π Lecture 29 β SALARY AND ITS COMPUTATION: GRATUITY
π Overview: This lecture explains the tax treatment of gratuity under Pakistani tax law. It covers the conditions for approved gratuity funds, the exemption provisions for different categories of employees, and demonstrates the computation through a practical example. Understanding gratuity taxation is crucial for accurate salary computation and tax planning for employees at retirement or termination.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the purpose and definition of gratuity, the conditions for an Approved Gratuity Fund, the detailed tax treatment of gratuity under clause 13 of Part I of the Second Schedule for government and non-government employees, the exceptions to exemption, and a solved exercise computing taxable income for a government employee receiving gratuity.
π Lecture Summary
Purpose:
The purpose of gratuity is to provide a benefit to employees or their dependents. It is a payment made upon:
- Provision of gratuity to employees, or
- Undertaking of provision (payment) of gratuity on retirement, or
- On employees becoming incapacitated, or
- On termination of their employment after completion of minimum period of service specified in the regulations of the fund, or
- To the widows, children or dependants of such employees on their death.
- All benefits granted by the fund shall be payable only in Pakistan.
Approved Gratuity Fund
The Commissioner of Income Tax may accord approval to any gratuity fund. A key condition for approval is that the fund must be established under an irrevocable trust and the purposes of gratuity must be fulfilled.
Tax Treatment of Gratuity
The tax treatment of gratuity is provided under Clause 13, Part I of Second Schedule. It distinguishes between different categories of employees:
(i) Government Employees: Any gratuity received on retirement or death by an employee of the Government, a local authority, or a statutory body or corporation or their family is wholly exempt from tax.
(ii) Approved Gratuity Fund: Any amount receivable from any gratuity fund approved by the Commissioner in accordance with the rules in Part III of the Sixth Schedule is exempt.
(iii) Other Employees (Approved Scheme): In the case of any other employee, the amount not exceeding two hundred thousand rupees receivable under any scheme applicable to all employees of the employer and approved by the Central Board of Revenue is exempt.
(iv) All Other Employees (Residual Category): In the case of any employee to whom sub-clause (i), (ii) and (iii) do not apply, fifty per cent of the amount receivable or seventy-five thousand rupees, whichever is the less, is exempt.
π‘ Why this matters: The residual category provides a minimum exemption for employees who don't fall under any specific exempt category, ensuring some tax relief.
Exceptions to Exemption: The gratuity exemption does not apply: (a) To any payment which is not received in Pakistan. (b) To any payment received from a company by a director of such company who is not a regular employee of such company. (c) To any payment received by an employee who is not a resident individual. (d) To any gratuity received by any employee who has already received any gratuity from the same or any other employer.
Exercise-1 on Gratuity:
Problem: Compute taxable income and tax thereon for tax year 2009 in respect of Mr. A, an employee of Government of the Punjab.
- Salary: Rs. 800,000
- Gratuity: Rs. 1,000,000
- Tax deducted at source: Rs. 54,000
Solution:
| Particulars | Total Income | Exempt Income | Taxable Income |
|---|---|---|---|
| Salary | 800,000 | Nil | 800,000 |
| Gratuity | 1,000,000 | 1,000,000 | Nil |
| Taxable Income | 800,000 |
Tax Liability Calculation: The tax rate of 7.50% is at serial no. 9 for taxable income exceeding Rs. 750,000 up to Rs. 900,000.
- Tax Liability = 800,000 x 7.5% = Rs. 60,000
- Tax deducted at source = Rs. 54,000
- Tax payable with return = Rs. 6,000
Note-1: Amount received as gratuity is exempt in this case under clause 13(i), Part I, Second Schedule of the Ordinance.
β Key Takeaways
The critical concepts for the exam are: (1) Gratuity received by government employees (and those of local authorities, statutory bodies, or corporations) is fully exempt from tax. (2) For employees under an approved gratuity fund, the entire amount receivable is exempt. (3) For other employees with an approved scheme, only the first Rs. 200,000 is exempt. (4) For all remaining employees, the exemption is the lower of 50% of the amount or Rs. 75,000. (5) Exemptions are not available if the payment is not received in Pakistan, the recipient is a non-resident, the payment is to a non-regular employee director, or the employee has already received gratuity from any employer.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under which clause of the Second Schedule is gratuity received by a government employee fully exempt from tax?
- What is the condition for a gratuity fund to be "approved" by the Commissioner of Income Tax?
- For an employee in the private sector (not covered by an approved fund), what is the maximum exemption available under the residual category (sub-clause iv)?
- List the four specific circumstances under which the gratuity exemption shall not apply.
