π Lecture 13 β Whole Language Method
π Overview: This lecture explores the Whole Language Method, an approach to language instruction that emerged in the 1980s emphasizing the teaching of language as a complete, integrated system rather than through isolated components like phonics or grammar. It matters because it represents a significant shift away from traditional decoding approaches toward meaning-making, authentic communication, and student-centered learning in both first and second language contexts.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the historical background and origins of the Whole Language Movement in the 1980s, its philosophical foundations and theories of language and learning, the key principles guiding instructional design and objectives, the specific roles of teachers, learners, and materials, and finally the classroom procedures and activities characteristic of this approach including the use of parallel texts.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-061: Background of Whole Language Method
The term Whole Language was created in the 1980s by U.S. educators concerned with teaching language arts, particularly reading and writing in the native language. It arose in opposition to "decoding" approaches that focus on separate components like grammar, vocabulary, and word recognition, especially phonicsβthe theory that reading involves identifying letters and turning them into sounds. Whole Language argues that language should be taught as a "whole," because "if language isn't kept whole, it isn't language anymore" (Rigg 1991, p. 522). The approach emphasizes learning to read and write naturally, focusing on real communication and reading for pleasure. It shares philosophical ground with Communicative Language Teaching by emphasizing meaning and meaning-making, and relates to natural approaches to language learning by aiming to help learners acquire a second language the same way children learn their first. In a survey of 64 articles, Bergeron (1990) found Whole Language treated as an approach (34.4%), a philosophy (23.4%), a belief (14.1%), or a method (6.3%). The lecture views it as an approach based on key principles: language is whole, and writing, reading, listening, and speaking should be integrated.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the origin and opposition to decoding approaches helps clarify why Whole Language prioritizes authentic, meaningful communication over skill drill.
Topic-062: Approach and Theory of Language and of Learning in Whole Language Method
Whole Language views language organization from an interactional perspective, a social view where language is a vehicle for human communication with an interactional relationship between readers and writers. Heavy emphasis is placed on "authenticity", engagement with authors of written texts, and conversation. For example, mastering sociolinguistic signals for "apologizing" requires an authentic, real situation where one truly needs to apologize. Whole Language also views language psycholinguistically as a vehicle for internal "interaction"βfor egocentric speech and thinking: "We use language to think" (Rigg 1991, p. 323). A functional model of language is also referenced: language is always used for meaningful purposes and authentic functions. The learning theory underlying Whole Language lies in humanistic and constructivist schools. Whole Language is described as authentic, personalized, self-directed, collaborative, and pluralisticβcharacteristics believed to focus learner attention and motivate mastery. Constructivist learning theory holds that knowledge is socially constructed rather than received or discovered. Thus, learners "create meaning," "learn by doing," and work collaboratively on common projects. Rather than transmitting knowledge, teachers collaborate with students to create understanding in their mutual social context, focusing on learners' experience, needs, interests, and aspirations.
Topic-063: Objectives, Syllabus, and Learning Activities in Whole Language Method
The major principles underlying the design of Whole Language instruction include: the use of authentic literature rather than artificial texts; a focus on real and natural events; the reading of real texts of high-interest, particularly literature; reading for comprehension and real purpose; writing for a real audience rather than to practice skills; writing as a process through which learners explore and discover meaning; the use of student-produced texts; integration of reading, writing, and other skills; student-centered learning where students choose what they read and write; reading and writing in partnership with other learners; and encouragement of risk-taking and acceptance of errors as signs of learning rather than failure.
Topic-064: Role of Learners, Teachers, and Materials in Whole Language Method
Role of the Teacher: The teacher is a facilitator and active participant in the learning community rather than an expert passing on knowledge. The teacher teaches students, not subject matter, and looks for teachable moments rather than following preplanned lesson plans. The teacher creates a climate supporting collaborative learning and has the responsibility of negotiating a plan of work with learners.
Role of the Learner: The learner is a collaboratorβcollaborating with fellow students, the teacher, and writers of texts. Students are also evaluators, evaluating their own and others' learning with the teacher's help. The learner is self-directed, using their own learning experiences as resources. Students are selectors of learning materials and activities: "Choice is vital in a whole language class, because without the ability to select activities, materials, and conversational partners, the students cannot use language for their own purposes" (Rigg 1991, p. 526).
Materials: Whole Language advocates the use of real-world materials rather than commercial texts. A piece of literature is an example because its creation was not instructionally motivated but resulted from the author's wish to communicate. Other real-world materials include newspapers, signs, handbills, storybooks, and printed materials from the workplace. Students also produce their own materials. Rather than purchasing textbooks and "basal readers," schools use class sets of literature, both fictional and nonfictional.
