π Lecture 8.34 β Deductions---Special Provisions
π Overview: This lecture covers special provisions for deductions under the Pakistani tax code, focusing on depreciation of business assets, initial allowances for new assets, and amortization of intangibles and pre-commencement expenditures. It also outlines key rules for scientific research, employee training, financial costs, bad debts, and the taxation of certain recoveries and gains even after business cessation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first details depreciation under Section 22, including the written down value computation, disposal rules, and the definition of depreciable assets. It then explains the initial allowance under Section 23 for eligible assets placed into service for the first time in Pakistan. Next, it covers amortization of intangibles under Section 24, followed by pre-commencement expenditure amortization under Section 25. The lecture concludes with a list of other special deduction provisions (Sections 26β30) and the taxation of certain income items even in the absence of a business under Section 31.
π Lecture Summary
Depreciation (Sec. 22)
A deduction for depreciation is allowed if depreciable assets are used in a personβs business in a tax year. The rate of depreciation is applied as specified in Part 1 of the 3rd Schedule. The written down value (WDV) of a depreciable asset at the beginning of the tax year is calculated as:
- For an asset acquired in the tax year: the cost of the asset reduced by any initial allowance under Section 23.
- For any other case: the cost of the asset reduced by the total depreciation deductions (including any initial allowance under Section 23) allowed in previous tax years.
π Definition β Depreciable asset: A tangible movable or immovable property (not unimproved land) or structural improvement to immovable property owned by a person that has a normal useful life of one year or more, is likely to lose value due to normal wear and tear, and is used wholly in deriving income from business chargeable to tax.
π Formula (Written Down Value for asset acquired in tax year): WDV = Cost of Asset β Initial Allowance (Sec 23) π Formula (Written Down Value for asset acquired in prior years): WDV = Cost β Total Depreciation allowed in previous years (including initial allowance)
π‘ Why this matters: Special rules apply when an asset is disposed of. No depreciation is allowed in the year of disposal. If the consideration received exceeds the WDV at the time of disposal, the excess is chargeable to tax under βIncome from business.β If the consideration received is less than the WDV, the difference is allowed as a deduction in computing business income for that year.
π Example (Gain on Sale): A machine with a cost of PKR 100,000 and accumulated depreciation of PKR 40,000 (WDV = PKR 60,000) is sold for PKR 80,000. The excess of PKR 20,000 (80,000 β 60,000) is chargeable to tax as income from business.
π Example (Loss on Sale): Using the same machine (WDV of PKR 60,000), if it is sold for PKR 50,000, the difference of PKR 10,000 (60,000 β 50,000) is allowed as a deduction from business income.
Initial Allowance (Sec. 23)
A person who places an eligible depreciable asset into service in Pakistan for the first time in a tax year shall be allowed a deduction at the rate of 50% of the cost of the asset. This allowance is provided that the asset is used by the person for business purposes for the first time or in the tax year in which commercial production is commenced, whichever is later.
π Definition β Eligible depreciable asset: A depreciable asset other than:
- Any road transport vehicle (unless the vehicle is plying for hire);
- Any furniture, including fittings;
- Any plant or machinery that has been used previously in Pakistan; or
- Any plant or machinery for which a deduction has been allowed under another section of this Ordinance for the entire cost of the asset in the acquisition year.
π Formula: Initial Allowance = 50% Γ Cost of Eligible Depreciable Asset
π Example: A company purchases a new, never-before-used-in-Pakistan machine for PKR 5,000,000 and places it into service for business in the current tax year. The initial allowance is PKR 2,500,000 (50% Γ PKR 5,000,000). This reduces the cost for computing future WDV.
Intangibles (Sec. 24)
A person shall be allowed an amortization deduction for the cost of intangibles, provided the intangibles are wholly or partially used in the tax year for deriving income from business and have a normal useful life exceeding one year.
π Formula (Amortization Deduction): A / B Where A is the cost of the intangible, and B is the normal useful life of the intangible.
π Special Rule: An intangible with a normal useful life of more than 10 years, or one that does not have an ascertainable useful life, shall be treated as if it had a normal useful life of 10 years.
π Example: A company acquires a patent for PKR 1,000,000 with a legal life of 8 years. The annual amortization deduction is PKR 125,000 (PKR 1,000,000 / 8 years).
π Example: A company acquires goodwill for PKR 2,000,000, which has an indefinite/useful life. Since the useful life is not ascertainable, it is treated as having a 10-year useful life. The annual amortization deduction is PKR 200,000 (PKR 2,000,000 / 10 years).
Pre-commencement expenditure (Sec.25)
Pre-commencement expenditure means any expenditure incurred before the commencement of the business wholly and exclusively to derive income chargeable to tax. This includes the cost of feasibility studies and trial production activities. However, it shall not include any expenditure incurred in acquiring land, or any expenditure which is depreciated under Section 22 (depreciation) or amortized under Section 24 (intangibles).
π Formula: Rate of amortization of pre-commencement expenditure = 20% (Straight line)
π Example: A new business incurs PKR 500,000 in feasibility studies and trial production costs before officially commencing operations. These costs cannot be deducted in full in year 1. Instead, the business can amortize them at 20% per year, allowing a deduction of PKR 100,000 each year for 5 years.
