π Lecture 10 β The Silent Way Method
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Silent Way, a language teaching method devised by Caleb Gattegno based on the premise that the teacher should be silent as much as possible while learners produce language. It explores the theoretical background, learning hypotheses, and practical applications of this unique approach, emphasizing discovery learning, physical objects, and problem-solving.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background of the Silent Way method, including its learning hypotheses derived from discovery learning theories, the role of physical objects like rods and charts, and problem-solving approaches. It then examines the approach and theory of language and learning behind the method, including Gattegno's skeptical view of linguistic theory and his emphasis on the "spirit" of language. Finally, it details the objectives, syllabus, learning activities, roles of learners, teachers, and materials, followed by a step-by-step procedure with a sample Thai lesson.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-046: Background of the Silent Way Method
The Silent Way is a language teaching method devised by Caleb Gattegno based on the premise that the teacher should be silent as much as possible while the learner should produce as much language as possible. Elements such as color charts and colored Cuisenaire rods grew out of Gattegno's previous experience as an educational designer of reading and mathematics programs.
The learning hypotheses underlying Gattegno's work are:
- Learning is facilitated if the learner discovers or creates rather than remembers and repeats.
- Learning is facilitated by accompanying (mediating) physical objects.
- Learning is facilitated by problem solving involving the material to be learned.
- The Silent Way belongs to a tradition viewing learning as a problem-solving, creative, discovering activity (Bruner 1966). Bruner discusses benefits of "discovery learning": increase in intellectual potency, shift from extrinsic to intrinsic rewards, learning heuristics by discovering, and aid to conserving memory. Gattegno claims similar benefits.
- Rods and color-coded pronunciation charts (Fidel charts) provide physical foci for student learning and create memorable images to facilitate recall, serving as associative mediators.
- The method relates to "problem-solving approaches to learning," captured by Benjamin Franklin's words: βTell me and I forget, teach me and I remember, involve me and I learn.β
π‘ Why this matters: This background establishes that the Silent Way fundamentally shifts responsibility from teacher to learner, using physical tools to create memorable learning experiences.
Topic-047: Approach & Theory of Language and Learning behind The Silent Way Method
Gattegno takes a skeptical view of linguistic theory in language teaching methodology, feeling linguistic studies may carry "a narrow opening of one's sensitivity." Considerable discussion is devoted to grasping the "spirit" of the language β the way each language is composed of phonological and suprasegmental elements giving it unique sound, system, and melody. The learner must gain a "feel" for this aspect.
The Silent Way takes a structural approach to language organization. The sentence is the basic unit of teaching, focusing on propositional meaning rather than communicative value. Students learn grammar rules through largely inductive processes.
Gattegno sees vocabulary as central, with the most important being "functional vocabulary" β the most functional and versatile words, many without direct equivalents in the learner's native language. This provides a key to comprehending the "spirit" of the language.
Regarding learning theory, Gattegno recommends the learner "return to the state of mind that characterizes a baby's learning - surrender." However, he states second language learning processes are "radically different" from first language learning because of what the learner now knows. "Natural" or "direct" approaches are misguided; a successful approach will "replace a 'natural' approach by one that is very 'artificial' and... strictly controlled."
Gattegno's "artificial approach" is based on commitment of the self through silent awareness and active trial. The self consists of two systems β a learning system and a retaining system. The learning system is activated only by intelligent awareness. Silence is considered the best vehicle for learning because students concentrate on the task. Repetition "consumes time and encourages the scattered mind to remain scattered."
Awareness is educable β as one learns "in awareness," one's powers become greater, facilitating "learning to learn." The process chain develops from attention, production, self-correction, and absorption. Silent Way learners acquire "inner criteria" allowing them to monitor and self-correct their own production. This capacity for self-awareness is where the Silent Way claims to differ most notably from other methods.
π Definition β Inner criteria: The self-monitoring system that allows learners to self-correct their own production, claimed to be the most distinctive feature of the Silent Way.
Topic-048: Objectives, Syllabus, and Learning Activities in The Silent Way Method
Objectives
The general objective is to give beginning-level students oral and aural facility in basic elements of the target language, with a goal of near-native fluency and emphasis on correct pronunciation and mastery of prosodic elements. An immediate objective is basic practical knowledge of grammar.
Elementary level objectives (Gattegno 1972): Students should correctly answer questions about themselves, education, family, travel, daily events; speak with a good accent; give written or oral description of a picture "including existing relationships that concern space, time and numbers"; answer questions about culture and literature; perform adequately in spelling, grammar (production rather than explanation), reading comprehension, and writing.