Topic-065: Procedure in Whole Language Method
The issue of specific instructional characteristics is problematic because Bergeron (1990) found Whole Language described differently in each of 64 articles surveyed, with only four classroom features mentioned in more than 50%: the use of literature, the use of process writing, encouragement of cooperative learning among students, and concern for students' attitude. Activities often used include: individual and small group reading and writing, ungraded dialogue journals, writing portfolios, writing conferences, student-made books, and story writing. Many activities are common in other approaches like Communicative Language Teaching, Content-Based Teaching, and Task-Based Language Teaching. Perhaps the only unique feature of Whole Language not appearing centrally in communicative approaches is the focus on literature. What differs is not incidental use of such activities, but their use as part of an overall philosophy of teaching and learning that gives new meaning and purpose.
The lecture provides an example using "Parallel Texts" βtwo English translations of the same Korean short story by Hwang Sun-Won. Study of the two translations highlights the range of linguistic choices open to the writer and translator. In pairs, one student acts as presenter/interpreter of one translation, a partner of the other. Sample student activities include: comparing which described village students would prefer to live in; discussing whether contrasting opening sentences set up different expectations; indicating story locations on a map; writing an opening sentence of the village in a different season; writing two parallel text opening sentences describing a familiar village; and discussing what different kinds of stories might follow, then writing an original first sentence drawing on both translations as resources.
β Key Takeaways
The Whole Language Method must be understood as an approach that fundamentally rejects decoding and phonics-based instruction, insisting instead that language must be taught as a complete, integrated whole where reading, writing, speaking, and listening are never separated. Its theoretical foundation rests on an interactional, constructivist perspective where knowledge is socially constructed through authentic communication and meaningful tasks rather than received from an expert teacher. The roles of all participants shift dramatically: teachers become facilitators who seek teachable moments, learners become collaborators and self-directed selectors of materials, and real-world texts like literature replace commercial textbooks entirely. Classroom procedures center on literature, process writing, cooperative learning, and student-produced texts, with activities like dialogue journals, writing portfolios, and parallel text analysis serving the overarching philosophy rather than isolated skill practice. For the exam, remember that Whole Language is distinguished from Communicative Language Teaching primarily by its central focus on literature as an authentic, integral component of the learning philosophy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does the "decoding" approach to reading emphasize, and how does Whole Language oppose it?
- According to Bergeron's 1990 survey, what percentage of articles treated Whole Language as an approach versus a method?
- What are the four classroom features mentioned in more than 50% of Bergeron's surveyed articles?
- What is a "Parallel Text" activity, and what does it aim to highlight for learners in a Whole Language classroom?
- According to Rigg (1991), why is "choice" vital in a Whole Language class?
π Lecture 14 β Multiple Intelligences Method
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Multiple Intelligences (MI) Method, a learner-based philosophy developed by Howard Gardner that challenges traditional views of intelligence as a single, fixed capacity. The lecture explores how MI theory recognizes eight distinct intelligences, its implications for language teaching, and practical classroom applications that accommodate diverse learner differences.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background of the Multiple Intelligences Method including Gardner's eight native intelligences and their signs; the approach and theory of language and language learning behind MI, including the contrast with the traditional "g" factor model; objectives, syllabus design, and learning activities in MI; roles of learners, teachers, and materials; and a detailed procedure demonstrating a four-stage MI lesson on describing physical objects.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-066: Background of Multiple Intelligences Method
Multiple Intelligences (MI) refers to a learner-based philosophy that characterizes human intelligence as having multiple dimensions that must be acknowledged and developed in education. Traditional IQ or intelligence tests are based on a test called the Stanford-Binet, founded on the idea that intelligence is a single, unchanged, inborn capacity. However, traditional IQ tests are increasingly being challenged by the MI movement. MI is based on the work of Howard Gardner of the Harvard Graduate School of Education (Gardner 1993). Gardner notes that traditional IQ tests measure only logic and language, yet the brain has other equally important types of intelligence. Gardner argues that all humans have these intelligences, but people differ in the strengths and combinations of intelligences. He believes that all of them can be enhanced through training and practice. MI thus belongs to a group of instructional perspectives that focus on differences between learners and the need to recognize learner differences in teaching. Learners are viewed as possessing individual learning styles, preferences, or intelligences.
π Definition β Multiple Intelligences (MI): A theory proposing that human intelligence consists of multiple, separate dimensions rather than a single general ability, with each intelligence being trainable and present in all individuals in different combinations.