DeductionsβSpecial Provisions (Sections 26β30)
The lecture lists the following special provisions for deductions:
- Scientific research institutions (sec 26)
- Employee training and facilities (sec 27)
- Profit on debt, financial costs and lease payments (sec 28)
- Bad debts (sec 29)
- Sec 29A: Deductions on consumer loans to a banking company, non-banking finance company, and house building finance corporations. (Deduction shall not exceed 3% of income for the tax year arising out of consumer loans.)
- Profit on non-performing debts of a banking company or development finance institution (sec 30)
Transfer to Participatory Reserve (Sec 31) β Income taxable even without business
The following incomes are taxable under the head "Income from Business" even in cases where no business is carried on by the taxpayer in that year:
- Recovery against any deduction/expenses previously allowed (Add back to income).
- Gain on sale of depreciable asset.
- Recovery of bad debt or written off loan.
- Trading liabilities not paid within expiration of three years.
- Amount received after discontinuance of business.
π Example: A business wrote off PKR 100,000 of bad debts in Year 1, getting a tax deduction. In Year 3, the customer pays PKR 50,000. Even if the business has ceased operations, this PKR 50,000 recovery is taxable as "Income from Business."
β Key Takeaways
Depreciation is allowed on tangible business assets with a useful life over one year, with the written down value method being the basis. The initial allowance of 50% is a significant upfront deduction for eligible new assets. Intangibles are amortized over their useful life, with a default of 10 years for those with a life exceeding 10 years or an unascertainable life. Pre-commencement expenditures are amortized at a flat rate of 20% per year. Crucially, certain recoveries and gains (e.g., on asset sales or bad debt recoveries) are taxable as business income even if the business has ceased operations.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating the written down value of a depreciable asset that was acquired in the current tax year and has received an initial allowance?
- If a depreciable asset with a WDV of PKR 200,000 is sold for PKR 250,000, how is the PKR 50,000 excess treated for tax purposes?
- List the four types of assets that are explicitly excluded from being an "eligible depreciable asset" for the purposes of the initial allowance under Section 23.
- An intangible asset has a normal useful life of 15 years. Over how many years must it be amortized under Section 24?
- Name two specific types of income that are taxable under the head "Income from Business" even when no business is being carried on, as per Section 31.
π Lecture 36 β Methods of Accounting
π Overview: This lecture covers the fundamental methods of accounting for tax purposes under Pakistani income tax law, including cash-basis and accrual-basis accounting. It also provides detailed tax rate schedules for individuals, AOPs, and companies for Tax Year 2009, along with specific rates for dividends, non-resident payments, withholding tax, and depreciation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with methods of accounting under Section 32, distinguishing between cash-basis (Section 33) and accrual-basis (Section 34) accounting, with mandatory accrual basis for companies. It then covers valuation of stock using the A+B-C formula, record-keeping requirements, and detailed tax rate schedules for individuals and AOPs (1st Schedule) and companies for Tax Year 2009. The lecture also includes rates for dividend tax under Section 5, tax on payments to non-residents under Section 6, withholding tax rates on profit on debt and prizes, and depreciation rates from the Third Schedule Part 1.
π Lecture Summary
Methods of Accounting
Under section 32, a person's income is to be computed in accordance with the method of accounting regularly employed by such person. There are two types of accounting methods: Cash-Basis accounting under Section 33, and Accrual-Basis accounting under Section 34. For companies, accrual basis is mandatory, while for other persons, it is optional to use either cash or accrual basis. Under Cash-Basis Accounting, a person derives income when it is received and incurs expenditure when it is paid. Under Accrual Basis Accounting, a person derives income when it is due to the person and incurs expenditure when it is payable by the person. Any change in the method of accounting requires prior approval from the Commissioner under Section 32(4).
Valuation of Stock
The cost of stock-in-trade disposed of (consumed) during the year is computed using the formula: π Definition β Stock-in-trade: Goods held by a business for the purpose of sale or trading. π Formula: A + B - C β Opening stock plus stock acquired during the year minus closing stock.
Records
The kinds of records to be maintained include: records of money received and expended, sales and purchases records, assets and liabilities records, and a stock register. If a computerized system is used, electronic receipts must be maintained. General instructions require that a backup system is in place, proper security arrangements/system are implemented, records are maintained in line with International Accounting Standards, and records are kept at a specified place.
Rates of Tax for Individuals and AOP (1st Schedule) for Tax Year 2009
The tax rates are slab-based, starting at 0% for taxable income up to Rs. 100,000, and increasing progressively to 25% for taxable income exceeding Rs. 1,300,000. For example, income between Rs. 100,001 and Rs. 110,000 is taxed at 0.5%, between Rs. 200,001 and Rs. 300,000 at 5%, between Rs. 600,001 and Rs. 800,000 at 15%, and between Rs. 1,000,001 and Rs. 1,300,000 at 21%.