Syllabus
The Silent Way adopts a basic structural syllabus, with lessons planned around grammatical items and related vocabulary. Language items are introduced according to:
- Grammatical complexity
- Relationship to what has been taught previously
- Ease with which items can be presented visually
Sample Peace Corps Silent Way Syllabus for Thai (first 10 hours):
| Lesson | Content |
|---|---|
| 1 | Wood color red |
| 2 | Numbers 1-10 |
| 3 | Wood color red two pieces |
| 4 | Take (pick up) wood color red two pieces |
| 5 | Take wood color red two pieces give him |
| 6 | Wood red where? Wood red on table |
| 7 | Wood color red on table, is it? Yes, on / Not on |
| 8 | Wood color red long / green longer / orange longest |
| 9 | Wood color green taller / Wood color red, is it? |
Vocabulary includes colors, numbers, verbs (take, give), pronouns, prepositions (where, on, under, near, far, over, next to, here, there), and question-forming rules.
Learning Tasks and Activities
Learning tasks encourage and shape oral response without direct oral instruction or unnecessary modeling. Basic tasks involve the teacher modeling a word, phrase, or sentence, then eliciting learner responses. Learners create their own utterances by combining old and new information. Charts, rods, and other aids elicit responses. Teacher modeling is minimal, though activity may be teacher-directed. Responses to commands, questions, and visual cues constitute the basis for activities.
Topic-049: Role of Learners, Teachers and Materials in the Silent Way Method
Role of the Learner
Learners develop independence, autonomy, and responsibility. Independent learners are aware they must depend on their own resources and can use knowledge of their own language or first few words in the new language to figure out additional words. The absence of correction and repeated modeling requires students to develop "inner criteria" and correct themselves. The absence of explanations requires learners to make generalizations, come to their own conclusions, and formulate their own rules. Learners rely on themselves and the group, learning to work cooperatively rather than competitively, comfortable both correcting one another and being corrected.
Role of the Teacher
Teacher's silence is the unique and most demanding aspect. Teachers must resist modeling, remodeling, assisting, and directing desired responses. Stevick defines the Silent Way teacher's tasks:
- To teach β presentation of an item once, typically using nonverbal clues to convey meanings
- To test β elicitation and shaping of student production, done as silently as possible
- To get out of the way β silently monitor learners' interactions, may even leave the room
The teacher uses gestures and charts to elicit and shape responses, requiring facility and creativity as a pantomimist and puppeteer. The Silent Way teacher is like a complete dramatist who writes the script, chooses props, sets mood, models action, designates players, and is a critic.
Materials
Silent Way materials consist of:
- A set of colored rods (Cuisenaire rods)
- Color-coded pronunciation and vocabulary wall charts (Fidel charts)
- A pointer
- Reading/writing exercises
Materials are designed for manipulation by students and teacher, independently and cooperatively, promoting language learning by direct association.
Fidel charts contain symbols for all vowel and consonant sounds, color-coded according to pronunciation β different symbols for the same sound are colored alike.
Colored Cuisenaire rods vary in length from 1 to 10 centimeters, each length having a specific color. They are used for: naming colors, size comparisons, representing people, building floor plans, constituting road maps, etc. Use promotes inventiveness, creativity, and interest in forming communicative utterances as students move from simple to more complex structures.
Topic-050: Procedure in the Silent Way Method
A Silent Way lesson follows a standard format:
First part: Focuses on pronunciation. The class works on sounds, phrases, or sentences designated on the Fidel chart. At the beginning, the teacher models the appropriate sound after pointing to a symbol. Later, the teacher silently points to symbols and monitors student utterances. The teacher may say a word and have students guess the sequence of symbols.
The pointer indicates stress (touching certain symbols more forcibly), phrasing, and intonation (tapping to the rhythm of the utterance).
After sounds, sentence patterns, structure, and vocabulary are practiced, the teacher models an utterance while creating a visual realization with colored rods. After modeling, a student attempts to produce the utterance, and the teacher indicates acceptability. If incorrect, the teacher reshapes the utterance or has another student present the correct model. After a structure is introduced, the teacher creates a situation for practice through rod manipulation. Variations are elicited using rods and charts.
Sample Lesson (Thai β first lesson):
- Teacher empties rods onto table.
- Teacher picks up rods of different colors, saying after each: [mai].
- Teacher holds up one rod, indicates student response required. Student says: [mai]. If incorrect, teacher elicits response from another student who models for the first.
- Teacher picks up a red rod: [mai sii daeng].
- Teacher picks up a green rod: [mai sii khiaw].