Pedagogy is most successful when these learner differences are acknowledged, analyzed for particular groups of learners, and accommodated in teaching. In both general education and language teaching, a focus on individual differences has been a recurring theme in the last 30 or so years, as seen in such movements or approaches as Individualized Instruction, Autonomous Learning, Learner Training, and Learner Strategies. The Multiple Intelligences model shares a number of commonalities with these earlier proposals.
Gardner (1993) proposed a view of natural human talents labeled the "Multiple Intelligences Model." This model is one of a variety of learning style models that have been proposed in general education and have subsequently been applied to language education. Gardner claims that his view of intelligence(s) is culture-free and avoids the conceptual narrowness usually associated with traditional models of intelligence (e.g., the Intelligent Quotient [IQ] testing model). Gardner posits eight native intelligences:
π Eight Native Intelligences:
- Linguistic: the ability to use language in special and creative ways, which is something lawyers, writers, editors, and interpreters are strong in.
- Logical/mathematical: the ability to think rationally, often found with doctors, engineers, programmers, and scientists.
- Spatial: the ability to form mental models of the world, something architects, decorators, sculptors, and painters are good at.
- Musical: a good ear for music, as is strong in singers and composers.
- Bodily/kinesthetic: having a well-coordinated body, something found in athletes and craftspersons.
- Interpersonal: the ability to be able to work well with people, which is strong in salespeople, politicians, and teachers.
- Intrapersonal: the ability to understand oneself and apply one's talent successfully, which leads to happy and well-adjusted people in all areas of life.
- Naturalist: the ability to understand and organize the patterns of nature.
The idea of Multiple Intelligences has attracted the interest of many educators as well as the general public. Schools that use MI theory encourage learning that goes beyond traditional books, pens, and pencils. Teachers and parents who recognize their learners'/children's particular gifts and talents can provide learning activities that build on those inherent gifts. As a result of strengthening such differences, individuals are free to be intelligent in their own ways.
Other "intelligences" have been proposed, such as Emotional Intelligence, Mechanical Intelligence, and Practical Intelligence, but Gardner defends his eight-dimensional model of intelligence by claiming that the particular intelligences he has nominated are verified by eight data-based "signs." Signs include such clues as an intelligence having a distinct developmental and a distinct evolutionary history; that is, within individuals there is a similar sequence of development of an intelligence beginning in early childhood and continuing into maturity. This sequence will be universal for individuals but unique to each intelligence. Similarly, each intelligence is deeply embedded in evolutionary history. Human tool using, for example, has such an evidential evolutionary history and is an example, Gardner says, of bodily/kinesthetic intelligence.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these signs helps educators validate that each intelligence is a genuine, distinct capacity with its own developmental trajectory rather than just a learning style preference.
Topic-067: Approach and Theory of Language and Language Learning behind Multiple Intelligences Method
MI theory was originally proposed by Gardner (1993) as a contribution to cognitive science. Fairly early on, it was interpreted by some general educators, such as Armstrong (1994), as a framework for rethinking school education. Some schools in the United States have indeed remade their educational programs around the MI model. Applications of MI in language teaching have been more recent, so it is not surprising that MI theory lacks some of the basic elements that might link it more directly to language education. One lack is a concrete view of how MI theory relates to any existing language and/or language learning theories, though attempts have been made to establish such links. It certainly is fair to say that MI proposals look at the language of an individual, including one or more second languages, not as an "added on" and somewhat peripheral skill but as central to the whole life of the language learner and user. In this sense, language is held to be integrated with music, bodily activity, interpersonal relationships, and so on. Language is not seen as limited to a "linguistics" perspective, but encompasses all aspects of communication.
Language learning and use are obviously closely linked to what MI theorists label "Linguistic Intelligence." However, MI proponents believe there is more to language than what is usually subsumed under the rubric linguistics. There are aspects of language such as rhythm, tone, volume, and pitch that are more closely linked, say, to a theory of music than to a theory of linguistics. Other intelligences enrich the tapestry of communication we call "language." In addition, language has its ties to life through the senses. The senses provide the accompaniment and context for the linguistic message that give it meaning and purpose. A multisensory view of language is necessary, it seems, to construct an adequate theory of language as well as an effective design for language learning.
A widely accepted view of intelligence is that intelligence β however measured and in whatever circumstance - comprises a single factor, usually called the "g factor." From this point of view, "Intelligence (g) can be described as the ability to deal with cognitive complexity." One popular explication of this view sees intelligence as a hierarchy with βgβ at the apex of the hierarchy: more specific aptitudes are arrayed at successively lower levels: the so-called group factors, such as verbal ability, mathematical reasoning, spatial visualization and memory, are just below g, and below these are skills that are more dependent on knowledge or experience, such as the principles and practices of a particular job or profession.
