π Lecture 23 β Significant points regarding Salary
π Overview: This lecture continues the computation of salary income under Pakistan's tax laws, focusing on key taxable items like reimbursement, profits in lieu of salary, and provident fund payments. It details how to value perquisites such as motor vehicles, domestic servants, utilities, loans, and housing, and covers special topics like employee share schemes, leave salary, and flying allowance taxation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers significant taxable salary items including reimbursement, profits in lieu of salary, and provident fund employer contributions. It explains the computation of perquisites under Section 13 (motor vehicle, domestic servants, utilities, loans, property, housing) with benchmark rate details. Also covered are employee share schemes (Section 14), Commissioner's power under Section 110 to tax deferred salary, leave salary exemptions, and various taxable salary components like bonus, commission, and flying allowance taxed at 2.5%.
π Lecture Summary
Significant points regarding Salary
Reimbursement of expenditure by the employer is considered Taxable. Profits in lieu of salary received as consideration for a personβs agreement to enter into an employment relationship, or on termination of employment (golden handshake payments), are also Taxable. Provident fund payments, specifically only the Employers contribution, are Taxable.
Computation of value of perquisites (Sec 13)
For a Motor vehicle, the value is computed As prescribed in IT rules 2002.
For Services of house keeper, driver, gardener, other domestic servant, the value is the Amount provided by employer which is added back to the employeeβs salary. For utilities, add the FMV of utilities as reduced by any amount paid by employee.
For a Loan below benchmark rate, the benchmark rate for tax year 2009 is 11% PA β the difference between the benchmark rate and actual interest paid is added back. However, if the concessional loan is used for construction of house or purchase of house, there is No Add back.
If an obligation of employee is waived off by the employer, this amount is Add back. If Any property transferred to employee, the FMV of property is to be added back. For Accommodation or housing provided, the value is As prescribed in IT rules 2002.
According to sub Section 14 of Section 13:
- Bench mark rate means rate of 5% PA for tax year 2003 and increase by 1% for succeeding tax years.
- Services include any facility provided.
- Utilities include electricity, gas, water, and telephone.
- Benchmark rate for the tax year 2008 is 10% and for the tax year 2009 is 11%.
Employee share schemes (Sec 14)
This covers the treatment of value of a right or option vested in an employee. The formula is: A β B (where A and B represent specific values as defined in the tax rules)
When Commissioner can tax βsalaryβ on due basis:-
Under Section 110 ("Salary paid by Private Companies"), the Commissioner has powers to tax salary on due basis. This applies when salary is paid by a private company to an employee for services rendered in an earlier tax year, and the salary has not been included in the employeeβs salary chargeable to tax in that earlier year. The Commissioner may, if there are reasonable grounds to believe that payment of the salary was deferred, include the amount in the employeeβs income under the head βSalaryβ in the earlier year.
Leave Salary
This is taxable whenever received or right to receive is exercised by the employee. Leave encashment on retirement falls in this category. The only exemption available is for members of the Armed Forces of Pakistan, employees of the Federal Government and Provincial Governments (under clause (19), Part I of Second Schedule to the Ordinance, any sum representing encashment of leave preparatory to retirement in their case is exempt).
Salary in lieu of notice: Taxable Fee and Commission: Taxable Bonus: Taxable Remuneration for extra duties: Taxable Voluntary payments to employees: Taxable
Flying Allowance
Any amount received as flying allowance by: a) pilots, flight engineers and navigators of Pakistan Armed forces, Pakistani Airline or Civil Aviation Authority; and b) Junior commissioned officers of Pakistan Armed Forces. Shall be taxed @ 2.5% as a separate block of income.
Deductible Allowance
The person shall be entitled to a deductible allowance for:
- Any Zakat paid by the person in a tax year according to provisions of sec.60
- Any Workersβ Welfare Fund paid by the person in a tax year under Sec 60-A
- Any Workersβ Participation Fund paid by the person in a tax year under section 60-B
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that reimbursement, profits in lieu of salary (including golden handshake), and employer contributions to provident fund are all taxable. For perquisites under Section 13, the benchmark rate for loans is 5% in 2003 increasing by 1% yearly (11% for 2009), but no add-back applies if the loan is for house construction or purchase. Leave salary is taxable for all except Armed Forces, federal, and provincial government employees. Flying allowance for specific aviation personnel is taxed at a flat 2.5% as a separate block. Finally, deductible allowances include Zakat, Workersβ Welfare Fund, and Workersβ Participation Fund.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the benchmark rate for tax year 2009 for concessional loans under Section 13? (Answer: 11% PA)
-
When does the Commissioner have power to tax salary on due basis under Section 110? (Answer: When a private company pays salary deferred from an earlier year and it wasn't included in that earlier year's salary)
-
Who is exempt from tax on leave encashment on retirement? (Answer: Members of the Armed Forces of Pakistan, employees of the Federal Government, and Provincial Governments)
-
At what rate is flying allowance taxed, and for which categories of employees? (Answer: 2.5% as a separate block of income for pilots, flight engineers, navigators of Pakistan Armed Forces/Pakistani Airline/CAA, and Junior Commissioned Officers of Pakistan Armed Forces)
-
What three deductible allowances are available to a person under this lecture? (Answer: Zakat (sec.60), Workersβ Welfare Fund (sec.60-A), Workersβ Participation Fund (sec.60-B))
π Lecture 24 β Tax Credits on Charitable Donations (Sec 61)
π Overview: This lecture continues the module on salary computation by focusing on various tax credits available under the Income Tax Ordinance. It explains the formulas and conditions for claiming tax credits on charitable donations (Sec 61), investment in shares (Sec 62), contributions to approved pension funds (Sec 63), and profit on debt for house construction (Sec 64). Additionally, it covers the Income Tax Rules 2002 regarding the valuation of perquisites like accommodation and conveyance, and key exemptions under the head 'Salary'.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers tax credits under Section 61 for charitable donations, Section 62 for investment in shares of public companies, Section 63 for contributions to approved pension funds, and Section 64 for profit on debt for house construction. It also details the Income Tax Rules 2002 for valuing perquisites (accommodation and conveyance) provided by employers and lists specific exemptions for salary income, such as TA/DA, free accommodation for high officials, and a tax rebate for teachers and researchers.