- Teacher picks up red or green rod, elicits response. If incorrect, student modeling follows.
- Teacher introduces two or three other colors similarly.
- Teacher shows previously taught rods, elicits response.
- Correction technique: student modeling, or teacher helps isolate error for self-correction.
- When mastery achieved, teacher puts one red rod in view: [mai sii daeng nung an].
- Teacher puts two red rods: [mai sii daeng song an].
- Teacher places two green rods: [mai sii khiaw song an].
- Teacher holds up two rods of different color, elicits response.
- Teacher introduces additional numbers and colors based on class retention.
- Rods are piled; teacher indicates rods should be picked up with correct utterance. All students participate. Peer-group correction is encouraged.
- Teacher says: [kep mai sii daeng song an] (pick up two red rods).
- Teacher indicates student should give the teacher the rods called for.
- Teacher asks other students to give rods requested, all in target language through unambiguous actions.
- Teacher indicates students should give each other commands regarding rods.
- Experimentation is encouraged. Teacher speaks only to correct incorrect utterances if no peer-group correction occurs.
β Key Takeaways
The Silent Way is fundamentally different from other methods because it reverses the traditional teacher-learner dynamic β the teacher remains silent while learners actively produce language through discovery and problem-solving. The method relies heavily on physical materials (colored rods and Fidel charts) as associative mediators to create memorable learning experiences without translation or repetition. Learners must develop independence, autonomy, and inner criteria for self-correction, working cooperatively rather than competitively. The structural syllabus organizes language items by grammatical complexity and visual presentation ease, with near-native fluency and correct pronunciation as ultimate goals. The most distinctive feature is that learners acquire self-awareness and the ability to self-correct, a capacity the Silent Way claims is little exercised in other methods.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three learning hypotheses underlying Gattegno's Silent Way method?
- How does Gattegno define the "spirit" of a language, and why is it important?
- What is the role of "inner criteria" in the Silent Way, and how is it different from other methods?
- Describe the three tasks of the Silent Way teacher according to Stevick.
- What is the purpose of the Fidel charts and Cuisenaire rods, and how are they used in a typical lesson?
π Lecture 11 β Community Language Learning
π Overview: This lecture examines the Community Language Learning (CLL) method, developed by Charles A. Curran, which applies psychological counseling techniques to language teaching. It explores how the teacher acts as a "counselor" and learners as "clients," emphasizing the humanistic, whole-person approach to language acquisition through community interaction and affective engagement.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers five main topics: the background of Community Language Learning including its origins in Rogerian counseling and humanistic techniques; the approach and theory of language and learning in CLL, including "Language as Social Process" and the SARD acronym; objectives, syllabus, and learning activities in CLL; roles of learners, teachers, and materials in CLL; and the procedure in Community Language Learning, including a detailed protocol of a first-day CLL class.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-051: Background of Community Language Learning Method
Community Language Learning (CLL) is the name of a method developed by Charles A. Curran and his associates. Curran was a specialist in counseling and a professor of psychology at Loyola University, Chicago. His application of psychological counseling techniques to learning is known as counseling-Learning. CLL derives its primary insights from Rogerian counseling (Rogers 1951). In lay terms, counseling is one person giving advice, assistance, and support to another who has a problem or is in some way in need. CLL draws on the counseling metaphor to redefine the roles of the teacher (the counselor) and learners (the clients) in the language classroom. The basic procedures of CLL can thus be seen as derived from the counselor-client relationship.
CLL techniques also belong to a larger set of foreign language teaching practices described as humanistic techniques (Moskowitz 1978). Moskowitz defines humanistic techniques as those that blend what the student feels, thinks and knows with what he is learning in the target language. Rather than self-denial being the acceptable way of life, self-actualization and self-esteem are the ideals pursued. The techniques help build rapport, cohesiveness, and caring, help students to be themselves, to accept themselves, and be proud of themselves, and foster a climate of caring and sharing in the foreign language class. In sum, humanistic techniques engage the whole person, including the emotions and feelings (the affective realm) as well as the linguistic knowledge and behavioral skills.
Another language teaching tradition linked to CLL is language alternation (Mackey 1972). In language alternation, a message/lesson/class is presented first in the native language and then again in the second language. Students know the meaning and flow of an L2 message from their recall of the parallel meaning and flow of an L1 message. In CLL, a learner presents a message in L1 to the knower. The message is translated into L2 by the knower. The learner then repeats the message in L2, addressing it to another learner. CLL learners are encouraged to attend to the "overhears" they experience between other learners and their knowers. The result of the "overhear" is that every member of the group can understand what any given learner is trying to communicate (La Forge 1983, p. 4S).
