that facilitate the interpretational phase of perception. c. Negative heuristics that tend to be associated with escalated conflict. d. Self-fulfilling-prophecy behavioral responses to application of a heuristic. e. Application of heuristics is associated with high levels of stress and reduced mental and emotional resources. f. Influenced by individual contextual factors and motivational factors.
๐ Definition โ Heuristic: mental shortcuts that facilitate the interpretational phase of perception.
4. Disputant generates options for responding
Option generation will be more or less abbreviated or detailed, depending on the importance of the situation, the stress and arousal level of the observer, and the cognitive resources of the observer.
5. Disputant weighs the options
The observer chooses an action by weighing the costs and benefits of each option. Factors that influence weights given to options include: i. Factors that influence availability of mental resources (complexity, fatigue, emotional arousal). ii. Salience of particular issues in the present context. iii. Blueprints about interpersonal conflict and how it should be resolved. iv. Personal values assigned to the likely possible outcomes. v. The weighing of options is often wholly or partially unconscious.
6. Disputant chooses an action
A stable source of choice is perceived self-efficacy, whereas transient sources include time limitations, cognitive overload, and attention-robbing factors.
๐ Definition โ Perceived self-efficacy: a stable source that influences the action a disputant chooses.
7. Disputant acts, creating a new social stimulus
The action that occurs may not be the one intended due to deficiencies in actual self-efficacy (proficiency). Proficiency is not a stable trait and is impaired by stress. Even proficiently executed tactics sometimes fail due to:
- Errors in interpretation or judgment.
- Mistaken beliefs about the effectiveness of various blueprints.
- Changes in the situation.
- Chanceโthe tactic may carry a known risk.
- Actions become social stimuli for the next cycle.
๐ก Why this matters: This step shows that even with good intentions, actions can fail, creating new stimuli that continue the conflict cycle.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that interpersonal conflict is a subjective, perceptual phenomenon, not an objective reality. The "Seven Steps of Conflict Diagnosis" provide a systematic framework for understanding how disputants perceive, interpret, and respond to conflict, with potential for error at every step. Perception has two partsโreceiving and interpretingโand interpretation is where most errors occur, especially through the use of heuristics under stress. Conflict is often hidden (like an iceberg), and what appears on the surface may not reflect the true sources of disagreement. Finally, every action in conflict creates a new social stimulus, making conflict a dynamic, cyclical process.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three metaphors used to describe interpersonal conflict, and what does each represent?
- What are the two essential parts of perception, and which one is more prone to error during conflict?
- List the Seven Steps of Conflict Diagnosis in order.
- What is a heuristic, and why does its use increase during conflict?
- Why can an action taken by a disputant fail even if it is executed proficiently?
๐ Lecture 8 โ Recurrent Themes in Conflict Diagnosis II
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of conflict diagnosis by applying the seven steps of social behavior to understand ten recurrent themes in conflict. It explains why individuals behave as they do during conflicts, how perceptions are formed, and why conflicts often persist or escalate. Understanding these themes is critical for anyone managing or intervening in interpersonal disputes.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers ten themes of conflict diagnosis: behavior makes sense to the actor, the subjective interpretation of reality, using conflict to form perceptions of others' motives, unconscious perceptual biases, how perceptual biases feed conflict, the pleasure principle, subjectivity of expectations about results, complexity and inconsistency of motivation, failure to attain intended goals, and the self-fulfilling prophecy of conflict.
๐ Lecture Summary
Recurrent Themes in Conflict Diagnosis II
This lecture continues from the previous one, applying the seven steps of social behavior to understand the ten themes of conflict diagnosis. These themes help explain why conflicts develop and persist the way they do.
Theme 1. Behavior makes sense to actor
An individual will behave in ways that make sense to him or her. It is of no utility to write off someoneโs behavior as motivated by evil intent. Every action, even if destructive or confusing to an outsider, is logical from the actor's perspective based on their understanding of the situation.
๐ Definition โ Behavior makes sense to actor: An individual will always behave in ways that are rational and logical to them, given their perception of the situation.
๐ก Why this matters: This principle prevents demonizing the other party and encourages exploring the reasoning behind their actions rather than dismissing them as irrational or evil.