π Lecture Summary
Tax Credits on Charitable Donations (Sec 61)
A tax credit is allowed for donations made to specific entities, including any board of education or university in Pakistan, any educational institution, hospital, or relief fund run by a federal/provincial government or local authority, and any non-profit organization. The amount of tax credit is computed using the formula: (A/B) x C.
π Definition β Tax Credit: A reduction in the amount of tax payable, calculated as a percentage of the donation made. π Formula: (A/B) x C
- A = tax assessed before any tax credit under this part
- B = person's taxable income for the year
- C = the lesser of:
- Total amount of donations (including fair market value of property given)
- For an individual or association of persons: 30% of taxable income; for a company: 15% of taxable income
- Fair market value of any property given as a donation is determined at the time it is given.
- For a cash donation to be eligible, it must be paid by a crossed cheque drawn on a bank. π‘ Why this matters: This encourages charitable giving by directly reducing a taxpayer's liability, subject to specific limits and payment methods.
Investment in Shares β Sec 62
A person (other than a company) is entitled to a tax credit for the cost of acquiring new shares in a public company listed on a stock exchange in Pakistan, where the person is the original allottee or acquires shares from the Privatization Commission of Pakistan. The same formula applies: (A/B) x C. π Formula: (A/B) x C
- C = the lesser of:
- Total cost of acquiring the shares in the year
- 10% of the person's taxable income for the year
- 300,000 rupees (substituted from 200,000 by Finance Bill 2007)
- Clawback: If the person disposes of the shares within 12 months of acquisition, the tax payable for the year of disposal shall be increased by the amount of the credit allowed. π‘ Why this matters: This incentivizes investment in the stock market but discourages short-term speculation by clawing back the credit if shares are sold quickly.
Contribution to an Approved Pension Fund β Sec 63
An eligible person (as defined in section 2(19A)) deriving income from salary or business is entitled to a tax credit for contributions to an approved pension fund under the Voluntary Pension System Rules, 2005. The formula is (A/B) x C. π Formula: (A/B) x C
- C = the lesser of:
- Total contribution paid in the year
- 20% of taxable income for the year (with an additional allowance for those joining after age 41). The total contribution for such persons cannot exceed 50% of the total taxable income of the preceding year.
- 500,000 rupees
- Exclusion: The transfer of existing balances from an approved employment pension or annuity scheme to an individual pension account does not qualify for the tax credit. π‘ Why this matters: This encourages long-term retirement savings by offering a significant tax benefit on contributions, subject to age-related and absolute limits.
Profit on Debt β Sec 64
A tax credit is allowed for profit or share in rent paid on a loan from a scheduled bank, non-banking finance institution, government, local authority, statutory body, or a public company. The loan must be used for the construction of a new house or the acquisition of a house. π Formula: (A/B) x C
- C = the lesser of:
- Total profit paid during the year
- 40% of taxable income for the year
- 500,000 rupees π‘ Why this matters: This supports home ownership by reducing the tax burden on mortgage interest payments.
Income Tax Rules, 2002 Regarding Salary (Effective Tax Year 2009)
- Rule 3: Benefits provided by the employer to the employee shall be included in salary income according to Rules 4 to 7.
- Rule 4 β Valuation of Accommodation:
- (a) House Rent Allowance: The whole amount received is taxable.
- (b) Accommodation Facility: The value added to income is the higher of:
- The amount the employer would have paid if accommodation was not provided
- 45% of MTS (Minimum Taxable Salary) or basic salary
- Rule 5 β Valuation of Conveyance:
- (i) Partly personal and partly official use: 5% of the cost to the employer or fair market value at lease commencement.
- (ii) Personal use only: 10% of the cost to the employer or fair market value at lease commencement.
- Rule 6: "Employee" includes a director of a company.
- Rule 7: These rules apply to salary income received after 30th June 2008. π‘ Why this matters: These rules standardize how non-cash benefits (perquisites) provided by an employer are valued and taxed as part of an employee's salary.
Exemptions under the Head 'Salary'
- TA/DA: Exempt under clause 39 of part 1 of the second schedule.
- Free furnished accommodation: Exempt for the President, Provincial Governors, and Chiefs of Staff of Armed Forces (clause 51).
- Free conveyance and entertainment: Exempt for Provincial Governors, Chiefs of Staff, and Corps Commanders (clause 52).
- Workers Participation Fund: Amounts received are exempt (clause 26).
- Local traveling allowance: Exempt for journalists (clause 40).