Topic-052: Approach and Theory of Language and Learning in Community Language Learning Method
Curran himself wrote little about his theory of language. His student, La Forge (1983), has attempted to be more explicit about this dimension of CLL theory. La Forge accepts that language theory must start, though not end, with criteria for sound features, the sentence, and abstract models of language. The foreign language learners' tasks are "to apprehend the sound system, assign fundamental meanings, and construct a basic grammar of the foreign language." La Forge goes beyond this structuralist view of language and elaborates an alternative theory of language referred to as 'Language as Social Process': communication is more than just a message being transmitted from a speaker to a listener. The speaker is at the same time both subject and object of his own message. Communication is an exchange which is incomplete without a feedback reaction from the destinee of the message.
π Definition β Language as Social Process: Communication is more than message transmission; it is an exchange where the speaker is both subject and object, incomplete without feedback from the receiver.
This social-process view of language is elaborated in terms of six qualities or sub-processes. La Forge also elaborates on the interactional view of language underlying CLL: "Language is people; language is persons in contact; language is persons in response" (1983, p. 9). CLL interactions are of two distinct and fundamental kinds: interactions between learners and interactions between learners and knowers. Interactions between learners are unpredictable in content but typically involve exchanges of affect. Learner exchanges deepen in intimacy as the class becomes a community of learners. The desire to be part of this growing intimacy pushes learners to keep pace with the learning of their peers. Interaction between learners and knowers is initially dependent. In later stages, interactions are characterized as self-assertive (stage 2), resentful and indignant (stage 3), tolerant (stage 4), and independent (stage 5). These changes are paralleled by the five stages of language learning and five stages of affective conflicts.
The CLL view of learning is a holistic one, since "true" human learning is both cognitive and affective. This is termed whole-person learning. Such learning takes place in a communicative situation where teachers and learners are involved in "an interaction in which both experience a sense of their own wholeness" (Curran 1972, p. 90). The process is divided into five stages and compared to the ontogenetic development of the child:
- First, "birth" stage: feelings of security and belonging are established.
- Second stage: as the learner's abilities improve, the learner begins to achieve a measure of independence from the parent.
- Third stage: the learner "speaks independently" and may need to assert his or her own identity, often rejecting unasked for advice.
- Fourth stage: the learner is secure enough to take criticism.
- Fifth stage: the learner merely works on improving style and knowledge of linguistic appropriateness. By the end, the child has become adult. The learner knows everything the teacher does and can become knower for a new learner.
The process of learning a new language is like being reborn and developing a new persona, with all the trials and challenges associated with birth and maturation.
π Definition β Consensual validation (convalidation): Mutual warmth, understanding, and a positive evaluation of the other person's worth that develops between the teacher and the learner. A relationship characterized by convalidation is considered essential to the learning process.
A group of ideas concerning the psychological requirements for successful learning are collected under the acronym SARD (Curran 1976, p. 6):
- 'S' stands for security: Unless learners feel secure, they will find it difficult to enter into a successful learning experience.
- 'A' stands for attention and aggression: Loss of attention indicates the learner's lack of involvement; variety in learner tasks increases attention. Aggression applies to the way a child, having learned something, seeks an opportunity to show strength by demonstrating what has been learned.
- 'R' stands for retention and reflection: If the whole person is involved, what is retained is internalized and becomes part of the learner's new persona. Reflection is a consciously identified period of silence for the student "to focus on the learning forces of the last hour, to assess his present stage of development, and to re-evaluate future goals" (La Forge 1983, p. 68).
- 'D' denotes discrimination: When learners "have retained a body of material, they are ready to sort it out and see how one thing relates to another" (La Forge 1983: 69). This process becomes more refined and ultimately "enables the students to use the language for purposes of communication outside the classroom."
π‘ Why this matters: These central aspects of Curran's learning philosophy address not the psycholinguistic and cognitive processes involved in second language acquisition, but rather the personal commitments that learners need to make before language acquisition processes can operate.
Topic-053: Objectives, Syllabus, and Learning Activities in Community Language Learning Method
Objectives: Since linguistic or communicative competence is specified only in social terms, explicit linguistic or communicative objectives are not defined in CLL. Most of what has been written about it describes its use in introductory conversation courses in a foreign language.