- In the solved exercise, why was Mr. A's entire gratuity of Rs. 1,000,000 treated as exempt?
π Lecture 30 β Gratuity Received Under Sixth Schedule
π Overview: This lecture covers the tax treatment of gratuity received by employees under different approval statuses, including fully exempt gratuity from Commissioner-approved funds, partially exempt gratuity from CBR-approved funds, and the default exemption rule for unapproved gratuity. It also explains the tax treatment of pension, commutation of pension, and lump sum payments like Golden Handshake, with practical exercises and solutions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers gratuity under the Sixth Schedule (fully exempt when fund is approved by Commissioner of Income Tax), gratuity approved under clause (13)(iii) by CBR (first Rs. 200,000 exempt), the default rule for unapproved gratuity (least of 50% of amount or Rs. 75,000), pension exemption for citizens and government employees, commutation of pension exemption, and the tax treatment of lump sum payments with averaging option.
π Lecture Summary
Gratuity Received Under Sixth Schedule
In the case of employees covered by an approved gratuity fund under the Sixth Schedule, any gratuity received from a fund approved by the Commissioner of Income Tax in accordance with Part III of the Sixth Schedule is fully exempt under clause (13)(ii), Part I of Second Schedule. This means the entire gratuity amount is excluded from taxable income.
π Definition β Gratuity under Sixth Schedule: A payment received from a gratuity fund approved by the Commissioner of Income Tax, which is fully exempt from tax under clause (13)(ii), Part I, Second Schedule. π Rule: Full exemption β gratuity amount = 0 taxable income π Example: Mr. A received Rs. 1,000,000 from a Commissioner-approved gratuity fund. In the solution, this entire amount is shown as exempt income (Rs. 1,000,000 exempt), and his taxable income is only basic salary Rs. 360,000, bonus Rs. 90,000, and gardener allowance Rs. 48,000, totaling Rs. 498,000. Tax payable = 498,000 Γ 3.5% = Rs. 17,430.
π‘ Why this matters: The approval status of the gratuity fund by the Commissioner determines whether the entire gratuity is tax-free β a critical distinction for compliance.
Treatment if Gratuity Approved by Central Board of Revenue (CBR)
In case gratuity is approved under clause (13)(iii), Part I, Second Schedule (CBR approval), the treatment is:
- First gratuity received up to Rs. 200,000 is exempt.
- Amount exceeding Rs. 200,000 will be taxable as salary.
π Definition β CBR-approved gratuity: Gratuity from a fund approved by the Central Board of Revenue, where only the first Rs. 200,000 is exempt, and the excess is taxable.
Treatment of Gratuity not Covered under any other Clause of Part I of 2nd Schedule
Gratuity received by an employee or family on retirement or death shall be exempt from tax to the extent of the least of the following: a. 50% of amount receivable Or b. Rs. 75,000
However, this exemption is not available in the following cases:
- If gratuity is received outside Pakistan
- Received by a director of a company who is not a regular employee
- If received by a non-resident person
- If recipient has already received any gratuity from the same or any other employer
π Definition β Default gratuity exemption: For unapproved gratuity, exemption is the lesser of 50% of the gratuity amount or Rs. 75,000. π Formula: Exempt amount = min(50% of gratuity, Rs. 75,000) π Example: Mr. A received Rs. 600,000 from an unapproved fund. 50% of Rs. 600,000 = Rs. 300,000. Compare with Rs. 75,000. The lesser is Rs. 75,000, which is exempt. The balance of Rs. 225,000 (600,000 - 75,000) is taxable.
Gratuity: Points to Remember
- Gratuity will be ignored while computing taxable income and tax liability of a deceased person.
- In case the gratuity is received by legal heirs, where employee dies before retirement, the gratuity would be taxable in the hands of legal heirs of the deceased.
Pension
Pension is the amount received on account of past services/employment.
Tax Treatment of Pension β Totally Exempt
Pension is totally exempt if received by a citizen of Pakistan under clause (8), Part I of Second Schedule, provided:
- The recipient should be a citizen of Pakistan
- The recipient must not be working for the same employer for any remuneration
- If a person receives pension from more than one employer, the exemption shall be available to the higher of the pensions received.
Pension Received by Ex-Government Employees and Members of Armed Forces
Any pension received by employees of Federal Govt./Provincial Govts., Members of Armed Forces of Pakistan, or granted under the rules to their families is exempt from tax under clause (9), Part I of Second Schedule.
π Definition β Pension: Amount received on account of past services/employment, which may be exempt depending on the recipient's status and circumstances.