π Definition β g factor: The single general intelligence factor proposed by traditional intelligence theory, representing the ability to deal with cognitive complexity, with more specific aptitudes arrayed hierarchically beneath it.
The view of Gardner "contrasts markedly with the view that intelligence is based on a unitary or 'general' ability for problem solving." In Gardner's view, there exists a cluster of mental abilities that are separate but equal and that share the pinnacle at the top of the hierarchy called intelligence - thus, the eight Multiple Intelligences that Gardner has described. One way of looking at the learning theoretical argument is to apply the logic of the single factor (g) model to the multiple Intelligences model. The single factor model correlates higher intelligence (+g) with greater speed and efficiency of neural processing. If there is not one I but several I's, then one can assume that the speed and efficiency of neural processing will be greatest when a particular I is most fully exercised; that is, if a language learner has a high musical intelligence, that person will learn most quickly (e.g., a new language) when that content is embedded in a musical frame.
π Formula Concept: Higher intelligence (+g) β greater speed and efficiency of neural processing β when applied to MI: specific intelligence strength β fastest learning when content matches that intelligence's frame
Topic-068: Objectives, Syllabus and Learning Activities in Multiple Intelligences Method
Objectives
There are no goals stated for MI instruction in linguistic terms. MI pedagogy focuses on the language class as the setting for a series of educational support systems aimed at making the language learner a better designer of his/her own learning experiences. Such a learner is both better empowered and more fulfilled than a learner in traditional classrooms. A more goal-directed learner and happier person is held to be a likely candidate for being a better second language learner and user.
Syllabus
There is no syllabus as such, either prescribed or recommended, in respect to MI based language teaching. However, there is a basic developmental sequence that has been proposed (Lazear 1991) as an alternative to what we have elsewhere considered as a type of "syllabus" design. The sequence consists of four stages:
π Four-Stage Developmental Sequence:
- Stage 1: Awaken the Intelligence β Through multisensory experiences like touching, smelling, tasting, seeing, and so on - learners can be sensitized to the many-faceted properties of objects and events in the world that surrounds them.
- Stage 2: Amplify the Intelligence β Students strengthen and improve the intelligence by volunteering objects and events of their own choosing and defining with others the properties and contexts of experience of these objects and events.
- Stage 3: Teach with/for the Intelligence β At this stage the intelligence is linked to the focus of the class, that is, to some aspect of language learning. This is done via worksheets and small-group projects and discussion.
- Stage 4: Transfer of the Intelligence β Students reflect on the learning experiences of the previous three stages and relate these to issues and challenges in the out-of-class world.
MI has been applied in many different types of classrooms. In some, there are eight self-access activity corners, each corner built around one of the eight intelligences. Students work alone or in pairs on intelligence foci of their own choosing.
Learning Activities
Nicholson-Nelson (1998) describes how MI can be used to individualize learning through project work. She lists four types of learning activities:
- Multiple intelligence projects: These are based on one or more of the intelligences and are designed to stimulate particular intelligences.
- Curriculum-based projects: These are based on curriculum content and make use of as many intelligences as possible but are categorized according to the particular intelligences they highlight.
- Thematic-based projects: These are based on a theme from the curriculum or classroom but are divided into different intelligences.
- Resource-based projects: These are designed to provide students with opportunities to research a topic using multiple intelligences.
- Student-choice projects: These are designed by students and draw on particular intelligences.
In other more fully teacher-fronted classrooms, the students move through a cycle of activities highlighting use of different intelligences in the activities that the teacher has chosen and orchestrated.
The following list summarizes several of the alternative views as to how the MI model can be used to serve the needs of language learners within a classroom setting:
π Four Alternative Classroom Applications:
- Play to strength: If you want an athlete or a musician to be an involved and successful language learner, structure the learning material for each individual around these strengths.
- Variety is the spice: Providing a teacher-directed rich mix of learning activities variously calling upon the eight different intelligences makes for an interesting, lively, and effective classroom for all students.
- All sizes fit one: Every individual exercises all intelligences even though some may be out of awareness or undervalued. Pedagogy that appeals to all intelligences speaks to the "whole person" in ways that more uninfected approaches do not.
- Me and my people: IQ testing is held to be badly biased in favor of Western views of intelligence. Other cultures may value other intelligences more than the one measured in IQ testing. Since language learning involves culture learning as well, it is useful for the language learner to study language in a context that recognizes and honors a range of diversely valued intelligences.