Syllabus: CLL does not use a conventional language syllabus, which sets out in advance the grammar, vocabulary, and other language items to be taught and the order in which they will be covered. The progression is topic-based, with learners nominating things they wish to talk about and messages they wish to communicate. The teacher's responsibility is to provide a conveyance for these meanings in a way appropriate to the learners' proficiency level. A CLL syllabus emerges from the interaction between the learner's expressed communicative intentions and the teacher's reformulations of these into suitable target-language utterances. Specific grammatical points, lexical patterns, and generalizations will sometimes be isolated by the teacher for more detailed study and analysis.
Learning Activities: CLL combines innovative learning tasks and activities with conventional ones. They include:
- Translation: Learners form a small circle. A learner whispers a message or meaning, the teacher translates it into the target language, and the learner repeats the teacher's translation.
- Group-work: Learners engage in various group tasks such as small-group discussion, preparing a conversation, preparing a summary of a topic, or preparing a story.
- Recording: Students record conversations in the target language.
- Transcription: Students transcribe utterances and conversations they have recorded for practice and analysis of linguistic forms.
- Analysis: Students analyze and study transcriptions of target-language sentences to focus on particular lexical usage or grammar rules.
- Reflection and observation: Learners reflect and report on their experience of the class, usually consisting of expressions of feelings.
- Listening: Students listen to a monologue by the teacher involving elements they might have elicited or overheard.
- Free conversation: Students engage in free conversation with the teacher or other learners, including discussion of what they learned and feelings about how they learned.
Topic-054: Roles of Learners, Teachers, and Materials in Community Language Learning Method
Role of the Learner: Learner roles in CLL are well defined. Learners become members of a community β their fellow learners and the teacher β and learn through interacting with the community. Learning is not viewed as an individual accomplishment but as something achieved collaboratively. Learners are expected to listen attentively to the knower, to freely provide meanings they wish to express, to repeat target utterances without hesitation, support fellow members of the community, to report deep inner feelings and frustrations as well as joy and pleasure, and to become counselors of other learners. CLL learners are typically grouped in a circle of six to twelve learners, with the number of knowers varying. Learner roles are keyed to the five stages of language learning. The view of the learner is an organic one, with each new role growing developmentally out of the one preceding it. These role changes are seen as outcomes of affective crises.
"One of the functions of the counseling response is to relate affect to cognition. Understanding the language of 'feeling', the counselor replies in the language of cognition." (Curran 1976: 26)
Role of the Teacher: The teacher's role derives from the functions of the counselor in Rogerian psychological counseling. The counselor's role is to respond calmly and non-judgmentally, in a supportive manner, and help the client understand problems better by applying order and analysis. There is also room for actual counseling in CLL: "Personal learning conflicts, anger, anxiety and similar psychological disturbance β understood and responded to by the teacher's counseling sensitivity β are indicators of deep personal investment" (J. Rardin, in Curran 1976, p. 103). Teacher roles are keyed to the five developmental stages. In early stages, the teacher operates in a supportive role, providing target-language translations and a model for imitation. Later, interaction may be initiated by students, and the teacher monitors learner utterances. As learning progresses, the teacher may intervene directly to correct deviant utterances, supply idioms, and advise on usage and grammar. The teacher's role is initially likened to that of a nurturing parent, and the student gradually "grows" in ability.
Role of Materials: Since a CLL course evolves out of the interactions of the community, a textbook is not considered a necessary component. A textbook would impose a particular body of language content on the learners, impeding their growth and interaction. Materials may be developed by the teacher as the course develops, generally consisting of summaries on the blackboard or overhead projector of some linguistic features of conversations generated by students. Conversations may also be transcribed and distributed for study and analysis, and learners may work in groups to produce their own materials, such as scripts for dialogues and mini-dramas.
Topic-055: Procedure in Community Language Learning Method
Because each CLL course is a unique experience, description of typical CLL procedures is problematic. Stevick (1980) distinguishes between "classical" CLL (based directly on Curran's model) and personal interpretations of it.
Generally, the observer will see a circle of learners all facing one another. The learners are linked in some way to knowers or a single knower as teacher. The first class may begin with a period of silence, in which learners try to determine what is supposed to happen. In later classes, learners may sit in silence while they decide what to talk about. The awkwardness of silence becomes sufficiently agonizing for someone to volunteer to break the silence. The knower may use the volunteered comment as a way of introducing discussion or as a stimulus for language interaction. The knower may encourage learners to address questions to one another or to the knower. Questions and answers may be tape-recorded for later use.
The teacher might then form the class into facing lines for 3-minute pair conversations, seen as equivalent to brief wrestling sessions in judo practice. The class might be re-formed into small groups where a single topic is discussed. The summary of the group discussion may be presented to another group.