- Tax Rebate for Teachers and Researchers: A full-time teacher or researcher at a non-profit education or research institution (recognized by HEC, a Board of Education, or a University) is allowed a tax rebate of 75%. π‘ Why this matters: These specific exemptions and rebates reduce the tax burden on certain groups of employees, recognizing their roles and encouraging specific professions.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are the formulas for computing tax credits, which all follow the structure (A/B) x C, where C represents the amount eligible after applying specific limits (e.g., 30% of income for donations, 20% for pension, 40% for profit on debt). Key limits include the absolute cap of Rs. 500,000 for pension and profit on debt, and Rs. 300,000 for share investment. It is essential to know that for charities, cash donations must be made via crossed cheque, and share disposals within 12 months trigger a clawback of the credit. For valuation of perquisites under the rules, the value of provided accommodation is the higher of 45% of salary or the allowance that would have been paid, while conveyance is valued at 5% or 10% of the vehicle's cost depending on usage. Finally, a 75% tax rebate is available for full-time teachers and researchers in recognized institutions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating the tax credit for charitable donations under Sec 61, and what are the two possible values for 'C' for an individual and a company?
- If an individual buys shares worth Rs. 500,000 and has a taxable income of Rs. 2,000,000, what is the maximum eligible value of 'C' for the tax credit under Sec 62?
- Under what condition will a tax credit for share investment be reversed (clawed back)?
- For the valuation of employer-provided accommodation under Rule 4, if the house rent allowance that would have been paid is Rs. 100,000 and 45% of the basic salary is Rs. 80,000, what amount is added to the employee's income?
- Which two groups of employees are specifically eligible for a 75% tax rebate on their salary income, and what are the key conditions for their institution to be recognized?
π Lecture 25 β Investment in Shares (Sec. 62) & Profit on Debt (Sec. 64) & Valuation of Perquisites & Rates of Tax for Salaried Individuals
π Overview: This lecture covers the computation of tax deductions for investment in shares and profit on debt under sections 62 and 64 respectively. It also details the valuation rules for perquisites like accommodation and conveyance, and provides the complete tax rate slabs for salaried individuals for the tax year 2009, including special provisions for marginal increases in income.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Investment in shares (Section 62) with the formula A/B Γ C and restrictions for original allottees. Profit on debt (Section 64) with similar formula and eligible loan providers. Valuation of perquisites including accommodation valuation at minimum 45% of MTS or basic salary, and conveyance valuation at 5% or 10% of cost. Various exemptions for salary income under different sections. Concept of MTS (Minimum of Time Scale). Complete tax rate slabs for salaried individuals for tax year 2009 with marginal relief provisions.
π Lecture Summary
Investment in Shares (Sec. 62)
This section provides a tax deduction for investment in shares, restricted to the original allottee of the shares. The deduction is computed using the formula A/B Γ C, where A and B are the same value. C is the lesser of: Cost on acquiring shares, 10% of taxable income, or Rs. 300,000 (originally "two hundred thousand" but substituted by Finance Bill 2007).
π Definition β Original allottee: The first person to whom shares are allotted by the company, not a subsequent purchaser from the secondary market. π Formula: A/B Γ C β The deduction amount where A and B are equal (making the ratio 1), and C is the lesser of the three specified limits. π Example: If taxable income is Rs. 500,000 and shares were acquired at cost of Rs. 50,000: C is lesser of (50,000, 50,000, 300,000) = Rs. 50,000. Deduction = 1 Γ 50,000 = Rs. 50,000.
π‘ Why this matters: This deduction encourages investment in equity markets by providing tax relief to original subscribers of shares.
Profit on Debt (Sec. 64)
This section provides a deduction for profit paid or shares in rent paid on loan for construction of a new house or acquisition of a house. Eligible loan providers include: Schedule Bank, Non-Banking Finance Institution, Government or Local Authority, Any Statutory Body, or Listed Public Company. The formula is again A/B Γ C, with A and B being the same. C is the lesser of: Total amount paid during tax year, 40% of taxable income, or Rs. 500,000.
π Definition β Profit on debt: Interest or profit payments made on loans, specifically for house construction or acquisition in this context. π Formula: A/B Γ C β Deduction amount where A and B are equal, and C is the lesser of the three limits. π Example: If taxable income is Rs. 1,000,000 and total profit paid during the tax year is Rs. 300,000: C is lesser of (300,000, 400,000, 500,000) = Rs. 300,000. Deduction = 1 Γ 300,000 = Rs. 300,000.
π‘ Why this matters: This deduction promotes home ownership by allowing taxpayers to claim interest payments on housing loans as a tax deduction.
Valuation of Perquisites
Valuation of Accommodation: The value is the amount that would have been otherwise provided under the terms of employment, but in no case less than 45% of MTS (Minimum of Time Scale) or basic salary.
Valuation of Conveyance:
- If the vehicle is used partly for personal and partly for official use: 5% of cost or 5% of FMV of vehicle on commencement of lease.
- If the vehicle is used for personal use only: 10% of cost or 10% of FMV of vehicle.
- This applies when the employee includes a director of a company.
π Definition β Perquisite: Any benefit or facility provided by the employer to the employee, which is taxable as part of salary income. π Example: If an employee's basic salary is Rs. 600,000 per year and the employer provides accommodation: Minimum value = 45% of 600,000 = Rs. 270,000, which would be added to taxable salary even if the actual rental value is lower.
Exemptions
Several exemptions are available for salary income:
- Salary earned abroad by a Pakistani citizen in the year of leaving Pakistan β exempt vide section 51(2).
- Exemptions available to Diplomatic personnel and their staff β exempt vide section 42.
- Salary received by foreign government officials β exempt vide section 43.
- Salary received by Foreigners working on certain projects β exempt vide section 44(2).
- Any benevolent grant paid from the benevolent fund to employees or their families β exempt under clause 24 of part 1 of 2nd schedule.