Each of these views has strengths and weaknesses, some of a theoretical, some of a pedagogical, and some of a practical nature. Potential MI teachers need to consider each of these possible applications of MI theory in light of their individual teaching situations.
Topic-069: Roles of Learners, Teachers, and Materials in Multiple Intelligences Method
Campbell notes that the MI theory "is not prescriptive. Rather, it gives teachers a complex mental model from which to construct curriculum and improve themselves as educators." In this view, teachers are expected to understand, master, and be committed to the MI model. Teachers are encouraged to administer an MI inventory on themselves and thereby be able to "connect one's life's experiences to their concept of Multiple Intelligences." (The MI inventory is a short checklist that enables users to create their own MI profiles and use these as a guide to designing and reflecting upon their learning experiences.) Teachers then become curriculum developers, lesson designers and analysts, activity finders or inventors, and most critically orchestrators of a rich array of multisensory activities within the realistic constraints of time, space, and resources of the classroom. Teachers are encouraged not to think of themselves merely as language teachers. They have a role that is not only to improve the second language abilities of their students but to become major "contributors to the overall development of students' intelligences."
Like teachers, learners need to see themselves engaged in a process of personality development above and beyond that of being successful language learners. The MI classroom is one designed to support development of the "whole person," and the environment and its activities are intended to enable students to become more well-rounded individuals and more successful learners in general. Learners are encouraged to see their goals in these broader terms. Learners are typically expected to take an MI inventory and develop their own MI profiles based on the inventory. "The more awareness students have of their own intelligences and how they work, the more they will know how to use that intelligence to access the necessary information and knowledge from a lesson." All of this is to enable learners to benefit from instructional approaches by reflecting on their own learning.
MI is richest in proposals for lesson organization, multisensory activity planning, and in using realia. There are also a number of reports of actual teaching experiences from an MI perspective that are both teacher-friendly and candid in their reportage.
Topic-070: Procedure in Multiple Intelligences Method
Christison describes a low-level language lesson dealing with description of physical objects. The lesson plan recapitulates the four-stage sequence described earlier:
π Four-Stage Lesson Procedure β Describing Physical Objects:
Stage 1: Awaken the Intelligence. The teacher brings many different objects to class. Students experience feeling things that are soft, rough, cold, smooth, and so on. They might taste things that are sweet, salty, sour, spicy, and so on. Experiences like this help activate and make learners aware of the sensory bases of experience.
Stage 2: Amplify the Intelligence. Students are asked to bring objects to class or to use something in their possession. Teams of students describe each object attending to the five physical senses. They complete a worksheet including the information they have observed and discussed.
Stage 3: Teach with/for the Intelligence. At this stage, the teacher structures larger sections of lesson(s) so as to re-enforce and emphasize sensory experiences and the language that accompanies these experiences. Students work in groups, perhaps completing a worksheet.
Stage 4: Transfer of the Intelligence. This stage is concerned with application of the intelligence to daily living. Students are asked to reflect on both the content of the lesson and its operational procedures (working in groups, completing tables, etc.).
π Sensory Handout Worksheet Example: The worksheet includes columns for team name, team members, and for each object: sight, sound, feel, smell, size, and what it's used for.
π "What am I describing?" Activity: Directions: Work with your group. Listen as the teacher reads the description of the object. Discuss what you hear with your group. Together, decide which object in the class is being described. Each group describes an object in the classroom using the formula given in Stage 2. Then, collect the papers and read them one at a time. Ask each group to work together to write down the name of the object being described.
This particular lesson on describing objects is seen as giving students opportunities to "develop their linguistic intelligence (for example, describing objects), logical intelligence (for example, determining which object is being described), visual/spatial intelligence (for example, determining how to describe things), interpersonal intelligence (for example, working in groups), and intrapersonal intelligence (for example, reflecting on one's own involvement in the lesson)."
Conclusion
Multiple Intelligences is an increasingly popular approach to characterizing the ways in which learners are unique and to developing instruction to respond to this uniqueness. MI is one of a set of such perspectives dealing with learner differences and borrows heavily from these in its recommendations and designs for lesson planning. The literature on MI provides a rich source of classroom ideas regardless of one's theoretical perspective, and can help teachers think about instruction in their classes in unique ways. Some teachers may see the assumptions of identifying and responding to the variety of ways in which students differ to be unrealistic in their own settings and antithetical to the expectations of their students and administrators. There are entire schools as well as language programs being restructured around the MI perspective. Evaluation of how successful these innovations are will be needed to more fully evaluate the claims of MI in education and in second language teaching.