In an intermediate or advanced class, a teacher may encourage groups to prepare a paper drama for presentation. A paper drama group prepares a story told or shown to the counselor. The counselor provides or corrects target-language statements and suggests improvements. Students are given materials to prepare large picture cards to accompany their story. After practicing the story dialogue, each group presents its paper drama to the rest of the class, accompanied by music, puppets, and drums.
Finally, the teacher asks learners to reflect on the language class, as a class or in groups. Reflection provides the basis for discussion of contracts (written or oral agreements specifying what they agree to accomplish), personal interaction, feelings, and sense of progress.
Dieter Strbinigg (in Stevick 1980: 185-186) presents a protocol of a first day's CLL class:
- Informal greetings and self-introductions were made.
- The teacher made a statement of the goals and guidelines.
- A conversation in the foreign language took place.
- A circle was formed so everyone had visual contact.
- One student initiated conversation with another by giving a message in L1 (English).
- The instructor, standing behind the student, whispered a close equivalent in L2 (German).
- The student repeated the L2 message to its addressee and into the tape recorder.
- Each student composed and recorded a few messages.
- The tape was rewound and replayed at intervals; each student repeated the meaning in English of what was said in L2.
- Students participated in a reflection period, expressing their feelings with total frankness.
- The instructor chose sentences to write on the blackboard highlighting grammar, spelling, and peculiarities of capitalization in L2.
- Students asked questions about any items above.
- Students copied sentences from the board with notes on meaning and usage, which became their "textbook" for home study.
Conclusion: CLL places unusual demands on language teachers. They must be highly proficient and sensitive to nuance in both L1 and L2. They must be familiar with and sympathetic to the role of counselors. They must resist the pressure "to teach" in traditional senses. The teacher must be relatively non-directive and prepared to accept the "adolescent" aggression of the learner. Special training in CLL techniques is usually required.
Critics question the appropriateness of the counseling metaphor, whether teachers should attempt counseling without special training, the lack of a syllabus making evaluation difficult, and the focus on fluency rather than accuracy. Supporters emphasize the positive benefits of a method that centers on the learner and stresses the humanistic side of language learning.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical elements to remember from this lecture are that Community Language Learning applies the Rogerian counseling metaphor to language teaching, redefining the teacher as a counselor and learners as clients in a supportive community. The method is grounded in whole-person learning, emphasizing both cognitive and affective dimensions, with the acronym SARD (Security, Attention/Aggression, Retention/Reflection, Discrimination) summarizing psychological requirements for learning. CLL follows a topic-based, emergent syllabus rather than a predetermined one, with learners generating content through activities like translation, group-work, recording, and reflection. The learner's role evolves through five developmental stages mirroring child development, from dependent to independent, while the teacher transitions from nurturing parent to advisor. Finally, CLL places significant demands on teachers requiring special training, and while critics note concerns about syllabus absence and accuracy focus, supporters value its humanistic, learner-centered approach.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary metaphor underlying Community Language Learning, and how does it redefine the roles of teacher and learner?
- Explain the five stages of language learning in CLL and how they parallel the ontogenetic development of a child.
- What does the acronym SARD stand for in CLL, and what does each component contribute to the learning process?
- Why does CLL not use a conventional language syllabus, and how is a syllabus generated in this method?
- Describe the procedure of a typical first-day CLL class based on the protocol provided by Dieter Strbinigg.
π Lecture 12 β Suggestopedia
π Overview: This lecture introduces Suggestopedia, a language teaching method developed by Bulgarian psychiatrist-educator Georgi Lozanov that harnesses non-rational and non-conscious influences to optimize learning. The method is notable for its dramatic claims about accelerated memorization and its distinctive use of classroom decoration, music, and teacher authority. It matters because it represents a radical departure from conventional methods, emphasizing psychological suggestion and environmental factors to unlock learning potential.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background of Suggestopedia, including its origins in Suggestology and influences from yoga and Soviet psychology. It then examines the approach and theory of language and learning, focusing on six principal theoretical components including authority, infantilization, and double-planedness. The objectives, syllabus, and learning activities are detailed, followed by the roles of learners, teachers, and materials. Finally, the procedure is explained, particularly the three-part class structure culminating in the seance or concert session.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-056: Background of Suggestopedia
Suggestopedia, also known as Desuggestopedia, is a method developed by Bulgarian psychiatrist-educator Georgi Lozanov. It derives from Suggestology, which Lozanov describes as a "science concerned with the systematic study of the non-rational and/or non-conscious influences" that human beings constantly respond to (Stevick 1976, p. 42). The method tries to harness these influences and redirect them to optimize learning. The most conspicuous characteristics are the decoration, furniture, and arrangement of the classroom, the use of music, and the authoritative behavior of the teacher.