Theme 2. Interpretation of reality is subjective
Each individualโs interpretation of reality is subjective. There is no single objective reality in conflict; every party sees the situation through their own unique lens shaped by their experiences, beliefs, and values.
๐ Definition โ Subjective interpretation of reality: No two people perceive the same event identically; each person filters reality through their own mental framework.
Theme 3. Conflict to Form Perception
Conflict participants use the conflict itself to make judgments about the motives of the other conflict participants. Mind reading is impossible, and the statements of others about their motives are usually not trusted. People infer intentions from observable behavior during the conflict.
๐ Definition โ Conflict to form perception: During conflict, people judge others' motives based on their observable actions rather than trusting their verbal statements about intentions.
Theme 4. Perceptual Biases are Unconscious
The influence of mental processes on the perception of reality in interpersonal conflict is largely unconscious and automatic. Because these processes are unconscious and automatic, errors of perception are not usually noted. The faulty perceptions that arise during conflicts are usually thought as "obvious" or self-evident truths.
๐ Definition โ Perceptual biases: Unconscious and automatic mental processes that distort how we perceive reality during conflict, and these distortions are typically unnoticed by the perceiver.
Theme 5. Perceptual Biases Feed Conflict
Expect interpersonal conflict to involve misperception. Because the perceptual frames of reference of disputants usually differ, they usually attribute the wrong motives to each other as they try to explain the behavior they are seeing using the wrong frame of reference. Emotional reactions to misunderstood actions feed the conflict. Defensive responses to misunderstood actions further confirm to the observer the negative perceptions.
๐ Definition โ Perceptual frames of reference: The unique mental lens through which each person interprets events; when these differ between disputants, they misinterpret each other's motives.
๐ก Why this matters: This creates a vicious cycle: misunderstanding leads to emotional reactions, which lead to defensive behavior, which confirms the original negative perception.
Theme 6. The Pleasure Principle
Each individual is motivated to improve his or her basic well-being, happiness, comfort, and pleasure and to reduce discomfort, pain, and harm to the self. This is an expression of the basic motivating force assumed by behaviorists and social learning theorists to underlie human and animal behavioral responses.
๐ Definition โ Pleasure principle: The fundamental human motivation to seek pleasure and avoid pain, which drives all behavioral responses in conflict.
Theme 7. Subjectivity of Expectations about Results
Expectations held by individuals, about the results that their behavior will produce, are subjective. People predict outcomes based on their personal beliefs, past experiences, and biases, not on objective probabilities.
๐ Definition โ Subjectivity of expectations: Each person's predictions about what their actions will achieve are colored by their subjective perspective, not objective reality.
Theme 8. Complexity and Inconsistency of Motivation
Individual choices in a conflict are the result of reconciling among many diverse and contradictory motivations. Motivation usually appears simpler to an observer than it does to the one taking action. Motivation is often unconscious to the actor. This can create a situation in which hidden motives unduly influence an actor because he or she is unaware of their existence and influence. It also can create a situation in which an actor seems to be lying, but in fact lacks insight into his or her own behavior. Interpersonal conflict creates predictable motivations, such as the desire to "beat" the other disputant.
๐ Definition โ Complexity and inconsistency of motivation: Human motivation in conflict involves multiple, often contradictory, conscious and unconscious drivers that are not easily understood even by the actor themselves.
Theme 9. Intended goals are not usually achieved
Individuals in a conflict frequently donโt attain their intended goals. Reasons for failure: i. Misinterpretation of the situation ii. Application of inappropriate conflict blueprint iii. Application of unhelpful strategies for resolving conflict iv. Failure to proficiently execute a strategy v. Chance: the strategy had a known risk of failure
๐ Definition โ Failure to attain goals: Despite best intentions, people in conflict often fail to achieve what they set out to accomplish due to multiple predictable reasons.
Theme 10. Self-fulfilling prophecy
The course of a conflict tends to be self-fulfilling. The dynamics of interpersonal conflict typically cause it to evolve into what the disputants think it is. Some ADR (Alternative Dispute Resolution) practitioners use this feature of conflict, subtly manipulating conflict participants into a frame of mind conducive to resolution. A more constructive approach to handling the conflict often follows.
๐ Definition โ Self-fulfilling prophecy: The tendency for conflict to evolve exactly as disputants expect it to, because their expectations shape their behavior and perceptions.