- Any special allowance or benefit (not being entertainment allowance or conveyance allowance) or other perquisites as contained in section 12 specially granted to meet expenses wholly or necessarily incurred in the performance of duties β exempt under clause 39 of part 1 of second schedule.
Concept of MTS (Minimum of Time Scale)
MTS stands for Minimum of Time Scale. This is the starting point or minimum amount which is available to an employee under a time scale. For example, if the time scale is: Rs. 20,000 -- 2000 -- 30000, here Rs. 20,000 is the Minimum of Time Scale.
π Definition β MTS: The lowest salary point in a government or organizational pay scale, used as a base for calculating perquisite values like accommodation.
Rates of Tax for Salaried Individuals for Tax Year 2009
The tax rates are slab-based, starting from 0% for income up to Rs. 180,000, and increasing progressively to 20% for income exceeding Rs. 8,650,000. The complete slab table is as follows:
| S. No | Taxable Income Range | Rate of Tax |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Up to Rs. 180,000 | 0% |
| 2 | Rs. 180,001 β 250,000 | 0.50% |
| 3 | Rs. 250,001 β 350,000 | 0.75% |
| 4 | Rs. 350,001 β 400,000 | 2% |
| 5 | Rs. 400,001 β 450,000 | 2.50% |
| 6 | Rs. 450,001 β 550,000 | 3.50% |
| 7 | Rs. 550,001 β 650,000 | 4.50% |
| 8 | Rs. 650,001 β 750,000 | 6.00% |
| 9 | Rs. 750,001 β 900,000 | 7.50% |
| 10 | Rs. 900,001 β 1,050,000 | 9.00% |
| 11 | Rs. 1,050,001 β 1,200,000 | 10.00% |
| 12 | Rs. 1,200,001 β 1,450,000 | 11.00% |
| 13 | Rs. 1,450,001 β 1,700,000 | 12.50% |
| 14 | Rs. 1,700,001 β 1,950,000 | 14.00% |
| 15 | Rs. 1,950,001 β 2,250,000 | 15.00% |
| 16 | Rs. 2,250,001 β 2,850,000 | 16.00% |
| 17 | Rs. 2,850,001 β 3,550,000 | 17.50% |
| 18 | Rs. 3,550,001 β 4,550,000 | 18.50% |
| 19 | Rs. 4,550,001 β 8,650,000 | 19.00% |
| 20 | Above Rs. 8,650,000 | 20.00% |
Special provision for women taxpayers: Where income of a woman taxpayer is covered, no tax shall be charged if the taxable income does not exceed Rs. 240,000.
Marginal Relief Provisions: Where the total income marginally exceeds the maximum limit of a slab, the income tax payable shall be the tax payable on the maximum of that slab plus an amount equal to:
(i) 20% of the amount by which the total income exceeds the said limit where total income does not exceed Rs. 500,000.
(ii) 30% of the excess where total income does not exceed Rs. 1,050,000.
(iii) 40% of the excess where total income does not exceed Rs. 2,000,000.
(iv) 50% of the excess where total income does not exceed Rs. 4,450,000.
(v) 60% of the excess where total income exceeds Rs. 4,450,000.
π Definition β Marginal relief: A mechanism to reduce the tax burden when income slightly exceeds a slab threshold, by taxing only the excess amount at a specified higher percentage rather than the entire income. π Example: If taxable income is Rs. 260,000 (exceeding the Rs. 250,000 slab maximum by Rs. 10,000): Tax on Rs. 250,000 at 0.50% = Rs. 1,250. Marginal relief = 20% of Rs. 10,000 = Rs. 2,000. Total tax = Rs. 1,250 + Rs. 2,000 = Rs. 3,250.
π‘ Why this matters: Marginal relief prevents taxpayers from being pushed into a much higher tax bracket when their income just exceeds a slab limit, ensuring a smooth transition between tax rates.
β Key Takeaways
Students must memorize the investment in shares deduction formula (A/B Γ C) where C is the lesser of cost, 10% of taxable income, or Rs. 300,000, and the profit on debt deduction where C is the lesser of total amount paid, 40% of taxable income, or Rs. 500,000. The valuation of accommodation is always at least 45% of MTS or basic salary, while conveyance is valued at 5% (mixed use) or 10% (personal only) of cost or FMV. The tax rate slabs for 2009 start at 0% up to Rs. 180,000 and end at 20% above Rs. 8,650,000, with a special threshold of Rs. 240,000 for women taxpayers. Marginal relief applies with increasing percentages (20% to 60%) as income exceeds slab limits across different income ranges.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three limits for determining "C" in the investment in shares deduction formula under Section 62?
- For the profit on debt deduction under Section 64, what is the maximum percentage of taxable income allowed as a limit?
- What is the minimum percentage of MTS or basic salary that must be used for valuation of accommodation?
- What is the tax rate for a salaried individual with taxable income of Rs. 500,000 for tax year 2009?
- Explain the marginal relief provision when taxable income exceeds Rs. 4,450,000 β what percentage applies to the excess amount?
π Lecture 26 β Exercises on Salary and Its Computation
π Overview: This lecture provides a series of practical exercises to compute taxable income and tax liability for salaried individuals in Pakistan for Tax Year 2009. It demonstrates how to apply salary tax rules, exemptions, and progressive tax rates to various scenarios involving basic salary, allowances, and bonuses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five comprehensive exercises that compute taxable income and tax for resident salaried employees. Each exercise applies specific tax rates based on taxable income brackets, demonstrates treatment of exempt and non-exempt allowances (house rent, utilities, medical, and hospitalization), and shows the computation of tax payable after adjusting for tax deducted at source. The exercises also clarify the difference between calendar year and tax year income, and illustrate the legislative changes that removed certain exemptions after June 2006.