Lozanov makes dramatic claims: "There is no sector of public life where suggestology would not be useful" (Lozanov 1978, p. 2), and "Memorization in learning by the suggestopedic method seems to be accelerated 25 times over that in learning by conventional methods" (Lozanov 1978, p. 27). The method acknowledges ties to yoga (borrowing techniques for altering states of consciousness and rhythmic breathing) and Soviet psychology (the notion that all students can be taught a given subject matter at the same level of skill). Lozanov claims success for both academically gifted and ungifted students, with or without outside study.
A most conspicuous feature is the centrality of music and musical rhythm to learning, giving Suggestopedia kinship with music therapy. Gaston (1968) defines three functions of music in therapy: to facilitate personal relations, to bring about increased self-esteem, and to use rhythm to energize and bring order. Lozanov calls upon the last function to relax learners and structure the presentation of linguistic material.
π Definition β Suggestopedia: A specific set of learning recommendations from Suggestology that harnesses non-rational and non-conscious influences to optimize learning, developed by Georgi Lozanov.
Topic-057: Approach and Theory of Language and Learning in Suggestopedia
Lozanov does not articulate a detailed theory of language. The emphasis on memorization of vocabulary pairs (a target-language item and its native language translation) suggests a view where lexis is central and lexical translation is stressed over contextualization. However, Lozanov occasionally refers to experiencing language material in "whole meaningful texts" (Lozanov 1978, p. 268) and notes the course directs "the student not to vocabulary memorization and acquiring habits of speech, but to acts of communication" (1978, p. 109). He refers to language as "the material," and the sample protocol does not suggest a theory markedly different from one holding language to be its vocabulary and grammar rules.
Suggestion is at the heart of the theory of learning. Lozanov distinguishes his theory from hypnosis, claiming other methods lack "a desuggestive-suggestive sense" and fail to create access to reserves through "concentrative psycho-relaxation." There are six principal theoretical components through which desuggestion and suggestion operate.
Authority: People remember best information from an authoritative source. Scientific-sounding language, positive experimental data, and true-believer teachers constitute a ritual placebo system. Commitment to the method, self-confidence, personal distance, acting ability, and a highly positive attitude give authority to the teacher.
π Definition β Ritual placebo system: The use of scientific-sounding language, positive data, and committed teachers to create an authoritative framework that appeals to learners.
Infantilization: Authority is used to suggest a teacher-student relation like that of parent to child. In the child's role, the learner takes part in role playing, games, songs, and gymnastic exercises that help "the older students regain the self-confidence, spontaneity and receptivity of the child" (Bancroft 1972, p. 19).
Double-Planedness: The learner learns not only from direct instruction but from the environment in which instruction takes place. Bright decor, musical background, chair shape, and teacher personality are as important as the instructional material itself.
Intonation, Rhythm, and Concert Pseudo-Passiveness: Varying tone and rhythm avoids boredom and dramatizes linguistic material. In the first presentation, three phrases are read with different voice levels and rhythm. In the second, a proper dramatic reading helps learners visualize context and aids memorization. Both are coordinated with musical background to induce a relaxed attitude called concert pseudo-passiveness, which is optimal for learning as it relieves anxieties and raises concentration.
π Definition β Concert pseudo-passiveness: A relaxed state induced by music that is optimal for learning, where anxieties are relieved and concentration is raised.
Topic-058: Objectives, Syllabus, and Learning Activities in Suggestopedia
Objectives: To deliver advanced conversational proficiency quickly, based on student mastery of prodigious lists of vocabulary pairs. Lozanov emphasizes that increased memory power is the result of "positive, comprehensive stimulation of personality" (Lozanov 1978, p. 253).
Syllabus: A Suggestopedia course lasts 30 days with ten units of study. Classes are held 4 hours a day, 6 days a week. Each unit's central focus is a dialogue of about 1,200 words with an accompanying vocabulary list and grammatical commentary. Dialogues are graded by lexis and grammar.
Unit study is organized around 3 days: day 1 (half a day), day 2 (full day), day 3 (half a day). On day 1, the teacher discusses the general content of the unit dialogue. Learners receive the printed dialogue with native language translation. The dialogue is read a second and third time. Days 2 and 3 involve primary elaboration (imitation, question and answer, reading, working with 150 new vocabulary items) and secondary elaboration (encouraging students to make new combinations and productions based on dialogues). During the course, there are two opportunities for generalization: in the middle (practicing target language in settings like hotels or restaurants) and on the last day (a performance where students construct a play and speak extempore).