β Key Takeaways
The Multiple Intelligences Method is fundamentally a learner-based philosophy that rejects the traditional view of intelligence as a single, fixed "g factor" and instead recognizes eight separate intelligences (linguistic, logical/mathematical, spatial, musical, bodily/kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrapersonal, and naturalist) that can all be enhanced through training. In language teaching, MI lacks prescribed objectives or syllabi but offers a four-stage developmental sequence (Awaken, Amplify, Teach with/for, Transfer) for lesson design. Teachers become orchestrators of multisensory activities and developers of the whole person, while learners use MI inventories to understand their own intelligence profiles and become better designers of their own learning. A key classroom application is the four-stage lesson on describing physical objects, which simultaneously develops multiple intelligences including linguistic, logical, visual/spatial, interpersonal, and intrapersonal skills.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the eight native intelligences proposed by Howard Gardner in the Multiple Intelligences Model?
-
How does the "g factor" model of intelligence differ from Gardner's Multiple Intelligences model in terms of the structure and hierarchy of intelligence?
-
What are the four stages of the developmental sequence proposed by Lazear (1991) as an alternative to a traditional syllabus in MI-based language teaching?
-
In the four-stage lesson procedure for describing physical objects, what specific intelligences are developed through the activity where students listen to object descriptions and identify which object is being described?
-
According to the lecture, what is the purpose of having both teachers and learners complete an MI inventory, and how does this support the overall goals of the MI classroom?
π Lecture 15 β Neurolinguistic Programming
π Overview: This lecture introduces Neurolinguistic Programming (NLP), a training philosophy and set of techniques developed in the mid-1970s for effective communication, personal growth, and learning. It explores NLP's background, underlying assumptions, key principles, and practical applications in language teaching, while critically evaluating its status as a teaching method.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main topics: the background, approach and theory behind Neurolinguistic Programming, including the meaning of its three components (neuro, linguistic, programming); the objectives and thirteen presuppositions that guide NLP application; the roles of teacher and learner in NLP, emphasizing rapport and modeling; a detailed lesson procedure demonstrating how NLP principles can teach grammatical structures like the present perfect; and critical comments evaluating NLP's status as a humanistic philosophy rather than a language teaching method.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-071: Background, Approach and Theory behind Neurolinguistic Programming
Neurolinguistic Programming (NLP) refers to a training philosophy and a set of training techniques first developed by John Grindler and Richard Bandler in the mid-1970s as an alternative form of therapy. Grindler (a psychologist) and Bandler (a student of linguistics) were interested in how people influence each other and how the behaviors of very effective people could be duplicated. They studied successful therapists and concluded that they "followed similar patterns in relating to their clients and in the language they used, and that they all held similar beliefs about themselves and what they were doing."
NLP is a collection of techniques, patterns, and strategies for assisting effective communication, personal growth and change, and learning. It is based on a series of underlying assumptions about how the mind works and how people act and interact. The NLP model provides a theoretical framework and a set of working principles for directing or guiding therapeutic change, but the principles of NLP have been applied in a variety of other fields, including management training, sports training, communications sales and marketing, and language teaching.
The name "Neurolinguistic Programming" might lead one to expect it is based on the science of neurolinguistics and draws on behaviorist theories of learning. However, in NLP, neuro refers to beliefs about the brain and how it functionsβthe literature on NLP does not refer to theory or research in neurolinguistics. Linguistic has nothing to do with the field of linguistics but refers to a theory of communication that tries to explain both verbal and nonverbal information processing. Programming refers to observable patterns (referred to as "programs") of thought and behavior.
Modeling is also central to NLP views on learning. Modeling a skill means finding out about it, and the beliefs and values that enable them to do it. You can also model emotions, experiences, beliefs and values. Modeling successful performance leads to excellence. If one person can do something, it is possible to model and teach others how to do it.
π Definition β Neurolinguistic Programming (NLP): A training philosophy and set of techniques developed by Grindler and Bandler in the mid-1970s for effective communication, personal growth, and learning, based on assumptions about how the mind works and how people interact.
π Definition β Modeling: Finding out about a skill and the beliefs and values that enable someone to perform it successfully, allowing others to learn the same skill.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the origin and components of NLP helps clarify that despite its name, NLP is not grounded in neurolinguistics or linguistics research but is rather a practical philosophy based on observing successful communicators.
Topic-072: Objectives and Presuppositions that Guide the Application of Neurolinguistic Programming
Four key principles lie at the heart of NLP:
- Outcomes: the goals or ends. NLP claims that knowing precisely what you want helps you achieve it. This principle can be expressed as "know what you want."