Clauses (8), (9), (12), (16), (17) Part I of Second Schedule
- Clause (8): Any pension received by a citizen of Pakistan from a former employer, other than where the person continues to work for the employer (or an associate). If more than one pension, exemption applies only to the higher of the pensions.
- Clause (9): Any pension (i) received in respect of services rendered by a member of the Armed Forces of Pakistan, Federal Government, or Provincial Government; (ii) granted to families and dependents of public servants or Armed Forces members who die during service.
- Clause (12): Any payment in the nature of commutation of pension received from Government or under a pension scheme approved by CBR.
- Clause (16): Any income derived by families and dependents of "Shaheeds" belonging to Pakistan Armed Forces from special family pension, dependents' pension, or children's allowance.
- Clause (17): Any income derived by families and dependents of "Shaheeds" belonging to Civil Armed Forces of Pakistan, to whom Joint Services Instruction No. 5/66 would have applied, from any like payment.
π Example (Pension): Mr. A retired and joined a private company. He received salary Rs. 600,000 and pension Rs. 300,000. Solution: Pension from ex-employer is exempt under clause (17), Part I, Second Schedule. Taxable income = Rs. 600,000 (salary only). Tax payable = 600,000 Γ 4.5% = Rs. 27,000.
Pension Granted to Injured or Disabled
Pension granted to a public servant or personnel of Armed Forces on injuries or body disability, and to families and dependents of 'Shaheeds' belonging to civil or Pakistan Armed Forces, or public servant or member of Armed Forces who dies during service, is exempt as provided in Part I of Second Schedule.
Any Payment in the Nature of Commutation of Pension [Clause (12), Part I, 2nd Schedule]
Any payment in the nature of commutation of pension received from the government or under any pension scheme approved by the Central Board of Revenue under clause (12), Part I, Second Schedule is exempt from tax.
π Example (Commutation of Pension): Mr. A, a government servant, retired and received Rs. 900,000 as commutation of pension. Solution: Commutation of Pension is exempt under clause (12), Part I of Second Schedule. The entire amount is exempt.
Exercise on Lump Sum Payments Received (Golden Handshake)
Mr. A received Rs. 1,500,000 on opting for Golden Handshake in tax year 2009. He received total income of Rs. 600,000 as salary during the year. Rate of tax for the preceding three tax years was 20%, 15%, and 10%. Compute taxable income and tax thereon.
Solution: Tax payer can opt to seek approval from CIT to charge lump sum payments received in a tax year at average tax rate of last three years. The average tax rate for last three years = (20% + 15% + 10%) / 3 = 15%. It is advisable to opt for this method.
Computation of Tax:
- Salary at normal rate: Rs. 600,000 Γ 4.5% = Rs. 27,000
- Lump sum payments: Rs. 1,500,000 Γ 15% = Rs. 225,000
- Total tax = Rs. 27,000 + Rs. 225,000 = Rs. 252,000
If lump sum payments of Rs. 1,500,000 had been included in salary income, taxable income would have been Rs. 2,100,000, charged at the rate of 25% (for taxable income exceeding Rs. 1,300,000). Tax liability would have been Rs. 2,100,000 Γ 25% = Rs. 525,000. Hence, it is advisable to opt for charging the tax at average rate of last three years.
π‘ Why this matters: The averaging option for lump sum payments can significantly reduce tax liability compared to including the lump sum in current year's income.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that gratuity exemption depends entirely on the approval status of the fund β Commissioner-approved funds give full exemption, CBR-approved funds exempt only the first Rs. 200,000, and unapproved funds exempt the lesser of 50% of amount or Rs. 75,000. Pension received by Pakistani citizens (who are not working for same employer) and government/armed forces pensions (including families of Shaheeds) are fully exempt. Commutation of pension from government or CBR-approved schemes is also fully exempt. For lump sum payments like Golden Handshake, the taxpayer can elect to tax them at the average tax rate of the preceding three years, which is often more favorable than inclusion in current year income.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the exemption limit for gratuity received from a fund approved by the Commissioner of Income Tax under the Sixth Schedule?
- A taxpayer receives Rs. 500,000 from a CBR-approved gratuity fund β what amount is exempt and what is taxable?
- Under the default rule for unapproved gratuity, what is the formula for computing the exempt amount?
- Under which clause is commutation of pension exempt, and from what sources?
- How is the average tax rate calculated for lump sum payments like Golden Handshake, and why would a taxpayer choose this option?
