๐ Lecture 16 โ The Lexical Approach
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the Lexical Approach, a language teaching methodology that prioritizes lexisโwords and word combinationsโover grammar as the fundamental building blocks of language learning and communication. It matters because it represents a significant shift from traditional grammar-based instruction to a focus on multi-word lexical units or "chunks," which are believed to be central to fluent language use and acquisition.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background, theory, and learning principles of the Lexical Approach, including Chomsky's Minimalist theory and the role of corpora in linguistics. It then details the objectives, syllabus design, and learning activities based on lexical principles, followed by the roles of teachers, learners, and different types of materials. Finally, the lecture outlines classroom procedures for teaching collocations and lexical phrases, including error correction techniques.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-076: Background of the Lexical Approach
Central to an approach or method in language teaching is a view of the nature of language. A lexical approach in language teaching is derived from the belief that the building blocks of language learning and communication are not grammar, functions, or notions, but lexisโthat is, words and word combinations. Lexical approaches reflect a belief in the centrality of the lexicon to language structure, second language learning, and language use, particularly to multiword lexical units or "chunks" that are learned and used as single items. Linguistic theory, including Chomsky's Minimalist Linguistic theory, has recognized a more central role for vocabulary, adopting a "lexicon-is-prime" position.
The role of lexical units has been stressed in both first and second language acquisition research, referred to by labels such as "holophrases", "prefabricated patterns", "gambits", "speech formulae", and "lexicalized stems". Several approaches have been proposed, including The Lexical Syllabus (Willis 1990), Lexical Phrases and Language Teaching (Nattinger and DeCarrico 1992), and The Lexical Approach (Lewis 1993). Advances in corpus linguistics have provided a huge, classroom-accessible database for lexically based inquiry and instruction, focusing on collocations of lexical items and multiple word units.
Topic-077: Approach and Theory of Language and Learning of the Lexical Approach
In contrast to Chomsky's theory of language, which emphasized the creation of entirely novel sentences, the lexical view holds that only a minority of spoken sentences are entirely new creations. Multiword units functioning as "chunks" or memorized patterns form a high proportion of fluent speech. Collocation refers to the regular occurrence together of words, for example, "do my hair/the cooking" versus "make my bed/a promise." Other lexical units include: Binomials (clean and tidy), Trinomials (cool, calm, and collected), Idioms (dead drunk), Similes (as old as the hills), Connectives (finally), and Conversational gambits (Guess what!).
Lexis is believed to play a central role in language learning. Nattinger (1980) suggested teaching should be based on the assumption that language production consists of piecing together ready-made units. However, the massive inventory of prepackaged phrases possessed by native speakers poses a daunting task for second language learners. Krashen suggests massive "language input" through reading is effective. Others propose using computer concordance databases, or a "contrastive" approach focusing on items with no direct translational equivalence (Bahns 1993).
Lewis (2000) provides assumptions for a learning theory in the lexical approach: encountering new items on several occasions is necessary but not sufficient; noticing chunks is necessary but not sufficient for input to become intake; noticing similarities and examples contributes to intake, but formal rule description probably does not. Acquisition is based on an accumulation of examples from which learners make provisional generalizations. Language production is the product of previously met examples, not formal rules. No linear syllabus can reflect the nonlinear nature of acquisition.
Topic-078: Objectives, Syllabus and Learning Activities in the Lexical Approach
The rationale for lexically based teaching described in The Lexical Syllabus (Willis 1990) and the Collins COBUILD English Course represents the most ambitious attempt to realize a syllabus based on lexical principles. The COBUILD computer analyses revealed that the 700 most frequent words account for around 70% of all English text. This led to the decision that word frequency would determine course content. Level I aimed to cover the most frequent 700 words together with their common patterns and uses (Willis 1990: vi).
Willis stresses that the lexical syllabus not only subsumes a structural syllabus but also indicates how structures should be exemplified, as the computer corpus reveals the commonest structural patterns. Other proposals include Nation's (1999) review of criteria for classifying collocations and Nattinger and DeCarrico's functional schema, which distinguishes lexical phrases as social interactions, necessary topics, and discourse devices.