Rates of Tax for Companies for Tax Year 2009
The standard rate of tax imposed on the taxable income of a company is 35%. However, for a small company as defined in section 2, tax is payable at the rate of 20%, provided the turnover does not exceed Rs. 250 million. If turnover exceeds Rs. 250 million, a graduated rate structure applies: 20% on income up to Rs. 250 million turnover, 25% on income attributable to turnover between Rs. 250 million and Rs. 350 million, 30% on income attributable to turnover between Rs. 350 million and Rs. 500 million, and 35% on income attributable to turnover exceeding Rs. 500 million. π‘ Why this matters: These progressive rates incentivize small companies and impose higher rates on larger businesses.
Rate of Dividend Tax under Section 5
Dividends received from another company are taxed at 10% of the gross amount of dividend. Dividends received from a power project company privatized by WAPDA are taxed at 7.5% of the gross amount. Dividends received from a power generation company are also taxed at 7.5% of the gross amount.
Rate of Tax on Certain Payments to Non-Residents under Section 6
Royalty or fee for technical services paid to a non-resident is taxed at 15% of the gross amount. For shipping or air transport of a non-resident person, the rate is 8% of the gross amount received for shipping income and 3% of the gross amount received for air transport income.
Deduction of Tax at Source
Profit on debt under Section 151 is subject to 10% withholding tax on the profit paid. For prizes and winnings under Section 156, a prize bond is taxed at 10% of the gross amount paid, while winnings from raffle, lottery, or winning a quiz are taxed at 20% of the gross amount paid.
Depreciation (Sec. 22) Third Schedule Part 1
Depreciation rates specified for the purposes of Section 22 are prescribed. For Building (all types), the rate is 10%. For Furniture (including fittings), machinery and plant (not otherwise specified), Motor Vehicles (all types), ships, technical or professional books, the rate is 15%. For Computer hardware including printer, monitor and allied items, machinery and equipment used in manufacture of I.T. products, aircrafts and aero engines, the rate is 30%. For mineral oil concerns, below ground installations are depreciated at 100%, and offshore platform and production installations are depreciated at 20%.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that companies are mandatorily required to use accrual-basis accounting, while individuals and AOPs have a choice. The valuation of stock follows the A+B-C formula, and comprehensive records including stock register and backup systems are mandatory. The tax rate schedules for Tax Year 2009 are critical: individuals and AOPs face progressive rates from 0% to 25%, while companies pay 35% generally, with small companies paying 20% up to Rs. 250 million turnover, after which graduated rates apply. Dividend tax rates vary (10% for regular companies, 7.5% for power companies), non-resident payments have specific rates (15% for royalties, 8% for shipping, 3% for air transport), and withholding tax applies at 10% for profit on debt and prize bonds, and 20% for other winnings. Depreciation rates under the Third Schedule are 10% for buildings, 15% for furniture/machinery/vehicles, 30% for computer hardware, and special rates for mineral oil concerns.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under which section is the method of accounting determined, and what are the two main types of accounting methods?
- What is the formula for computing the cost of stock-in-trade disposed of during the year?
- For Tax Year 2009, what is the tax rate for an individual with taxable income of Rs. 450,000?
- What is the tax rate for a small company with a turnover of Rs. 300 million, and how is it computed?
- What is the depreciation rate for computer hardware under the Third Schedule, and what is the rate for a building?
π Lecture 37 β Taxation of Resident Company & Business Income Computation
π Overview: This lecture covers the computation of taxable income and tax liability for resident companies in Pakistan, focusing on disallowed deductions under Section 21, minimum tax on turnover under Section 113, depreciation calculations, and the treatment of speculation business losses. It is important for understanding how tax authorities adjust declared income and how companies must comply with specific payment and deduction rules.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture presents four exercises: Exercise 1 deals with add-backs for failure to deduct tax at source on salaries, contract payments, and professional fees; Exercise 2 addresses add-backs for cash payments exceeding certain thresholds under Section 21; Exercise 3 covers the computation of normal depreciation and initial allowance on plant and machinery; Exercise 4 deals with the treatment of speculation business losses and their set-off against speculation income only.
π Lecture Summary
Taxation of Resident Company β Exercise 1
M/S XYZ Ltd. declared taxable income of Rs. 1,350,000 for tax year 2009. During scrutiny, the tax authority found the company failed to deduct tax at source on three payments: salaries of Rs. 350,000, payments for a contract to purchase office appliances of Rs. 150,000, and professional fees paid to a chartered accountant of Rs. 100,000. Since deductions are not allowed under provisions of Section 21, these amounts are added back to income.
π Definition β Add Back: An amount that must be added to declared taxable income because an expense claimed as a deduction is disallowed under tax law.
π Formula: Taxable Income after add back = Declared taxable income + Total amounts added back under Section 21
π Example: Declared taxable income Rs. 1,350,000 + Add back of Rs. 600,000 (350,000 + 150,000 + 100,000) = Rs. 1,950,000. Tax on declared income: Rs. 1,350,000 x 35% = Rs. 472,500. Additional tax on add backs: Rs. 600,000 x 35% = Rs. 210,000.
Taxation of Companies β Minimum Tax on Resident Companies Sec. 113
A resident company is subjected to minimum tax at 0.50% of its turnover for a tax year, even when the company sustains a loss. Turnover under this section includes gross receipts from the sale of goods (exclusive of sales tax, central excise duty, and trade discounts shown on invoices), gross fees for rendering services or giving benefits including commissions, gross receipts from the execution of contracts, and the companyβs share of these amounts from any association of persons it is a member of.