π Lecture Summary
Exercise 1
This exercise calculates the taxable income for Mr. A, an employee of XYZ Company for the tax year 2009. The employee receives a basic salary of Rs 30,000 per month from January 1, 2008, to December 31, 2008. However, the tax year 2009 in Pakistan covers the period from July 1, 2008, to June 30, 2009, so only six months of salary (180,000) are taxable. The taxable income of Rs 180,000 falls within the first tax bracket (Serial #1) where tax is 0% for income not exceeding Rs 180,000. Therefore, income tax payable = Nil.
π Definition β Tax Year 2009: For the tax year 2009 in Pakistan, the income period is from July 1, 2008, to June 30, 2009, not the calendar year.
π Formula: Taxable Income = Total Income β Exempt Income β Tax Liability = Taxable Income Γ Applicable Tax Rate (0% for income β€ Rs 180,000)
π Example: Mr. A earns Rs 360,000 during calendar year 2008 (Jan-Dec), but only Rs 180,000 falls within the tax year 2009 (Jul 2008-Jun 2009). Tax payable = 180,000 Γ 0% = Rs 0.
Exercise 2
This exercise computes taxable income for Mr. X, an employee of a private company. He receives basic salary of Rs 40,000 per month (Rs 480,000 annually), bonuses of Rs 80,000, and utilities paid by employer of Rs 40,000. The utilities were previously exempt up to 10% of Minimum Time Scale (MTS) or Basic salary under clause 38 of Part 1 of the Second Schedule, but this clause was omitted by Finance Act, 2006. Hence, no exemption is available for tax year 2009. Total taxable income is Rs 600,000, which falls under tax bracket Serial #7 (income exceeding Rs 550,000 up to Rs 650,000) at a tax rate of 4.50%. Income tax payable = 600,000 Γ 4.50% = Rs 27,000.
π Definition β Utilities Exemption (Omitted): The exemption for utilities (up to 10% of MTS or Basic salary) was available until June 30, 2006, but was removed by the Finance Act, 2006.
π Formula: Tax for income Rs 550,001 to Rs 650,000 = Taxable Income Γ 4.50%
π Example: Mr. X's total income = 480,000 (salary) + 80,000 (bonus) + 40,000 (utilities, no exemption) = Rs 600,000. Tax = 600,000 Γ 4.50% = Rs 27,000.
Exercise 3
This exercise computes taxable income for Mr. Y, where the Minimum Time Scale (MTS) is given as Rs 20,000β2000β30,000 (starting pay Rs 20,000, increment Rs 2,000, maximum Rs 30,000). He receives basic salary of Rs 24,000 per month (Rs 288,000 annually), house allowance of Rs 2,000 per month (Rs 24,000 annually), and utilities of Rs 36,000 paid by employer. The utilities exemption (clause 38) has been omitted by Finance Act, 2006, so no exemption is available. Total taxable income is Rs 348,000, which falls under tax bracket Serial #3 (income exceeding Rs 250,000 up to Rs 350,000) at 0.75%. Income tax payable = 348,000 Γ 0.75% = Rs 2,610.
π Formula: Tax for income Rs 250,001 to Rs 350,000 = Taxable Income Γ 0.75%
π Example: Mr. Y's taxable income = 288,000 (salary) + 24,000 (house allowance) + 36,000 (utilities, fully taxable) = Rs 348,000. Tax = 348,000 Γ 0.75% = Rs 2,610.
Exercise 4
This exercise calculates taxable income for Mr. A, with an MTS of Rs 30,000β5000β50,000. He receives basic salary of Rs 40,000 per month (Rs 480,000 annually) and house allowance of Rs 120,000 per annum. Tax deducted at source (TDS) is Rs 6,000. Total taxable income is Rs 600,000, which falls under bracket Serial #7 (income exceeding Rs 550,000 up to Rs 650,000) at 4.50%. Gross tax = 600,000 Γ 4.50% = Rs 27,000. After deducting TDS of Rs 6,000, net tax payable = Rs 21,000.
π Definition β Tax Deducted at Source (TDS): Tax already withheld by the employer from salary payments, which reduces the final tax payable by the employee.
π Formula: Net Tax Payable = Gross Tax Liability β Tax Deducted at Source
π Example: Mr. A's taxable income = 480,000 (salary) + 120,000 (house allowance) = Rs 600,000. Gross tax = 600,000 Γ 4.50% = Rs 27,000. TDS = Rs 6,000. Net tax payable = 27,000 β 6,000 = Rs 21,000.
Exercise 5
This exercise computes taxable income for Mr. Yasir with multiple allowances. He receives basic salary Rs 20,000/month (Rs 240,000), house rent allowance Rs 5,000/month (Rs 60,000), medical allowance Rs 5,100/month (Rs 61,200), free hospitalization services valued at Rs 40,000 (exempt under clause 139(a) of Second Schedule), driver's salary paid by employer Rs 8,000/month (Rs 96,000), and dearness allowance Rs 6,000/month (Rs 72,000). The hospitalization services are fully exempt as per clause 139(a) & (b): free hospitalization provided under terms of employment is exempt; if not available, then 10% of basic salary is exempt for medical allowance. Total taxable income = Rs 529,200, which falls under bracket Serial #6 (income exceeding Rs 450,000 up to Rs 550,000) at 3.50%. Income tax payable = 529,200 Γ 3.50% = Rs 18,515.