Topic-079: Role of Learners, Teachers, and Materials in the Lexical Approach
Role of the Teacher: Lewis supports Krashen's Natural Approach, suggesting teacher talk is a major source of learner input. Willis proposes teachers need to manage a methodology based on Task, Planning, and Report stages. Willis views the teacher's role as creating an environment for effective learning and helping learners manage their own learning, requiring teachers to "abandon the idea of the teacher as `knower' and concentrate instead on the idea of the โlearnerโ as โdiscovererโ" (Willis 1990, p. 131).
Role of the Learner: Learners may use computers to analyze text data, assuming the role of data analyst constructing their own linguistic generalizations. Teachers provide scaffolding to help build autonomy. Learners need training in using concordance lines effectively, progressing through stages of lexical analysis such as observation, classification, and generalization.
Materials: Four types of materials support lexical approaches:
- Complete course packages like the Collins COBUILD English Course.
- Collections of vocabulary teaching activities (e.g., Lewis 1997).
- Printout versions of computer corpora with student exercises.
- Computer concordancing programs with attached data sets on CD-ROM or the Internet.
An example shows how corpus access allows students to see differences in collocation, such as between "predict" and "forecast" in authentic textual use.
Topic-080: Procedure of the Lexical Approach
Procedural sequences vary depending on the type of materials employed. All designers assume the learner must take on the role of "discourse analyst." Classroom procedures involve activities that draw students' attention to lexical collocations and enhance retention and use. Woolard (2000) suggests teachers reexamine course books for collocations, adding exercises focusing on lexical phrases and developing activities for independent discovery.
Hill (2000) suggests classroom procedures involve: (a) teaching individual collocations, (b) making students aware of collocation, (c) extending knowledge of collocation restrictions, and (d) storing collocations through a lexical notebook. ๐ก Why this matters: Lewis (2000) gives an example of extending knowledge through error correction. When a student says "make an exam," the teacher writes "exam" on the board and asks for verbs used with "exam" (take, pass, fail, retake) and adverbs (comfortably). This technique builds students' awareness of collocational patterns actively.
โญ Key Takeaways
The Lexical Approach fundamentally shifts language teaching from grammar to lexis, emphasizing multiword units or "chunks" as the primary building blocks of communication. Collocationโthe regular co-occurrence of wordsโis central to understanding and producing fluent language. Syllabus design is driven by word frequency, as demonstrated by the COBUILD corpus which showed 700 words account for 70% of English text. The teacher's role changes to facilitator and "knower" of language patterns, while the learner becomes a "discourse analyst" or "data discoverer" who must actively notice, record, and generalize from lexical samples. Classroom procedures focus on drawing attention to collocations, extending known vocabulary with collocation restrictions, and using computer concordance data to explore authentic language use.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the central belief of the Lexical Approach regarding the building blocks of language learning and communication?
- Define "collocation" and provide two examples of verb + noun collocations from the lecture.
- According to Willis's Lexical Syllabus, what key finding about word frequency determined the content of the COBUILD course?
- What are the four types of materials that support lexical approaches in language teaching?
- In Lewis's error correction example, how does the teacher extend a student's knowledge when they say "make an exam"?
๐ Lecture 17 โ Competency-Based Language Teaching
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces Competency-Based Language Teaching (CBLT), an outcome-focused approach that emerged from Competency-Based Education (CBE) in the 1970s. It covers the background, theoretical foundations, syllabus design, learning activities, implementation factors, procedures, and criticisms of this approach. Understanding CBLT is crucial for designing language programs that prepare learners for real-world tasks and social functioning.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background of Competency-Based Language Teaching, including its origins in the 1970s US educational movement and its reemergence in Australia. It then explores the approach and theory of language and learning, focusing on functional and interactional perspectives. Next, it examines objectives, syllabus design, and learning activities, contrasting traditional subject-based approaches with competency-based frameworks. Finally, it discusses factors involved in implementation, procedures using the Australian Migrant Education Program as an example, and critiques of the approach.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-081: Background of Competency-Based Language Teaching
Competency-Based Education (CBE) is an educational movement that focuses on the outcomes or outputs of learning in the development of language programs. It emerged in the United States in the 1970s and defines educational goals in terms of precise, measurable descriptions of knowledge, skills, and behaviors students should possess at the end of a course. The focus on outputs rather than inputs to learning is central to the competencies perspective.