π‘ Why this matters: This minimum tax ensures that even loss-making companies contribute a baseline amount of tax based on their business activity.
Exercise 2 β Add Back for Cash Payments
M/s XYZ (Pvt) Ltd. filed a return for tax year 2009 declaring taxable income of Rs. 1,300,000 and paid the full tax liability of Rs. 455,000 (1,300,000 x 35%). The tax authorities found that certain payments were made in cash. Under Section 21, payments for salary (Rs. 30,000), office rent (Rs. 120,000), and professional fee (Rs. 80,000) made by cash are added back, totaling Rs. 230,000.
π Definition β Section 21(L): A provision that disallows deductions for certain expenses if they are paid in cash and exceed specified limits. In this exercise, postages (Rs. 8,000), freight (Rs. 9,000), electricity bill (Rs. 7,000), telephone (Rs. 5,000), and penalty (Rs. 9,000) are not added back as they are not covered by the cash payment prohibition.
π Formula: Additional tax = Add back amount x 35%
π Example: Rs. 230,000 x 35% = Rs. 80,500 additional tax payable.
Computation of Depreciation β Exercise 3
M/S A.K. Brothers, a partnership firm, provided information on plant and machinery: opening book value (W.D.V) as on 01-07-2008 was Rs. 1,800,000, machinery with a book value of Rs. 600,000 was disposed of during the year, and additions of eligible depreciable assets during the year were Rs. 1,000,000.
π Definition β Initial Allowance: An additional depreciation allowance granted in the year of acquisition of a depreciable asset, calculated at a specified rate (here 50%) on the cost of additions.
π Definition β Normal Depreciation: The standard annual depreciation rate applied to the written down value (W.D.V) of an asset, here 15% for plant and machinery.
π Formula:
- Opening W.D.V β Disposals = Balance W.D.V
- Initial Allowance = Additions x 50%
- Total book value = Balance W.D.V + (Additions β Initial Allowance)
- Normal Depreciation = Total book value x 15%
π Example: Opening W.D.V Rs. 1,800,000 β Disposal Rs. 600,000 = Balance W.D.V Rs. 1,200,000 (X). Additions Rs. 1,000,000. Initial Allowance = Rs. 1,000,000 x 50% = Rs. 500,000. Balance book value of additions = Rs. 1,000,000 β Rs. 500,000 = Rs. 500,000 (Y). Total book value (X+Y) = Rs. 1,200,000 + Rs. 500,000 = Rs. 1,700,000. Normal Depreciation = Rs. 1,700,000 x 15% = Rs. 255,000. Total Depreciation = Rs. 500,000 (Initial) + Rs. 255,000 (Normal) = Rs. 755,000.
On Speculation Business β Exercise 4
M/s ABC Ltd., a manufacturing company, provided: gross income from normal business Rs. 2,500,000, expenditures on normal business Rs. 1,000,000, gross income from speculation business Rs. 600,000, expenditures on speculation business Rs. 300,000, loss carried forward on normal business Rs. 200,000, loss carried forward on speculation business Rs. 900,000, and advance tax paid Rs. 200,000.
π Definition β Speculation Business: A business where profits arise from transactions involving the purchase and sale of commodities or securities without the intention of taking delivery, and losses from such business can only be set off against profits from speculation business.
π Formula:
- Net Income = Gross Income β Expenditures
- Taxable Income = Net Income β Carried Forward Loss (subject to set-off rules)
π Example:
- Speculation: Gross income Rs. 600,000 β Expenditure Rs. 300,000 = Net Income Rs. 300,000.
- Normal: Gross income Rs. 2,500,000 β Expenditure Rs. 1,000,000 = Net Income Rs. 1,500,000.
- Total Net Income = Rs. 1,800,000.
- C/F Loss: Speculation Rs. 900,000 (can only be set off against speculation income), Normal Rs. 200,000.
- Speculation Net Income Rs. 300,000 β C/F Speculation Loss Rs. 900,000 = Rs. (600,000) (cannot be set off against normal income; carried forward).
- Normal Net Income Rs. 1,500,000 β C/F Normal Loss Rs. 200,000 = Rs. 1,300,000.
- Taxable Income: Normal business Rs. 1,300,000. Tax = Rs. 1,300,000 x 35% = Rs. 455,000.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that Section 21 requires add-backs of certain expenses where tax was not deducted at source or payments were made in cash, with specific items like salary, rent, and professional fees being affected. Minimum tax under Section 113 is 0.50% of turnover and applies even if the company has a loss. Depreciation computation involves calculating initial allowance (50% on additions) and then normal depreciation (15%) on the total written down value. Speculation business losses can only be set off against speculation business profits, not against normal business income, and any unabsorbed loss is carried forward to subsequent years.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under Section 21, what three payments made by M/S XYZ Ltd. were added back for failure to deduct tax at source, and what was the total add-back amount?
- What is the rate of minimum tax on turnover for a resident company under Section 113, and what components constitute turnover?
- In Exercise 2, which cash payments were added back under Section 21 and which were not, and why?