๐ก Why this matters: This principle can be used positively: if disputants can be guided to expect resolution, the conflict itself is more likely to move toward constructive outcomes.
โญ Key Takeaways
The ten themes reveal that conflict behavior is always logical to the actor, perception is subjective and largely unconscious, and misperceptions feed and sustain conflict. People are motivated by the pleasure principle but their motivations are complex, contradictory, and often hidden from themselves. Despite these complexities, disputants rarely achieve their intended goals due to misinterpretation, inappropriate strategies, or poor execution. Critically, conflicts tend to become self-fulfilling prophecies, which means that changing disputants' expectations can alter the course of the conflict. Understanding these themes is essential for effective diagnosis and intervention in any interpersonal dispute.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to Theme 1, why is it unhelpful to write off someone's conflict behavior as motivated by evil intent?
- What does "perceptual frames of reference" mean, and how do differing frames of reference lead to misattribution of motives (Theme 5)?
- List at least four reasons why individuals in conflict frequently fail to attain their intended goals (Theme 9).
- What is the "pleasure principle" and how does it relate to behavioral responses in conflict?
- How can the self-fulfilling prophecy feature of conflict (Theme 10) be used constructively by Alternative Dispute Resolution practitioners?
๐ Lecture 9 โ DESCRIBING THE CONFLICT I
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on the process of accurately describing interpersonal conflicts before attempting resolution. It introduces the concept of building a conflict map (sociogram) to visually represent the parties, their relationships, and the underlying issues, emphasizing that roles can shift based on which specific conflict is being analyzed.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the critical importance of correctly identifying interpersonal versus intrapersonal conflict and then systematically mapping the conflict. It details the purposes of a conflict map or sociogram, explains the various participant roles including disputants, advocates, agents, constituents, and neutrals, and illustrates these concepts with a sample divorce and custody dispute scenario involving multiple parties.
๐ Lecture Summary
Description of Conflict
Make sure that we understand the roles of the parties to a conflict. Clarify that often there are several interpersonal conflicts hidden in a situation, and that the participant role assignments may change if the focus of the dispute is changed. It is essential to tease out underlying and hidden interpersonal conflicts, as this will help uncover paths to constructive resolution of the conflict.
Identifying Interpersonal Conflict
First, analyze the situation carefully to ensure it really is โinterpersonalโ and not an โinner conflictโ (intrapersonal). Identify the disputants, and the divergent goals and interests that create the interpersonal conflict. The next step is to start diagramming or mapping the conflict.
Purposes of the conflict map or โsociogramโ
When it is decided that a conflict is interpersonal conflict not intrapersonal conflict, then we map out the conflict. The purposes of a map or sociogram are:
- It clarifies what the conflicts are among the disputants.
- It helps us analyze disputantsโ interests.
- It reveals interests of non-disputants that may impede resolution or provide ways to creative strategies to resolve the conflict.
- It clarifies the points on which more information is needed.
Place symbols on the sociogram that represent the disputants and briefly write the divergent goals of the principal disputant. Evaluate the situation, conduct research where necessary, to identify agents, advocates, and constituents, and place them on the sociogram as well. Explain the sociogram with side conflicts that add to the complexity of the situation. Be prepared to edit the sociogram as and when additional information becomes available.
Keep in Mind the complexity
Many conflict situations will have more than one interpersonal conflict. You must ask: Who are the main disputants, agents, advocates, constituents, or neutrals, if any? This explanation will depend on the conflict that is being focused. Often, we know which conflict to focus on. Sometimes, we have to decide systematically which conflict is to be focused, as there are usually multiple conflicts. Whether to include some individuals with loose connections to the conflict as constituents will depend on our goals. It will be good to include all conflicts.
Parties to an Interpersonal Conflict
The lecture provides a diagram of the parties to an interpersonal conflict, showing the relationships between Disputant, Advocate, Agent, Constituent, and Neutral parties. Lines of communication and lines of relationship connect the parties, with the conflict (incompatible goals) placed between the two main disputants.
๐ Definition โ Sociogram/Conflict Map: A visual tool representing the parties in a conflict, their relationships, and the nature of their disagreement to help analyze the situation. ๐ Formula: The structure involves Disputants (those directly in conflict) at the center, connected by Lines of Communication and Lines of Relationship to Advocates (speak on behalf of a party), Agents (act on behalf of a party), Constituents (have an interest or stake), and Neutrals (uninvolved third parties).