Competency-Based Language Teaching (CBLT) is an application of CBE principles to language teaching. It was widely adopted by the late 1970s, particularly for work-related and survival-oriented adult ESL programs. The Center for Applied Linguistics called competency-based ESL curricula "the most important breakthrough in adult ESL" (1983). By the 1990s, CBLT was accepted as "the state-of-the-art approach to adult ESL" by national policymakers. By 1986, any refugee in the United States who wished to receive federal assistance had to be enrolled in a competency-based program.
Advocates see CBLT as a powerful agent of change. Docking (1994) notes that competency-based approaches "offer teachers an opportunity to revitalize their education and training programs," improving the quality of assessment, teaching, and student learning through clear specification of expected outcomes and continuous feedback.
In the United States, the most recent realization of the competency perspective is found in the "standards" movement, which dominated educational discussions since the 1990s. Second language teaching, especially ESL, was a late entry in this movement. The Center for Applied Linguistics, under contract to TESOL, developed K-12 "school" standards for ESL, completed in 1997. These standards are framed around three goals and nine standards, organized into grade-level clusters: pre-K-3, 4-8, and 9-12.
CBLT also shares features of the graded objectives movement in Britain in the 1980s, which defined a series of short-term goals, each building upon the one before, so the learner advances in knowledge and skill.
๐ Definition โ Competency-Based Education (CBE): An educational movement that advocates defining educational goals in terms of precise measurable descriptions of the knowledge, skills, and behaviors students should possess at the end of a course of study.
๐ Definition โ Competency-Based Language Teaching (CBLT): An application of the principles of Competency-Based Education to language teaching, based on a performance outline of language tasks that lead to demonstrated mastery of language associated with specific skills necessary for individuals to function proficiently in society.
๐ Example: By 1986, any refugee in the United States who wished to receive federal assistance had to be enrolled in a competency-based program, based on a performance outline of language tasks leading to demonstrated mastery of language associated with specific skills necessary for functioning in society.
Topic-082: Approach and Theory of Language and Learning of Competency-Based Language Teaching
CBLT is based on a functional and interactional perspective on the nature of language. It seeks to teach language in relation to the social contexts in which it is used. Language always occurs as a medium of interaction and communication between people for the achievement of specific goals and purposes.
CBLT has most often been used as a framework for language teaching in situations where learners have specific needs and are in particular roles, and where the language skills they need can be fairly accurately predicted or determined. It shares with behaviorist views of learning the notion that language form can be inferred from language function; that is, certain life encounters call for certain kinds of language.
Central to both language and learning theory is the view that language can be functionally analyzed into appropriate parts and subparts that can be taught and tested incrementally. CBLT takes a "mosaic" approach to language learning in that the "whole" (communicative competence) is constructed from smaller components correctly assembled.
CBLT is also built around the notion of communicative competence and seeks to develop functional communication skills in learners. These skills are generally described in only the most general terms, rather than being linked to the performance of specific real-world tasks. CBLT thus shares some features with Communicative Language Teaching.
๐ก Why this matters: CBLT's theoretical foundation combines functional language use with behaviorist learning principles, assuming that language skills can be broken down into teachable, testable components that, when assembled correctly, form complete communicative competence.
Topic-083: Objectives, Syllabus and Learning Activities in Competency-Based Language Teaching
Objectives
Docking (1994) contrasts traditional approaches with CBLT. In the traditional approach, syllabus planning is based on understanding of subject matter. One starts with the field of knowledge to be taught and selects concepts, knowledge, and skills that constitute that field. Assessment is usually based on norm referencing, where students are graded on a single scale relative to other students, making it difficult to judge specific knowledge or skills acquired.