- In Exercise 3, how is initial allowance calculated, and what is the normal depreciation rate applied to plant and machinery?
- In Exercise 4, why was the loss of Rs. 600,000 from speculation business not set off against normal business income, and what happens to it?
π Lecture 38 β Taxation of Companies
π Overview: This lecture covers the practical computation of taxable income and tax liability for different business structures in Pakistan, specifically a limited company, a sole proprietorship, and an association of persons (partnership firm). It demonstrates how a taxation officer identifies and adds back inadmissible expenses and how the tax liability is calculated for each entity type.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture presents three detailed exercises: Exercise 5 on the taxation of a limited company running a hospital chain, including the identification of inadmissible expenses and their add-back; Exercise 6 on the taxation of a sole proprietorship, covering the computation of gross profit and net profit from a trading and profit & loss account; and Exercise 7 on the taxation of an association of persons (a partnership firm), explaining the firm's tax liability and the individual partners' tax computation, including the special rule for adding a partner's share of profit for rate purposes only.
π Lecture Summary
Taxation of Companies Exercise-5
The first exercise involves M/S XYZ Ltd., a resident company running hospitals, whose tax return for tax year 2009 has been selected for total audit. As a taxation officer, you must compute the taxable income and tax liability. The solution begins by reconstructing the revenue account as submitted by the company, showing total receipts of Rs. 8,200,000 and total expenditures including medicines, ambulances running expenses, depreciation, salaries, and other items, resulting in a net profit of Rs. 5,388,000. The company then set off a loss carried forward from tax year 2005 of Rs. 1,200,000, arriving at a taxable income of Rs. 4,188,000 and a tax payable of Rs. 1,465,800 (at 35%), which after withholding tax deductions of Rs. 525,000 resulted in a tax paid of Rs. 940,800 showing nil balance.
However, the taxation officer must make additions for inadmissible expenses discovered during audit. These include an unsupported payment of Rs. 12,000, depreciation claimed on a personal car of the director of Rs. 40,000, payment of legal fee by cash of Rs. 60,000 (which violates the specified mode of payment rule), and the purchase of an X-Ray machine of Rs. 1,000,000 which was incorrectly shown as a revenue expense but must be capitalized as a balance sheet item. These total additions of Rs. 1,112,000 are taxed at 35%, resulting in an additional tax of Rs. 389,200 payable by the company.
π Definition β Inadmissible Expenses: Expenses that are not allowed as deductions under tax law, either because they are personal in nature, lack proper supporting evidence, or violate payment rules. π Formula: Tax on Additions = Total Inadmissible Expenses Γ Corporate Tax Rate π Example: For M/S XYZ Ltd., the inadmissible expenses (Rs. 1,112,000) are added back to the income and taxed at 35%. The extra tax payable is Rs. 1,112,000 Γ 35% = Rs. 389,200. This is in addition to the tax already computed on the originally reported net profit. π‘ Why this matters: This shows that a company can still face additional tax liability even after filing a return if the taxation officer identifies expenses that do not meet the legal requirements for deduction.
Sole Proprietorship Exercise-6
The second exercise covers Mr. A, a sole proprietor, for tax year 2009. A trading and profit & loss account is prepared to compute taxable income. The trading account starts with an opening stock of Rs. 800,000 plus purchases of Rs. 1,000,000 and carriage inwards of Rs. 30,000. After accounting for sales of Rs. 2,000,000 and a closing stock of Rs. 800,000, the gross profit is calculated as Rs. 970,000. From this gross profit, operating expenses including electricity (Rs. 18,000), telephone (Rs. 20,000), office rent (Rs. 120,000), stationery (Rs. 4,000), postages (Rs. 3,000), salaries (Rs. 200,000), and advertising (Rs. 10,000) are deducted, yielding a net profit of Rs. 595,000.
The tax payable is then calculated at the applicable individual tax rate. For tax year 2009, the rate used is 12.50% on the net profit of Rs. 595,000, resulting in a gross tax of Rs. 74,375. After subtracting the advance tax paid of Rs. 60,000, the balance tax payable is Rs. 14,375, which was paid with the return, showing a nil tax payable or refundable.
π Definition β Sole Proprietorship: A business owned and operated by one individual, where the business income is taxed as part of the individual's total income at personal income tax rates. π Formula: Gross Profit = Sales + Closing Stock - (Opening Stock + Purchases + Carriage Inwards) π Example: Gross Profit = Rs. 2,000,000 + Rs. 800,000 - (Rs. 800,000 + Rs. 1,000,000 + Rs. 30,000) = Rs. 2,800,000 - Rs. 1,830,000 = Rs. 970,000. Net Profit = Gross Profit - Total Operating Expenses = Rs. 970,000 - (Rs. 18,000 + Rs. 20,000 + Rs. 120,000 + Rs. 4,000 + Rs. 3,000 + Rs. 200,000 + Rs. 10,000) = Rs. 970,000 - Rs. 375,000 = Rs. 595,000.