Sample Interpersonal Conflict
The lecture uses the example of Saleem and Naila, who are in the process of divorcing and disagree over the custody of their two children.
- Lawyer Babar represents Saleem and Salma represents Naila.
- The children are upset with each other, blaming each other for the impending divorce between their parents.
- Babarโs mother cannot decide about her possible role to resolve their dispute by providing child care, if given custody of children to the father.
- Other constituents include Ayesha (secretary), Babarโs mother, the kids, and a Manager, Fellow Workers, a Dear Friend, a Supervisor, a Sick Father, and the fatherโs Mother.
This scenario creates a Conflict Map where the central conflict is the "Children custody dispute" between Saleem and Naila. Each disputant has an advocate (Babar for Saleem, Salma for Naila). The map also shows agents, constituents (like the kids, who are also in conflict with each other), and neutrals.
๐ Example: In the Saleem and Naila conflict, the advocate for Saleem is Babar (the lawyer). While Babar is an advocate for the custody dispute, he might be a constituent or have his own interests in a different conflict, such as his billing dispute with Saleem. The diagram shows how the kids are both constituents and have their own interpersonal conflict with each other.
Important Point
Roles of participants change, depending on which interpersonal conflict is given focus. A person who is an advocate in one conflict (e.g., the lawyer for the custody dispute) could be a disputant in a different conflict (e.g., a fee dispute with the client).
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding that roles are fluid prevents you from making assumptions about a person's position in a complex situation. You must clearly define which interpersonal conflict you are focusing on before assigning roles in your conflict map.
โญ Key Takeaways
- Always distinguish between an intrapersonal (inner) and interpersonal conflict before mapping.
- A conflict map (sociogram) is a powerful tool to visualize the dispute, clarify the roles of disputants, advocates, agents, constituents, and neutrals, and reveal the interests of all parties.
- The primary purposes of a sociogram are to clarify the specific conflicts, analyze disputant interests, reveal non-disputant influences, and identify information gaps.
- A single situation often contains multiple, overlapping interpersonal conflicts. The participant roles (e.g., advocate vs. disputant) for any individual will change depending on which specific conflict you are mapping.
- The sociogram is a dynamic tool that should be edited and updated as new information about the situation becomes available.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the most critical first step to take before drawing a conflict map for a situation?
- List the four specific purposes of creating a conflict map (sociogram).
- In the lecture's sample conflict, what is the primary interpersonal conflict under focus, who are the two main disputants, and who is the advocate for each?
- Explain the difference between an advocate and an agent in the context of a conflict map.
- Why is it important to remember that "roles of participants change" when analyzing a complex conflict situation?
๐ Lecture 10 โ Describing the Conflict II
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the process of conflict diagnosis by focusing on the critical first step: describing the conflict. It explains how to create a conflict map or sociogram to visualize relationships, identify the true focus of a dispute, and distinguish between interpersonal and intrapersonal conflicts, which is essential for effective resolution.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the first step of conflict diagnosisโdescribing the conflictโand the importance of putting the situation into words to clarify it. It introduces the sociogram as a mapping tool, explains how to identify the true focus of a conflict by uncovering hidden disputes, and teaches how to differentiate between interpersonal (between people) and intrapersonal (internal to one person) conflicts, using real-world examples like a father-son career disagreement and a corporate sale of a product.
๐ Lecture Summary
Quotation
The lecture opens with two quotations. Aristotle states, โWell begun is half done,โ emphasizing that a proper start to conflict diagnosis is crucial. Hilaire Belloc adds, โAll men have an instinct for conflict: at least, all healthy men,โ highlighting that conflict is a natural part of healthy human relationships. The lecture notes that concepts like conflict, mistrust, insecurity, individualism, and competition depict relationships, and understanding their anatomy can improve personal, work, and social life.
Step 1 for Conflict Diagnosis
The first step towards conflict diagnosis is the description of conflict. Putting the situation or conflict into words helps clarify it in your mind. Developing a conflict map or sociogram helps understand the nature of conflict. A sociogram is defined as a diagram or chart that shows individuals and their relationships to one another.