Syllabus
In CBLT, the syllabus is designed not around subject knowledge but around the notion of competency. The focus moves from what students know about language to what they can do with it. The focus on competencies or learning outcomes underpins the curriculum framework, syllabus specification, teaching strategies, assessment, and reporting. Instead of norm-referenced assessment, criterion-based assessment procedures are used, in which learners are assessed according to how well they can perform on specific learning tasks.
Learning Activities
Competencies consist of a description of the essential skills, knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors required for effective performance of a real-world task or activity. Activities may relate to any domain of life but have typically been linked to work and social survival. For example, areas for which competencies have been developed in a vocationally oriented ESL curriculum for immigrants and refugees include: Task Performance, Safety, General Word-Related, Work Schedules, Time Sheets, Paychecks, Social Language, Job Application, and Job Interview.
For the area of "Retaining a Job," competencies include: following instructions, responding to supervisor's comments, requesting supervisor to check work, reporting completion of tasks, requesting supplies, asking where objects are located, following oral directions, reading charts/labels/forms, stating problems and asking for help, responding to inquiries about task progress, and responding appropriately to work interruption or modification.
Docking (1994) explains that a qualification or job can be described as a collection of units of competency, each composed of a number of elements of competency. A unit of competency might be a task, a role, a function, or a learning module. An element of competency is any attribute of an individual that contributes to successful performance of a task, job, function, or activity in an academic and/or work setting. This includes specific knowledge, thinking processes, attitudes, and perceptual and physical skills.
Tollefson (1986) observes that the analysis of jobs into constituent functional competencies to develop teaching objectives goes back to the mid-nineteenth century. In the 1860s, Spencer outlined major areas of human activity for curricular objectives, and in 1926, Bobbitt developed objectives based on analysis of functional competencies required for adults in America.
๐ Definition โ Competency: A description of the essential skills, knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors required for effective performance of a real-world task or activity.
๐ Definition โ Element of competency: Any attribute of an individual that contributes to the successful performance of a task, job, function, or activity in an academic setting and/or a work setting; the building block for competency specifications.
๐ Definition โ Norm referencing: Assessment where students are graded on a single scale relative to other students, with the expectation of a wide range of scores or a preset distribution.
๐ Definition โ Criterion-based assessment: Assessment procedures where learners are evaluated according to how well they can perform on specific learning tasks, rather than relative to other students.
๐ Example: For the area of "Retaining a Job," competencies include "Follow instructions to carry out a simple task" and "Respond appropriately to supervisor's comments about quality of work on the job, including mistakes, working too slowly, and incomplete work."
Topic-084: Factors involved in the Implementation of Competency-Based Language Teaching Programs
Auerbach (1986) identifies eight key features of CBE programs in ESL:
- A focus on successful functioning in society: The goal is to enable students to become autonomous individuals capable of coping with the demands of the world.
- A focus on life skills rather than teaching language in isolation: CBLT teaches language as a function of communication about concrete tasks. Students are taught just those language forms/skills required by the situations in which they will function.
- Task or performance-centered orientation: What counts is what students can do as a result of instruction. The emphasis is on overt behaviors rather than knowledge or the ability to talk about language and skills.
- Modularized instruction: Language learning is broken down into manageable and immediately meaningful chunks. Objectives are broken into narrowly focused sub-objectives so that both teachers and students can get a clear sense of progress.
- Outcomes that are made explicit are a priority: Outcomes are public knowledge, known and agreed upon by both learner and teacher. They are specified in terms of behavioral objectives so that students know exactly what behaviors are expected of them.
- Continuous and ongoing assessment: Students are pretested to determine what skills they lack and post-tested after instruction. If they do not achieve the desired level of mastery, they continue to work on the objective and are retested.
- Demonstrated mastery of performance objectives: Rather than traditional paper-and-pencil tests, assessments are based on the ability to demonstrate pre-specified behaviors.
- Individualized, student-centered instruction: In content, level, and pace, objectives are defined in terms of individual needs; prior learning and achievement are taken into account in developing curricula. Instruction is not time-based; students progress at their own rates.