π Definition β Medical Exemption (Clause 139): Clause 139(a) exempts free hospitalization services provided under the terms of employment. Clause 139(b) provides that if (a) is not available, 10% of basic salary is exempt for medical allowance.
π Formula: Tax for income Rs 450,001 to Rs 550,000 = Taxable Income Γ 3.50%
π Example: Mr. Yasir's total income = 240,000 (salary) + 60,000 (house allowance) + 61,200 (medical allowance) + 0 (hospitalization, exempt) + 96,000 (driver's salary) + 72,000 (dearness allowance) = Rs 529,200. Tax = 529,200 Γ 3.50% = Rs 18,515.
β Key Takeaways
The critical concepts for the exam include understanding that the tax year 2009 covers July 1, 2008, to June 30, 2009, not the calendar year, and that all allowances (house, utilities, medical, driver's salary, dearness) are generally fully taxable unless a specific exemption applies. The tax rates are progressive using a slab system, where the applicable rate depends on which bracket the taxable income falls into. Exemptions for utilities were removed by the Finance Act, 2006, making them fully taxable for tax year 2009, while free hospitalization under employment terms remains exempt under clause 139(a). Finally, tax deducted at source (TDS) is subtracted from the gross tax liability to determine the net amount payable.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the tax year 2009 period in Pakistan, and how does it affect salary income calculation?
-
For tax year 2009, is the utilities exemption (clause 38) still available? Why or why not?
-
Under clause 139(a) and (b) of the Second Schedule, what medical benefits are exempt from tax?
-
If taxable income is Rs 529,200, which tax bracket applies and what is the tax rate?
-
How do you calculate net tax payable when tax deducted at source (TDS) is provided?
π Lecture 6.27 β Computation of taxable income and tax thereon in respect of Mr. Umar (a salaried individual) for the tax year 2009
π Overview: This lecture is a practical exercise session demonstrating how to compute taxable income and tax liability for salaried individuals in Pakistan for tax year 2009. Through three detailed case studies (Exercises 6, 7, and 8), it applies key rules for allowances, exemptions, accommodation valuation, and motor vehicle benefits, showing the step-by-step process from gross income to final tax payable.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three sequential exercises: Exercise 6 computes taxable income for Mr. Umar with Basic Salary, Conveyance Allowance, Medical Allowance (with exemption calculation), and Dearness Allowance, applying the 0.75% tax rate. Exercise 7 adds Accommodation provided by employer (valued at 50% of Minimum Time Scale), Computer Allowance, and Qualification Pay, applying the 3.50% tax rate. Exercise 8 for Mr. Yasir includes Accommodation valued at 60% of Basic Salary and a Motor Vehicle for personal use (valued at 10% of cost), applying the 6% tax rate. Each exercise includes detailed notes on exemption rules and valuation methods.
π Lecture Summary
Computation of taxable income and tax thereon in respect of Mr. Umar (a salaried individual) for the tax year 2009 from the following information/ data:
Basic Salary Rs. 20,000 pm, Conveyance Allowance Rs. 1,000 pm, Medical Allowance Rs. 28,000 pa, Dearness Allowance Rs. 1,000 pm.
In Exercise 6, Mr. Umar's total income is computed by annualizing all monthly amounts: Basic Salary (20,000 x 12 = 240,000), Conveyance Allowance (1,000 x 12 = 12,000), Medical Allowance (28,000 per annum), and Dearness Allowance (1,000 x 12 = 12,000). The taxable income is calculated by subtracting exempt portions. For Medical Allowance, the exemption is calculated per Note 1: exempt up to 10% of Basic Salary, provided free hospitalization or reimbursement of medical expenses is not given. 10% of 240,000 = 24,000 exempt, so taxable Medical Allowance = 28,000 β 24,000 = 4,000. All other allowances are fully taxable (no exemption). Total taxable income = 240,000 + 12,000 + 4,000 + 12,000 = 268,000.
Tax liability: Since taxable income (268,000) exceeds Rs. 250,000 but is less than Rs. 350,000, the tax rate at serial #3 for that slab is 0.75%. Income tax payable = 268,000 Γ 0.75% = Rs. 2,010.
π Definition β Medical Allowance exemption: Medical allowance is exempt up to 10% of Basic salary, if free hospitalization services or reimbursement of medical expenses are not provided by the employer. π Formula: Exempt Medical Allowance = min(Actual Medical Allowance, 10% Γ Basic Salary) π Example: Basic Salary = 240,000; 10% = 24,000; Actual Medical Allowance = 28,000; Exempt = 24,000; Taxable = 28,000 β 24,000 = 4,000.
Computation of taxable income and tax thereon in respect of Mr. Umar (a salaried individual) for the tax year 2009 from the following information/data:
Minimum Time Scale Rs. 20,000-2000-30,000, Basic Salary @ Rs. 24,000 pm, Accommodation provided by the employer (employee entitled for house rent allowance @ 50% of MTS), Computer Allowance Rs. 1,000 pm, Qualification pay Rs. 1,000 pm.