π Lecture 31 β SALARY AND ITS COMPUTATION: PROVIDENT FUND
π Overview: This lecture covers the different types of provident funds under Pakistani tax law, focusing on their definitions, conditions for recognition, and tax treatment. It also addresses benevolent grants. Understanding these concepts is crucial for correctly computing taxable salary income and exemptions for employees.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture defines and distinguishes between Statutory, Recognized, and Unrecognized Provident Funds. It details the conditions for approval of a Recognized Provident Fund by the Commissioner of Income Tax. The tax treatment for each fund type is explained, including the exemption limit for employer contributions. An exercise demonstrates the computation of taxable income for provident fund contributions, and the lecture concludes with an exercise on the exemption for benevolent grants.
π Lecture Summary
Types: Provident Fund
The lecture introduces the three main types of provident funds in Pakistan. A Provident Fund is a retirement savings fund for employees. The first type is the Statutory Provident Fund, governed by the Provident Funds Act, 1925 (commonly known as GP Fund). The second is a Recognized Provident Fund, which is recognized by the Commissioner of Income Tax under Part I of the Sixth Schedule. The third is an Unrecognized Provident Fund, which does not meet the conditions for recognition.
π Definition β Recognized Provident Fund: A provident fund recognized by the commissioner in accordance with Part I of the Sixth Schedule [as defined in clause (48) of Section 2].
Recognized Provident Fund under Part I of 6th Schedule
The Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) may accord recognition to a fund if it complies with the requirements laid down in rule 2. The CIT may also withdraw recognition after providing a reasonable opportunity to the fundβs trustees to be heard.
Condition for Approval
For a provident fund to be recognized, several conditions must be met. All employees shall be employed in Pakistan, or shall be employed by an employer whose principal place of business is in Pakistan. An employee's contributions in a tax year shall be a definite proportion of his salary. An employer's contributions to an employee's individual account in a tax year shall not exceed the contributions made by the employee. The fund shall be vested in two or more trustees, or an official trustee. The accumulated balance due to an employee shall be payable on the day he ceases to be an employee of the employer who maintains the fund.
Tax Treatment
The tax treatment varies by fund type. A Statutory Provident Fund is wholly exempt under Clause 22. A Recognized Provident Fund is partially taxable within limits. An employerβs contribution up to 10 percent of salary is exempt, while any employerβs contribution exceeding 10% of βsalaryβ is taxable under rule 3, Part 1 of the Sixth Schedule. An Unrecognized Provident Fund is wholly taxable.
The accumulated balance due and becoming payable to any employee participating in a recognized provident fund is fully exempt under clause (23) Part I of Second Schedule.
π Example: Mr. A received a credit of Rs. 50,000 as employerβs contribution to his recognized provident fund. His salary during tax year 2009 is:
- Basic salary: Rs. 840,000
- Computer allowance: Rs. 12,000
- Medical allowance: Rs. 60,000 Compute taxable income.
Solution: N-1: Under rule 3 of Part I of Sixth Schedule, exemption is available up to 10% of salary, and the excess amount shall be taxable. In this case, the entire amount of Rs. 50,000 is exempt as it is within the prescribed limit of 10% of salary. The salary for this purpose is Rs. 840,000 + Rs. 12,000 = Rs. 852,000 (Basic + Computer Allowance). 10% of Rs. 852,000 is Rs. 85,200. Since Rs. 50,000 is less than Rs. 85,200, it is fully exempt. N-2: Medical allowance up to 10% of basic salary (Rs. 84,000) is exempt. Since the allowance is Rs. 60,000, the full amount is exempt. Taxable income is Rs. 852,000 (Basic + Computer Allowance), and tax can be computed as explained in previous exercises.
Computation of Taxable Income:
| Particulars | Total Income | Exempt Income | Taxable Income |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic Salary | 840,000 | Nil | 840,000 |
| Computer allowance | 12,000 | Nil | 12,000 |
| Medical allowance (10% of basic exempt) | 60,000 | 84,000 | Nil |
| Employerβs contribution to SPF Exempt | --- | --- | --- |
| Taxable Income | 852,000 |
Benevolent Grant
A Benevolent Grant is a payment made from a Benevolent Fund to employees or their families in case of need.
π Definition β Benevolent Grant: Any benevolent grant paid from the Benevolent Fund to the employees or members of their families in accordance with the provisions of the Central Employee Benevolent Fund and Group Insurance Act, 1969 [under clause (24) of part 1 of 2nd schedule].
π Example: Mr. A, a government servant, retired on 01-05-2009. He received Rs. 600,000 from a duly approved benevolent fund. He received total income amounting to Rs. 480,000 under the head salary during tax year 2009. Compute taxable income and tax.
Solution: The benevolent grant of Rs. 600,000 is fully exempt from tax under clause (24) of Part I of the Second Schedule. Therefore, only the salary income of Rs. 480,000 is taxable.