Advantages from the learner's point of view include: competencies are specific and practical and relate to learner's needs; learners can judge relevance and usefulness; competencies taught and tested are specific and public so learners know exactly what needs to be learned; and competencies can be mastered one at a time so learners can track progress.
๐ก Why this matters: These eight features form the operational framework for implementing CBLT programs, emphasizing explicit outcomes, continuous assessment, individualized instruction, and demonstrated performance rather than theoretical knowledge.
Topic-085: Procedure and Criticism on Competency-Based Language Teaching
Procedure
The Australian Migrant Education Program, one of the largest providers of language training to immigrants, exemplifies CBLT procedures. The program has undergone philosophical reorientations since the mid-1970s, moving from centralized curriculum planning with content-based and structural curriculum (late 1970s) to decentralized learner-centred, needs-based planning (1980s), and to competency-based curriculum frameworks (1990s).
In 1993, the Certificate in Spoken and Written English (CSWE) was introduced as the framework. Learning outcomes are specified at three stages, leading to an Advanced Certificate in Spoken and Written English at Stage 4 of the framework.
Hagan (1994) describes how the framework operates: After an initial assessment, students are placed within the framework based on their current English proficiency level, learning pace, needs, and social goals. The twelve core competencies at Stages 1 and 2 relate to general language development. At Stage 3, learners are grouped according to their goal focus, with competencies defined according to three syllabus strands: Further Study, Vocational English, and Community Access.
Competency descriptions at each stage are divided into four domains:
- Knowledge and learning competencies
- Oral competencies
- Reading competencies
- Writing competencies
All competencies are described in terms of:
- Elements that break down the competency into smaller components and refer to essential linguistic features of the text
- Performance criteria that specify the minimal performance required to achieve a competency
- Range of variables that sets limits for performance of the competency
- Sample texts and assessment tasks that provide examples relating to the competency
Criticism on CBLT
Despite enthusiasm from large sections of the ESL profession, CBLT faces both practical and philosophical criticisms.
Tollefson (1986) argues that there are no valid procedures available to develop competency lists for most programs. Many areas for which competencies are needed, such as "adult living," "survival," and "functioning proficiently in the community," are impossible to operationalize. Others point out that dividing activities into sets of competencies is a reductionist approach, and the sum of the parts does not equal the complexity of the whole.
Auerbach, summarizing the work of Paolo Freire, points out that CBLT reflects a "banking" model of education. This assumes there is a structure of socially prescribed knowledge to be mastered by students, where the function of education is to transmit knowledge and socialize learners according to the values of the dominant socio-economic group. The teacher's job is to devise more effective ways to transmit skills, and educational progress is defined in terms of improving delivery systems.
CBLT is therefore seen as prescriptivist in that it prepares students to fit into the status quo and maintain class relationships. Teaching typically focuses on behavior and performance rather than on the development of thinking skills.
Because competencies are designed to enable learners to participate effectively in society, Tollefson and others point out that they typically represent value judgments about what such participation involves. Competencies for refugee settlement programs in the United States, for example, attempt to inculcate attitudes and values that will make refugees passive citizens who accept the status quo rather than challenge it.
Despite these criticisms, CBLT appears to be gaining strength internationally. Such outcomes-based approaches have attracted a large political following from those seeking "accountability" for educational investment.
๐ Definition โ "Banking" model of education: A model where there is a structure of socially prescribed knowledge to be mastered by students, the function of education is to transmit knowledge and socialize learners according to dominant socio-economic values, and the teacher's role is to devise effective ways to transmit skills.
๐ Example: The Australian Migrant Education Program's Certificate in Spoken and Written English (CSWE) frames learning outcomes at three stages, with twelve core competencies at Stages 1 and 2 for general language development, and competencies at Stage 3 defined according to Further Study, Vocational English, and Community Access strands.