In Exercise 7, Mr. Umar's Basic Salary = 24,000 Γ 12 = 288,000. Accommodation is valued per Note 1: the amount that would have been otherwise provided under terms of employment, but in no case less than 45% of Minimum Time Scale (MTS) or basic salary. Here, entitlement is 50% of MTS. MTS minimum = 20,000. So 50% Γ 20,000 = 10,000 per month (or 120,000 per year if annualized at 12 months). However, the solution shows 144,000. This is calculated as: entitlement is 50% of MTS which is 50% Γ 20,000 = 10,000 pm = 120,000 per year. The "in no case less than 45% of MTS or basic salary" β 45% of MTS = 9,000 pm, 45% of basic salary (24,000) = 10,800 pm. The solution uses the entitlement rate of 50% of MTS but applies it to Basic Salary? Careful check: The solution says Accommodation = 144,000. This equals 50% of Basic Salary (288,000 Γ 50% = 144,000). So the rule applied: Amount that would have been otherwise provided under terms of employment (50% of MTS or basic salary?) β here "50% of MTS" is the entitlement, but the note says "in no case less than 45% of MTS or basic salary". The solution uses 50% of Basic Salary (144,000), which is greater than 45% of MTS (45% Γ 240,000? Wait, careful: 45% of MTS = 45% Γ 20,000 Γ 12 = 108,000) or 45% of Basic Salary (45% Γ 288,000 = 129,600). So 144,000 > 129,600, so the amount used is the entitlement rate applied to Basic Salary. Computer Allowance = 1,000 Γ 12 = 12,000 (fully taxable). Qualification Pay = 1,000 Γ 12 = 12,000 (fully taxable). Total taxable income = 288,000 + 144,000 + 12,000 + 12,000 = 456,000.
Tax liability: Since taxable income (456,000) exceeds Rs. 450,000 but is less than Rs. 550,000, the tax rate at serial #6 is 3.50%. Income tax payable = 456,000 Γ 3.5% = Rs. 15,960.
π Definition β Accommodation valuation (employer-provided): The taxable value of accommodation is the amount that would have been otherwise provided under terms of employment (e.g., house rent allowance as a percentage of MTS or Basic Salary), but in no case less than 45% of MTS or basic salary.
Computation of taxable income and tax thereon in respect of Mr. Yasir (a salaried individual) for the tax year 2009 from the following information/data:
MTS Rs. 20,000-2000-30000, Basic Salary @ Rs. 30,000 pm, Accommodation provided to Mr. Yasir by employer (entitled for house rent allowance @60% of Basic Salary), Motor vehicle provided by the employer exclusively for personal use (cost of vehicle is Rs.1 million).
In Exercise 8, Mr. Yasir's Salary = 30,000 Γ 12 = 360,000. Accommodation: Entitlement is 60% of Basic Salary = 60% Γ 360,000 = 216,000. Check floor: 45% of MTS = 45% Γ 20,000 Γ 12 = 108,000; 45% of Basic Salary = 45% Γ 360,000 = 162,000. 216,000 > 162,000, so use 216,000. Motor Vehicle for personal use is valued per Note 2: 10% of cost or 10% of Fair Market Value (FMV) of Vehicle, in case of lease. Cost = 1,000,000, so 10% = 100,000. Total taxable income = 360,000 + 216,000 + 100,000 = 676,000.
Tax liability: Since taxable income (676,000) exceeds Rs. 650,000 but is less than Rs. 750,000, the tax rate at serial #8 is 6%. Income tax payable = 676,000 Γ 6% = Rs. 40,560.
π Definition β Motor Vehicle valuation (personal use): For a vehicle provided by the employer exclusively for personal use, the taxable value is 10% of the cost or 10% of the Fair Market Value of the vehicle; in case of lease, the value is determined differently. π Formula: Taxable value of motor vehicle = 10% Γ Cost (or FMV) of vehicle
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding how to value non-cash benefits like accommodation and motor vehicles is critical because these "perquisites" are often the largest components of taxable income for higher-salaried employees, pushing them into higher tax brackets.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember the step-by-step process for computing taxable income: start with gross income (annualize monthly amounts), identify exempt portions using specific rules (Medical Allowance exemption = 10% of Basic Salary), and add all taxable allowances. For accommodation, the taxable value is the higher of the entitlement percentage (of MTS or Basic Salary) and the floor of 45% of MTS or basic salary. For motor vehicles used personally, the taxable value is 10% of cost. Finally, apply the correct tax slab rate (0.75% for income 250,000-350,000; 3.5% for 450,000-550,000; 6% for 650,000-750,000) to compute tax payable.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- In Exercise 6, why is only Rs. 4,000 of Medical Allowance taxable when the total is Rs. 28,000?
- In Exercise 7, how is the taxable value of accommodation calculated when the entitlement is 50% of MTS, and what is the "floor" rule?
- In Exercise 8, what is the taxable value of the motor vehicle provided for personal use, and what percentage of cost is used?
- What tax rates are applied to taxable incomes of Rs. 268,000, Rs. 456,000, and Rs. 676,000 in these exercises?
- What is the difference between the accommodation valuation rules in Exercise 7 (50% of MTS) versus Exercise 8 (60% of Basic Salary)?
π Lecture 6.28 β EXERCISES ON SALARY AND ITS COMPUTATION (CONTD....)
π Overview: This lecture continues practical computation of salary income and tax liability for salaried individuals in Pakistan. It walks through three progressively complex exercises, covering key fringe benefits (accommodation, motor vehicle, loans, flying allowance), deductions (Zakat, donations), special income blocks (golden handshake, former/prospective employer salary), and tax credits.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture presents three detailed exercises (9, 10, and 11) that cover the computation of taxable income from salary components such as basic pay, accommodation valuation, motor vehicle for personal vs. official use, flying allowance taxed as a separate block, concessional loan benefit, medical allowance, leave pay, bonuses, utilities, TA/DA, golden handshake payments, and the tax credit for charitable donations.