β Key Takeaways
A student must understand the three types of provident funds (Statutory, Recognized, Unrecognized) and their respective tax treatments. For a Recognized Provident Fund, the key threshold is that employer contributions up to 10% of salary are exempt, and any excess is taxable. The accumulated balance from a recognized provident fund is fully exempt when paid. Finally, benevolent grants received from an approved Benevolent Fund are fully exempt under the Second Schedule. The salary for calculating the 10% limit on employer contributions includes basic salary and allowances, but not medical allowance if it is within the exempt limit.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of provident funds discussed in this lecture?
- What is the maximum percentage of salary that an employer's contribution to a Recognized Provident Fund can be without being taxable?
- Which clause of the Second Schedule exempts the accumulated balance from a Recognized Provident Fund?
- What is the tax treatment of a benevolent grant paid from a duly approved Benevolent Fund?
- In the exercise on Mr. A, which allowance was fully exempt even though it was below the usual 10% limit, and why?
π Lecture 32 β Taxation of rental income arising from use and exploitation of immovable property βIncome from Propertyβ
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the taxation of rental income from immovable property under Section 15 of the Income Tax Ordinance. It defines βrent,β explains how fair market rent is applied, and outlines the treatment of non-adjustable advances. The lecture also covers exemptions, the final tax regime, and the specific tax rate slabs for individuals, AOPs, and companies, with solved exercises for practical application.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining income from property under Section 15 and the meaning of βrent,β including forfeited deposits and utilities. It covers the application of fair market rent and exemptions for trusts and welfare institutions. The treatment of non-adjustable amounts is explained with an illustration. The lecture then details exclusions from property income, the final tax regime and rate slabs for individuals, AOPs, and companies, and ends with solved exercises demonstrating the computation of taxable income and tax.
π Lecture Summary
Taxation of rental income arising from use and exploitation of immovable property βIncome from Propertyβ
βIncome from Propertyβ includes Rent received or receivable by a person in a tax year other than rent exempt from tax, as per Sec 15 (1) . Rent means any income received or receivable by the owner of land or building as consideration for: use, occupation, or the right to use the land or building. Rent also includes forfeited deposits paid under a contract for the sale of land or building.
Where a building is leased out together with Plant & Machinery, it is not income from property but βincome from other sourcesβ under Sec. 15(3). Rent must be in line with Fair Market Rent. If the rent received is less than the fair market rent, the person shall be treated as having derived the fair market rent for the period the property is let. Where utilities are included in rent, such amount is chargeable to tax under the head income from other sources and not under the head income from property.
π Definition β Rent: Any income received or receivable by the owner of land or building as consideration for its use, occupation, or the right to use it, including forfeited deposits from a sale contract.
π Definition β Fair Market Rent: The rent a person is treated as having derived if the actual rent received is less than the market rate for the property.
Exemptions Available Under Property Income
Exemptions are available for income of a trust or welfare institution from housing property under clause (58)(1) and for income from property held under trust or other legal obligations for religious or charitable purpose under Clause (59) of Part 1 of the 2nd Schedule.
Certain deductions were allowable under sec 17 up to tax year 2006, but Section 17 stands omitted by Finance Act, 2006. Hence, no deductions are permissible from 1st July 2006.
Sec 15 (7) states that provisions of Section 15 shall not apply to a taxpayer who: (i) is an individual or association of persons; (ii) derives income from property not exceeding Rs. 150,000 in a tax year; and (iii) does not derive taxable income under any other head.
Fair Market Rent is not applicable when the lessee is chargeable to tax under the head βSalary Incomeβ.
Treatment of Non-Adjustable Amounts Received in Relation to Buildings
These amounts shall be treated as rent and chargeable to tax under the head βincome from propertyβ. These amounts are spread over a period of 10 years.
π Example: Say non-adjustable advance rent received is Rs. 120,000. Amount adjustable per year shall be 120,000/10 = Rs. 12,000. Rs. 12,000 shall be adjustable for ten years.
Income from Property not taxable under section 15
The following are not taxable under Section 15: Ground rent, Rental income from a building kept on lease together with plant and machinery, Rental income derived by subletting a building or land by a tenant, Mining right and royalty, and Provision of amenities, utilities, or any other service connected with renting of building.
Treatment of Income from Property under Sec 15
Income from property is taxable as a separate block of income and should not be included in total income and taxable income. The tax deducted under sub-section (1) is a final tax on the income from property. Persons liable to deduct tax at source include the Federal Government, a Provincial Government, a local authority, a company, a non-profit organization, a diplomatic mission, or any other person notified by the CBR.