โญ Key Takeaways
CBLT is fundamentally an outcome-based approach that focuses on what learners can do with language rather than what they know about it, with competencies derived from analysis of real-world tasks. The approach is built on functional and interactional language theory, using a "mosaic" approach where communicative competence is assembled from smaller, teachable components assessed through criterion-based, not norm-referenced, procedures. Implementation requires eight key features: focus on societal functioning, life skills teaching, task orientation, modularized instruction, explicit outcomes, continuous assessment, demonstrated mastery, and individualized instruction. The Australian Migrant Education Program's Certificate in Spoken and Written English provides a concrete example of CBLT procedures with staged competencies across four domains. Despite practical and philosophical criticismsโincluding reductionism, the "banking model" of education, and prescriptivist social valuesโCBLT continues to gain international strength, particularly from those seeking accountability in education.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What distinguishes Competency-Based Education (CBE) from traditional education approaches in terms of focus on inputs versus outputs?
- What are the eight key features of CBLT implementation identified by Auerbach (1986)?
- How does the Australian Migrant Education Program's Certificate in Spoken and Written English structure its competency framework across stages and domains?
- What are the main criticisms of CBLT, including Tollefson's argument and the "banking model" critique?
- What is the difference between norm-referenced assessment and criterion-based assessment in the context of CBLT?
๐ Lecture 18 โ Communicative Language Teaching Approach
๐ Overview: This lecture traces the historical and theoretical foundations of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT), a learner-centered pedagogy that emerged in response to the limitations of language-centered methods. It explores the multidisciplinary influences that shaped CLT's theory of language, learning, and teaching, and critically examines its syllabus design, classroom procedures, and overall effectiveness in fostering genuine communication.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the background of CLT, detailing the growing skepticism toward language-centered pedagogy in the 1960s and 1970s, and the key developments in linguistics, sociolinguistics, psychology, and European policy that prompted a search for an alternative method. It then presents the theory behind CLT, covering its theory of language (drawn from Chomsky, Halliday, Hymes, and Austin), theory of language learning (based on cognitive psychology), and theory of language teaching (focusing on teacher and learner roles). Next, it examines the contents in CLT, including notional/functional syllabuses and the focus on learner needs. The lecture then describes classroom procedures, including input modifications and interactional activities such as information-gap tasks. Finally, it offers a critical assessment, highlighting CLT's achievements and its shortcomings, particularly its retention of a linear, additive view of learning.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-086: Background of Communicative Language Teaching Approach
By the late 1960s and early 1970s, researchers and teachers became increasingly skeptical about the effectiveness of language-centered pedagogy to foster communicative capability. The skepticism grew from the realization that correctly manipulating target language structures is only part of what is involved in learning and using it.
Newmark's 1966 paper, โHow Not to Interfere with Language Learning,โ epitomized these doubts. He doubted that language learning can be additive and linear, asserting that if each item had to be acquired one at a time, the learner would be old before being able to say a single appropriate thing. He declared that language-centered pedagogy, with its sequential presentation of isolated linguistic items, โconstitutes serious interference with the language learning process.โ
The search for an alternative method was accelerated by developments in social sciences and humanities during the 1960s. In linguistics, Chomsky demonstrated the generative nature of language, and Halliday highlighted its functional properties. In sociolinguistics, Hymes proposed a theory of communicative competence. Austin's speech act theory elaborated on how language users perform acts like requesting and apologizing. In psychology, cognitivism replaced behaviorism, focusing on human cognition as a mediator between stimulus and response.
A key political development was the formation of the European Economic Community (EEC), which eased trade and travel, providing an impetus for a function-oriented language teaching pedagogy. In 1971, the Council of Europe commissioned European applied linguists to design a new way to teach foreign languages. Wilkins, a British applied linguist, proposed a set of syllabuses in his 1976 book Notional Syllabuses, which consisted of categories of notions (e.g., time, quantity, location) and communicative functions (e.g., informing, requesting). This notional/functional syllabus marked the beginning of the communicative method or communicative language teaching (CLT).