๐ก Why this matters: Creating a visual map of the conflict forces you to systematically think about all parties involved, their connections, and the underlying issues, rather than relying on a vague or emotional understanding.
๐ Definition โ Sociogram: A diagram or chart that shows individuals and their relationships to one another.
๐ Example: To map a conflict between two coworkers A and B and their manager C, draw three circles (A, B, C). Draw a solid line between A and B to show a direct conflict, a dotted line from A to C to show a good relationship, and a jagged line from B to C to show a tense relationship. This visual instantly reveals the relational dynamics.
Focus of conflict
When focusing on a dispute, it is useful to identify other conflicts involved in the dispute. Usually several interpersonal conflicts are involved but they are hidden. The focus on one conflict in a dispute can change the total situation; and ultimately the resolution of the conflict will also change significantly. The lecture advises: write down or map your conflict and sleep over it for about at least 12 hours. This pause helps clarify hidden conflicts that might not be immediately obvious.
๐ก Why this matters: The surface conflict may not be the real problem. By sleeping on it, you allow your subconscious to process hidden issues, preventing you from solving the wrong problem.
๐ Definition โ Hidden conflicts: Additional interpersonal conflicts that exist within a dispute but are not immediately obvious or expressed.
๐ Example: In a team dispute over budget allocation, the surface conflict is about money. Hidden conflicts might include a rivalry between two department heads, a lack of trust in finance, or resentment from a past decision. Focusing only on the budget without addressing these hidden conflicts will lead to an incomplete resolution.
Conflict: interpersonal or intrapersonal
It is essential to understand the nature of conflict: is it interpersonal or intrapersonal? An interpersonal conflict occurs between two or more people. An intrapersonal conflict occurs within a single person's mind, often involving a dilemma or internal struggle.
๐ Example (Father and Son): A son wants to pursue a career based on his understanding of his own limitations, while his father wants a high-profile career for his son. Both want a good career for the boy, so there is no actual interpersonal conflict (they share the same goal). The conflict is actually intrapersonalโit is within the person of the boy. He misinterprets his father's feelings and mistakenly thinks there is a conflict between him and his father. The real conflict is his internal struggle between his own perceived limitations and his father's expectations.
๐ Definition โ Interpersonal conflict: A conflict that occurs between two or more individuals or groups. ๐ Definition โ Intrapersonal conflict: A conflict that occurs within a single person, often involving conflicting thoughts, feelings, or values.
Sale of a product as conflict
This section presents an example from the textbook: Company S wants to sell its product (a microchip) to Company B (a mobile phone manufacturer). Although this is a Western example, it can apply to companies in Pakistan. The lecture notes that as an employee of a company, you may face such a situation. This example illustrates that a simple business transaction can be viewed as a conflict where each party has competing interests (e.g., price, quality, delivery terms). Understanding this dynamic helps negotiators prepare better.
๐ Example: Company S (chip maker) and Company B (mobile phone maker). Company S wants to sell its chip at a high price with a large order. Company B wants a low price with flexible terms. This creates a negotiation conflict. A conflict map would show S and B as two nodes with a line representing the negotiation. Hidden conflicts might include Company B's internal struggle between engineering (who wants the best chip) and finance (who wants the lowest cost), or Company S's internal pressure to meet quarterly sales targets.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is that the first step in conflict management is comprehensive description, achieved through creating a conflict map or sociogram to visualize all parties and their relationships. You must learn to identify the focus of conflict, which often includes hidden, underlying disputes that change the entire situation if addressed. Crucially, you must distinguish between interpersonal conflict (between people) and intrapersonal conflict (within a person), as misdiagnosing one for the other can lead to failed resolution. The simple act of writing down or mapping a conflict and waiting 12 hours can reveal these hidden layers. Finally, even routine business transactions like a product sale can be framed as a conflict requiring negotiation skills, and this understanding is applicable in both Western and local (e.g., Pakistani) contexts.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is a sociogram, and why is it useful in the first step of conflict diagnosis?
- Explain the concept of "hidden conflicts" and give an example from a workplace dispute.
- Using the father-son career example, describe the difference between interpersonal and intrapersonal conflict.
- Why does the lecture recommend "sleeping on" your description of a conflict for at least 12 hours?
- How can a simple product sale between two companies (like Company S and Company B) be considered a conflict?