Taxation of Association of Persons Exercise-7
The third exercise deals with M/S XYZ brothers, a partnership firm (an Association of Persons) comprising three partners (Mr. X, Mr. Y, and Mr. Z) with equal profit shares. The firm's net profit for tax year 2009 is Rs. 900,000. The tax liability of the firm itself is computed at the applicable rate for the firm, which for this income range (Rs. 800,000 to 1,000,000) is 17.50%, resulting in a tax of Rs. 157,500. This tax liability is the obligation of the firm, not of the partners individually.
The lecture then explains the special rule for partners, specifically Mr. Z, who has additional income from other sources of Rs. 200,000. For the purpose of determining Mr. Z's tax rate, his share of profit from the firm (Rs. 300,000) is added to his other income for rate purposes only. This gives a total of Rs. 500,000, on which the tax is calculated at the rate of 10%, yielding Rs. 50,000. However, a proportional deduction is made to remove the tax attributable to the share of profit (which is taxed at the firm level). This deduction is calculated as (Rs. 50,000 / Rs. 500,000) Γ Rs. 300,000 = Rs. 30,000. Therefore, the final tax payable by Mr. Z is Rs. 50,000 - Rs. 30,000 = Rs. 20,000.
π Definition β Association of Persons (AOP): A business structure, including a partnership firm, which is taxed as a separate entity on its total income, and partners are not taxed on the same share of profit again, except for rate determination. π Formula: Tax Payable by Partner = [Tax on (Partner's Other Income + Share of Profit)] - [Proportional Tax on Share of Profit] π Example: For Mr. Z, the tax on Rs. 500,000 (Rs. 200,000 other income + Rs. 300,000 share of profit) at 10% is Rs. 50,000. The proportional tax on the share of profit is (Rs. 50,000 / Rs. 500,000) Γ Rs. 300,000 = Rs. 30,000. Therefore, Mr. Z's final tax is Rs. 50,000 - Rs. 30,000 = Rs. 20,000. Without this rate effect, he would have paid only Rs. 8,000 (Rs. 200,000 Γ 4%).
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that for a company under audit, a taxation officer must scrutinize all expenses and add back any that are inadmissible, such as unsupported payments, personal expenses, cash payments above the specified limit, and capital expenditures incorrectly claimed as revenue expenses, all of which attract additional tax at the corporate rate. For a sole proprietorship, the taxable income is simply the net profit computed from the trading and profit & loss account, and the tax is applied at the individual income tax rates. For an association of persons, the firm itself is taxed on its profit, but a partner's share of profit is added to their other income only for determining the applicable tax rate, not for double taxation, requiring a proportional deduction to avoid taxing the same income twice. The specific tax rates used in the exercises (35% for companies, 12.50% for individuals, and 17.50% for AOPs) are crucial for historical context; students must refer to current tax rates for contemporary applications.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four inadmissible expenses identified in the audit of M/S XYZ Ltd., and what is the total amount added back and the resulting additional tax?
- In Exercise 6, how is the gross profit calculated, and what is the net profit for Mr. A's sole proprietorship?
- What is the firm-level tax liability for M/S XYZ brothers on a net profit of Rs. 900,000, and what tax rate is applied?
- Explain the rule for adding a partner's share of profit for rate purposes only. What is the final tax payable by Mr. Z, and why is a deduction made?
- Why is the purchase of an X-Ray machine for Rs. 1,000,000 considered an inadmissible expense in the company's revenue account, and how should it have been treated?
π Lecture 39 β Capital Gains
π Overview: This lecture explains how capital gains are defined, computed, and taxed under the Income Tax Ordinance. It covers the formula for calculating capital gains, special treatment for assets held over one year, exemptions, and the definition of capital assets and disposal. Understanding capital gains taxation is essential for accurate tax compliance on asset sales.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the chargeability of capital gains to tax, the formula for computing capital gain (consideration received minus cost), the reduced gain rate for assets held over one year (three-fourths of total gain), treatment of cost for assets acquired by gift or inheritance, deductions for losses on capital asset disposal (with exceptions for certain items like artwork and jewelry), the definition of "capital asset" including excluded items, examples of capital assets, and the legal definition of "disposal" with examples.
π Lecture Summary
Capital gain subject to this ordinance
A gain arising on the disposal of a capital asset by a person in a tax year, other than a gain that is exempt from tax under this ordinance, shall be chargeable to tax under the head "Capital gains".
Computation of Capital Gain
Capital gain shall be computed in accordance with the following formula:
Capital Gain = A - B
- A is the consideration received by the person on disposal of the capital asset
- B is the cost of the asset
If a capital asset has been held by a person for more than one year, the gain shall be considered as 3/4th of total capital gain derived on disposal of the capital asset.
π Example: Say capital gain is Rs 100,000, if the capital asset is disposed of after retaining for more than one year, then gain chargeable to tax would be: 100,000 Γ 3/4 = Rs 75,000
No amount shall be included in the cost of the capital asset (B) for any expenditure incurred by a person where a capital asset becomes the property of the person as outlined below:
- a) Under a gift or will
- b) By succession, inheritance or devolution
- c) A distribution of assets on dissolution of an association of persons
- d) On distribution of assets on liquidation of a company
In these cases, the fair market value of the asset on the date of its transfer or acquisition by the person shall be treated to be the cost of the asset.
π Definition β Fair market value: The price that an asset would sell for on the open market on the date of transfer or acquisition.