(a) Rate of tax for individuals and AOPs:
| S.No. | Gross amount of rent | Rate of tax |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Does not exceed Rs. 150,000. | Nil. |
| 2 | Exceeds Rs. 150,000 but does not exceed Rs. 400,000. | 5% of the amount exceeding Rs. 150,000. |
| 3 | Exceeds Rs. 400,000 but does not exceed Rs. 1,000,000. | Rs. 12,500 plus 7.5% of the amount exceeding Rs. 400,000. |
| 4 | Exceeds Rs. 1,000,000. | Rs. 57,500 plus 10% of the amount exceeding Rs. 1,000,000. |
(b) Rate of tax for companies:
| S.No. | Gross amount of rent | Rate of tax |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Does not exceed Rs. 400,000. | 5% of the gross amount of rent. |
| 2 | Exceeds Rs. 400,000 but does not exceed Rs. 1,000,000. | Rs. 20,000 plus 7.5% of the amount exceeding Rs. 400,000. |
| 3 | Exceeds Rs. 1,000,000. | Rs. 65,000 plus 10% of the amount exceeding Rs. 1,000,000. |
π‘ Why this matters: These are the specific tax rate slabs used to compute the final tax liability on rental income.
Exercise-1
Mr. A let out a building for rent of Rs 1,600,000 and received Rs 800,000 as a non-adjustable advance. He also forfeited a Rs 200,000 deposit from a failed sale.
The solution shows:
- Rental Income: Rs. 1,600,000 is taxable.
- Non-adjustable advance: Rs. 800,000 / 10 = Rs. 80,000 is taxable for the year.
- Forfeited deposit: Rs. 200,000 is taxable as rent.
- Gross Taxable Income: Rs. 1,880,000.
- Tax Calculation: Tax on initial Rs. 1,000,000 is Rs. 57,500. Tax on the remaining Rs. 880,000 at 10% is Rs. 88,000. Total tax: Rs. 145,500.
Exercise-2
Mr. A has rental income from a shop of Rs 120,000 and a gratuity of Rs 900,000.
The solution shows:
- The rental income (Rs. 120,000) does not exceed Rs. 150,000.
- Mr. Aβs gratuity of Rs. 900,000 is exempt income.
- Therefore, Mr. A does not derive taxable income under any other head.
- As all three conditions of Sec 15(7) are met, the rental income is exempt.
- Taxable income: Nil.
Exercise-3
Mr. A has rental income from a building of Rs 450,000 and a non-adjustable advance of Rs 200,000.
The solution shows:
- Rental Income: Rs. 450,000 is taxable.
- Non-adjustable advance: Rs. 200,000 / 10 = Rs. 20,000 is taxable for the year.
- Gross Taxable Income: Rs. 470,000.
- Tax Calculation: Tax on initial Rs. 400,000 is Rs. 12,500. Tax on the remaining Rs. 70,000 at 7.5% is Rs. 5,250. Total tax: Rs. 17,750.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point is the definition of βrentβ for tax purposes, which includes forfeited deposits and is adjusted to fair market rent if the actual rent is too low. A key rule is that non-adjustable advances are spread over 10 years and taxed as rent each year. You must memorize the progressive tax rate slabs for individuals and AOPs to compute the final tax on gross rental income. Finally, remember the three conditions for exemption: the taxpayer is an individual or AOP, the total rental income does not exceed Rs. 150,000, and the person has no other taxable income. The tax is a final tax, and no deductions are allowed after 2006.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of βrentβ under Section 15(1), and name two specific items included in this definition.
- How is a non-adjustable advance received from a tenant treated for tax purposes, and over how many years is it spread?
- What are the three conditions that must be met for rental income to be exempt under Section 15(7)?
- For an individual with a gross rental income of Rs. 500,000, calculate the final tax liability using the correct tax rate slab.
- Is the rental income from a building leased together with plant and machinery still taxable under the head βIncome from Propertyβ? If not, under which head is it taxed?
π Lecture 33 β Business Defined Section 2(9)
π Overview: This lecture defines what constitutes "business" under Section 2(9) of the Income Tax Ordinance, including the various types of income chargeable under the head "Income from Business." It also covers exemptions on business income and the special treatment of speculation business, which is crucial for distinguishing between ordinary business income and speculative transactions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the legal definition of business under Section 2(9), enumerates specific types of income taxable under the head "Income from Business" (including profit on debt, leasing income, and management fees), lists exemptions from business income under Part 1 of the Second Schedule, and explains the separate treatment of speculation business under Section 19 with its exclusions for hedging and arbitrage transactions.
π Lecture Summary
Business Defined Section 2(9)
"Business includes any trade, commerce, manufacture, profession, vocation but doesnβt include employment."