- Rapport: a factor essential for effective communication maximizing similarities and minimizing differences between people at a non-conscious level. This principle can be expressed as "Establish rapport with yourself and then with others."
- Sensory acuity: noticing what another person is communicating, consciously and nonverbally. This can be expressed as "Use your senses. Look at, listen to, and feel what is actually happening."
- Flexibility: doing things differently if what you are doing is not working; having a range of skills to do something else or something different. This can be expressed as "Keep changing what you do until you get what you want."
Thirteen presuppositions guide the application of NLP in language learning and other fields. These principles become part of the belief system of the teacher and shape the way teaching is conducted. Five of these presuppositions are:
- Mind and body are interconnected: They are parts of the same system, and each affects the other.
- The map is not the territory: We all have different maps of the world.
- There is no failure, only feedback and a renewed opportunity for success.
- The map becomes the territory: What you believe to be true either is true or becomes true.
- Knowing what you want helps you get it.
π Definition β Rapport: Meeting others in their world, trying to understand their needs, their values and their culture and communicating in ways that are congruent with those values, without necessarily agreeing with those values.
π Example β Applying rapport in teacher responses to student statements:
- Student: "I hate this stuff. It's such a waste of time." Teacher: "Is a part of you saying that you want to be sure your time is well spent today?"
- Student: "I can't do it." Teacher: "What, specifically, can't you do?"
- Student: "This is all theory." Teacher: "Are you saying you want practical suggestions?"
π Example β Finding positive intention in classroom situations:
- A learner disagrees strongly with the teacher β positive intent: wanting to have expertise acknowledged
- A student frequently comes late to class β positive intent: having other important priorities
- A student seeks to dominate discussions β positive intent: needing to vocalize thoughts in order to internalize them
Topic-073: Role of Teacher and Learner in Neurolinguistic Programming
In NLP, modeling is central to practice. Just as Bandler and Grinder modeled NLP on the practices of successful therapists, teachers are expected to model their teaching on expert teachers they most admire. Teachers should look at what excellent teachers do, how they act, what sort of relationship they have with their students and colleagues. Teachers should also position themselves by imagining what it is like to be those excellent teachers and put techniques and strategies into practice.
Learners are expected to find successful models for that person they themselves are striving to become. Teachers should share modeling strategies with students, set the project of modeling good learners, and encourage them to share and try out strategies they learn.
What makes NLP language teachers different from other language teachers? According to NLP, they seek to apply the principles in their teaching, and this leads to different responses to many classroom events and processes. For example, the principle of rapport means meeting others in their world, trying to understand their needs, their values and their culture, and communicating in ways congruent with those values. The teacher does not necessarily have to agree with the students' values but simply recognizes that they have a right to them and works within their framework.
The principle "All behavior has a positive intention" would lead the teacher to seek for a positive intent in situations such as a learner disagreeing strongly with the teacher, a student frequently coming late to class, or a student seeking to dominate discussions.
π Definition β Sensory acuity: Noticing what another person is communicating, both consciously and nonverbally.
π‘ Why this matters: The NLP teacher's role is distinctly different from traditional teachingβteachers are expected to model excellence, seek positive intentions behind all behavior, and build rapport by entering students' worlds rather than imposing their own.
Topic-074: Procedure of Neurolinguistic Programming
NLP principles can be applied to the teaching of all aspects of language. The following suggested lesson sequence is "to help students become aware at a feeling level of the conceptual meaning of a grammatical structure." This sequence focuses on awareness and production of instances of the present perfect in English. The lesson begins with a guided fantasy of eating a food item and then reflecting on the experience.
Lesson procedure:
- Students are told they are going on an "inner grammatical experience as you eat a biscuit."
- Check that they understand vocabulary of the experience (smell, taste, chew, swallow, bite, lick, etc.).
- Students are asked to relax, close their eyes, and "go inside."
- Teacher produces a fantasy text: "Imagine a biscuit. A delicious biscuit. The sort you really like. Pick it up and look at it closely. Notice how crisp and fresh it is. Smell it. Notice how your mouth is beginning to water. In a moment you are going to eat the biscuit. Say the words to yourself: 'I am going to eat this biscuit.' Slowly chew the biscuit and notice how delicious it tastes on your tongue and in your mouth. Say the words to yourself, 'I'm really enjoying eating this biscuit.' Take another bite. Chew it. Taste it. Enjoy it. And then swallow. Lick your lips, move your tongue all around the inside of your mouth to catch any last bits of biscuit, and swallow them. Notice how you feel now. Notice the taste in your mouth. Notice how your stomach feels with a biscuit inside it. Notice how you feel emotionally. You have eaten a biscuit. Say the words to yourself, 'I've eaten a biscuit.'"