Deductions of losses in computing the amount chargeable under the head "Capital Gains" [sec 38]
Deductions shall be allowed under sec 38 for any loss on the disposal of a capital asset by the person in the year.
However, no loss shall be recognized under this ordinance on the disposal of the following capital assets:
- A painting, sculpture, drawing or other work of art
- Jewelry
- A rare manuscript, folio or book
- A postage stamp
- A coin or medallion
- An antique
Definition of 'Capital Asset'
'Capital Asset' means property of any kind held by a tax payer, whether or not connected with business, but does not include the following:
Assets Excluded From the Definition of "Capital Asset":
- Any stock-in-trade (not being stocks and shares), consumable stores or raw materials held for the purpose of business
- Any property with respect to which the person is entitled to a depreciation deduction under section 22 or amortization deduction under section 24
- Any immovable property
- Any movable property (excluding capital assets specified in sub section (5) of section 38) held for personal use by the person or any member of the person's family dependent on the person
π‘ Why this matters: These exclusions mean that most business assets (like inventory and depreciable property) and personal-use movable property are not treated as "capital assets" for capital gains tax purposes.
"Capital Assets" Include among others the following:
- Movable assets
- Immovable Assets (excluding Immoveable Property)
- Tangible Assets
- Intangible Assets, etc.
- Share of partner/member in a firm or AOP (in this ordinance even firms are treated as AOP)
- Mining rights
- Industrial licenses & import/export licenses acquired for consideration
- Tenancy right or leasehold rights
- Foreign currency
- Right to subscribe for shares
- The contractual right of a purchaser to obtain title to an immovable property
- A license to manufacture certain product or render any services (known as franchise)
- Goodwill for which payment has been made. Self-created goodwill does not come into the ambit of chargeability under this head
- All precious metals, gems, stones, antique pieces and Jewelry which are not held by the assessee for his family members dependent on him. This includes gold and silver coins, art collections, etc.
Term Disposal β Defined [Section 2(8) read with section 75]
Some Examples of Disposal: i. Transfer of capital asset by a subsidiary company to a parent company or vice versa ii. Any transfer, in a scheme of amalgamation, of a capital asset by the amalgamating company to the amalgamated company iii. Transfer of share by a shareholder in a scheme of amalgamation of companies iv. Any transfer of a capital asset by a wholly-owned subsidiary company to its Pakistani holding company v. Any transfer of capital asset being any work of art, archaeological, scientific nature or art collection, book, manuscript, drawing, painting, photograph or print, to the Government or a University or the National Museums, National Art Gallery, National Archives or any other such public museum or institution
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: (1) Capital gain is computed as consideration received minus cost, but for assets held over one year only 3/4th of the gain is chargeable to tax. (2) For assets acquired by gift, will, inheritance, or distribution on dissolution/liquidation, the fair market value on the date of transfer is treated as the cost. (3) No loss is recognized on disposal of specified personal property like paintings, jewelry, stamps, coins, antiques, or rare manuscripts. (4) "Capital asset" excludes stock-in-trade, depreciable property, immovable property, and personal-use movable property, but includes shares, mining rights, licenses, franchise rights, purchased goodwill, and precious metals/gems not held for personal use. (5) Disposal includes specific transfers between related companies, amalgamation transfers, and transfers of art/archaeological items to government or public institutions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for computing capital gain under the Income Tax Ordinance?
- How is capital gain reduced if the asset was held for more than one year?
- When a capital asset is acquired by gift or inheritance, how is the cost determined?
- Which types of capital assets are excluded from recognition of loss on disposal under section 38?
- List five items that are specifically included in the definition of "capital asset" but are not ordinary business assets.
π Lecture 40 β Disposals Not Chargeable To Tax Under Sec.79 Non Recognition Rules
π Overview: This lecture covers situations where capital gains or losses are not recognized for tax purposes under Section 79 of the Income Tax Ordinance, along with exemptions provided in the Second Schedule. It explains the "non-recognition rules" that apply to specific disposals like gifts, inheritances, and transfers between spouses, and provides practical exercises to calculate taxable capital gains.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the six types of disposals that are not chargeable to tax under Section 79, including transfers between spouses, gifts, inheritances, and compulsory acquisitions with reinvestment. It then outlines exemptions for capital gains from the Second Schedule, covering shares, Mudarba certificates, and special zones. Finally, it presents four practical exercises that demonstrate how to calculate capital gains and determine taxability in different scenarios, including compulsory acquisition, share sales, and mining rights.
π Lecture Summary
Disposals Not Chargeable To Tax Under Sec.79 Non Recognition Rules
No gain or loss shall be taken to arise on the disposal of an asset in the following situations:
- Between spouses under an agreement to live apart
- By reason of the transmission of the asset to an executor or beneficiary on the death of a person
- By reason of a gift of the asset
- By reason of the compulsory acquisition of the asset under any law where the consideration received for the disposal is reinvested by the recipient in an asset of a like kind within one year of the disposal
- By a company to its shareholders on liquidation of the company
- By an association of persons to its member on dissolution of the association where assets are distributed according to their interests
π‘ Why this matters: These non-recognition rules prevent tax from triggering on transfers that don't involve real economic gain, such as gifts or inheritances, and encourage reinvestment of compensation into similar assets.