Following incomes (except exempt income) shall be charged to tax under the head 'Income from Business': a) Profits & Gains from any business in a tax year. b) Income derived from any trade, profession, sale of goods or provision of any services. c) Income from hire or lease of tangible movable property. d) FMV (Fair Market Value) of Perquisites derived by a person by virtue of business relationships. e) Management Fee derived by a management company.
Income from Business also includes:
- Any profit on debt derived by a person (only applicable to persons whose business is to derive such income, e.g., a banking company).
- Any amount received by a schedule bank from a mutual fund as share of profit.
- Profit earned on debts in the course of business shall be chargeable to 'income from business'.
- Income on leasing by lessor, being banks, leasing companies, etc.
π‘ Why this matters: The definition of business is broad and covers many activities beyond traditional trading, including professional income and income from leasing movable property. The key distinction is that employment income is excluded.
π Definition β Perquisite: Any benefit or privilege received by a person by virtue of their business relationship, valued at Fair Market Value (FMV).
π No formula required.
Exemptions on Business Income Under Part 1 of Second Schedule
The following clauses provide exemptions from tax on business income:
| Clause | Exempt Income |
|---|---|
| (91) | Income of a Text-Book Board |
| (92) | University or Educational Institution established not for profit purpose |
| (93) | Recognized Computer Training Institution |
| (93A) | Recognized Vocational Institute |
| (98) | Income of Recognized Sports Board |
| (100) | Income of Modaraba Companies |
π‘ Why this matters: These exemptions are specific to entities serving public or educational purposes. Students must memorize these clauses for exam purposes.
Speculation Business (Sec 19)
Speculation Business shall be charged under the head "Income from Business" but with separate treatment.
Treatment of Speculation Business (Sec 19):
- To be treated as distinct and separate from other business carried on by the person.
- Expenditures/deductions incurred on account of speculation business shall be apportioned in light of Section 67.
- Profit and gains arising out of speculation business shall be included in the person's income chargeable under the head "Income from Business".
Definition of Speculation Business (Sec. 19): Speculation means any business in which a contract for the purchase and sale of any commodity (including stocks and shares) is periodically or ultimately settled otherwise than by the actual delivery or transfer of the commodity, but does NOT include a business in which:
- A contract in respect of raw materials or merchandise is entered into by a person in the course of a manufacturing or mercantile business to guard against loss through future price fluctuations for the purpose of fulfilling the person's other contracts for the actual delivery of the goods to be manufactured or merchandise to be sold;
- A contract in respect of stocks and shares is entered into by a dealer or investor therein to guard against loss in the person's holding of stocks and shares through price fluctuations; or
- A contract is entered into by a member of a forward market or stock exchange in the course of any transaction in the nature of jobbing (arbitrage) to guard against any loss which may arise in the ordinary course of the person's business as such members.
π Definition β Speculation Business: A business where contracts for purchase/sale of commodities (including stocks/shares) are settled without actual delivery or transfer of the commodity.
π Formula: Speculation Business = Contracts settled without delivery β Taxed separately under Section 19
π Example: If a trader enters into a contract to buy 100 shares of Company A at Rs. 100 per share, but settles the contract by paying the difference in price (instead of taking delivery of the shares), this is speculation business. However, if the same trader is a dealer holding shares and enters into a futures contract to guard against a fall in price (hedging), that is not speculation business under the exclusions.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture clarifies that "business" is broadly defined to include trade, commerce, manufacture, profession, and vocation but explicitly excludes employment. All profits and gains from business, including profit on debt (for financial institutions), leasing income, and management fees, are taxable under this head. Certain entities like Text-Book Boards, non-profit educational institutions, and Modaraba companies enjoy exemptions from business income. Speculation business receives special treatment under Section 19: it must be treated as a separate business, with its own expenses apportioned under Section 67, and excludes hedging transactions for raw materials, stocks/shares, and arbitrage by exchange members from the definition of speculation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the legal definition of "business" under Section 2(9) of the Income Tax Ordinance?
- List five types of income specifically included under the head "Income from Business" besides general profits and gains.
- Name three types of entities whose business income is exempt under Part 1 of the Second Schedule.
- What is the key difference between speculation business and hedging transactions under Section 19?
- How must speculation business be treated for tax purposes under Section 19?