- Ask students to describe how they are feeling nowβ"the feeling of the present perfect." Listen for statements linking the past experience of eating the biscuit with their present feelings (e.g., "I feel full," "I'm not hungry anymore").
- Ask them to say again the sentence that describes the cause of the way they feel ("I've eaten a biscuit").
- Put a large piece of paper on the wall with "I've eaten a biscuit" at the top. Have students write how they feel underneath.
- On other papers, write sentences such as: I've painted a picture. I've had a row with my boy/girlfriend. I've finished my homework. I've cleaned my teeth.
- Ask students to stand in front of each sentence, close their eyes, and strongly imagine what they have done to be saying that sentence now.
- Students write on the paper how they feel now about these sentences.
- Leave the papers on the wall as a reminder of the feeling link to the grammatical structure.
- As follow-up, contrast the feeling of the present perfect with the feeling of the simple past. Ask students to remember things they did in the last lesson ("I ate a biscuit").
- Ask them to say "Yesterday, I ate a biscuit."
- Discuss the comparison between the feelings (e.g., "I remember the taste, but I can't actually taste it").
- Similar exercises can be done to exemplify other tenses using different tastes and sensory experiences.
π Example: The guided fantasy lesson for teaching present perfect uses sensory experience (taste, smell, touch) to create an emotional connection with the grammatical structure. Students physically experience the difference between "I've eaten a biscuit" (present perfectβpast action with present relevance/feeling) and "I ate a biscuit" (simple pastβcompleted past action with no present feeling).
Topic-075: Critical Comments on Neurolinguistic Programming
NLP is not a language teaching method. It does not consist of a set of techniques for teaching a language based on theories and assumptions at the level of an approach and a design. Rather, it is a humanistic philosophy and a set of beliefs and suggestions based on popular psychology, designed to convince people that they have the power to control their own and other people's lives for the better and practical prescriptions on how to do so.
NLP practitioners believe that if language teachers adopt and use the principles of NLP, they will become more effective teachers. Workshops on NLP are typically short on theory and research to justify its claims and strong on creating positive expectations, bonding, and enthusiasm. As Revell and Norman comment, the assumptions on which NLP are based "need not be accepted as the absolute truth, but acting as if they were true can make a world of difference in your life and in your teaching."
In language teaching, the appeal of NLP to some teachers stems from the fact that it offers a set of humanistic principles that provide either a new justification for well-known techniques from the communicative or humanistic repertoire or a different interpretation of the role of the teacher and the learner, one in harmony with many learner-centered, person-centered views.
π Definition β NLP (as applied to language teaching): A humanistic philosophy and set of beliefs based on popular psychology that offers principles for effective communication and teaching, rather than a specific language teaching method with a coherent theory of language and learning.
π‘ Why this matters: The critical evaluation of NLP reveals that while it offers appealing humanistic principles for teaching, it lacks empirical research support and is not a systematic language teaching methodβit is better understood as a set of beliefs that can inform teaching practice.
β Key Takeaways
Neurolinguistic Programming is a training philosophy developed by Grindler and Bandler in the 1970s based on observing successful therapists, and it has been applied to language teaching as a humanistic approach. The four key principles of NLPβoutcomes, rapport, sensory acuity, and flexibilityβalong with presuppositions like "there is no failure, only feedback" and "the map is not the territory" guide its application in teaching. Teachers in NLP are expected to build rapport, model excellence from successful teachers, seek positive intentions behind all student behavior, and use techniques like guided fantasy to create sensory-emotional connections with language structures. However, NLP is critically viewed as not a true language teaching method but rather a humanistic philosophy based on popular psychology with little empirical research support. Students must remember that NLP focuses on changing teacher and learner mindsets through presuppositions rather than providing specific language teaching techniques.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What do the three components of the name "Neurolinguistic Programming" actually refer to, and how do these differ from what the names might suggest?
- What are the four key principles that lie at the heart of NLP, and how can each be expressed in simple terms?
- According to NLP, how should a teacher respond to a student who says "I hate this stuff. It's such a waste of time" in order to establish rapport?
- Describe the step-by-step procedure for using a guided fantasy to teach the present perfect tense, including how the teacher contrasts it with the simple past.
- What are the main critical comments about NLP as it applies to language teaching, and why is it considered not a true language teaching method?