Learning Activities: Include imitation, question and answer, and role play (not unusual activities). More original are listening activities concerning text and text vocabulary, typically part of the "pre-session phase" on the first day of a new unit. Students first look at and discuss a new text, then relax in reclining chairs and listen to the teacher read the text in a certain way.
Topic-059: Role of Learners, Teachers and Materials in Suggestopedia
Role of the Learner: The learner's mental state is critical to success. Learners must forgo mind-altering substances and immerse themselves in procedures. They must maintain a pseudo-passive state and not try to figure out or study the material. They are expected to tolerate their own "infantilization" by acknowledging the teacher's absolute authority and giving themselves over to activities like role playing, games, songs, and gymnastic exercises. Groups are ideally socially homogeneous, twelve in number, equally divided between men and women, sitting in a circle.
Role of the Teacher: The primary role is to create situations where the learner is most suggestible and present linguistic material to encourage positive reception and retention. Lozanov lists expected teacher behaviors: show absolute confidence in the method; display fastidious conduct in manners and dress; organize and strictly observe the initial stages; maintain a solemn attitude; give tests and respond tactfully; stress global rather than analytical attitudes; maintain modest enthusiasm.
Materials: Consist of direct support materials (text and tape) and indirect support materials (classroom fixtures and music). The text is organized around ten units and should have emotional force, literary quality, and interesting characters. Language problems should not worry or distract students. The learning environment comprises the classroom appearance (bright and cheery), furniture (reclining chairs in a circle), and music (Baroque largo).
Topic-060: Procedure in Suggestopedia
The 4-hour language class has three distinct parts. The first part, an oral review section, uses previously learned material as the basis for discussion. Participants sit in a circle in specially designed chairs. This may involve micro-studies (specific attention to grammar, vocabulary, and precise questions) and macro-studies (emphasis on role playing and wider-ranging language constructions).
In the second part, new material is presented and discussed. This involves looking over a new dialogue with its native language translation and discussing grammar, vocabulary, or content. This section is typically conducted in the target language. Students are led to view the experience as interesting and undemanding.
The third part, the seance or concert session, is what Suggestopedia is best known for. At the beginning, conversation stops for a minute or two. The teacher listens to music from a tape recorder to enter the mood, then reads or recites the new text, voice modulated in harmony with musical phrases. Students follow the text in their textbooks with mother tongue translations. Between the first and second part of the concert, there are several minutes of solemn silence. Before the second part, students close their textbooks and listen. At the end, students silently leave the room and are instructed to read the lesson cursorily once before bed and again before getting up.
π‘ Why this matters: The concert session represents the core innovation of Suggestopedia, combining music, rhythmic reading, and relaxation to bypass conscious barriers to learning.
Conclusion
Suggestopedia has received both rave reviews and scathing criticism. Scovel (1979) notes Lozanov is opposed to eclectic use of techniques outside the full suggestopedic science, commenting that language teaching will benefit little from the "pseudo-science of suggestology." However, Lozanov maintains that the air of science gives Suggestopedia its authority and prepares students to expect success, acknowledging it is introduced as a "suggestive-desuggestive ritual placebo-system." The lecture concludes that it may be more productive to identify and validate effective techniques from Suggestopedia that harmonize with other successful techniques.
β Key Takeaways
Suggestopedia is fundamentally about using psychological suggestionβthrough authority, infantilization, double-planedness, and concert pseudo-passivenessβto optimize learning by tapping into non-conscious reserves. Its most distinctive features are the central role of Baroque music, an authoritative teacher, a specially designed classroom environment, and the three-part class structure culminating in the concert session where music and rhythmic reading create optimal learning conditions. Lozanov claims accelerated memorization (25 times) but this is highly controversial, with critics dismissing suggestology as pseudo-science. The method requires learners to maintain a pseudo-passive state and embrace infantilization while teachers must display absolute confidence and authority. For exam purposes, remember the six theoretical components, the 30-day course structure with ten units, and the specific roles and procedures that distinguish Suggestopedia from all other methods.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six principal theoretical components through which desuggestion and suggestion operate in Suggestopedia?
- What is the significance of "concert pseudo-passiveness" and how is it achieved?
- Describe the three-part structure of a typical 4-hour Suggestopedia class.
- What does Lozanov claim about memorization acceleration, and what controversy surrounds this claim?
- What are the specific roles and expected behaviors of the teacher and learner in Suggestopedia?