π Lecture 8.33 β Deductions Allowed under Section 20 & Deductions not Allowed β Sec. 21
π Overview: This lecture details the specific deductions allowed under Section 20 of the Income Tax Ordinance for business expenditures, and then comprehensively lists the deductions not allowed under Section 21. Understanding these disallowed expenses is critical for correctly computing taxable income from business, as claiming them can lead to penalties and reassessment.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first covers two specific deductions allowed under Section 20: expenditure on acquiring a depreciable asset or intangible with a useful life of more than one year, and expenditure in the course of amalgamation. It then provides a detailed enumeration of all deductions not allowed under Section 21, covering taxes, personal expenses, capital expenditures, and specific payment methods, including special conditions for salary payments and cash transactions.
π Lecture Summary
Deductions Allowed under Section 20
Deduction is allowed for expenditure incurred by a person in the year wholly for the purpose of business. This includes expenditure on acquiring a depreciable asset or an intangible with a useful life of more than one year. It also includes expenditure in the course of amalgamation of companies incurred by an amalgamated company.
π‘ Why this matters: These are specific exceptions to the general rule that capital expenditures are not deductible, allowing for tax relief on certain long-term business investments and restructuring costs.
Deductions not Allowed β Sec. 21
This section lists all expenditure that is disallowed for deduction when computing business income. The key categories are:
a. Taxes: Any cess, rate or tax paid or payable by a person in Pakistan or a foreign country under PTR/Final Tax Regime is not allowed. Also, any amount of tax deducted at source (TDS) is not allowed.
b. Failure to deduct tax (Salary): If the payer/employer does not deduct tax from payments/disbursement of salary, then the payments made, salaries paid by such payer/employer shall not be allowed for deduction of these expenses.
c. Entertainment expenditure: Any entertainment expenditure in excess of such limits [or in violation of such conditions] as may be prescribed.
d. Unrecognized funds: Any contribution made by the person to a fund that is not a recognized provident fund*, approved pension fund, approved superannuation fund, or approved gratuity fund.
e. Employee funds without tax deduction: Any contribution made by the person to any provident or other fund established for the benefit of employees, unless the person has made effective arrangements to secure that tax is deducted under section 149 from any payments made by the fund in respect of which the recipient is chargeable to tax under the head βSalaryβ.
f. Fines and penalties: Any fine or penalty paid or payable by the person for the violation of any law, rule or regulation.
g. Personal expenses: Any personal expenditures incurred by the person.
h. Reserves and capitalization: Any amount carried to a reserve fund or capitalized in any way.
i. Payments to AOP members: Any profit on debt, brokerage, commission, salary or other remuneration paid by an association of persons to a member of the association.
j. Cash payments exceeding Rs. 50,000 (Banking Channel Requirement): Any expenditure for a transaction, paid or payable under a single account head which, in aggregate, exceeds fifty thousand rupees, made other than by a crossed cheque drawn on a bank or crossed bank draft or crossed pay order or any other crossed banking instrument showing transfer of amount from the business bank account of the taxpayer. Provided that: Online transfer of payment from the business account of the payer to the business account of payee as well as payments through credit card shall be treated as transactions through the banking channel, subject to verification from bank statements. Further provided that this clause shall not apply in the case of:
- (a) Expenditure not exceeding ten thousand rupees;
- (b) Expenditures on account of: utility bills; freight charges; travel fare; postage; and payment of taxes, duties, fee, fines or any other statutory obligation.
k. Omitted by finance act, 2006.
l. Salary exceeding Rs. 10,000 per month (Banking Channel Requirement): Any salary paid or payable exceeding [ten] thousand rupees per month other than by a crossed cheque or direct transfer of funds to the employeeβs bank account.
m. Capital nature expenditures: Except as provided in Division III of this Part, any expenditure paid or payable of a capital nature.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway is that Section 21 explicitly disallows a wide range of common business expenditures, including taxes, fines, personal expenses, reserves, and payments to AOP members. Any expenditure exceeding Rs. 50,000 under a single account head must be made through a banking channel (crossed cheque, bank draft, or online transfer) to be deductible, with specific exceptions for small amounts and utility bills. Similarly, salary exceeding Rs. 10,000 per month must be paid by crossed cheque or direct bank transfer. Failure to deduct tax on salary payments also disallows the entire salary expense. Capital expenditures are generally not deductible unless specifically allowed under Division III of Part III of the Ordinance. The only deductions specifically allowed under Section 20 are for acquiring depreciable assets or intangibles with useful lives over one year, and for amalgamation expenses.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary rule under Section 21 regarding salary payments exceeding Rs. 10,000 per month?
- Under what condition is an expenditure exceeding Rs. 50,000 under a single account head disallowed, and what are the exceptions?
- Are contributions to an unrecognized provident fund allowed as a deduction under Section 21?
- Why are fines or penalties paid for violation of law not allowed as a deduction?
- What specific expenditures are allowed as deductions under Section 20?