Topic-087: Theory behind Communicative Language Teaching Approach
Theory of Language
CLT's theory of language drew from several sources. Chomsky pointed out that language is a network of transformations, not just a hierarchical structure, focusing on โdeepโ structures. Halliday emphasized the triple macro-functions of language: textual (phonological/syntactic signals), interpersonal (sociolinguistic features for roles and relationships), and ideational (concepts underlying phenomena), invoking the โmeaning potentialโ of language. Hymes questioned Chomsky's grammatical competence, proposing that a person must be not just grammatically correct but communicatively appropriate โ learning what to say, how to say it, when, and to whom. Austin looked at language as a series of speech acts (e.g., to command, to inform), where the illocutionary force (intended meaning) is crucial, not just grammatical form.
Based on these, CLT operates on broad principles: language is a system for expressing meaning; its structures reflect functional and communicative import; basic units are notional and functional; the central purpose is communication; and communication is based on shared sociocultural norms.
๐ Definition โ Communicative Competence: The ability to use language not only correctly (grammatically) but also appropriately according to the sociocultural context of communication.
Theory of Language Learning
CLT derived its learning theory from cognitive psychologists, who dismissed habit formation and focused on insight formation. The learner's cognitive capacity mediates between teacher input (stimulus) and learner output (response). The learner forms, tests, and confirms hypotheses, contributing to language development. Mental processes are more important than the response itself. Only meaningful learning, not rote learning, can lead to internalization of language systems.
CLT viewed language communication as a synthesis of textual, interpersonal, and ideational functions, involving abilities of interpretation, expression, and negotiation. Importantly, CLT did not neglect grammar. It insisted language learning entails development of both accuracy (conscious grammar learning) and fluency (communicative potential). The Five Cs (communication, cultures, connections, comparisons, communities) represent a holistic, communicative approach to language learning.
Theory of Language Teaching
The teacher's responsibility is to help learners: (a) develop the ability to manipulate the linguistic system and use it spontaneously; (b) understand the distinction and connection between linguistic forms and communicative functions; (c) develop strategies to communicate meanings effectively; and (d) become aware of sociocultural norms.
To foster meaningful communication, teachers should: design information-gap activities (where one learner knows something the other doesn't); offer choice of response; emphasize contextualization; use authentic language; introduce language at discourse level; tolerate errors; and develop activities integrating all four skills.
Breen and Candlin identified two main teacher roles: (1) to facilitate the communicative process between participants, and (2) to act as an interdependent participant within the group. Learners must take an active role, learning to navigate the self, the learning process, and the learning objectives.
Topic-088: Contents in Communicative Language Teaching Approach
CLT opted for a product-oriented syllabus design, but selected and sequenced both grammatical and notional/functional categories. A learner-centered curriculum identifies language features needed by learners for their specific communicative purposes. One way of constructing a profile of needs is to ask: โWho is communicating with whom, why, where, when, how, at what level, about what, and in what way?โ (Munby, 1978).
Wilkins (1972) proposed a notional/functional syllabus with semanticogrammatical notions (duration, quantity, location) and communicative functions (greeting, requesting). Van Ek (1975) expanded this with a detailed needs analysis. Munby (1978) provided an elaborate taxonomy for Communicative Syllabus Design. Finocchiaro and Brumfit (1983) provided guidelines for teachers.
A need-based curriculum helps create learner motivation and facilitates specific purpose courses. However, Johnson (1982) noted difficulties: if learners have different purposes, it's hard to derive a manageable list. Also, there are no clear criteria for selecting and sequencing input โ criteria of simplicity or priority of needs are problematic, as functions like apologizing cannot be ordered for complexity or need.
๐ก Why this matters: The focus on learner needs is CLT's hallmark, but the practical challenge of selecting and sequencing content for diverse learners reveals a tension between theoretical ideals and classroom realities.
Topic-089: Classroom Procedures in Communicative Language Teaching Approach
While content specifications differ, from a classroom procedural point of view, there is no fundamental difference between language-centered and learner-centered pedagogy.
Input Modifications
CLT pursued a form- and meaning-based approach, attempting to connect form and meaning. However, there is no one-to-one correspondence between grammatical forms and communicative functions. A single form (e.g., "Close the door") can express several functions (command, request, hint), and a single function can be expressed through several forms (e.g., "Close the door, please," "Could you please close the door?"). A single expression like "I've got a headache" can perform functions of warning, request, or apology depending on context.