Exemptions as Contained in Second Schedule
The Second Schedule provides several exemptions for capital gains:
- Clause 110: Exempts income from the sale of Mudarba certificates, any instrument of redeemable capital as defined in Companies Ordinance, 1984 and listed on a stock exchange in Pakistan, shares of a public company, and Pakistan Telecommunication Corporation vouchers issued by the Government of Pakistan
- Clause 111: Exempts capital gains from sale of shares of a public company derived by a foreign institutional investor approved by the Federal Government
- Clause 112: Omitted
- Clause 113: Exempts capital gains from sale of shares of a public company set up in any special industrial zone (referred to in clause 126), derived by a person for five years from the date of commencement of commercial production, provided the company is eligible for exemption under clause 126
- Clause 114: Exempts capital gains derived by a person from an industrial undertaking set up in an area declared by the Federal Government to be a "Zone" within the meaning of the Export Processing Zone Authority Ordinance 1980
- Clause 114A: Exempts capital gains from sale of ships and all floating crafts including tugs, dredgers, survey vessels and other specialized craft up to the tax year ending on 30th June, 2011
Exercise on Capital Gain
Exercise-1: On 1st July 2008, the Govt. prohibited sale of plastic bags and took over machines of M/s WW Ltd (cost Rs. 1,000,000). The Govt. paid Rs. 2,500,000 as compensation. The company purchased new machines of the related business on 1st April 2009 costing Rs. 4,000,000.
π Formula: Capital Gain = Consideration received β Cost of acquisition β Plain-English: The profit is the amount received minus what you originally paid. π Example:
- Consideration received (A) = Rs. 2,500,000
- Cost of Acquisition (B) = Rs. 1,000,000
- Capital Gain = Rs. 2,500,000 β Rs. 1,000,000 = Rs. 1,500,000
- Result: Although there is a gain of Rs. 1,500,000, it is not chargeable to tax because the consideration received was reinvested in a like business within one year of disposal (compulsory acquisition rule).
Exercise 2: On 01/01/2007, Mr. Y purchased 10,000 shares at Rs. 30 per share. He sold them on 20/06/2009 at Rs. 50 per share.
π Formula: Taxable Capital Gain (held > 1 year) = Capital Gain Γ 3/4 π Example:
- Consideration received (A) = 10,000 Γ 50 = Rs. 500,000
- Cost of acquisition (B) = 10,000 Γ 30 = Rs. 300,000
- Capital Gain = Rs. 500,000 β Rs. 300,000 = Rs. 200,000
- Since shares held for more than one year, 3/4th of the gain is taxable:
- Taxable Capital Gain = Rs. 200,000 Γ 3/4 = Rs. 150,000
Exercise 3: On 01/10/2008, Mr. A acquired mining rights at Rs. 2,000,000. On 01/02/2009, he disposed of them to Mr. Y for Rs. 5,000,000.
π Example:
- Consideration received (A) = Rs. 5,000,000
- Cost of acquisition (B) = Rs. 2,000,000
- Capital Gain = Rs. 5,000,000 β Rs. 2,000,000 = Rs. 3,000,000
- Note: Held for less than one year (4 months), so full gain is taxable (no 3/4 reduction).
Exercise 4: On 01/01/2007, M/s XYZ Pvt. Ltd. purchased 5,000 shares of a public company at Rs. 100 per share. On 10/05/2009, they sold at Rs. 150 per share.
π Example:
- Consideration received (A) = 5,000 Γ 150 = Rs. 750,000
- Cost of acquisition (B) = 5,000 Γ 100 = Rs. 500,000
- Capital Gain = Rs. 750,000 β Rs. 500,000 = Rs. 250,000
- Since held more than 1 year, normally taxable gain = Rs. 250,000 Γ 3/4 = Rs. 187,500
- However, gain is not taxable because exemption under Clause 110 of Part I of Second Schedule applies to gains from sale of shares of a public limited company.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points to remember are the six non-recognition rules under Section 79, where no gain or loss arises: transfers between spouses under separation agreements, inheritances, gifts, compulsory acquisitions with reinvestment within one year into like-kind assets, company liquidations to shareholders, and dissolution of associations to members. For capital gains taxation, if an asset is held for more than one year, only three-quarters (3/4th) of the gain is taxable, while gains from assets held less than one year are fully taxable. Crucially, exemptions under the Second Schedule (especially Clause 110 for shares of public companies and Clause 111 for foreign institutional investors) can override normal taxability, so always check applicable exemptions before computing tax.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- List four of the six situations where no gain or loss arises on disposal under Section 79.
- If a person receives compensation for compulsory acquisition and reinvests it in a different type of asset after 13 months, is the gain taxable?
- Under which clause of the Second Schedule are capital gains from shares of a public company exempt for a Pakistani taxpayer?
- Calculate taxable capital gain: Mr. X bought shares at Rs. 20 each on 1 Jan 2008 and sold them at Rs. 35 each on 30 June 2009 (no exemption applies).
- Why was the capital gain in Exercise 4 not taxable despite the shares being held for more than one year?
Here is the summary of the provided lecture text, formatted according to your strict instructions.