π Lecture Summary
Exercise 9: Computation for Mr. Yasir (Basic + Fringe Benefits)
This exercise computes taxable income for a salaried individual receiving basic salary, employer-provided accommodation, a motor vehicle for mixed use, flying allowance from a Pakistani airline, and a concessional loan. The solution adds back the value of accommodation, vehicle personal use, and the loan interest differential, while taxing flying allowance as a separate block.
π Definition β Accommodation benefit: Value is the amount that would have been otherwise provided under the terms of employment, but in no case less than 45% of MTS or basic salary. The problem uses 50% of basic salary here: 20,000 Γ 50% = 10,000 pm β 120,000 per year. π Formula β Motor vehicle valuation (mixed use): 5% of cost or 5% of FMV of vehicle if leased. Cost = 1,000,000 β 1,000,000 Γ 5% = 50,000 per year. π Formula β Concessional loan benefit: (Benchmark rate β actual markup rate) Γ loan amount. Benchmark = 11%, actual = 6%, difference = 5%. 1,000,000 Γ 5% = 50,000. π Definition β Flying allowance: Taxed at 2.5% of the amount received as a separate block of income under sub clause 1 of part 3 of the second schedule. The entire 400,000 is exempt from normal tax but taxed separately at 2.5%. π Example: Tax liability = Normal tax (460,000 Γ 3.5% = 16,100) + Separate block tax (400,000 Γ 2.5% = 10,000) = Total 26,100.
π‘ Why this matters: Concessional loans and mixed-use vehicles are common employer-provided benefits. Their valuation rules ensure that the economic benefit to the employee is captured in taxable income.
Exercise 10: Computation with Donations and Zakat
This exercise adds the considerations of Zakat paid as a deductible allowance and charitable donations as a tax credit. Here, the motor vehicle is provided exclusively for official use, so no add-back is made.
π Definition β Motor vehicle for exclusive official use: No add-back is made to the employeeβs salary income. The vehicle provided is fully exempt. π Formula β Tax credit on donation: A/B Γ C, where A = tax payable before credit, B = total taxable income, C = actual donation or 30% of taxable income (whichever is lower). Here: 42,900/715,000 Γ 10,000 = 600. (C is taken as 10,000 since 30% of 715,000 = 214,500, which is greater than the donation of 10,000.) π Example: Total taxable income = 480,000 (salary) + 240,000 (accommodation) β 5,000 (Zakat) = 715,000. Tax at 6% = 42,900. After donation credit of 600, final tax = 42,300.
π‘ Why this matters: Zakat is deducted from total income, while donations reduce the final tax liability through a credit β both are distinct mechanisms that lower the tax burden.
Exercise 11: Consolidated Comprehensive Exercise
This is the most complex exercise, consolidating many salary components: basic salary, salary from former and prospective employers, tax liability paid by employer, voluntary payments, leave pay, medical allowance, free hospitalization, extra duty allowance, bonuses, utilities, TA/DA, golden handshake, and donations.
π Definition β Salary from former employer & prospective employer: Fully taxable as part of total salary income. 200,000 + 100,000 added. π Definition β Tax liability paid by employer: This is a taxable fringe benefit β the amount is added to the employee's salary as if it were paid to the employee. π Definition β Voluntary payments by employee (80,000): These are not deductible for salaried individuals. Similarly, personal expenses like car (40,000) and house renovation (100,000) are not admissible. π Definition β Medical allowance: Exemption is not allowed if free hospitalization services are already provided under terms of employment. Here, free hospitalization of 100,000 is exempt, but medical allowance of 60,000 is fully taxable. π Definition β TA/DA for official assignments: Fully exempt (40,000). No tax is charged. π Definition β Golden handshake payment (1,600,000): Can be taxed at the average rate of tax of the last 3 years. Average = (25+20+15)/3 = 20%. The tax on this block is at 20% (not the slab rate). The solution notes this is "not advisable" β meaning it is computed separately. π Formula β Tax credit on donation: A/B Γ C = 416,800 / 2,605,000 Γ 40,000 = 6,400. (C is 40,000 since 30% of taxable income = 781,500 > 40,000.) π Example: Total taxable income = 2,605,000. Tax at 16% slab = 416,800. Donation credit = 6,400. Tax payable = 410,400. Deduct tax at source (224,000) β Net tax payable = 186,400.
π‘ Why this matters: Golden handshake payments and salary from multiple employers are real-world complexities. The average-rate method for golden handshake can significantly lower the tax compared to the marginal slab rate.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember: (1) Accommodation benefit is at least 45% of MTS or basic salary; (2) Motor vehicle valuation is 5% of cost for mixed use, nil for exclusive official use; (3) Flying allowance is a separate block taxed at 2.5%; (4) Concessional loan benefit = loan Γ (benchmark rate β actual rate); (5) Zakat is a deduction from total income, while donations provide a tax credit (A/B Γ C, capped at 30% of taxable income); (6) Tax liability paid by employer is a taxable benefit; (7) TA/DA for official use is exempt; (8) Medical allowance is taxable if free hospitalization is provided; (9) Golden handshake is taxed at the average rate of the last 3 years; (10) Tax at source is deducted from final tax payable.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How is the value of accommodation benefit computed when the employee is entitled to house rent allowance of 50% of basic salary, and what is the minimum floor?
- Under what condition is a motor vehicle provided by the employer NOT added back to salary income?
- What is the tax rate applied to flying allowance, and how is it treated in the tax computation?
- How is the concessional loan benefit calculated when the employer charges 6% markup and the benchmark rate is 11%?
- Explain the formula for the tax credit on charitable donations using the numbers from Exercise 10 (tax payable 42,900, taxable income 715,000, donation 10,000).