Therefore, language input can only provide standardized functions in stereotypical contexts. It is left to the learner to figure out how utterances are realized and reformulated in actual situations.
Interactional Activities
CLT followed the presentationโpracticeโproduction (PPP) sequence but applied it to notional/functional categories. Littlewood (1981) presented a methodological framework with pre-communicative activities (structural and quasi-communicative) and communicative activities (functional and social interaction).
๐ Definition โ Information-Gap Activity: A classroom task where one learner possesses information that another learner does not, requiring them to communicate to complete the task.
๐ Example โ Discovering Missing Information: Learner A has a table with distances between towns, with some items deleted. Learner B has an identical table with different items deleted. Each completes their table by asking their partner for the missing information, using forms like "How far is... from...?".
๐ Example โ Pooling Information to Solve a Problem: Learner A has a train timetable from X to Y; Learner B has a timetable from Y to Z. Together, they work out the quickest journey from X to Z without seeing each other's information.
These functional communication activities require learners to overcome an information gap or solve a problem, with the stimulus and yardstick for success contained within the situation itself.
Topic-090: A Critical Assessment & Conclusion of Communicative Language Teaching Approach
CLT's greatest achievement is directing attention to aspects of language beyond grammatical structures, treating language as discourse rather than merely a system. It bestowed legitimacy on negotiation, interpretation, and expression, and underscored the creative, unpredictable character of communication.
CLT did not do away with grammar but extended it to include functional features, anticipating later research showing that form-focused instruction within a communicative program is more effective than exclusive emphasis on accuracy or fluency.
However, CLT retained the linear and additive view of language learning and the presentationโpracticeโproduction sequence from audio-lingualism. This contradicts the principle that language learning is adaptive and reconstructive, not accumulative. As Widdowson (2003) stated, "The acquisition of competence is not accumulative but adaptive."
Data-based classroom research (Nunan, 1987; Legutke & Thomas, 1991; Kumaravadivelu, 1993a) revealed that so-called communicative classrooms are often not very communicative. Form-focused activities dominated fluency activities, and genuine interaction was rarely created.
Another drawback is the "tabula rasa attitude" โ the false belief that adult L2 learners do not possess normal pragmatic skills to transfer from their L1. Swan (1985) argued that adult learners know how to negotiate meaning and perform speech acts; they need lexical items, not skills. Research (Rose & Kasper, 2001) supports that adult learners get considerable L2 pragmatic knowledge for free from universal knowledge and L1 transfer.
๐ก Why this matters: The critical assessment reveals that despite its innovations, CLT's claim of being a "communicative revolution" is an overstatement. Its classroom procedures share fundamental similarities with the language-centered approach it sought to replace.
โญ Key Takeaways
Communicative Language Teaching emerged as a reaction to the limitations of language-centered pedagogy, drawing from Chomskyan linguistics, Hallidayan functional linguistics, Hymsian sociolinguistics, Austinian speech act theory, and cognitive psychology. It views language as both system and discourse, emphasizing communicative competence โ the ability to use language appropriately in context. CLT introduced notional/functional syllabuses focused on learner needs, and innovative classroom activities like information-gap tasks. However, it retained the linear, additive view of learning and the presentation-practice-production sequence from its predecessors, and research showed communicative classrooms often failed to achieve genuine interaction. Additionally, CLT's dismissal of learners' pre-existing L1 pragmatic skills has been challenged by research supporting cross-linguistic transfer.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What were the key developments in linguistics, sociolinguistics, and psychology that contributed to the emergence of Communicative Language Teaching?
- What is the notional/functional syllabus, and how does it differ from a purely grammatical syllabus?
- According to Hymes, what is communicative competence, and why did he argue it goes beyond Chomsky's grammatical competence?
- What are information-gap activities, and how do they support communicative language learning?
- What are the main criticisms of CLT regarding its view of language learning and its assumptions about adult L2 learners' pragmatic abilities?